Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 06.02.2026
Pronounced on: 19.02.2026
+
FAO(OS) 16/2026, CM APPL. 8462/2026 & CM APPL.
8466/2026
SHRI LALIT MOHAN SHARMA
Through:
.....Appellant
Dr. Bharat Bhushan, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Sonam Priya & Mr.
Ayush Kumar Singh, Advs.
along with Appellant in person.
versus
SHRI DIVAKAR SHARMA
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. M. Dutta, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Aayush Goyal & Mr.
Aditya Guha, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE RENU BHATNAGAR
JUDGMENT
RENU BHATNAGAR, J.
1.
The present appeal is directed against the order dated
25.07.2025 (herein after referred to as ‘Impugned Order’) passed by
the learned Single Judge in I.A. No. 17718/2025 in CS(OS) No.
691/2023, whereby the application filed by the Appellant under
FAO(OS) 16/2026
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
15:00:09
Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking
modification of the order dated 20.02.2025 was dismissed.
2.
The appellant and the respondent are real brothers, being sons
of late Shri Pran Nath Sharma and late Smt. Radha Rani Sharma.
Disputes have arisen between the parties in relation to partition and
distribution of assets stated to be owned by their parents as well as
properties and assets claimed to belong to Pran Nath Sharma HUF,
which disputes are the subject matter of CS(OS) No. 691/2023
pending before learned Single Judge.
3.
During the pendency of the said suit, an order dated 20.02.2025
came to be passed by learned Single Judge to the following effect:
“1. Plaintiff and defendant are brothers and the
matter relates to distribution of the properties which
have been inherited from their deceased parents.
2. Both the parties agree that all the assets,
irrespective of the status, shall be put in a common
pot and they have agreed to divide the said assets, in
50% each, i.e. equal shares.
3. There are certain aspects relating to the existence
of the HUF (‘Hindu Undivided Family’) and the
taxation relating to the same, which is a matter of
detail and can be discussed between the parties, as
well as the counsels appearing for the parties, to
resolve.
4. The defendant appears in-person and states that
he doesn’t have the resources to engage a counsel.
5. Accordingly, Ms. Phalguni Nigam, Advocate
(Enrolment No. D/5425/2020; Ph. No. 9873122789),
who is present in Court, has been appointed as an
Amicus Curiae to assist the defendant in this regard.
6. She is at liberty to seek help of a senior member of
the Bar, in case she so requires.
FAO(OS) 16/2026
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
15:00:09
7. For the purposes of parties to achieve a
consensus regarding distribution of the properties
and the management of the estate, re-list on 20th
March 2025.
8. Order be uploaded on the website of this Court.”
4.
Thereafter, the appellant filed an affidavit dated 15.03.2025
stating that he had not agreed to any such equal division and that
disputes continued to subsist in respect of certain properties and
assets. On that basis, the appellant filed I.A. No. 17718/2025 seeking
modification of the order dated 20.02.2025, which application was
dismissed vide the Impugned Order, giving rise to the present appeal.
5.
The relevant portion of the Impugned Order is extracted below:
“1. This application has been filed by defendant
seeking modification of order dated 20th February
2025 to the extent that the defendant never agreed
that all assets, irrespective of the status, shall be put
in a common pot and have been agre3ed to be
divided in 50% each, equal shares…
…3. The Court is not inclined to allow the
application for the reason that this order was
dictated in open Court, duly signed and uploaded
soon thereafter. In fact, on the persuasion of the
Court, both the plaintiff and defendant had appeared
in person and considering it was a dispute between
brothers, an effort was made by the Court with the
assistance of the counsel, in order to resolve and
telescope the disputes. It was in this context that the
agreement of the parties was recorded in paragraph
no.2.
4. Today, defendant’s attempt to try and displace
the statement, is in the opinion of the Court, mala
fide; an attempt to retract and to displace what had
been resolved in the open Court and accordingly
recorded.
5. Attempt of plaintiff by this application (filed in
July 2025), five months after the order have been
FAO(OS) 16/2026
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
15:00:09
dictated, passed and uploaded is ex-facie specious
and unacceptable.
6. Moreover, none of the other counsels including
Mr. M. Dutta, Senior Counsel who appears for
plaintiff, who is also an Officer of the Court, states
that the said agreement between the parties was
wrongly recorded.
7. It is also noted that on 20th February 2025, the
Court appointed Ms. Phalguni Nigam, Advocate as
an Amicus Curiae for the defendant to legally assist
him in the matter. However, order dated 20th March
2025 notes that Amicus Curiae expressed her
difficulty and sought discharge from the matter. 8. In
view of the same, the application is dismissed.
9. Parties are at liberty to raise their contentions in
Suit, which is already pending before the Roster
Bench.”
6.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant submitted that on
20.02.2025, when the alleged consent order was recorded, appellant
was appearing in person before the Court and was not represented by
any counsel. It is that upon being informed by the learned Amicus
Curiae on 25.02.2025 about the contents of the order dated
20.02.2025,
the
appellant
disagreement
through
immediately
WhatsApp
messages
communicated
his
and
and
emails,
subsequently filed a sworn affidavit dated 15.03.2025 reiterating that
disputes continued to subsist in respect of the properties.
7.
It is further submitted that on the subsequent date of hearing i.e.
20.03.2025, the learned Amicus Curiae recused herself from the
matter and did not file her vakalatnama. The appellant, therefore,
continued to remain without legal assistance.
8.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent submits that
FAO(OS) 16/2026
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
15:00:09
on 15.01.2025, the learned Single Judge had recorded that the parties,
along with their respective counsels, were exploring the possibility of
settlement. It is contended that after hearing the parties, the learned
Single Judge duly recorded the agreement arrived at between them,
which culminated in the order dated 20.02.2025, and that the said
order correctly reflects the consensus between the parties. He further
submitted that the application seeking modification of the order dated
20.02.2025 was filed after a lapse of approximately four months, and
such delay clearly demonstrates the mala fide intention of the
appellant to resile from a settlement already recorded by the Court.
9.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have
carefully examined the record.
10.
The principle issue which arises for consideration is whether the
learned Single Judge has rightly dismissed the application of the
appellant in treating the said order dated 20.02.2025 as recording a
concluded settlement within the meaning of Order XXIII Rule 3 of the
CPC.
11.
It is well settled that a consent order or compromise decree
stands on a higher pedestal than an adjudicated decree, being founded
on the agreement of the parties. Such an order partakes the character
of both a contract between the parties and a command of the Court.
However, the Court’s jurisdiction to record a compromise is strictly
governed by Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC, which mandates that the
compromise must be in writing and signed by the parties. This
FAO(OS) 16/2026
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
15:00:09
requirement is mandatory and not merely procedural.
12.
The expression “in writing and signed by the parties” was
brought into the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 by the Code of Civil
Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1976 to remedy recurring disputes
regarding alleged oral or inaccurately recorded settlements. The
legislative intent was to ensure certainty, authenticity, and
voluntariness in compromises. The statutory safeguard is thus
designed to prevent precisely such controversies and cannot be diluted
as a technical formality.
13.
In the present case, the order dated 20.02.2025 records that both
parties agreed that all assets, irrespective of status, shall be placed in a
common pool and divided equally. However, no written compromise
signed by the parties was placed before the Court.
14.
Further paragraph 3 of the order dated 20.02.2025 itself
indicates that issues relating to the HUF and taxation were matters yet
to be discussed. This demonstrates that the understanding between the
parties was not fully crystallised or reduced into definitive terms.
15.
Mere recording of submissions in the order sheet, in absence of
a written and signed compromise, does not satisfy the mandatory
requirement of Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC.
16.
Even otherwise, the record reveals that the Appellant was
unrepresented at the relevant time when the order dated 20.02.2025
was recorded; that the learned Amicus Curiae did not continue to
represent him thereafter; that objections were promptly raised and
FAO(OS) 16/2026
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
15:00:09
placed on record by way of a sworn affidavit; and that no conclusive
settlement qua all the issues had been agreed upon between the
parties. In such circumstances, the refusal to examine the matter on
merits is unsustainable.
17.
Furthermore, though it is correct that the application seeking
modification of the order dated 20.02.2025 came to be filed after a
period of approximately four months, the learned Single Judge, while
dismissing the said application, did not consider the fact that the
appellant had already placed his objection on record by filing an
affidavit dated 15.03.2025. The filing of the affidavit at the earliest
available opportunity assumes significance while examining whether
the appellant had actually consented for compromise.
18.
Accordingly viewed in the given scenario, the so-called consent
recorded on 20.02.2025 cannot be elevated to the status of a concluded
settlement. The oral statement made on that date at best, can be
construed as submission made before the Court towards peaceful
resolution of their all disputes, which were subject to finalisation upon
the settlement of other controversies as reflected in Para no. 3 of the
order dated 20.02.2025 by submitting a written compromise and could
not, by themselves, bind the parties in respect of disputed rights.
19.
In our considered view, the alleged consent recorded on
20.02.2025 does not fulfil the mandatory requirements of Order XXIII
Rule 3 CPC. The learned Single Judge, therefore, erred in treating the
said order as recording a concluded settlement. The matter deserves to
FAO(OS) 16/2026
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
15:00:09
be proceeded on merits.
20.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the present appeal is
allowed and the impugned order dated 25.07.2025 is hereby set aside.
The matter is remanded to the learned Single Judge for hearing and
deciding CS(OS) No. 691/2023 on merits.
21.
The present appeal along with the pending applications stand
disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
22.
Parties to appear before the learned Single Judge on 19.03.2026.
RENU BHATNAGAR, J.
VIVEK CHAUDHARY, J.
FEBRUARY 19, 2026/ bs/my/kp
FAO(OS) 16/2026
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
15:00:09
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review