The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
29. 08.2024, when the earlier order restricting the movement of the petitioner has not seized to have an effect. A plain reading of Section 15(5) of KAA(P) Act which we have extracted above clearly shows that a new order under Section 15(1) can be passed against the same person if he continues to be a person falling within the definition of ‘known rowdy’ or ‘known goonda’ as defined under Section 2(p) or 2(o) and if the order issued earlier under Section 15(1) has seized to have effect. Moreover, after the cessation, he should involve in an offence of the nature described under Section 2(o) or 2(p) of the KAA(P) Act at least in one instance. Therefore, the scheme of the act is that, in order to pass an order under Section 15(1) against a person who is already slapped with an order of :8: 2025:KER:31020 similar nature, he should commit an offence of the nature described in Section 2(o) or section 2(p) at least in one instance after the earlier order seized to have effect. In the case at hand, we have already found that the last prejudicial activity was not committed by the petitioner after the cessation of the effect of the earlier order, but while the earlier order was subsisting. In such circumstances, the subsequent order passed under Section 15(1) again against the same person will not be sustained. If at all, the respondents have any grievance regarding the repetition of the of…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31020
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.B.SURESH KUMAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE JOBIN SEBASTIAN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(CRL.) NO. 140 OF 2025
PETITIONER:
SHIHAB K P., AGED 28 YEARS
S/O SHAJAHAN, KANHIRAMPARA HOUSE, KOOLIKKAL,
MAMPAD POST, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT., PIN - 676542
BY ADVS.
P.SAMSUDIN
JASNEED JAMAL
LIRA A.B.
DEVIKA E.D.
ABIN RASHID
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO
HOME DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM., PIN - 695001
THE STATION HOUSE OFFICER NILAMBUR
NILAMBUR POLICE STATION, NILAMBUR P.O.,
MALAPPURAM DISTRICT., PIN - 679329
THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
THRISSUR RANGE. THRISSUR DISTRICT., PIN - 680001
THE DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF MALAPPURAM, POLICE HEAD
QUARTERS, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT., PIN - 676505
BY ADVS.
SRI. K.A. ANAS, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 27.03.2025, THE COURT ON 10.04.2025 DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
WP(C) No.140/2025
:2:
2025:KER:31020
JUDGMENT
Jobin Sebastian, J.
This is a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India challenging Ext.P2 order of externment dated 26.11.2024 passed
against the petitioner under Section 15(1)(a) r/w 15(5) of the Kerala
Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 [KAA(P) Act for the sake of
brevity].
2.
By the said order, the petitioner was interdicted from entering
the jurisdictional limits of Malappuram District, for one year from the date
of the receipt of the order. However, after considering the representation
submitted by the externee, the Advisory Board modified the said order,
and the period of externment was reduced to six months from the date of
the service of the impugned order and it is further directed that after the
expiry of the period of six months of externment, the petitioner shall
appear before the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Nilambur, on every
Sundays, between 10 a.m. and 1.00 p.m. for the remaining period of three
months.
3.
The records available before us reveal that it was after
considering the recurrent involvement of the petitioner in criminal cases,
the District Police Chief, Malappuram submitted a proposal for the initiation
:3:
WP(C) No.140/2025
2025:KER:31020
of proceedings against the petitioner, under Section 15(1) (a) r/w 15(5) of
the KAA(P) Act, 2007 before the authorised officer, the Deputy Inspector
General of Police, Thrissur Range. For initiation of proceedings, the
petitioner has been classified as a “known goonda” as defined under
Section 2(o)(i) r/w 2(j) of the KAA(P) Act, 2007.
4.
For passing the order of externment, the authorities reckoned
4 cases in which the petitioner was involved. The details of the said cases
are as follows:
Sl.
No.
Crime No.
Police Station
934/2022
Nilambur
379 IPC and 20 r/w 23 of 9.12.2022
KPRB and RRS Act.
Convicted
111/2022
Nilambur
379 IPC and 20r/w 23 of
KPRB and RRS Act.
Pending
trial
1431/2023
Nilambur
379 IPC and 20 r/w 23,12 10.12.2023
of KPRB and RRS Act.
1100/2024
5.
Nilambur
Sections involved
303(2) BNS and section
20,23 of KPRB and RRS
Act and section 56,196
r/w 146 of MV Act.
Date of
occurrence
16.02.2022
29.8.2024
Status of
case
Pending
trial
Pending
trial
Heard Sri.Jasneed Jamal, the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner and Sri. K.A. Anas, the learned Government Pleader.
6.
On perusal of the records it is gatherable that the last
prejudicial activity considered by the Superintendent of Police, Malappuram
WP(C) No.140/2025
:4:
2025:KER:31020
to moot the proposal for initiation of proceedings under the KAA(P) Act is
crime No.1100/2024 of Nilambur Police Station registered against the
petitioner alleging commission of offences punishable under Sections
303(2) BNS and 20 and 23 of Kerala Protection of River Banks and
Regulation of Removal of Sand Act, 2001. The last prejudicial activity was
committed on 29.08.2024.
The petitioner was arrested in this case on
02.09.2024 and released on bail on 04.09.2024. Records further reveal
that, after his release from jail, it was on 24.10.2024, the District Police
Chief had submitted a proposal for initiation of proceedings under the
KAA(P)Act against the petitioner. Thereafter, the jurisdictional authority
issued a notice on 05.11.2024 calling upon the petitioner to show cause
why an order of externment shall not be passed against him. He was also
directed to appear in person for a personal hearing on 19.11.2024.
Accordingly, the petitioner appeared before the jurisdictional authority on
19.11.2024.
It was after considering his written objection and
submissions,
the impugned order of externment was passed on
26.11.2024.
7.
The sequence of events narrated above reveals that there is
no inordinate delay in passing the impugned order.
Moreover, an
externment order under the KAA(P) Act is having a significant bearing on
the personal as well as fundamental rights of an individual. Therefore,
WP(C) No.140/2025
:5:
2025:KER:31020
some minimum time is required to collect the details of the cases in which
the petitioner is involved and to comply with the procedural formalities.
Therefore, we are of the view that it could not be said that the live link
between the last prejudicial activity and the purpose of the impugned
order is snapped. Moreover, unlike in the case of an order of detention
passed under Section 3 of KAA(P) Act, even if some delay has been
occured in passing an order of externment, the same has no serious
bearing, as the consequences of both the orders are different. Because an
order of detention is a grave deprivation of the personal liberty of the
person detained. We are cognizant that Section 15 also visits the person
concerned with an intrusion to his personal liberty within the limit of
Article 21 especially when the said order restrains a citizen from his right
to travel in any part of India. However, when a detention order under
Section 3 is compared with an order of externment passed under Section
15(1) of KAA(P) Act, the latter visits a person with lesser deprivation of
liberty. Therefore, the nature of proceedings under Section 3 and Section
15 are inherently different. In this regard, we are fortified by the decision
in Stalin C.V. v. State of Kerala and others [2011 (1) KHC 852].
8.
One of the main contentions raised by the learned counsel for
the petitioner is that the order of externment impugned by way of this writ
petition was passed by the jurisdictional authority while another order
WP(C) No.140/2025
:6:
2025:KER:31020
under Section 15(1) of KAA(P) Act requiring him to appear before the Sub
Divisional Police Officer, Nilambur on every Saturday between 11 a.m. and
3 p.m. for six months was subsisting against the petitioner. According to
the counsel, an order of externment under section 15(5) of KAA(P) Act can
be passed against a person only if the earlier order passed under Section
15 (1) is seized to have an effect and after such cessation, he has again
involved in an offence of the nature described in Section 2(o) or 2(p) at
least in one instance. The learned counsel would submit that the earlier
order restricting the movement of the petitioner was passed against the
petitioner on 21.03.2024 and the said order ceases to have effect only on
26.09.2024. Therefore, the subsequent order of externment passed with
respect to an offence allegedly committed on 29.08.2024, that too before
the cessation of the earlier order will not sustain. While considering the
said contention it is necessary to refer the provision contained under
Section 15(5) of the KAA(P) Act.
15(5); if an order issued under sub section 1 above has
seized to have effect for any reason, a new order under the said sub
section may be issued against the same person, if he continues to
be a person falling within the definition of known rowdy or known
goonda given under Section 2(o) or 2(p) and if after such cessation,
he has again involved in an offence of the nature described in
Section 2(o) or 2(p) at least in one instance.
WP(C) No.140/2025
9.
:7:
2025:KER:31020
In the case at hand, it is an admitted fact that an order
restricting the movement of the petitioner has been passed earlier against
the petitioner and the order which is under challenge in this writ petition is
passed subsequently. The earlier order under Section 15(1) of KAA(P) Act
was passed on 21.03.2024 and in terms of the said order, the same will
cease to have effect only on 26.09.2024. Anyhow, the subsequent order
of externment was passed on 26.11.2024. Therefore, it cannot be said
that the said order of externment was passed before the earlier order had
ceased to have effect. Anyhow, it is apparent that the offence which led
to the passing of the externment order was committed by the petitioner on
29.08.2024, when the earlier order restricting the movement of the
petitioner has not seized to have an effect. A plain reading of Section
15(5) of KAA(P) Act which we have extracted above clearly shows that a
new order under Section 15(1) can be passed against the same person if
he continues to be a person falling within the definition of ‘known rowdy’
or ‘known goonda’ as defined under Section 2(p) or 2(o) and if the order
issued earlier under Section 15(1) has seized to have effect. Moreover,
after the cessation, he should involve in an offence of the nature described
under Section 2(o) or 2(p) of the KAA(P) Act at least in one instance.
Therefore, the scheme of the act is that, in order to pass an order under
Section 15(1) against a person who is already slapped with an order of
WP(C) No.140/2025
:8:
2025:KER:31020
similar nature, he should commit an offence of the nature described in
Section 2(o) or section 2(p) at least in one instance after the earlier order
seized to have effect. In the case at hand, we have already found that the
last prejudicial activity was not committed by the petitioner after the
cessation of the effect of the earlier order, but while the earlier order was
subsisting.
In such circumstances, the subsequent order passed under
Section 15(1) again against the same person will not be sustained. If at
all, the respondents have any grievance regarding the repetition of the
offence during the currency of the earlier order passed under Section
15(1), the respondent could have very well proceeded against the
petitioner for violation of the order and the remedy was not to pass
another order again.
Resultantly, Ext.P2 order is set aside and the petition stands allowed.
Sd/P.B. SURESH KUMAR
JUDGE
Sd/JOBIN SEBASTIAN
JUDGE
ncd
:9:
WP(C) No.140/2025
2025:KER:31020
APPENDIX OF WP(CRL.) 140/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO. B3-4011/2024/TSR DATED
21-03-2024 OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF ORDER PASSED BY THE 3RD
RESPONDENT U/S 15 (5) OF THE ACT VIDE ORDER
NO. B3-19876/2024/TSR DATED 26-11-2024
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF ORDER BY KAAPA ADVISORY BOARD IN
OP229/2024 VIDE ORDER DATED 07/01/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review