Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 15th January, 2026
+
CEAC NO. 48/2018
SHRI HIMANSHU GUPTA
D-21, MODEL TOWN, PART-II,
DELHI-110009
Through:
.....APPELLANT
Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar,
Advocate (through VC)
Versus
THE COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE,
C.R. BUILDING, I.P. ESTATE,
NEW DELHI-110002.
....RESPONDENT
Through:
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing
Counsel
with
Mr. Jatin Kumar Gaur,
Advocate
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE, J.
1.
Heard.
2.
This appeal is under Section 35G of Central Excise Act, 1944
questioning the legality and sustainability of the final order dated 16th
January, 2018 passed by the Custom, Excise & Service Tax
Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter shall be referred to as the
‘CESTAT’).
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
3.
One Mr. Chander Kumar Gupta had a son namely Mr.
Himanshu Gupta, who is the appellant to the present appeal. Mr.
Chander Kumar Gupta was Director of M/s M.R. Tobacco Pvt. Ltd.
(hereinafter shall be referred to as ‘M/s MRTPL’) and was blessed
with three daughters also, namely, Ms. Tripti, Ms. Mahek and Ms.
Shraddha, who are married.
4.
Alleging that M/s MRTPL was setup jointly by Mr. C.K.
Gupta, former Director of M/s MRTPL with Mr. A.K. Gupta in the
year 1988, the Central Excise Registration for their factory located at
Samaypur Badli, Delhi, for manufacturing of Gutkha. It is claimed
that manufacturing of Gutkha was stopped for domestic market for
want of demand in February, 2008 and the machines were
accordingly sealed by the department. However, to continue with the
export activities, M/s MRTPL sought permission to open the seal and
operate the said machines.
5.
In the appeal, it is alleged by the appellant that his father Mr.
Chander Kumar Gupta had serious health ailments such as brainstroke, left side being paralyzed, appellant having lost his mother i.e.
wife of Mr. Chander Kumar Gupta on 1st August, 2009, same led Mr.
Chander Kumar Gupta to be bed-ridden as he also suffered from oral
cancer.
6.
During visit of officers of Central Excise Department on 11th
October, 2009 at Plot no.112, Khasra No.301, Gali no.6, Master
Mohalla, Libaspur, Delhi, it was noticed that manufacturing of
Gutkha was carried out with the help of two pouch packaging/filling
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
machines and two sealing heater plates. The officers of the
respondent-Central Excise Department on 11th October, 2009 also
visited the factory premises of M/s MRTPL, wherein all 15 packing
machines were allegedly found to be in sealed condition.
7.
One Mr. Raisuddin submitted a letter to Superintendent,
Central Excise (Anti-Evasion) on 15th December 2009 accepting the
act of manufacturing Gutkha through the unit located at 30/5, Gali
No.6, Master Mohalla, Libaspur and offered Rs.25 lakhs towards the
duty and other liability under the Central Excise Act, 1944.
8.
The said event has culminated into an investigation and a
Show Cause Notice on 7th November, 2013 was issued to M/s
MRTPL raising propose demand for alleged clearance made from
operation of the packing machines at Libaspur, Delhi referred above
and also penalty was sought to be imposed under Rule 26 of Central
Excise Rules. The clearance was alleged for the period 1st July, 2008
to October, 2009.
9.
The present appellant claimed that he sought return of non-
relied documents so also the documents relied upon by the
respondent through communication dated 18th November, 2013 and
subsequent thereto, having received the notice of personal hearing,
the appellant submitted his reply to the Show Cause Notice on 29th
July, 2014. Accordingly, the Adjudicating Authority proceeded to
confirm the demand of duty of M/s MRTPL and imposed penalty of
Rs.50 lakhs on the appellant.
10.
The appellant, feeling aggrieved, preferred an appeal before
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
the CESTAT being Appeal No.E/52156-52157/2015, which came to
be dismissed vide impugned order and as such, this appeal under
Section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
11.
The appellant has raised number of grounds in this appeal and
has submitted the written submissions.
12.
Amongst other, the question of law which the appellant has
tried to canvass area.
Whether the Commissioner, Central Excise, who has passed
the order-in-original, so also, the CESTAT erred in failing to
appreciate the very statutory mandate and opportunity
provided under Section 9D of the Central Excise Act, 1944,
thereby denying an opportunity of cross examination of the
witnesses;
b.
In absence of specific finding as regards the status of Mr.
Chander Kumar Gupta who has resigned w.e.f 15th July, 2009,
for which, Form 32 was submitted on 10th October 2009 to the
Registrar of Companies, can be held responsible for the
liability.
c.
Whether the Authorities below have failed to consider the
liability of Mr. Habibullah who was the Director of M/s
MRTPL post resignation of Mr. Chander Kumar Gupta and
who has voluntarily paid the tax dues.
13.
So as to substantiate the aforesaid questions of law, learned
counsel for the appellant has invited attention of this Court to the
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
death of Mr. Chander Kumar Gupta, the then Director, who was
seriously ailing and expired post the raid in question i.e. on 11th
October, 2009. According to him, the reply to the Show Cause
Notice, in categorical terms, demanded certain documents which
were not supplied to him, which amounts to denial of opportunity of
hearing and as such, according to him, in absence thereof, the
appellant was handicapped in submitting his detailed submission. He
would claim that the reply filed by him, so also, the demise of his
father was not at all appreciated before passing the order-in-original
as well as by the CESTAT. According to him, the Show Cause
Notice, the order-in-original so also, the order passed by the
CESTAT are wholly based on the statement of witnesses and the said
statements were never supplied to him and such witnesses whose
statements are being relied on, if are to be considered in evidence, it
is necessary to grant an opportunity of hearing to the appellant as
mandated under Section 9D of the Central Excise Act, 1944. He
would claim that there is no independent material relied on by the
respondent in the matter of imposing tax liability, penalty etc.
14.
So as to substantiate the aforesaid contention, learned counsel
for the appellant has invited attention of this Court to the contents of
the Show Cause Notice, the observations made in the order-inoriginal, the judgment of the Apex Court in the matter of Kranti
Associates Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Masood Ahmed Khan, reported in 2011
(273) E.L.T. 345 (S.C.) so as to urge that to avoid arbitrary exercise
of powers by the Authorities and the Tribunals, it is necessary that
the reasons in support of decision must be recorded which are not
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
only cogent, but also sufficient for recording the reasons in the matter
of adjudication of liability and as such, it was necessary for the
respondent to offer opportunity of hearing.
15.
In addition to above, so as to substantiate his claim that the
appellant has a statutory right of cross examination of witnesses,
support is drawn from Division Bench judgment of this Court in the
matter of Flevel International Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise
[2016 (332) E.L.T. 416 (Del.)], particularly, para 45, which reads
thus:“45. As regards the request for cross-examination of
the other witnesses, the adjudication order again
dealt with this perfunctorily. It simply stated in para
36 that if the request made by the Appellant in the
letter dated 31st January 1985 for cross-examination
of “such a large number of persons was granted it
would have take the case to a non-ending process.”
This cannot be a justified reason within the meaning
of Section 9D of the Act to deny that opportunity to
the Appellant. Further the CCE proceeds to observe
that in their reply dated 3rd February 2002 the
Appellant had somehow shortened the list of persons
it wanted to cross-examine. This is not borne out from
the reading of the reply dated 3rd February 2002.”
16.
In addition to above, learned counsel for the appellant has
drawn support from the judgment of Apex Court in the matter of J &
K Cigarettes Ltd & Others Vs. Collector of Central Excise [2009
(242) E.L.T. 189 (Del) so as to substantiate his claim that right to
cross examination cannot be denied since there are exceptional
reasons or circumstances.
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
17.
That being so, it is urged that both the orders impugned are
liable to be quashed and set-aside.
18.
As against above, Mr. Harpreet Singh, learned Senior
Standing Counsel appearing for the respondent has supported both
the orders viz. order-in-original, so also, the order passed by the
CESTAT. According to him, even if in the Show Cause Notice a
reference is made to the statement of the witnesses, it is not only that
statement of such witnesses are only relied on for passing of the
orders impugned. According to him, such statements are further
corroborated by independent evidence as could be referred from the
orders impugned including the Show Cause Notice. He would further
claim that all the witnesses whose statements were recorded are
admissible in evidence and same are since corroborated by the other
piece of evidence, the exceptional circumstances exist qua the denial
of opportunity of cross examination.
19.
Learned counsel for the respondent would urge that the
appellant is trying to take advantage of death of his mother, death of
his father post the proceedings initiated so as to evade his liability of
payment of tax, penalty etc.
20.
Learned counsel for the respondent has drawn support from
certain judgments which are as under:i.
Kanungo & Co. Versus Collector of Customs, Calcutta
& Ors [1983 (13) E.L.T. 1486 (S.C.)]
ii.
Surjeet Singh Chhabra Vs. Union of India [1997 (89)
E.L.T. 646 (S.C)
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
iii.
Union of India Vs. Rajendra Bajaj [2010 (253) E.L.T.
165 (Bom.)]
iv.
Patel Engineering Ltd. Vs. Union of India [2014 (307)
E.L.T. 862 (Bom.)]
v.
M/s Vallabh Textiles Vs. Additional Commissioner
Central Tax GST, Delhi East & Ors. [W.P.(C)
no.4576/2025 decided on 9th April, 2025]
21.
As such, dismissal of the present appeal is sought.
22.
We have considered the submissions.
23.
It is not in dispute that the Firm of which the appellant is a
Director, was in the business of manufacture of Gutkha of various
brands such as ‘Pan king’ etc.
24.
The said Firm through present appellant was prima facie found
to be in collusion with Mr. Sharad Kumar Yadav, who was
clandestinely manufacturing and removing the Pan king Brand
Gutkha from Plot no.112, Khasra No.301, Gali No.6, Master
Mohalla, Libaspur, Delhi, which was taken on rent from relative of
one Mr. Jitendra Yadav. The aforesaid act was carried out
clandestinely to avoid payment of Central Excise duty. The Gutkha
packaging/filling machines was being run illegally without filing any
declaration and without intimating the respondent, which resulted
into the Central Excise (Anti Evasion), Delhi officers carrying out a
search on 11th October, 2009. Accordingly, a Panchnama dated 11th
October, 2009 was drawn in relation to the aforesaid area viz Plot
no.112, Khasra No.301, Gali No.6, Master Mohalla, Libaspur, Delhi
and following seizures were made:Signature Not Verified
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
Sl. No. Description of seized goods
Quantity Value (in Rs.)
1.
Panking brand Gutkha
382200
3,82,200/-
(MRP Re.1/-each)
Pouches
@ Rs.1 per
pouch
2.
Ready Mix Masala
437 Kg
2,42,780/-
@
Rs.555.56 per
Kg
3.
4.
Packing Material
14,400/-
@
Printed Plastic Lamination
Rs.160/-
per
Rolls
Kg.
Gutkha Pouch Packing
90 Kg
2 Nos.
Machines
1,50,000/- @
Rs.75,000/per machine
5.
Sealing Heater Plate
2 Nos.
10,000/-
@
Rs.5,000/each
Total
7,99,380/-
Value
25.
Same has led to the recording of the statements of Mr. Jitendra
Yadav on the very same day i.e. on 11th October, 2009, Mr. Vinay,
Mr. Gunjan, Mr. Chander Kumar Gupta, Mr. Shrawan Tiwari, Mr.
Raisuddin, Mr. Ram Babu Yadav, Mr. Sharad Kumar and Mr.
Habibullah under Section 14 of the Central Excise Act, 1944, are part
of judicial proceedings within the meaning of Sections 193 and 228
of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
26.
Apart from above, the Panchnama were drawn on 11th
October, 2009 at D-21 Model Town-II, Delhi and A-6/22, Sector 16,
Rohini, Khasra No.753 Sirsapur near Hanuman Mandir, Delhi.
27.
The stock of the finished goods of Gutkha/material/packaging
material is drawn as Annexure A to the Panchnama, a video
recording of the proceedings also took place at the premises and two
machines which were engaged in the manufacturing and packaging
were seized. The statement of Mr. Jitendra Yadav speaks of that his
relative Shri. Naresh Kumar being the owner of the property at
Libaspur, Delhi has given the same on rent to one Mr. Sharad and
rent was being collected by him. He disclosed about the Gutkha
packaging work to be in operation. The statements of workers namely
Vinay and Gunjan specifically establish the said fact. A pen drive
was seized from the premises owned by Mr. Chander Kumar Gupta
at D-21, Model Town-II, Delhi so also the documents which are kept
in File A and B. The pen drive was found to be containing the
material in regard to export of Gutkha by M/s MRTPL, which was
found to be not connected with the matter in question.
28.
The appellant was found to be managing the affairs of the
company as the documents which were seized speaks so. At the
premises at A-6/22, Sector 16 Rohini, Delhi from the custody of Mr.
Sharad Kumar loose papers such as Bank Cheque Books, Income Tax
Returns and samples of Gutka were discovered. On scrutiny of said
papers, the documents containing electricity bill of the premises at
aforesaid property and other documents were also discovered,
wherein name of Mr. Himanshu Gupta, S/o Mr. Chander Kumar
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
Gupta i.e. the present appellant was found. Besides above, Mr.
Sharad Kumar Gupta was having a telephone bill, wherein address
was shown to be that of Mr. Himanshu Gupta, the appellant herein.
29.
During course of investigation at the premises of M/s MRTPL,
a mixing machine, oven and Supari cutting machine (total five in
number) were found. The oven was having high temperature and the
trays were filled with supari mixture. The material therein was seized
as Annexure 8 to the Panchnama dated 11th October, 2009 and
further enquiry led to recovery of certain incriminating documents
viz. the Memorandum of Association of M/s MRTPL, rent agreement
between M/s MRTPL and Mr. Himanshu Gupta, list of employees
containing names of Raisuddin and Habibullah.
30.
All the statistics in relation to the electricity consumption, the
summary drawn therefrom discloses that for the period from 14th
September 2009 to 22nd October 2009, the consumption was 1,466
unit, whereas preceding said period, it was only 540 units.
31.
The consumption bills at other places were also taken into
account. A comparative chart of the consumption was also drawn
based on the documents received from Energy companies.
32.
On the appreciation of above materials, the order-in-original
came to be passed, operative part of which, reads thus:“i. I determine & confirm the Central Excise
Duty of Rs. 5,87,50,000/- (Rupees Five Crores
Eighty Seven Lakhs Fifty Thousand Only)
[Duties leviable under Central Excise Act, 1944
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
amounting to Rs. 4,32,10,625/- (Rs. Four crores
thirty two lacs ten thousand six hundred twenty
five), Addl. Duty of Excise leviable under Section
85 of the Finance Act, 2005 amounting to-Rs.
51,87,625/- (Fifty one lacs eighty seven
thousand six hundred twenty five), National
Calamity Contingent Duty leviable under
Section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001 amounting
to Rs. 86,42,125/- (Eighty six lacs forty two
thousand one hundred twenty five), Education
Cess leviable under Section 91 of the Finance
Act, 2004 amounting to Rs.1l,39,750/- (Rs.
Eleven lacs thirty nine thousand seven hundred
fifty only) & Secondary & Higher Education
Cess leviable under Section 136 of the Finance
Act, 2007 amounting to Rs. 5,69,875/- totalingRs. 5,87,50,000/-)] and order recovery of the
same from M/s M. R. Tobacco Pvt. Ltd. B-14,
Gali .No. 7, Samaypur Badli, New Delhi under
proviso to sub-Section (1) of Section llA of the
Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Rule 9 of the
provisions of Pan Masala Packing Machines
(Capacity Determination and Collection of
Duty) Rules, 2008.
ii. I order recovery of interest at applicable rates
on the duty not paid and to be recovered from
M/s M. R. Tobacco Pvt. Ltd., B-14, GaIi No.7,
Samaypur Badli, Delhi as above under Section
11AB of the Central Excise Act, 1944 (now
Section 11AA);
iii. I impose penalty of Rs. 5,87,50,000/- (Rupees
Five Crores Eighty Seven Lakhs Fifty Thousand
Only) upon M/s M. R. Tobacco Pvt. Ltd., B-14,
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
Gali No.7. Samaypur Badli, Delhi under Section
11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with
Rule 17(1) of Pan Masala Packing Machines
(Capacity Determination and Collection of
Duty) Rules, 2008. If such duty as determined
under sub-section (2) of Section l1A. and the
interest payable thereon under section 11AB
(now Section 11AA), is paid within thirty days
from the date of communication of the order. The
benefit of reduced penalty of 25% shall be
available if the amount of penalty so determined
has also been paid within the period of thirty
days.
iv. I impose penalty of Rs. 50,00,000/-( Rupees
fifty lakhs only) on Shri Chander Kumar Gupta,
Director of M/s M.R. Tobacco Pvt. Ltd., B-14,
Gali No.7, Samaypur Badli, Delhi under Rule 26
of Central Excise Rules, 2002 for the reasons
stated herein above.
v. I impose penalty of Rs. 50,00,000/-( Rupees
fifty lakhs only)- Shri Himanshu Gupta S/o Shri
Chander Kumar Gupta under Rule 26 of Central
Excise Rules, 2002 for the reasons stated herein
above.
vi. I impose penalty of Rs. 50,00,000/-( Rupees
fifty lakhs only) Sh, Sharad Kumar, Labour
Contractor under Rule 26 of Central Excise
Rules, 2002 for the reasons stated herein above..
vii. I impose penalty of Rs. ,.00,000/-( Rupees
five lakhs only) Sh. Rahisuddin under Rule 26 of
Central Excise Rules, for the reasons stated
herein above.
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
viii. I impose penalty of Rs. 5,00,000/-( Rupees
five lakhs only) Shri Hazi Habibullah alias Hazi
Mullah under Rule 26 of Central Excise Rules,
2002 for the reasons stated herein above.
ix. I impose penalty of Rs. 5,00,000/-( Rupees
five lakhs only) Shri Ram Babu alias Ram Babu
Yadav under Rule 26 of Central Excise Rules,
2002 for the reasons stated herein above:
x. I impose penalty of Rs. 50,00,000/-( Rupees
fifty lakhs only) M/s R. R. Industries, Khasra No.
753, Siraspur, Near Hanuman Mandir, Delhi110042 under Rule 26 of Central Excise Rules,
2002 for the reasons stated herein above.”
33.
The order-in-original, in specific terms, deals with all these
issues. Leave apart the confessional statements, the independent
material as referred to above is also taken into account by the
Authority while passing the order-in-original. The seizure of
packaging material and the ready mixture gutkha valued
Rs.7,99,380/-, total value of other material being Rs.26,82,654/-, the
independent stand of the appellant to the Show Cause Notice, the
stand of the appellant that appellant and his father Mr. Chander
Kumar Gupta were in the manufacture of Pan Masala, seizure of
packaging machines, voluntarily payment of tax by employee of the
appellant, had led to the only inference that manufacturing operation
was being carried out without registration. Consumption of energy as
certified by NDPL in view of illegal operation of machines by M/s
MRTPL from 14th August 2008 demonstrate that the appellant was
in the business of manufacturing of excisable goods without
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
obtaining Central Excise registration.
34.
On the issue of cross examination and the statutory right of the
appellant, it has been specifically observed that the statements of the
workers/employees, and co-noticee were recorded which are having
monetary interest in operation of illegal business and as such, are not
expected to support the case of the respondent. It was not that the
denial of cross examination is immaterial as apart from the
statements recorded, there is independent material to corroborate the
very charge against the appellant. Even otherwise, it was noticed that
the co-noticee and the employee are directly connected with the
appellant and as such, are not expected to take stand of appellant in
the cross examination.
35.
A similar view, upon appreciation, is expressed by the
CESTAT in its order.
36.
Though learned counsel for the appellant so as to substantiate
his right of statutory right of cross examination of witnesses has
relied on the judgment of CESTAT in the matter of M/s Surya Wires
Pvt Ltd. Vs. Principal Commissioner, CGST Raipur [Excise Appeal
No.51148 of 2020] decided on 1st April, 2025 by Principal Court No1, New Delhi with connected matter, we are equally required to be
sensitive to the fact that the said judgment of the CESTAT was
delivered in the facts and circumstances of the said case.
37.
The appellant has specifically relied on the judgments of Apex
Court in the matter of Kranti Associates Pvt. (referred above) and J
& K Cigarettes Ltd & Others (referred above), so also on the
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
Division Bench judgment of this Court in the matter of Flevel
International (referred above).
38.
In the matter of Flevel International (referred above), this
Court has observed that serious attempts were not made to secure the
presence of witnesses in the adjudication proceedings. It appears that
in the said case, summons were issued to the witnesses upon
satisfaction that opportunity of cross-examination has to be afforded
to the party therein.
39.
It is not that the party has no right of cross-examination of
witnesses, however, same depends on the facts and circumstances of
each case as in the given convincing circumstances, the right of cross
examination can be denied.
40.
In the case in hand, it is specifically noted that co-noticee and
the employee are related to the appellant having common financial
interest either in the form of employer-employee or that of the blood
relation. In such an eventuality, it is not expected that the witnesses
will dare to depose against the appellant.
41.
The Apex Court in the matter of Kanungo & Co. Vs. Collector
of Customs, Calcutta & Others [1983 (13) E.L.T 1486 (S.C)] had
made following observations:“12. We may first deal with the question of breach of
natural justice. On the material on record, in our
opinion, there has been no such breach. In the showcause notice issued on August 21, 1961, all the
material on which the Customs Authorities have relied
was set out and it was then for the appellant to give a
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
suitable explanation. The complaint of the appellant
now is that all the persons from whom enquiries were
alleged to have been made by the authorities should
have been produced to enable it to cross-examine them.
In our opinion, the principles of natural justice do not
require that in matters like this the persons who have
given information should be examined in the presence
of the appellant or should be allowed to be crossexamined by them on the statements made before the
Customs Authorities. Accordingly we hold that there is
no force in the third contention of the appellant.”
42.
In Surjeet Singh Chhabra Vs. Union of India [1997 (89)
E.L.T. 646 (SC)], the Apex Court observed as under:“3. It is true that the petitioner had confessed that he
purchased the gold and had brought it. He admitted
that he purchased the gold and converted it as a kara.
In this situation, bringing the gold without permission
of the authority is in contravention of the Customs Duty
Act and also FERA. When the petitioner seeks for
cross-examination of the witnesses who have said that
the recovery was made from the petitioner, necessarily
an opportunity requires to be given for the crossexamination of the witnesses as regards the place at
which recovery was made. Since the dispute concerns
the confiscation of the jewellery, whether at conveyor
belt or at the green channel, perhaps the witnesses
were required to be called. But in view of confession
made by him, it binds him and, therefore, in the facts
and circumstances of this case the failure to give him
the opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses is not
violative of principle of natural justice. It is contended
that the petitioner had retracted within six days from
the confession. Therefore, he is entitled to crossexamine the panch witnesses before the authority takes
a decision on proof of the offence. We find no force in
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
this contention. The customs officials are not police
officers. The confession, though retracted, is an
admission and binds the petitioner. So there is no need
to call panch witnesses for examination and crossexamination by the petitioner.”
43.
In Patel Engineering Ltd. Vs. Union of India [2014 (307)
E.L.T. 862 (Bom.)], the High Court of Bombay observed as under:“21. Thus, the consistent view is that may be and only
in case of want of Notice to the affected party in all
other cases it is not enough to allege breach of
principles of natural justice but also demonstrate that
prejudice is caused by such breach. This is for the
simple reason that any departure or every breach does
not necessarily result in miscarriage of justice or gross
failure of justice. Further, the principles of natural
justice are not a strait-jacket formula. Which
principles of natural justice or which facet of the same
is applicable, depends upon the nature of the lis, the
statute under which an adjudication is undertaken and
several other factors. This has been now firmly
established in the decision of Bar Council of
India v. High Court of Kerala reported in (2004) 6
SCC 311 : AIR 2004 SC 2227. In that case, in the SCC
report, this is what is held:—
49. In N.K. Prasada v. Govt. of India [(2004) 6 SCC
299] this Court observed : (SCC p. 308, paras 2425)
“24. The principles of natural justice, it is well
settled, cannot be put into a straitjacket formula. Its
application will depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case. It is also well settled
that if a party after having proper notice chose not
to appear, he at a later stage cannot be permitted to
say that he had not been given a fair opportunity of
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
hearing. The question had been considered by a
Bench of this Court in Sohan Lal Gupta v. Asha
Devi Gupta [(2003) 7 SCC 492] of which two of us
(V.N. Khare, C.J. and Sinha, J.) are parties wherein
upon noticing a large number of decisions it was
held : (SCC p. 506, para 29)
‘29. The principles of natural justice, it is trite,
cannot be put in a straitjacket formula. In a given
case the party should not only be required to show
that he did not have a proper notice resulting in
violation of principles of natural justice but also to
show that he was seriously prejudiced thereby.’
25. The principles of natural justice, it is well
settled, must not be stretched too far.”
(See also Mardia Chemicals Ltd. v. Union of
India [(2004) 4 SCC 311 : (2004) 4 Scale 338]
and Canara Bank v. Debasis Das [(2003) 4 SCC
557 : 2003 SCC (L&S) 507].)
50. In Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel [(1985) 3
SCC 398 : 1985 SCC (L&S) 672] whereupon
reliance has been placed by Mr Reddy, this Court
held : (SCC p. 477, para 97)
“97. Though the two rules of natural justice,
namely, nemo judex in causa sua and audi alteram
partem, have now a definite meaning and
connotation in law and their content and
implications are well understood and firmly
established, they are nonetheless not statutory rules.
Each of these rules yields to and changes with the
exigencies of different situations. They do not apply
in the same manner to situations which are not alike.
These rules are not cast in a rigid mould nor can
they be put in a legal straitjacket. They are not
immutable but flexible. These rules can be adapted
and modified by statutes and statutory rules and also
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
by the constitution of the Tribunal which has to
decide a particular matter and the rules by which
such Tribunal is governed.”
22. xxxxxxxxxxxx
23. Therefore, we are of the opinion that it will not be
correct to hold that irrespective of the facts and
circumstances and in all inquiries, the right of cross
examination can be asserted. Further, as held above
which rule or principle of natural justice must be
applied and followed depends upon several factors and
as enumerated above. Even if there is denial of the
request to cross examine the witnesses in a inquiry,
without anything more, by such denial alone, it will not
be enough to conclude that principles of natural justice
have been violated. Therefore, the judgments relied
upon by Shri Kantawala must be seen in the factual
backdrop and peculiar circumstances of the assessee's
case before this Court.”
44.
In the matter of M/s Vallabh Textiles Vs. Additional
Commissioner Central Tax GST, Delhi East & Ors [W.P. (C)
4576/2025 decided on 9th April, 2025], this Court observed as under:“15. While cross-examination can be granted in
certain proceedings, if it is deemed appropriate, the
right to cross-examine cannot be an unfettered right.
This has been so held recently by this Court in Sushil
Aggarwal v. Principal Commissioner Of Customs
(2025:DHC:698-DB). The relevant portion of the
decision reads as under:
“15. Accordingly, this Court is of the opinion that in
order to ensure that there is compliance of Section
138(B) of the Act, though the same cannot be
claimed as an unfettered right in all cases, in the
facts of the present case, both Mr. Sushil Aggarwal
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
and Mr. Aidasani are afforded an opportunity to
cross examine Mr. Bhalla.”
45.
Apart from above, it is not the case of the appellant that each
of the witnesses whose statements are relied on, have retracted the
same. At least, no material to that effect is placed on record by the
appellant. That being so, the denial of cross examination can be said
to be justified and appropriate, for which, reliance can be placed on
the judgments in the matter of Commissioner of Customs Excise,
Mumbai Vs. Kalvert Foods India Pvt. Ltd. [2011 (270) E.L.T 643
(S.C.)] and Sushil Aggarwal Vs. Principal Commissioner of
Customs [2025: DHC:698-DB].
46.
In wake of above, it is apparent that the entire proceedings
against the appellant are based on un-retracted statements of the
witnesses, corroborative evidence in the form of recovery of material,
energy details, employment related documents and rental agreements
etc.
47.
In wake of above, it cannot be said that while passing the
orders impugned, the respondent had failed to understand or consider
the very object of Section 9D of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and has
illegally denied the opportunity of cross-examination of the
witnesses.
48.
For the aforesaid reasons, in our opinion, the questions of law
which are sought to be canvassed, cannot be answered in favour of
the appellant. Rather, we are of the view that there is no question of
law involved.
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
49.
As such, the appeal stands dismissed.
50.
Pending application, if any, also stand disposed of
51.
A copy of this Judgment be uploaded on the website of this
Court.
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
(JUDGE)
AJAY DIGPAUL
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 15, 2026/ay/ok
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:48:59
CEAC No.48/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review