Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 16th October, 2025
Pronounced on: 20th January, 2026
%
+
CRL.M.C.3484/2018, CRL.M.A. 12638/2018 (stay)
SHAKUNTALA DEVI
@ SHAKUN RANA
W/o Shri Surender Singh Rana
R/o SFS Flat No.7A, Pkt B,
Mayur Vihar, Phase III,
Delhi-110095.
Through:
......Petitioner
Mr. Rakesh Tiku, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Arpan Wadhawan, Mr. Sandeep
Kumar and Mr. Monu Kumar,
Advocates.
versus
1.
SMT. SUDHA SINGH
W/o Late Shri Anil Rana
2.
TUSHAR RANA
S/o Late Shri Anil Rana
Both residents of House No.140-141,
Block C-1, New Kondli,
Delhi-110096.
3.
SHRI SURNDRA SINGH RANA
S/o Late Shri Basudev Singh Rana
4.
SHRI DIPIN RANA
S/o Shri Surender Singh Rana
Both residents of Flat No.7-A, Pkt-B,
DDA HIG SFS Flats, Mayur Vihar,
Phase III, Delhi.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
5.
SMT. SUCHIN RANA
Wife of Shri Himanshu
Resident of House No.25-A/1A,
Gali No.17, Pandava Road,
Bhola Nath Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi-110032.
Also at:
Flat No.7A, Pkt-B DDA HIG SFS Flats,
Mayur Vihar Phase III, Delhi-110096.
6.
SHRI PRAMOD KUMAR SAGAR
Son of Shri B.D. Sagar
R/o H.No.B-101, Kothiyat Mandal,
Town Uttari, Ghaziabad, UP.
Also at:
Directorate of Marin Engineering
1HQ, Ministry of Defence (Navy)
Sena Bhawan, New Delhi-110011.
7.
SHRI KUMAR SUNIL
Son of Late Shri Lal Singh
R/o H.No.93/1, Sector I,
Central Government Colony,
Pushp Vihar, Delhi-110017.
Also at:
Directorate of Navy Design (SDG) 1HQ
Ministry of Defence (Navy)
New Delhi-110066.
8.
SHRI NEPAL SINGH @ RINKU
Son of Shri Lekhraj Singh
9.
SHRI RAHUL SINGH
Both residents of Village Naisar,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
Tehsil Khurja, District Bulandshahar, UP.
10.
SUB REGISTRAR-III, L.M. BANDH
Shastri Nagar, Geeta Colony, Delhi.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Rajesh Srivastava & Mr. Gaurav
Verma, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
A Petition has been filed on behalf of the Petitioner/Shakuntala
Devi under Article 227 of the Constitution of India read with Section 482 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “Cr.P.C”)
to challenge the Order of the learned ACMM dated 27.02.2018 summoning
the Petitioners in the Complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C. for the offences
under Section 420, 467, 468 and 471 read with Section 120B Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”), which Order has been
upheld by the learned Special Judge, PC Act, CBI, Delhi in Criminal
Revision No.102/2018, vide Order dated 30.05.2018.
2.
The facts in brief are that Respondent No.1/Sudha Singh and
Respondent No.2/Tushar Rana had filed a Complaint under Section 200 read
with Section 156(3) Cr.P.C for the trial of the Respondents under Section
416/417/418/419/420/506/467/468/471/120-B/34 IPC.
3.
The Complainant, Sudha Singh asserted that her husband, Anil Rana
was working as Sr. Draftsman, Directorate of Naval Design (SSG), IHQ,
MOD Navy, Govt. of India, Delhi. He died intestate on 15.02.2011 and was
survived by the Complainant, Sudha Singh and their minor son, Ayush Rana
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
(aged about 13 years). On the demise of Sh. Anil Rana, all his assets and
properties devolved upon the Complainant being the Class-I heirs, by virtue
of law of Succession.
4.
The husband had an agricultural property bearing Khaka No.00011
Khasra No.227 and Khaka No.00012 Khasra No.248M situated at village
Naisar, Tehsil Khurja, District Bulandshahar, U.P. in his name which was
mutated in the name of the Complainant vide Order dated 28.06.2011 by the
Tehsildar, Khurja.
5.
Thereafter, the Accused persons hatched a conspiracy and filed an
Application/Appeal before ADM, Khurja to challenge the mutation, which
was dismissed. The Order was challenged before the DM, but to no avail,
and was also dismissed on 30.08.2014.
6.
The Complainant asserted in her Complaint that thereafter, on
19.12.2014, Smt. Shakuntala Devi moved the Application for Mutation of
the subject property in her name on the basis of the Will dated 28.01.2008
registered on 28.11.2014 before Sub-Registrar-VIII, Delhi, copy of which
was annexed with the Application.
7.
The Complainant asserted that this Will was forged and fabricated and
was never mentioned by Smt. Shakuntala Devi in the earlier proceedings.
The Complainant came to know about this alleged Will for the first time
when it was filed before SDM, Khurja. Thereafter, the Complainants made
Complaint to the Police, but no action was taken. Thereafter, the
Complainants filed a Complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C for the offence
under Section 416/417/418/419/420/506/467/468/471/120-B/34 IPC.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
8.
The learned ACMM vide the Order dated 27.02.2018, summoned
Shakuntala Devi and co-accused, Pramod Sagar and Sunil Kumar, for the
offence under Section 420/467/468/471 read with Section 120B IPC.
9.
The Order on Summoning was challenged before the learned ASJ,
who in his detailed Order dated 30.05.2018, did not find any merit in the
Revision Petition and dismissed the same while upholding the Order of
Summoning of learned ACMM.
10.
Aggrieved by the Summoning, Smt. Shakuntala Devi has filed the
present Petition, wherein it is submitted that there was a Will dated
28.01.2008 which was registered on 28.11.2014, executed by deceased, Sh.
Anil Rana which had been filed before the Tehsildar, Khurja, U.P. for
mutation of the properties in the name of Smt. Shakuntala Devi on the basis
of the registered Will. The said proceedings are pending in Secunderabad
Court and is at the stage of evidence.
11.
The Complainants filed a Civil Suit against Surender Singh Rana and
others to seek an Injunction to restrain them from taking possible possession
of the properties, which is pending in the Court of Civil Judge, Khurja, U.P.
wherein the evidence of the Complainant is being recorded, though Interim
relief was granted to the Petitioner to the effect that the Complainant and
others were restrained from interfering in the peaceful possession of the
Petitioner in respect of the property.
12.
The Objection/Application has been filed by the Respondent Nos. 1
and 2 in the Mutation proceedings at Khurja. The Petitioner/Shakuntala Devi
has also filed a Suit for Declaration, etc. against the Complainant/Sudha
Singh for being declared as the owner and in possession of the suit property
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
since the time of its purchase and also that the Complainant and others, got
the property mutated in their name against the law and the rules.
13.
The Respondent Nos.1 and 2 have also filed a Suit for Declaration
and Injunction in the Civil Court, Delhi claiming the same relief against
the Petitioner.
14.
It is submitted that the question of genuineness of the Will, is pending
before the Judicial Court at Khurja. The Complainants before filing the
present Complaint, have already approached the Civil Court, wherein the
same relief has been sought. The question which has arisen in Civil Court at
Khurja and Karkardooma, is in regard to the territorial jurisdiction of the
Court to decide the question of genuineness of the Will.
15.
The impugned Order dated 30.05.2018 of learned Revisional
Court has been challenged on the grounds that it has not been considered
that Civil Suit has already been filed by the Complainants, for the similar
relief. The Will in question was filed before the SDM, Khurja, U.P. where
the question of its genuineness was to be testified. The Complainants had
also filed their objection at Khurja Court in a Suit, for initiating necessary
action qua the same.
16.
In view of the multiple Civil/Revenue litigation, the present
Complaint is not maintainable. The disputes which have been raised pertain
to the genuineness of the Will, which can be decided only by the Civil
Courts. Furthermore, the Complainants had the option to challenge the
registration of the Will by filing an Appeal under the Registration Act.
17.
The reference is made to Sardool Singh vs. Naseem Kaur, decided on
10.02.1987 cited as 1987 LawSuits SC 155, wherein it was observed that
where the matter is sub judice in civil courts about the validity of Will,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
permission to institute a criminal prosecution on the allegation that the Will
is a forged one, cannot be held maintainable.
18.
Furthermore, it is claimed that the Will was duly witnessed by the
witnesses and attested by Notary Public. The Register is in the possession of
the Notary Public and has all the relevant entries. The CGHS Card on the
basis of which the registration was done, was in possession of the
Respondent. It all reflects that the Petitioner had no involvement with the
CGHS Card entry.
19.
It has not been appreciated that the Report of Hand Writing Expert
cannot be relied upon as it is not a conclusive proof. The Report was
prepared on the basis of the photocopy of the Will and the alleged signatures
of deceased, Sh. Anil Rana. The Signature Matching Report is not a proper
and a correct guidance for ascertaining the forgery of the alleged Will.
20.
Therefore, the learned ASJ has committed the jurisdictional error and
therefore, the Order of the ACMM dated 27.02.2018 and the Order of the
learned ASJ dated 30.05.2018 upholding the Order of learned M.M., is
liable to be set aside.
21.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner has relied upon the judgments
passed by the Apex Court in Sardool Singh vs. Nasib Kaur, 1987 SCC (Cri)
672 and R. Nagender Yadav vs. State of Telegana & Anr., Criminal Appeal
No. 2290/2022 in support of her assertions.
22.
The Respondent Nos.1 and 2 in their Reply have taken a preliminary
objection that the present Petition amounts to second Revision which is not
maintainable in law. The Petitioner has filed many new documents along
with this Petition, which were not filed in the Courts below. No permission
has been sought from this Court, to produce the additional documents.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
Therefore, the documents filed along with this Petition, cannot be
considered as they do not form part of the Court of ACMM and learned ASJ.
It is claimed that the true and correct facts have not been disclosed and the
Petitioner has not approached the Court with clean hands. The Order of
Summoning of the learned ACMM, is only an interlocutory Order against
which the Revision was filed, which has been dismissed.
23.
The issue involved in the present Petition is in regard to the
fabrication of the Will of Sh. Anil Rana by the Petitioner/Shakuntala Devi
and the two other co-accused persons. It is asserted that the Will was
allegedly got registered by the Petitioner after more than three years of
demise of Sh. Anil Rana.
24.
After the demise of Sh. Anil Rana, the claim was filed for settlement
of his service benefits, in the Ministry of Defence, Navy. At the time of
settlement of GPF and other claims, the Petitioner did not raise any
execution of Will in her favour. It is evident that this Will has been forged
and prepared subsequently by the Petitioner in connivance with the other coaccused.
25.
It is further submitted that after the demise of Sh. Anil Rana, the
property was duly mutated in the name of the Complainant vide Order dated
28.06.2011 of judicial Tehsildar, Khurja, Bulandshahar, U.P., which was in
the knowledge of the Petitioner, but therein also she did not produce the
alleged Will. The criminal conspiracy between the Petitioner and other coaccused persons is evident from the fact that while challenging the Mutation
Order of the Tehsildar dated 28.06.2011, there was no Will projected even at
that time and the Appeals preferred before the ADM and DM were,
respectively dismissed.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
26.
It is only thereafter, that the Petitioner started taking of false plea of
having a registered Will in her favour and sought the mutation of the subject
property in her name. It is evident that the only intention of the Petitioner
and her associates, was to grab the property of the Respondent by any
means. If the Petitioner was having a genuine Will of Late Shri Rana, she
would have placed the same in the first instance and not waited
subsequently. The circumstances make it crystal clear that the alleged Will
is forged and fabricated and has been created only to fulfil the illegal interest
or motive of the Petitioner.
27.
The Respondent/Complainant came to know about the forged Will
only on 29.01.2015 at the time of hearing before the SDM, Khurja. The
Complainant and the other accused persons, are allegedly the beneficiaries
under the forged Will and Accused No.5 and 6, Pramod Kumar Sagar and
Sunil Kumar, were the witnesses to the forged Will. The Accused No. 9,
Sub Registrar had wrongly registered the Will. In fact, this alleged Will
which is totally fabricated, is liable to be cancelled. The malafide of the
accused persons is evident as they intent to grab the properties of Late Shri
Rana which already stands mutated in the name of the Complainant and the
two sons.
28.
The Respondent No.2 after coming to know about the Will, had
approached the Sub Registrar for clarification. She applied for the certified
copy of the alleged Will, on 18.02.2015. It is claimed that the Petitioner and
other Accused who are her in-laws, are creating regular problems in her life.
They have committed offence of cheating, forgery, perjury, misappropriation and mis-representation and have been threatening the
answering Respondent to plea Complainant of dire consequences.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
29.
It is submitted that the learned ASJ has rightly upheld the Order of
the learned ACMM summoning the Petitioner and the two other co-accused.
There is no merit in the present Petition, which is liable to be dismissed.
30.
Learned counsel for the Respondent No. 1 and 2 have relied upon
the judgements passed by the Apex Court in Kamaladevi vs. State of W.B.&
Ors., 2002 (1) SCC 555; Iqbal Singh Marwah & Anr. vs. Meenakshi
Marwah & Anr., 2005 4 SCC 370; Rumi Dhar vs. State of W.B. & Anr.,
(2009) 6 SCC 364; K. Jagadish vs. Udaya Kumar & Anr., (2020) 14 SCC
552; and Syed Askari Hadi Ali Augustine Imam & Anr. vs. State (Delhi
Administration) & Anr., (2009) 5 SCC 528 in support of their assertions.
Submissions heard and record perused.
31.
From the facts as narrated above, it emerges that after the demise of
Sh. Anil Rana, the terminal benefits of his service were distributed by
Ministry of Defence to the Complainant/Wife and the sons, in accordance
with Rules and no alleged Will was presented by the Petitioner. Likewise,
the properties of Sh. Anil Rana were transferred/mutated in the name of the
Complainant by the Order of the Tehsildar, Khurja, U.P.
32.
The two Appeals preferred by the Petitioner to challenge the mutation
before the ADM and DM, did not succeed. Pertinently, no alleged Will was
presented till then before any of the Authority. It is only subsequently, on
19.12.2014 that the Petitioner (mother of the deceased) filed an Application
for mutation of the same property in her name, on the basis of this Will
before the Tehsildar, Khurja. It is then that the Complainant became aware
of the Will dated 28.01.2008 which has been subsequently registered on
28.11.2014, which she claims is a forged and a fabricated document.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
33.
It is not in dispute that the proceedings before the Tehsildar preferred
by the Petitioner/Smt. Shakuntala Devi, is being contested by the
Complainant. Aside from this, multiple Civil Suits have been filed by the
Petitioner as well as the Complainant to seek the protection of the
possession and also for the declaration in respect of the Will.
34.
The learned ACMM duly considered the testimony of the
Complainant about the Will being forged which got corroborated by the
testimony of CW5/Syed Imtiaz Ahmed, handwriting expert who deposed
that the signatures on the Will were not those of Sh. Anil Rana. The
documents of deceased, Sh. Anil Rana bearing his original signatures, were
produced by CW3 and CW4, the Bank officials.
35.
CW2/Sh. Madan Lal Gupta Notary Public, who had allegedly
notarized the Will (Ex.CW1/4) produced his Register pertaining to the entry
at Page No.13 at Sr. No.30 (Ex.CW2/A) and it was found that there was
some discrepancy with regard to the manner in which the identification of
the deceased was conducted. It was admitted that the Will was not bearing
the thumb impression of the executant, while in all other entries the
Executant had put his thumb impressions, which was considered as another
factor to create a doubt about the genuineness of the Will. Reference was
also made to the CGHS Card of the deceased on the basis of which the
deceased had been identified before the Notary Public/CW2, to observe that
the validity of the CGHS Card is for five years from the month of issue or
till the validity whichever is earlier. The use of CGHS Card which was
issued in May, 2010 was also considered as a factor raising the doubt about
the Will. It was further noted that Accused No.2, Smt. Shakuntala Devi was
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
the beneficiary under the disputed Will while Accused No.5 and 6, Pramod
Kumar Sagar and Sunil Kumar were the attesting witnesses.
36.
It was thus, observed by the learned ACMM that there was prima
facie offence under Section 420/467/468 and 471 read with 120B IPC made
out against the Petitioner/Shakuntala Devi, Pramod Kumar Sagar and Sunil
Kumar.
37.
These findings of the learned ACMM were considered by learned ASJ
who also concurred with these observations and did not find any ground to
upset the findings of learned ACMM.
38.
The main contention raised by the Petitioner is that both the parties
have filed their respective Suits for Declaration in respect of the Will and
once the civil litigation has been initiated, the criminal litigation is not
maintainable.
39.
This question whether criminal prosecution can be initiated in case
where the challenge to the genuineness of the Will is pending consideration
in Probate proceedings, was addressed in the case of Sardool Singh vs.
Nasib Kaur, 1987 SCC (Cri) 672 wherein it was observed as under:
“2.
A civil suit between the parties is pending
wherein the contention of the respondent is that no will was
executed whereas the contention of the appellants is that a will
has been executed by the testator. A case for grant of probate is
also pending in the court of learned District Judge, Rampur.
The civil court is therefore seized of the question as regards
the validity of the will. The matter is sub judice in the
aforesaid two cases in civil courts. At this juncture the
respondent cannot therefore be permitted to institute a
criminal prosecution on the allegation that the will is a forged
one. That question will have to be decided by the civil court
after recording the evidence and hearing the parties in
accordance with law. It would not be proper to permit the
respondent to prosecute the appellants on this allegation when
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
the validity of the will is being tested before a civil court. We,
therefore, allow the appeal, set aside the order of the High
Court, and quash the criminal proceedings pending in the Court
of the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Chandigarh in the case
entitled Smt Nasib Kaur v. Sardool Singh. This will not come in
the way of instituting appropriate proceedings in future in case
the civil court comes to the conclusion that the will is a forged
one. We of course refrain from expressing any opinion as
regards genuineness or otherwise of the Will in question as
there is no occasion to do so and the question is wide open
before the lower courts.”
40.
While referring to Sardool Singh, (supra) this aspect was distinguished
by the Apex Court in Kamaladevi Agarwal vs. State of West Bengal, (2002)
1 SCC 555, by observing that the nature and scope of civil and criminal
proceedings, as well as the standard of proof applicable thereto, are
fundamentally different and distinct. The Court rejected the contention that
the pendency of a civil suit before the High Court disentitled the Magistrate
from proceeding with the criminal case, either as a matter of law or on the
grounds of propriety. It was held that criminal proceedings must be
conducted strictly in accordance with the procedure prescribed under Cr.P.C,
and the pendency of a civil action in a different court even though higher
in status and authority, cannot be made a basis for quashing of the
proceedings.
41.
Furthermore, in the case of Syed Askari Haid Ali Augustine Iman and
Another vs. State (Delhi Administration) and Another, (2009) 5 SCC 528,
similar question of the FIR and the Probate proceedings considering the
validity of the Will, came into consideration. While adverting to Sardool
Singh, (supra), the Court observed that no binding ratio could be culled out
from the said decision, as the reasons for issuance of such directions or
observations were not discernible therefrom. The Court held that no
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
straightjacket formula can be applied and that the exercise of jurisdiction
to quash criminal proceedings is discretionary and must depend on the
cumulative facts of each case.
42.
The law on the permissibility of parallel civil and criminal
proceedings is now well settled and has been reiterated by the Apex Court in
recent case of Kathyayini vs. Sidharth P.S. Reddy & Ors., 2025 INSC 818,
order of the High Court which had quashed criminal proceedings involving
allegations of forgery, cheating and criminal conspiracy on the ground that
civil proceedings for partition and declaration were pending between the
parties, was set aside. The Court observed that it would be “unwise to rely
on unverified testimony” to ascertain the genuineness of a document and
held that the High Court erred in heavily relying on such material to
conclude that no offence was made out. Furthermore, it cautioned that such
an approach amounts to prematurely evaluating evidence, which is
impermissible at the threshold.
43.
Similarly, in the most recent decision, the Apex Court in C.S. Prasad
vs. C. Satyakumar and Ors., 2026 INSC 39 while referring to Neeharika
Infrastructure Private Limited vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors., (2021) 19
SCC 401) and Kathyayini, (supra), reaffirmed that adjudication in civil
matters and criminal prosecution proceed on different principles. It was
observed that it is a settled principle of criminal jurisprudence that civil
liability and criminal liability may arise from the same set of facts and that
the pendency or conclusion of civil proceedings does not bar prosecution
where the ingredients of a criminal offence are disclosed. It was observed
that there cannot be any general proposition that whenever dispute involves
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
a civil element, a criminal proceeding cannot go on. Criminal liability must
be examined independently.
44.
To sum up, what emerges is that it is a settled position of law that the
ingredients required to be established in civil proceedings and criminal
proceedings, even when arising from the same transaction, operate in
distinct spheres. In civil proceedings, the court is primarily concerned with
the validity, enforceability of a document, to be tested on the touchstone of
preponderance of probabilities. In contrast, criminal law is attracted only
where the allegations disclose the requisite mens rea and the commission of
an offence beyond the civil consequences of the act. The threshold in
criminal law is necessarily higher, as the court is required to examine
whether the act complained of was accompanied by dishonest intent since
the inception.
45.
Forgery, fabrication of documents and their use for wrongful gain are
therefore, not mere matters of civil invalidity but constitute independent
offences under the criminal law. Hence, civil adjudication regarding the
validity of a document cannot preclude criminal prosecution where the
ingredients of offences (such as cheating/forgery/conspiracy herein) are
prima facie disclosed, as the two remedies differ in their objective, scope
and standard of proof.
46.
Herein, it is also pertinent to refer to State of Haryana vs. Bhajan Lal,
1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 where the Apex Court considered in detail the scope
of powers of the High Courts under Section 482 Cr.P.C and/or Article 226 of
the Constitution of India to quash the FIR and held that the High Court
should not embark upon an inquiry into the merits and demerits of the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
allegations and quash the proceedings without allowing the investigating
agency to complete its task.
47.
In furtherance, the Apex Court in Neeharika Infrastructure, (supra)
cautioned that courts must not stifle legitimate investigation at the threshold
and that quashing should be an exception, exercised sparingly, only where
the complaint or FIR does not disclose the commission of any cognizable
offence.
48.
Applying the above-mentioned principles to the present case, the
summoning Order dated 27.02.2018 is confined to examining whether a
prima facie case was made out on the basis of the material placed before the
learned ACMM, who has rightly not ventured into an evaluation of the
defence set up by the Petitioner. The allegations, taken at face value, disclose
that the Will dated 28.01.2008 surfaced for the first time only in the year
2014, long after the demise of Sh. Anil Rana in 2011, and after the mutation
of the property as well as dismissal of revenue appeals.
49.
At the stage of summoning, the Magistrate is required only to
ascertain whether sufficient grounds exist to proceed and not whether the
evidence is sufficient for conviction. The learned ACMM has relied upon
the testimony of the Complainant, the handwriting expert, the bank officials
who produced the admitted signatures of the deceased, and the Notary
revealed discrepancies in identification and execution of the Will.
Cumulatively, the evidence on record prima facie discloses the commission
of offences under Sections 420, 467, 468 and 471 read with Section 120B
IPC.
50.
While upholding the above Order of learned ACMM, learned Special
Judge rightly observed that the factum of forging the Will in itself
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
contemplates an intention to defeat right of some other legitimate persons
while using such Will. It is that intention with which the Will was forged,
which is relevant for constituting a forgery.
51.
Furthermore, it was rightly noted that the mutation proceedings
pending before the SDM are altogether distinct from civil or probate
proceedings and cannot be treated as determinative of the genuineness of the
Will. The filing of an Application under Section 340 Cr.P.C by the
Complainant before the SDM also does not alter the character of the
proceedings. Consequently, the argument that the criminal complaint is
premature or not maintainable is devoid of merit.
52.
Any challenge to the validity or reliability of the expert opinion or
documentary evidence cannot be adjudicated in proceedings under Article
227 of the Constitution or Section 482 Cr.P.C. Those issues are matters of
investigation to be tested during the course of criminal investigation.
53.
The submission of the Petitioner that the dispute is purely civil in
nature is, therefore, untenable at this stage. The existence of civil and
probate proceedings concerning the validity of the Will does not eclipse the
allegations of forgery, fabrication and use of a forged document for securing
wrongful gain. Even if the Will is ultimately upheld or rejected in civil
proceedings, the criminal liability arising from the alleged acts of forging
and using the Will as genuine is required to be examined independently. To
accept the contention of the Petitioner would amount to prematurely
terminating a criminal prosecution at the first instance, which is contrary to
the settled principles of law.
54.
To accept the contention of the Petitioner, would tantamount to
considering the FIR/Complaint as an encyclopaedia of all the relevant
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
evidence, as observed in the case of Neeharika Infrastructure, (supra). In
fact, FIR/Complaint is only the commencement point and if the allegations
are not substantiated, it would be so concluded after investigations.
55.
Lastly, in this regard, reference be also made to M.S. Sheriff & Anr.
vs. State of Madras & Ors., AIR 1954 SC 397, referred in Syed Askari Haid
Ali Augustine Iman, (supra) wherein the Apex Court held that “as between
the civil and the criminal proceedings we are of the opinion that the
criminal matters should be given precedence”, observing that “a civil suit
often drags on for years and it is undesirable that a criminal prosecution
should wait till everybody concerned has forgotten all about the crime. The
public interests demand that criminal justice should be swift and sure; that
the guilty should be punished while the events are still fresh in the public
mind and that the innocent should be absolved as early as is consistent with
a fair and impartial trial. Another reason is that it is undesirable to let
things glide till memories have grown too dim to trust.”
Conclusion:
56.
In light of the above discussion, it is held that there exists no ground
for quashing the FIR at this initial stage. There is no merit in the present
Petition, which is hereby dismissed.
57.
The pending Application also stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 20, 2026
va
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:51:43
CRL.M.C.3484/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review