The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. At the cost of repetition, we may notice, that this Court has consistently taken the view that recording of reasons is an essential feature of (2010) 4 SCC 785. dispensation of justice. A litigant who approaches the Court with any grievance in accordance with law is entitled to know the reasons for grant or rejection of his prayer. Reasons are the soul of orders. Non-recording of reasons could lead to dual infirmities; firstly, it may cause prejudice to the affected party and secondly, more particularly, hamper the proper administration of justice. These principles are not only applicable to administrative or executive actions, but they apply with equal force and, in fact, with a greater degree of precision to judicial pronouncements. A judgment without reasons causes prejudice to the person against whom it is pronounced, as that litigant is unable to know the ground which weighed with the Court in rejecting his claim and also causes impediments in his taking adequate and appropriate grounds before the higher Court in the event of challenge to that judgment. Now, we may refer to certain judgments of this Court as well as of the High Courts which have taken this view.
14. The principle of natural justice has twin ingredients; firstly, the person who is likely to be adversely affected by the action of the authorities should be given notice to show cause thereof and granted an opportunity of hearing and secondly, the orders so passed by the authorities should give reason for arriving at any conclusion showing proper application of mind. Violation of either of them could in the given facts and circumstances of the case, vitiate the order itself. Such rule being applicable to the administrative authorities certainly requires that the judgment of the Court should meet with this requirement with higher degree of satisfaction. The order of an administrative authority may not provide reasons like a judgment but the order must be supported by the reasons of rationality. The distinction between passing of an order by an administrative or quasi-judicial authority has practically extinguished and both are required to pass reasoned orders.” Respondents may not have acted as quasi- judicial authority while rejecting petitioner’s case but considering the factual background of the case where there is no reflection whatsoever of the reasons for rejection of petitioner’s application, where there is nothing on record to figure out as to why the respondents have granted LOI in favour of some institutes and refused to the petitioner; where no criteria for grant of L…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 19623 of 2025
Decided on: 10.07.2026
Shiva Educational Society,
Abdhanighat (Panol)
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P and another
..Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting?1Yes
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Kul Bhushan Khajuria,
Advocate.
For the Respondents:
Mr. Rajat Choudhry, Assistant
Advocate General.
------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Petitioner
questions
the
decision
of
the
respondents in refusing to grant it Letter of Intent (LOI)/
No
Objection
Certificate
(NOC)
for
establishing
Multipurpose Health Worker (Male) [MPHW(M)] Training
Institute
as being
arbitrary, discriminatory and non-
speaking.
2.
Heard and considered the case file.
2(i).
The respondent- State notified a policy on
31.08.2023 regarding start of MPHW(M) Training Courses
in the State in private sector. Pursuant
to this policy,
notice inviting Expression of Interest (EOI)/ Letter of Intent
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
for opening MPHW(M) Training Institutions
in private
sector was circulated and applications were invited. The
policy spelt out
eligibility conditions for applying,
minimum requirement of land, transport, infrastructure
facilities, trainer faculty and other ancillary factors etc.
2(ii).
Petitioner, on 30.10.2023, applied for grant of
NOC/ permission to establish MPHW(M) Training Institute
at Village Luhnoo Kanatian, P.O. Chandpur, District
Bilaspur,
H.P.
The
requisite
documents
alongwith
prescribed fee also submitted alongwith application.
Detailed Project Report of the proposed institution of the
petitioner was also made part of the application. The date
of applying for running the training course was extended
by the respondents upto 12.02.2024.
Certain clauses of
the policy were also amended by the respondents during
this period.
2(iii).
On 20.07.2024, the Inspection Committee as
also the Evaluation Committee
were constituted to
inspect and evaluate the proposal of the applicants for
starting the institutes in question. The report submitted
by
the
Inspection
Committee
regarding
petitioner’s
institute was evaluated by the Evaluation Committee. The
Evaluation Committee on 25.07.2024 recommended the
petitioner institute for issuance of LOI for establishment/
opening of MPHW(M) Training Course.
2(iv).
The office letter dated 04.09.2024 makes it
evident that apart from petitioner’s institute, two other
institutes
namely, Dogra Institute, Village Mehan, P.O.
Chandpur, Tehsil Sadar, District Bilaspur and Adarsh
Training Institute Amarpur, Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur,
H.P. were also recommended for running the training
course in question in District Bilaspur.
2(v).
On 13.05.2025, the Principal Secretary, Health
to the Government of Himachal Pradesh- respondent No.1
conveyed the decision of the Council of Ministers that
before proceeding further in the matter of granting LOI for
starting MPHW(M) Training Course in private sector in the
State, the
department may examine
employment
opportunities of the course in question in the State as also
in the Country. The department was also to intimate the
retirement
status for the next three years of the
incumbents working in the department. The petitioner
assailed this decision by instituting Shiva Educational
Society versus State of H.P2.
The writ petition was
disposed of as under:“By way of this petition, the petitioner has, inter
alia, prayed for the following reliefs:2
CWP No.8259/2025, decided on 25.08.2025.
“A) That writ may kindly be allowed and the
communication dated 13.5.2025 contained in
Annexure P-11 may kindly be quashed and set
aside and the decision contained therein may
kindly be declared as null and void. B) That
the respondent No.1 may kindly be directed to
issue Letter of Intent (LOI) to the petitioner
institute to establish Shiv Multipurpose Health
Worker (Male) Training Institute at Village
Luhnoo Kanatain, PO Chandpur, Distt. Bilaspur
and for starting up MPHW(M) course.”
2.
I have heard learned Counsel for the
petitioner as well as learned Advocate General.
3.
Learned Advocate General informs the Court
that the position as it is today is that the matter
has been discussed by the Cabinet and it has been
decided that call thereupon will either be taken by
the Cabinet or the highest Authority within some
reasonable time. He submits that needful is likely
to be done within six weeks.
4.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits
that whereas permission has not been granted to
the petitioner, on the pretext that the decision has
to be taken by the Cabinet. Institutions similarly
situated as the petitioner have already been
granted permission that that too in the month of
September, 2024.
5.
Be that as it may, having perused the
impugned order (Annexure P-11), this Court is of
the considered view that to some extent the
petition is pre-mature. In terms of Annexure P-11,
the case of the petitioner has not been rejected by
the Authority, but it has been intimated that taking
into consideration the larger picture, the
Government intends to take a decision with regard
to feasibility of granting permission to such kind of
Institution to crop up in the State of Himachal
Pradesh.
6.
In the light of the statement of the learned
Advocate General that the Government of
Himachal Pradesh is already seized of the matter,
this petition is closed with the direction that
whatever has to be done at the end of the State be
positively done within a period of three weeks from
today and appropriate decision be taken in the
case of the petitioner accordingly.
7.
The petition stands disposed of, in above
terms. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any
also stand disposed of accordingly.”
2(vi).
The documents appended with the writ petition
(Annexure P-13) are to the effect that the respondentdepartment
received
proposals
from
private
institutions for running MPHW(M) course, out of which, 27
proposals were found fit by the Inspection/Evaluation
Committee and were also recommended by the Director,
Medical Education
& Research, H.P. The name of the
petitioner figures at Sr. No.21 in the list of institutions
found fit & recommended for opening MPHW(M) Training
Institute. Out of 27 proposals including that of petitioner,
recommended for issuance of LOI, the State conveyed its
approval on 04.09.2025 in favour of four institutions that
figured at Sr. Nos. 6, 12, 11 & 7 of the list. The noting
sheets
obtained
by
the
petitioner
under
Right
to
Information Act reveal that pursuant to the directions
issued in Shiva Educational Society2, the respondents
also
considered
petitioner’s
case
for
issuance
of
LOI/opening of MPHW(M) Training Institute. It has come in
the reply filed by the respondents that petitioner’s
institute was “not approved” by the Council of Ministers in
the meeting convened on 15.09.2025.
2(vii).
With the above background
facts, petitioner
has instituted this writ petition seeking directions to
respondent No.1 to issue LOI in its favour for establishing
MPHW(M) Training Institute at Village Luhnoo Kanatian,
P.O. Chandpur, District Bilaspur, H.P.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that apart from four institutions (mentioned in para-2 (vi)
above), the Competent Authority had approved five more
institutes figuring at Sr. Nos, 1, 8, 14, 22 & 24 in the list of
27 proposals found fit by the Inspection Committee/
Evaluation Committee for opening MPHW(M) Training
Institute. The decision of the
Competent Authority was
thereafter placed before the Council of Ministers and expost facto approval was granted in favour of these five
additional institutes. Thus, in all, LOI has been sanctioned
in favour of 04+05= 09 institutes in the State for starting
the MPHW(M) course. Learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that action of the respondents in not issuing LOI/
NOC in petitioner’s favour
for opening/ establishing
MPHW(M)
sets
Training
arbitrariness.
The
Institute
respondents
out
have
clear
line
of
discriminatively
acted in the matter. Petitioner’s case has been rejected
by an arbitrary exercise of power
without passing any
speaking order. Opposing this, learned Assistant Advocate
General
reiterated
the
pleaded
defence
of
the
respondents and highlighted that Cabinet has taken the
impugned decision in accordance with law.
4.
Under the policy notified on 31.08.2023, no
criteria has been fixed by the respondents as to how
many institutes for running MPHW(M) Training Course are
to be opened,
in which
districts these are to be
established and the basis for selecting/approving the
applications recommended by the Inspection/Evaluation
Committee for starting the institutes. The policy does not
throw any light as to how to move forward in situation
where multiple applicants apply for grant of NOC/LOI in
one
particular
district
and
their
names
are
recommended by Inspection/Evaluation Committee. The
policy does not explain whether approval/LOI/NOC can be
withheld from duly recommended institutes, or the
parameters thereof to be considered or the process and
procedure to be followed for restricting issuance of LOI
for establishing MPHW(M) Training Courses. There is
nothing on record to show that any such criteria was even
followed by the
respondents while processing the
applications of those institutes which were found eligible
and fit for establishing MPHW(M) Training Institute.
Nothing has come on record as to why out of 27 proposals
which
were
found
fit
by
the
respective
Inspection/Evaluation Committees, the respondents chose
to grant LOI/ NOC only in favour of 04+05=09 institutes.
In fact five additional institutions were approved by the
Competent Authority on 17.09.2025 which were later on,
granted
ex-post facto
approval by the Council of
Ministers.
The
considering
basis
of
only
institutions for running Training Course
these
has not come
forth. There cannot be absolute power to be exercised in
whimsical manner without regard to well established
principles of law and procedure. Learned counsel for the
petitioner has also pointed out that 02 out of these 09
institutes to whom LOI has been granted, figured at Sr.
Nos. 11 & 12 of the list and were not otherwise found
completely
compliant with laid down conditions of the
policy dated 31.08.2023. The case of the petitioner,
despite there being directions in Shiva Educational
Society,2 has been rejected by the respondent simply as
‘not approved’.
rejecting
No reasons have been assigned for
petitioner’s
circumstances,
it is
case.
apt to
In
the
given
reiterate
principles that reasons are hallmark
facts
and
well settled
of the decision. In
State Project Director, U.P. Education for all Project
Board and others,3 Hon’ble Apex Court reiterated that a
judgment
cannot be
sustained in absence of reasons.
Relevant paras are as under:“4. We are of the opinion that in the absence of
any reasoning in the impugned judgment, the
same cannot be sustained. In this regard, we are
benefitted by the following observations made by
this Court in CCT v. Shukla & Bros., (2010) 4 SCC
785. The relevant paragraphs of the judgment are
extracted hereinbelow: “23. We are not venturing to comment upon
the correctness or otherwise of the
contentions of law raised before the High
Court in the present petition, but it was
certainly expected of the High Court to
record some kind of reasons for rejecting the
revision petition filed by the Department at
the very threshold. A litigant has a legitimate
expectation of knowing reasons for rejection
of his claim/prayer. It is then alone, that a
party would be in a position to challenge the
order on appropriate grounds. Besides, this
would be for the benefit of the higher or the
appellate court. As arguments bring things
hidden and obscure to the light of reasons,
reasoned judgment where the law and
factual matrix of the case is discussed,
provides
lucidity
and
foundation
for
conclusions or exercise of judicial discretion
by the courts. 24.
Reason is the very
life of law. When the reason of a law once
ceases, the law itself generally ceases
(Wharton's Law Lexicon). Such is the
significance of reasoning in any rule of law.
Giving reasons furthers the cause of justice
as well as avoids uncertainty. As a matter of
fact it helps in the observance of law of
precedent. Absence of reasons on the
contrary essentially introduces an element of
uncertainty, dissatisfaction and give entirely
different dimensions to the questions of law
(2024) 12 SCC 609,
raised before the higher/appellate courts. In
our view, the court should provide its own
grounds
and
reasons
for
rejecting
claim/prayer of a party whether at the very
threshold i.e. at admission stage or after
regular hearing, howsoever concise they may
be.
25. We would reiterate the principle that
when reasons are announced and can be
weighed, the public can have assurance that
process of correction is in place and working.
It is the requirement of law that correction
process of judgments should not only appear
to be implemented but also seem to have
been properly implemented. Reasons for an
order would ensure and enhance public
confidence
and
would
provide
due
satisfaction to the consumer of justice under
our justice dispensation system. It may not
be very correct in law to say, that there is a
qualified duty imposed upon the courts to
record reasons.
26. Our procedural law and the established
practice, in fact, imposes unqualified
obligation upon the courts to record reasons.
There is hardly any statutory provision under
the Income Tax Act or under the Constitution
itself requiring recording of reasons in the
judgments but it is no more res integra and
stands unequivocally settled by different
judgments of this Court holding that the
courts and tribunals are required to pass
reasoned judgments/orders. In fact, Order 14
Rule 2 read with Order 20 Rule 1 of the Code
of Civil Procedure requires that, the court
should record findings on each issue and
such findings which obviously should be
reasoned would form part of the judgment,
which in turn would be the basis for writing a
decree of the court.
27. By practice adopted in all courts and
by virtue of judge-made law, the concept of
reasoned
judgment
has
become
an
indispensable part of basic rule of law and, in
fact, is a mandatory requirement of the
procedural law. Clarity of thoughts leads to
clarity of vision and proper reasoning is the
foundation of a just and fair decision. In
Alexander Machinery (Dudley) Ltd., 1974 ICR
120 (NIRC) there are apt observations in this
regard to say “failure to give reasons
amounts to denial of justice”. Reasons are
the real live links to the administration of
justice. With respect we will contribute to this
view. There is a rationale, logic and purpose
behind a reasoned judgment. A reasoned
judgment is primarily written to clarify own
thoughts; communicate the reasons for the
decision to the concerned and to provide and
ensure
that
such
reasons
can
be
appropriately
considered
by
the
appellate/higher court. Absence of reasons
thus would lead to frustrate the very object
stated hereinabove.”
Kranti Associates Private Limited and
another versus Masood Ahmed Khan and others, 4
inter- alia holds that even administrative decisions should
record reasons if they cause prejudice:“47. Summarizing the above discussion, this Court
holds:
(a). In India the judicial trend has always been to
record reasons, even in administrative decisions, if
such decisions affect anyone prejudicially.
(b). A quasi-judicial authority must record reasons in
support of its conclusions.
(c). Insistence on recording of reasons is meant to
serve the wider principle of justice that justice must
not only be done it must also appear to be done as
well.
(d). Recording of reasons also operates as a valid
restraint on any possible arbitrary exercise of judicial
and quasi-judicial or even administrative power.
(e). Reasons reassure that discretion has been
exercised by the decision maker on relevant grounds
and by disregarding extraneous considerations.
(2010)9 SCC 496,
(f). Reasons have virtually become as indispensable a
component of a decision making process as
observing principles of natural justice by judicial,
quasi-judicial and even by administrative bodies.
(g). Reasons facilitate the process of judicial review
by superior Courts.
(h). The ongoing judicial trend in all countries
committed to rule of law and constitutional
governance is in favour of reasoned decisions based
on relevant facts. This is virtually the life blood of
judicial decision making justifying the principle that
reason is the soul of justice.
(i). Judicial or even quasi-judicial opinions these days
can be as different as the judges and authorities who
deliver them. All these decisions serve one common
purpose which is to demonstrate by reason that the
relevant factors have been objectively considered.
This is important for sustaining the litigants' faith in
the justice delivery system.
(j). Insistence on reason is a requirement for both
judicial accountability and transparency.
(k). If a Judge or a quasi-judicial authority is not
candid enough about his/her decision making process
then it is impossible to know whether the person
deciding is faithful to the doctrine of precedent or to
principles of incrementalism.
(l). Reasons in support of decisions must be cogent,
clear and succinct. A pretence of reasons or `rubberstamp reasons' is not to be equated with a valid
decision making process.
(m). It cannot be doubted that transparency is the
sine qua non of restraint on abuse of judicial powers.
Transparency in decision making not only makes the
judges and decision makers less prone to errors but
also makes them subject to broader scrutiny. (See
David Shapiro in Defence of Judicial Candor, (1987)
1100 Harvard law Review 731-37)
(n). Since the requirement to record reasons
emanates from the broad doctrine of fairness in
decision making, the said requirement is now
virtually a component of human rights and was
considered part of Strasbourg Jurisprudence. See
Rioz Tproka v. Spain, (1994) 19 EHRR 553 EHRR. at
562 para 29 and Anya v. University of Oxford,2001
EWCA Cov 405(CA), wherein the Court referred to
Article 6 of European Convention of Human Rights
which requires, "adequate and intelligent reasons
must be given for judicial decisions".
(o). In all common law jurisdictions judgments play a
vital role in setting up precedents for the future.
Therefore, for development of law, requirement of
giving reasons for the decision is of the essence and
is virtually a part of "Due Process".
In Assistant Commissioner, Commercial
Tax Department, Works Contract and Leasing, Kota
versus Shukla Brothers5, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reiterated
that
administrative
process
will
best
be
vindicated by clarity in its exercise. It was further held
that the distinction between passing of an order by an
administrative or quasi-judicial authority has practically
extinguished and both are required to pass reasoned
orders. The relevant paras are as under:11. The Supreme Court in the case of S.N.
Mukherjee v. Union of India, while referring to the
practice adopted and insistence placed by the
Courts in United States, emphasized the
importance of recording of reasons for decisions by
the administrative authorities and tribunals. It said
"administrative process will best be vindicated by
clarity in its exercise". To enable the Courts to
exercise the power of review in consonance with
settled principles, the authorities are advised of the
considerations underlining the action under review.
This Court with approval stated:"the orderly functioning of the process of
review requires that the grounds upon which
the administrative agency acted be clearly
disclosed and adequately sustained."
12. xxx
13.
At the cost of repetition, we may notice, that
this Court has consistently taken the view that
recording of reasons is an essential feature of
(2010) 4 SCC 785.
dispensation of justice. A litigant who approaches
the Court with any grievance in accordance with
law is entitled to know the reasons for grant or
rejection of his prayer. Reasons are the soul of
orders. Non-recording of reasons could lead to dual
infirmities; firstly, it may cause prejudice to the
affected party and secondly, more particularly,
hamper the proper administration of justice. These
principles are not only applicable to administrative
or executive actions, but they apply with equal
force and, in fact, with a greater degree of
precision to judicial pronouncements. A judgment
without reasons causes prejudice to the person
against whom it is pronounced, as that litigant is
unable to know the ground which weighed with the
Court in rejecting his claim and also causes
impediments in his taking adequate and
appropriate grounds before the higher Court in the
event of challenge to that judgment. Now, we may
refer to certain judgments of this Court as well as
of the High Courts which have taken this view.
14. The principle of natural justice has twin
ingredients; firstly, the person who is likely to be
adversely affected by the action of the authorities
should be given notice to show cause thereof and
granted an opportunity of hearing and secondly,
the orders so passed by the authorities should give
reason for arriving at any conclusion showing
proper application of mind. Violation of either of
them could in the given facts and circumstances of
the case, vitiate the order itself. Such rule being
applicable to the administrative authorities
certainly requires that the judgment of the Court
should meet with this requirement with higher
degree of satisfaction. The order of an
administrative authority may not provide reasons
like a judgment but the order must be supported
by the reasons of rationality. The distinction
between passing of an order by an administrative
or
quasi-judicial
authority
has
practically
extinguished and both are required to pass
reasoned orders.”
Respondents may not have acted
as quasi-
judicial authority while rejecting petitioner’s case but
considering the factual background of the case where
there is no reflection whatsoever of the reasons for
rejection
of
petitioner’s
application,
where
there
is
nothing on record to figure out as to why the respondents
have granted LOI in favour of some institutes and refused
to the petitioner; where no criteria for grant of LOI or
restricting it to the institutes to whom it has been granted
has come forth, it has to be held that there cannot be an
arbitrary exercise of power in favour of some
qua others. There is no absolute
& denial
power with the
respondents to be exercised in a discriminative manner
without even giving the reasons for such discrimination. It
is well settled that arbitrariness is antithetical to equality
and any arbitrary State action violates Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
For the foregoing reasons, the decision of the
respondents in not granting Letter of Intent/ No Objection
Certificate in favour of the petitioner’s institute for
establishing/ running MPHW(M) Training Course is setaside. Respondent No.1/ Competent Authority is directed
to consider the case of the petitioner afresh on its own
merits in accordance with law keeping in view the
observations made herein as also keeping in view the
approvals granted to 09 institutions. This exercise be now
carried out within three weeks. The copy of order so
passed be also communicated to the petitioner.
The writ petition stands disposed of in the
above
terms,
so
also
the
pending
miscellaneous
application(s), if any.
July 10, 2026
yogesh
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review