Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 29th July, 2026
%
+
W.P.(C) 7282/2014 & CM APPL. 17058/2014
SHRI DURGA ENGINEERING
WORKS THR ITS PROPRIETOR
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Nishtha Chawla, Advocate.
versus
SOMNATH PANDEY
Through:
%
.....Respondent
Mr. Rajat Sharma, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
ORDER
29.07.2026
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
The present petition is filed under Article 226/227 of the
Constitution of India assailing award dated 03.06.2014 (hereinafter
‘impugned award’) passed by the learned Labour Court awarding the
respondent reinstatement with full back wages, continuity of service
and other consequential benefits.
2.
Briefly stated, the respondent was working with the petitioner
as a ‘helper’/ ‘machine man’. On 25.10.2009, while operating a kharad
machine, the workman/respondent allegedly suffered serious injuries
when a piece of iron broke and fell on him during the course of his
employment. The workman was initially taken to ESI Hospital,
thereafter shifted to DDU Hospital and finally to Safdarjung Hospital.
After being discharged from the hospital, the workman remained on
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
medical leave as advised by the doctors. Upon being declared fit, he
reported for duty on 07.04.2010 but was allegedly refused employment
and informed that his services had already come to an end with effect
from 26.10.2009. It is the case of the petitioner that the respondent
wilfully abandoned his job and did not join back despite the petitioner
sending various letters from November to December 2009 asking the
respondent to join duty, otherwise his services would be deemed to have
been abandoned.
3.
The workman issued a demand notice to the petitioner seeking
reinstatement with full back wages. Although the management replied
to the notice, it did not reinstate him. Thereafter, the respondent raised
an industrial dispute against the petitioner, which was referred to the
learned Labour Court.
4.
The learned Labour Court framed issues regarding (i) whether
the services of the workman had been illegally and/or unjustifiably
terminated, (ii) whether the workman had voluntarily absented himself
from duty, and (iii) the relief to which he was entitled.
5.
The learned Labour Court noted that the petitioner failed to
establish voluntary abandonment, as the workman had remained on
medical leave following the admitted workplace accident and the
alleged letters calling upon him to resume duty were not proved to have
been served. It was also found that no charge-sheet, domestic enquiry,
notice of termination, notice pay, or retrenchment compensation under
Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act had been provided before
terminating the workman's services.
6.
Consequently, the Labour Court held that the termination was
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
illegal and directed reinstatement of the workman with continuity of
service, full back wages, and all consequential benefits.
7.
Aggrieved thereby, the present petition has been filed.
8.
This Court vide order dated 10.11.2014 stayed the operation of
the impugned award qua the back wages awarded to the respondent.
Further, this Court vide order dated 10.08.2016 noted that the
respondent was offered reinstatement by the petitioner, however he
denied the same as he was already employed elsewhere. Thus, the issue
to be considered in the present petition is only in regard to the legality
of termination and compensation, if any, since the respondent is not
claiming reinstatement.
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
Labour Court gravely erred in holding that the Respondent had not
abandoned his employment.
10.
She submits that the respondent initially joined the services of
the petitioner as a helper on 28.07.2006. However, he voluntarily
abandoned his employment on 28.02.2007. Thereafter, upon the
respondent requesting the management for re-employment, he was
engaged afresh with effect from 01.08.2009. She submits that the
respondent was habitually irregular in attending duties and had a
consistent practice of remaining absent from work for months together
on the pretext of visiting his native village. She submits that the learned
Labour Court failed to appreciate this consistent pattern of conduct
while determining the issue of abandonment.
11.
She submits that the learned Labour Court failed to appreciate
that the respondent failed to join back duty even after he was declared
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
medically fit. She submits that several letters were issued to the
Respondent, duly dispatched through post, requiring him to report for
duty and specifically informing him that failure to do so would result in
his services being treated as having come to an end. She submits that
despite receipt of such communications, the respondent neither resumed
duties nor furnished any satisfactory explanation, thereby clearly
demonstrating his intention to abandon employment.
12.
She submits that the direction of the learned Labour Court
reinstating the respondent with full back wages is wholly unjustified in
the facts of the present case.
13.
She submits that after the impugned award was passed on
03.06.2014, the petitioner discovered that the respondent had been
working as a Security Guard with M/s Tiger 4 Security & Detective
India Pvt. Ltd. for nearly three years. She submits that during the
proceedings before this Court, the respondent, through his counsel,
admitted his employment with the said establishment, and such
admission was duly recorded in the order dated 10.08.2016.
14.
The learned counsel for the respondent vehemently opposes the
present petition and submits that the learned Labour Court has rightly
appreciated the evidence on record and returned well-reasoned findings
warranting no interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.
15.
He submits that the respondent never abandoned his service. He
submits that on 25.10.2009, while performing his duties, the respondent
sustained injuries in an accident at the workplace, a fact admittedly
known to the management. He submits that the respondent remained
under medical treatment and bed rest as advised by the doctors and,
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
upon being declared fit, reported for duty on 07.04.2010. However, the
management refused to permit him to resume duties and orally
terminated his services.
16.
He submits that the management's plea of abandonment is
unsupported by evidence. He submits that although reliance was placed
on certain letters allegedly calling upon the respondent to rejoin duty,
the management failed to establish their service. He submits that the
letters were not sent by registered post, no proof of delivery was
produced, and the respondent was never confronted with the said letters
during his cross-examination.
17.
He submits that the medical documents placed on record
establish that the respondent remained under treatment during the
relevant period. He submits that the management did not dispute the
accident or cross-examine the Respondent regarding his medical
condition or the period of prescribed rest.
18.
He further submits that the management admittedly did not issue
any charge-sheet, conduct any domestic enquiry, or comply with the
mandatory requirements of Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act
before terminating the respondent's services. He submits that the
learned Labour Court, therefore, rightly held the termination to be
illegal.
19.
I have heard the counsel and perused the record.
20.
At the outset, it is necessary to note that the scope of interference
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India with an Award
passed by the Labour Court is limited. This Court does not sit as a Court
of appeal over findings of fact rendered by the Labour Court.
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
Interference is warranted only where the findings are perverse, based
on no evidence, suffer from patent illegality, or disclose a jurisdictional
error. Reference in this regard may be made to the judgment in
International Airport Authority of India v. International Air Cargo
Workers Union : (2009) 13 SCC 374 where the Hon’ble Apex Court
held as under:
47. It is true that in exercising the writ jurisdiction, the High Court
cannot sit in appeal over the findings and award of the Industrial
Tribunal and therefore, cannot reappreciate evidence. The findings
of fact recorded by a fact-finding authority should ordinarily be
considered as final. The findings of the Tribunal should not be
interfered with in writ jurisdiction merely on the ground that the
material on which the Tribunal had acted was insufficient or not
credible.
48. It is also true that as long as the findings of fact are based on
some materials which are relevant, findings may not be interfered
with merely because another view is also possible. But where the
Tribunal records findings on no evidence or irrelevant evidence, it
is certainly open to the High Court to interfere with the award of the
Industrial Tribunal.
21.
Adverting to the merits of the present case, it is the case of the
petitioner that the respondent had voluntarily abandoned his
employment and that the learned Labour Court failed to appreciate that
his prolonged and frequent absenteeism constituted abandonment of
service. This contention does not merit acceptance.
22.
The learned Labour Court examined the management's plea that
the respondent had abandoned his services on 28.02.2007 and was
subsequently re-employed on 01.08.2009. Upon appreciation of the
evidence, it was rightly noted that the management had failed to
produce any resignation letter, full and final settlement, or any
contemporaneous record evidencing cessation of service. It was further
noted that the management had admittedly issued only one appointment
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
letter and one ESI Card to the respondent, and there was no material to
show that his name had ever been struck off the rolls or that his ESI
registration had been cancelled. The learned Labour Court, therefore,
rightly concluded that the plea of abandonment in 2007 was
unsupported by the record and that the Respondent's service was
continuous from 25.10.2006 till 07.04.2010.
23.
It is further the petitioner's case that several letters were
dispatched to the respondent requiring him to resume duties, failing
which his services would be deemed to have come to an end, and that
the learned Labour Court erred in ignoring the same. This submission
is equally unpersuasive. The learned Labour Court specifically
examined the said letters and rightly found that they had merely been
sent through UPC without any explanation as to why they were not
dispatched by registered post. The Labour Court also noted that the
respondent was never confronted with these letters during his crossexamination. In these circumstances, the Labour Court rightly declined
to place reliance upon the said documents for drawing an inference of
abandonment.
24.
The petitioner further contends that the respondent failed to
report for duty even after the expiry of the prescribed period of medical
rest and that the accident itself had occurred due to the respondent's own
negligence. This contention was also duly considered by the learned
Labour Court. It was rightly noted that the occurrence of the accident
dated 25.10.2009 was admitted by both parties. The respondent had
placed on record medical documents evidencing his treatment and the
period of bed rest advised by the doctors. Significantly, the petitioner
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
neither effectively challenged the medical documents nor crossexamined the respondent on the duration of his treatment. The learned
Labour Court also noticed that the ESI contribution records produced
by the management itself reflected the respondent to be on leave during
the relevant period. In view thereof, the finding that the Respondent
could not be treated as having remained unauthorisedly absent or
having abandoned his service cannot be faulted.
25.
Having rightly held that the respondent had neither abandoned
his service nor remained unauthorisedly absent, the learned Labour
Court rightly concluded that the termination was illegal. The
management admittedly neither issued a charge-sheet nor conducted a
domestic enquiry, and further failed to comply with the mandatory
requirements of Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act by not
issuing any notice of termination, notice pay or retrenchment
compensation. In these circumstances, the finding that the Respondent's
termination was illegal warrants no interference.
26.
Having upheld the finding of illegal termination, the next issue
that arises for consideration is the nature and extent of relief to be
granted to the respondent. It is a matter of record that the petitioner had
offered reinstatement to the respondent. However, the respondent is
stated to be gainfully employed elsewhere. Thus, the same cannot be
granted to the respondent.
27.
At the same time, no material has been placed on record by the
respondent to establish the date from which such employment was
secured. In the absence of any evidence demonstrating that the
respondent was not gainfully employed throughout the period from the
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
date of termination, grant of back wages for the entire period would not
be justified.
28.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Allahabad Bank v. Krishan Pal
Singh : (2021) 19 SCC 227, has held that reinstatement with full back
wages is not automatic in every case where termination or dismissal is
found to be not in accordance with the procedure prescribed under law
and that the relief can be moulded depending upon the facts and
circumstances of the case.
29.
In the opinion of this Court, in the facts and circumstances of the
present case, ends of justice will be met if the respondent is awarded a
lump-sum compensation of ₹2,00,000/-. The said amount shall be paid
by the Petitioner within a period of eight weeks from the date of this
order.
30.
The present petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
31.
Pending applications also stand disposed of.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
JULY 29, 2026
DU
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 7282/2014
KAUR
17:08:49
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review