Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved on
: 13.03.2026
Pronounced on : 07.07.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 07TH DAY OF JULY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M. NAGAPRASANNA
WRIT PETITION No.38771 OF 2025 (GM - RES)
BETWEEN:
SHRI MOHAMMED KAMRAN
S/O SHRI AKRAM PASHA
AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS
RESIDING AT HOUSE NO-L1G61,
3RD STAGE, BANNAMANTAPPA,
MYSURU-570015.
(NOW IN JUDICIAL CUSTODY,
CENTRAL PRISON, BANGALORE)
... PETITIONER
(BY SRI HASHMATH PASHA, SR.ADVOCATE FOR
SRI KARIAPPA N.A., ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by
PADMAVATHI
BK
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka
AND:
1.
THE SENIOR INTELLIGENCE OFFICER
DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF GOODS
AND SERVICE TAX INTELLIGENCE,
BENGALURU ZONAL UNIT,
NO.112, S.P.ENCLAVE,
ADJACENT TO KARNATAKA BANK,
K.H.ROAD, BENGALURU CITY – 560 027.
2.
ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR
DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF
GST INTELLIGENCE,
BENGALURU ZONAL UNIT,
BENGALURU NO.112,
SPENCLAVE, K.H.ROAD,
BENGALURU – 560 027.
3.
THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER
COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICE (ENFORCEMENT)-10,
NO.487, BIDARAM KRISHNAPPA ROAD,
DEVARAJ MOHALLA,
MYSURU – 570 001.
4.
JOINT COMMISSIONER OF
COMMERCIAL TAXES (ENFORCEMENT)
NO.487, BIDARAM KRISHNAPPA ROAD,
DEVARAJ MOHALLA,
MYSURU – 570 001.
(R-1 AND R-2 ARE REPRESENTED BY
LEARNED SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR FOR DGGI,
AND R-3 AND R-4 ARE REPRESENTED BY
GA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
BENGALURU – 560 001.
... RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI MADHU N.RAO, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 AND R-2;
SRI B.N.JAGADEESHA, ADDL.SPP FOR R-3 AND R-4)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA READ WITH SECTION 528 OF BNSS,
PRAYING
TO
ANNEXURE-F)
QUASH
AND
THE
ENTIRE
COMPLAINT
PROCEEDINGS
DATED
12.11.2025
(AS
PER
(AS
PER
ANNEXURE-H) FILED BY RESPONDENT NO.1 IN CRIME NO.34/2025
IN FILE NO.DGGI/INV/125/2025-GR-C-01 O/O PR-ADG-DGGI ZU
BANGALORE WHICH IS PENDING ON THE FILE OF HON’BLE
SPECIAL COURT FOR ECONOMIC OFFENCES, BANGALORE CITY AS
ABUSE OF PROCESS OF LAW IN SO FAR AS PETITIONER IS
CONCERNED; 2) TO ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR WRIT OR
ORDER OR DIRECTION OF APPROPRIATE IN NATURE AND QUASH
THE ARREST OF PETITIONER DATED 16-9-2025 AND CONSEQUENT
ORDER OF REMAND ORDER DATED 16-9-2025 (AS PER ANNEXUREF)
PASSED
BY
HON’BLE
OFFENCES,
IN
CRIME
SPECIAL
COURT
FOR
NO.34/2025
IN
ECONOMIC
FILE
NO.
DGGI/INV/125/2025-GR-C-01 O/O PR- ADG-DGGI-ZU- BANGALORE
AS ILLEGAL AND CONSEQUENTLY RELEASE THE PETITIONER
FORTHWITH IN SO FAR AS PETITIONER IS CONCERNED; 3) TO
ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR A WRIT OR ORDER OF
DIRECTION OF APPROPRIATE IN NATURE AND QUASH THE ORDER
OF
COGNIZANCE
DATED 25-11-2025 (AS
PER
ANNEXURE-F)
PASSED IN PCR NO.280/2025 ON THE FILE OF HON’BLE SPECIAL
COURT FOR ECONOMIC OFFENCES, BANGALORE WHICH IS IN
CRIME NO.34/2025 IN FILE NO. DGGI/INV/125/2025-GR-C-01-0/0
PR-ADG-DGGI-ZU-BANGALORE (AS PER ANNEXURE-H), AS ILLEGAL
AND ABUSE OF PROCESS OF LAW IN SO FAR AS PETITIONER IS
CONCERNED.
THIS WRIT PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 13.03.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT
THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:-
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
CAV ORDER
The petitioner is before the Court seeking the following
prayer:
1.
“To issue a writ of certiorari or a writ or order or direction
of appropriate in nature and quash the entire proceedings
(as per Annexure-F) and complaint dated 12-11-2025 (as
per Annexure-H) filed by respondent No.1 in Crime
No.34/2025 in File No.DGGI/INV/125/ 2025-Gr-C-01 O/o
Pr-ADG-DGGI-ZU – Bangalore which is pending on the file
of Hon’ble Special Court for Economic Offences, Bangalore
City as abuse of process of law insofar as petitioner is
concerned.
2.
To issue a writ of certiorari or writ or order or direction of
appropriate writ in nature and quash the arrest of
petitioner dated 16-09-2025 and consequent order of
remand order dated 16-09-2025 (as per Annexure-‘F’)
passed by Hon’ble Special Court for Economic Offences,
Bangalore in Crime No.34/2025 in File No.DGGI/INV/125/
2025-Gr-C-01 O/o Pr-ADG-DGGI-ZU – Bangalore as
illegal and consequently release the petitioner forthwith
insofar as petitioner is concerned.
3.
To issue a writ of certiorari or a writ or order of direction
of appropriate in nature and quash the order of
cognizance dated 25-11-2025 (as per Annexure-F) passed
in PCR No.280 of 2025 on the file of Hon’ble Special Court
for Economic Offences, Bangalore which is in Crime
No.34/2025 in File No.DGGI/INV/125/ 2025-Gr-C-01 O/o
Pr-ADG-DGGI-ZU – Bangalore (as per Annexure-H), as
illegal and abuse of process of law insofar as petitioner is
concerned.
4.
2.
To pass such other order or orders as this Hon’ble Court
deems fit to grant in the facts and circumstances of the
case, in the interest of justice.”
Heard
Sri
Hashmath
Pasha,
learned
senior
counsel
appearing for the petitioner, Sri Madhu N.Rao, learned counsel
appearing for respondent Nos.1 and 2 and Sri B.N. Jagadeesha,
learned Additional State Public Prosecutor appearing for respondent
Nos.3 and 4.
3. The facts, in brief, germane are as follows: 3.1. The petitioner is the proprietor of one M/s M.K. Traders
engaged in the business of iron and steel waste scrap. The
petitioner is said to have obtained Goods and Service Tax (‘GST’ for
short) registration and used to buy scrap materials from different
suppliers and sell them to registered manufacturers of steel and
allied products.
3.2. On 14-05-2025, the 3rd respondent/Commercial Tax
Officer and the 4th respondent/Joint Commissioner of Commercial
Taxes commence investigation with respect to business transactions
between the petitioner and one M/s A.R. Steels and two others –
M/s N.M.G. Traders and M/s U.K. Steel Traders. On 17-06-2025,
the 3rd and 4th respondents conduct inspection of the business spot
where the accused runs his business. Thereafter, a notice is issued
for commencement of formal investigation against the petitioner.
The 4th respondent/Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes issues
a notice alleging gross discrepancies in payment of GST and
demanded
production
of
invoices/documents
concerning
the
business. Three months thereafter, in reply, the accused is said to
have produced invoices and bills and other accounts pertaining to
the payment of GST before the 3rd respondent.
3.3. When things stood thus, another notice is issued, now by
the Central GST authorities/respondent Nos.1 and 2 on specific
intelligence input indicating that the petitioner and his associate
firms were involved in receiving fake invoices without actual receipt
of goods or services from fictitious and non-existent suppliers.
Based on the said intelligence input received, a report was
generated through the Business Intelligence and Fraud Analytics
platform under an early warning category. This results in conduct
of a search of the premises, both residential and business premises
of the petitioner/accused and his father under Section 67 of the
Central Goods and Services Act, 2017 (‘the Act’ for short) leading to
certain seizures. A case is registered in Crime No.162 of 2025
against the accused and his family by the Directorate General of
GST Intelligence (‘DGGI’) for showing complete non-cooperation
and obstructing the proceedings.
3.4. On 15-09-2025, the accused is asked to be present
before the 1st respondent for interrogation. The accused then
travels from Mangalore to Bangalore for the purpose of personal
interrogation and is taken into custody the moment he reaches the
Airport at Bangalore. Before the petitioner was taken into custody,
the officers conducted a search on him and recovered from him 6
mobile phones and one laptop and arrested him at 6.30 a.m. on
16-09-2025. At about 8.55 p.m. on 16-09-2025, the accused was
produced before the Court of Economic Offences, Bangalore along
with the remand application. On 13-11-2025, the 1st and 2nd
respondents file the prosecution complaint before the jurisdictional
Court under Section 223 of the BNSS for offences punishable under
Sections 132(1)(b), 132(1)(c), 132(1)(f) r/w 134 and 135 of the
Act.
The present petition is then preferred seeking to quash the
proceedings in the private complaint so registered against the
petitioner and hold the arrest of the petitioner to be illegal. The
challenge is on the score that there cannot be dual proceedings on
the same set of facts. In the interregnum, the application filed by
the petitioner seeking default bail comes to be rejected. The
petitioner then approaches a co-ordinate Bench of this Court in
Criminal Petition No.16884 of 2025, wherein the plea of the
petitioner for regular bail comes to be allowed.
4. The learned senior counsel Sri Hashmath Pasha appearing
for the petitioner would submit that the petitioner/accused is
subjected to parallel investigation in violation of Section 6(2)(b) of
the Act. He would submit that the Apex Court in ARMOUR
SECURITY
(INDIA)
LIMITED
v.
COMMISSIONER,
CGST,
DELHI EAST COMMISSIONERATE reported in 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 1700 holds that parallel proceedings should not be instituted by
another tax administration, when one tax administration has
already initiated proceedings. The petitioner was taken into custody
without furnishing grounds of arrest and reasons for arrest either
orally or in writing which is violative of Article 22 of the Constitution
of India and Section 47 of the BNSS. The arrest of the petitioner
was neither informed to any relative nor his friend before he was
produced before the Magistrate. The petitioner had explained all the
deposits of input tax credit from business transactions. It is his
submission that filing of partial investigation report is resorted to
deny statutory bail to the petitioner in violation of Section 187(3) of
the BNSS and Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The offences
alleged against the petitioner are the ones punishable under Section
132 of the Act, which are punishable to a maximum of 5 years
imprisonment. Therefore, the petitioner ought to have been issued
notice prior to taking him into custody.
5.1. Contrariwise, the learned counsel Sri Madhu N. Rao
appearing for the respondent Nos.1 and 2/DGGI would vehemently
contend
that
the
arrest
was
necessitated
on
account
of
non-cooperation of the petitioner and since the petitioner has
previously fled from the premises when search proceedings were
being conducted. The petitioner was arrested as there were reasons
to believe that he had committed offences under Section 132(1)(c)
of the Act. The investigation is conducted on the basis of the
intelligence received by the DGGI and no notice is required to be
issued to the accused before causing search proceedings. The
intelligence input received by the GST authorities were placed
before the Competent Authority, who after going through the
intelligence
developed
by
the
concerned
officer,
issued
authorization for search, and based on the authorization, search
was conducted in the premises of the petitioner and allied concerns.
The accused never showed any cooperation with the investigation
and had fled the premises when search and seizure proceedings
were being conducted. The accused was duly served the grounds of
arrest
and
reasons
acknowledged
by
for
the
arrest
in
petitioner
writing,
which
and
mother
the
has
of
been
the
petitioner/accused was also informed of his arrest.
5.2. Learned counsel would submit that whether parallel
proceedings are being conducted by the State and the Central GST
authorities cannot be determined now at the stage of investigation.
The State GST authorities may have been inquiring into the
discrepancies in the GST payment. Respondent Nos.1 and 2 are
enquiring into the larger supply chain where around 140 suppliers
are involved multi-fold revenue is at stake. Therefore, the two
though may arise on the same facts, but for different reasons,
which will be known only on completion of investigation. The
judgment of the Apex Court in ARMOUR SECURITY, on which the
learned senior counsel places reliance upon itself permits such
investigation to be conducted. The Apex Court in the said judgment
holds that inquiry or gathering of evidence or information would not
become ‘proceedings’ under Section 6(2)(b) of the Act. Learned
counsel would further submit that the investigation pending before
the State GST authorities was transferred to the Central GST
authorities/DGGI in accordance with the judgment of the Apex
Court in ARMOUR SECURITY. Therefore, he would seek dismissal
of the petition.
6. The learned Additional State Public Prosecutor Sri B.N.
Jagadeesha would also toe the lines of the learned counsel
Sri Madhu N.Rao in seeking dismissal of the petition on the score
that investigation was transferred from the hands of the State GST
authorities upon the filing of the prosecution complaint by the
Central GST authorities/DGGI.
7. I have given my anxious consideration to the submissions
made by the respective learned senior counsel, learned counsel and
learned Additional State Public Prosecutor and have perused the
material on record. In the light of the aforesaid submissions, the
following issues would arise for consideration:
“(i) Whether the proceedings instituted by respondent
Nos.1 and 2 against the petitioner in Crime No.34
of 2025 arising out of PCR 280 of 2025 deserve to
be quashed?
(ii)
Whether arrest of the petitioner is in violation of
law which results in obliteration of proceedings?”
ISSUE NO.1:
Whether the proceedings instituted by respondent
Nos.1 and 2 against the petitioner in Crime No.34 of 2025
arising out of PCR 280 of 2025 deserve to be quashed?
8.1. A notice comes to be issued by the State GST authorities
to the petitioner on 17-06-2025 alleging discrepancies in payment
of
GST
and
demanding
production
of
certain
documents.
Investigation qua the petitioner commences upon the issuance of
the said notice. The reply of the petitioner to the said notice is as
follows:
“Dt:09.09.2025
To
The Commercial Tax Officer, (Enf)-10, MZ-11
Office of the Joint Commissioner of
Commercial Taxes (Enf) No. 487, Bidaram
Krishnappa Road, Devaraja Mohalla Mysore
570024
From
M/s M.K. Traders
GSTIN: 29IRZPK8080E1ZT
75, 2nd Main Road, 4th Cross, Kesare
Village, Kasaba Hobli, Mysuru-570007
Email: mktraderskamran@gmail.com | Contact: 9110247185
Respected Sir,
Subject: Submission of records/books evidencing in
response to Summons u/s 70 of
CGST/KGST
Act,
RFN:
MA290725018233X, dated 04.07.2025.
With respect to the subject sited above, in the process of
enquiry I attended on the date 10-07-2025 scheduled and I
have given all the explanations in response to the enquiry made
by you. But due to short duration I couldn't evident the
documents called for by your goodself. I hereby submitting the
following books of accounts/records pertaining to M/s. M K
Traders, GSTIN: 29IRZPK8080E1ZT for the following periods
available as on today and other related records will be
submitted as soon as our auditor arrives who is out of station.
1.
Inward supply invoices & E-Way bills from October-2021
to December-2021 and October-2024 to June-2025.
2.
Outward supply invoices & E-Way bills from Februry-2021
to December-2021 and October-2024 to June-2025.
3.
Copies of Weighment slips and LR for outward supplies
from October-2024 to June-2025.
4.
Bank statement: Current A/c hold by me In Axis Bank
having A/c No. 921020005135334, N.R. Mohalla Branch,
Mysuru in the name of M/s. M K Traders from 01-10-2024
to 30-06-2025.
Thanking you.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/Mohammad Kamran
Proprietor-M.K.Trader”
During the pendency of investigation at the hands of the State GST
authorities, officers of the DGGI-Central GST authorities commence
investigation qua the petitioner/accused and his associate firms.
The reason for commencement of investigation was that the DGGI
had
received
specific
petitioner/accused
and
intelligence
his
input
associate
indicating
firms
were
that
the
involved
in
receiving fake invoices without actual receipt of goods or services
from fictitious/non-existent suppliers. Based on intelligence input
received, a report was generated through the Business Intelligence
and Fraud Analytics platform under the early warning category.
Analysis was from the data of GST returns, e-way bills, registration
details to identify suspicious linkages of common logins and shared
contact information. The report against the accused reveals that
several suppliers had filed GST returns from common IP addresses
and had issued invoices to common recipients indicating close
interconnection or possible collusion. The GST status showed that
many of the registrations from which transactions had taken place
had already been cancelled. The major identities identified were M/s
U.K. Steel Traders, M/s N.M.G. Traders, M/s M.K. Traders and M/s
A.R. Steels. M/s M.K. Traders belongs to the petitioner. M/s A.R.
Steels belongs to the father of the petitioner. A search then is
conducted in the houses and business premises of those persons.
The result of search is registration of a crime in Crime No.34 of
2025 before the jurisdictional Court. The petitioner was then
directed to appear for personal interrogation and when appeared he
was taken into custody on an application for remand. The
application for remand is as follows:
“APPLICATION FOR REMAND OF ARRESTED ACCUSED
The complainant most humbly prays as follows:
INTRODUCTION:
1. The Intelligence developed by the officer of Directorate
General of Goods and Services Tax Intelligence, Zonal Unit,
Bengaluru indicated that several entities including M/s. M.K.
Traders, M/s. A.R. Steel, M/s. U.K. Steel Trader and M/s.
N.M.G. Traders are involved in availing and passing on of
inadmissible Input Tax Credit (ITC) on the strength of invoices
issued by fictitious entities without associated supply of goods
and/or services. As per the data available in the GST portal the
commodity transacted by these entities is predominantly
'ferrous scrap'. Discreet enquiries have revealed that majority of
the premises pertaining to these entities are either non-existing
or non operational. The GSTINs of majority of the impugned
entities are cancelled suo moto ab-inition by the department
which further consolidates the suspicion of their involvement in
fictitious transactions for availing and passing on inadmissible
ITC on the strength of fake invoices. Analysis of the GST returns
and corresponding E-waybills filed by the entities indicates that
in majority of the cases the vehicle movement details are not
available. It is also observed in certain cases that the vehicle
was found to be moving on a different route other than the
appropriate route for the E-waybill in which the said vehicle has
been used. The quantum of evasion of GST by these taxpayers
cumulatively amounts to over One Hundred Crores. The
investigation proceedings are elaborated in ensuing paragraphs.
INTELLIGENCE:
2.
Analysis of the data available in GST portal regarding the
has led to unearthing of a syndicate of fictitious entities who had
reported suspicious transactions viz. issuing of invoices without
actual supply of goods/services. The details of four entities
operating at Mysuru, Karnataka, under investigation by this
office are tabulated as under:
3.
Intelligence gathered, indicated that the above four
entities namely M/s A R STEEL, GSTIN- 29AHBPA2384H1ZJ,
M/s.
MK
Traders,
GSTIN29IRZPK8080E1ZT,
M/s.
N.M.G.Traders, GSTIN- 29EMIPA3360K1ZW and M/s. U.K. Steel
Traders, GSTIN-29NSDPS9559A1ZY are registered with the
department for supply of scrap. On perusal of intelligence, it
appears that they are indulged in availing and passing on of
fake ITC. A summary of the ITC availed and passed on by the
impugned entities is tabulated as under:
On the basis of the above intelligence and analysis, investigation
was initiated, and searches were carried out at the registered
premises of the above entities. The details of investigation
proceedings are elaborated in the following paragraphs.
INVESTIGATION:
4.
In pursuance to the outcome of analysis of the GST
returns of the impugned taxpayers, searches were carried out
under section 67 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act,
2017 at the registered premises of the said taxpayers and the
residential premises of the individuals related to the said
taxpayers. The Taxpayer-wise discussion of their involvement in
the syndicate of entities indulged in the availing and passing on
of inadmissible ITC, outcomes of the searches at their premises
and other evidences are discussed as underi.
M/s. U.K. Steel Traders:
a. The TP was registered with the GST department on
09-09-2021. Their registration is active as on date. Shri
Saddam is the proprietor of M/s U.K. Steel Traders.
b. GSTR2A returns of this TP indicates that they have
availed input tax credit of Rs. 37,85,64,955/- from
various suppliers, out of which Rs.29,76,30,325/- has
been received from suppliers which are Suo-moto
cancelled/ or cancelled on application of taxpayer and
Rs.8,09,34,629/- has been received from the suppliers
whose GSTIN is Active but most of the suppliers at Level2 (inward supply) are found to be cancelled by the
department or cancelled by the taxpayer on application
within a brief period after obtaining registration.
c. It is pertinent to mention here that amongst the Active
Suppliers of M/s U.K. Steel Traders, suppliers viz. 5star
Traders (GSTIN-29FCZPA6147JIZU), RMS Enterprises
(GSTIN-29BOFPR7678M1ZS), AHB Enterprises (GSTIN29EWQPA9619P1ZG),
Fortune
Enterprises
(GSTIN29JATPK3193N1ZI),
A
R
Traders
(GSTIN29FDEPA7685H1Z5),
P
VR
Traders
(GSTIN29COBPV6331L1ZD).
Junaid
Enterprises
(GSTIN29CIUPJ8764L1Z1),
Blue
Enterprises
(GSTIN-
29FKXPK2789A1ZG), R S Selvam Traders (GSTIN29CSYPV9104Q1Z7), do not have Input Tax Credit to
the extent they have passed on to their recipients.
d. The entities mentioned above are into the business of
sale and purchase of scrap. In the absence of adequate
inward supplies at the suppliers end, the outward supplies
cannot be affected and thus indicating clearly that the
said supplier entities are generators of fake input tax
credit in the chain. Thus, since the inward supplies as
well as outward supplies of M/s UK Steel Traders appear
to be dubious without actual accompanying supplies of
goods (and/or services).
e. The
taxpayer
has
passed
on
ITC
of
Rs.42,45,53,127/- to M/s. N.M.G Traders which
accounts to 98% of outward supplies of M.s U.K.
Steel Traders.
f. Search of the principal place of business of M/s U.K. Steel
Traders located at 31, Shop No 01, Old Kesare, Mysuru,
Karnataka, 570007, was carried out on 10-09-2025 under
Authorization
for
search
bearing
CBIC-DIN202509DS0000000D412 dated 09-09-2025 under section
67(2) of the CGST Act, 2017. During the search
proceedings at the above premises was occupied by other
unconnected entity and that M/s U. K. Steel Traders was
not existing in the said premises. Enquiry with the owner
of the said premises revealed that the said owner did not
know any Saddam or his Firm and has never entered into
any rental agreement to let out his premise to them. On
perusal of rental agreement uploaded during request for
revocation of suo-moto cancelled GSTIN, the name of
owner of the premises as per the rent agreement was
mentioned as Abdul Aleem whereas actual owner of the
said premises was found to be 'Shri Ramana'. The
registered mobile number -7483520394 of M/s U.K. Steel
Traders was found to be switched off.
g. Further, search of the residence premises of Shri Saddam,
Proprietor of M/s U.K. Steel Traders located at 410
Azmatulla Bharath Nagar Sathgalli Badawane KAMYS
570019, was carried on 10-09-2025 under Authorization
for Search bearing CBIC-DIN-202509DS00000722019
dated 09-09-2025. During search, it was found that the
said premise was occupied by one Smt. Asma Jabin on
rent from Smt. Kushter Banu. On being called by the
Officer, Smt. Kushter Banu submitted that the premise
has never been rented to Shri Saddam and does not have
any relation to him. (MAHAZAR)
h. The above search of the principal place of business and
residential premises of the proprietor of M/s U.K. Steel
Traders and their availing of ITC on the strength of bogus
invoices without actual supply of goods indicates dubious
nature of transactions reported by them. Therefore, M/s
U. K. Steel Traders appears to be a fake entity floated
with sole intention of availing and passing on of
inadmissible ITC on the strength of invoices without
actual receipt of goods and/or services. (MAHAZAR)
ii.
M/s. N.M.G.Traders (GSTIN-29EMIPA3360K1ZW)
a. The TP is registered with the department since 2022-0517. Their registration is active as on date and Shri Nasir
Ahmed is the proprietor of the taxpayer.
b. As per GSTR2A registration The taxpayer has received
total ITC of Rs.49,76,23,850/-from 18 suppliers (as per
inward supply statement GSTR-2A). Major supplier is M/s.
U.K. Steel Traders who alone have passed on ITC of
Rs.42,45,53,127/- to M/s. NMG Traders. Remaining 13
suppliers are cancelled suo-moto by the department.
c. The taxpayer has passed on ITC of Rs. 46.52 Crore to
various recipients and major recipients are ACTIVE.
d.
The major recipient is M/s. A R Steel (GSTIN29AHBPA2384HIZJ) who have received input tax credit of
Rs.20,52,39,822/- from M/s. N.M.G Traders. The other
recipient, M/s. M K Traders (GSTIN-29IRZPK8080E1ZT)
has received ITC of Rs.18,57,88,319/- which is Active.
e. Search at the principal place of business of M/s N.M.G
Traders located at No 4540 L.12, 2nd Cross, N.R Mohalla,
Mysuru, Karnataka, 570007, was carried out on 10-09-
2025 under Authorization for search bearing CBIC-DIN202509DS0000061186A
dated
09-09-2025.
During
search proceeding, the said premises was found to be
empty and upon enquiry from the owner of the premises,
no business activity was conducted at the premises in
past months. (MAHAZAR).
f. Search at the additional premises of M/s N.M.G Traders
located at 4-4/3B-1, bannimantap A industrial layout,
Mandi Mohalla, Mysuru, Karnataka, 570021 was carried
out on 10-09-2025 under Authorization for search bearing
CBIC-DIN-202509DS00000555C0E dated 09-09-2025.
During search proceeding, the said premises was found to
be closed and on being contacted over registered mobile
number, no response was found and hence the premise
was sealed in the presence of independent witness. It
appeared that the no business activities were carried out
on the said premises. (MAHAZAR)
g. In view of the above, it appeared that M/s N.M.G. Traders
is a fictitious entity floated with sole intention to avail and
pass on inadmissible ITC without actual supply of goods
and/or services.
h. The search proceedings at the residential premises of
proprietor of M/s N.M.G Traders is elaborated at Para-6
below.
iii.
M/s. M K Traders (GSTIN-29IRZPK8080E1ZT):
(Legal name-Mohammed Kamran):
a. M/s M K Traders is registered with the department since
01-02-2025 and Shri Mohammed Kamran S/o Akram
Pasha.
b. The taxpayer has received total inwards supply of Rs.
21,78,73,544/- from the various suppliers, out of which
Rs. 2,53,04,402/- has been availed from the suo-moto
cancelled taxpayers.
c. Further, the taxpayer has received inward supply with ITC
of Rs. 18,57,88,319/- from one major supplier namely
M/s. N.M.G Traders.
d. Search at the registered principal place of business of
premises of M/s M.K. Traders located at 75, 2nd Main
Road, 4th Cross, Kesare Village, Kasaba Hobli, Mysuru,
Karnataka, 570007, was carried out on 10-09-2025under
Authorization
for
Search
bearing
CBIC-DIN202509DS0000000E37E
dated
09-09-2025.
During
Search proceeding, the premise was found to be locked.
The officer on search tried to contact the Prop. On the
registered mobile number but no response was found and
hence, it was sealed in the presence of independent
witness. It appeared that no business activity was being
carried out on the said premises. (MAHAZAR)
e. The proceedings at the residence of the proprietor of M/s
M.K. Traders is elaborated at para-6 below.
5.
For ease of understanding, the supply chain is
illustrated in the following flow chart:
6.
During investigation, simultaneous searches were carried
out at the registered principal places, additional places and
available residential premises of the proprietors of the abovementioned entities. The outcome of the searches of the principal
places of business and additional places has been discussed at
Para-4 above while describing the nature of transactions
undertaken by M/s. M.K. Traders, M/s. A.R. Steel, M/s. U.K.
Steel Trader and M/s. N.M.G. Traders. The search proceedings
at the residential premises of the proprietor of the said entities
is elaborated as under:
i. Search at the residential premises of Shri Mohammed
Kamran (Prop: M.K. Traders) and Shri Akrampasha
(Prop: AR Steel).
a. As per the information available on the GST portal the
residence of the proprietors of AR Steel and MK Traders is
same since both are father and son viz. Akram Pasha is
father of Mohammed Kamran. The declared residential
address as per the GST portal is located at House No.
LIG
61,
3rd
Stage,
Bannimantapa,
Mysore,
Karnataka-570015.
However,
discreet
enquires
revealed that the actual residential address of Shri
Akrampasha (Prop: AR Steel) and Shri Mohammed
Kamran (Prop: M.K. Traders) is located at 7,
Bannimantap A Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru, Karnataka
570015. Regardless, the search of both the premises was
conducted by the officers.
b. Accordingly search at the declared residence of Shri
Akrampasha (Prop: AR Steel) and Shri Mohammed
Kamran (Prop: M.K. Traders) is located at LIG 61 Mysuru
Banni Mantap Road KAMYS 570015, was carried out on
10-09-2025. During search, it was found that the said
premises was occupied by one Shri Nadeem Ahmed and
his family. During search, the forensic imaging of the
mobile phone of Shri Nadeem Ahmed was done by the
forensic examiner. The search was going smoothly till
around 1:30 PM. However, at around 1:30 PM, two people
claiming to be brothers of Shri Mohammad Kamran
forcibly entered in the said premises under search and
disrupted the proceeding. They forcefully pushed the
officers out of the said premises. Taking advantage of the
situation, Shri Nadeem Ahmed assaulted the officers
present at the premises and fled the search premises.
The proceedings at the premises during search are
recorded in the Mahazar drawn on the spot and the same
is enclosed as Document No.1 to this petition.
c. Further, search of the residential premises of Shri
Akrampasa and Shri Mohammed Kamran located at
7, Bannimantap A Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru,
Karnataka 570015, was carried out 10.09.2025 under
Authorization
for
Search
bearing
CBIC-DIN202509DS0000000DAA4 dated 09-09-2025. During
search proceedings, the officer when Knocked the door
for opening the premises, no response was received for
about one hours. After much persuasion, the door was
opened by Shri Mohammed Kamran who was shown the
search authorization. After reading and acknowledging
the same, he allowed the officer to search the premises.
On enquiry about the family members present in the
house and especially about Shri Akrampasa, they
informed about the presence of Shri Mohammed Kamran,
his mother, Sister, brother, Wife and one infant. With
regard to Shri Parampasa, they informed that he is not in
the house. The officer started looking after the recording
of CCTV to find out the possible reason for delay in
opening the door. From the recording, it was known that
Shri Akrampasa was visible on the terrace and managed
to jump to the adjacent building and escaped from there
on one scooter with the help of one unidentified Aides.
While officer started recording statement of the Shri
Mohammed Kamran, he started showing aggression and
after some time his brother and other family members
took their mobile phone one after another and made calls
to their accomplices. Soon thereafter, people on the bikes
arrived at the premise and pretended to be from Media
and started shouting over officers. Within no time many
people gathered outside the premises and entered into
premise under search. While the officers present were
busy in calming down the mob and Shri Kamran took
advantage of the mob and escaped from the premises.
Meanwhile, the family members took out the segregated
documents by the officer which appears to be
incriminating for the evidence purpose. Later, while the
forensic examiner was sealing the Hard disk of CCTV,
Smt. Farzana banu, mother of Kamran, snatched the hard
disk from his hand and entered into one of the room
adjacent hall on the Ground floor and locked herself and
attempted to destroy the said hard disc as was evident
from the sound coming from the room. Thereafter, Shri
Umar and his sister entered into the said room and after
coming out from the room, they forcefully fled the
premises with the said hard disc. Later, when police came
and situation was brought to the control, they offered to
search again the rooms for documents and missing
DVR/Hard disk. However, the segregated documents and
hard disk could not be found there which confirmed that
the said documents and DVR/Hard disk were taken away
by the accomplices of Shri Mohammed Kamran and Shri
Akram Pasha. The i-phone of Shri Kamran could not be
subjected to forensic examination as he was reluctant to
open it even after much persuasion from the officer.
While escaping from the house, he took the mobile with
him. However, one macbook which was locked with the
ID of Shri Mohammed Kamran and one Pendrive
alongwith some hand written paper, unsigned Financials
were seized from the premises under Mahazar drawn on
the spot. Thus, the search proceeding completely
disturbed and obstructed by Shri Kamran, his brother,
Shri Umar and the family members. The entire
proceedings were recorded under Mahazar drawn on the
spot which is placed as Document No.2 to this petition.
d. Later, was learnt that the group of people headed by Shri
Mohammed Umar and his brother visited the other two
residential locations in synchronized manner and helped
in escaping of Shri Nadeem Ahmed and Shri Nasir Ahmed
from their respective premises where the search
proceedings were already under progress.
ii
Search at the residential premises of Shri Nasir Ahmed
(Prop: N. M. G. Traders):
a. As per Search Authorization bearing CBIC-DIN202509DS00000444A72
dated
09-09-2025,
search
operation was conducted at No 408 EWS Mysuru 2nd
Stage KAMYS 570015 residence address of M/s. NMG
Traders by the Authorized officer, Shri Randhir Kumar
Singh, SIO and Team on 10-09-2025. During Search
proceeding, it was found that the said premise was
occupied by Shri Nasir Ahmed, Prop. Of M/s. N.M.G
Traders and his family. During the search proceedings,
Shri Umar and friend of Umar entered into the premises
forcibly and started shouting over the officers and
disturbed the search proceeding. Also, they took out Shri
Nashir Ahmed out of the premises with them. During the
initial enquiry with the Prop. Nashir Ahmed, it was known
that the business of M/s. N.M.G Traders are dealt by Shri
Mohammed Kamran, prop. Of M/s. M. K. Trader. Such
submission was recorded in the video taken during the
investigation but the recorded statement in writing could
not be signed by Shri Nasir Ahmed due obstruction
caused by Shri Mohammed Umar (the brother of Kamran)
and his associates who forcibly took him with them. The
proceedings at the premises during search are recorded
in the Mahazar drawn on the spot which is placed as
Document No.3 to this petition.
7.
As elaborated above, the search proceedings at the
premises were disrupted by a group of people which were
apparently mobilized by Shri Akram Pasha, who had fled the
premises before the search at the said premises could even
begin and by his son Shri Mohammed Kamran who did not cooperated in the search proceedings and made calls during the
search after which the mob intruded in the premises under
search and assisted Shri Mohammed Kamran in fleeing the
premises during ongoing search proceedings. Shri Mohammed
Umar (brother of Shri Mohammed Kamran) and other members
of family of Shri Mohammed Kamran have played pivotal role in
destruction of evidence, escaping of key persons and
manhandling and threatening the officers of search party.
Following the above incidents two FIRs 0161/2025 and
0162/2025 were filed on 10-09-2025 at the N R Police Station
for obstructing the proceedings, destroying the evidence,
misbehaving with the officers on duty, manhandling and
assualting of officers on duty and other offences, under section
132.121(1),122(1), 208, 210, 212, 214, 218, 221, 224, 238,
241, 351(1), 352,r/w3(5) of BNS,2023. The FIRs are placed as
Document No.4&5 to this petition
8. STATEMENTS
8.1
During the search proceedings, statements were sought
to be recorded under Section 70 of the Central Goods and
Services Tax Act, 2017, particularly at the residential premises
of Shri Mohammed Kamran and Shri Nasir (Hussain/Ahmed).
Shri Mohammed Kamran, from the outset, adopted an evasive
and non-cooperative stance and, during the course of the
proceedings, fled his residence with the assistance of a mob. At
Shri Nasir's premises the recording initially proceeded
peacefully, Shri Nasir admitted on record that he is the
proprietor of M/s NMG Traders but that Shri Mohammed Kamran
managed the firm's entire operations - including the filing of
returns and handling departmental queries - and paid Shri Nasir
regular sums for the use of his identity in running the firm.
Thereafter, persons allegedly acting on Shri Kamran's directions
reached Shri Nasir's premises, abused the officers, obstructed
the proceedings and facilitated Shri Nasir's escape, thereby
preventing continuation of the statement recording.
8.2. An Authorization for Search bearing CBIC-DIN202509DS$000007227B9 dated 16-09-2025 was obtained
under section 67(2) of the CGST Act, 2017 for causing
search/seizure duly authorized by the Additional Director of
DGGI, BZU. Accordingly, search proceedings were conducted at
Kempegowda International Airport for searching the personal
belongings of Shri Mohammed Kamran and the proceedings
were recorded under Mahazar dated 16-09-2025. In accordance
with the Mahazar, there was an order of seizure in Form GSTINS02 wherein 6 mobile phones and one Dell Inspiron laptop
were seized.
8.3
Subsequently, a statement of Shri Mohammed Kamran
was recorded under Section 70 at Kempegowda International
Airport, Bengaluru on 16.09.2025; he again remained evasive
and non-cooperative, though the statement was duly recorded.
The said statement dated 16.09.2025 of Shri Mohammed
Kamran is placed as Document No.6 to this petition.
9. EXAMINATION AND ANALYSIS OF THE EVIDENCE
SEIZED DURING INVESTIGATION:
i. During the search proceedings at the residence of Shri
Mohammed Kamran, located at 7, Bannimantap A
Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru, Karnataka - 570015,
one MacBook, a pendrive, and certain documents were
seized. Forensic imaging of these electronic devices is
required to be carried out in the presence of Shri
Mohammed Kamran. Among the seized documents, a
handwritten account detailing date-wise payments made
to various persons was found. These entries appear to
reflect cash transactions routed through intermediaries,
as each entry mentions the names of two individuals. In
addition, unsigned trading/financial statements of M/s
A.R. Steel (Prop. Akram Pasha) and M/s A.K. Steel
Traders (Prop. Shri Abdul Asif) were also found at the
premises.
ii. It is noteworthy that M/s A.K. Steel Traders (Prop.
Abdul Asif, GSTIN 29DSQPA7479L1ZR) is a
suspended entity, which also appears in the list of
suppliers to M/s M.K. Traders (Prop. Mohammed
Kamran). Shri Abdul Asif is part of a wider supply chain
that includes suo-moto cancelled suppliers, namely M/s
M.Z. Traders (GSTIN 29DPRPR6133E1ZD) and M/s
Μ.Κ. Enterprises (GSTIN 29GECPM7261H1Z4).
Together, these two entities have availed/passed ITC to
the extent of `54 crore. The availability of unsigned
financial documents of Shri Abdul Asif at the premises of
Shri Akram Pasha and Shri Mohammed Kamran strongly
indicates a nexus among them, which requires further
investigation.
iii. With regard to the forensic imaging of data extracted
from the mobile phone of Shri Nadeem Ahmed, the
following facts have emerged:
o
Two digital images of rubber stamps were found, one
in the name of N.A. Traders, #161, 1st Stage,
Mysore,
Karnataka
570019,
GSTIN
29EAMPA0528R1Z7,
and
another
with
the
impression "For N.A. Traders."
o
On
verification
of
GSTN
records,
GSTIN
29EAMPA0528R1Z7 was found to be registered in
the name of Shri Nadeem Ahmed with trade name
M/s N.A. Traders, which is currently "Active."
However, no inward or outward supplies have been
reported for the past four years, and only NIL returns
have been filed.
iv. Further, on perusal of WhatsApp chats, it was seen that
Shri Nadeem Ahmed is in regular contact with a user
saved as "Kamran..one" (mobile number 9110247185),
which pertains to Shri Mohammed Kamran. The chats,
primarily in audio format, contain multiple instances of
confirmation of payments made by Shri Nadeem Ahmed
to various persons. Additionally, Shri Nadeem Ahmed was
found reporting payment confirmations through audio
chats to:
o
"Mueez..Kamran" (mobile number 9110255504),
believed to be Shri Mohammed Mueez Ulla Shariff, and
o
"Shoiab..Office" (mobile number 8660641723),
believed to be Shri Mohammed Shoib Hussain.
V. From the evidence available, Shri Nadeem Ahmed appears
to be handling cash transactions, as reflected in the audio
confirmations of payments made to various persons.
10.
SUMMARY OF PROCEEDINGS:
i. During the search proceedings at the residential premises
in Mysuru of Shri Akram Pasha (Proprietor, M/s A.R.
Steel), Shri Mohammed Kamran (Proprietor, M/s M.K.
Traders), and Shri Nasir Ahmed (Proprietor, M/s N.M.G.
Traders), deliberate obstruction was caused with malafide
intent and attempts were made to destroy evidence. Shri
Mohammed Kamran and his father, Shri Akram Pasha,
managed to escape during the entry of officers for search.
Shri Mohammed Umar, brother of Shri Kamran, played a
key role in organizing an agitation together with Shri
Kamran, which facilitated the escape of Shri Nadeem
Ahmed and Shri Nasir Ahmed. The synchronized nature of
the escapes clearly indicates close nexus among all the
proprietors - Shri Mohammed Kamran, Shri Akram Pasha,
Shri Nadeem Ahmed, and Shri Nasir Ahmed - with Shri
Kamran emerging as the mastermind, as all agitation and
escapes (except that of Akram Pasha) occurred after
Kamran and his brother Umar absconded during the
search of their premises.
ii. The principal and additional places of business of the
above entities were found locked, with no signs of active
business operations at multiple locations. Further,
documents seized during the searches reveal that Shri
Akram Pasha is also the proprietor of M/s A.R. Traders,
and unsigned financial documents of M/s A.K. Steel
Traders (Prop. Abdul Asif), along with handwritten
records of payments, point to their nexus with multiple
firms. The material collected during the searches
corroborates the intelligence gathered by this office that
the four entities mentioned above are engaged in passing
on fake Input Tax Credit (ITC). The evidence also
indicates that Shri Mohammed Kamran, is the
masterminds behind the Operation of these entities.
iii. Additionally, during the search, it was found that the
declared residential premises of Shri Akram Pasha and
Shri Mohammed Kamran was in fact occupied by their
uncle, Shri Nadeem Ahmed, who appears to be handling
cash transactions for them, as evidenced from
WhatsApp/audio-recordings
recovered
during
investigation.
iv. From the above investigation and findings, it is revealed
that Shri Saddam (Prop. M/s U.K. Steel Traders) had
availed Input Tax Credit (ITC) from entities which were
subsequently cancelled suo-moto by the department. The
ITC passed on by these entities appears to have been
availed on the strength of fake invoices without any
actual supply of goods. Shri Saddam further passed on
such ineligible credit to M/s N.M.G. Traders. In his
statement (which could not be signed due to obstruction
caused by Shri Mohammed Kamran, his brother, and their
aides), Shri Nasir Ahmed (Prop. M/s N.M.G. Traders)
stated, in response to a query regarding the suo-moto
cancelled suppliers of his firm:
"I am not aware about these suppliers of my firm M/s
N.M.G. Traders and I am not in contact with any of them,
as Mohammed Kamran alone handles all the sales and
purchase related transactions."
Further, WhatsApp chats of Shri Nadeem Ahmed
confirm that he was reporting payments made to various
persons. These chats indicate that Shri Mohammed
Kamran is the mastermind in the chain, having
engaged these entities for passing on fake ITC.
11.1 In view of Clause (c) of Sub-section (1) of Section 132 as
above, any person "who avails input tax credit using such
invoice or bill referred to in clause (b) or fraudulently avails
input tax credit without any invoice or bill;" shall be punishable
in cases where the amount of tax evaded or the amount of input
tax credit wrongly availed or utilized or the amount of refund
wrongly taken exceeds five hundred lakh rupees, with
imprisonment for a term which may extend to five years and
with fine;
11.2 Further as per Section 132 (5) of the CGST Act, 2017, the
offences specified in clause (a) or clause (b) or clause (c) or
clause (d) of sub-section (1) and punishable under clause(i) of
that sub-section shall be cognizable and non-bailable.
11.3. Further as per Section 69(1) of the CGST Act, 2017,
"Where the Commissioner has reasons to believe that a person
has committed any offence specified in clause (a) or clause (b)
or clause (c) or clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 132
which is punishable under clause (i) or (ii) of sub-section (1), or
sub-section (2) of the said section, he may, by order authorize
any officer of Central tax to arrest such person".
12. Further, in view of the incidents during the search
proceedings dated 10.09.2025 particularly the acts of
absconding from premises and attempts to obstruct/destroy
evidence is a grave apprehension that if the above-named
persons are left at large, they will tamper with crucial evidence,
threaten/coerce witnesses, and thereby frustrate the course of
investigation. It is also pertiment that several sets of
documents and digital records are yet to be recovered,
examined, and verified, which are essential to quantify the full
extent of tax evasion and identify - the entire beneficiary
network.
Their
custodial
interrogation
is,
therefore,
indispensable to safeguard the integrity of the investigation.
13.
The facts brought on record indicates that, Shri
Mohammed Kamran, is the mastermind responsible for
commission of offences under clause (c) of sub-section (1) of
Section 132 of the CGST Act, 2017, which are punishable under
clause (i) of the said sub-section with imprisonment up to five
years and fine. The offences committed by them are cognizable
and non-bailable in terms of Section 132(5) of the Act.
Therefore, Shri Mohammed Kamran was clearly liable and
therefore arrested under Section 69(1) of the CGST Act, 2017,
in order to secure their custodial interrogation, prevent further
destruction of evidence, and protect the interest of revenue.
14.
The above-mentioned firms appear to be non-existent or
do not carry out any active business at their registered
premises, as established during the search proceedings. Further,
it is evident that these firms, including M/s MK Traders, have
availed Input Tax Credit (ITC) without actual supply of goods
and/or services. Verification from the GSTN back office also
indicates that the registrations of most of the suppliers to these
entities were cancelled on account of availment and passing on
of ineligible ITC or due to non-existence of business premises.
ROLE OF SHRI MOHAMMED KAMRAN:
i. Investigation indicates that Shri Mohammed Kamran,
S/o Shri Akram Pasha, Proprietor of M/s. MK Traders
(GSTIN-29IRZPK8080E1ZT) has fraudulently availed
ineligible input tax credit (ITC) of ₹21.11 crores approx,
without actual receipt of goods or services. Out of the
same, ineligible ITC of ₹2.53 crores has been received
from 19 suppliers whose registrations have been suomoto cancelled/suspended by the Department on the
grounds of being non-existent or engaged in passing on
ineligible credit. Further, fake ITC of ₹18.58 crores has
been availed on invoices from M/s. N.M.G. Traders, which
have no active business operations and have been floated
only to avail of and pass fake ITC.
ii. Evidence on record indicates that Shri. Mohammed
Kamran has not only fraudulently availed fake ITC
but also failed to cooperate in the ongoing
investigation by this office. He misbehaved,
obstructed and fled the search premises with the
support of the mob. He also snatched away crucial
digital evidence. Shri Mohammed Kamran raises
serious apprehensions of tampering with evidence
and
influencing
co-conspirators
and
crucial
witnesses. He is also at risk of fleeing
furthering the scam he has orchestrated.
and
iii. In view of the above, and considering the grave
offence committed by Mohammed Kamran, he is at
risk of fleeing and evading the investigation.
Furthermore, there is a high risk that Mohammed
Kamran will tamper with the evidence and influence
the witness in the scam. The culpable mental state
of
Mohanimed
Kamran
has
already
been
demonstrated by his acts of fleeing the ongoing
search proceedings at his residence with crucial
digital evidence. It raises serious apprehensions of
tampering with evidence and influencing coconspirators and vital witnesses in the case.
iv. The facts brought on record firmly establish beyond
doubt that Mohammed Kamran is the mastermind
who is responsible for the commission of offences
under clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 132
of the CGST Act, 2017, which are punishable under
clause
(i)
of
the
said
sub-section
with
imprisonment up to five years and fine. The
offences committed by them are cognizable and
non-bailable in terms of Section 132(5) of the Act.
Therefore, Mohammed Kamran is clearly liable for
arrest under Section 69(1) of the CGST Act, 2017,
to secure their custodial interrogation, prevent
further destruction of evidence, and protect the
interest of revenue.
v. In view of the above, the offences committed by
Shri Mohammed Kamran are offences as per Clause
(c) of Sub-section (1) of Section 132 of the Central
Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. They are
punishable with imprisonment for a term which
may extend to five years and with a fine in terms of
clause (i) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 132 of the
said Act. Further, these offences are cognizable and
non-bailable in terms of sub-section (5) of Section
132 of the said Act.
vi. In view of the above, there are sufficient and
reasonable grounds to believe that Shri Mohammed
Kamran has committed the offences punishable
under Section 132(1)(i) of the CGST Act, 2017,
which are cognizable and non-bailable. Accordingly,
I invoke my powers under Section 69(1) of the
CGST Act, 2017, to effect his arrest to prevent
further destruction of evidence, enable custodial
interrogation, and safeguard the revenue.
16. LEGAL PROVISIONS AND CONTRAVENTIONS
16.1 As per Section 132(1) of the Central Goods and Services
Tax Act, 2017,
"Section 132. Punishment for certain offences.(1) 1[Whoever commits, or causes to commit and retain the
benefits arising out of, any of the following offences],
namely:(a) supplies any goods or services or both without issue of
any invoice, in violation of the provisions of this Act or the
rules made thereunder, with the intention to evade tax:
(b) issues any invoice or bill without supply of goods or
services or both in violation of the provisions of this Act,
or the rules made thereunder leading to wrongful
availment or utilisation of input tax credit or refund of
tax:
(c) avails input tax credit using the invoice or bill referred to
in clause (b) or fraudulently avails
input tax credit
without any invoice or bill:
….
shall be punishable(i) in cases where the amount of tax evaded or the amount
of input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised or the
amount of refund wrongly taken exceeds five hundred
lakh rupees, with imprisonment for a term which may
extend to five years and with fine:
….”
16.2 Further super Section 132(5) of the CGST Act, 2017, the
offences specified in clause (a) or clause (b) or clause (c) or
clause (d) of sub-section (1) and punishable under clause(i) of
that sub-section shall be cognizable and non-bailable.
16.3 Further as per Section 69(1) of the CGST Act, 2017,
"Where the Commissioner has reasons to believe that a person
has committed any offence specified in 132(1)(a, b, c &d) of the
CGST Act, 2017 which is punishable under clause (i) or (ii) of
sub-section (1), or sub-section (2) of the said section, he may,
by order, authorize any officer of central tax to arrest such
person".
16.4. In this case, Shri Mohammed Kamran S/o Shri
Akram Pasha, aged about 24 Years (DoB: 26.12.2000),
Resident of LIG-61, bannimantap road, Bannimantap,
Mysore-570015, has involved himself in the evasion of
GST by way of availing of ITC totally amounting to
Rs.21.11 Crores without underlying supply of goods or
services which is an offence under Section 132(1)(c) of
Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017,. The same is a
cognizable offence and non-bailable as per the provisions
of Section 132(5) of the CGST Act, 2017. Further it
appears that he is liable for arrest under Section 69(1) of
the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 for offence
committed under Clause (a) and Clause (b) of Subsection (1) of Section 132 of the Central Goods and
Services Tax Act, 2017 which is liable for punishment
with imprisonment for a term which may extend to five
years and with fine in terms of Clause (i) of Sub-section
(1) of Section 132 of Central Goods and Services Tax Act,
2017.
16.5 In view of the above offence, the accused Shri
Mohammed Kamran was placed under arrest on 16th
September 2025 at 6:30 Hours (Memorandum of arrest is
attached
Document
No.7
to
this
petition),
at
Kempegowda International Airport, Bengaluru within the
jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court. Shri Mohammed
Kamran's arrest has been conveyed to his mother Smt.
Farzana Banu telephonically on number at about 7:30
hours on 16th September 2025 in the presence of Shri
Mohammed Kamran and he has made an endorsement in
the arrest memo about the aforementioned telephonic
conversation informing about his arrest. The Grounds of
Arrest, reasons of arrest and reasons to believe have
been communicated to Shri Mohammed Kamran as
annexure to the Arrest Memo and the same have been
read over and explained to him. A letter intimating the
arrest of the accused was sent to Smt Farzana Banu on
her mobile number 9611604595 by WhatsApp. However,
out of inadvertence the date of arrest in the intimation
letter was mentioned as 15-09-2025 instead of 16-092025. However, in the WhatsApp message which was
sent to her was correctly mentioning as 16-09-2025.
Accordingly, a revised intimation correcting the above
date was also sent to Farzana Banu over WhatsApp. The
procedure of arrest is in line with the Hon'ble Apex Court
Judgements.
17 Justification of Remand:
17.1 The investigation at hand is in initial state and it
has clearly outlined the role of Shri Mohammed Kamran
in orchestrating the scam unearthed during the
investigation. The investigation at hand involves scrutiny
of humongous data and thousands of documents
recovered during the investigation thus far. Several other
individuals are required to be questioned, documents and
details are required to be recovered and numerous
information
to
be
collected
and
collated.
The
investigation involves unearthing the network of
transactions, layers of benefits drawn, evaluating
quantum of evasion of GST, collecting, collating and
scrutinizing thousands of records pertaining to the said
entities and questioning several individuals involved in
the meticulously planned scam in order to conclude the
investigation into meaningful and justified outcome.
17.2 The investigation at hand has evidenced that Shri
Mohammed Kamran has availed fraudulent ITC to the
tune of 21.11 crores without supply of goods and/or
services and availing input tax credit without actual
receipt of goods and/or services. His name has figured
out from every nook and corner of the investigation. It is
evident from the investigation done thus far that Shri
Mohammed Kamran has several other conspirators and
accomplices - both small and big- in the syndicate.
17.3 As the proprietor of M/s M.K. Traders, Shri Mohammed
Kamran has attempted to tamper with evidence in several ways.
He initially obstructed the search by refusing to open the door of
his residence for about 1.5 to 2 hours, evidently to conceal or
destroy evidence. During the proceedings, he also facilitated the
escape of Shri Akram Pasha (proprietor of M/s A.R. Steel) from
the premises. Evidence on record indicates that Shri
Kamran not only fraudulently availed fake ITC but also
failed to cooperate with the investigation. He misbehaved
with officers, obstructed proceedings, fled the search
premises with the support of a mob, and even snatched
away crucial digital evidence. Further, he directed
persons to other premises to obstruct proceedings and
assist co-accused in escaping. He is also not cooperating
in the examination of seized digital devices by denying
access and refusing to share passwords for his mobile
phones and laptop. His conduct raises serious concerns
regarding tampering with evidence, influencing coconspirators and witnesses, and the risk of absconding
and furthering the fraudulent activities orchestrated by
him.
17.4 Shri
Mohammed
Kamran
has
willfully
and
consciously tried to destroy the crucial evidence which
would have led to investigation of other individuals
involved in the above offence. His intent to destroy the
evidence and misled the investigation may hamper the
investigation at hand. It is submitted that the
investigation is being done aspects viz. recipient of
goods, receipt of proceeds, involvement of other
individuals and companies etc. It is feared that Shri
Mohammed Kamran may temper/destroy the evidence,
influence the witness or escape. Therefore, it appears
just and necessary to place Shri Mohammed Kamran
under Judicial Remand so that the investigation can be
concluded in a logical manner.
17.5 The investigation at hand involves unearthing the
network of transactions, layers of benefits drawn,
evaluating quantum of evasion of GST, collecting,
collating and scrutinizing thousands of records pertaining
to the said companies and questioning several individuals
involved in the meticulously planned scam. The nature of
investigation at hand is subtle and complex at the same
time and even smallest attempt to tamper the evidence,
influence the witnesses of scuttle the proceedings may
hamper the recovery of evidence and in such scenario the
justice envisioned at the end of the investigation and
adjudication proceedings may also suffer. Therefore, it is
just and essential to confine the arrested accused in
Judicial Custody to enable the investigating officers to
conclude the investigation in an unimpeded manner.
17.6 It is respectfully submitted that the department is pursuing
further investigation in the matter and the investigations need
to be conducted to quantify total GST liability and gather further
evidence establishing the evasion of GST.
18. In view of the foregoing, the complainant most prays that:
PRAYER
The arrested accused, Shri Mohammed Kamran S/o
Akram Pasha are hereby produced before the Hon'ble Court.
In view of the above circumstances, it is most humbly
prayed that the accused Shri Mohammed Kamran, may be
remanded to Judicial Custody for fifteen (15) days in the
interest of further investigation and thus render justice.
Place: Bengaluru
Date: 16.09.2025
Sd/-16/09/2025
ASHOK KUMAR YADAV
SENIOR INTELLIGENCE OFFICER
DGGI BENGALURU ZONAL UNIT”
The arrest memo reads as follows:
“GSTIN-29IRZPK8080E1ZT CBIC-DIN-202509DSS0000021262E
File No- DGGI/INV/125/2025-Gr C-01-0/0 Pr ADG-DGGI-ZU-BENG
ARREST MEMO
(To be prepared in duplicate)
[under Section 69 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017]
Whereas, the principal Commissioner/Commissioner,
Anwar Ali T.P. has reasons to believe that you, Mr Mohammed
Kamran, Proprietor of M/s. M K Traders, age about 24 years,
son/ daughter of Shri Akram Pasha and address LIG 61 Mysuru
Banni Mantap Road, Mysore, Karnataka- 570015 have commited
an offence specified in clause (a) or clause (b) or clause (c) or
clause (d) of sub section (1) of section 132 of the Central Goods
and Service Tax, 2017 which is punishable under clause (i) or
(ii) of sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) of the said section.
2.
I, Ashok Kumar Yadav Senior Intelligence Officer Office of
the Principal Commissioner/Commissioner, CGST O/o the Pr.
Additional Director General, Directorate General of GST
Intelligence, Bangalore Zonal Unit, No.112, S.P.Enclave,
Adjacent to Karnataka Bank, KH Road, Bangalore-560027
being duly authorized, hereby arrest you today at 6:30:AM on
2025-09-16 00:00:00.0 at Kempegowda International Airport,
Bangalore under Section 69 of the said Act.
3. Accordingly, Shri Mohammed Kamran son / daughter of
Akram Pasha has been placed under arrest and he has been
explained the grounds of his arrest. He was also informed about
his right to have someone informed about his arrest and Sh./Ms
has been informed about his arrest.
Signature
Sd/- 16/09/2025
Name: Ashok Kumar Yadav
Designation: Superintendent /Appraiser/Senior Intelligence Officer
4. I have been explained the grounds of my arrest. The fact of
my arrest have been witnessed by Shri Boddu Sreekanth,
Baggage Helper, son/daughter of Duggaiah B. resident of
Narayanam Peta, VTC+PO: Seetharamapuram, Dist- Nellore,
AP-524310
Received copy of arrest Memo
Sd/Signature of the Arrestee
Sd/Counter Signature of Witness
Sd/Wimen-2”
The grounds of arrest and reasons for arrest read as follows:
“F. No. F. No. DGGI/INV/125/2025-Gr C-01-0/0 Pr ADG-DGGIZU-BENGALURU
दनांक Date: 16.09.2025
CBIC-DIN: 202509DSS0000021262E
Annexure to Arrest Memo issued to Shri Mohammed
Kamran
I.
Grounds of arrest :
1.
That Shri Mohammed Kamran, has involved himself in
the illicit activity of issuance of invoices without supply of goods
and/or services in the name of M/s M K Traders. The grounds of
arrest are as follows:
i)
M/s. M K TRADERS, (hereinafter referred to as "the said
taxpayer") a proprietary firm under the proprietorship of
Shri. Mohammed Kamran S/o Shri Akram Pasha, is
registered
with
the
department
under
GSTIN
29IRZPK8080E1ZT for supply goods viz. FERROUS WASTE
AND SCRAP; REMELTING SCRAP INGOTS OF IRON OR
STEEL, HSN-7204. The taxpayer has registered principal
place of business at 75, 2nd Main Road, 4th Cross, Kesare
Village, Kasaba Hobli, Mysuru (Mysore) - 570007 and an
Additional Place of Business at Ground Floor, Bunder,
ANSARI ROAD, Near Yateem Khana, Mangaluru, Dakshina
Kannada, Karnataka, 575001. The taxpayer falls under
the jurisdiction of Lashker Mohalla Range of Mysore CGST
Commissionerate.
ii)
Further, Shri Mohammed Kamran, has been found
to have fraudulently availed ineligible input tax
credit (ITC) of Rs.21.11 Crores on the strength of
invoices
without
accompanying
supply
of
goods/services. Out of the above ITC, Rs.2.53 Cr
has
been
availed
from
suppliers,
whose
registrations
have
been
suo-moto
cancelled/suspended by the Department on the
grounds of being non-existent or engaged in
passing on ineligible credit. Further, he has availed
ITC of Rs.18.58 Crores from M/s. N.M.G. Traders
which does not have any legitimate business and is
a proprietary concern of Nasir Ahmed which have
emerged as major players in the fake ITC racket
and are under active investigation. Though the GST
Registration of M/s NMG Traders is active, they do
not have actual business operations and have been
floated only for availing and passing fake ITC.
Search at the address of the principal place of
business and additional place of business indicated
no business activity. Further, the principal place of
business was found to be rented premises, and the
owner of the premises has submitted that there has
been no business activity at the said premises. On
perusal of the GSTR2A return of M/s NMG Traders,
it is seen that major suppliers are either suo-moto
cancelled by the department and the among the
Active suppliers, several appear to be generators of
fake ITC.
iii)
The details of supplier wise ITC availed and status of their
GST registration is tabulated below:
iv.
Shri Mohammed Kamran has fraudulently availed ITC of
Rs.21.11 Crores without receipt of goods/services,
solely on the strength of bogus invoices issued by nonexistent/fictitious firms, including M/s. N.M.G. Traders.
v.
His acts constitute offences under the CGST Act, 2017,
under Section 132(1)(c): Availment/utilisation of ITC
without actual receipt of goods/services;
vi.
The fraudulent ITC involved, Rs.21.11 Crores, far exceeds
the statutory threshold of `5 Crores. Therefore, in terms
of Section 132(5) of the CGST Act, 2017, the offences are
cognizable and non-bailable.
vii.
In view of the above, there are sufficient and reasonable
grounds that Shri Mohammed Kamran has committed the
offences punishable under the CGST Act, 2017.
Accordingly, in exercise of powers under Section 69(1) of
the CGST Act, 2017 is warranted to effect his arrest in
order to prevent further destruction of evidence, enable
custodial interrogation, and safeguard the revenue
II. Reasons for Arrest:
i.
To prevent Shri Mohammed Kamran from tampering with
the evidence in any manner;
ii.
To prevent Shri Mohammed Kamran from committing any
further offence;
iii.
To prevent Shri Mohammed Kamran from making
inducement, threat, promise to any person acquainted
with fact of the case so as to dissuade him from disclosing
such facts to the court or to the investigating officer;
iv.
To prevent Shri Mohammed Kamran from fleeing thereby
dodging the investigation;
III. Reasons to Believe:
The competent authority has the following reasons to
believe:
1.
That Shri Mohammed Kamran, S/o Shri Akram
Pasha, Proprietor of M/s. MK Traders (GSTIN29IRZPK8080E1ZT) has fraudulently availed ineligible
input tax credit (ITC) of ₹21.11 crores approx, without
actual receipt of goods or services. Out of the same,
ineligible ITC of ₹2.53 crores has been received from 19
suppliers whose registrations have been suo-moto
cancelled/suspended by the Department on the grounds
of being non-existent or engaged in passing on ineligible
credit. Further, fake ITC of 18.58 crores has been availed
on invoices from M/s. N.M.G. Traders, which have no
active business operations and have been floated only to
avail of and pass fake ITC.
2.
That evidence on record indicates that Shri.
Mohammed Kamran has not only fraudulently
availed fake ITC but also failed to cooperate in the
ongoing
investigation
by
this
office.
He
misbehaved, obstructed and fled the search
premises with the support of the mob. He also
snatched away crucial digital evidence. Shri
Mohammed Kamran raises serious apprehensions of
tampering with evidence and influencing coconspirators and crucial witnesses. He is also at
risk of fleeing and furthering the scam he has
orchestrated.
3.
That, Shri Mohammed Kamran, is at risk of fleeing
and evading the investigation and tampering with
the evidence and influence the witness in the scam.
The culpable mental state of Mohammed Kamran
has already been demonstrated by his acts of
fleeing the ongoing search proceedings at his
residence with crucial digital evidence. It raises
serious apprehensions of tampering with evidence
and influencing co-conspirators and vital witnesses
in the case.
4.
That Shri Mohammed Kamran has committed the offences
as per Clause (c) of Sub-section (1) of Section 132 of the
Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, which are
punishable with imprisonment for a term which may
extend to five years and with a fine, in terms of clause (i)
of Sub-Section (1) of Section 132 of the said Act. Further,
these alleged offences are cognizable and non-bailable in
terms of sub-section (5) of Section 132 of the said Act.
7.
In view of the above, there are sufficient and reasonable
grounds to believe that Shri Mohammed Kamran has
committed the offences punishable under Section
132(1)(i) of the CGST Act, 2017, which are cognizable
and non- bailable. Accordingly, I invoke my powers under
Section 69(1) of the CGST Act, 2017, to effect his arrest
to prevent further destruction of evidence, enable
custodial interrogation, and safeguard the revenue.
8.
Hence, I have reasons to believe that Shri Mohammed
Kamran, has committed offences as per Clause (c) of
Sub-section (1) of Section 132 of the Central Goods and
Services Tax Act, 2017, which are punishable with Section
132 of the said Act. Further, these alleged offences are
cognizable and non-bailable in terms of sub-section (5) of
Section 132 of the said Act.
9.
Wherever the provisions of the CGST Act, 2017, have
been invoked, the corresponding provisions of the
Karnataka GST Act, 2017, read with Section 20 of the
IGST Act, 2017, as applicable, are deemed to be invoked.
10.
Accordingly, in exercise of the powers vested in me, in
terms of Sub-Section (1) of Section 69 of CGST Act,
2017, I hereby authorize Shri Ashok Kumar Yadav, Senior
Intelligence Officer, Directorate General of GST
Intelligence, Bengaluru Zonal Unit, Bengaluru, to arrest
Shri Mohammed Kamran, aged about 24 years (DOB:
26.12.2000), S/o Shri Akram Pasha residing LIG 61
Mysuru Banni Mantap Road, Mysore, Karnataka570015(as declared in GST registration)
15/09/2025 08:10 PM
Place: BENGALURU
Date: 16.09.2025
Sd/- 16/09/20 25
अशोक कमार
यादव / Ashok Kumar Yadav
ु
व र आसचना
अ धकार /Senior Intelligence Officer
ू
डी. जी. जी. आई., बगल!
ु जोनल इकाई/DGGI, Bengaluru Zonal Unit
To
Shri Mohammed Kamran,,
aged about 24 Years (DoB: 26-12-2000),
S/o Shri Akram Pasha
Residing at LIG 61 Mysuru Banni Mantap Road,
Mysore,Karnataka-570015(as declared in GST registration)”
(sic)
(Emphasis added at each instance)
The petitioner is before the Court on the plea that there cannot be
parallel proceedings by the State GST authorities and the Central
GST authorities.
8.2. Both the learned senior counsel for the petitioner and the
learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 and 2 have relied on the
judgment of the Apex Court in the case of ARMOUR SECURITY
supra. Therefore, certain paragraphs that are relevant of the said
judgment are required to be noticed. They read as follows:
“….
….
….
83. However, we shall now proceed to interpret the term
“subject- matter” as employed in section 6(2)(b) of the Act. It is
abundantly clear from the purport of the said section that
“subject-matter” needs to be understood in perspective of
initiation of proceedings. In other words, subject-matter of the
proceedings. In the preceding paragraphs of this judgment, we
have stated that proceedings stand initiated when a showcause notice is issued with regard to a subject-matter.
We say so because an issuance of a show-cause notice is
the first stage whereby the Revenue for the very first
time elaborately pens down various grounds and charges
it is alleging against the assessee, who is invited to show
cause as to why adverse action must not be taken against
him on the basis of the apprehensions that the authority
contemplates.
…
…
…
85. Primacy is given to the cogency of a show-cause
notice. The subject- matter of the proceedings lies in the
contents of the notice. Hence, it ought to be exhaustive,
so much so that it is capable of presenting the case of the
Revenue in a nutshell. In Commissioner of Central Excise,
Bhubaneswar-I v. Champdany Industries Limited reported in
[(2010) 1 GSTR 52 (SC); (2009) 9 SCC 466; 2009 SCC OnLine
SC 1606.], while deciding upon the classification of jute carpets,
this court noted that in the failure of mentioning the application
of certain tests which the Revenue relied upon in the
proceedings before the court, the Revenue cannot rely on such
tests at a later stage. A show-cause notice must lay down
the foundation of the case. Such is the importance of a
show cause as a starting point in proceedings. The
relevant extracts have been supplied below [ Page 64 in 1
GSTR.]:
“50. Apart from that, the point on rule 3 which
has been argued by the learned counsel for the Revenue
was not part of its case in the show-cause notice. It is
well-settled that unless the foundation of the case is
made out in the show-cause notice, Revenue cannot in
court argue a case not made out in its show-cause
notice. See: Commissioner of Customs, Mumbai v. Toyo
Engineering India Ltd. [(2006) 7 SCC 592, paragraph
16; 2006 SCC OnLine SC 902.].
51. Similar view was expressed by this court in
the
case
of Commissioner
of
Central
Excise,
Nagpur v. Ballarpur Industries Ltd. [(2007) 9 RC 456;
(2007) 8 SCC 89; 2007 SCC OnLine SC 1076.]. In
paragraph 27 of the said report, learned judges made it
clear that if there is no invocation of the concerned rules
in the show-cause notice, it would not be open to the
Commissioner to invoke the said rule.” (emphasis
supplied)
86. From the above exposition of law, we can safely
conclude that a show-cause notice delineates the scope of
the proceedings in the expression of subject-matter with
which the authority would be dealing. It would be
impermissible for an authority to invoke such rules,
claims or grounds at a later stage which do not figure in
the show-cause notice. That is to say, any ground,
reasoning or claim which does not figure out in the showcause notice cannot be permitted to adversely affect the
noticee. Such recognition has even been made statutorily, as
per sub-section (7) of section 75 of the Act, which reads as
thus:
“75. General provisions relating to determination
of tax.—(1) to (6)…
(7) The amount of tax, interest and penalty
demanded in the order shall not be in excess of the
amount specified in the notice and no demand shall be
confirmed on the grounds other than the grounds
specified in the notice.”
87. The expression “subject-matter” contemplates
proceedings directed towards determining the taxpayer's
liability or contravention, encompassing the alleged
offence or non-compliance together with the relief or
demand sought by the Revenue, as articulated in the
show-cause notice through its charges, grounds, and
quantification of demand. Accordingly, the bar on the
“same subject-matter” is attracted only where both
proceedings seek to assess or recover an identical
liability, or even where there is the slightest overlap in
the tax liability or obligation.
88. In other words, under section 6(2)(b), the
“subject-matter” is intrinsically tied to the determination
of the specific violation under scrutiny or the liability
alleged to be unpaid. The statutory bar is triggered only
when the two proceedings against the same taxpayer are,
in substance, directed towards the very same or
overlapping deficiency in tax discharge or the identical
contravention alleged. Where the proceedings concern
distinct infractions, each Department is entitled to
proceed within its respective statutory remit without
infringing the prohibition. Where the proceedings concern
distinct infractions, each Department is entitled to
proceed within its respective statutory remit without
infringing the prohibition.
89. In order to bolster such embodiments of section
6(2)(b) at large, we lay down a twofold test, discernible
from our discussion above, to determine whether a
subject-matter is “same” : first, the subject-matter will
be considered the same if an authority has already
proceeded on an identical liability of tax or alleged
offence by the assessee on the same facts; and secondly,
if the demand or relief sought is identical.
90. In the present case, the learned counsel for the
petitioner contended that the subject-matter of the
proceedings pertained to the availability of input-tax
credit in respect of cancelled dealers. However, this
contention fails for two reasons : first, the summons, on
its own, cannot reveal the subject-matter; and secondly,
the subject-matter can be ascertained only from the
show-cause notice. The apprehension of the petitioner
cannot be countenanced merely because a facet of the
ongoing inquiry overlaps with the subject-matter of the
show-cause notice already issued.
91. Upon crystallization of the subject-matter through a
show-cause notice issued pursuant to an intelligence, no other
tax authority may assume jurisdiction over it, provided it is
ascertainable
that
the
consequences
of
any
further
departmental action would be subsumed within the same
subject-matter.
III. What is the purport of an “Order” under section
6(2)(a) of the CGST Act ?
92. Clause (a) of sub-section (2) of section 6 of the
CGST Act stipulates that where any proper officer issues
an order under the CGST Act, he must issue an order
under the SGST Act or the UTGST Act in order to intimate
the jurisdictional officer of the State tax or Union
territory tax. The provision reads thus:
“6(2) Subject to the conditions specified in the
notification issued under sub-section (1),—
(a) where any proper officer issues an order
under this Act, he shall also issue an order under the
State Goods and Services Tax Act or the Union Territory
Goods and Services Tax Act, as authorised by the State
Goods and Services Tax Act or the Union Territory Goods
and Services Tax Act, as the case may be, under
intimation to the jurisdictional officer of State tax or
Union territory tax;”
93. In construing section 6(2)(a), it is imperative to have
due regard to the legislative intent permeating the GST
enactments. Section 6, in particular, advances the objective of
establishing a unified national market for goods and services
and to prevent taxpayers from the undue hardship of being
subjected to the rigours of multiple jurisdictions.
94. The provision serves a twofold purpose : first,
to insulate taxpayers from the prospect of being
proceeded against by more than one authority for the
same subject-matter; and secondly, to vest in the officers
functioning under the CGST Act, the SGST Act, or the
UTGST Act, to render a comprehensive order, thereby
avoiding multiplicity of proceedings. Such a construction
is also in consonance with the well-recognized principle
of comity between jurisdictions, which mandates that
coordinate authorities must act with mutual respect and
due regard for each other's domain, so as to preclude the
possibility of conflicting determinations on the same
issue.
95. To give effect to the above intent, section 6(2)(a)
is couched in terms that are both enabling and
mandatory. It confers upon, and simultaneously obliges,
the proper officer to issue a corresponding order under
the SGST Act or the UTGST Act in cases where an order is
being issued under the CGST Act. The expression “order”,
qualified by the terms “under this Act”, occurring in the
said provision admits of a broad construction, so as to
include every form of order which a proper officer is
competent to issue by virtue of the authority vested in
them under the statute. Such an interpretation is
necessary to ensure that the statutory mandate achieves
its intended purpose of avoiding multiplicity of
proceedings and securing uniformity of adjudication
across the parallel enactments.
96. Inasmuch as the CGST Act vests the proper officer
with authority to issue “orders” under various provisions, it
becomes imperative that such officer duly apprises the
jurisdictional counterpart of any action initiated by the
Department in relation to a taxable person who may otherwise
fall within the administrative domain of that officer. Given that
the statutory framework envisages a regime of crossempowerment amongst officers, the obligation so cast
operates as a safeguard against the prejudice which may
arise from the initiation of parallel or overlapping
proceedings against the same taxpayer by different wings
of the Department.
E. Conclusion
97. We summarize our final conclusion as under:
(i)
Clause (b) of sub-section (2) of section 6 of
the CGST Act and the equivalent State
enactments bars the “initiation of any
proceedings” on the “same subject-matter”.
(ii)
Any action arising from the audit of accounts or
detailed scrutiny of returns must be initiated by the
tax administration to which the taxpayer is
assigned.
(iii)
Intelligence based enforcement action can be
initiated by any one of the Central or the State
tax administrations despite the taxpayer
having
been
assigned
to
the
other
administration.
(iv)
Parallel proceedings should not be initiated by
other tax administration when one of the tax
administrations has already initiated intelligencebased enforcement action.
(v)
All actions that are initiated as a measure for
probing an inquiry or gathering of evidence or
information do not constitute “proceedings”
within the meaning of section 6(2)(b) of the
CGST Act.
(vi)
The expression “initiation of any proceedings”
occurring in section 6(2)(b) refers to the
formal
commencement
of
adjudicatory
proceedings by way of issuance of a showcause notice, and does not encompass the
issuance of summons, or the conduct of any
search, or seizure, etc.
(vii) The expression “subject-matter” refers to any
tax liability, deficiency, or obligation arising
from any particular contravention which the
Department seeks to assess or recover.
(viii) Where any two proceedings initiated by the
Department seek to assess or recover an identical
or a partial overlap in the tax liability, deficiency or
obligation
arising
from
any
particular
contravention, the bar of section 6(2)(b) would be
immediately attracted.
(ix)
Where the proceedings concern distinct infractions,
the same would not constitute a “same subjectmatter” even if the tax liability, deficiency, or
obligation is same or similar, and the bar under
section 6(2)(b) would not be attracted.
(x)
The twofold test for determining whether a subjectmatter is “same” entails, first, determining if an
authority has already proceeded on an identical
liability of tax or alleged offence by the assessee on
the same facts, and secondly, if the demand or
relief sought is identical.
98. We issue the following guidelines to be followed
in cases where, after the commencement of an inquiry or
investigation by one authority, another inquiry or
investigation on the same subject-matter is initiated by a
different authority.
(a)
Where a summons or a show-cause notice is
issued by either the Central or the State tax
authority to an assessee, the assessee is, in
the first instance, obliged to comply by
appearing and furnishing the requisite
response, as the case may be. We say, so
because, mere issuance of a summons does
not enable either the issuing authority or the
recipient to ascertain that proceedings have
been initiated.
(b)
Where an assessee becomes aware that the
matter being inquired into or investigated is
already the subject of an inquiry or
investigation by another authority, the
assessee shall forthwith inform, in writing,
the
authority
that
has
initiated
the
subsequent inquiry or investigation.
(c)
Upon receipt of such intimation from the
assessee, the respective tax authorities shall
communicate with each other to verify the
veracity of the assessee's claim. We say, so as
this course of action would obviate needless
duplication of proceedings and ensure optimal
utilization of the Department's time, effort,
and resources, bearing in mind that action
initiated by one authority enures to benefit of
all.
(d)
If the claim of the taxable person regarding the
overlap of inquiries is found untenable, and the
investigations of the two authorities pertain to
different “subject-matters”, an intimation to this
effect, along with the reasons and a specification of
the distinct subject-matters, shall be immediately
conveyed in writing to the taxable person.
(e)
The taxing authorities are well within their
rights to conduct an inquiry or investigation
until it is ascertained that both authorities are
examining the identical liability to be
discharged, the same contravention alleged,
or the issuance of a show-cause notice. Any
show-cause notice issued in respect of a
liability already covered by an existing showcause notice shall be quashed.
(f)
However, if the Central or the State tax
authority, as the case may be finds that the
matter being inquired into or investigated by
it is already the subject of inquiry or
investigation by another authority, both
authorities shall decide inter se which of them
shall
continue
with
the
inquiry
or
investigation. In such a scenario the other
authority shall duly forward all material and
information relating
to
its inquiry
or
investigation into the matter to the authority
designated
to
carry
the
inquiry
or
investigation to its logical conclusion. We say,
so because, the taxable person except for
being afforded the statutory protection from
duplication of proceedings, otherwise has no
locus to claim which authority should proceed
with the inquiry or investigation in a
particular matter.
(g)
However, where the authorities are unable to reach
a decision as to which of them shall continue with
the inquiry or investigation, then in such
circumstances, the authority that first initiated the
inquiry or investigation shall be empowered to
carry it to its logical conclusion, and the courts in
such a case would be competent to pass an order
for transferring the inquiry or investigation to that
authority.
(h)
If it is found that the authorities are not complying
with these aforementioned guidelines, it shall be
open to the taxable person to file a writ petition
before the concerned High Court under article 226
of the Constitution of India.
(i)
At the same time, taxable persons shall ensure
complete cooperation with the authorities. It is
incumbent upon them to appear in response to a
summons and/or reply to a notice.”
The Apex Court considers what would be the subject matter as
obtaining under Section 6(2)(b) of the Act and holds that it is
intrinsically tied to the determination of specific violation under
scrutiny or liability alleged to be unpaid. At paragraph 98, the Apex
Court holds that when an investigation or inquiry is already pending
before the State or the Central GST authorities, both authorities
shall decide inter se which authority shall continue with the
investigation and accordingly hand over the material qua the
investigation to the designated authority. In the case at hand, after
the complaint was received, the State GST authorities have
transferred the pending investigation to the Central GST authorities.
The contention that parallel proceedings are commenced and
therefore, they should be stalled is a submission that would not
merit acceptance, in the light of the judgment of the Apex Court in
the case of ARMOUR SECURITY supra.
ISSUE NO.2:
Whether arrest of the petitioner is in violation of law
which results in obliteration of proceedings?
9. The next submission is with regard to the arrest of the
petitioner. GST investigation wing has notified certain guidelines on
13-01-2025, which is the subsisting guidelines today. It reads as
follows:
“Instruction No. 01/2025-GST
(Amendment to Instruction No. 02/2022-23 GST
(Investigation) dated 17.8.2022)
SUBJECT: GUIDELINES FOR ARREST AND BAIL IN
RELATION TO OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER THE CGST
ACT, 2017 -REG.
Please refer to Instruction No. 02/2022-23 GST (Investigation)
dated 17.8.2022 on the above subject.
Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in case of KSHITIJ GHILDIYAL
versus DIRECTOR GENERAL OF GST INTELLIGENCE, DELHI
[W.P. (CRL) No. 3770/2024], vide judgement dated 16.12.2024,
has held that the grounds of arrest have to be communicated in
writing to the arrested person. In coming to this conclusion, the
Hon'ble High Court has relied on the judgements of Hon'ble
Supreme Court the cases of Pankaj Bansal Versus Union of India
& Ors., Criminal Appeal Nos. 3051-3052 of 2023 {@ Special
Leave Petition (Crl.) Nos. 9220-21 of 2023} dated 3rd October,
2023, and PRABIR PURKAYASTHA Vs STATE (NCT OF DELHI),
CRIMINAL APPEAL (D. No. 42896/2023) Judgement dated 15th
May, 2024.
In this context it is relevant to note the distinction between
'reasons for arrest' and 'grounds of arrest' made by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of PRABIR PURKAYASTHA Vs STATE
(NCT OF DELHI), CRIMINAL APPEAL (D. No. 42896/2023). The
relevant para of the said Judgement dated 15th May, 2024,
reads as follows:
"49. It may be reiterated at the cost of repetition that there is a
significant difference in the phrase 'reasons for arrest’ and
'grounds of arrest’. The 'reasons for arrest' as indicated in the
arrest memo are purely formal parameters, viz., to prevent the
accused person from committing any further offence; for proper
investigation of the offence; to prevent the accused person from
causing the evidence of the offence to disappear or tempering
with such evidence in any manner; to prevent the arrested
person for making inducement, threat or promise to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade him from
disclosing such facts to the Court or to the Investigating Officer.
These reasons would commonly apply to any person arrested on
charge of a crime whereas the 'grounds of arrest' would be
required to contain all such details in hand of the Investigating
Officer which necessitated the arrest of the accused.
Simultaneously, the grounds of arrest informed in writing must
convey to the arrested accused all basic facts on which he was
being arrested so as to provide him an opportunity of defending
himself against custodial remand and to seek bail. Thus, the
'grounds of arrest' would invariably be personal to the accused
and cannot be equated with the ‘reasons of arrest’ which are
general in nature.
In light of the above, Para 4.2.1 of Instruction 02/2022-23 GST
(Investigation) dated 17.8.2022 is amended and may be read as
followsPara 4.2.1 - The grounds of arrest must be explained to
the arrested person and also furnished to him in writing
as an Annexure to the Arrest Memo. Acknowledgement of
the same should be taken from the arrested person at the
time of service of the Arrest Memo.”
It is in supersession or amendment to Circular dated 17-08-2022.
The specific amendment is to para-4.2.1. It mandates that the
grounds of arrest must be explained to the arrested person and also
furnished to him in writing as an annexure to the arrest memo.
Acknowledgment should be taken from the person arrested at the
time of service of arrest memo. The arrest memo is communicated
to the petitioner and such communication is quoted hereinabove. It
is acknowledged by the petitioner. Therefore, there is compliance
with law as laid down by the Apex Court considering all the earlier
judgments in the case of RADHIKA AGARWAL v. UNION OF
INDIA1. The circulars of the GST investigation wing are considered
by the Apex Court in the said judgment. The observations are as
follows:
“….
….
….
57. Sub-section (4) to Section 132, an important
provision
for
our
consideration,
states
that
notwithstanding anything in the Code, all offences under
the GST Act, except the offences referred to in subsection (5), are non-cognizable and bailable. Thus, noncognizable offences have been made bailable. Subsection (4) to Section 132 has to be read in light of the
dictum of Om Prakash [Om Prakash v. Union of India,
(2011) 14 SCC 1: (2012) 3 SCC (Cri) 1249: (2011) 11
GSTR 195] which decision the legislature was fully aware
(2025) 6 SCC 545
and conscious of when they enacted the GST Acts. This is
also clear from sub-section (5) to Section 132 which
states that the offences specified under clauses (a) to (d)
of sub-section (1) to Section 132 and punishable under
clause (i) of that sub-section are cognizable and nonbailable. Thus, only when the offence falls under the
limited categories specified in clauses (a) to (d) of subsection (1) to Section 132, and, when the amount of tax
evaded, amount of input tax credit wrongly availed or
utilised, or the amount of refund wrongly taken exceeds
Rs 500 lakhs, that the offence is non-bailable and
cognizable. At this stage, we must note the submission
made on behalf of the Revenue that in cases of bailable
and non-cognizable offences, the Central/State officers
do not make arrests. Arrests are made only when the
offence is non-bailable and cognizable, satisfying the
conditions of sub-section (5) to Section 132, as specified
in clauses (a) to (d) of sub-section (1) to Section 132 of
the CGST Act.
58. It is clear from the aforesaid provisions that, to
pass an order of arrest in case of cognizable and noncognizable
offences,
the
Commissioner
must
satisfactorily show, vide the reasons to believe recorded
by him, that the person to be arrested has committed a
non-bailable offence and that the preconditions of subsection (5) to Section 132 of the Act are satisfied. Failure
to do so would result in an illegal arrest. With regard to
the submission made on behalf of the Revenue that
arrests are not made in case of bailable offences, in our
considered view, the Commissioner, while recording the
reasons to believe should state his satisfaction and refer
to the “material” forming the basis of his finding
regarding the commission of a non-bailable offence
specified in clauses (a) to (d) of sub-section (1) to
Section 132. The computation of the tax involved in terms
of the monetary limits under clause (i) of sub-section (1),
which make the offence cognizable and non-bailable,
should be supported by referring to relevant and
sufficient material.
59. The aforesaid exercise should be undertaken in
right earnest and objectively, and not on mere ipse dixit
without foundational reasoning and material. The arrest
must proceed on the belief supported by reasons relying
on material that the conditions specified in sub-section
(5) of Section 132 are satisfied, and not on suspicion
alone. An arrest cannot be made to merely investigate
whether the conditions are being met. The arrest is to be
made on the formulation of the opinion by the
Commissioner, which is to be duly recorded in the
reasons to believe. The reasons to believe must be based
on the evidence establishing—to the satisfaction of the
Commissioner—that the requirements of sub-section (5)
to Section 132 of the CGST Act are met.
60. Our attention was drawn to the judgment of the High
Court of Delhi in MakeMyTrip (India) (P) Ltd. v. Union of
India [MakeMyTrip (India) (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, (2016) 96
VST 37: 2016 SCC OnLine Del 4951], which is a decision
interpreting the power of arrest under the Finance Act, 1994.
These provisions are related to service tax. Excise duty, service
tax, and other taxes are subsumed under the GST regime.
Accordingly, we are in agreement with the findings recorded in
this decision to the extent that the power of arrest should be
used with great circumspection and not casually. Further, as in
the case of service tax, the power of arrest is not to be used on
mere suspicion or doubt, or for even investigation, when the
conditions of sub-section (5) to Section 132 of the CGST Act are
not satisfied.
61. However,
relying
upon
the
judgment
in MakeMyTrip [MakeMyTrip (India) (P) Ltd. v. Union of India,
(2016) 96 VST 37 : 2016 SCC OnLine Del 4951] , it has been
submitted on behalf of the petitioners, that the power under
sub-section (5) to Section 132 cannot be exercised unless the
procedure under Section 73 of the CGST Act is completed and
an assessment order is passed quantifying the tax evaded or
erroneously refunded or input tax credit wrongly availed.
According to us, this contention should not be accepted as a
general or broad proposition. We would accept that normally the
assessment proceedings would quantify the amount of tax
evaded, etc. and go on to show whether there is any violation in
terms of clauses (a) to (d) to sub-section (1) of Section 132 of
the CGST Act and that clause (i) to sub-section (1) is attracted.
But there could be cases where even without a formal
order of assessment, the Department/Revenue is certain
that it is a case of offence under clauses (a) to (d) to subsection (1) of Section 132 and the amount of tax evaded,
etc. falls within clause (i) of sub-section (1) to Section
132 of the CGST Act with sufficient degree of certainty. In
such cases, the Commissioner may authorise arrest when
he is able to ascertain and record reasons to believe. As
indicated above, the reasons to believe must be explicit
and refer to the material and evidence underlying such
opinion. There has to be a degree of certainty to establish
that the offence is committed and that such offence is
non-bailable. The principle of benefit of doubt would equally be
applicable and should not be ignored either by the
Commissioner or by the Magistrate when the accused is
produced before the Magistrate.
62. The findings and the ratio recorded in paras 32 to 49
above with reference to the Customs Act would equally apply
insofar as maintenance of records as well as obligations of the
arresting officer and rights of the accused/person arrested are
concerned. Compliance in this regard must be made.
63. The Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs
(GST-Investigation Wing), has accepted the said position vide
Circular dated 17-8-2022, the relevant portion of which reads as
under:
“F. No. GST/INV/Instructions/2021-22
GST-Investigation Unit
17-8-2022
Instruction No. 02/2022-23 [GST — Investigation]
Subject:
Guidelines for arrest and bail in relation to
offence punishable under the CGST Act,
2017 — reg.
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in its judgment
dated
16-8-2021
in Siddharth v. State
of
U.P. [Siddharth v. State of U.P., (2022) 1 SCC 676:
(2022) 1 SCC (Cri) 423] , has observed as follows: (SCC
p. 682, para 10)
‘10. We may note that personal liberty is an
important aspect of our constitutional mandate. The
occasion to arrest an accused during investigation
arises when custodial investigation becomes
necessary or it is a heinous crime or where there
is a possibility of influencing the witnesses or
accused may abscond. Merely because an arrest
can be made because it is lawful does not mandate
that arrest must be made. A distinction must be
made between the existence of the power to
arrest and the justification for exercise of it
[Joginder Kumar v. State of U.P., (1994) 4 SCC
260: 1994 SCC (Cri) 1172]. If arrest is made
routine, it can cause incalculable harm to the
reputation and self-esteem of a person. If the
investigating officer has no reason to believe that
the accused will abscond or disobey summons and
has, in fact, throughout cooperated with the
investigation we fail to appreciate why there
should be a compulsion on the officer to arrest the
accused.’
***
3. Conditions precedent to arrest:
3.1. Sub-section (1) of Section 132 of the
CGST Act, 2017 deals with the punishment for
offences specified therein. Sub-section (1) of
Section 69 gives the power to the Commissioner to
arrest a person where he has reason to believe
that the alleged offender has committed any
offence specified in clause (a) or clause (b) or
clause (c) or clause (d) of sub-section (1) of
Section 132 which is punishable under clause (i)
or clause (ii) of sub-section (1), or sub-section (2)
of the Section 132 of the CGST Act, 2017.
Therefore, before placing a person under arrest,
the legal requirements must be fulfilled. The
reasons to believe to arrive at a decision to place
an alleged offender under arrest must be
unambiguous and amply clear. The reasons to
believe must be based on credible material.
3.2. Since arrest impinges on the personal
liberty of an individual, the power to arrest must
be exercised carefully. The arrest should not be
made in routine and mechanical manner. Even if
all the legal conditions precedent to arrest
mentioned in Section 132 of the CGST Act, 2017
are fulfilled, that will not, ipso facto, mean that an
arrest must be made. Once the legal ingredients of
the offence are made out, the Commissioner or the
competent authority must then determine if the
answer to any or some of the following questions
is in the affirmative:
3.2.1. Whether the person was concerned in
the non-bailable offence or credible information
has been received, or a reasonable suspicion
exists, of his having been so concerned?
3.2.2. Whether arrest is necessary to ensure
proper investigation of the offence?
3.2.3. Whether the person, if not restricted,
is likely to tamper the course of further
investigation or is likely to tamper with evidence
or intimidate or influence witnesses?
3.2.4. Whether person is mastermind or key
operator effecting proxy/benami transaction in
the name of dummy GSTIN or non-existent
persons, etc. for passing fraudulent input tax
credit, etc.?
3.2.5. As unless such person is arrested, his
presence before investigating officer cannot be
ensured.
3.3. Approval to arrest should be granted
only where the intent to evade tax or commit acts
leading to availment or utilisation of wrongful
Input Tax Credit or fraudulent refund of tax or
failure to pay amount collected as tax as specified
in sub-section (1) of Section 132 of the CGST Act,
2017, is evident and element of mens rea/guilty
mind is palpable.
3.4. Thus, the relevant factors before
deciding to arrest a person, apart from fulfilment
of the legal requirements, must be that the need
to ensure proper investigation and prevent the
possibility of
tampering
with
evidence
or
intimidating or influencing witnesses exists.
3.5. Arrest should, however, not be resorted
to in cases of technical nature i.e. where the
demand of tax is based on a difference of opinion
regarding interpretation of law. The prevalent
practice of assessment could also be one of the
determining factors while ascribing intention to
evade tax to the alleged offender. Other factors
influencing the decision to arrest could be if the
alleged offender is cooperating in the investigation
viz. compliance to summons, furnishing of
documents called for, not giving evasive replies,
voluntary payment of tax, etc.
***
64. The circular also refers to the procedure of
arrest
and
that
the
Principal
Commissioner/Commissioner has to record on the file,
after considering the nature of the offence, the role of the
person involved, the evidence available and that he has
reason to believe that the person has committed an
offence as mentioned in Section 132 of the CGST Act. The
provisions of the Code, read with Section 69(3) of the
CGST Act, relating to arrest and procedure thereof, must
be adhered to. Compliance must also be made with the
directions in D.K. Basu [D.K. Basu v. State of W.B., (1997)
1 SCC 416: 1997 SCC (Cri) 92].
64.1. The format of arrest, as prescribed by the
Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs in Circular
No. 128/47/2019-GST dated 23-12-2019, has also been
referred to in this Instruction. Therefore, the arrest
memo should indicate the relevant section(s) of the GST
Act and other laws.
64.2. In addition, the grounds of arrest must be
explained to the arrested person and noted in the arrest
memo. This instruction regarding the grounds of arrest
came to be amended by the Central Board of Indirect
Taxes and Customs (GST-Investigation Wing) vide
Instruction
No.
01/2025-GST
dated
13-1-2025
(GST/INV/Instructions/21-22). The Circular dated 13-12025 now mandates that the grounds of arrest must be
explained to the arrested person and also be furnished to
him in writing as an Annexure to the arrest memo. The
acknowledgment of the same should be taken from the
arrested person at the time of service of the arrest
memo.
64.3. Instruction
No.
02/2022-23
GST
(Investigation) dated 17-8-2022 further lays down that a
person nominated or authorised by the arrested person
should be informed immediately, and this fact must be
recorded in the arrest memo. The date and time of the
arrest should also be mentioned in the arrest memo.
Lastly, a copy of the arrest memo should be given to the
person arrested under proper acknowledgment.
64.4. The circular also makes other directions
concerning medical examination, the duty to take
reasonable care of the health and safety of the arrested
person, and the procedure of arresting a woman, etc. It
also lays down the post-arrest formalities which have to
be complied with. It further states that efforts should be
made to file a prosecution complaint under Section 132 of
the CGST Act at the earliest and preferably within 60 days
of arrest, where no bail is granted. Even otherwise, the
complaint should be filed within a definite time-frame. A
report of arrests made must be maintained and submitted
as provided in Para 6.1 of the Instruction.
64.5. The aforesaid directions in the circular/instruction
should be read along with the specific directions outlined in the
earlier judgments of this Court and the present judgment.
65. One of the assertions and allegations made on behalf
of the petitioners is that the parties are compelled and coerced
to admit and make payment of tax in view of the threat of
arrest. This is in spite of the fact that there is no assessment or
adjudication as to the alleged demand.”
(Emphasis supplied at each instance)
The arrest of the petitioner is undertaken following the guidelines
laid down by the Apex Court in RADHIKA AGARWAL supra and in
compliance with the judgment of the Apex Court in VIHAAN
KUMAR v. STATE OF HARYANA reported in (2025) 5 SCC 799.
Therefore, it cannot be said that the arrest of the petitioner is illegal
by any means. In that light, none of the grounds that are urged by
the petitioner would merit acceptance.
10. Finding no merit in this petition, the petition stands
dismissed.
Sd/(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
bkp
CT:MJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review