Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 18422/2025 and CM APPL. 76281/2025
Date of Decision: 20.02.2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
SHREE CEMENT LIMITED
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Satvinder Singh with Mr. Yash
Chopra, Mr. Gagandeep Singh & Mr.
Piyush Singh, Advocates.
versus
UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF COAL THROUGH ITS
SECRETARY & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sandeep Kumar Mahapatra,
CGSC with Ms. Mrinmayee Sahu,
Mr. Tribhuvan, Mr. Abhimanyu and
Ms. Anushka Sarraf, Advs. for R1
and R2.
Mr. Jayant Mehta, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Rohan Talwar, Ms. Sanjivani
Pattjoshi, Mr. Nilay Gupta & Mr.
Uday Aditya Jetley Pocha, Advocates
for R3.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
JUDGEMENT
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J. (ORAL)
1.
The present writ petition arises out of a dispute concerning the Datima
Coal Mine, situated in District Surajpur, Chhattisgarh. The said mine was
Signed By:PRIYA
19:27:57
W.P.(C) 18422/2025
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
originally allotted to M/s. Binani Cement Limited (“Binani Cement” or
“the Prior Allottee”). Pursuant to the judgment of the Supreme Court in
Manohar Lal Sharma & Ors. v. The Principal Secretary & Ors.1, the
allotment of the Datima Coal Mine, along with a large number of other coal
block allocations made by the Central Government between 1993 and 2011
through non-competitive, Screening Committee-based routes, was declared
arbitrary, illegal, and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution, and
accordingly, was cancelled. It is pertinent to note that in the subsequent
order dated 24.09.2014, the Supreme Court gave effect to such cancellations
and imposed compensatory levies, paving the way for fresh auction of the
cancelled coal blocks through the Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015
(“the Act”).
2.
Respondent No. 3, M/s. UltraTech Cement Limited (“UltraTech”),
claims to have stepped into the shoes of M/s. Binani Cement Limited as the
Prior Allottee by virtue of its status as the Successful Resolution Applicant
under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“IBC”). The NCLAT had
approved UltraTech’s resolution plan for the acquisition of Binani Cement, a
decision subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court vide its order dated
19.11.2018. Upon implementation of the approved resolution plan, Binani
Cement Limited stood effectively merged with and succeeded by Ultra
Tech, and accordingly, the latter claims all rights, entitlements, and interest
that Binani Cement held as the Prior Allottee in relation to the Datima Coal
Mine.
3.
The Petitioner, M/s. Shree Cement Limited (“the Petitioner” or
“SCL”), is mainly aggrieved by the order dated 16.10.2025 passed by the
(2014) 9 SCC 614
Signed By:PRIYA
19:27:57
W.P.(C) 18422/2025
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Nominated Authority (“NA”). The Petitioner submits that upon cancellation
of the allotment of the Datima Coal Mine and the consequent re-allocation
process under the Act, the Petitioner emerged as the Successful Allottee of
the said mine through a tender process pursuant to Tender Document dated
15.11.2022. In terms of Section 16 of the Act read with Clause 3.3.2(h) of
the aforesaid Tender Document, the Petitioner claims to have deposited a
total sum of ₹11,88,63,316.32/- with the NA, comprising: (i) a fixed amount
of ₹11,81,21,568.32/- representing the Geological Report (“GR”) cost
payable in terms of the Act; and (ii) a sum of ₹7,41,748/- towards Central
Mine Planning and Design Institute Limited (“CMPDIL”) expenses.
4.
The Petitioner further submits that the claim raised by Ultra Tech
over the aforesaid fixed amount was rejected by the NA vide order dated
22.07.2025. In that order, the NA, upon consideration of the entire factual
matrix including the failure of the Prior Allottee to produce any documents
establishing its entitlement to compensation, determined that the valuation
of compensation under Section 16 of the Act for Geological Report cost,
Cost of Consents, Land value, and Mine Infrastructure stood at NIL, and
accordingly directed that the fixed amount of ₹11,81,21,568.32/- shall
remain deposited with the Government of India in the absence of any legally
established claim from the Prior Allottee pertaining to the Datima Coal
Mine.
5.
The Petitioner further submits that thereafter, without having recourse
to the procedure prescribed under Section 27 of the Act, the NA, on the
basis of an application moved by Ultra Tech, proceeded to recall and modify
the order dated 22.07.2025, and by the impugned order dated 16.10.2025,
directed that the fixed amount of ₹11,81,21,568.32/- be released in favour of
Signed By:PRIYA
19:27:57
W.P.(C) 18422/2025
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Ultra Tech. The Petitioner’s principal grievance is that this direction was
issued without any notice or opportunity of hearing being afforded to it,
therefore, the petitioner is severely prejudiced.
6.
The submissions of the Petitioner are strongly opposed by Mr. Jayant
Mehta, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Ultra Tech, and by the learned
Central Government Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the Union of
India (Respondents No. 1 and 2). Mr. Mehta submits that the entitlement of
the Prior Allottee (now Ultra Tech) to receive the fixed amount directed to
be released by the impugned order dated 16.10.2025 remains undisputed in
principle. According to him, the fixed amount was retained by the NA
earlier only on account of the Prior Allottee’s failure to furnish the requisite
documentary proof of its entitlement, and that upon such documents being
placed on record, the release of the said amount was a natural and inevitable
consequence. Mr. Mehta further submits that, insofar as the Petitioner’s
claimed right over the said amount is concerned, the same had already been
rejected by the NA, as the NA had held that the Petitioner is not entitled to a
refund of the fixed amount.
7.
While the submissions by the Respondents have been strongly
opposed by Mr. Satvinder Singh, learned counsel for the Petitioner, the
Court is of the view that these aspects, at this stage, are not required to be
adjudicated. The submissions made by the parties could have been
considered by the NA before passing any direction on 16.10.2025. If the
order dated 22.07.2025 is considered in the context of the subsequent
decision passed on 16.10.2025 it would clearly appear that some assertions
have been recorded in the order dated 16.10.2025 without affording an
opportunity of hearing to the petitioner. The principle of natural justice is
Signed By:PRIYA
19:27:57
W.P.(C) 18422/2025
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
the rule and its exclusion is an exception. No doubt, the Courts have evolved
the doctrine of exclusion of the principles of natural justice, but the same is
confined to cases where no prejudice is shown to have been caused to the
affected party. Or the same is shown to be useless formality. In the present
case, however, the Petitioner has been demonstrably prejudiced, inasmuch
as an amount of ₹11,81,21,568.32/- deposited by it has been directed to be
released to a third party without affording the Petitioner any opportunity of
hearing.
8.
Mr. Mehta endeavoured to bring the instant matter in the category of
the cases where the opportunity of hearing could be termed a useless
formality. The Court, however, is not persuaded by the said submission.
The order dated 16.10.2025 is extracted as under:
“The compensation w.r.t Datima Coal mine was determined and
settled by Final Compensation Order dated 22.07.2025. The
compensation for Land, Mine Infrastructure and Cost to Consent was
determined as Nil, while the value for Geological Report (GR) was
determined as Rs. 11,81,21,568.32/- (excl. CMPDIL exp.) which was
kept with the Government of India in absence of any supporting
documents/legal claim by M/s UltraTech Cement Limited (UCL)
which has taken over the M/s Binani Cement Limited (Prior Allottee
of Datima coal mine) under Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
2.
Subsequently, M/s UltraTech Cement Limited (UCL), vide
its representation dated 16.09.2025, has submitted that the Geological
Reports (GRs) were prepared by the prior allottee, M/s Binani Cement
Limited (BCL) and were assets of BCL. By virtue of the Resolution
Plan approved under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, the
GRs was lawfully vested in UCL.
3.
On examination, it is observed that the Geological Reports
constitute an asset created by the prior allottee at substantial cost,
and ownership thereof now stands vested in UCL as the lawful
successor of BCL. In view of the binding effect of the approved
Resolution Plan, UCL’s entitlement to compensation for GRs under
Section 16 of the CMSP Act, 2015 is duly established.
4.
The request of M/s Shree Cement Limited (SCL) dated
17.09.2025 for refund of fixed amount deposited by them is not
Signed By:PRIYA
19:27:57
W.P.(C) 18422/2025
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
sustainable, since the ground on which refund was sought i.e. absence
of a valid claim has been conclusively displaced by the subsequent
recognition of UCL’s rights.
5.
Accordingly, it has been decided that the compensation
amount of Rs 11,81,21,568.32/- towards Geological reports shall be
released in favour of M/s UltraTech Cement Limited.
6.
In accordance with Section 27 of the Coal Mines (Special
Provisions) Act, 2015, and the judgment dated March 9, 2017, M/s
UltraTech Cement Limited and M/s Shree Cement Limited are hereby
informed that they may raise disputes regarding the quantum of
compensation before the Tribunal constituted under the Coal Bearing
Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957”
9.
In paragraph 4 thereof, the request made by the Petitioner dated
17.09.2025 for refund of the fixed amount has been found to be
unsustainable. Further, it has been noted that the grounds on which such
refund was sought, namely the absence of a valid claim by the Prior
Allottee, had been conclusively displaced by the subsequent recognition of
Ultra Tech right. This finding, recorded in paragraph 4, alone suffices to
establish that the Petitioner was a necessary party who ought to have been
heard before any direction were issued. Even if it were to be assumed that
the observations in paragraph 4 were merely a reiteration of earlier findings,
nothing prevented the NA from affording an opportunity of hearing to the
Petitioner. The same would have been necessary for the proper adjudication
of the case.
10.
Since the impugned order is found to be in violation of principles of
natural justice, the petitioner cannot be relegated to alternate remedy which,
according to the respondents, is under Section 27 of the Act. It is a wellsettled legal position, reiterated by the Supreme Court in a long line of
decisions, that an order passed in violation of the principles of natural justice
constitutes an exception to the general rule requiring a litigant to exhaust
Signed By:PRIYA
19:27:57
W.P.(C) 18422/2025
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
statutory remedies before approaching the High Court under Article 226 of
the Constitution. In Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks,
Mumbai & Ors.2, the Supreme Court held that a writ petition can be
maintained, notwithstanding the availability of an alternative remedy, in
cases involving: (i) enforcement of fundamental rights; (ii) failure of the
principles of natural justice; or (iii) proceedings wholly without jurisdiction
or challenging the vires of a statute. The instant case plainly falls within the
second of these categories. In this regard, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
State of Orissa v. Dr. (Miss) Binapani Dei & Ors.3, held:
"The rule that a party to whose prejudice an order is intended to be passed
is entitled to a hearing applies to judicial tribunals and bodies of persons
invested with authority to adjudicate upon matters involving civil
consequences. It is one of the fundamental rules of our constitutional set-up
that every citizen is protected against exercise of arbitrary authority by the
State or its officers... If the essentials of justice be ignored and an order to
the prejudice of a person is made, the order is a nullity."
11.
In view thereof, the Court finds that the impugned order suffers from
material illegality on account of not affording the opportunity of hearing to
the petitioner. The said order is accordingly set aside. The matter is remitted
to the NA for afresh consideration.
12.
Let the NA to decide the matter afresh after affording opportunity of
hearing to all concerned with due expedition without any undue delay. The
amount which appears to have been released to the Ultra Tech shall remain
subject to further orders to be passed by the NA.
13.
Accordingly, the writ petition stands disposed of. Pending application
shall also stand disposed of.
(1998) 8 SCC 1
AIR 1967 SC 1269
Signed By:PRIYA
19:27:57
W.P.(C) 18422/2025
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
14.
All rights and contentions of the parties are left open.
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J
FEBRUARY 20, 2026
Tr/ap
Signed By:PRIYA
19:27:57
W.P.(C) 18422/2025
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review