Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 17.02.2026
Date of decision: 06.04.2026
+
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
SHRI SHASHI SHEKHAR PRASAD
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Apurv Kurup, Sr. Adv. with Mr.
Kanu Agrawal, Ms. Mehak Kumar,
Mr. Gaurav Vats, Mr. Akhil Hasija
& Ms. Nidhi Mittal, Advs.
versus
LOKPAL OF INDIA AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Nishant R. Katneshwarkar with
Mr. Vijay Singh Mehra & Mr.
Shrirang Katneshwarkar Advs. R-1/
Lokpal of India.
Mr. Anupam S. Sharma, SPP with
Mr. Vashisth Rao, Ms. Amisha P.
Dash, Ms. Riya Sachdev & Mr.
Deepak Rawat, Advs. for R-2/CBI.
Mr. Premtosh K. Mishra, CGSC with
Mr. Shrey Sharma, Mr. Anubhav
Upadhyay, Mr. Arpit Bamal, Advs.
for R-3/UoI.
Mr. N. Venkataraman, ASG with
Mr. Anurag Ojha, Sr. SC for R-4.
Mr. Abhimanyu Bhandari, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Rooh-e-hin Dua, Mr.
Harshit Khanduja, Ms. Shreya
Arora, Mr. Ricky Chaudhary and
Ms. Aroha Kadyan, Advocates for
R-5.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE RENU BHATNAGAR
JUDGMENT
1.
The Petitioner prays for a writ of certiorari for quashing of the Order
dated 24.07.2025 passed by Respondent No.1/The Lokpal of India. By the
impugned order, the Lokpal has directed an investigation under Section
20(3) of the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013 (“the Act”) by the
Respondent No.2/Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) against the
Petitioner and certain other custom department officials from Kolkata
[Kolkata RPSs] impleaded as respondents.
2.
The facts, inter alia, are that the Respondent No.5, the complainant
before the Lokpal, is alleged to have masterminded a huge smuggling
syndicate controlling more than 20 dummy firms. Over the period several
show-cause notices were issued to Respondent No.5 proposing confiscation
of goods and raising demands running into several hundred crores of
rupees. At the relevant time, the petitioner was serving as Senior
Intelligence Officer, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), Delhi
Zonal Unit, Ministry of Finance, and was part of the investigation team of
the said matter. Respondent no.5 lodged a Complaint bearing no. 196/2024,
before the Lokpal on 13.09.2024 alleging corruption, misuse of office and
other misconduct against the petitioner and Kolkata RPSs. By an order
dated 27.09.2024 passed under Section 20(1) of the Act, the Lokpal
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
directed a preliminary inquiry by the CBI against all officials. The CBI
after conducting a thorough inquiry, and finding no material against the
Petitioner, submitted its preliminary inquiry report dated 11.12.2024 in his
favour. The report, however, did not absolve the Kolkata RPSs. The Lokpal
thereafter sought comments from the Director General of Vigilance
(DGoV), who concurred with the findings of the CBI. The DGoV
endorsement was also accepted by the Finance Minister of India, as the
Competent Authority of the Ministry of Finance.
3.
After taking into consideration the findings of preliminary inquiry
report and the defence of only the Kolkata RPSs, the Lokpal by its Order
dated 21.05.2025, issued show-cause notice under Section 20 (3) of the Act
to the Kolkata RPSs, but along with the same the Lokpal also added the
petitioner and issued notice to him. After considering the replies, the
Lokpal by the impugned order dated 24.07.2025 has directed an
investigation under Section 20(3)(a) of the Act by the CBI against the
Kolkata RPSs and the petitioner, holding that “Preliminary Inquiry has
brought in fore counter allegations supported with verifiable facts”.
Aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner has approached this Court by
way of this petition.
4.
We have heard learned counsels for the parties at length and have
perused the record.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the preliminary
inquiry conducted by the CBI, after finding no material against the
Petitioner, had exonerated him. It is submitted that Respondent No.1/
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
Lokpal was required to indicate specific reasons, material or infirmities in
the preliminary report and material available against the petitioner
constituting a prima facie case for directing an investigation under Section
20(3) of the Act. The Lokpal without referring to any material whatsoever
against the Petitioner could not have passed the impugned order against
him. Petitioner claims that neither the order of Lokpal dated 21.05.2025
and show-cause notice dated 23.05.2025, nor the impugned order dated
24.07.2025 contains anything against the Petitioner; still he is being
harassed by the said proceedings without any basis.
6.
It is further submitted for the petitioner that though the alleged acts
of bribery and threats were committed in 2019, the Complaint 196/2024, on
the basis of which the impugned order has been passed, was made against
the petitioner only in the year 2024, i.e., after a delay of 5 years. The
complaint was in fact in retaliation of several show-cause notices issued to
the Respondent No. 5 by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, Delhi
Zonal Unit (DRI).
7.
Per contra, learned counsels for the Respondent no. 1/Lokpal and
Respondent no.5/Complainant submit that Section 20(3) of the Act confers
discretion to the Lokpal to either direct an investigation by the CBI, or
initiation of a departmental proceedings or any other appropriate action
against the concerned public servants by the competent authority, or for
closure. It is submitted that the Lokpal is not bound by the preliminary
inquiry report of the CBI and has power to form an independent view.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
8.
Learned ASG for Respondent No. 4/ DRI supports the submissions
advanced on behalf of the petitioner, that in absence of any supportive
material, the Lokpal could not have taken a view adverse to the preliminary
report of CBI and that of DGoV, which was also accepted by the Minister
of Finance.
9.
In the present matter, the preliminary inquiry of the CBI found the
allegations against the petitioner to be unsubstantiated but found sufficient
material against the Kolkata RPSs. The DGoV concurred with those
findings, and the concurrence was also accepted by the competent authority
in the Ministry of Finance. This formed the complete record placed before
the Lokpal along with the complaint for passing order under Section 20(3)
of the Act. Once these materials favoured the petitioner, the statute required
the Lokpal to record reasons explaining why, notwithstanding such
exculpatory material, a prima facie case still existed. Solely, the complaint
filed after years could not have constituted the basis on which prima facie
satisfaction under Section 20(3) could rest, because the statutory scheme
contemplates that the complaint is to be tested through a preliminary
inquiry before any further steps may be taken.
10.
The Order of the Lokpal dated 21.05.2025, by which show-cause
notices under Section 20(3) of the Act were issued, concerns itself only
with the role, conduct, replies and defences of the Kolkata RPSs and not
that of Petitioner. Notwithstanding this complete absence of any discussion
about Petitioner, the Order dated 21.05.2025 directs notice to be issued to
all the RPSs, including the Petitioner. Thus, a Notice dated 23.05.2025
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
under Section 20(3) came to be issued to the petitioner along with the
Kolkata RPSs. This Order dated 21.05.2025 and Notice dated 23.05.2025
based upon the same, are not supported by any material or discussion with
regard to the Petitioner. Issuing notices mechanically, without any
discussion as to the role of the person proceeded against, undermines the
very integrity of the statutory mechanism. Thus, both Order dated
21.05.2025 and Notice dated 23.05.2025, being without any basis to the
extent they relate to Petitioner, are perverse and illegal.
11.
The statutory framework under Section 20 of the Act is structured
with precision and must be followed in letter and spirit. There must first be
a preliminary inquiry under Section 20(1), followed by the comments of
the competent authority under Section 20(2), and finally a consideration of
every report received under sub-section (2) together with the explanation of
the public servant under Section 20(3). On the basis of above, the Lokpal
has to decide whether there exists a prima facie satisfaction under Section
20(3). This is not a procedural formality but a mandatory requirement. The
Lokpal must show that this satisfaction is based upon some material and
after due application of mind. This ensures that further actions are not taken
merely on the basis of mere allegations or assumptions.
12.
The impugned Order dated 24.07.2025 also does not disclose any
clear articulation of facts or material by the Lokpal for arriving at its prima
facie satisfaction. No defects, contradictions, or omissions in the
preliminary inquiry report have been identified. No cogent reasoning has
been recorded to reject the findings of the CBI and the DGoV. Instead, the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
impugned order appears to rely on general assertions and allegations, which
do not satisfy the statutory mandate. In the absence of such reasons, the
impugned order does not reflect the application of mind as required by law,
particularly when the effect of such an order is to set in motion an
investigation against a public servant. Merely because power is vested in
Lokpal to hold investigation under section 20(3), it does not mean that the
same can be exercised in a whimsical or arbitrary manner. There should
exist sufficient material duly considered in the order to support such
exercise of power. In absence of the same it becomes arbitrary and illegal.
13.
It is well settled that an order passed by a quasi-judicial authority or
even an administrative authority affecting the rights of the parties must be
supported by clear and cogent reasons. Mere allegation or suspicion cannot
lead or form the basis of a finding of prima facie satisfaction.
14.
The Supreme Court in The Siemens Engineering & Manufacturing
Co. Of India Ltd. v. The Union Of India & Anr., (1976) 2 SCC 981, held
that: “6. …
It is now settled law that where an authority makes an order in
exercise of a quasi-judicial function, it must record its reasons in
support of the order it makes. Every quasi-judicial order must be
supported by reasons. That has been laid down by a long line of
decisions of this Court ending with N.M. Desai v. Testeels Ltd.
[C. A. No. 245 of 1970, decided on December 17, 1975].
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
If courts of law are to be replaced by a administrative authorities
and tribunals, as indeed, in some kinds of cases, with the
proliferation of Administrative Law, they may have to be so
replaced, it is essential that administrative authorities and
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
tribunals should accord fair and proper hearing to the persons
sought to be affected by their orders and give sufficiently clear and
explicit reasons in support of the orders made by them. Then
alone administrative authorities and tribunals exercising quasijudicial function will be able to justify their existence and carry
credibility with the people by inspiring confidence in the
adjudicatory process. The rule requiring reasons to be given in
support of an order is, like the principle of audi alteram partem, a
basic principle of natural justice which must inform every quasijudicial process and this rule must be observed in its proper spirit
and mere pretence of compliance with it would not satisfy the
requirement of law…”
(emphasis added)
15.
In Mohinder Singh Gill & Anr. v. The Chief Election
Commissioner, New Delhi & Ors., (1978) 1 SCC 405, the Supreme Court
held: “8. The second equally relevant matter is that when a statutory
functionary makes an order based on certain grounds, its validity
must be judged by the reasons so mentioned and cannot be
supplemented by fresh reasons in the shape of affidavit or otherwise.
Otherwise, an order bad in the beginning may, by the time it comes to
court on account of a challenge, get validated by additional grounds
later brought out. We may here draw attention to the observations of
Bose, J. In Gordhandas Bhanji [Commr. of Police, Bombay v.
Gordhandas Bhanji, 1951 SCC 1088 : AIR 1952 SC 16] :
“Public orders, publicly made, in exercise of a statutory authority
cannot be construed in the light of explanations subsequently given by
the officer making the order of what he meant, or of what was in his
mind, or what he intended to do. Public orders made by public
authorities are meant to have public effect and are intended to affect
the actings and conduct of those to whom they are addressed and must
be construed objectively with reference to the language used in the
order itself.”
(emphasis added)
16.
The Supreme Court in S.N. Mukherjee v. Union of India, (1990) 4
SCC 594, held that the requirement of recording reasons by an
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
administrative authority while exercising quasi-judicial functions serves an
important purpose and reasons must be recorded. It ensures that the
authority has applied its mind to the issues involved, introduces clarity in
the decision-making process, and minimizes the possibility of arbitrariness.
Essentially, recording of reasons enables the appellate or supervisory
Courts to effectively exercise their jurisdiction. Reasons must be clear and
explicit so as to indicate that the authority has given due consideration to
the points in controversy.
17.
In the present case, the impugned order does not reflect adherence to
fundamental principles. Para 19 of the impugned order refers to “counter
allegations supported with verifiable facts” but does not identify what those
facts are, how they reject or overcome the findings of the CBI, approval of
DGoV and of the Minister of Finance, or how they justify a deeper probe.
Without such clarity, the statutory satisfaction required under Section 20(3)
of the Act cannot be achieved. A direction for investigation under the said
provision carries serious consequences and, therefore, demands strict
adherence to statutory requirements and the principles of fairness in
decision-making.
18.
In the present case, neither the Order dated 21.05.2025, nor the
Notice dated 23.05.2025, nor the impugned Order dated 24.07.2025
disclose any reasoning justifying further investigation against the
petitioner. The Lokpal has failed to indicate any concrete or verifiable
material, or any infirmity in the preliminary inquiry report, warranting a
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
departure from findings which, along with the concurrence of the DGoV,
and Minister of Finance are in favour of the petitioner.
19.
It is made clear that this Court has examined the Order dated
21.05.2025, Notice dated 23.05.2025 and impugned Order dated
24.07.2025 only to the extent they relate to the Petitioner and not with
regard to Kolkata RPSs.
20.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the present writ petition
deserves to succeed and is allowed. The impugned Order dated 24.07.2025
passed by Respondent No.1/ Lokpal is hereby quashed in so far as it relates
to the petitioner.
VIVEK CHAUDHARY
(JUDGE)
RENU BHATNAGAR
(JUDGE)
APRIL 6, 2026/nc
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
12:38:20
W.P.(C) 12845/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review