Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE UDAY KUMAR
CRR 4691 OF 2024
SHARAD KUMAR SETH
-VSTHE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ANR.
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Pratim Priya Dasgupta,
Mr. Prabhat Kumar Srivastava,
Mr. Tirthankar Kumar Dey,
Ms. Ankita Singh
For the State
: Ms. Sreyashee Biswas,
Ms. Singdha Saha
Hearing concluded on
: 24.02.2026
Judgment on
: 20.03.2026
UDAY KUMAR, J.: –
1. This is an application under Section 528 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (corresponding to Section 482
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973), seeking the quashing
of the proceedings in connection with G.R. Case No. 2087 of
2011, arising out of Sankrail Police Station Case No. 225 of
CRR 4691 OF 2024
2011, currently pending before the Learned Judicial Magistrate,
1st Court, Howrah. The Petitioner stands arraigned for the
alleged commission of offences punishable under Sections 420,
471, and 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
2. The central theme of this adjudication involves a delicate
intersection of criminal jurisprudence and equity in commercial
transactions. The question posed for this Court’s determination
is whether a criminal prosecution for forgery and cheating can
be sustained against a corporate director who, having been
allegedly
misled
into
a
defective
land
purchase
by
impersonators, subsequently cured the defect by paying full
market consideration to the rightful owner. The Court must
determine if the "restitution of a private property dispute" via a
registered instrument renders the continuation of the criminal
trial an exercise in futility and an abuse of the judicial process.
3. The genesis of the present litigation traces back to early 2008.
The Petitioner, acting in his capacity as a Director of South Asia
Rubber and Polymers Parks, was in search of land for a
corporate project. He was introduced by local intermediaries to
Sk. Ambia and Seikh Moktar, who held themselves out as the
absolute title-holders of 57 decimals of Sali land in Mouza Jala
Dhulagari. Relying upon the title deeds produced by the said
individuals, the Petitioner executed a registered Deed of
CRR 4691 OF 2024
Conveyance on May 9, 2008, paying a consideration of Rs.
6,20,727/- through banking channels.
4. The status quo was disrupted on March 19, 2011, when the
Opposite Party No. 2, Mansura Begum, visited the site and
asserted her title based on a 1983 registered sale deed. It then
surfaced that the 2008 deed was purportedly a product of
impersonation and forgery. Aggrieved by this revelation, the
Opposite Party No. 2 moved a petition under Section 156(3) of
the Cr.P.C., leading to the registration of the FIR on May 6,
2011.
5. A pivotal turn occurred during the investigation. The Petitioner,
upon realizing the title was defective, opted for "restitution"
rather than evasive litigation. On August 11, 2011, a second
Registered Deed of Conveyance was executed, whereby the
Petitioner paid a further, substantial sum of Rs. 22,61,155/- to
Mansura
Begum—nearly
four
times
the
original
price—to
regularize the title. Consequently, the Complainant filed an
affidavit before the Learned Magistrate confirming that the
dispute was amicably settled and she had no further grievances.
6. Notwithstanding
this
documented
settlement
and
the
Complainant's formal request to the police to withdraw the case,
the investigating agency submitted a Charge Sheet (No.
408/12) on April 30, 2012. While the Investigating Officer (I.O.)
CRR 4691 OF 2024
noted the "amicable settlement," the prayer for trial against the
Petitioner was maintained, prompting this revisional challenge.
7. Mr. Pratim Priya Dasgupta, Learned Counsel for the Petitioner
characterized
the
continued
prosecution
as
"manifestly
oppressive." The primary thrust of his argument is that the
Petitioner is not a perpetrator of fraud, but a bona fide
purchaser
for
value
who
fell
victim
to
a
sophisticated
impersonation scam.
8. Mr. Dasgupta argued that the initial payment via an account
payee cheque in 2008 is the antithesis of "dishonest intention."
Furthermore, he submitted that the subsequent voluntary
payment of a significantly higher sum in 2011 to the true owner
serves as a conclusive rebuttal of any fraudulent intent. Relying
on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) 10 SCC 303, it is
argued that as the dispute is purely private and restitution is
complete, the criminality has effectively evaporated. He further
submitted that the Charge Sheet is "conspicuously silent" as to
any
evidence—forensic
or
otherwise—suggesting
that
the
Petitioner manufactured the 2008 deed. In the absence of an
expert report or proof of knowledge of the forgery, the charge
under Section 471 cannot be sustained. So, he prayed for
quashing of the instant proceedings as it amounts to abuse of
process against the petitioner.
CRR 4691 OF 2024
9. Curiously, Mr. Sreyashee Biswas, the learned Counsel for the
State and the Opposite Party No. 2 find themselves in a unique
position. The record contains an unequivocal stand by the
Complainant herself, stating:
"The dispute has been mutually settled... I have no
further
claim...
I
do
hereby
withdraw
the
said
complaint."
7. The State, however, maintains that because offences under
Sections 467 and 471 are non-compoundable, the I.O. was
procedurally bound to submit a Charge Sheet, regardless of the
private settlement.
8. Having
scanned
the
records
and
mulled
over
the
rival
contentions, this Court identifies the following quintessential
questions for determination:
I.
Whether the subsequent act of "re-purchasing" the
land from the rightful owner at a higher price serves
as conclusive evidence to negate the mens rea
("dishonest intention") required under Section 420 IPC
at the inception of the transaction?
II. Whether a bona fide purchaser of property, who is
himself a victim of impersonation by the sellers, can
be held criminally liable for "using a forged document"
(Section 471 IPC) in the absence of evidence showing
his knowledge of the forgery?
CRR 4691 OF 2024
III. Whether the "Settlement of a Private Land Dispute"
through a registered deed, followed by an affidavit of
the complainant, renders the continuation of a 13year-old criminal proceeding an "abuse of process"
warranting the exercise of inherent powers under
Section 528 BNSS (Section 482 CrPC)?
IV. Whether the Investigating Agency, having noted the
"amicable settlement" in the Charge Sheet, was
justified in praying for trial against the purchaser, or
whether such an act reflects a "mechanical application
of mind" by the police?
9. I have scanned the records with clinical precision and, after
mulling over the submissions, I find that this case presents a
classic conflict between the rigors of criminal procedure and the
equities of a bona fide commercial transaction. The core of this
adjudication rests on whether the "criminality" survived after
the "restitution."
10. The quintessential ingredient of "cheating" is a dishonest
intention existing at the inception of the transaction. The
Petitioner argues that his conduct—paying twice for the same
land—negates such intent. A person intending to "grab" land
would not leave a transparent banking trail. As highlighted by
the Petitioner, the re-purchase on August 11, 2011, for a sum of
Rs. 22,61,155/- is an act that unequivocally demonstrates bona
CRR 4691 OF 2024
fide intention. If the Petitioner had intended to "cheat," he
would not have voluntarily enriched the complainant to the tune
of nearly four times the original price to rectify the title. Such
subsequent conduct serves as a conclusive rebuttal of any
fraudulent intent at the threshold of the transaction.
11. To sustain a charge of "using a forged document as genuine,"
the prosecution must establish that the accused had knowledge
that the document was forged. The record is conspicuously
silent on any material linking the Petitioner to the creation of
the forged deed. The Petitioner was a bona fide purchaser for
value who acted on registered documents. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court, in Anukul Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2025) INSC
1153,
reiterated
the
standards
for
quashing,
stating
at
Paragraph 11.5:
"It is the duty of the High Court to intervene where
continuation of criminal proceedings would amount to an
abuse of process of law... The court must ensure that
criminal proceedings are not used as a weapon of
harassment."
12. In the present case, the harassment is evident. The Petitioner
was a victim of an impersonation scam by the co-accused. To
try the Petitioner for forgery, when he himself was financially
bled by the fraud and subsequently indemnified the true owner,
would be a perversion of the criminal justice system.
CRR 4691 OF 2024
13. I find that the continuation of this 13-year-old proceeding has
become
a
classic
case
of
an
"abuse
of
process."
The
Investigating Officer (I.O.) recorded in the Charge Sheet that
the dispute had already been amicably settled, yet prayed for a
trial. The I.O. acted mechanically by ignoring that the "wrongful
loss" which triggered the FIR had been transformed into a "fair
gain" via a registered instrument.
14. As held in the landmark case of Gian Singh v. State of Punjab
(2012) 10 SCC 303, the High Court must exercise its power to
quash when the dispute is predominantly civil or private and
the parties have settled. The Hon'ble Court observed at
Paragraph 61:
"But the criminal cases having overwhelmingly and predominatingly civil flavour stand on a different footing...
the High Court may quash the criminal proceeding if in
its view... the possibility of conviction is remote and
bleak."
15. This is a quintessential civil dispute dressed in criminal attire.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Indian Oil Corpn. v. NEPC India
Ltd. (2006) 6 SCC 736 and G. Sagar Suri v. State of U.P.
warned against using criminal courts as a "weapon of coercion"
to settle civil disputes. Once the title was regularized via the
2011 Deed, the foundation of the criminal case collapsed.
CRR 4691 OF 2024
16. Based on the exhaustive factual analysis and the application of
settled legal principles, this Court arrives at the following legal
conclusions:
I.
The act of an accused paying full consideration to the
rightful owner upon discovery of a defective title
serves as a conclusive rebuttal of "dishonest intent"
under Section 420 IPC.
II. In the absence of evidence showing a prior "meeting
of minds" to forge, a purchaser for value cannot be
prosecuted for the fraud committed by his sellers.
III. In
private
property
complete
and
through
a
disputes,
acknowledged
registered
once
by
deed,
restitution
the
the
is
complainant
"criminality"
is
extinguished for all practical purposes.
17. In
light
of
the
discussions
above,
I
conclude
that
the
continuation of the proceedings in G.R. Case No. 2087 of 2011
against the Petitioner would amount to be an abuse of the
process of law, as the dispute being private and civil in nature,
has been conclusively settled between the parties through
registered instruments and full financial restitution.
18. For the reasons recorded hereinabove, the present Criminal
Revision application is allowed. Accordingly:
CRR 4691 OF 2024
i.
The proceedings in connection with G.R. Case No. 2087
of 2011 arising out of Sankrail P.S. Case No. 225/2011
are hereby quashed and set aside, but only insofar as
the Petitioner, Sharad Kumar Seth, is concerned.
ii.
The Petitioner is hereby discharged from his bail bonds.
Any security or documents deposited shall be returned
to him forthwith.
iii.
It is directed that the trial shall proceed against the
remaining accused persons (the alleged impersonators
and sellers) in accordance with the law, with utmost
expedition. The quashing of proceedings against the
bona fide purchaser does not absolve those who
allegedly manufactured the forged instruments.
iv.
The Learned Trial Court is directed to isolate the trial
and proceed with vigor against the primary offenders.
v.
All connected applications stand disposed of.
19. Let a copy of this judgment be sent to the learned Trial Court
for immediate compliance.
20. The Trial Court Record (TCR), if any, shall be sent down to the
Trial Court, at once.
21. Case diary, if any, be returned forthwith.
22. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties, as expeditiously as possible, upon
compliance with the necessary formalities in this regard.
CRR 4691 OF 2024
23. Parties to act on a server copy of this order.
(Uday Kumar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review