Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[3300 I
AD
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDE
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
,
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 3s836 0F 2025
Between
Shaik Khader Basha, S/o Sk.Hajipeera, aged 64 years Licensee of Stall No.
SMU/018, Platform No 4 and 5, Kachiguda Railway Station, Hyderabad - 500027,
Ryo 1-1768-1 , Appa Rao Building, Opp, Singareddy Apartment, Gandhi Nagar, Yerra
Mukha Palli (Y.M.Palli), KADAPA, Andhra Pradesh- 516001
...PETITIONER
AND
. Union of lndia, Rep by The Chief Executive Officer-cum- Chairman, Railway
Board, Ministry of Railways, Rail Bhawan, New Delhi- 110001
2. The General Manager, South Central Railway, Rail Nilayam, Secunderabad,
Telangana State - 500071
3. The Senior Divisional Commercial Manager, South Central Railway,
Hyderabad Division, Hyderabad Bhawan, Secunderabad - 500071
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased lo issue a Writ, Order or direction more particularly one in the nature of
Mandamus directing the respondent Railways to renew the license of SMU No018lKCGl4-5lTS from 30.O7.2O25 in accordance with the provisions of
Commercial Circular No. 22 of 2017 granting all copsequential benefits.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the action conveyed vide Letter No. Y/C.79/CATG/KCG-SMU-TS/PF-4-5
DIME END/2025, dated 21 .11.2025.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI K.R.K.V.PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent: SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO,
Dy.Solicitor General Of lndia
.
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN TIIE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI{A
WRIT PETITION No. 35836 OF 2o25
o8.o L.2026
Betwe,en:
Shaik l(hadar Basha
..... Petitioner
And
Union of India
Rep. by the Chief Executive Officer-cum-Chairman
& two cthers.
.. Respondents
ORDI} R:
Petitioner states that he has been earning his
tivelihood solely through raiiway catering licences. He previously
held pla':form sta-lls at various railway stations and was awarded
a Special Minor Unit Tea Stall No. SMU/018 on Platforms 4 and
5 at Kacheguda Railway Station with effect from 10.09.2016. He
was also awarded a General Minor Unit licence at Guntakal
Railway Station with effect from 19.O7.2Ot8. It is stated,
notifications issued under Catering Policy, 2OLO were
challenged by the SCR Caterers, Dry Fruits, Fruit Juice Stalls
Welfare Association and others in Writ Petition Nos . L4577,
14888 and L5O72 of 2013. By order dated 16.08.2013, this
Court held that existing licensees were entitled to consideration
for renewal subject to policy conditions, which order was
confirmed by the Division Bench on 12.09.2013 in Writ Appeal
Nos. 1573,1574 and 1575 of2013.
1.1.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal Nos.
6L8-62O of 20 16 arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 9921-9923 of 2014,
by judgment dated 29.OL.2016, held that denial of renewal was
arbitrary and it affected the right to livelihood of licensees solely
dependent on such units. The Court clarified that renewal
would be available onLy to those holding a single unit and
declaring the same on affidavit. It
is stated further,
subsequently, the Ministry of Railways issued Catering Policy,
2fr17 uide Commercial Circular No. 20 of 2OL7 dated
27.02.20 17, revising the teni:re of units to five years without
renewal. In compliance with the Supreme Court judgment,
Commercial Circular No. 22 of 2077 dated 15.O3.2OL7 was
issued, permitting renewal of a single retained minor unit after
surrender of other units, subject to conditions specified. therein.
L.2.
At the time of issuance of Commercial Circular No.
22 of 2017, petitioner held the Tea Stall licence at Kacheguda
Railway Station and a GMU licence at Guntakal Railway
a
J
Statiorr. The Tea Stall licence was awarded uide Letter of Award
dated '.28.07.2O 16 under Special Minor Units - Minorities quota,
comm€:rrc€d on lO.O9.2016 and was initially valid till
09.09.r)021. Due to Covid-19, a dies-non period of 323 days was
grantecl and the licence was extended up to 29.07.2022. To
comply with Commercial Circular No. 22 of 2017, petitioner
surrenclered the GMU licence at Guntakal Railway Station,
which rsas valid from L9.1O.2O18 to 18.10.2023 and the said
surrender was accepted by the Senior Divisional Commercial
Manage:, Guntakal Division, and the GMU licence was
surrend,:red with elTect from 18.02.2022. After submission of
required documents pursuant to letter dated LO.O3.2O22, the
Tea Stall licence at Kacheguda was renewed for three years from
3O.O7.2C22 to 29.07 .2025, and an agreement dated 18.11 .2022
was executed specifically referring to Railway Board letter dated
15.03.2017, Commercial Circular No. 22 of 2OI7.
1.3.
Before expiry of the renewed period, petitioner
applied f:r further renewal for three years uide letter dated
I3.l2.2otl4 and again on 08.05.2025 due to no response. He
was pernritted to continue operating the Tea Stall beyond
29.07.2025, creating a legitimate expectation of renewal in
terms of poticy. However, it is stated, he received a show
cause
Notice dated 29.09.2025, served on 03.10.2025, invoking Para
17 of Catering Policy, 2OlO, alleging unsatisfactory performance
due to penalties imposed on more than five occasions. Petitioner
replied on 09.10.2025 stating that he retained only one stall
under Commercial Circular No. 22 of ZOLZ,ldepend.ed solely on
it for livelihood; complaints regarding overcharging of packaged
drinking water were vague and did not identi$r vendors, and
that penalties were paid to avoid disputes.
L.4.
By letter dated 21.11.2025, the 3.d regpondent
rejected the request for renewal under Para 17.1 of Catering
Policy, 2OlO, terminated the contract with immediate effect and
directed closure of the Tea Stall. Petitioner states that no Show
Cause Notice was issued during the subsisting licence period
and that termination occurred after the renewal period had
commenced. He had continued employing L2 vepdors in
anticipation of renewal, and termination of the sole licence has
caused severe financial hardship to him and loss of livelihood to
those vendors. It is stated, Kacheguda Railway Station has 19
stalls operated by 19 licensees with about 200 vendors selling
eatables and packaged drinking water. In penalty letters issued
to petitioner, ro specific vendor details were mentioned,
therefore irregularities could not be attributed to his stall
!
I
withou.t proper investigation. The allegations are stated to be
vague end insufficient to deny renewal.
1.5.
Petitioner also contends that reliance on Catering
Policy, 20lO in the impugned letter dated 21.L1.2025 is illegal,
as his licence was renewed earlier strictly under Commercial
Circular No. 22 of 2017 issued pursuant to the judgment of the
Honble Supreme Court. It is stated, Article 2-2 of the Master
Licence Agreement required the Railways to notify parameters
for determining satisfactory performance, which was never done
after e>recution of the agreement dated i8.1 1 .2022. Letters
dated 2;.1O.2022, 03.O5.2024, OL.O7.2024 and 03.07.2024 did
not spet:ify that the1, would be relied upon for denial of renewal,
and no Show Cause Notices were issued at the relevant time.
ISsuing a Show Cause Notice after commencement of renewed
period ir; stated to be violative of principles of natural justice
and it would defeat legitimate expectation.
1.6.
Petitioner relies on the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Sentor Dioisional Commercial Manager a.
SCR Caterers, Dry Fnfits, Fntit Juice Stalls Welfare
Associatiottl, holding that denial of renewal to persons soleiy
depender.t on such units is unfair and. arbitrary and affects the
t(zote) 3 scc s82
right to livelihood. It is stated that Commercial Circular No. 22
of 2017 does not contemplate coercive termination of the nature
adopted in the petitioner's case. Petitioner alleges that Show
Cause Notice and termination letter dated 21.17.2025 contain
identical reasoning, showing non-consideration of reply and lack
of an independent decision. The impugned order is stated to be
non-speaking, unsupported by evidence of unsatisfactory
performance, and passed despite absence of dues or court
cases. The action is alleged to be arbitrary, irrational, illegal,
vitiated by malice in law and violative of Articles 19(1)(g), 39 and
2L of the Constitution of India.
2.
Heard Sri K.R.K.V. Prasad, learned counsel for
petitioner.
3.
Sri N. Bhujanga Rao, learned Deputy Solicitor
General, based on the written instructions submitted by the
Assistant Commercial Manager, submits that Tea Stall was
awarded pursuant to Tender Notice dated 30.1 1 .2015 strictly
under the Catering Policy-2010 for five years from 1O.O9.2016 to
O9.O9.2O21, petitioner is governed by the said Policy and the
Master Licence Agreement, along with subsequent circulars
issued from time to time. It is submitted, due to COVID-l9
pandemic, a dies-non period of 323 days was granted, extending
the licence up to '29.o7.2022, and thereafter, upon submission
of an affidavit under commercial circular No. 22 0f 20L7,
licence was renewr:d for a further three years from 3o-o7.2o22
to 2g.o7.2025. According to the learned Deputy Solicitor
General, renewal is not a matter of right either under Article 2'2
of the Master Licence Agreement or under Point No- 17 of the
catering Policy-2010, and it is strictly subject to satisfactory
perforrrLance of the licensee during the tenure of the contract.
As
per Article 2 of the Master License Agreement' particularly
clause 2.2 relating to renewal, renewal of the agreement is not a
matter of right of the licensee and is subject to satisfactory
perforr-nance during the tenure of the agreement. satisfactory
performance is assessed through various parameters including
cirstome,r feedback as defined. under Clause 6.4 of the
agreement, and the Railways are entitled to obtain independent
customer feedback to assess passenger satisfaction' During the
renewal period from 3o.o7.2022 to 29.07.2025, penalties were
imposed on petitioner on six occasions for deficiencies including
overcharging and deviation from service standards.
3.1.
Relying on Article 2.2(b) of the Master Licence
Agreement, which mandates timely pa]rment of licence fee and
all appli<:able charges including fines and submission of No
I
I
,
I
Dues Certificate at the time of renewal, it is submitted that in
several instances, petitioner delayed payment of penalties,
thereby committing breach of contractual obligations. In view
of repeated violations and delayed payments, Show Cause
Notice dated 29.09.2025 was issued to petitioner, to which
explanation dated Og.1O.2025 was submitted which was found
unsatisf,actory., as it failed to justi$r repeated non-cor,npliance
and unsatisfactory operational performance. Consequently, the
competent authority terminated the contract uide Letter dated
2L.71.2025 under Para 17.1 of the Catering Policy-2OlO.
3.2.
Learned Deputy Solicitor General also placed
reliance on inspection reports and public complaints and
submits that Commercial Inspectors conducted. inquiries on
complaints of overcharging packaged d.rinking water, during
which vendors admitted to overcharging and were found
irregular in paying penalties within stipulated time. During
inspection by the Senior Divisional Commercial Manager on
15.02.2025, it was observed that a vendor overcharged a water
bottle by Rs.S/-, indicating a recurring practice. It is.submitted
that the Railway Administration never directed petitioner to
surrender the contract nor restrained him from participating in
any other tenders. Petitioner remains free to participate in
caterir.Lg tenders across Indian Railways.
3.3.
It is further submitted that petitioner's contention
that Tr:a Stall was awarded pursuant to Commercial Circular
No. 22 0f 2017 dated 15.03.2017 is incorrect. The stall was
originatly awarded under catering Policy-20lo pursuant to
Tender Notice dated 30.11 .2015, and therefore, petitioner is
governe,d by catering Policy-2o10 along with subsequent
circulars issued b)' the Railways from time to time' As per
Article L3 of the Master License Agreement relating to Events of
Default and Material Breach, failure to provide satisfactory
services, breach o[ prescribed limits relating 'to fines and'
warnings, furnishing false information for renewal, or
ehgagenrent in corrupt or fraudulent practices constitutes
material breach, rendering the licensee liable for termination
and other penal action. In the present case, petitioner was
penalize<l on more than five occasions for violations including
overcharging, theretry establishing non-compliance with the
catering Policy-2010 and the executed agreement, and making
the petiticner liable f<rr termination.
3.4.
As per Article 15.3, the Railway Administration is
empowerr:d to terminate the contract by issuing a 15-day notice
I
in the event of material breach or inability of the licensee to
perform satisfactorily, and the decision of the Railways in this
regard is final and binding. It is submitted that petitioner has
not been blacklisted or debarred and continues to be eligible to
participate in future catering tenders. In view of petitioner's
repeated violations, delayed payment of
penalties,
unsatisfactory performance and breach of contractual and
policy conditions, rejection of renewal and termination of
contract was effected to ensure accountability, maintain public
confidence, and safeguard the interests of passengers using
Railway premises. It is therefore, submitted that action of the
Railway Administration is strictly in accordance with the
catering Policy-2010, the Master License Agreement,
Commercial Circular No. 22 of 2OIZ.
4'
upon perusar of the material on record
heard learned counsel on either
side, it is seen, petitioner,s
contention that catering poricy-2010
without merit. The original aflotment
Catering Policy-2o10 pursuant
30.11 .2OlS. Commercial
supersede the catering
and having
cannot be appried is
of Tea stall was under
to Tender Notice dated
Circular No. 22 of 2OlT
Policy-2olo but operates
does not
*ithi, it,
ll
framervork, permitting retention of a single unit subject to
condit;ons. The Agreement dated 18.11.2022 also incorporates
the M,rster Licence Agreement clauses, including provisions
relatinli to satisfactory performance and termination. Further,
the reliance placed by petitioner on the judgment of the Honble
Suprere court in civil Appeal Nos. 618-620 of 2016 does not
advanct: his case. The said judgment itself clarifies that renewal
is subje:t to compliance with poticy conditions and is available
only to eligible licensees fulfiliing stipulated criteria' In
the
presentcase,petitionerhasad'mittedlysufferedpenaltieson
more than five occasions' which' under
Catering Policy-2O10, mandates
5.
Para 17 | of the
rejection of renewal'
The plea of legitimate expectation
also cannot be
s'ustainecl.Merecontinuationbeyondtheexpirydatedoesnot
conferaiegalrighttorenewal,particularlywhenthegoverning
that renewal is not a
state
explicitly
policy and agreement
the Show
was put on notice through
Petitioner
right'
of
matter
an
and was afforded
Cause Irlotice
dated 29 'Og '2025
opPortunitY to submit
his exPlanation'
The contention that Show
Cause Notice and
terminatitlnordercorrtainidenticalreasoningdoesnotvitiate
discloses objective material'
record
the
when
decision
the
ili
ll
r1
.:
t2
I
li
ri
:;
:
inspection reports, penalty records and contractual breaches.
The decision is traceable to statutory policy provisions and
contractual clauses, and therefore cannot be termed arbitrary or
non-speaking. Learned counsel for petitioner contended that no
parameters were notified under Article 2.2 of the Master Licence
Agreement, however, the said contention is untenable in view of
Para 17.l of the Catering Policy-2O70, which clearly prescribes
imposition of f,rnes or warnings on more than five occasions as a
disqualifying factor
7.
Respondents further clarified that petitioner has not
been blacklisted or debarred and he remains eligible to
participate in future tenders. Termination pertains only to the
i
present licence and is based on documented unsatisfactory
performance. Ifl this connection, it is to be observed, the
principle of social justice and right to livelihood, though
significant, cannot be invoked to protect practices such as
overcharging passengers or repeated violation of service
standards, which adversely affect the travelling public and
tarnish the image of Indian Railways
8.
This Court therefore, is of the opinion that the
action of respondents is justified in the light of the catering
Policy-2olo, Master Licence Agreement, commercial circular
No. 22 of 2017, inspection records, penalt5r history and due
process. No arbitrariness, mala fides or violation of Articles
19(1)(g), 2l or 39 of the Constitution is made out by petitioner.
The Writ Petition is therefore, devoid of merits and the same is
liable tc be dismissed
9.
The \['rit Petition is accordingly, dismissed. No
costs.
10.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
SD/.P. PONNA KRISHNA
SISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY/
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC lo SRI K.R.K.''/.PRASAD, Advocate' I
RAO, Deputy Solicitor General of lndia' High
2 one cc to SRI N.BHUJANGA
"reri
UC]
court for rhe stateti
Two CD OoPies.
BSK
BS
nga ni ai r-tyoera6ad. [oP
t
t
HIGH COURT
DATED:08/01 12026
,/
,,.irid{i:
r
(-
ORDER
z 3 Jtil a0ffi
*
WP.No.3li836 of 2025
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUTCOSTS
I leh
'k
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review