Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 20thDecember, 2025
Pronounced on: 06th January, 2026
%
+
+
+
BAIL APPLN.4476/2024
VISHAL VEERSINGH SUKHANI
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Aman Preet Singh, Mr.
Puneet Thakur, Advs.
Vs
STATE NCT OF DELHI
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Aman Usman, APP.
Mr. Aashul Aggarwal, Mr.
Rajat Mishra, Ms. Kamakshi
Gupta, Mr. Himanshu Yadav,
Advs. for complainant.
BAIL APPLN. 4530/2024
DALIP DALAL
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Aman Preet Singh, Mr.
Puneet Thakur, Advs.
Vs
STATE GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Aman Usman, APP.
Mr. Aashul Aggarwal, Mr.
Rajat Mishra, Ms. Kamakshi
Gupta, Mr. Himanshu Yadav,
Advs. for complainant.
BAIL APPLN. 4556/2024
SHOBIT AGGARWAL
Through:
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
.....Petitioner
Mr. Aman Preet Singh, Mr.
Shakeel Saifi, Mr. Puneet
Thakur, Mr. Vishvendra Tomar,
Advs.
Vs
STATE GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Aman Usman, APP.
Mr. Aashul Aggarwal, Mr. Rajat
Mishra, Ms. Kamakshi Gupta, Mr.
Himanshu
Yadav,
Advs.
for
complainant.
CORAM:HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA
JUDGMENT
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J.
1.
The present applications under Section 482 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 [“BNSS”] are filed by the petitioners
seeking grant of anticipatory bail in FIR No. 456/2024 registered at
Police Station Anand Vihar, under Sections 420/406/34 of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860 [“IPC”]. Since the applications emanate from a
common set of facts and pertain to the same FIR, they are being
disposed of together by this common judgment.
Factual background
2.
The genesis of the dispute lies in a re-development project of
Nirmal Anand Cooperative Housing Society, Mumbai [“Society”]. A
re-development agreement dated 25.09.2013 was executed between
the said society and M/s Aditya Developers [“Developer”], whereby
the developer was entitled to 13 flats and had to construct residential
flats which were to be allotted to existing members of the society.
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
3.
The petitioners herein, namely Vishal Sukhani, Dalip Dalal and
Shobhit Aggarwal, were investors in the said project and had entered
into separate arrangements with the developer for purchase of specific
flats. Mr. Neeraj Jain [“complainant”], through his company M/s
RBN Equity Consultant Pvt. Ltd., also invested in the project and
claims to have paid approximately Rs.1.91 crores towards the
purchase of 02 flats.
4.
It is the case of the complainant that despite payment of the said
amount, the promised flats were not delivered and that the accused
persons, in conspiracy with each other, misappropriated the funds.
Subsequently, disputes arose between the developer and the society,
on account of non-completion of the project, resulting in termination
of the development agreement.
5.
Owing to such disputes, arbitration proceedings were initiated,
culminating in an arbitral award dated 19.01.2021. In September 2024,
nearly four years after the execution of the consent terms and
arbitration proceedings, the complainant lodged the present FIR dated
24.09.2024.
6.
The gravamen of the allegations in the FIR is that the
complainant was induced by the accused person Shobhit Aggarwal to
invest substantial sums of money in a re-development project on the
assurance of being allotted residential flats therein. It is alleged that
the accused persons, acting in concert, represented themselves as
having lawful authority and control over the project and induced the
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
complainant to part with approximately Rs.1.91 crores. The
complainant alleges that despite receipt of the said amount, the
promised flats were neither delivered nor was the money refunded.
7.
Apprehending arrest, anticipatory bail application on behalf of
accused persons/petitioners was moved before the Ld. Court of
Sessions, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi which was dismissed vide order
dated 23.11.2024 on the ground that the allegations disclosed serious
economic offences involving misappropriation of substantial public
money, and that custodial interrogation was necessary to unearth the
complete modus operandi and the trail of funds involved. Aggrieved
by the same, the petitioners have filed the present applications seeking
anticipatory bail.
Submissions on behalf of the Petitioners
8.
The dispute pertains to alleged suppression of the actual
consideration paid by the complainant for two flats [Flat nos. 401 and
701], wherein the Consent Terms forming part of the arbitral award
dated 11.01.2021 recorded an amount of Rs. 40 lacs instead of Rs.1.91
crores. It was submitted that this discrepancy occurred due to
information supplied by the developer and not due to any act or
misrepresentation by the petitioners. The developer recorded the
receipt of payment of Rs. 40 lacs, but later admitted in MoU dated
04.01.2025, that the amount was mistakenly recorded as Rs. 40 lacs
instead of Rs. 1.91 crores. This admission of amount clarification, it
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
was argued, was also ratified by the petitioners in MoU dated
08.12.2025 executed between them and the complainant.
9.
The record reveals that the complainant and the petitioners were
all purchasers of flats from the same developer- M/s Aditya
Developers. The petitioners, like the complainant, had independently
purchased their respective flats and had no control over or authority
concerning the complainant’s flats. Owing to disputes between the
developer and the society, construction was stalled, leading to
arbitration proceedings wherein the petitioners, along with other
purchasers, sought protection of their interests. The consent terms and
arbitral award arose out of these proceedings and were never intended
to bind the complainant, who was not a party thereto.
10.
It
was
submitted
that
the
petitioners
were
merely
investors/financiers and not developers or promoters. The construction
was undertaken by the society, and the petitioners neither received nor
misappropriated any amount paid by the complainant. It was argued
that the petitioners never claimed any authority over the 02 flats
belonging to the complainant and that they were not beneficiaries of
the amounts allegedly paid by the complainant and hence no role
could be attributed to them. The allegations of forgery and siphoning
of funds are unsupported by cogent material and appear to be designed
to criminalise what is purely a civil dispute.
11.
It was further argued that subsequent documents, including the
MoU dated 04.01.2025, ROC Undertaking dated 11.12.2024, and
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
Tripartite Settlement Agreement dated 08.12.2025, unequivocally
acknowledge that the complainant had paid Rs.1.91 crores, thereby
resolving the factual controversy and demonstrating the civil nature of
the dispute. Parallel civil proceedings between the parties are pending
before the Bombay High Court and the City Civil Court, wherein
interim protection has been granted, further affirming that the dispute
is essentially civil and contractual in nature. It was submitted that the
continuation of criminal proceedings is an abuse of the process of law,
particularly when the complainant has himself entered into
settlements. The FIR has been lodged only to exert pressure and is
liable to be quashed.
12.
Learned counsel emphasized that the petitioners have fully
cooperated with the investigation and have joined the investigation
whenever called upon. It was further submitted that custodial
interrogation is wholly unnecessary, as the entire case is documentary
in nature and all relevant documents are already in the possession of
the investigating agency. It is prayed that the petitioners be granted
anticipatory bail.
Submissions on behalf of the State and Complainant
13.
Per contra, Ld. APP for the respondent/State, supported by
counsel for the complainant opposed the grant of anticipatory bail. It is
submitted that the FIR discloses serious offences involving cheating
and criminal breach of trust, wherein the petitioners induced the
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
complainant to invest substantial amounts on false assurances of
allotment of residential flats.
14.
It was argued that the since the project could not be completed
by Aditya developers, the petitioners, even though being the financers
of the project, had taken over the project from the Developer and were
involved in the affairs/functioning of the project. Even though the
payment was made by the complainant to the Developer, the petitioner
were in-charge of the project and had diverted the funds elsewhere and
hence, custodial interrogation of the petitioners is necessary to trace
the money trail.
15.
Furthermore, it was contended that the petitioners had
purchased total of 09 flats, but they misrepresented in the consent
terms before the Arbitrator that they represent 11 flats- including 02
flats belonging to the complainant. This suggests that they had created
forged documents to show such false representation before the
Arbitrator.
16.
It was also argued that the MoU dated 04.01.2025 clearly
records the statement of the Developer that the receipt of amount of
Rs. 1.91 crores was duly informed to the petitioners via email and
orally, yet they chose to misrepresent the amount as Rs. 40 lacs before
the Arbitrator.
17.
The Ld. APP argued that the allegations in the FIR and status
report point to a pre-planned conspiracy and wrongful gain at the cost
of the complainant, thereby satisfying the ingredients of the offences
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
invoked. It is urged that grant of anticipatory bail at this stage would
seriously hamper investigation. Given the gravity of offences and
magnitude of financial loss, it is prayed that the bail applications be
dismissed.
Analysis and Reasoning
18.
The Court has carefully considered the rival submissions and
perused the material placed on record.
19.
At the outset, it is evident that the allegations in the present case
pertain to serious economic offences involving inducement and
misrepresentation. The gravamen of the accusation is that the
petitioners, acting in concert, induced the complainant to invest large
sums on the assurance of allotment of residential flats, which were
neither delivered nor was the money refunded. While the Court is not
required to conduct a mini-trial or adjudicate upon the veracity of rival
claims, it is nonetheless obliged to assess whether the allegations,
taken at face value, disclose the commission of cognizable offences
and whether custodial interrogation of the accused is necessary in the
facts and circumstances of the case.
20.
The allegations in the present case pertain to inducement of the
complainant to invest a substantial amount of approximately Rs.1.91
crores on the assurance of allotment of residential flats, followed by
alleged misrepresentation. The FIR specifically alleges that the
petitioners, acting in concert, misrepresented their authority and
control over the project and projected themselves as persons
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
competent to deal with the flats in question, thereby inducing the
complainant to part with substantial funds.
21.
The petitioners misrepresented themselves before the Arbitrator
as representatives of 11 flats, when in fact they had purchased 09 flatsas seen from the record. They had no exercise of right over the 02 flats
of the complainant and did not obtain consent from him to represent
his flats. The petitioners were aware of the receipt of Rs. 1.91 crores
by the complainant, yet they misrepresented the same as Rs. 40 lacs.
The Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the complainant alleges
deliberate misrepresentation and concealment of material facts. The
reliance placed by the petitioners on subsequent MoUs, settlement
documents and civil proceedings does not, at this stage, efface the
allegations contained in the FIR. Whether such documents were
executed bona fide or as an afterthought to cover up earlier acts is a
matter that requires detailed investigation. These allegations, at this
stage, cannot be brushed aside as purely civil in nature.
22.
The defence of the petitioners that they were merely investors
and not developers, and that the dispute is purely civil in nature,
cannot be accepted at this stage. The material placed on record prima
facie indicates that the petitioners were not passive investors but were
actively involved in the project and in dealings concerning the flats.
The investigation prima facie indicates that the petitioners were privy
to the financial dealings and their custodial interrogation is necessary.
The Supreme Court inState Vs. Anil Sharma, (1997) 7 SCC 187 held
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
that it is a well-established legal principle that custodial interrogation
is significantly more effective for eliciting information compared to
questioning an accused who is protected by an anticipatory bail order
under Section 438 Cr.P.C (Section 482 BNSS). Granting anticipatory
bail to the petitioners at this stage would undeniably obstruct the
course of further investigation. Such relief cannot be granted as a
matter of routine, especially when it may be misused by the petitioners
as a protective shield against further investigation.
23.
Economic offences of massive nature, as repeatedly emphasised
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, affect the financial fabric of society
and must be approached with the seriousness they warrant. In
Nimmagadda Prasad v. CBI, (2013) 7 SCC 466, the Supreme Court
observed that such offences, involving deep-rooted conspiracies and
financial loss, have far-reaching implications for society and must be
approached with a different yardstick when considering bail. In Y.S.
Jagan Mohan Reddy v. CBI, (2013) 7 SCC 439, it was held that
economic offences constitute a class apart and grant of bail should be
exercised with great circumspection.
24.
Having regard to the totality of the circumstances, including the
magnitude of funds involved and the nature of allegations, this Court
is of the view that the petitioners are not entitled to seek the benefit of
pre-arrest bail/anticipatory bail.
25.
Accordingly, the present applications are disposed of alongwith
pending application(s), if any.
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
26.
Nothing in this judgment shall tantamount as an expression of
opinion on the merits of the case and any observations made are only
for the purpose of deciding the present bail application.
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J.
06th January, 2026
AK
BAIL APPLN. 4476/2024 & connected matters
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:22:20
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review