Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 29TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S VISHWAJITH SHETTY
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 1733 OF 2009 (DEC)
BETWEEN:
SHIVALINGAPPA
S/O NEELA GOWDA
R/AT S. MAKANAHALLIKASABA
HOBLI, ARASIKERE TALUK - 573 103.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI HARISH N.R, AMICUS CURIE)
AND:
Digitally
signed by
NANDINI M S
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
1.
SANNAIAH
S/O NINGAPPA
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
2.
SIDDE GOWDA
S/O NINGAPPA
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS.
3.
THIMMAPPA
S/O RANGE GOWDA
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS.
ALL ARE RESIDING AT MAKANAHALLI
KASABA HOBLI, ARASIKERE TALUK - 573 103.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI H.T. NATARAJ, ADV. FOR R-1 TO R-3)
THIS
RSA
IS
FILED
U/S
OF
CPC,
AGAINST
THE
JUDGEMENT & DECREE DTD19.09.2009 PASSED IN R.A.NO.48/2007
ON THE FILE THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN) & ADDL. CJM, AARSIKERE,
DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE JUDGEMENT AND
-2NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
DECREE DTD 12.04.2007 PASSED IN O.S.NO.229/2005 ON THE FILE
OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (JR.DN), ARSIKERE.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S VISHWAJITH SHETTY
ORAL JUDGMENT
1.
Plaintiff is before this Court in this regular second appeal
filed under Section 100 of CPC with a prayer to set-aside the
judgment
and
decree
dated
19.09.2009
passed
in
RA
No.48/2007 by the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Dn.) and Addl.
CJM, Arsikere and the judgment and decree dated 12.04.2007
passed in OS No.229/2005 by the Court of Addl. Civil Judge (Jr.
Dn.), Arsikere.
2.
Heard the learned amicus curiae appearing on behalf of
the appellant and the learned counsel for the respondents.
3.
Facts leading to filing of this regular second appeal as
revealed from the records are, the appellant herein had filed OS
No.229/2005 before the Court of Civil Judge (Jr. Dn.) Arsikere,
seeking the relief of declaration in respect of the suit schedule
A property and also the relief of possession in respect of suit
-3NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
schedule B property. A further prayer was made claiming
mesne profits in respect of the suit schedule B property. It is
the case of the plaintiff that suit schedule A property is his
ancestral property and was allotted to his share in a family
partition
between
himself
and
his
brother
Krishnappa.
Subsequently, revenue entries of the suit Schedule A property
were also transferred in his name. Suit schedule B property
which is part and parcel of suit schedule A property was
encroached by the defendants about four to five years back and
therefore, plaintiff had filed suit in OS No.63/2000 seeking the
relief of permanent injunction. The said suit was dismissed on
08.02.2005. Though plaintiff had requested defendants to
vacate and hand over possession of B schedule property, they
had rejected his claim and therefore, he had filed the present
suit. The defendants contested the suit by filing written
statement
denying
the
plaint
averments.
However,
they
admitted about plaintiff filing OS No.63/2000 seeking the relief
of permanent injunction. They also claimed that they are in
possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule B property for
the last more than 100 years without any obstruction from the
plaintiff and they also claimed that though the plaintiff was
-4NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
throughout aware about their possession over B schedule
property, he has not taken any action against them and
therefore, they have perfected their title by way of adverse
possession. They also contended that the suit was barred by
limitation.
4.
Based on the rival pleadings, the Trial Court had framed
as many as seven issues in OS No.229/2005, which reads as
follows:"1. Whether plaintiff proves that he is the absolute owner
of the 'A' schedule property as on the date of suit?
2.Whether plaintiff proves that the defendants are in
illegal possession of the 'B' suit schedule property?
3. Whether plaintiff is entitle for the possession of the 'B
schedule property?
4. Whether plaintiff is entitle for the relief of mesne profit?
5. Whether defendant proves that the suit of the plaintiff
is time barred?
6. Whether Plaintiff are entitle for the relief claimed in the
suit?
7. What order or decree?"
-5NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
5.
During the course of trial, two witnesses were examined
on behalf of the plaintiff as PW1 and PW2 and he got marked
four documents as Ex.P1 to P4. On behalf of the defendants,
two witnesses were examined as DW1 and DW2 and seven
documents were got marked as Ex.D1 to D7. After hearing the
arguments addressed on both sides, the Trial Court had partly
decreed the suit in OS No.229/2005 and had declared that the
plaintiff is the owner in possession of 15 guntas of land in suit
schedule A property except schedule B property. The said
judgment and decree passed in OS No.229/2005 was confirmed
in RA No.48/2007 by the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Dn.) and
Addl.
CJM,
Arsikere,
by
judgment
and
decree
dated
19.09.2009. Aggrieved by the aforesaid two judgments passed
by both the Courts, the plaintiff is before this Court.
6.
This Court, while admitting this regular second appeal,
has framed the following two substantial questions of law for
consideration in this appeal, which read as under:-
"1) Whether the Courts below were justified in
holding that the defendants could have set up a
claim for adverse possession in the manner in which
it was done?
-6NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
2) Whether the ingredients claiming perfection of
title by adverse possession were present?"
7.
According to the plaintiff, suit schedule A property is his
ancestral property and the same was allotted to his share
under a registered Partition Deed dated 20.10.2005. Ex.P1 is
the copy of the registered Partition Deed dated 20.10.2005 and
Ex.P2 is the Pahani extract, which prima facie shows that the
Partition Deed at Ex.P1 was acted upon and the revenue entries
of the suit schedule property was transferred in the name of
the plaintiff. Suit schedule B property is undisputedly part of
suit schedule A property and according to the plaintiff, the
defendants are in wrongful possession of the same for the last
4 to 5 years and it is under these circumstances, he had sought
the relief of possession of the suit schedule B property.
8.
The defendants, on the other hand, had filed written
statement opposing the suit claim and contended that they and
their forefathers are in peaceful possession and enjoyment of
the suit schedule B property for the last more than 100 years,
which was within the knowledge of the plaintiff and his
-7NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
forefathers and therefore, they have perfected their title over
the suit schedule B property by adverse possession.
9.
In paragraph No.15 of the order, the Trial Court has
observed as follows:"15. In this case, defendants have not sought
for any counter claim relating to adverse possession.
Even then their plea is to be considered while
considering Plaintiffs right over the 'B' schedule
property.
Admittedly, defendants are in possession
of 'B' schedule property from morethan 100 years,
within the knowledge of this plaintiff, hostile to their
interest.
Such being the case they have perfected
their title by way of adverse possession."
10.
In the plaint, it is specifically stated that suit schedule B
property was in wrongful possession of the defendants for the
last 4 to 5 years and even during the course of deposition of
PW1, he has stated that possession of the defendants over the
suit schedule B property is only for the last about 4 to 5 years.
However,
defendants'
strangely,
the
possession
Trial
of
suit
Court
has
schedule
observed
B
that
property
is
admittedly for the last more than 100 years within the
knowledge of the plaintiff and hostile to their interest. Such a
-8NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
finding recorded by the Trial Court is not based on the
pleadings or documentary evidence available on record.
11.
For the purpose of proving perfection of title by adverse
possession, defendants were required to unequivocally admit
the title of the plaintiff and raise a plea that their possession
over suit schedule B property was open and undisturbed over a
period of more than 12 years which was known to the plaintiff
and his forefathers. Defendants are also required to show that
on what day they came into possession and what was the
nature of their possession over the suit schedule B property.
The material on record would go to show that such a plea was
not raised in the present case by the defendants. Plaintiff has
pleaded in his plaint that suit schedule A property is his
ancestral property and the same was allotted to his share
under a registered partition Deed dated 20.10.2005. In
paragraph No.2 of their written statement, defendants have
denied the said contention of the plaintiff though subsequently
in paragraph No.4, they have vaguely admitted that suit
schedule B property belongs to the plaintiff.
-9NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
12.
Plaintiff has produced certified copy of the written
statement and deposition of defendant No.2/Siddegowda in OS
No.63/2000, which was filed by the plaintiff seeking the relief of
permanent injunction. The said documents are marked as Ex.P3
and Ex.P4 in the present case. In Ex.P3 also, defendants have
specifically raised a contention denying the title of the plaintiff
over the suit schedule property. In Ex.P4 which is the
deposition of defendant No.2 Siddegowda in OS No.63/2000
also, he had denied the title of the plaintiff over the suit
schedule property and he also had stated that since the suit
schedule property was a government land, defendants had filed
application before the Tahsildar to grant the said property in
their favour. In Ex.P4, it is also stated that defendants were
under the impression that suit schedule B property belonged to
them and therefore, they were in possession and cultivation of
the
said
land.
From
the
aforesaid,
it
is
apparent
that
defendants had not unequivocally admitted the title of the
plaintiff over the suit schedule B property in respect of which
they
have
possession.
claimed
perfection
of
their
title
by
adverse
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
13.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Chatti Konati
Rao and Others vs. Palle Venkata Subba Rao - (2010) 14
SCC 316, in paragraph Nos.13 to 15, has observed as follows:-
"13. What facts are required to prove adverse
possession have succinctly been enunciated by this
Court in Karnataka Board of Wakf v. Govt. of India
[(2004) 10 SCC 779]. It has also been observed that
a person pleading adverse possession has no equities
in his favour and since such a person is trying to
defeat the rights of the true owner, it is for him to
clearly
plead
and
establish
necessary
facts
to
establish his adverse possession. SCC para 11 of the
judgment which is relevant for the purpose reads as
follows: (SCC p. 785)
“11. In the eye of the law, an owner would be
deemed to be in possession of a property so
long as there is no intrusion. Non-use of the
property by the owner even for a long time
won't affect his title. But the position will be
altered when another person takes possession
of the property and asserts a right over it.
Adverse possession is a hostile possession by
clearly asserting hostile title in denial of the
title of the true owner. It is a well-settled
principle
that
a
party
claiming
adverse
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
possession must prove that his possession is
‘nec vi, nec clam, nec precario’, that is,
peaceful, open and continuous. The possession
must be adequate in continuity, in publicity and
in extent to show that their possession is
adverse to the true owner. It must start with a
wrongful disposition of the rightful owner and
be
actual,
visible,
exclusive,
hostile
and
continued over the statutory period. (See S.M.
Karim v. Bibi Sakina [AIR 1964 SC 1254] ,
Parsinni v. Sukhi [(1993) 4 SCC 375] and D.N.
Venkatarayappa v. State of Karnataka [(1997)
7 SCC 567] .) Physical fact of exclusive
possession and the animus possidendi to hold
as owner in exclusion to the actual owner are
the most important factors that are to be
accounted in cases of this nature. Plea of
adverse possession is not a pure question of
law but a blended one of fact and law.
Therefore,
a
person
who
claims
adverse
possession should show: (a) on what date he
came into possession, (b) what was the nature
of his possession, (c) whether the factum of
possession was known to the other party, (d)
how long his possession has continued, and (e)
his possession was open and undisturbed. A
person pleading adverse possession has no
equities in his favour. Since he is trying to
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
defeat the rights of the true owner, it is for him
to
clearly
plead
and
establish
all
facts
necessary to establish his adverse possession.
(Mahesh Chand Sharma v. Raj Kumari Sharma
[(1996) 8 SCC 128] .)”
14.
In view of the several authorities of this
Court, few whereof have been referred above, what
can safely be said is that mere possession however
long does not necessarily mean that it is adverse to
the true owner. It means hostile possession which is
expressly or impliedly in denial of the title of the true
owner and in order to constitute adverse possession
the possession must be adequate in continuity, in
publicity and in extent so as to show that it is
adverse to the true owner. The possession must be
open and hostile enough so that it is known by the
parties interested in the property. The plaintiff is
bound to prove his title as also possession within
twelve years and once the plaintiff proves his title,
the burden shifts on the defendant to establish that
he has perfected his title by adverse possession.
Claim by adverse possession has two basic elements
i.e. the possession of the defendant should be
adverse to the plaintiff and the defendant must
continue to remain in possession for a period of
twelve years thereafter.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
15.
Animus possidendi as is well known is a
requisite ingredient of adverse possession. Mere
possession does not ripen into possessory title until
the possessor holds the property adverse to the title
of the true owner for the said purpose. The person
who
claims
adverse
possession
is
required
to
establish the date on which he came in possession,
nature of possession, the factum of possession,
knowledge to the true owner, duration of possession
and that possession was open and undisturbed. A
person pleading adverse possession has no equities
in his favour as he is trying to defeat the rights of
the true owner and, hence, it is for him to clearly
plead and establish all facts necessary to establish
adverse possession. The courts always take unkind
view
towards
statutes
of
limitation
overriding
property rights. The plea of adverse possession is not
a pure question of law but a blended one of fact and
law."
14.
In the background of the principles laid down in the case
of Chatti Konati Rao (supra), if the facts of the present case
and the oral and documentary evidence available on record is
appreciated, it is found that the defendants had completely
failed to prove that they had perfected their title by adverse
possession. Defendants have taken inconsistent stand with
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
regard to the title of the plaintiff over the suit schedule
property. Though in the pleadings, they have denied the title of
the plaintiff, during the course of their deposition, DW1 and
DW2 have admitted that suit schedule A and B properties are
the ancestral properties of the plaintiff. It has also come on
record that defendants had filed an application before the
jurisdictional Tahsildar with a prayer to grant the suit schedule
B property presuming that the suit schedule B property was a
government land. In Ex.P4, defendant No.2 herein has stated
that defendants were under the impression that the suit
schedule
property
belonged
to
them
and
they
were
in
possession and enjoyment of the said property.
15.
As observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Chatti Konati Rao (supra) unless the defendants clearly plead
and establish all facts necessary to establish their adverse
possession, the Courts cannot grant them any relief since an
attempt is being made by person claiming adverse possession
to defeat the right of the true owner. Under the circumstances,
the Trial Court was not justified in partly decreeing the suit in
OS No.229/2005. The Appellate Court also has failed to
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
appreciate the aforesaid aspects of the matter and has erred in
confirming the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court
in OS No.229/2005. In view of the aforesaid analysis of the
matter, the substantial questions of law framed by this Court
are answered in the negative and it is held that both the Courts
have erred in arriving at the conclusion that defendants have
perfected their title over the suit schedule B property by
adverse possession. Under the circumstances, the following:ORDER
(i)
The regular second appeal is allowed.
(ii)
The judgment and decree dated 19.09.2009
passed in RA No.48/2007 by the Court of Civil Judge
(Sr. Dn.) and Addl. CJM, Arsikere and the judgment
and
decree
dated
12.04.2007
passed
in
OS
No.229/2005 by the Court of Addl. Civil Judge (Jr.
Dn.), Arsikere, to the extent it relates to dismissing
the suit in respect of suit schedule B property is setaside and the suit of the plaintiff is decreed in its
entirety and the plaintiff is declared as the lawful
owner of the suit schedule A property and he is
entitled to recover possession of the suit schedule B
property from the defendants.
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:5202
RSA No. 1733 of 2009
HC-KAR
(iii)
Accordingly, defendants are directed to hand
over possession of suit schedule B property in favour
of the plaintiff.
(iv)
The services of learned Amicus Curiae is
placed on record and his fees is fixed at Rs.15,000/-.
Sd/(S VISHWAJITH SHETTY)
JUDGE
DN
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review