Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
RSA 8/2026, CM APPL. 1734-1736/2026
SHRI RAMESH PARKASH
Through:
Versus
SHRI BALBIR SINGH
Through:
Mr.
Tarun
Advocate.
.....Appellant
Kumar
Bhardwaj,
.....Respondent
None.
%
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
ORDER
12.01.2026
1.
Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 CPC has been filed on
behalf of the Appellant against the Judgment and Decree dated 18.08.2025
of learned JSDCC/ASCJ/Guardian Judge-01, Delhi in RCA SCJ
No.340/2016, whereby the Judgment of Dismissal of Suit for Permanent
Injunction dated 01.10.2012 by learned Senior Civil Judge, Delhi, has been
set aside and the Suit has been decreed.
2.
The brief facts are that a Suit for Permanent Injunction was filed by
Balbir Singh, Respondent in the year 1999 wherein he alleged that he had
purchased the Plot of land No.22 ad-measuring 261 sq. yds forming part of
Khasra No.98/1/1, Swaran Park Extn., village Mundka, from Shri Shyam
Lal on 21.12.1988 for a valuable consideration of Rs.30,000/-, on execution
of Agreement to Sell, GPA, Affidavit, Receipt, etc. who was the owner and
in possession of the Suit property. Shri Shyam Lal in turn, had purchased the
Plot from Ram Kishan on 26.05.1998 who in turn had purchased it from
Satish Kumar and Krishan Kumar on 18.12.1986. Each of the vendors had
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
executed the conventional documents i.e., Agreement to Sell, GPA, etc. in
favor of the subsequent purchaser. Satish Kumar and Krishan Kumar were
the actual owners/Bhumidars of the said Khasras. They had sold the other
portions of the Khasra to other persons.
3.
Shri Shyam Lal had handed over the vacant and peaceful physical
possession of the Plot in the year 1999 and since then the Plaintiff has been
in physical possession of the property. He asserted that at the time of
purchase, there was a boundary wall on two sides of the adjoining plot
owners and on the other two sides, the Plaintiff had raised the boundary
wall.
4.
Balbir Singh, the plaintiff therefore, asserted that having purchased
the property from Shri Shyam Lal on execution of valid documents of Title,
he acquired the ownership and Defendants had no right, title, or interest in
the Suit property. However, Defendant No.1, who is a muscle man and
Property Dealer by profession and a land grabber who is in the habit of
taking forcible possession of plots and land of others, had made an endeavor
to forcibly take the possession of the Suit plot.
5.
The Plaintiff, Balbir Singh went to the Suit Plot on 27.07.1999 and
was shocked to see that Defendant No.1 had removed the kachha boundary
wall of the Plot and was attempting to occupy the Plot. The Plaintiff
protested and did not let him do so. He approached the Local Police PS
Nangloi, but the Police failed to take any action. He then gave a Complaint
in writing on 02.09.1999 to SHO and another Complaint to the DCP on
13.09.1999, though to no avail. The Plaintiff claimed that the Local Police,
in league with the high-ups in the Police, did not take any action on his
Complaints.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
6.
On 16.09.1999 while the Plaintiff was present on his Plot in the
evening, Defendant No.1 Shri Ramesh Parkash/Appellant accompanied by
Defendant No.2 Shri Satbir Singh again came to the Plot and claimed to be
the owner of the same, having purchased the same from Defendant No.2.
Defendant No.1 threatened to take forcible possession of the Suit property.
The Plaintiff, thus, filed a Suit for Permanent Injunction to restrain the
Defendant from taking forcible possession of the Suit property.
7.
The Defendant No.1/Sh. Shri Ramesh Parkash in his Written
Statement took an objection that the Plaintiff was neither the owner nor in
possession of the Suit property and the Suit was not maintainable. He
explained that Shri Satbir Singh had purchased the Suit Property from
Krishan Kumar and Satish Chander, sons of Ghasi Ram, on 13.01.1987 on
payment of sale consideration of Rs.30,000/-. The defendant No.1 became
the owner of the Plot in question, having purchased it vide Agreement to
Sell, etc. dated 12.04.1999 and was handed over the physical possession of
the Plot, by Shri Satbir Singh. He thereafter, had raised the boundary wall
on the two sides and fixed the Iron Gate. The chain of the purchasers as
detailed by the Plaintiff in his Plaint, was denied, though it is admitted that
the original owners were Krishan Kumar and Satish Chander.
8.
Defendant No.2/Sh. Shri Satbir Singh in his Written Statement
asserted that he was in physical possession of the Suit property till
12.04.1999 and thereafter, sold the property to Defendant No.1 vide
Agreement to Sell, etc.
9.
After the framing of Issues, the parties led their evidence.
10.
Learned Civil Judge in the impugned Judgment dated 01.10.2012,
on appreciation of evidence, concluded that the Plaintiff had not been able to
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
establish a title better than that of the Defendants in the Suit plot and
thereby dismissed the Suit.
11.
The Regular First Appeal RFA No.17/2012 was preferred by the
Plaintiff/Balbir Singh wherein the learned ASCJ allowed the Appeal and set
aside the Judgment dated 01.10.2012 and the Suit of the Plaintiff was
decreed and Injunction was granted against the Appellant/Defendants.
12.
Aggrieved by this Order of learned ASCJ, the present Regular
Second Appeal has been preferred by the Appellant/Defendant.
13.
The question of law raised is whether a Suit for Permanent
Injunction is maintainable without claiming Declaratory or title relief; and
secondly whether the Declaration of possessory title only is maintainable,
where the title of the Claimant is under shadow or cloud.
14.
The grounds for challenge are that the Local Commission had been
appointed who had given a Report that there was a heap of cow dung on the
plot and no party was found to be in possession. The Appellant has
contended that it is not possible for the heap the cow dung being kept on the
Plot without one using the property regularly. The cow dung on the suit plot
belonged to the Appellant as he lives in the same village and uses the Suit
property for dumping the cow dung.
15.
It has not been further appreciated that just by painting the name by
the plaintiff on the door in the night would not make the Respondent/ Balbir
Singh an owner of the Suit property. It belongs to the person who had the
belongings inside the property. The Suit property was never locked by either
of the parties, nor has any finding regarding the possession been given by
the Local Commissioner.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
16.
It has not been appreciated that merely lodging an FIR against the
sellers i.e., Krishan Kumar and Satish, would not disentitle the Appellant
from possession and title. Moreover, the Criminal Case is still pending
adjudication. PW1 Balbir Singh has admitted in his evidence that he had not
filed any Complaint against the Defendant. It has been wrongly held by the
Appellate Court that the Criminal Case has gone against Satish and Krishan.
It has not been appreciated that the statements before the Police, are not
admissible in evidence.
17.
It is further not appreciated that Defendant No.2 Satbir Singh was not
competent to execute the documents in favor of the Appellant, in the year
1999 at which time he was about 23 years old. The Plaintiff as PW1, had
categorically admitted that he did not take the possession and no Possession
Letter was executed by Shyam Lal in his favor. He further admitted that he
did not go to the site to ascertain its boundaries.
18.
The Respondent is living at least 30 Kms. away from the Suit
property, whereas the Appellant is residing near to the Suit property.
19.
The DW5/Sh. Satish Chander had categorically stated that he had sold
the property to Defendant No.2/Satbir Singh and doubt on the execution of
the documents qua the suit property is against the Respondent, as DW5 was
the co-sharer and both the brothers who executed the documents in favor of
the Appellant were totally competent to transfer their property to anyone.
20.
It is further asserted that a simpliciter Suit for Permanent Injunction
without seeking Declaration of Title, is not maintainable where the
possession and the title is in dispute and there are complicated questions of
law.in the present case, complex issue of title of the parties to the Suit
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
Property on the basis of title documents was involved, which could not have
been decided in the Suit for Injunction.
21.
Reference is made to Anathula Sudhakar vs. P. Buchi Reddy through
L.Rs, Civil Appeal No.6191 of 2001, Supreme Court and Tehsildar, Urban
Improvement Trust vs. Ganga Bai Menariya Through L.Rs, Civil Appeal
No.722 of 2012, Supreme Court.
22.
A prayer is, therefore, made that the impugned Judgment dated
18.06.2025 of learned ASCJ, be set aside.
Submissions Heard and Record Perused.
23.
A Suit No. 39/2010 for Permanent Injunction was filed by the
Plaintiff Balbir Singh (Respondent herein) for restraining his illegal
dispossession by the Defendant (Appellant herein).
24.
The Issue was framed as under:
(1) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for the relief of Permanent
Injunction as prayed for? OPP
(2) Relief.
25.
The evidence was led by the parties. The Plaintiff in support of his
case examined himself as PW1 and three other witnesses namely Vijender
Lakra, Randhir Singh, and Balraj Kaushik.
26.
The Defendant No.1 examined himself as DW1, DW2/Constable
Hari Om, DW3/Suresh Kumar Ahlmad, DW4/Krishan Kumar LDC from the
office of Sub-Registrar, DW5/Satish Chander, DW6/Chand Ram and
DW7/Shri Satbir Singh (Defendant No.2).
27.
The learned Civil Judge did not find favor in granting the Injunction
in favor of plaintiff and dismissed the Suit on 01.10.2012. However, the
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
fortune turned for the plaintiff when he succeeded in RFA SCJ No.340/2016
and the learned ASCJ decreed the Suit of the Plaintiff and granted an
Injunction against the defendant. The relief so granted to the
Plaintiff/Respondent has compelled the Appellant Ramesh Parkash to file
the present Appeal.
28.
The Plaintiff/Respondent had been claiming a title in the Suit property
on the basis of the GPA/Agreement to Sell, etc. dated 21.12.1988 executed
in his favor by Shyam Lal. However, the Appellant/Defendant is also
staking his claim on the basis of similar documents, having purchased the
property from Satbir. Pertinently, the chain of documents for both the
parties, commence from Satish Kumar and Krishan Kumar, sons of Ghasi
Ram were the original owners of the Suit plot.
29.
The learned Civil Judge in the impugned Judgment observed that the
Suit plot was an open plot of land wherein both the parties were claiming to
be in possession. In these circumstances, the presumption of possession
follows the title. Therefore, for the limited purpose of ascertaining whether
the Plaintiff had the title and the consequent possession, the sale documents
of the Plaintiff were considered.
30.
The Respondent asserted that the original owners Satish Kumar and
Krishan Kumar sold the property to Ram Krishan who in turn sold it to Shri
Shyam Lal and thereafter, the property was purchased by the
Plaintiff/Respondent. Pertinently, the entire chain of documents through
which the title is alleged to have travelled from one person to another is
through ATS/ GPA/ Will etc. The Plaintiff proved his GPA/ Agreement to
Sell/ Affidavit/ Receipt dated 21.12.1988 as Ex.PW1/1 to Ex.PW1/4
respectively. The documents of sale i.e. GPA, etc. in favor of the erstwhile
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
purchaser of property i.e. Shyam Lal, which had been executed in his favour
by the erstwhile owner Ram Kishan, were proved by PW4 Balraj Kaushik
Ahlmad from the Court of learned ACMM, where these documents had been
filed in the Criminal Case titled State vs. Ram Prakash. The certified copies
were compared with the originals and the documents were so exhibited as
Ex.PW4/1 to Ex.PW4/4. The Plaintiff, however, had only the photocopies of
the title documents handed over by the original owners i.e. Satish Kumar
and Krishan Kumar to Ram Krishan which were exhibited as GPA Mark
X1/D1, Agreement to Sell Mark X1/D2 and Affidavit as Mark X1/D3.
31.
The learned Civil Judge noted that the set of documents executed by
the original Bhumidars in favor of Krishan Kumar were not proved by any
cogent evidence and being the photocopies, the same could not have been
considered especially when the alleged co-owner Satish Kumar had denied
executing these documents. The first set of Agreement to Sell, etc. Mark
X1/D1 to Mark X1/D3 were thus, not proved to establish the transfer of the
Plot to Krishan Kumar and thereafter, to subsequent Purchasers.
32.
While there was a reference to the sale documents, but that was not
the basis for denying Injunction to the Plaintiff. The learned Civil Judge, in
fact referred to ocular evidence and the Report of the Local commissioner,
to conclude that the Plaintiff was never in possession of the Suit property.
33.
The first such document was the Report of the Local Commissioner
Ex.DW1/P1 dated 30.09.1999 who had observed that since it was a vacant
plot; it was not possible to state who was in possession. However, it was
noted in the Report of the Local Commissioner that the walls of the two
sides were of the adjoining plots while the wall on the other two (opposite)
sides was recently constructed. Also, the Local Commissioner noted that the
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
name of the Plaintiff was printed on the Iron Gate indicating that he was in
possession.
34.
The first thing which emerges from the Report of the Local
Commissioner is that he was unable to state who was in possession as the
suit property was an open plot. The second aspect which emerges is that
there were recently constructed two walls.
35.
In this context, reference was made to the Complaint dated
27.08.1999 Ex.PW1/6 made by the Plaintiff/Respondent to ACP
complaining that the Defendant was getting the mason work (chenai) on the
temporary wall on the Plot of the Plaintiff, which clearly indicated that the
Plaintiff was not in possession and it was the Defendant/Appellant who was
getting the boundary walls made. When this Complaint is read along with
the Report of the Local Commissioner Ex.DW1/D1, it is established that
there were recent boundary walls constructed thereby pointing that it was the
Defendant/Appellant who was in possession of the Suit plot.
36.
As per the Plaintiff’s witnesses, the boundary walls were constructed
in the early 1990s, whereas the Report of the Local Commissioner reflected
that the boundary walls had been constructed recently, which establishes that
on the date of filing of the Suit it was the Defendant who was in possession
of the property.
37.
A Reference was also made to the certified copies of the cross-
examination of the Plaintiff in the Criminal Case filed by him against the
Defendant/Appellant pertaining to the Suit Plot, wherein he had deposed that
Defendant No.1/Appellant had removed the Plaintiff’s walls and constructed
his own wall and was in illegal possession of the Plot in question.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
38.
The Civil Judge thus, on the basis of the evidence, confined itself only
to ascertaining the possession and not the title documents to conclude that
the Plaintiff was not in possession of the Plot. Consequently, the relief of
Permanent Injunction for restraining the Defendants from dispossessing the
Plaintiff was rightly denied.
39.
The Supreme Court in the case of Anathula Sudhakar (supra) had held
that the Plaintiff, who is not in possession of the Suit property, is not entitled
to an Injunction without first claiming the possession of the same.
40.
Likewise, in M. Kallapa Setty vs. M.V. Lakshminarayana Rao AIR
1972 SC 2209, it was held that the Plaintiff, who is in possession of the Suit
property, can resist its interference by the Defendant who has no better title
than himself. The learned Civil Judge, therefore, concluded on the basis of
overwhelming evidence led by the parties, that it was established that the
Plaintiff was not in possession of the Suit property and thus, was not entitled
to Injunction.
41.
The learned ASCJ in the First Appeal fell in error in discussing in
detail the documents of title of the Plaintiff as well as of the Defendant to
hold that the Defendant was not able to prove his possession to the suit plot.
It was further held that on the preponderance of probabilities, the Plaintiff
was shown to be in possession of the property and the Suit for Permanent
Injunction was decreed in favor of the Respondent/Plaintiff.
42.
The learned ASCJ considered the validity of the Title documents
executed in favor of the Plaintiff and held them to be of greater evidentiary
value than those of the Defendant and thereby, held that the Plaintiff was
shown
to
be
in
possession
and
consequently
injuncted
Appellant/Defendant from disturbing the possession of the property.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
the
43.
However, the learned ASCJ fell in error in determining the Possession
on the basis of Title documents, when in fact there was overwhelming
evidence as discussed by the learned Civil Judge to establish that the
Plaintiff was not in possession of the Suit plot, at the time when the Suit for
Injunction was filed.
44.
Before concluding, it is pertinent to emphasize that a Suit for
Permanent Injunction is only based on preponderance of probability of the
possession of the Plaintiff and not on the Title documents. In the case of
Anathula Sudhakar (supra), it was held that where there are complex
questions of the Title of the parties to the Suit which need determination,
then such complex questions of Title must not be considered in the
simpliciter case of Permanent Injunction and that the Plaintiff must file a
Declaration for claiming an Injunction.
45.
In the recent judgment of the Apex Court in T.V. Krishna Reddy vs.
M. Mallappa and Anr. Civil Appeal No.5577/2021 in SLP (C)
No.10621/2020 it was held that the question whether a simpliciter Suit for
Permanent Injunction without Declaration of title was maintainable arose.
Reference was made to Anathula Sudhakar (supra) to hold that when the
Plaintiff’s title is under a cloud and he does not have Possession, a Suit for
Declaration and Possession with or without a consequential injunction, is the
appropriate remedy. If the Plaintiff is out of Possession, he has to sue for
Possession with consequential Injunction. It is only when there is mere
threat of interference with the Plaintiff’s lawful possession that a Suit for
Permanent Injunction simpliciter is maintainable. The Title of the parties if
not directly and substantially an issue, then the Suit for Injunction is
maintainable.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
46.
Apex Court in T.V. Krishna Reddy (supra) observed that the prayer
for Injunction has to be decided solely with reference to the finding of
Possession. However, in cases where de jure possession has to be
established on the basis of title of the property as in the case of vacant site,
the issue of title may directly and substantially arise for consideration which
is not possible to decide in a simpliciter Suit for Injunction. It was further
noted that where there are necessary pleadings and the issue is framed on
which the parties have to lead evidence and the issue involved is simple and
straightforward, the Court may decide the issue regarding title even in a Suit
for Injunction, but it is an exception to the normal rule that the title shall not
be decided in a Suit for Injunction. But where the Title and Possession are
clear, then simpliciter Injunction Suit is maintainable, as it would not be in
the interest of justice to drive such parties to a costlier and more
cumbersome remedy of a Suit for Declaration, merely because some
meddler vexatiously or wrongfully makes a claim or tries to encroach upon
his property.
47.
In the present case as well, while there is a complex question involved
in respect of the better title of the parties, the Suit for Injunction from
disturbing the possession of the Plaintiff/Respondent had been decided by
the learned Civil Judge purely on the basis of evidence led by the parties to
conclude that the Plaintiff was not in possession of the property, without
going into the documents pertaining to rival title of the parties.
Conclusion:
48.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, it emerges that the learned Civil
Judge had rightly denied the relief of Permanent Injunction to the Plaintiff.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
The learned ASCJ fell in error while deciding the RFA, in delving into the
issue of title rather than the possession.
49.
The impugned Judgment dated 18.08.2025 in RFA is hereby, set aside
and the Judgment of the learned Civil Judge dated 01.10.2012 is hereby,
restored.
50.
The Appeal is accordingly allowed and
the Suit of the
Respondent/Plaintiff for Injunction is hereby dismissed.
51.
The pending Application(s) are disposed of accordingly.
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
JANUARY 12, 2026
va
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 30/01/2026 at 13:17:50
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review