Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision: 30.01.2026
FAO 168/2025 & CM APPLs. 38121/2025, 38124/2025
SH SURENDER PAL GIRI
Through:
.....Appellant
Shri Puneet Kumar Saxena, Advocate
versus
SHRI RAJ KUMAR & ORS.
Through:
+
.....Respondents
None.
FAO 193/2025 & CM APPLs.43118/2025, 43119/2025, 43120/2025
SHRI JAGDISH GOSWAMI ALIAS JAGDISH
KUMAR GIRI
.....Appellant
Through: Shri Puneet Kumar Saxena, Advocate
versus
SHRI RAJ KUMAR & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
None.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The present appeals have been preferred against the common order
dated 28.03.2025, whereby the applications filed by the appellants under
Order IX Rule 13 CPC were dismissed. The review application filed under
Section 114 read with Section 151 CPC was also dismissed vide order dated
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
FAO 168/2025 & FAO 193/2025
Pg. 1 of 7
02.05.2025. Since common submissions have been advanced in the context of
Civil Suit No. 356/2011, titled Raj Kumar v. Om Prakash Giri, the present
appeals are taken up together for consideration and are being disposed of by
this common order.
2.
The background facts in nutshell are:
The respondents (plaintiffs in the suit) instituted a suit for recovery of
Rs.19,04,000/- along with interest. In the plaint, it was averred that the
defendants were owners in possession of land measuring 1750 sq. yards,
forming part of land admeasuring 4 bighas 19 biswas in Khasra No.98, Abadi
Village Gokalpur, Delhi, presently known as Ganga Vihar Colony
(hereinafter referred to as the “suit property”). It was pleaded that, being
desirous of purchasing the suit property, the parties entered into an agreement
dated 14.10.2007 for a total sale consideration of Rs.52.50 lakhs, pursuant to
which an aggregate amount of Rs.14 lakhs was paid by the plaintiffs to the
defendants towards advance/part consideration. It was further averred that the
defendants neither came forward to execute the sale deed nor refunded the
said amount, leading the plaintiffs to institute the suit seeking recovery of the
amount along with interest. Summons of the suit were issued and the
defendants entered appearance and filed their written statement. However,
upon their subsequent non-appearance, they were proceeded ex parte,
culminating in the passing of an ex parte judgment and decree dated
21.08.2012.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
FAO 168/2025 & FAO 193/2025
Pg. 2 of 7
3.
The appellants, arrayed as defendant nos. 3 and 4 in the suit, filed an
application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC, claiming that they were never
served with summons in the suit and, consequently, were unaware of the
passing of the ex parte judgment and decree against them. It was their case
that they acquired knowledge of the decree only upon service of process in
Execution Petition No. 33/2024. The said applications were opposed by the
respondents and, upon consideration, came to be dismissed by the Trial Court
vide the impugned order.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellants (defendant nos. 3 and 4) assailed
the impugned order contending that the Trial Court failed to appreciate that
the summons of the suit were received by Shiv Kumar Giri (defendant no. 2)
only, who was stated to be residing separately, and therefore service upon
him could not be presumed to constitute valid service upon the other
defendants. It was next contended that though a Vakalatnama came to be
filed and signed by one Mr K Kumar, Advocate, however, the defendants
were shown to be represented through one Ms Priyanka Rai, Advocate. It
was further contended that although a vakalatnama was filed in the suit, the
present appellants were neither served nor had they signed the vakalatnama
or authorised any counsel to represent them. It was argued that the written
statement was filed on behalf of the defendants through a power of attorney
holder, namely Praveen Kumar Jain, and that the present appellants had
neither executed the General Power of Attorney (GPA) dated 11.08.2010 nor
authorised the said attorney to act or file pleadings on their behalf. The
written statement had not even been signed by the present appellants, thus,
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
FAO 168/2025 & FAO 193/2025
Pg. 3 of 7
showing that the entire exercise was carried out by the plaintiffs in collusion.
It is also submitted that a complaint has also been filed on 11.07.2025 against
the plaintiffs, the said attorney and the concerned advocates, alleging
unauthorised representation. Learned counsel has also handed over a certified
copy of record of the Trial Court.
5.
A perusal of the Trial Court record reveals that the appellants, in their
application filed under Order IX Rule 13 CPC, asserted that they were never
served with summons in the suit. It was further claimed that they had neither
executed the GPA dated 11.08.2010 in favour of Praveen Kumar Jain, nor
signed any vakalatnama in favour of Mr. K. Kumar, Advocate, and had not
authorised the said Praveen Kumar Jain in any manner to represent them or
to file a written statement on their behalf.
6.
A perusal of the Trial Court record reveals that the plaint was
instituted on 16.10.2010, whereupon summons of the suit, including dasti,
were issued and made returnable on 10.11.2010. On the said date, Mr. K.
Kumar, Advocate, appeared on behalf of the defendants and time was granted
for filing the written statement. On the next date i.e., on 02.12.2010, Ms.
Priyanka Rai, Advocate, appeared for the defendants and a copy of the
written statement was supplied, whereafter time was granted to place the
power of attorney on record. On the next date, i.e., 13.12.2010, the General
Power of Attorney was produced and taken on record, and the Trial Court
proceeded to frame issues.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
FAO 168/2025 & FAO 193/2025
Pg. 4 of 7
7.
After the framing of issues, the defendants failed to appear before the
Trial Court and were ultimately proceeded ex parte. Consequently, the suit
proceeded without their participation, culminating in the passing of the ex
parte judgment and decree dated 21.08.2012.
8.
A perusal of the certified copy of the Trial Court record placed before
this Court shows that, as per the Process Server’s report, summons of the suit
were sought to be served at the address mentioned in the plaint, where the
defendants were shown to be residing. The Process Server met Shiv Kumar
Giri (defendant no. 2), who accepted service on his own behalf as well as on
behalf of the other defendants. The record further reflects that a
vakalatnama, bearing signatures purporting to be of the defendants,
including the power of attorney holder, was signed on 10.11.2010 and filed
on record, on which date Mr. K. Kumar, Advocate, appeared before the Trial
Court. On the next date of hearing, the defendants were represented through
Ms. Priyanka Rai, Advocate, and the written statement was placed on record.
Although learned counsel for the appellants contended that the written
statement was not signed by them and only signed by Praveen Kumar Jain, a
copy of the registered GPA is available on the Trial Court record, which
contains the photographs, thumb impressions and signatures of all the
defendants, including the present appellants.
9.
It is also relevant to note that the appellants have not disclosed the
specific date on which they were served in the aforesaid Execution Petition.
Further, upon a query by this Court as to whether any steps have been taken
pursuant to the criminal complaint stated to have been filed against Praveen
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
FAO 168/2025 & FAO 193/2025
Pg. 5 of 7
Kumar Jain and the concerned advocates, learned counsel fairly stated that
no further proceedings have been initiated. A perusal of the said complaint
also indicates that no specific allegation has been made therein with regard
to the forgery of the GPA.
10.
The contention of the appellants that they were never served with
summons in the suit, were unaware of the institution of the plaint, and
acquired knowledge of the proceedings only upon service of process in the
Execution Petition, does not merit acceptance. A perusal of the order dated
13.12.2010 passed by the Trial Court records the presence of defendant no. 3
in the order sheet itself. The relevant extract of the said order reads as under:
“IN THE COURT OF SH.VINOD KUMAR,
ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE-04, NORTH EAST, KKD, DELHI
CS No.127/2010
Sh. Raj Kumar
Versus
Sh. Om Parkash Giri & Ors.
13.12.2010
Present: Plaintiff with counsel Sh Shive Kr Sharma, adv.
Sh. Praveen Kumar, the Special Power of Attorney, for all the
defendants along with defendant no.2 and 3.
Sh. K. Kumar, adv. for all the defendants.
Sh. K Kumar, adv. for all the defendants submits that defendant n.1
is physically challenged person and defendant no.4 is out of station.
Therefore they could not come to the court.
Ld. Counsel for plaintiff has filed the copies of the documents along
with the list. Copies supplied.
Ld. Counsel for defendants files Special Power of Attorney and it is
taken on record.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
FAO 168/2025 & FAO 193/2025
Pg. 6 of 7
From the pleadings following issues are hereby framed:1.
Whether the signatures of the defendants were procured by the
plaintiff on blank papers on which the agreement to sell, receipt of money
etc. were written by the plaintiff?
OPD
2.
Whether the suit of the plaintiff is premature? OPD
3.
Whether the plaintiff’s suit is not maintainable in view of the fact
that the defendants have no rights to transfer the suit property?
OPD
4.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of suit amount as
prayed in the plaint?
OPD
5.
Relief.
6.
Interest.
7.
Costs.
No other issue is raised or pressed. Plaintiff shall lead evidence on
affidavit. The advance copy of the affidavit be supplied to Ld. Counsel for
defendants at his chamber.
To come up for PE on 15.1.2011.
Sd/ADJ-04/NE/KKD
13.12.2010”
11.
The aforesaid circumstance clearly belies the contentions advanced on
behalf of the appellants and demonstrates that the plea of non-service and
lack of knowledge of the suit proceedings is unsustainable. This Court,
therefore, finds no merit in the present appeals, which are accordingly
dismissed with costs of Rs.10,000/- to be deposited within 2 weeks of
uploading of this order with DSLSA.
12.
All pending applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 30, 2026
pmc
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
FAO 168/2025 & FAO 193/2025
Pg. 7 of 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review