Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~2 to 4
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
#
+
Date of Decision: 07.08.2026
CNR No. DLHC011509072018
W.P.(C) 10074/2018
HARKESH & ORS
Through:
.....Petitioners
Ms. Meghna De,
Mr.Siddharth Sapra, and
Mr.Tusshay Singh,
Advocates
versus
INDIA TRADE PROMOTION ORGANIZATION & ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Rajinder Wali and
Ms.Shivani Gupta, Advocates
for Respondent No. 1/ITPO
Mr. Arnindan Mukherjee and
Ms.
Khushi
Cheetei,
Advocates for Respondent
No. 2
#
+
CNR No. DLHC013245522018
W.P.(C) 10086/2018
SHRIRAM VED & ORS
Through:
.....Petitioners
Ms. Meghna De,
Mr.Siddharth Sapra, and
Mr.Tusshay Singh,
Advocates
versus
INDIA TRADE PROMOTION ORGANIZATION & ANR
.....Respondents
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
Through:
#
+
Mr. Rajinder Wali and
Ms.Shivani Gupta, Advocates
for Respondent No. 1/ITPO
Mr. Arnindan Mukherjee and
Ms.
Khushi
Cheetei,
Advocates for Respondent
No. 2
CNR No. DLHC013245492018
W.P.(C) 10088/2018
SMT. LAXMI AND ORS.
Through:
.....Petitioners
Ms. Meghna De,
Mr.Siddharth Sapra, and
Mr.Tusshay Singh,
Advocates
versus
M/S INDIA TRADE PROMOTION ORGANIZATION
AND ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Rajinder Wali and
Ms.Shivani Gupta, Advocates
for Respondent No. 1/ITPO
Mr. Arnindan Mukherjee and
Ms.
Khushi
Cheetei,
Advocates for Respondent
No. 2
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The three instant writ petitions are being disposed of vide this
common judgment as they arise out of similar references decided by
the learned Presiding Officer, Labour Court-XI, Karkardooma
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
Courts, involving identical claims of illegal termination made by the
petitioners/workmen,
who
are
former
Safai
Karamcharis
(Sweepers), against respondent/management 1, M/s. India Trade
Promotion Organization, and respondent/management 2, M/s.
Sulabh International Delhi, regarding their engagement at Pragati
Maidan, New Delhi.
2.
The workmen are challenging the awards passed by the
Labour Court insofar as their claims for reinstatement with full back
wages, bonus, and payment for weekly/yearly leaves were denied,
while granting them monetary compensation instead.
3.
The three disputes were referred to the Labour Court in terms
of three largely identical references by the Secretary (Labour), Govt.
of NCT of Delhi, asking whether the services of the workmen were
terminated illegally and/or unjustifiably, and if so, to what sum of
money as monetary relief along with consequential benefits they are
entitled, to what other relief they are entitled, and what directions
are necessary in this respect.
4.
Briefly stated, the workmen claimed before the Labour Court
that they were continuously working on the post of „Sweeper/Safai
Karamchari‟ with their last drawn salary being Rs.2,700/- per
month since January 1996. They asserted that they were engaged to
perform sweeping and cleaning work at Pragati Maidan, New
Delhi, a premises owned and maintained by management 1. They
alleged that management 1 got this work executed through
contractor management 2, which had deployed them at the premises
of management 1. The workmen submitted that the work of Safai
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
Karamchari was of a permanent nature, but they were deprived of
consequent statutory legal benefits. They asserted that upon raising
an industrial dispute through their union before the Labour Office
for parity of pay with the permanent employees of management 1,
both the managements in collusion with each other wrongfully
terminated their services on 15.01.2002/31.01.2002 without serving
any notice, charge-sheet, or paying their legal dues.
5.
Management 1 contested the claim by pleading that it had no
direct employer-employee relationship with the claimants. It
submitted that conservancy work at Pragati Maidan was entrusted
to management 2 on a nomination basis via yearly agreements
executed between 1996 and 2002. It maintained that the claimants
were never in its employment and that management 1 never paid
them any wages directly.
Management 2 contested the claim by stating that it is a nonprofit voluntary social organization engaged in social work. It
submitted that it is not an “Industry” as defined under Section 2(j)
of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter the “ID Act”) and
the claimants were social workers/volunteers rendering voluntary
social services on an honorarium or pocket expenses, free to render
services as and when they so like, without any employer-employee
relationship.
6.
In the aforesaid backdrop, issues were framed by the Labour
Court regarding direct relationship of employer and employee
between the workmen and management 1, whether the claims were
maintainable, whether the workmen fell within the definition of
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
“workman” under the ID Act, terms of reference, and relief.
7.
The Labour Court decided the issue of employer-employee
relationship between management 1 and the workmen in favour of
management 1. Qua the issue of maintainability and status of
management 2, the Labour Court held management 2 to be an
“Industry” and the claimants to be “workmen” under the ID Act.
The Labour Court further held that management 2 had illegally
terminated the services of the workmen in violation of Section 25F
of the ID Act.
8.
As for relief, while denying reinstatement and back wages,
the Labour Court awarded lump-sum monetary compensation to the
proven workmen along with litigation costs of Rs.10,000/- payable
to each workman by management 2. In LIR No. 4853/16, proven
workmen were awarded lump-sum compensation of Rs.1,50,000/each; in LIR No. 4852/16, proven workmen were awarded
compensation of Rs.1,50,000/- each, except Sh. Sri Ram-II who was
awarded Rs.1,00,000/-, Sh. Raju-I and Sh. Sunil who were awarded
Rs.75,000/- each, and Sh. Ravinder who was awarded Rs.25,000/-;
and in LIR No. 4851/16, proven workmen were awarded
compensation of Rs.1,50,000/- each, except Sh. Devender who was
awarded Rs.75,000/-. Aggrieved by the denial of reinstatement, full
back wages, bonus, and leave benefits, the workmen have preferred
the present writ petitions.
9.
Learned counsel for the workmen contends that the Labour
Court erred in denying reinstatement and full back wages once the
termination was categorically held to be illegal and in violation of
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
Section 25F of the ID Act. It is submitted that the lump-sum
compensation awarded is on the very lower side and that the Labour
Court failed to consider that the workmen gave sincere services and
remained unemployed post-termination.
10.
Before proceeding further, this Court takes note of the limited
scope of writ jurisdiction in exercise of powers conferred under
Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India. It is well settled that
the challenge is not in the nature of an appeal, but to see if the order
has been passed without jurisdiction, is perverse, or does not follow
the principles of natural justice (Ref: Syed Yakoob Vs. K.S.
Radhakrishnan1). The said principle was reiterated by the Supreme
Court in International Airport Authority of India Vs. International
Air Cargo Workers Union2. This Court has also considered the
scope of writ jurisdiction in Ritz Theatre Private Limited Vs.
Ramesh Chandra3.
11.
The Labour Court held that the workmen had failed to
establish
any
direct
employer-employee
relationship
with
management 1, observing that the workmen were deployed through
management 2, and there was no pleading or proof on record that
the contract between management 1 and management 2 was sham or
bogus.
12.
Insofar as the termination by management 2 is concerned, the
workmen were held to be “workmen” under Section 2(s) of the ID
1963 SCC OnLine SC 24
(2009) 13 SCC 374
2024 SCC OnLine Del 3633
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
Act upon observing that they worked for fixed 8-hour shifts in
uniforms and were paid monthly wages linked directly to minimum
wages prescribed by the Govt. of NCT of Delhi. Holding that their
services were terminated without complying with Section 25F of the
ID Act, their termination from service was held to be illegal.
13.
Turning to the relief granted, the Labour Court declined
reinstatement and full back wages on the ground that an order for
reinstatement was not likely to result in cordial industrial relations
and considering job opportunities available in a metropolitan city
like Delhi, and instead awarded monetary compensation along with
litigation costs. A gainful reference may be made to Jagbir Singh
Vs. Haryana State Agriculture Mktg. Board4, wherein the Supreme
Court clarified that reinstatement with back wages is not automatic,
and in appropriate cases, compensation may be granted instead,
observing as under:
“7. It is true that the earlier view of this Court articulated
in many decisions reflected the legal position that if the
termination of an employee was found to be illegal, the relief of
reinstatement with full back wages would ordinarily follow.
However, in recent past, there has been a shift in the legal
position and in a long line of cases, this Court has consistently
taken the view that relief by way of reinstatement with back
wages is not automatic and may be wholly inappropriate in a
given fact situation even though the termination of an employee
is in contravention of the prescribed procedure. Compensation
instead of reinstatement has been held to meet the ends of
justice.”
14.
Similarly, the Supreme Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam
(2009) 15 SCC 327
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
Limited Vs. Bhurumal5 observed that in cases where termination is
found to be illegal due to procedural defects, compensation in place
of reinstatement may be appropriate:
“33. It is clear from the reading of the aforesaid
judgments that the ordinary principle of grant of reinstatement
with full back wages, when the termination is found to be illegal
is not applied mechanically in all cases. While that may be a
position where services of a regular/permanent workman are
terminated illegally and/or mala fide and/or by way of
victimisation, unfair labour practice, etc. However, when it
comes to the case of termination of a daily-wage worker and
where the termination is found illegal because of a procedural
defect, namely, in violation of Section 25-F of the Industrial
Disputes Act, this Court is consistent in taking the view that in
such cases reinstatement with back wages is not automatic and
instead the workman should be given monetary compensation
which will meet the ends of justice. Rationale for shifting in this
direction is obvious.
34. The reasons for denying the relief of reinstatement in
such cases are obvious. It is trite law that when the termination
is found to be illegal because of non-payment of retrenchment
compensation and notice pay as mandatorily required under
Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, even after
reinstatement, it is always open to the management to terminate
the services of that employee by paying him the retrenchment
compensation. Since such a workman was working on dailywage basis and even after he is reinstated, he has no right to
seek regularisation [see State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3)
[(2006) 4 SCC 1: 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] ]. Thus when he cannot
claim regularisation and he has no right to continue even as a
daily-wage worker, no useful purpose is going to be served in
reinstating such a workman and he can be given monetary
compensation by the Court itself inasmuch as if he is terminated
again after reinstatement, he would receive monetary
compensation only in the form of retrenchment compensation
and notice pay. In such a situation, giving the relief of
reinstatement, that too after a long gap, would not serve any
purpose.
35. We would, however, like to add a caveat here. There
may be cases where termination of a daily-wage worker is found
(2014) 7 SCC 177
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
to be illegal on the ground that it was resorted to as unfair
labour practice or in violation of the principle of last come first
go viz. while retrenching such a worker daily wage juniors to
him were retained. There may also be a situation that persons
junior to him were regularised under some policy but the
workman concerned terminated. In such circumstances, the
terminated worker should not be denied reinstatement unless
there are some other weighty reasons for adopting the course of
grant of compensation instead of reinstatement. In such cases,
reinstatement should be the rule and only in exceptional cases
for the reasons stated to be in writing, such a relief can be
denied.”
15.
In the present cases, the events relate back to 1996-2002, and
over two decades has elapsed since the termination of the
workmen‟s services. Taking into account the nature of the
workmen‟s engagement, their age, the lengths of service rendered,
this Court is of the considered opinion that the quantum of
compensation determined by the Labour Court is just, fair, and
reasonable, and cannot be termed as perverse or arbitrary so as to
warrant interference under writ jurisdiction.
16.
Accordingly, the present writ petitions are dismissed.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
AUGUST 07, 2026
nb
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:48:10
W.P.(C) 10074/2018 & Other connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review