Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/3494/2017
(GJHC240416612017)
ORDER DATED: 09/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3494 of 2017
==========================================================
SHRIRAM FINANCE COMPANY LIMITED
Versus
AARTIBEN BHARATBHAI PETHANI & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR MANISH J PATEL(2131) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
RULE SERVED for the Defendant(s) No. 1,2
SERVED BY AFFIX. (R) for the Defendant(s) No. 3
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE J. C. DOSHI
Date : 09/10/2026
ORDER
1.
The present First Appeal, under Section 173 of Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, is preferred by the appellant being
aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and award dated
17.1.2017 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Rajkot in Motor Accident Claim Petition No.1026 of 2011.
2.
Since the factual aspects of the case involving the
vehicle in the road accident and the liability of the owner as
well as the insurer are not disputed by the Insurance
Company, to streamline the consideration of the present
appeal, I have adopted approach that avoids burdening the
judgment with unnecessary narration, since the facts are
already detailed in the record and there is no practical
purpose in restating the same. Likewise, re-evaluating the
underlying findings would serve no useful purpose in the
C/FA/3494/2017
(GJHC240416612017)
ORDER DATED: 09/10/2026
appeal. The efficiency of stating the facts and evaluating the
evidence is entirely justified, since the core element remains
undisputed.
Thus, reiterating these settled matters would
only clutter the final judicial analysis. Therefore, this Court
can safely adopt the existing record without further review.
This
omission
ensures
a
focused,
clear,
and
efficient
resolution of the remaining issue argued before the Court.
3.
Learned advocate Mr. Manish Patel appearing for the
appellant – insurance company raised solitary contention that
the learned Tribunal has wrongly interpreted the definition of
“owner” to consider the appellant as owner of the offending
vehicle, whereas, the appellant has issue loan for purchase of
the offending vehicle and executed Hypothecation Agreement
(HPA) and thus, Mr.Vijaybhai Vachhrajani is the owner of the
offending vehicle and is liable to pay the compensation and
thus, the learned Tribunal has erred in marking the liability of
the appellant – insurance company to pay the compensation
being the owner of the offending vehicle. Thus, he prays to
allow this First Appeal.
4.
Though served, none appears for the respondents.
5.
Having heard learned advocate for the appellant, let
refer para 11 of the impugned judgment and award, whereby
the learned Tribunal has decided the issue raised in this First
Appeal (translated into English from vernacular language).
“If we look at the liability to pay the compensation to
which the applicants are entitled, then in the present
case, looking at the retail invoice submitted by the
C/FA/3494/2017
(GJHC240416612017)
ORDER DATED: 09/10/2026
applicants at No. 32 and the sale certificate
submitted by the applicants at No. 33, it is seen that
the Bajaj auto rickshaw involved in the accident was
new at that time and its owner was opponent No. 1.
Further, looking at the said evidence, it is also seen
that the said auto rickshaw was purchased on loan by
opponent No. 1, so that the HPA of the said auto
rickshaw was with Shri Ram Finance K.L., opponent
No. 2. The main submission of the applicants is that It
has been submitted that the respondent no.1 is the
owner of the said auto rickshaw and he has taken a
loan from the respondent no.2 Shri Ram Finance Co.
Ltd. and the said rickshaw is owned by the
respondent no.2 company HPA and thus the
respondent no.2 is the co-owner of the said rickshaw
involved in the accident, so that both the respondents
should be held liable to pay compensation. If this
submission made by the petitioners is taken into
consideration, the fact that the respondent no.1 is the
owner of the said rickshaw involved in the accident is
evident from the documentary evidence of figures-32
and 33 presented on the record. If figure-32 is seen,
it is a copy of the retail invoice and in the said retail
invoice it is clearly seen that the said vehicle is HPA
BY Shri Ram Finance Co. Ltd. i.e. respondent no. The
said retail invoice has been issued on 7-4-2011. That
is, it is clearly evident that it is an invoice before the
accident. Similarly, if the sale certificate submitted
with No. 33 is seen, the said sale certificate states
that "The Vehicle is held under agreement of Hire
Purchase with Shri Ram Loans Fin. Co. Ltd." The said
sale certificate has been issued on 15-4-2011 as per
the said sale certificate. The accident in question has
taken place on 13-4-2011 and looking at the facts of
the retail invoice with No. 32 and the sale certificate
with No. 33, the said vehicle is registered with No. 2
Shri Ram Finance Qu. Ltd. H.P.A. If the accident
occurred, the constructive possession of the said
vehicle involved in the accident is considered to be
that of respondent no. 2. In this context, if we look at
the definition of owner as per section 2(19) of the MV
Act, it is as follows:
C/FA/3494/2017
(GJHC240416612017)
ORDER DATED: 09/10/2026
"OWNER" means a person in whose name a motor
vehicle stands registered and where such person is a
minor, the guardian of such minor, and in relation to
a motor vehicle which is the subject of a hirepurchase, agreement, or an agreement of lease or an
agreement of hypothecation, the person in possession
of the vehicle under that agreement; Thus, despite
the fact that the respondent No.2 has been served
with notice for the purpose of the compensation
application, he has not appeared in person or through
his lawyer and no denial has been made of the record
submitted for the purpose of the compensation
application. If we look at the judgment of the Hon'ble
Gujarat High Court in Himmatnagar Nagarik
Sahakari Bank Ltd., vs. Sureshkumar Jayantilal
Thakkar and others, 2016 ACJ 2821, the Hon'ble
Gujarat High Court has concluded as follows in para
5.11 and 5.12 of the said judgment:
5.11 After considering various earlier decisions, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Godavari
Finance Co., 2006 ACJ 1612 (SC), in para-10 has
observed and held as under :"(10) on a plain reading of the aforesaid definition, it
is demonstrable that a person in whose name a motor
vehicle stands registered is the owner of the vehicle
and, where motor vehicle is the subject of hirepurchase
agreement
or
an
agreement
of
hypothecation, the person in possession of the vehicle
under that agreement is the owner. It also stipulates
that in case of a minor, the guardian of such a minor
shall be treated as the owner. Thus, the intention of
the legislature in case of a minor is mandated to treat
the guardian of such a minor as the "owner", This is
the first exception to the definition of the term
"owner". The second exception that has been carved
whcih is the subject of hire-purchase agreement or an
agreement
of
lease
or
an
agreement
of
hypothecation, the person in possession of vehicle
under that agree,ent is the owner. be it noted, the
legislature has deliberately carved out these
exceptions from registered owners thereby making
C/FA/3494/2017
(GJHC240416612017)
ORDER DATED: 09/10/2026
guardian of a minor liable, and the person in
possession of the vehicle under the agreement
mentioned in the dictionary clause to be the owners
for the purposes of this Act."
5.12 Applying the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the aforesaid decisions and even
considering the definition of "owner" contained in
section 2(19) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, and
considering the fact that the appellant bank- creditor
was in possession of the jeep under both the
agreements, i.e., agreement of pledge as well as
hypothecation agreement the appellant bank can be
said to be the "owner" within the definition of section
2(19) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 and therefore,
being "owner", the appellant bank is liable to pay
comepsnation to the victim of the accident. Under the
circumstances, as such no error has been committed
by the learned trial court in holding the appellant
bank jointly and severally liable to pay comepsnation
to the victim of the accident. The Learned Tribunal
has rightly passed the award agaisnt the appellant
bank also and has rightly held the appellant bank also
liable to pay comepsnation to the victim of the
accident."
Thus, in view of the above facts, taking into account
the principles laid down in the above judgment by the
Hon'ble Gujarat High Court, it is held that the liability
for paying the compensation to which the petitioners
are entitled lies with the co-defendants No. 1 and 2
jointly and severally and therefore the petitioners are
entitled to compensation from both the codefendants. Therefore, I hereby pass the following
final order in the interest of justice under point No.
3.”
6.
The
aforesaid
finding
of
the
learned
Tribunal
demonstrates that the learned Tribunal has followed the
judgment of this Court and held that the vehicle since
C/FA/3494/2017
(GJHC240416612017)
ORDER DATED: 09/10/2026
hypothecated under the HPA, the owner would be the financer
u/s 2(19) of the MV Act and is liable to pay the compensation.
Learned advocate Mr. Patel failed to point out any infirmity in
the aforesaid findings of the learned Tribunal.
7.
In view of above, First Appeal fails and stands dismissed.
The Tribunal shall disburse the entire awarded amount
lying in the FDR and/or with the Tribunal, with accrued
interest thereon, if any, to the claimant, by account payee
cheque / NEFT / RTGS, after proper verification and after
following due procedure.
9.
While making the payment, the Tribunal shall deduct the
courts fees, if not paid, in accordance with rules/law.
10.
Record and proceedings be sent back to the concerned
Tribunal, forthwith.
(J. C. DOSHI,J)
SHEKHAR P. BARVE
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review