Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
B. A. No. 10960 of 2025
Shailesh Kumar, aged about 43 years, son of Uday Shankar Prasad, resident
of Dey Farm House Road, behind VVPS School, Chiraundi, P.O. and P.S.
Bariyatu, District-Ranchi, Jharkhand
...... … Petitioner
Versus
The State of Jharkhand through Anti-Corruption Bureau, Hazaribagh, P.O.,
P.S. and District-Hazaribagh
.…. …
Opposite Party
-------CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR DWIVEDI
For the Petitioner
:Mrs. Anjana Prakash, Senior Advocate
Mr. Anil Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Pradum Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Arpit Kumar, Advocate
For the ACB
: Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
Mr. Ritesh Kumar Gupta, Advocate
: Mr. Nillohit Choubey, Advocate
Ms. Shruti Shekhar, Advocate
Ms. Sanya Kumari, Advocate
04/
07.01.2026: Heard Mrs. Anjana Prakash, learned senior counsel for
the petitioner and Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, learned counsel for the A.C.B.
2.
The petitioner has been made an accused in connection with
Hazaribagh A.C.B. Sadar P.S. Case No. 11 of 2025 registered under sections
13(2) read with 13 (1) (d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and
under sections 420, 467, 468, 471, 120B of the Indian Penal Code, pending
in the Court of
learned
Additional District Judge-II-cum-Special Judge,
Vigilance (ACB), Hazaribagh.
3.
Mrs. Anjana Prakash, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submits that petitioner is presently posted as Deputy Director Panchayati
Raj, Panchayati Raj Department and he was the Circle Officer at the relevant
period of time and has acted strictly in terms of law as a public authority
within the norms stipulated by the law and he has been falsely implicated in
this case. She next draws the attention of the Court to the contents of F.I.R.
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
and submits that allegations are made that the petitioner has recommended
for cancellation of five jamabandi however he has not acted for cancellation
of further illegal jamabandi recorded in the name of other persons. Learned
senior counsel further submits that after almost 14 years of alleged mutation
by transfer by the petitioner which has never been challenged and still rent
receipts are being issued, the petitioner has been implicated in the present
case. She next submits that the petitioner has not created fresh jamabandi
and by way of transfer of mutation and after considering the long existing
jamabandi created earlier by respective officers on the basis of existing
provisions and Government circulars the petitioner has mutated the land in
favour of 23 persons. She also submits that allegation relating to Khata No.
95 is there that khata is huge chunk of land having 572 acres of land in view
of that it cannot be said that the petitioner has transferred the government
land only.
She next submits that
concerned, that is governed
so far cancellation of
mutation is
by the Bihar Land Reforms Act and the
procedures have been prescribed therein. By way of referring section 4 (h)
of Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950 and section 14 of the Bihar
Tenants
Holdings (Maintenance of Records) Act, 1973, she submits that by following
these provisions
the petitioner has passed order. She also submits that
reports have been called upon by the petitioner which was submitted by the
Circle Inspector and due publication of notice was made and thereafter the
order has been passed and to buttress this argument she
draws the
attention of the Court to the counter affidavit filed by the Anti Corruption
Bureau. She also submits that once a long standing jamabandi is there the
petitioner cannot suo motu take step for cancellation and this is settled
principle of law and by way of example she has cited judgment of the Patna
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
High court in the case of “Ram Prit Rao Vs. State of Bihar” reported in
2006 (2) PLJR 245. By way of placing the facts of paras 7 and 8 of the
counter affidavit filed by the Anti Corruption Bureau, learned senior counsel
for the petitioner submits that allegations of illegally doing the mutation in
favour of the 23 persons by the petitioner, are false which is fortified by the
documents brought on record by the ACB. She next submits that land was
mutated on the basis of sale deed of raiyati land created in
1959. She
further submits that petitioner has done due diligence which is fortified by
Annexure B. She has repeated her argument by way of saying that Khata No.
95 is huge chunk of land and it cannot be said that only the Government
land has been mutated by the petitioner. She also submits that five
jamabandi were recommended for cancellation by the petitioner as it has
come in the knowledge of the petitioner
created in accordance with law.
that those jamabandi were not
She next submits that
petitioner’s
successor and predecessors have done mutation and in view of that
allegation against the petitioner is false. She next submits that
allegation in
the F.I.R. is made of not following the guidelines of the Hon’ble High Court
of order dated 12.12.1996 passed in W.P.(C) No. 202 of 1995, is not correct.
By placing the said judgment, learned senior counsel submits that there is no
restriction of transferring the land and only observation is made that forest
land will not be used for other purpose.
4.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner also questions the
propriety of the document contained in Annexure-A to the counter-affidavit
filed by the A.C.B as there is cut at top and it has been stated that plots
described in that documents are restricted to be registered
to another
person. She next submits that notification which has come in the year 2015
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
with regard to restriction of transfer of land
has been quashed by the
Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court by order dated 01.05.2025 in W.P.(C) No.
5088 of 2018. She submits that there is no allegation of money trail against
the petitioner. She also submits that the petitioner was cooperating in the
investigation and in spite of that petitioner has been arrested by the ACB.
She next submits that the father-in-law of the petitioner was ill and he was
being treated at Delhi and the petitioner has gone to Delhi on 13.10.2025
and the father-in-law of the petitioner has left for his heavenly abode and
thereafter the petitioner came along with body of the father-in-law in the
morning of 14.10.2025 and in view of that the petitioner has not been able to
appear before the A.C.B. She also submits that the contents of notice of ACB
under section 35(3) of BNSS was not properly drafted and vague grounds
have been given and even the threatening was there that if the petitioner will
not appear before the ACB he will be arrested. She further submits that bail
application of the co-accused namely, Binay Kumar Singh has been rejected
by this Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court has granted interim bail to the
Co-accused Binay Kumar Singh by order dated 17.12.2025 passed in Special
Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No. (s) 20248/2025. In this background she submits
that for the allegation of 2010, the F.I.R has been registered in the year,
2025 and in view of that the petitioner may kindly be granted regular bail.
Lastly, learned senior counsel submits that the petitioner is in custody since
15.10.2025.
5.
Per contra, Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, learned counsel for the Anti
Corruption Bureau vehemently opposes the prayer for grant of regular bail of
the petitioner and submits that in the contents of F.I.R. the plot number and
Khata number disclosed, are tallying in the light of Annexure-A of the F.I.R
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
that is details of 23 mutation cases. He draws the attention of the Court to
Annexure-A of the counter affidavit and submits that document relates to
Gairmajarua Khas Forest Land and that is the document which is in the
signature of the petitioner. He also submits that the petitioner was knowing
about the fact inspite of that he has passed the order. He next submits that
records of mutation case was obtained by the I.O. of the case and further
signature of document annexed as Annexure-B, it appears that the petitioner
has also signed as the Circle Officer and Rajendra Prasad Singh as Circle
Inspector and their signatures are there at Annexure-A. He also submits that
in paras 153 to 165 and 271 to 280 of the Case Diary it has come that then
Circle Inspector namely, Rajendra Prasad Singh and Revenue Sub Inspector
namely, Ramprakash Choudhary improperly submitted report for mutation in
respect of the 22 Mutation Cases and have given incorrect enquiry report and
on the basis of that petitioner has passed order of mutation.
6.
By way of drawing the attention of the Court to para 18 of the
counter affidavit learned counsel for the ACB submits that during course of
investigation the I.O. of the present case made an attempt to collect the
original records
pertaining to 22
Mutation Cases done by the petitioner
whereby it has been revealed that the after plot no. 1 upto plot nos. 773
were found
unavailable at the Circle Office, Sadar, Hazaribagh
and
thereafter documents of plots were found to be missing and not traceable.
He further submits that this has been done by the Circle Officer, Staff along
with the Land Mafias destroying the khatian of the land in question and this
fact has come in para 188 of the case diary. He further submits that ACB has
taken all care so that the petitioner may cooperate in the investigation. By
way of drawing the attention of the Court to para 120 of the case diary he
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
submits that the petitioner is attempting lying low or going into hiding in
order to evade his arrest. He next submits that on 07.10.2025 notice under
section 35(3) of BNSS was sent through the Special Messenger to the
petitioner directing him to appear within a week and that notice has been
received by the brother of the petitioner on the same day inspite of that the
petitioner failed to appear before the I.O and an information was received
by the reliable source that the petitioner is attempting lying low or going into
hiding in order to evade his arrest and in view of that again notice was issued
on 13.10.2025 through Special Messenger directing the petitioner to appear
on 14.10.2025 before the I.O. He next submits that since the petitioner was
involved in rituals of his father-in-law on 13.10.2025 and in view of that
A.C.B has not disturbed the petitioner and the petitioner has assured the
I.O. that he will appear on 14.10.2025 and in view of that it has transpired
that the petitioner is attempting to go underground again and information
was received by the A.C.B that petitioner is available in his office at 6.00 P.M.
on 14.10.2025 and accordingly the team reached the office of the petitioner
and sought for his co-operation
in investigation however, the petitioner
denied to go along with the team and told that he will not go along with the
team after the office hours are over. thereafter the petitioner was taken into
custody on 15.10.2025. He also refers to Annexure-1 of the supplementary
affidavit
filed by the petitioner and submits that land has been
sold by
Shashi Shekhar Prasad, Ramdhani Ram and Rajendra Prasad Prasad however,
reason has been given of raiyati right of Bhimnath Mahto and Parputo Kapur
Devi. He submits that it is not known how Shashi Shekhar Ram, Ramdhanri
Ram and others who are the seller of the land were related to Bhimnath
Mahto and Parputo Kapur Devi. He further submits that in view of this fact
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
this petitioner being the Circle Officer is fully responsible for illegal mutation
in favour of 23 persons and in view of that the regular bail of this petitioner
may kindly be rejected as
there is every apprehension that seeing the past
conduct of the petitioner the petitioner will not cooperate in the investigation.
7.
In view of above submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties it transpires that allegation is made against the petitioner in the F.I.R
that he has suo motu has recommended for cancellation of five jamabandi
with regard to land in question however, he has not taken any step so far
rest of the jamabandi are concerned.
8.
There is no doubt that section 4 (h) of Bihar Land Reforms Act,
1950 and section 14 of the Bihar Tenants Holdings (Maintenance of Records)
Act, 1973 prescribed procedure of passing order of mutation. However that
procedure is required to be made in terms of strict provision made therein.
It has been alleged that on the incorrect report of Circle Inspector namely,
Rajendra Prasad Singh
and Revenue Sub Inspector namely, Ramprakash
Choudhary the petitioner has passed order of mutation. The plot numbers
mentioned in the contents of F.I.R and annexure-A which is part of the F.I.R
some of plots are similar.
9.
It has been argued by way of referring Annexure-A of the
counter-affidavit that document is in the signature of the petitioner and that
document relates to Gairmajurua Jungle Land which are not transferable and
in view of that the petitioner was knowing all these facts of the nature of
the land as the said document is in the signature of petitioner which is not
denied
in course of the argument by the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner. It has come in para 188 of the case diary that document relating
to khata no. 95 of plot. No. 01 to 773 are found in record and thereafter the
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
documents relating to plot nos. 811, 848, 1055, 1060, 1062, 1063 and
776/1055 which were all mutated by the petitioner and those documents are
missing from the record.
10.
It has been alleged that those documents have been purposely
removed from the record of the Circle Office. Now the petitioner is evading
his arrest as noted in the argument of the learned counsel for the Anti
Corruption Bureau.
11.
The documents on the record and averments made in the counter
affidavit of the A.C.B, it transpires that the petitioner was not cooperating in
the investigation.
12.
Although there has been a long delay in the initiation of
proceedings, the gravity of the allegations, the alleged abuse of official
position, custodial interrogation cannot be diluted merely on the ground of
delay. Even in a case based largely
on documentary evidence, custodial
interrogation may be essential to trace the chain of transactions ascertain
complicity, and prevent further suppression or tampering of records.
13.
The role of the Circle Officer in the State of Jharkhand was the
subject matter before the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in WP (PIL)
No. 4736 of 2018 and analogous cases wherein paras 16, 18, 23 and 26 it
has been observed as under:“ 16. This Court to say the least is shocked to note at no
stage, any query has been raised regarding the issue of title of the
land by the concerned authorities and the land has been allowed to
be transferred in favour of one or the other private party even
though the land had already been acquired as has been dealt with
in the various orders as referred hereinabove.
18. This Court needs to comment herein about the conduct
of the district administration including the Revenue Authorities
which include the Circle Officers of the concerned circle that circle
officers who were in the possession of the entire record but very
surprisingly, the Circle Officers of the concerned circle without
verifying the said record had entered the name of the subsequent
purchasers), even though as per the Bihar Maintenance of Records
Act, 1973, the circle officer is the custodian of the record. It is also
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
surprising that the circle officer has placed the record before this
Court but while entering the name of the litigant concerned at the
relevant time, has not taken care to even consult much less verify
the said record.
23 is only after the order having been passed by this Court
directing the learned Member Secretary, JHALSA to conduct an
enquiry with respect to the issue of encroachment and the
infrastructure then the learned Member Secretary, JHALSA by doing
the commendable job has reported about the encroachment over 07
acres of land within the precincts of the RIMS as has been taken
note in the order dated 03.12.2025. Therefore, the authority of the
RIMS is also equally accountable for allowing such rampant
encroachment to carry on within the precincts of the RIMS.
26. On similar line, this Court can also handover the investigation
to the CBI in the present scenario but, for the present, we are
refraining ourself in handing over the investigation to the CBI rather
this Court is directing the State Police to institute FIR and
investigation be conducted by the Anti Corruption Bureau against
the erring officials.”
14.
So far as parity is concerned, the law is well settled that the
principle of parity is to be applied if the case on fact is exactly similar then
only the principle of parity in the matter of passing order is to be passed but
if there is difference in between the facts then the principle of parity is not to
be applied. It is also well known that the Court cannot exercise its power in a
capricious manner and has to consider the totality of circumstances before
granting bail and only because another accused has been granted bail, the
present petitioner is also entitled for bail if the present facts are not similar,
i.e. not the law. So far the co-accused Binay Kumar Singh is concerned, he
was the purchaser of the land in question and the present petitioner is Circle
Officer and he has not acted in the light of his jurisdiction and it was
expected from the government officer to protect the right of the State and
not to connive in transferring the land of the State and in view of these
facts, the ground of parity is not made out so far this petitioner is concerned
and such the argument with regard to parity is, hereby rejected.
15.
Further the case relied by the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner in the case of Ram Prit Rao (supra) is on another facts. As such
that case is not helping the petitioner.
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
16.
What has been discussed herein above and the materials on record
it clearly suggests that the petitioner has connived with the purchasers and
others passed the said orders of mutation. The petitioner has also not
cooperated in the investigation.
17.
In view of what has been discussed hereinabove, the present
bail application fails and is hereby rejected at this stage. Pending I.A, if any,
stands dismissed.
( Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi, J.)
Dt.07.01.2026
Satyarthi/-
( 2026:JHHC:212 )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review