Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:19634
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 4235 of 2021
……
Shailesh Kumar Singh, aged about 67 years, son of Late Rajendra Prasad
Singh, resident of House no. 4A, Shyam Bachau Path, Uliyan Kadma, P.O. &
P.S.- Kadma, Town-Jamshedpur, District- East Singhbhum.
….
Petitioner(s)
-VERSUS1. The State of Jharkhand, through the Secretary / Principal Secretary, School
Education and Literacy Department, having office at MDI Building, Dhurwa,
P.O. & P.S.- Dhurwa, Town and District- Ranchi.
2. The Director, Secondary Education, School Education and Literacy
Department, Government of Jharkhand, having office at Secondary
Education Directorate, MDI Building, Dhurwa, P.O. & P.S.- Dhurwa, Town
and District- Ranchi.
3. Regional Deputy Director of Education, Kolhan Division, Chaibasa,
having office at Chaibasa, P.O. & P.S. Chaibasa, District-West Singhbhum.
…..Respondent (s)
……
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent (s)
: Mr. Manoj Tandon, Adv
Mrs. Neha Bhardwaj, Adv
Mr. Shubham Kumar, Adv
Ms. Shivani Bhardwaj, Adv
Mr. Karamjit S. Chhabra, Adv
: Mr. Kunal Chandra Suman, A.C. to G.P.-II
……
05/01.07.2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The writ petition has been preferred for a direction to quash and set
aside the decision contained in Letter No.550 dated 20.07.2021 (Annexure11), issued by Regional Deputy Director of Education, Kolhan, Chaibasa;
whereby the claim of the petitioner has been rejected. The petitioner has
further prayed for a direction upon the respondents to grant the benefits of
3rd MACP according to Resolution dated 01.09.2009 in the Pay Band of
PB-II, 9300-34800 with Grade Pay of 4800 and thereby to modify the office
order contained in Memo No.64 dated 30.01.2019 (Annexure-8), so far it
relates to the petitioner. Other consequential benefits have also been prayed
for in the writ petition.
BRIEF FACTS:
3.
Writ petitioner was appointed on 01.08.1978 on the post of clerk in
South Chotanagpur Division, Ranchi and was posted in the office of
District Superintendent of Education, Chaibasa, West Singhbhum. He
completed 20 years of service on 01.08.1998 and 30 years on 01.08.2008.
2026:JHHC:19634
The State of Jharkhand, Department of Finance issued Resolution
No.5207/F dated 14.08.2002 for extending the benefit of Assured Career
Progression (ACP) on completion of 12 years and 24 years of service.
Subsequently, South Chotanagpur Division was bifurcated and
Kolhan Division came into effect in the year 2008. The petitioner’s posting
came under Kolhan Division.
4.
The pay revision was notified by Resolution No.660/A dated
28.02.2009, whereby 6th Pay Revision was effected in Jharkhand from
01.01.2006. The pay scales of 5000-8000, 5500-9000 and 6500-10500 were
merged in the pay scale of 9300-34800 with Grade Pay of Rs.4200.
Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP) Scheme was promulgated
on 01.09.2009.
The 1st, 2nd and 3rd MACPs were to be granted on completion of 10
years, 20 years and 30 years of service respectively.
5.
The Regional Deputy Director of Education, South Chotanagpur
Division, Ranchi issued a Memo No.243 dated 20.02.2010; whereby, the
clerks, posted under the South Chhotanagpur Division, Ranchi were
extended the benefits of 3rd MACP in the Grade Pay of 4800 on completion
of 30 years of service with effect from 01.09.2008. Ram Lagan Ram and
several others similarly situated persons were granted such benefits. Such
grant of benefits was also approved by the Divisional Commissioner, South
Chhotanagpur Division, Ranchi.
6.
The petitioner was extended the benefits of 1st ACP in the Scale of
4500-7000 and 2nd ACP in scale of 5000-8000. The benefits of 1st ACP was
granted from 09.08.1999 and 2nd ACP with effect from 01.08.2002 on
completion of 12 and 24 years of service; though the petitioner was entitled
for 5000-8000 and 5500-9000 respectively as 1st and 2nd ACPs.
7.
The petitioner and another filed W.P.(s) No.2170 of 2015 for grant of
5000-8000 and 5500-9000 as 1st and 2nd ACPs respectively instead of 45007000 and 5000-8000. The said writ petition was disposed of on 13.11.2017
directing the respondents to pay the pay scale of 5000-8000 and 5500-9000
respectively for 1st and 2nd ACPs to the petitioner and another.
This led to issuance of Memo No.64 dated 30.01.2019 by RDDE,
Kolhan Division, Chaibasa and the 1st and 2nd ACPs were granted to the
2026:JHHC:19634
petitioner in the scale of 5000-8000 and 5500-9000 from 09.08.1999 and
01.08.2002 respectively.
The petitioner, however, was extended the benefits of 3rd MACP with
effect from 01.09.2008 in the Grade Pay of 4600 though as per the
petitioner, he is entitled for 4800. The petitioner submitted representation
on 18.06.2021, but the same was rejected by Letter No.550 dated
20.07.2021, which is impugned in the writ petition.
ARGUMENT Of The PETITIONER:
8.
Mr. Manoj Tandon, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that from perusal of MACP Scheme dated 01.09.2009 (Annexure-3
to the writ petition), more particularly Clause 5 of Appendix-I, it is evident
that the merger of two pay scales shall have no bearing on grant of the
benefits under the MACP Scheme as the same was fit to be ignored. While
assailing Annexure-11, being Letter No.550 dated 20.07.2021, learned
Counsel contended that no reason has been assigned as to why the
petitioner shall be entitled for Grade Pay of 4600 instead of 4800.
He contended that merger of scales has nothing to do with grant of
MACP in view of Clause 5 of Appendix-I of MACP Scheme dated
01.09.2009.
9.
He further submits that from bare perusal of Annexure-4 dated
19.02.2010, it is evident that the Clerks/Stenographers are entitled for 3rd
MACP benefits in the Grade Pay of 4800. This decision, however, was
taken by the Regional Deputy Director of Education, South Chotanagpur
Division, Ranchi, from where Kolhan Division was carved out in the year
2008.
Merely because of creation of new Kolhan Division in 2008, the
petitioner cannot be deprived of such benefits, which has already been
given to many persons including Shri Ram Lagan Ram whose position
appears at Sl. No.1, thereof. He further submits that this petitioner was
already granted the pay scale of 5500-9000 on grant of 2nd ACP and hence
he is entitled for 3rd MACP in the Grade Pay of 4800.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner further submits that even as per
Annexure-‘H’ of the counter affidavit filed by respondents, it is crystal
2026:JHHC:19634
clear that 3rd MACP benefits were extended in the Grade Pay of 4800 to
those who were working in the South Chotanagpur Division, Ranchi.
10. Mr. Tandon, lastly submits that merely because the petitioner was
working in Kolhan Division, Chaibasa, he may not be held disentitled for
the grant of 3rd MACP benefits in the Grade Pay of 4800. Learned Counsel
submits that pursuant to order dated 08.09.2022 passed in this writ petition,
a supplementary counter affidavit has been filed, but the issue raised has not
been answered.
In nutshell the submission of the petitioner is that once such benefits
have been extended to the Clerks posted in South Chhotanagpur Division,
Ranchi, the petitioner is also entitled for the same benefits though he was
working in Kolhan Division which was carved out in 2008 from South
Chhotanagpur Division, Ranchi.
ARGUMENT Of The RESPONDENTS:
11. Learned AC to GP-II appearing on behalf of the respondents submits
that a detailed counter affidavit has been filed by the respondents stating,
inter alia, that as per the ACP Scheme dated 14.08.2002, the petitioner was
granted the benefits in the scale of 5000-8000 as 1st ACP which was not
proper and the same was wrongly granted. He further submits that several
others were granted the benefits of 3rd MACP in the Grade Pay of 4800, but
the same was later on modified which led to filing of W.P.(s) No.6760 of
2017. The writ petition was allowed on 01.08.2018 and thereafter L.P.A.
No.666 of 2018 was preferred in which notices were issued.
Learned Counsel for the State further submits that the pay scales of
5000-8000 and 5500-9000 were merged with the pay scale of 6500-10500.
In view of such merger the petitioner is entitled for Grade Pay of 4600 only
on grant of 3rd MACP.
12. While referring to paragraph no.13 of the main counter affidavit,
learned Counsel for the State submits that in compliance of the order passed
in W.P.(s) No.2170 of 2015, the earlier pay scale granted was revised to
5000-8000 and 5500-9000 with effect from 09.08.1999 and 01.08.2002
respectively on grant of 1st and 2nd ACPs. He, therefore, submits that the
petitioner is not entitled for the reliefs sought for and the writ petition
deserves to be dismissed.
2026:JHHC:19634
REASONS:
13. I have heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the materials
on record. The writ petition deserves to be allowed for the following facts
and reasons:(a) The facts are not in dispute. Initially the petitioner was granted
the benefits of 1st and 2nd ACPs in the pay scales of 4500-7000 and
5000-8000. The petitioner and others, being aggrieved, filed writ
petition before this Court. In the light of the order passed in W.P.(s)
No.2170 of 2015 such benefits were revised and the petitioner was
granted 5000-8000 and 5500-9000 respectively on grant of 1st and
2nd ACPs, which is not in dispute. Once this petitioner was already in
pay scale of 5500-9000 on grant of 2nd ACP, it is natural that the
petitioner would get the Grade Pay of 4800 on grant of the benefits
of 3rd MACP on completion of 30 years of his service.
(b) The statement made in paragraph no.12 of the supplementary
counter affidavit filed by respondents is highly contemptuous.
Regional Deputy Director of Education, West Singhbhum (Shri
Abhay Shankar) has sworn the affidavit contending, inter alia, that
the benefits of 5000-8000 was wrongly granted to the petitioner. This
statement made in paragraph no.12 runs contrary to the decision of
this Court in W.P.(s) No.2170 of 2015, placed at Annexure-7 of the
writ petition. Not only this, this order passed by the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court was duly complied with by Regional Deputy
Director of Education, Kolhan Division, Chaibasa, which is evident
from Office Order contained in Memo No.64 dated 30.01.2019,
placed at Annexure-8 of the writ petition. Once this fact has not been
disputed, the deponent of supplementary counter affidavit cannot
have audacity to make such statement that such benefit was wrongly
granted.
(c) The stand of State-respondent that against the order passed in
W.P.(s) No.6706 of 2017, L.P.A. No.666 of 2018 was preferred and
notices were issued also has no bearing on the fate of this case,
inasmuch as, such L.P.A. No.666 of 2018 was dismissed on
08.08.2023 itself. Moreover, the fact remains that order passed in the
2026:JHHC:19634
case of petitioner was never challenged by the state and, in fact, the
same was complied.
(d) When this writ petition was heard on 08.09.2022 the Coordinate Bench this Court, while referring the facts of this case,
directed the respondent-State to file a short counter affidavit
explaining as to why this petitioner has been discriminated. The issue
raised in the order dated 08.09.2022 by the Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court has not at all been answered by the respondents, though the
supplementary counter affidavit was filed thereafter.
Strangely enough, many other aspects have been highlighted,
but the issue and the points posed by this Court have been purposely
avoided by the deponent of supplementary counter affidavit.
(e) The order impugned contained in Letter No.550 dated
20.07.2021 is absolutely without any reason. The impugned order is
cryptic and has no leg to stand in the facts of this case. The petitioner
has submitted a detailed representation in the shape of Annexure-9
which is dated 18.06.2021, but the respondent concerned has not
bothered to answer the issue raised therein.
It is well settled that the reasons cannot be supplemented in the
shape of counter affidavit. The reasons are required to be mentioned
in the order under challenge. This Court finds that when others have
been extended such benefit in South Chotanagpur Division, Ranchi,
the petitioner is also entitled for the same. If a contrary view is taken,
the reasons have to be assigned. However, the same is totally absent
in the impugned order dated 20.07.2021. In this context, it is
profitable to refer the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in the case of Mohinder Singh Gill Vs. Chief Election
Commissioner, reported in (1978) 1 SCC 405. Paragraph 8 reads
thus:
The second equally relevant matter is that when a
statutory functionary makes an order based on certain
grounds, its validity must be judged by the reasons so
mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons
in the shape of affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order
bad in the beginning may, by the time it comes to Court
on account of a challenge, get validated by additional
“8.
2026:JHHC:19634
grounds later brought out. We may here draw attention to
the observations of Bose, J. in Gordhandas Bhanji:
Public orders, publicly made, in
exercise of a statutory authority cannot be
construed in the light of explanations subsequently
given by the officer making the order of what he
meant or of what was in his mind, or what he
intended to do. Public orders made by public
authorities are meant to have public effect and are
intended to affect the actings and conduct of those
to whom they are addressed and must be construed
objectively with reference to the language used in
the order itself.
Orders are not like old wine becoming better as they
grow
older.
[emphasis supplied]
(f)
It has rightly been pointed out by the learned Counsel for the
petitioner that since the petitioner was already getting the pay scale
of 5500-9000 on grant of 2nd ACP, he is entitled for 3rd MACP
benefits in the Grade Pay of 4800. Order issued by Regional Deputy
Director of Education, South Chotanagpur Division, Ranchi dated
19.02.2010 is on record as Annexure-4, as per which a number of
persons were granted the benefits of 3rd MACP in the Grade Pay of
4800.
Not only this even Annexure-‘H’ to the main counter
affidavit, filed by the respondents, discloses that the 3rd MACP
benefits were granted to similarly situated persons in the Grade Pay
of 4800. In the same Office Order the name of this petitioner also
appears under the caption “Kolhan Division, Chaibasa” wherein
the name of this petitioner appears but he has been granted the Grade
Pay of 4600 on grant of 3rd MACP that too without disclosing any
reason therefor. This is nothing but a clear-cut violation of Article 14
of the Constitution of India. The similarly situated person, like
petitioner, has been treated differently that too without there being
any reasonable classification. Merely because this petitioner was
then posted in Kolhan Division, the same would not be a ground to
deprive the benefits which was already granted to many persons in
the South Chotanagpur Division, Ranchi.
(g)
It further appears that for every benefit the petitioner had to
approach this Court. From the facts of the case, it appears that this
petitioner filed writ petition earlier, being W.P.(s) No.2170 of 2015
2026:JHHC:19634
with another. The writ petition was disposed of on 13.11.2017 with a
direction to pay the benefits of 1st and 2nd ACPs at the pay scale
which was granted to others. Pursuant thereto; Office Order dated
30.01.2019 was issued and the petitioner was extended the benefits
of 1st and 2nd ACPs in the scales of 5000-8000 and 5500-9000.
Once this issue was settled, the next benefit of 3rd MACP was required
to be given to the petitioner in accordance with law. But, however, the
petitioner has again been constrained to knock the door of this Court which
cannot be countenanced. Once the order was passed by this Court and the
same was complied, the respondent concerned should have acceded the
request of the petitioner to put him in the proper pay scale on grant of 3rd
MACP benefits. This action of the respondent, in the present case, is highly
arbitrary, unconstitutional and, in fact, in colourable exercise of power and
nothing else.
CONCLUSION:
14.
In the light of what has been held above, the impugned order
contained in Letter No.550 dated 20.07.2021 (Annexure-11), is set aside.
The respondents are directed to extend the benefits of 3rd MACP to the
petitioner in the scale of PB-II, 9300-34800 with Grade Pay of 4800 with
effect from 01.09.2008 with all consequential benefits.
The difference of amount accrued from the due date till the date of
payment must be paid within a period of 8 weeks from the date of receipt of
a copy of this order, failing which the same would carry simple interest @
6% per annum from the date the same was payable till the date of actual
payment.
15.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands allowed. No order as to
costs. Pending I.A., if any, stand closed.
(Deepak Roshan, J)
01.07.2026
Amardeep/
Uploaded on
07.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review