Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:37154
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
CWPOA No.8017 of 2019
Decided on: 31.08.2026.
________________________________________________________
Shakuntla Devi
...Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Others
...Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge
1Whether approved for reporting?. No.
For the petitioner:
Ms. Archna Dutt, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Sumit Sharma, Deputy
Advocate General.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge
Petitioner, Shakuntla Devi, had initially
filed an Original Application i.e. OA No.3860 of
before
Learned
Himachal
Pradesh
State
Administrative Tribunal and upon abolition of the
Tribunal, the same was transferred to this Court
as CWPOA No.8017 of 2019, seeking the following
relief(s):
“(a). That the impugned order dated 4 th April,
2016 passed by respondent No.2 may
kindly be quashed and set-aside.
(b).
That
the
respondents
may
kindly
be
directed to count
the services of the
applicant
rendered
on
to
for
contract
the
w.e.f.
purpose
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
of
2026:HHC:37154
-2pensionary benefits.”
FACTUAL MATRIX:
2.
Case as set up by Learned Counsel is that
the petitioner had rendered continuous and uninterrupted service, on the post of JBT [Junior Basic
Training] Teacher under the respondents w.e.f. 1997
to 2006. Her services were regularized with effect
from 01.01.2006. It is averred that the aforesaid
contractual service followed by regular service may
be
treated
benefits
as
from
qualifying
service
the
of
date
for
pensionary
superannuation
on
30.11.2015 in accordance with Rule 17 of the CCS
(Pension) Rules. It is averred that the petitioner had
submitted representations, but her case was rejected
by
the
Respondent
No.2-Director
of
Elementary
Education on 27.04.2016 [Annexure A-7], primarily
on the ground that, as per Rule 2 of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972, the contractual service is not
to be counted as qualifying service, whereas the
qualifying service is to commence only from the date
of substantive-regular appointment, which in instant
case,
was
after
15.05.2003.
The
petitioner
has
2026:HHC:37154
-3-
assailed the rejection orders, with the prayer for,
counting
the
uninterrupted
and
continuous
contractual service rendered on the post of JBT,
followed by regular service, as qualifying service for
pensionary benefits w.e.f. 01.12.2015 or with the
alternative prayer w.e.f. 01.04.2023 in view of the
Notification dated 04.05.2023 issued during the
pendency of the writ petition [whichever is earlier]
with all consequential benefits.
STAND OF STATE AUTHORITIES:
3.
Pursuant to the issuance of notice, the
respondents
have
filed
the
Reply-Affidavit
dated
03.10.2016 of Director of Elementary Education,
Himachal Pradesh.
3(i).
Perusal of the Reply-Affidavit admits that,
though the petitioner had rendered the continuous
and uninterrupted contractual service from 1997 to
2006 and her services were regularized with effect
from 01.01.2006, but the said service cannot be
counted for as qualifying service for pensionary
benefits
on
Department
the
ground
ceased
to
that
be
the
Respondent-
pensionable
from
2026:HHC:37154
-4-
15.05.2003 till 31.03.2023 and once the petitioner
was substantively appointed-regularized on a post
after
15.05.2003
coupled
with
the
fact
that
contractual service was not countable as qualifying
service for pension as per Rule 2 (h) of the CCS
(Pension) Rules and in this backdrop, the claim of
the petitioner was opposed by the State Authorities,
with the prayer to dismiss the petition.
4.
Heard Ms. Archna Dutt, Learned Counsel
for the petitioner and Mr. Sumit Sharma, Learned
Deputy Advocate General, for the respondents.
ANALYSIS:
5.
Taking into account the entirety of the facts
and circumstances, this Court is of the considered
view, that the claim of the petitioner, a contractual
appointee,
who
has
rendered
continuous
and
uninterrupted service, on a post coupled with the
fact that said contract service was followed by
regular appointment/regularization is to be counted
as qualifying service for pensionary benefits under
Rule 17 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, for the following
reasons:
2026:HHC:37154
-5-
5(i).
rendered
The
issue
by
an
as
to
whether
employee,
who
the
has
service
rendered
continuous/un-interrupted contractual service on a
post, upon regularization, shall count as qualifying
service
for
pension/retiral
benefits
stands
adjudicated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State
of Himachal Pradesh & Another versus Sheela
Devi, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1272, decided on
07.08.2023, and this principle was followed in the
case of S.D. Jayaprakash and Others Versus
Union of India and Others, 2025 SCC OnLine SC
973.
5(ii).
The declaration of law in the case of Sheela
Devi and S. D. Jayaprakash (supra) has been
reiterated by the Division Bench of this Court in
Shiv Saran Sharma versus State of Himachal
Pradesh
and
Others, CWP
No.2045
of
2016,
decided on 07.05.2025, upholding the entitlement of
contractual employee, for counting the contractual
service rendered on a post followed by substantive/
regular service on the same or another post to be
counted, as qualifying service for pension, in the
2026:HHC:37154
-6-
following terms:
“11(vi).The issue as to whether the contractual
service was countable as qualifying service
for pension upon regularization on same or
other post of a person on superannuation
became the subject matter of in State of
Himachal Pradesh & Anr. Versus Sheela
Devi, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1272 wherein,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has affirmed that
past
service
rendered
as
contractual
employee is followed by service rendered on
same
or
another
post
in
a
substantive
capacity, in a pensionable establishment is
to
be
treated
as
qualifying
service
by
exercising an option, if any, as may be
prescribed
by
the
State
Authorities,
for
purposes of extending benefit of pension, in
the following terms: “9. The Learned Advocate General is
correct
in
his
interpretation,
inasmuch as a facial reading of
Rule 2(g) would indicate that
contractual
employees
are
excluded from the pale of Pension
Rules. However, what is significant
is that the rule itself in its opening
terms saves the application of
other provisions of the pension
rules: “Save as otherwise provided
in these rules”. If the opening
phrase of Rule 2 were to be
understood in this context, any
interpretation of Rule 17 as is
urged by the State would render
such
substantive
provision
redundant. Rule 17 was engrafted
essentially to cater to the
eventuality,
where
the
employees working on contract
basis were regularized at a later
stage. It is only for the purposes
of pension that the past service
as a contractual employee is to
be taken into account.
-7-
2026:HHC:37154
10. So far as the other arguments with
respect to the voluntariness when
the
employees
enters
into
contractual services is concerned,
this Court is unpersuaded by the
submission because those terms
were applicable as long as the
employees remained on contract.
However, his or her status ceased
upon regularization.
11. In view of the above reasoning,
this court is of the opinion that
there is no merit in the appeal
however,
the
following
directions are issued:—
The
state
shall
take
immediate steps to indicate
the mode and manner of
exercising option by all the
employees concerned (who
had been regularized after
spells
of
contractual
employment) regardless of
the dates on which they
were engaged i.e. prior to
the
year
or
subsequently, within a time
frame, of within eight weeks
from today.
(ii) After receiving the options
within the time indicated in
the notice, the concerned
employee(s) who exercise the
relevant options should be
notified about the amounts
they would have to remit in
case any amount towards
contribution
is
required,
clearly.
(i)
(iii) The
options
should
be
processed
and
completed
within eight weeks from the
last date of receiving options.
(iv) Time limit for payment too
should be indicated and entire
process should be completed
within four months and all
orders fixing pensions or
family pension as the case
may be, shall be issued.”
11(vii). A similar issue as to whether contractual
2026:HHC:37154
-8-
service upon regularization on the same or
other post was to be counted for pension
under Rule 17 of CCS [Pension] Rules, was
re-affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in
the
case
of
S.D.
Jayaprakash
and
Others Versus Union of India and Others,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 973, in the following
terms :“3. The short facts that are necessary are as
follows. The appellants were appointed
as Data Entry Operators under the
Plan Scheme called ‘Rationalization of
Data
Processing
Facilities’
on
temporary
and
contractual
basis
between 1996 and 1999. Pursuant to
an order of the Central Administrative
Tribunal 3 dated 01.04.2013 the
respondents
issued
an
Office
Memorandum
dated
5.1.2015
to
regularise the appellants’ service from a
prospective date, i.e., from the date of
issuance of this order. Pursuantly, the
appellants were appointed on a regular
basis by order dated 01.04.2015, w.e.f.
05.01.2015. The appellants preferred an
Original Application before the CAT,
with a prayer to regularize their services
from the date of initial appointment or
at least from the date of completing 10
years of service, and to protect their
pay and to grant seniority, service
benefits and pension by counting
their period of contractual service.
The CAT allowed the same by order
dated 19.01.2016 and directed as
follows:
“31. Therefore, after considering the
entire facts and circumstances of
the case, we order as follows:
1. The pay and other allowances
drawn by the applicants prior
to their appointment on regular
basis on 1.4.2015 shall be
protected and they shall be
allowed the pay being drawn by
them immediately prior to their
regularisation as their basic
pay as on 1.4.2015. Their
annual increment shall be
-9-
2026:HHC:37154
determined accordingly.
2. The applicants from whose
salary, the GPF and other
contributions made right from
the date of their appointment
on contract basis shall be
entitled to come under the old
pension scheme and the entire
period of service right from
the
date
of
initial
appointment
on
contract
basis
shall
be
counted
towards pensionary benefits.
3. For the purpose of seniority,
ACP and other service benefits
etc., the regular service of the
applicants shall be reckoned
from the date of completion
of 10 years of service from
their initial appointments on
contract basis.
32.
The Respondents are directed to
fix the salary of the applicants and
grant the consequential benefits in
terms of the above direction within
a period of two (2) months from
the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.”
4. The respondents challenged the
above
order
by
way
of
a writ petition, which was
partly allowed by the impugned
order. The High Court set aside
the CAT’s directions to the
extent
of
counting
the
period
of contractual service for grant
of seniority, service benefits,
and pension on the ground that
the
initial
appointment
was
on
a
contractual
basis
and
not
pursuant
to
the
recommendation
of
the Staff Selection Commission.
It held that the appellants will
be entitled to regularisation
and its consequential benefits
only from 01.04.2015. However,
the
Court
upheld
the
CAT’s
direction
regarding
protection of pay while fixing
2026:HHC:37154
- 10 the pay scale.
9. In light of the clear language
of Rule 17 of the Pension
Rules
as
well
as
its
interpretation in Sheela Devi
(supra),
the
contractual
service period rendered prior
to
the
appellants’
regularization in 2015 must
be
counted
towards
the
payment of their pensionary
benefits in accordance with
the mechanism set out in
Rule 17. In line with the
directions issued in Sheela
Devi
(supra)
extracted
hereinabove, we direct the
respondent Union of India to
take immediate steps and
indicate
the
mode
and
manner for the appellants to
exercise the option provided
under Rule 17 of the Pension
Rules as well as to notify the
amounts that the appellants
would have to remit in case
they opt for grant of pension
under the Rules.”
11(viii). A similar claim came up for adjudication
before this Court in CWPOA No. 5507 of
2020 Oma Wati and another versus State
of Himachal Pradesh and others, decided
on 21.08.2023, upholding the claim for
pension by counting the service rendered on
a post uninterruptedly, which was followed
by substantive-regular service rendered on
another
post
as
qualifying
service
for
pension, as under:
2.
Petitioner No.1 Oma Wati was
initially appointed on contract
basis against the post of Junior
Basis Teacher (JBT) on 24.7.1998
and served as such till 24.8.2000.
Thereafter, she was appointed as
Shastri on regular basis and she is
serving as such since 25.8.2000.
8.
Despite repeated observations as
- 11 -
2026:HHC:37154
well as directions of the Courts in
numerous cases that State must
behave like a Model Employer,
State, irrespective of persons in
power and change in Guard,
successively
keeps
on
to
formulate, adopt and practise
exploitative policies as a device to
avoid extension of legitimate rights
of the employees for which they
are
otherwise
entitled.
On
intervention
of
the
Courts
directing the State to extend such
benefits like pay scale, increment,
leave and counting of service etc.,
State every time tries to deprive
the employee from such benefit by
changing nomenclature of post
and scheme to continue with
practice of temporary/ ad-hoc
appointments.
Appointment
of
Voluntary
Teachers,
ad-hoc
Teachers, Vidya Upasaks, Contract
Teachers, PARA Teachers, PAT,
PTA
and SMC
Teachers
are
examples of clever phraseology
devised by State to overcome
directions of the Courts in order to
avoid permanent appointments by
appointing
ad-hoc
/Temporary
Teachers depriving them of service
benefits
available
to
regular
employees. When Courts upheld
the
entitlement
of
ad-hoc
employees for service benefits,
State came with Scheme for
appointment
of
Voluntary
Teachers. Again, on intervention of
the
Court,
State
continued
changing the name of Policy but
for appointment on exploitative
terms. Therefore, we are of the
opinion that all these terms are
similar temporary appointments
irrespective of their nomenclature.
Therefore, verdict of the Court
regarding extension of service
benefits with respect to one kind of
temporary appointment is equally
applicable to similar temporary
appointment
with
different
nomenclature.
9.
The claims of the petitioners are
squarely covered by the judgments
2026:HHC:37154
- 12 -
in Sheela Devi, Jagdish Chand as
well as Youdhishther Kumar
Sharma, referred supra. Therefore,
the aforesaid judgments shall
mutatis mutandis be applicable to
the present cases also, subject to
clarification that petitioner No. 1
shall be entitled for counting of
contract service only for the
purpose of pensionary benefits,
whereas, benefits to the husband
of petitioner No 2 shall be
extended by counting his contract
service for the purpose of annual
increments as well as pensionary
benefits.
10.
Present petition was filed on
30.10.2018.
The
actual
consequential financial benefits
shall, however be restricted to
three years prior to filing of the
writ petition. Due and admissible
benefits
be
released
to
the
petitioners within a period of three
months from today.
11(ix). A coordinate Division Bench of this Court in
CWPOA 7216 of 2020, in Re: Kewal Singh
versus
State
of
Himachal
Pradesh,
decided on 10.07.2024 allowed the pension
by
counting
the
contractual
service
rendered as JBT on contract basis which
was
followed
by
service
rendered
substantive-regular
basis
as
on
drawing
teacher till retirement as qualifying service
for pension on the basis of Rule 17 and the
mandate of law in the case of Sheela Devi
[supra] in the following terms:2.
Petitioner was initially appointed on
contract basis against the post of
Junior Basis Teacher (JBT) on
24.09.1996 and served as such till
13.7.2003.
Thereafter,
he
was
appointed as Drawing Teacher on
regular basis and he served as such
since 14.7.2003 till the date of his
superannuation i.e. 31.05.2018.
2026:HHC:37154
- 13 -
14 The claim of the petitioner is
squarely covered by the judgments
in Sheela Devi, Jagdish Chand as
well
as
Youdhishther
Kumar
Sharma,
cases
referred
supra.
Therefore, ratio of the aforesaid
judgments as well as reasons
assigned therein for extending the
benefits of contract service to the
employee shall mutatis mutandis
applicable to the present case also,
and petitioner shall be entitled for
counting of contract service for
the purpose of all pensionary
benefits.
15 Present
petition
was
filed
on
10.7.2019. The actual consequential
financial benefits shall, however, be
restricted to three years prior to
filing of the writ petition. Due and
admissible benefits be released to
the petitioner within a period of
three months from today.”
5(iii).
Based on factual matrix and the mandate
of law as declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Sheela Devi, reiterated in the case of
S. D. Jayaprakash and followed by the Hon’ble
Division Bench of this Court, in the case of Shiv
Saran Sharma (supra) the petitioner is held entitled
for
counting
of
continuous
and
uninterrupted
contractual service rendered by the petitioner, on the
post
of
JBT,
substantive
which
was
appointment
on
followed
the
by
same
regular/
post
as
qualifying service under Rule 17 of the CCS (Pension)
Rules.
2026:HHC:37154
- 14 -
5(iv).
Besides the above, indisputably once the
State Authorities have restored the CCS (Pension)
Rules
entitling
the
employees
appointed
between the period from 15.05.2003 to 31.03.2023,
in terms of Notification No. Fin (Pen) A (3)-1/2023,
dated 04.05.2003 for pension, therefore, the claim of
petitioner for pension/retiral benefits by extending
benefit
of
continuous/un-interrupted
contractual
service followed by regular service on same post till
retirement needs to be reconsidered, subject to
exercising an option by the petitioner within four
weeks from today, in case, not exercised earlier.
5(v).
Moreover, once the initial appointment of
petitioner on contract basis as Junior Basic Training
[JBT] Teacher was in accordance with the Statutory
Rules
and
such
continuous
and
un-interrupted
contract service was followed by regular appointment
on the same post, therefore, upon regularization/
substantive appointment, the entire service rendered
from date of initial appointment shall count as
qualifying service for pensionary benefits.
Consequent
upon
the
entitlement
of
2026:HHC:37154
- 15 -
counting of contractual service, as qualifying service
for retiral benefits, the petitioner is held entitled for
revised retiral benefits, including pension and other
retiral benefits, from the due date of retirement w.e.f.
01.12.2015
or
w.e.f.
01.04.2023
[whichever
is
beneficial] in terms of Notification dated 04.05.2023
issued
during
pendency
of
instant
petition,
as
referred to above.
6.
No other point has been argued/raised by
the parties.
DIRECTIONS :
7.
In view of the above discussion and for
reasons recorded hereinabove, the instant petition, is
allowed, in the following terms:
(i). Impugned
order
dated
27.04.2016
[Annexure A-7] rejecting the claim of the
petitioner
for
counting
service
as
qualifying
pension
and
other
of
contractual
service
retiral
towards
benefits,
is
quashed and set aside;
(ii). State Authorities are directed to count the
contractual service followed by regular/
substantive service on the same or another
post by the petitioner as qualifying service
for
pension
benefits,
and
w.e.f.
all
admissible
01.12.2015
or
retiral
w.e.f.
2026:HHC:37154
- 16 01.04.2023
terms
of
[whichever
Notification
is
beneficial]
dated
in
04.05.2023
(supra) subject to exercising an option in
terms of Notification dated 04.05.2023, on
or before 30.09.2026;
(iii). Upon exercising of option, necessary action
for extending benefits be taken within next
four weeks thereafter and not later than
31.10.2026.
(iv). No order as to costs.
8.
In aforesaid terms, the instant petition and
all pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall
also stand disposed of, accordingly.
(Ranjan Sharma)
Judge
August 31, 2026
[Shivender]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review