The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. After having gone through the writ petition as well as the counter affidavit what 2026:UHC:2465 this Court has observed is that in fact this petition has been moved by the petitioners to grab the property which in fact is the ancestral property of the respondent no.5 as per the report. Therefore, this Court is of the view that the instant petition has been filed with an ulterior purpose and motive and appears to be an abuse of process of law and the writ petition is dismissed. In addition to this, it is made clear that the dismissal of this petition will not prejudice the right of the petitioners to avail the civil remedy as per law.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:2465
SL.
No.
Dat e
Of f i ce N o t e s ,
r ep or t s, or d er s
o r p r o ce e d i n g s
o r d i r e ct i o n s
a n d Re g i s t r a r ’ s
or der w it h
Si g n a t u r e s
COURT’ S OR JUD GE’ S ORD ERS
WPCRL No. 1722 of 2025
Hon'ble Rakesh Thapliyal, J.
1.
Mr. Gaurav Kandpal and Mr. Anas Ali
(through V.C.) learned counsel for the
petitioners.
2.
Mr. G.S. Sandhu, learned Addl.
Advocate General with Mr. Deepak
Bhardwaj, learned Brief Holder for the State.
3.
Mr. M.C. Pant and Ms. Anupriya
Kukreti, learned counsel for the respondent
no.5.
4.
By the instant writ petition, the
petitioners Shamshad Ali and Smt. Batulan,
are praying for the following reliefs:(i) Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of
mandamus directing the respondent no. 1 and 2
to ensure protection of life and liberty of the
petitioners and that of property of the petitioners
and that no harm is caused to the petitioners and
property of the petitioners at the hands of
respondent no. 5 and 6.
5.
In this petition, the S.S.P. Dehradun,
S.H.O. Ranipokhri, the District Magistrate
Dehradun and the Sub Divisional Magistrate
are arrayed as the officials respondents and
the respondent no. 5 and 6 are the
individuals namely Naresh Sharma and Gopi
Chandra Mittal. It is contended by the
petitioners that there is regular threat from
the respondent no. 5 and 6 in respect of their
life and liberty including the property in
which the petitioners are in possession since
last 70 years.
2026:UHC:2465
6.
It is further contended by the learned
counsel for the petitioners that the petitioner
approached to the police authority but no
action was taken for their protection and on
10.12.2025, the respondent no.5 trespassed
over the land with JCB machine and resumed
demolition activities and this is nothing but
an attempt to grab the property in which the
petitioners are in possession since last 70
years. He submits that a written complaint
was made to the District Magistrate on
11.12.2025 but nothing was done and
thereafter the respondent no.6 Mr. Gopi
Chandra Mittal along with many antisocial
elements visited the petitioners house and
extended life threats which was reported on
15.12.2025 which is annexed as Annexure
No.3.
7.
It is further contended that the Gram
Pradhan of the Gram Panchayat Thano also
issued a legal heir certificate wherein the
petitioners have been shown the legal heir of
late Fakira, the grandfather of the petitioner
no.2 from which it reveals that the petitioners
and their ancestors were residing over the
land since last several years. In para-9 it is
contended that name of late Fakira, the
grandfather of petitioner no.2 was duly
recorded in the revenue records, which
establishes the possession. Certain coloured
photographs of the property are also
enclosed in order to demonstrate that the
private respondents herein dispossess them
in an unauthorised manner. He submits that
despite the repeated complaints to the official
respondents, no action was taken which
shows that there is complete inaction on their
part. Annexure-5 which is appended along
with a petition is the relevant khatauni
wherein the name of Fakira, the grandfather
of the petitioner is shown in respect of the
land falling in Khasra No. 148ka. Page 27 is
2026:UHC:2465
the another extract of the Khatauni and land
falling in Khasra No. 148 kha is shown as
Abadi though the Fakira name is recorded in
Khasra No. 148 ka.
8.
Prima facie from these two revenue
records, it is reveals that Khasra No. 148 ka
and Khasra No. 148 kha are two distinct
Khasras relating to different piece of land.
9.
The respondent no.5 filed his counter
affidavit wherein in para -4 it is contended
that he is the owner of the dilapidated house
which is located at village Thano falling in
Khata No. 37 of Khasra No. 148 kha and after
the death of his father he became the absolute
owner of the said house which was
constructed by his forefather. It is further
contended that the private respondent are
also the owner of the agricultural land in
Khata No. 31 of Khasra No. 137 ka. In para-6
it is further contended that respondent no.5
is residing at Dehradun and this dilapidated
house which is parental house is located at
village Thano and on 18.10.2025, he has
moved an application before the Tehsildar
Doiwala as well as to the S.D.M. Doiwala for
seeking permission to demolish the house
which was in dilapidated condition. It is
further contended that on the application, the
Tehsildar Doiwala instructed to the revenue
officials to conduct an inquiry and thereafter
an inquiry was conducted and a report was
forwarded to Tehsildar Doiwala on
28.11.2025 where it is mentioned that the
house which is in a very dilapidated
condition and situated in Khata No. 37 of
Khasra No. 148 kha measuring 0.1360 hectare
is recorded in category 6(2) in Abadi land is
the parental house of the deponent. The
report is enclosed as CA-2. In para-8, it is
further contended that on 17.12.2025 he made
an application to the S.H.O. of P.S.
2026:UHC:2465
Ranipokhri as well as the District Magistrate
and the S.S.P Dehradun and also a complaint
to the Chief Secretary with regard to the
encroachment over their parental house and
also gave the reference of the threat received
from the petitioners. On 19.12.2025 the
Division Bench passed an order for
maintaining status quo.
10. As it appears from the relief clause, the
relief is sought by the petitioners for
protection of their life and liberty as well as
to the property. Generally if there is threat
perception to any person, this Court directs
to the S.S.P. to make an assessment and take
appropriate steps so that nobody can take
law in their hands but by the relief as sought
in this petition, the petitioners deliberately
praying for protection to the property. The
question is whether in a writ petition under
Article 226 of Constitution of India, the
petitioners can pray for the protection to the
property.
11.
After having gone through the counter
affidavit and the relevant Khatauni, it reveals
that asking protection to the property is a
deliberate attempt of the petitioners,
otherwise, the petitioners have a remedy to
avail the civil remedy, if there is an any
dispute with regard to the property in
question, however, instead of availing the
civil remedy, the petitioners have filed this
petition seeking protection to the property.
12. This matter is being heard since last so
many dates but every time the counsel for
the petitioners, on one pretext to another
taking adjournment and on his request this
Court accommodate him.
13. On 08.05.2026 the matter was posted for
today on the request of learned counsel for
2026:UHC:2465
the petitioners since he wanted to show
certain documents. Today, now a specific
question is asked from the counsel for the
petitioners is whether there is any evidence
with regard to the possession over the
property in question, he could not show any
such document.
14. On the other side, so far as the private
respondents are concerned, they reported to
the revenue officers, who visited the site and
submitted report from which it reveals that
disputed property is parental house of the
respondent no. 5 and this report is
unchallenged.
15.
The Court also posed a question to the
counsel for the petitioners as to how the writ
petition is maintainable.
16.
Learned counsel for the petitioners
tried his best to convince the Court by saying
that even otherwise if the petitioners are
trespassers over the property, law is very
well settled that even they cannot be evicted
without due process of law. He submits that
at the most property in question as per the
revenue record belongs to the State since it is
show as Abadi and as such they can be
evicted only by the State not by private
respondents.
17.
This Court is not deciding the issue
with regard to the property in question and
this petition in fact has been filed only to seek
the protection to the property. The admitted
position is that the petitioners could not
show their possession over the property,
rather the report as enclosed with the counter
affidavit shows that the property in question
is the parental house of the respondent no.5.
18. After having gone through the writ
petition as well as the counter affidavit what
2026:UHC:2465
this Court has observed is that in fact this
petition has been moved by the petitioners to
grab the property which in fact is the
ancestral property of the respondent no.5 as
per the report. Therefore, this Court is of the
view that the instant petition has been filed
with an ulterior purpose and motive and
appears to be an abuse of process of law and
the writ petition is dismissed. In addition to
this, it is made clear that the dismissal of this
petition will not prejudice the right of the
petitioners to avail the civil remedy as per
law.
19. The interim order to maintain the
status quo stands vacated.
20.
No order as to costs.
(Rakesh Thapliyal, J.)
12.05.2026
Nahid
2026:UHC:2465
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review