Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: December 19, 2025
Pronounced on: January 05, 2026
%
+
RC.REV. 313/2023, CM APPL. 57766/2023
SHASHIKANT DIXIT
Through:
.....Petitioner
Dr. Amit George, Ms. Hitaakshi
Mehra, Mr. Nitesh Mehra and Mr.
Dushyant Kishan Kaul, Advs.
Versus
RENUKA SHARMA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Preet Pal Singh, Ms. Tanupreet
Kaur and Ms. Medha Navami, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAURABH BANERJEE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner/ landlord1 filed an eviction petition being RC ARC
57/2018 entitled ‘Shashikant Dixit vs. Renuka Sharma’ under Section
14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 19582 against the respondent/
tenant3 seeking eviction of the property bearing Flat no.313, DDA Tower
No. 1, Mount Kailash, East of Kailash, New Delhi4, before the learned
Senior Civil Judge-cum-Rent Controller, South-East District, Saket Courts,
Delhi5.
2.
Briefly put, it was the case of the landlord therein that the respondent
Hereinafter ‘landlord’
Hereinafter ‘DRC Act’
Hereinafter ‘tenant’
Hereinafter ‘subject premises’
Hereinafter ‘learned RC’
RC.REV. 313/2023
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
15:15:23
was inducted as a tenant by the erstwhile owner and that the landlord
became the owner of the subject premises by virtue of the registered
Agreement to Sell and Purchase, General Power of Attorney, Special
Power of Attorney, Will and Possession Letter, all dated 13.08.19996
executed in his favour by the erstwhile owner for a sale consideration of
Rs.7,00,000/-. As the landlord with his wife were residing with his own
brother and his family, it was causing acute inconvenience to both families
due to the growing needs of their respective households, moreover, since
the son of the landlord’s brother also get married on 23.11.2016, his brother
has requested to vacate the said premises. Hence, there was a bona fide
requirement by the landlord for residential purpose of his family members
as there were no other suitable alternative accommodation available with
them for the same.
3.
Upon service, the tenant filed her application seeking leave to
defend. It was her case that she was neither a tenant of the landlord nor he
was the owner-landlord of the subject premises as she had entered into an
Agreement to Sell dated 01.06.1996 with the erstwhile owner qua the
subject premises. Although, she had paid the sale consideration, however,
the landlord in collusion with the erstwhile owner, subsequently executed
fraudulent documents purporting to transfer the subject premises in favour
of the landlord. Even though a Suit for Specific Performance being CS DJ
No.609557/167 instituted by her against them was dismissed vide order
dated 31.08.2018, however, an appeal being RFA 213/20198 entitled
‘Renuka Sharma vs. Surinder Singh Sodhi & Anr.’ is already pending
Hereinafter ‘possessory documents’
Hereinafter ‘Suit’
Hereinafter ‘Appeal’
RC.REV. 313/2023
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
15:15:23
before this Court. Therefore, the issue of ownership of the subject premises
is yet to attain finality. Lastly, it was stated that the landlord had other
alternative accommodation available with him and the need projected by
the landlord was not genuine or bona fide.
4.
In response, as per landlord since there was no stay granted by this
Court in the Appeal, the pendency thereof could not come in the way. In
any event, the erstwhile owner of the subject premises has himself admitted
the sale of the subject premises to the landlord herein while deposing as a
witness in the Suit.
5.
Hearing the parties, the learned RC proceeded to pass the order dated
04.10.20239, allowing the application of the tenant seeking leave to defend
as the tenant was able to raise a triable issue qua the alleged claim of the
landlord qua the ownership and landlord tenant relationship between the
parties over the subject premises.
6.
Hence, the present petition filed by the landlord seeking setting aside
of the impugned order dated 04.10.2023 passed by the learned RC.
7.
Though the landlord has raised various grounds herein, Dr. Amit
George, learned counsel for the landlord primarily submitted that the
learned RC failed to appreciate that the landlord is in possession of various
possessory documents relating to the subject premises in his favour
executed by the erstwhile owner. Moreover, the Suit of the tenant against
the landlord and the erstwhile owner has already been dismissed by the
learned Trial Court qua the very same subject premises.
8.
Dr. Amit George, learned counsel further submitted that the plea qua
ownership raised by the tenant was vague and uncorroborated. Relying
Hereinafter ‘impugned order’
RC.REV. 313/2023
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
15:15:23
upon Sardar Mahinder Singh vs. Sukhwant Kaur10, the learned counsel
submitted that the issue of ownership in an Eviction Petition under Section
14(1)(e) of the DRC Act need not be that of absolute title/ ownership,
rather the requirement of ownership under the DRC Act is of a title better
than that of the tenant, which the landlord was clearly able to establish by
relying upon the possessory documents in his favour.
In light of the
aforesaid, Dr. Amit George, learned counsel urged that the impugned order
is liable to be set aside.
9.
Per contra, Mr. Preet Pal Singh, learned counsel for the tenant
supporting the impugned order submitted that since a categoric plea/
dispute qua ownership of the subject premises has been raised by the
tenant, more so, since the erstwhile owner of the subject premises had
entered into an Agreement to Sell dated 01.06.1996 with the tenant as also
an Appeal is still pending before this Court, as also that the alleged
possessory documents are all fabricated documents executed by the
landlord in connivance with the erstwhile owner. In view thereof, he
submitted that the impugned order needs no interference as they were
sufficient for raising a triable issue.
10.
Lastly, relying upon Liaq Ahmed vs. Habeeb-Ur-Rehmaan11, S.S.
Puri vs. S.P. Malhotra12 and Sh. Najmul Arafeen Chawla & Anr. vs. Dr.
Mohd. Najeeb13, and the Scheme of the DRC Act, Mr. Preet Pal Singh,
learned counsel submitted that since the tenant was able to disclose grounds
as also prima facie show a cause which was not baseless, unreal, and
20l9 (258) DLT 605
2000 (5) SCC 708
2002 (95) DLT 399
2025 (318) DLT 631
RC.REV. 313/2023
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
15:15:23
unfounded, the learned RC was obligated to grant the leave to defend
against the eviction sought by the landlord. Further, relying upon Abid-UlIslam vs. Inder Sain Dua14, the learned counsel submitted that as per the
settled position of law, the degree of interference by the revisionary Court
is to be exercised sparingly and only under exceptional circumstances
under Section 25B of the DRC Act. In light of the aforesaid, Mr. Preet Pal
Singh, learned counsel urged this Court to uphold the impugned order.
11.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at considerable length, as also
carefully gone through the documents and pleadings on record and the
judgments cited by them at the Bar.
12.
It is an admitted fact that the landlord had filed possessory
documents before the learned RC. As held in Shanti Sharma vs. Ved
Prabha15, it is now well-settled that based thereon once the landlord herein
was able to show a ‘better title’ in his favour than the tenant, there was no
occasion for the learned RC to go into the issue of ownership, when,
admittedly after observing in the impugned order that in view of the
Transfer of Property Act, 188216 the learned RC did not have the
jurisdiction to deal with it. Since the eviction proceedings under the DRC
Act are not pertaining to ‘absolute title’, and they were not under the TP
Act, it was beyond the realm of the learned RC to adjudicate upon the
same, as also consider that there was no registered Sale Deed to return a
finding that the tenant was able to raise a triable issue. Presiding over rent
control matters, learned RC has wrongly assumed the role of a Civil Court.
13.
Once the landlord was in possession of the possessory documents in
(2022) 6 SCC 30
(1987) 4 SCC 193
Hereinafter ‘TP Act’
RC.REV. 313/2023
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
15:15:23
his favour, challenge whereof has already been negated in another
proceedings initiated by the tenant, the tenant could not have questioned
the title and/ or the documents therefor in favour of the landlord and/ or the
date(s) of execution thereof under eviction proceedings. Thus, the
pendency of the Appeal was no bar and could not have been considered by
the learned RC.
14.
Likewise, initiation of proceedings prior to the filing of the Eviction
Petition by the landlord was/ is not a basis under the DRC Act.
15.
Lastly, the statement made by the erstwhile owner in the Suit, being
made before a Court of Law in a judicial proceedings, ought to have been
given due weightage independently by the learned RC as well.
16.
In view thereof, there is no gain-saying that the landlord tenant
relationship between the parties are not established.
17.
Thus, the impugned order is liable to be set aside. However, since
there are no findings rendered on merits regarding the bona fide
requirement by the landlord, if any, as also non-availability of a suitable
alternative accommodation with him, in view of Hindustan Petroleum
Corporation Limited vs. Dilbahar Singh17, wherein it is well-settled that
while acting in supervisory jurisdiction under Section 25B(8) of the DRC
Act, this Court can test whether the impugned order suffers from any
arbitrariness, perversity, illegality, impropriety or the like. Consequently,
finding manifest errors in the impugned order, as also in view of the
documents and pleadings before this Court, it becomes the bounden duty of
this Court to invoke its powers under revisional jurisdiction.
18.
For the sake of completeness qua the aspect of bona fide requirement
(2014) 9 SCC 78
RC.REV. 313/2023
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
15:15:23
of the landlord, which has not been argued for and on behalf of the tenant,
since it has consistently been the case of the landlord that he required the
subject premises for residential purpose of his family members and as held
in Baldev Singh Bajwa vs. Monish Saini18 & Kanahaiya Lal Arya vs. Md.
Ehshan & Ors.19, this Court is of the view that a genuine assertion by the
landlord, like the present, is sufficient to presume the genuineness thereof.
Also, since the landlord who was/ is the sole and best judge of his own
bona fide requirement, with the tenant having no role to play therein. The
assertions made by the tenant qua the same before the learned RC have no
cogent basis and/ or substantiation for raising a triable issue.
19.
Similarly, regarding non-availability of alternative accommodation
with the landlord, which has also not been argued for and on behalf of the
tenant, as held in Yodh Raj, Satya Prakash & Sons [Firm] & Anr. vs.
Narain Kumar & Sons [HUF]20, it was/ is the paramount discretion of the
landlord to asses his own requirements, needs, necessities, purpose,
sufficiency and suitability qua residing in the subject premises with his
family members, on which the tenant has no say, especially, whence once
again, there was nothing on record before the learned RC substantiating
anything contrary thereto, barring bald assertions. Therefore, the tenant was
unable to raise a triable issue thereon as well.
20.
In view of the aforesaid analysis and findings, the present revision
petition is allowed and the impugned order dated 04.10.2023 passed by the
learned RC is set aside.
21.
Resultantly, an order of eviction is passed in favour of the landlord in
MANU/SC/0264/2025
AIR 1999 SC 100
227[2016] DLT 363
RC.REV. 313/2023
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
15:15:23
respect of property bearing Flat no.313, DDA Tower No. 1, Mount Kailash,
East of Kailash, New Delhi, albeit, the same shall be given effect to only
after the expiry of six months period from today in terms of Section 14(7)
of the DRC Act.
22.
Accordingly, the present petition along with the pending application
is disposed of in terms of the above with no order as to costs.
SAURABH BANERJEE, J.
JANUARY 05, 2026
Ab/DA
RC.REV. 313/2023
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
15:15:23
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review