Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Criminal Appeal (S.J.) No. 737 of 2024
---------1.Shankar Mahto, son of Late Bhondwa Mahto, aged
about 62 years,
2.Jiwan Devi, wife of Shankar Mahto, aged 58 years,
3.Rathu Mahto, son of Late Chamra Mahto, aged about 63
years
4.Parmila Devi, wife of Rathu Mahto, aged about 58 years,
5.Asha Devi, wife of Arun Mahto, aged about 26 years,
6.Anand Mahto, son of Shankar Mahto, aged about 38
years,
All residents of village-Kathchancho, P.O.
Mandar, P.S. Mandar, District-Ranchi, Jharkhand
7.Rajendra Gope @ Rajendra Mahto, son of Late Sarju
Mahto, aged about 37 years, resident of Village-Mandar,
P.O. and P.S. Mandar, District-Ranchi
..… Appellants
Versus
1.The State of Jharkhand
2.Mary Lakra, wife of Late Arun Ekka, resident of village
Kathchcho, Post Mandar, Police Station Mandar, District
Ranchi
….. Respondents
---------CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PRASAD
---------For the Appellants : Mr. Samavesh Bhanjdeo, Advocate
For the State
: Mr. Shree Prakash Jha, A.P.P.
For Resp.No. 2
: Ms. Khalida Haya Rashmi, Advocate
Mr. Shreya Anugrah Balmuchu, Adv.
C.A.V. Order
---------Pronounced on 06.05.2026
This Criminal Appeal has been filed on
behalf of the appellants, namely Shankar Mahto, Jiwan
Devi, Rathu Mahto, Parmila Devi, Asha Devi, Anand
Mahto and Rajendra Gope @ Rajendra Mahto, under
Section 14-A of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act, who are apprehending their
arrest in connection with Mandar P.S. Case no. 36 of
2021, instituted for the offences under Sections 147, 148,
149, 341, 323, 427, 504 & 506 of I.P.C. and under
Sections 3(1)(r)(w) of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act (To be referred to
hereinafter as S.C./S.T. Act), which is presently pending
in the Court of learned A.J.C.II-cum-Special Judge,
S.C./S.T. Act, Ranchi.
2.
Lakra,
As per F.I.R., Informant, namely Mary
wife
of
Arun
Lakra,
has
alleged
that
on
22.02.2021, at about 11.15 A.M., the accused persons,
i.e. Shankar Mahto, Jiwan Devi, Ranthu Mahto, Pramila
Devi, Asha Devi, Anand Mahto and Rajendra Gope @
Rajendra Mahto and other 25-30 unknown persons came
near her house and destroyed her fruits and eggs which
she was selling in her property and also demolished the
boundary wall of her house again and used caste symbol
word and pelted stones and bricks upon her and had
demanded Rangdari of Rs.10,00,000/-. It is further
alleged that Mandar Police Station is near to her house,
but the Police has not apprehended the appellants.
It is further alleged that even prior to this
incident she had also lodged F.I.R. against these accused
persons on 04.01.2021 under Sections 341, 323, 427,
504, 506 and under the provision of SC/ST Act. She has
suffered a loss of property to the tune of around
Rs.5,50,000/- and she wants compensation.
3.
Heard learned counsel for the appellants,
learned counsel for the State and learned counsel for the
Respondent No.2-Informant.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellants has
submitted that the appellants are innocent and have
committed no offence and have been falsely implicated.
It is submitted that the disputed land in
question pertaining to R.S. Khata No. 28, Plot No.s 73,
648, 665, 963 measuring an area of 3.57 acres of land at
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
Mauza Kathchancho, P.S. Mandar within Revenue Thana
No. 89 of District Ranchi was recorded in the Draft
Records of Right in the name of Jharia Ahir and Kunwa
Ahir, both sons of Gopla Ahir as Khatyani which was
finally published around the year 1935.
However,
Raiyat
Kunwa
Ahir
died
issueless and the other recorded tenant namely Jharia
Ahir due to need of money sold the land of R.S. Khata
No.28, Plot No.s 73, 648, 665, 963 measuring an area of
3.57 acres of Khata No. 28 and R.S. Plot No. 210 and 211
measuring an area of 7 decimal land of Khata No.54 to
Baiju Ahir, son of Mangra Ahir by virtue of registered Sale
Deed on 21.12.1965 which was entered in Book No.1,
Volume No. 22, Page No. 213 to 215 being Sale Deed No.
8286. After purchasing the aforesaid land, Baiju Ahir, son
of Mangra Ahir applied for mutation of land and after due
enquiry it was mutated in their name and was granted
rent receipts year by year.
Thereafter the said vendee namely Baiju
Ahir, son of Mangra Ahir, sold the purchased land
measuring an area 1.78 acres land and Plot No.s 210 and
211, measuring an area of 3.50 decimal land of Khata no.
54 (Belagan) total measuring an area 1.82 acres land of
mouza Katchchancho to Late Chamra Mahto @ Ahir,
Sukhram Ahir, Bhulwa Ahir, Bhondwa Mahto @ Ahir,
Sahua Ahir and Sanichara Ahir, i.e. the ancestors of the
present
appellants
by
Registered
Sale
Deed
dated
13.02.1973 which was entered in Book No.1, Vol.No.83,
Page No.s 226 to 228. After purchasing the aforesaid land,
the ancestors of the present Appellant No.3,
namely
Ranthu Mahto, and others filed a Mutation case and after
due enquiry it was mutated in their name and were
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
granted rent receipts year by year by the Anchal Officer
and granted rent receipt, except the Khata No. 54, being
Plot No. 210 and 211 which was Belagan being plot no.
73, 648, 665 and 963 of Khata No. 28, total measuring an
area of 1.78 Acres land in the name of Chamra Ahir
(Father of the Appellant No.3) and others which is still
running in the name of Chamra Ahir and others who were
the ancestors of the present appellants and the vendee
namely Chamra Ahir died leaving behind three sons
namely Mahadeo Mahto, Shiv Sagar Mahto and Ranthu
Mahto(Appellant No.3).
It is submitted that the Appellant No. 4,
Pramila Devi is the wife of Ranthu Mahto (Appellant No.3).
5.
It is further submitted that Bhandua Ahir
@ Bholua Ahir, Vendee No.3 died leaving behind two sons
namely Shankar Mahto (Appellant No.1) and Shibu Mahto
and the Appellant No.2, namely Jiwan Devi happens to be
the wife of the Shankar Mahto (Appellant No.1) and the
Appellant No.6, namely Anand Mahto, happens to be the
son of the Appellant No.s 1 and 2.
It is submitted that the Appellant No.7, namely
Rajendra Mahto @ Rajendra Gope has no concern with the
land in question nor does he come within the genealogical
table of Vendee or Vendor rather he has been falsely
implicated due to the ulterior motive of the Informant.
It
is
submitted
that
the
appellants
had
immediately responded to the Notice under Section 41(A)
of the Code of Criminal Procedure by filing reply.
It is submitted that the Informant is the
litigating lady of the locality and she, with intention to
harass the appellants/accused persons, is always taking
illegal acts to forcibly dispossess the appellants.
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
6.
It is submitted that prior to this case, the
informant tried to take illegal possession through the
construction work, with respect to the land of Khata No.28
and 54 for that the appellant No.1, namely Shankar
Mahto filed a case under Section 144 Cr.P.C. which was
registered as M.Case No. 06 of 2021, dated 04.01.2021
which, after hearing the then learned S.D.J.M. started
proceeding
under
Section
of
the
Cr.P.C.
on
08.03.2021, but the informant after disobeying the status
quo order as passed by learned S.D.M., Ranchi, regularly
continued the construction work and when the appellants
and their family members went to the land in question
and requested to the informant to stop the construction
work and obey the order of S.D.O. Court, but the
Informant disobeyed the order of S.D.O. Court and falsely
implicated them in this case.
It is submitted that after passing of order of
status quo dated 04.01.2021, then S.D.M. also called for
the police report and issued show-cause to the second
party/Informant and after getting notice the second
party/informant
appeared
before
the
S.D.M.
Court,
Ranchi and filed her show cause, but she regularly
continued the construction work. Therefore, after perusal
of police report as submitted by the police, the then
S.D.M. started proceeding under Section 144 of the
Cr.P.C. on 08.03.2021.
It is submitted that the legal heirs of Baiju
Ahir, namely Gowardhan Mahto and Madan Mahto filed
an original suit, which was registered as Original Suit No.
158 of 2021 for declaration of right, title and interest and
possession over the land in question and the present
Informant and others have already filed their written
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
statement in Original Suit No. 158 of 2021. It is submitted
that all the appellants have been implicated twice by the
Informant in this case due to an ulterior motive.
It is submitted that the appellants are poor
farmers and hence, they may be granted Anticipatory Bail.
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the
State has opposed the prayer for anticipatory bail made
on behalf of the appellants. It is submitted that Section 18
of the S.C./S.T Act completely bars grant of anticipatory
bail. It is submitted that several witnesses, namely Mary
Sibiria Ekka (i.e. the mother-in-law), Nitin Pascal Ekka
(i.e. the son of the Informant) and Basanti Devi (i.e. tenant
of the Informant), whose statements have been recorded
at Para 9, 10 and 11 respectively of the Case Diary, have
fully supported the prosecution case and hence, this
criminal appeal may be dismissed.
8.
Learned counsel for the Informant has
also opposed the prayer for anticipatory bail made on
behalf of the appellants. It is submitted that the present
criminal appeal is not maintainable and it may be
dismissed as there is an expressed and clear-cut statutory
bar of Section 18A(2) of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled
Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 for granting
anticipatory bail in such cases.
9.
It is submitted that the question of title
raised by the appellants, in disputed land in question,
pertaining to R.S. Khata No.28, Plot No.s 73, 648, 665,
963 at Mauza Kathchancho, P.S. Mandar within Revenue
Thana No.89 of District Ranchi, is already decided vide
judgment dated 18.04.2009, in Title Suit No. 85 of 2007,
by Sri Parveen Kumar Sinha, learned Court of Sub-JudgeII, at Ranchi, by which the learned Court has held that
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
the appellants have clearly failed to prove their title or
possession and hence, they do not have any right over the
aforesaid land.
It is submitted that the said land was
brought by Magadali Orain, who happens to be the
mother-in-law of the Respondent No.2 and said Magadali
Orain had purchased the total area of 77 decimals of Plot
No. 963 in the year 1940, from the Khatiyani Raiyat Jitua
Ahir and Jharia Ahir, through registered sale deed No.
2633 and dated 06.06.1940 and came in possession over
the said property. After the purchase of the said land the
name of Magadali Orain was mutated in the Sherista of
State of Bihar and she was paying rent thereon and where
she had resided and after her death, the Respondent No.2
inherited the said property as the heir and successor of
her mother-in-law and possessed the same. Thereafter,
she had constructed the boundary wall and shops over
the said land, which were destroyed by the appellants.
The Respondent No.2 was also threatened and abused in
the name of her caste and now she lives in fear of the
appellants.
10.
incident
It is submitted that on the date of the
on
22.02.2021
again
the
appellants
had
demolished the boundary wall and the shop of the
informant after abusing her in the name of her caste,
which shows their aggressive and abusive behaviour
towards the informant. Such demolition indicates that the
appellants are bent upon to harass the Respondent No.2.
It
is
further
submitted
that
the
investigation is still going on and the appellants may
tamper with the evidence or may hinder the process of
investigation.
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
It is further submitted that the F.I.R. has been
registered under Sections 341, 323, 427, 504, 506/34 of
Indian Penal Code, in which Sections 341 and 323 are serious
in nature. Further a bare reading of section 155(4) of Cr.P.C.
and also in the case of State of Orissa v. Sharat Chandra
Sahu, reported in (1996)6 SCC 435, it has been held that
when a case is related to two or more offences of which at
least one is cognizable, the entire case will be deemed to be a
cognizable case. Thus, whole case is to be treated as
cognizable and police has no option but to investigate the
whole of the case and to submit a chargesheet in respect of all
the offences in that case and hence, the prayer of anticipatory
bail of the appellant may be rejected.
11.
In support of her argument, learned counsel
for the Informant has placed reliance upon the case of Kiran
Versus Rajkumar Jivraj Jain & Anr. reported in 2025 INSC
1067, hence the prayer for Anticipatory Bail of the appellants
may be dismissed.
12.
Perused the record of this case, the Case Diary
and considered the submission of both the sides.
13.
It appears that the matter was taken up on
28.11.2024 before the Co-ordinate Bench (Hon’ble Mr. Sanjay
Kumar Dwivedi) of this Court and interim order was granted,
which was continued on 04.02.2025,13.02.2025. 28.03.2025,
17.04.2025,
12.06.2025,
11.08.2025,
08.09.2025,
13.10.2025, 24.11.2025, 15.12.2025 and 22.01.2026.
14.
It further reveals that T.S. No. 85 of 2007 was
filed and in which Appellant No.1, namely
Shankar Mahto
was Plaintiff No.3 in the said T.S. No. 85 of 2007 and he has
deposed as P.W.6, which is also evident from the judgment
dated 18.04.2009, passed in T.S. No. 85 of 2007, which was
dismissed by the learned Sub-Judge-II, Ranchi and the said
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
T.S. No.85 of 2007 was filed by Nine (09) persons as it reveals
from Page 2 of the judgment, namely Chamra Ahir, Shukhram
Ahir, Sanicharwa Ahir, Shankar Mahto, Siba Mahto, Kisun
Mahto and Bisun Mahto, Phuleshwar Mahto and Sukesh
Mahto and the Appellant No.1, namely Shankar Mahto was
the Plaintiff No.3.
The learned Sub-Judge has held that the
Plaintiffs have failed to prove their title by observing that
Baiju Ahir has no right to sell the 77 Decimal of disputed land
to the Ancestor of the Appellant No. 3 and Appellant No.6 as
their ancestors Jharia Ahir and Jhagru Ahir had sold the suit
property in the year 1940.
15.
It appears that Shankar Mahto, i.e.
Appellant No.1 and Chamra Mahto, who is ancestor of Rathu
Mahto ( i.e. Appellant No.3) have lost Title Suit No. 85 of
2007, which was dismissed on 18.04.2009 by the learned
Sub-Judge-II, Ranchi with regard to 77 decimal of land in
question, which has been referred to in the F.I.R. and the
proceeding under Section 144 Cr.P.C. was initiated on
08.03.2021 at the instance of Appellant No.1, namely
Shankar Mahto.
16.
It is well settled from the judgment of
Hon’ble the Supreme Court passed in Hitesh Verma Vs.
State of Uttarakhand & Ors, reported in (2020) 10 SCC
710 that provisions of S.C./S.T. Act is not attracted in a case
of land dispute between the parties.
17.
It
has
been
held
in
Kiran
Versus
Rajkumar Jivraj Jain & Anr. reported in 2025 INSC
1067, at Para 5.7, 6 and 6.2 as follows:“Para 5.7:- The aforesaid provision of Section
18 and the bar created thereunder has to be seen in the
context of the object and purpose with which the
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
Parliament enacted the SC/ST Act, 1989. This legislation
was brought into force with an avowed object of
implementing
the
measures
to
improve
the
socio-
economic conditions of the Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes, who have remained a vulnerable class
in the society. The underlying idea is to ensure that the
persons belonging to these classes are not denied their
civil rights, are not subjected to indignities and are
insulted from humiliation and harassment.
Para 6:- In light of the parameters in relation
to the applicability of Section 18 of the Act emanating
from afore-discussed various decisions of this Court, the
proposition could be summarized that as the provision of
Section 18 of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes,
Act, 1989 with express language with express language
excludes the applicability of Section 438 Cr.P.C., it
creates a bar against grant of anticipatory bail in
absolute terms in relations to the arrest of a person who
faces specific accusations of having committed the
offence under the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe
Act. The benefit of anticipatory bail for such an accused
is taken off.
Para 6.2:- Non-making of prima facie case about the
commission of offence is perceived to be such a situation
where the Court can arrive at such a conclusion in the
first blush itself or by way of the first impression upon
very reading of the averments in the FIR. The contents
and the allegations in the FIR would be decisive in this
regard. Furthermore, in reaching a conclusion as to
whether a prima facie offence is made out or not, it
would not be permissible for the Court to travel into the
evidentiary realm or to consider other materials, nor the
Court could advert to conduct a mini trial.”
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
18.
failed
Learned counsel for the appellants has
to
controvert
the
statement
of
the
Informant-
Respondent No.2 as Respondent No. 2 has claimed 77
Decimal of land by virtue of sale deed of the year 1940
through Jharia Ahir and Jhagru Ahir.
19.
It appears that some of the appellants
are ladies, i.e. Appellant No.2, namely Jiwan Devi, who is the
wife of Appellant No.1-Shankar Mahto, Appellant No.4,
namely Parmila Devi, who is the wife of Appellant No.3 and
Appellant No.5, namely Asha Devi, whereas Appellant No.6,
namely Anand Mahto is the son of Appellant No. 1 and
Appellant No.2. However, there is no specific allegation
against the Appellant No.2, 4, 5 and 6, namely Jiwan Devi,
Parmila Devi, Asha Devi and Anand Mahto respectively and
allegation against them are general and omnibus in nature
and no specific overt act is attributed to them.
20.
It appears that Appellant No.1, 3 and 7,
namely Shankar Mahto, Ranthu Mahto @ Rathu Mahto and
Rajendra Mahto respectively are male member and they have
committed an offence twice and for which two F.I.R.s have
been instituted and they are interested parties over the
disputed land in question and mere filing of subsequent
Title Suit No. 158 of 2021 may not come to their rescue at
this stage as the Title Suit is subsequent to the offence
committed by them.
21.
Under the circumstances, so far as the
conduct of Appellant No.1, 3 and 7, namely Shankar Mahto,
Rathu Mahto and Rajendra Mahto respectively is concerned,
they are not entitled to be enlarged on anticipatory bail as
they are alleged to have demolished the boundary wall of the
Informant, accordingly the prayer for anticipatory bail of the
appellants, i.e. Appellant No. 1, 3 and 7, namely Shankar
( 2026:JHHC:15520 )
Mahto, Rathu Mahto and Rajendra Gope @ Rajendra Mahto
respectively is rejected.
22.
Considering the fact mentioned above,
Appellant No.s 2, 4, 5 and 6 namely Jiwan Devi, Parmila
Devi, Asha Devi and Anand Mahto respectively are directed
to surrender before the learned Court below within Six (06)
weeks from today and in the event of their arrest or
surrender, the Appellant No.s 2, 4, 5 and 6, namely Jiwan
Devi, Parmila Devi, Asha Devi and Anand Mahto respectively
shall be released on bail, on furnishing bail bonds of
Rs.15,000/- (Rupees Fifteen thousand) with two sureties of
the like amount each in connection with Mandar P.S. Case
No.36 of 2021, to
the satisfaction of the Court of learned
A.J.C. II-cum-Special Judge, S.C./S.T. Act, Ranchi and also
subject to the provisions of Section 482 (2) of B.N.S.S.
23.
Accordingly, Order dated 19.03.2024,
passed in A.B.P. No. 157 of 2024, by the learned A.J.C.-IIcum-Special Judge, S.C./S.T. Act, Ranchi is set aside so far
Appellant No.s 2, 4, 5 and 6 namely Jiwan Devi, Parmila
Devi,
Asha
Devi
and
Anand
Mahto
respectively
are
concerned.
24.
Thus, this Criminal Appeal (S.J.) No. 737
of 2024 is partly allowed.
(Sanjay Prasad, J.)
s.m.
Dated 06.05.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review