Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
RegularList
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 39 of 2012
Date of Decision: 09.02.2021
Shri Gonoth Manda Sangma Vs.
& Anr.
Smti Dewin Gabil Momin & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Biswanath Somadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s):
Mr. R. Kar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. K. Paul, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Per. H.S. Thangkhiew, (J):
1.
The instant appeal has been preferred against the judgment
& order dated 29.11.2010 passed in WP(C) No. 389 (SH) of 2004,
whereby
the
learned
Single
Judge
allowed
the
writ petition of the respondents, by quashing and setting aside the
order dated 18.02.1985 passed by the Executive Member, GHADC and
orders dated and 09.02.1999 and 30.08.2004 of the Chief Executive
Member, GHADC. The grievance of the writ petitioner is that by the
order impugned herein, the operation of the office of Nokma, of
Sasatgiri Akhing as per the Garo customary practice, has been
disrupted irreparably. Hence the appeal.
WA No. 39 of 2012
2.
Mr. R. Kar, learned counsel for the appellant submits that
the Akhing in question namely; Sasatgiri Akhing is one of the oldest
recorded Akhings in the Garo Hills, and that the respondents herein
were given only a limited right over the Nokmaship of the said
Akhing; which he contends, was subject to orders dated 04.08.1947
and 20.10.1952, passed by the then Deputy Commissioners of Garo
Hills, wherein the said matter at an earlier point, had been adjudicated.
Learned counsel submits though adjudicated, the matter had not
attained finality and a challenge to, or modification of these orders was
not barred by the principles or resjudicata, inasmuch as, the same were
conditional orders, subject to future eventualities. Mr. R. Kar, seeks to
defend the order dated 18.02.1985 passed by the Executive Member,
GHADC in GDC Rev. No. 88 of 1984-85 and orders dated 09.02.1999
and 30.08.2004, passed by the Chief Executive Member, GHADC in
appeal and review, by maintaining that the same were not bad in law,
nor barred by the principles of resjudicata, but in fact were passed in
accordance with, and by the application of prevalent Garo customary
law. Learned counsel therefore prays that the impugned judgment and
order dated 29.11.2010 having failed to consider the matter in its
proper perspective be set aside and quashed.
3.
Mr. K. Paul, learned counsel for the respondents in his
brief submissions submits that the issue of Nokmaship of the
respondent No.1, could not have been revisited, at the instance of the
writ appellants, in view of the orders dated 04.08.1947 and 20.10.1952.
He submits that the orders stood unchallenged for decades and that, the
eventuality that the learned counsel for the appellants had alluded to,
WA No. 39 of 2012
such as the desertion of the respondent No. 1 from the Akhing, or her
failure to have female issues which would have prevented her from
Nokmaship were totally absent. He submits that admittedly and as
evidenced by a judicial proceeding, the respondent No. 1 never
deserted the Akhing and admittedly further she has two daughters. In
fact, one of them has been arrayed as respondent No. 4 by the writ
appellants themselves. He submits that the orders dated 04.08.1947
and 20.10.1952 having attained finality, there was no scope for the
Executive Member and Chief Executive Member, GHADC, to have
engaged in the exercise of overhauling and disrupting a settled
position. As such, he prays that the writ appeal be dismissed.
4.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties, and
perused the judgment in question. The learned Single Judge, it is seen,
has painstakingly dwelt on the matter in-depth, and examined all the
points in issue, both on facts and law, and as such, without further
again elaborating or recounting all the facts and details, this appeal is
being examined on a narrow compass, which basically stems from the
interpretation of the two orders, dated 04.08.1947, and 20.10.1952,
which for the sake of convenience, are reproduced herein below.
“4.8.47
The Mauzadar Laskar and parties have appeared, I have
heard their views. In view of the circumstances Dewin
Momin Mechik is appointed a Nokma in place of
Thache Mechik.
Should Dewin deserts from household or
has no female issue Jeng Momin will succeed her.
Sd/- A. Ahmed
Dt. 4.8.47
WA No. 39 of 2012
Rev. Case No. 13 A.C. of 1952-53
Appointment of Nokma of Sasatgiri III-32 (13) 20/10/52:Seen Mauzadar’s report. Phanna Marak, Laskar present
with 20 Maharis all of whom agree that in place of
Khimrang Nokma deceased his Nokkrom Khijing should
be appointed as Nokma.
Enter his name in the G.T. accordingly (with Dewin
Momin) Khijing’s wife Jeng Momin cannot be appointed
Nokma as long as Dewin Momin is alive.
Sd/- G.S. Izer,
20/10/52
5.
There is no dispute whatsoever that the respondent No. 1
(writ petitioner) Smti Dewin Gabil Momin, who has since deceased,
referred to in both the aforementioned orders, was holding the office of
the Nokma of Sasatgiri Akhing. The purport of the first order dated
04.08.1947 on a plain reading is, should the respondent No. 1, desert
the household or have no female issue, the predecessor in interest of
the appellants i.e. Smti Jeng Momin would succeed to the office of
Nokma. It has been conclusively observed in the order of the learned
Single Judge that this order was never put to challenge by any
interested party at that point of time. It may be mentioned herein that
Smti Jeng Momin was the earlier wife of one Khijing Sangma, who
had been accepted by the respondent No. 1, as a substituted husband,
which is in accordance and in conformity with Garo Customary law.
Coming to the second order in question, i.e. order dated 20.10.1952,
whereby it has been held that the said Jeng Momin could not be
appointed Nokma as long as the Respondent No. 1 was alive, the
Learned Single judge had also returned a finding that the aforesaid
order had also attained finality as there was no challenge to the same
by any party and that it was only in 1984 on the demise of Khijing
Sangma that the said Jeng Momin started agitating to oust the
WA No. 39 of 2012
respondent No. 1 from office. Smti Jeng Momin it seems, is also
incidentally the mother-in-law of Gonoth Manda Sangma (writ
appellant No. 1) and as evidenced by the proceedings before the
Judicial Officer Magistrate First Class, Garo Hills District Council,
Tura, in Misc. Case No. 1 of 84, and recorded in an order dated
21.12.1991, the writ appellant No. 1, had physically assaulted the
respondent No. 1 with the intent to cause harm and to oust the
respondent No. 1 from office. As noted by the learned Single Judge,
the writ appellants pursued their objective of trying to attain their goal
of Nokmaship by filing a case before the Executive Member, GHADC.
This initial proceeding resulted in the order dated 18.02.1985, whereby
the Executive Member, GHADC, by disregarding the orders dated
04.08.1947 and 20.10.1952, reopened the matter and appointed the
writ appellants No. 1 & 2 as Nokmas. The learned Single Judge had
observed the perversity in the finding of the order of the Executive
Member, and held that it amounted to sitting in appeal over the orders
dated 04.08.1947 and 20.10.1952.
6.
On an appeal by the respondents, the aforementioned order
dated 18.02.1985, thereafter was followed by the other orders dated
09.02.1999 and 30.08.2004, which were passed by the Chief Executive
Member, GHADC, in the appeal and subsequently, in review. The
appellate order however, allowed the writ appellant No. 1 to continue
as Nokma, along with the respondent No. 1, but also held that after the
death of respondent No. 1, the writ appellant No. 2 would succeed into
the office. As observed by the learned Single Judge, the only question
that arose is whether such findings recorded by the appellate authority
WA No. 39 of 2012
were perverse and opposed to the orders passed in 1947 and 1952. As
observed and noted, the two conditions imposed, which would bar or
disentitle the respondent No. 1 from holding the office or continuing as
Nokma were; if she deserted the household and, if she did not have any
female issue. The second order of 1952, which further imposed the
condition that Jeng Momin would not be entitled to get Nokmaship as
long as the respondent No. 1 (Dewin) was alive, is a continuation and
the culmination of the same adjudication, and thus the order
necessarily has to be read in conjunction with the order of 1947. The
conditions as stated have conclusively been found to be nonexistent,
after a detailed analysis of the entire facts and circumstances,
surrounding the entire issue, by the learned Single Judge.
7.
We are in full agreement with the findings that the claim of
Jeng Momin (predecessor in interest of the writ appellants) being
rejected as far back as in 1947 and 1952, the same could not have been
reopened by the Executive Member, GHADC nor could the appellate
authority (CEM) have held that the respondent No. 1 had only a
limited right from Nokmaship confined to her life time. As such, no
case can be said to have been made out to warrant any interference or
afford any other possible opinion.
8.
For reasons stated above, there being no palpable
infirmity in the judgment of the learned Single Judge, the Intra-Court
Mandamous Appeal is liable to be dismissed and stands accordingly
dismissed.
9.
Before parting with the records it has to be put on record
that the writ appellant No.1 (Gonoth Manda Sangma) and Respondent
WA No. 39 of 2012
No 1 (Dewin Gabil Momin) have since deceased during the pendency
of the instant writ appeal, and have been stuck off from the array of
parties by our order dated 04.02.2021. However the same would have
no bearing on the outcome of this appeal inasmuch as their successors
in interest are already on record and are party to the instant
proceedings.
(H.S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
09.02.2021
“V. Lyndem PS”
WA No. 39 of 2012
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review