Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 28th September 2026.
Pronounced on: 05th October 2026.
Uploaded on: 06th October 2026.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC011348482018
MAC.APP. 490/2018 & CM APPL. 21237/2018
SHRIRAM GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Sameer Nandwani & Mr.
Nakshatra Bhasin, Advocates
(through VC).
versus
SIMRAN KAUR & ORS
Through:
#
+
.....Respondents
Ms. Urvashi Sharma, Ms. Swati
Popli, Advocates (through VC).
Dr. Manish Dhawan, Senior
Consultant at Sir Ganga Ram
Hospital (through VC).
CNR No. DLHC010456742026
MAC.APP. 626/2026
SIMRAN KAUR
.....Appellant
Through: Ms. Urvashi Sharma, Ms. Swati
Popli, Advocates (through VC).
versus
ASHID AND ORS (SHRIRAM GENERAL INSURANCE CO
LTD )
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sameer Nandwani & Mr.
Nakshatra Bhasin, Advocates for
Insurance Company (through
VC).
Dr. Manish Dhawan, Senior
Consultant at Sir Ganga Ram
Hospital (through VC).
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
%
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
These cross-appeal appeals have been filed assailing impugned
award dated 13th March 2018, passed by the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi [hereinafter, ‘MACT/Tribunal’] in
MACT Case No. 477726/2016, whereby compensation of Rs.14,89,090/,
along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum, was awarded to the
injured/claimant, namely Ms. Simran Kumar [hereinafter, ‘impugned
award’].
2.
MAC.APP. 490/2018 has been filed by the Insurance Company,
assailing compensation awarded to the injured/claimant under certain
non-pecuniary heads, whereas MAC.APP. 626/2026 has been filed by
injured/claimant seeking enhancement of the compensation awarded.
The Incident
3.
The impugned award arose out of an accident which occurred on
12th March 2016, when Ms. Simran Kumar, injured/claimant, who was a
minor at the time, aged 15 years, was travelling on a bus, heading from
Ludhiana to Delhi and Jaipur, along with her father. Upon reaching,
G.T. Road, Panchi Gujran cut, the said bus was hit by a truck bearing
registration no. UP-78AN-9971, which was being driven rashly and
negligently. As a result of the said accident, injured/claimant suffered
grievous injuries, leading to 66% permanent disability.
Submissions on behalf of the parties
4.
Mr. Sameer Nandwani, counsel for Insurance Company, has
challenged two components of the awarded compensation, first, grant of
Rs.4,00,000/- towards ‘loss of studies’ and second, grant of Rs.2,00,000/Signature Not Verified
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
towards ‘loss of marriage prospects’. In this regard, Mr. Nandwani
submitted that the injured/claimant ought to have placed on record,
certain documentary evidence, such as her school marksheet or
attendance record to establish the fact that she suffered “loss of studies”
as a result of the said accident. Furthermore, he submitted that the nature
of her injuries was not such as would adversely affect her future career
prospects.
5.
Ms. Urvashi Sharma, counsel for injured/claimant, on the other
hand, has sought enhancement of the awarded compensation on account
of future treatment, for which only an amount of ‘Rs.1,00,000/-’ had
been granted, inspite of an estimation of ‘Rs.10,00,000/-’ being provided
by Sir Ganga Ram Hospital for her future surgery. She stated that more
than 10 years have passed since the accident and that the
injured/claimant has now attained the age of majority.
6.
Ms. Sharma, counsel for injured/claimant, further submitted that
the possibility of a corrective surgery would be able to reduce the
suffering and disability of injured/claimant to some extent, particularly,
when the disability was assessed as “deformity of the left foot, including
varus deformity of the heel, equnius deformity of the ankle, amputated
toes and shortening of limb”.
7.
Ms. Sharma, counsel for injured/claimant, argued that the
aforesaid surgery had been prescribed to injured/claimant, in order that
the deformity in her left heel may be treated for better mobility. The
Estimated Cost Certificate dated 03rd February 2026 had been appended
along with the appeal as ‘Annexure A-1’, and was signed by Dr. Manish
Dhawan, Senior Consultant, Department of Orthopaedics at Sir Ganga
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
Ram Hospital.
8.
Pursuant to the aforesaid submission of Ms. Sharma, counsel for
injured/claimant, Court Notice was issued to Dr. Manish Dhawan,
Senior Consultant, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, to enable him to testify
regarding the certificate issued by him.
9.
Accordingly, Dr. Manish Dhawan, Senior Consultant, Department
of Orthopaedics at Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, had appeared before the
Court, through VC, and deposed as under:
i)
That he is a limb correction specialist, and that the elective surgery
that Ms. Simran Kaur [injured/claimant herein] is opting for is a
specialized and complicated surgery, requiring at least three
separate surgical procedures, which would aid in the recovery of
her amputated toes as well as the limb which has been shortened
as a result of the accident. The said surgery involves the use of a
specialized software and technique which is not easily available.
However, he receives a number of references, particularly for this
purpose.
ii)
He further stated that the cost estimate given by him on 03 rd
February 2026, amounting to about Rs.9,35,000/- is a legitimate
estimate, but is based on the option of the ‘single room’ category
in the hospital, and if a slightly lower category of room is opted
for, the cost would reduce by about Rs.1,00,000/-. The recovery
following the surgery and the process as a whole, is a prolonged
one and may take up to a year, since lengthening of the limb
proceeds at a very slow pace.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
10.
Upon
taking
instructions
from
Ms.
Simran
Kumar
[injured/claimant] in this regard, Ms. Urvashi Sharma, counsel for
injured/claimant, submitted that it is not as if the injured/claimant was
opting to take an expensive room and, thereby, incur a higher treatment
cost, but was instead seeking to correct, in a reasonable manner, the huge
impediment which had been caused to her by the accident, and keep
herself safe from infections.
Analysis
11.
Having heard the submissions of the parties as also the opinion of
Dr. Mahesh Dhawan, this Court is of the view that, considering the
prolonged treatment and complicated nature of the surgery, it was
reasonable for the injured/claimant to expect a single room for her
treatment, so as to ensure that her health and recovery are not exposed to
any further risk. Further, in view of the testimony of Dr. Dhawan, who
stated that the difference in cost would be only about Rs.1,00,000/-, it
would not be appropriate to expose the injured/claimant to any additional
health risk or bodily suffering.
12.
Accordingly, the Court is inclined to grant a sum of Rs.10,00,000/,
to injured/claimant towards cost of said surgery/treatment, as sought,
considering that there may be minor variations in the cost of this
treatment.
13.
As regards the issue raised by Mr. Sameer Nandwani, counsel for
Insurance Company, of Rs.4,00,000/- being awarded towards loss of
studies and Rs.2,00,000/- being awarded towards loss of marriage
prospects, the same needs to be considered in context of the fact that the
functional disability of injured/claimant had been assessed at 66%.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
14.
There are few facts which need to be placed in perspective, with
respect to injured/claimant, which were elaborated upon by the MACT.
Firstly, the MACT took note of the testimony of PW-2, Dr. Naresh
Chandra, Specialist and In-Charge of Orthopaedic Department, Guru
Govind Singh, Government Hospital, who deposed that she would not be
able to walk and run as a normal human being.
15.
Moreover, the injured/claimant was studying in the 8th standard at
Garden Valley International School and was 16 years of age at the time
of the accident. The MACT accordingly noted there existed exceptional
circumstances in the case, warranting a higher compensation, since the
entire career of the injured/claimant had been spoiled due to the accident.
16.
Injured/claimant had also been a champion at Kho-Kho and Long
Jump and had a bright career in sports and academics. The MACT noted
the precarious condition of her left leg, apparent from the photograph
exhibited as Ex.PW1/12, which has also been perused by this Court, as
well as the Certificate of Appreciation, exhibited as Ex.PW1/10 (Colly.),
recording that she had been securing the 3rd, 2nd and 1st positions at KhoKho and Long Jump, and awarded the compensation accordingly.
17.
As regards the compensation to be awarded in cases of injury, the
principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Raj Kumar v. Ajay
Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343, are well established. As per the said
principles, in cases involving injuries caused due to motor accidents, the
compensation under non-pecuniary heads, shall be awarded towards
damages for pain and suffering, loss of prospects of amenities/loss of
prospects of marriage, and loss of expectation of life.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
18.
Accordingly, in case of a young girl, who has been deprived of the
opportunity to lead a normal life due to the accident, it was not amiss for
the MACT to award Rs.2,00,000/- towards loss of marriage prospects
and Rs.4,00,000/- towards loss of studies. The ability to pursue
academics and sports, develop a career, and in due course, establish a
family of her own, are ordinary aspirations and expectations, forming an
integral part of the normal course of life of any person. These are not
merely aspirations for the future but aspects of life that injured/claimant
would have reasonably expected to pursue had the accident not occurred.
Therefore, having been deprived of the same on account of the accident,
there is no reason why she ought not be adequately compensated for it.
19.
Particularly, as regards the compensation awarded towards ‘loss of
studies’, similar views have also been taken by this Court in a number of
decisions, inter alia, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sarfaraz Safi,
2026 SCC OnLine Del 6310, wherein the Court had considered the
impact of loss of studies upon the injured/claimant and concluded that
the loss of studies would result in a corresponding loss of amenities.
Accordingly, compensation awarded under the head of loss of amenities
was enhanced by the Court.
20.
The same was principle was then followed by this Court in Satish
Kumar v. Kanika Sibal, 2026 SCC OnLine Del 2441, wherein loss of
studies was considered to relate to the overall deprivation suffered by the
claimant during the period of disability and consequent disruption of
academic progression, and was accordingly subsumed within loss of
amenities of life.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
21.
In Niketa Chauhan v. Suresh, 2026 SCC OnLine Del 1459, the
Court assessed the impact of the accident on the claimant’s education
and studies, leading to lack of progress in the claimant’s ability to pursue
a vocation and earn a livelihood. The Court, therefore, awarded
compensation towards loss of studies and loss of marriage prospects.
22.
In any event, compensation for injuries may broadly be assessed
under three heads, namely, pain and suffering, loss of amenities of life
including loss of marriage prospects, and loss of expectation of life.
However, the question is not of the head of compensation itself, but the
nature of loss which has been covered under each of these components.
Loss of studies and loss of marriage prospects certainly fall within the
broader head of loss of amenities of life. Further, considering that the
said amount has already been granted, though under independent
components, the Court is not inclined to reduce the compensation so
awarded, as pleaded by the Insurance Company.
23.
In view of the above as well as the settled position of law, as per
which, the principle of ‘just and fair compensation’ must always be kept
in mind while awarding compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988, the Court does not find any reason to reduce the compensation
awarded by the MACT.
Directions
24.
Accordingly, Rs.10,00,000/- towards the cost of future surgery of
injured/claimant, shall be deposited by the Insurance Company before
the MACT, within a period of 4 weeks and shall be kept in an interestbearing fixed deposit, with liberty to injured/claimant to withdraw from
the said amount, as and when required. It is made clear that the said
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
amount shall be released to injured/claimant only upon production of
requisite documents from the hospital, confirming that she has been
planned for the surgery.
25.
Vide order dated 21st May 2018, this Court had directed the
Insurance Company to deposit the entire awarded amount before the
MACT along with release of 30% of the said amount in favour of
injured/claimant.
26.
Accordingly, the balance amount, along with accrued interest
thereon, if not already released, shall be released to the injured/claimant,
as a lump sum, considering that the accident occurred way back in 2016.
27.
Statutory amount, if any, shall be refunded to the Insurance
Company, only if the order of deposit has been complied with.
28.
Appeals are disposed in above terms.
29.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
30.
Judgement be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
OCTOBER 05, 2026/MK/ya
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC.APP. 490/2018 & MAC.APP. 626/2026
14:50:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review