Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
SHAHID HUSSAIN
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. T.D. Yadav, Advocate.
versus
GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC (GNCTD)
with Mrs. Tania Ahlawat, Mr. N.K.
Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam and Mr.
Mohnish Sehrawat, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
22.04.2026
%
1.
This petition assails two orders arising out of disciplinary proceedings
instituted against the Petitioner. The first is the order dated 22nd January,
2013 passed by the Vice-Chairman, Delhi Agricultural Marketing Board
[“DAMB”], acting as the disciplinary authority, whereby the Petitioner was
dismissed from service. The second is the order dated 2nd April, 2014 passed
by the Secretary-cum-Commissioner (Development), Government of NCT
of Delhi [“GNCTD”], whereby the Petitioner’s appeal was rejected and the
penalty was upheld.
Factual Background
2.
The Petitioner was initially engaged on 14th July, 1987 as a Peon on
daily wages. The Respondents state that he was appointed on a regular basis
in Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee, Najafgarh [“APMC”] with
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
effect from 3rd March, 1996. It is, however, not in dispute that by the year
2002 he stood posted at Fish, Poultry & Egg Marketing Committee, Gazipur
[“FP&EMC”] and was working in the cadre of Gateman/Peon.
3.
The controversy arises from the Petitioner’s absence from duty with
effect from 15th February, 2003. According to the Respondents, the
Petitioner absented himself without “prior intimation/sanction” and did not
report back despite repeated directions. The Respondents rely on a Show
Cause Notice [“SCN”] dated 4th April, 2003, a memorandum dated 17th
February, 2004, a further communication dated 28 th August, 2004, another
memorandum dated 16th January, 2005, and a public notice published on 16th
July, 2005 in newspapers calling the Petitioner to resume duty.
4.
The Petitioner does not dispute that he remained away from duty. His
case is that such absence was occasioned by serious illness. The Counter
Affidavit records that, vide letter dated 15th September, 2004, DAMB was
informed that he remained ill from 15th March, 2003 to 14th September, 2004
and was undergoing treatment at MMG Hospital, Ghaziabad.
5.
On 18th November, 2005, DAMB issued a charge-sheet memorandum
under Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and
Appeal) Rules, 1965 [“CCS (CCA) Rules”] proposing a disciplinary inquiry
against the Petitioner. The said memorandum stated that the Petitioner had
remained “unauthorisedly absent from duty” since 15th February, 2003,
thereby violating the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972 [“CCS (Leave) Rules”] and
the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 [“CCS (Conduct) Rules”].
6.
It is stated that the Petitioner submitted a reply on 9th December,
2005. The Respondents, in their Counter Affidavit, do not dwell upon the
contents of the said reply, but narrate the sequence of events by stating that
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
the Petitioner had, at the relevant time, taken the position that he was
suffering from illness and was undergoing treatment at MMG Hospital,
Ghaziabad. Also, the earlier communications sent to the Petitioner had
returned undelivered with the remark “the address is incomplete”.
7.
The record thereafter reflects a somewhat convoluted sequence of
events. According to the Respondents, the Petitioner submitted an
application on 13th March, 2006 along with medical material covering the
period up to 5th December, 2005, which indicated that he had been found fit
to resume duty with effect from 6th December, 2005. As no material was
furnished for the subsequent period, DAMB called upon him to explain his
medical condition and thereafter issued a memorandum dated 10 th August,
2006 requiring submission of medical/fitness certificates. The Petitioner, in
his reply dated 22nd August, 2006, stated that even on 6th December, 2005,
while on his way to the office, he again developed acute pain, returned to the
hospital, remained under bed rest till 12th April, 2006, and thereafter
continued under medical advice till October, 2006. The Respondents also
acknowledge that certificates were produced indicating fitness with effect
from 13th April, 2006 and again with effect from 26th October, 2006, though
their case is that the Petitioner did not report at his place of posting.
8.
It is not in dispute that, on 26th October, 2006, the Petitioner
approached DAMB with medical documents. According to the Respondents,
his papers were returned and he was directed, by a memorandum of the
same date, to report to FP&EMC, which he failed to do. The Petitioner,
however, asserts that he repeatedly approached the office of DAMB as well
FP&EMC, met officials, and was sent back and forth without any effective
decision, despite attempting to submit joining reports along with medical
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
documents. He further claims to have approached the Chairman and
submitted a written representation, but without any result. These assertions
find place in his appeal dated 19th February, 2012 as well as in his reply to
the inquiry findings dated 14th February, 2012.
9.
The Petitioner again addressed a communication dated 21st December,
2009, stating that he was now fit to join duty. The Respondents maintain that
no proper medical fitness certificate for the relevant period accompanied this
request and that the competent authority did not permit him to resume duty.
10.
On 31st May, 2010, DAMB issued an amended charge-sheet. The
substance of the charge remained unchanged, namely unauthorised absence
from 15th February, 2003 onwards. By orders dated 23rd August, 2010, an
Inquiry Officer and a Presenting Officer were appointed. The first Inquiry
Officer, Ms. Janak Juneja, later expressed her inability to proceed,
whereupon Mr. R.L. Srivastava was appointed as the Inquiry Authority. The
inquiry report dated 22nd December, 2011 records that notice was issued to
the Petitioner on 25th July, 2011 at his permanent address; he did not appear
on 9th August, 2011; and the matter was initially directed to proceed ex
parte. It further records that the Petitioner thereafter contacted the Inquiry
Officer, appeared on 2nd September, 2011, sought permission to participate,
nominated a defence assistant, cross-examined the prosecution witnesses,
led defence evidence, and filed a written brief on 14th December, 2011.
11.
Four management witnesses were examined. Their evidence, in
substance, was that the Petitioner had remained absent from duty from 15th
February, 2003; repeated memoranda were issued; a public notice was
published; he was repeatedly called upon to furnish his medical status; and
when he approached DAMB in October 2006 he was directed to report to
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
FP&EMC. The Petitioner’s defence before the Inquiry Officer was that he
had been suffering from tuberculosis of the spine, had undergone treatment
at MMG Hospital, Ghaziabad, had attempted to submit joining reports along
with medical certificates both before DAMB and FP&EMC, and had again
fallen ill thereafter. The report also notes that the Petitioner stated that he
informed FP&EMC about his illness “after six months”.
12.
The Inquiry Officer submitted the report on 22 nd December, 2011.
The report rejected the Petitioner’s objections regarding non-supply of
documents and copies of witness statements, recording that the listed
documents had already been supplied with the charge-sheet memorandum,
that no additional documents were sought, and that the Petitioner had been
afforded full opportunity to participate in the inquiry, including crossexamining witnesses and leading defence evidence. On merits, the Inquiry
Officer concluded that the Petitioner had remained unauthorisedly absent
from duty with effect from 15th February, 2003. Reliance was also placed on
the fact that the Petitioner did not inform FP&EMC at the relevant time,
admitted approaching the office after about six months, and even after the
memorandum dated 26th October, 2006, did not establish that he had joined
duty at his place of posting.
13.
The Petitioner, thereafter, submitted his reply to the inquiry report on
14th February, 2012. In his reply, he reiterated that he had remained ill and
had placed medical material before DAMB, had repeatedly attempted to
resume duty, his joining papers had been returned, he had been made to
move from one office to another, and the inquiry had proceeded without due
regard to the medical evidence and without affording him a fair opportunity.
He also relied upon departmental instructions dated 5 th October, 1975 to
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
contend that, during disciplinary proceedings, if an employee reports for
duty, he ought ordinarily be permitted to do so unless placed under
suspension.
14.
The disciplinary authority, by impugned order dated 22nd January,
2013, accepted the findings of the Inquiry Officer and imposed the penalty
of dismissal from service. The order concluded that the Petitioner had failed
to explain his absence from “15.02.03 onwards upto 23.08.2010”. It further
observed that, although he claimed treatment at MMG Hospital, Ghaziabad,
the same was not supported by “documentary evidence”. On that basis, the
disciplinary authority held that the Petitioner had voluntarily remained
absent for a prolonged period exceeding seven years and that the penalty of
dismissal was warranted.
15.
The appellate authority then rejected the Petitioner’s appeal by order
dated 2nd April, 2014. The appellate authority held that the charge of
unauthorised absence from 15th February, 2003 stood proved; the findings of
the Inquiry Officer were consistent with the record; the Petitioner had
disobeyed directions to rejoin duty; and such prolonged absence reflected
lack of interest in service. The penalty of dismissal was, thus, affirmed.
Petitioner’s Contentions
16.
During proceedings, Mr. T.D. Yadav, counsel for the Petitioner, fairly
narrowed the controversy. He submits that the Petitioner must not
necessarily be reinstated in service. However, even assuming the
disciplinary finding is not displaced in its entirety, the case calls for
reconsideration of the penalty. He emphasises that the Petitioner had put in a
long span of service with no prior misconduct. The case does not involve
moral turpitude, dishonesty or pecuniary loss, and the Petitioner would be
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
content even with substitution of the penalty by a lesser major penalty.
17.
Mr. Yadav submits that even on merits, the charge of ‘unauthorised
absence’ is not made out. The Petitioner was suffering from tuberculosis of
the spine, and was undergoing treatment at MMG Hospital, Ghaziabad,
which position was communicated to DAMB from time to time along with
medical certificates. In these circumstances, the absence could not have been
treated as unauthorised at all, and the finding of misconduct is unsustainable.
18.
The departmental authorities approached the case in a mechanical
manner. The record itself reflects prolonged medical treatment and the
Respondents’ have acknowledged medical certificates for certain periods.
The Petitioner consistently asserted his readiness to rejoin duty as soon as he
was medically fit, and on more than one occasion he physically approached
DAMB and FP&EMC with joining papers and medical documents. The
authorities failed to undertake meaningful scrutiny of the periods for which
medical documentation was provided and instead treated the entire span
from 15th February, 2003 onwards as one continuous period of misconduct.
19.
The inquiry stands vitiated on account of procedural irregularities and
violation of principles of natural justice. The relied-upon documents were
not furnished, copies of witness statements were not supplied to enable an
effective defence, and the inquiry was not conducted in accordance with the
requirements of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. Although the Petitioner
was later permitted to participate in the proceedings, the earlier lapses
caused prejudice, and the disciplinary authority merely adopted the inquiry
report while the appellate authority affirmed the same without independent
application of mind.
20.
The Respondents acted contrary to the applicable departmental
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
instructions, including the instruction dated 5 th October, 1975, inasmuch as
the Petitioner was not permitted to rejoin duty even when he expressed
readiness to do so during the pendency of the proceedings. In such
circumstances, the Petitioner cannot be faulted for non-joining.
21.
In any event, the penalty of dismissal from service is grossly
disproportionate. Even if some lapse is assumed on part of the Petitioner, the
extreme penalty of dismissal is not warranted, particularly having regard to
the length of service, the nature of the post, and the consistent plea of
medical illness.
Respondents’ Contentions
22.
Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC (GNCTD) appearing for the Respondents,
opposes this petition. She contends that the Petitioner remained
unauthorisedly absent from 15th February, 2003 and failed to report back
despite repeated directions. Several memoranda and communications were
issued, including an SCN, subsequent reminders, and even a public notice in
newspapers, calling upon him to resume duty, but to no avail. The Petitioner
did not inform DAMB in time regarding his absence and failed to furnish
complete and satisfactory medical material covering his period of absence.
Even on occasions when the Petitioner was declared fit, he did not report for
duty at his place of posting and continued to remain absent.
23.
Mrs. Ahlawat further submits that the disciplinary proceedings were
conducted in accordance with law and the requirements of Rule 14 of the
CCS (CCA) Rules. Reliance is placed upon the inquiry report to contend
that the Petitioner was initially proceeded ex parte on account of nonappearance but was subsequently permitted to participate in the inquiry; was
allowed to engage a defence assistant, cross-examine the prosecution
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
witnesses, lead defence evidence, and submit a written brief. All relied-upon
documents were supplied along with the charge-sheet, and the plea of nonsupply of documents or witness statements is incorrect and an afterthought.
24.
Mrs. Ahlawat also contests the Petitioner’s reliance on departmental
instructions regarding permission to rejoin duty during the pendency of
disciplinary proceedings. In that regard, it is submitted that the competent
authority did not consider it appropriate to permit the Petitioner to resume
duty, having regard to his conduct and prolonged absence. In any case,
adequate opportunity was nevertheless afforded to the Petitioner to defend
himself in the inquiry.
25.
On the question of punishment, she argues that the misconduct
established against the Petitioner is grave and warrants the penalty imposed.
Prolonged unauthorised absence in public service reflects lack of discipline
and disinterest in service, and that retaining such an employee would be
detrimental to the functioning of the department. The disciplinary authorities
have considered the material on record and passed reasoned orders, and no
interference is called for in exercise of Article 226 of the Constitution.
Issues for Consideration
26.
In light of the foregoing, the following issues arise for consideration:
(i)
Whether the disciplinary proceedings stand vitiated on account of
denial of reasonable opportunity, including the objection relating to nonsupply of relied-upon documents and witness material.
(ii)
Whether the finding that the Petitioner remained unauthorisedly
absent from duty with effect from 15th February, 2003 suffers from
illegality, perversity, or non-application of mind, particularly in the context
of the medical documents supplied to authorities and the Petitioner’s case
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
that he made attempts to rejoin duty but was not permitted to do so.
(iii)
Even if the finding of misconduct is not liable to be interfered with in
exercise of judicial review, whether the penalty of dismissal from service is
liable to be interfered with on the ground of disproportionality.
(iv)
If interference is warranted only on the question of penalty, what
should be the nature and extent of relief, particularly when the Petitioner
does not press for reinstatement and seeks reconsideration of punishment.
Analysis
27.
At the outset, the limits of judicial review in matters arising out of
departmental enquiries must be kept firmly in view. As observed by the
Supreme Court in B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India & Ors.1, judicial
review is not an appeal from a decision but a review of the manner in which
the decision is made. The Court is concerned not with the correctness of the
conclusion reached, but with ensuring that the delinquent employee has
received fair treatment in accordance with law. It does not reappreciate the
evidence or substitute its own findings for those of the disciplinary
authorities, which are the sole judge of facts. Interference is warranted only
where the enquiry is conducted in violation of principles of natural justice or
statutory rules, where the finding is based on no evidence, or where the
conclusion is such as no reasonable person could have reached.
28.
The same restraint extends, though in a distinct manner, to the
question of punishment. As is evident from the decisions of Om Kumar &
Ors. v. Union of India2 and B.C. Chaturvedi, the choice of penalty lies
primarily within the domain of the disciplinary authority, and the Court, in
(1995) 6 SCC 749.
(2001) 2 SCC 386.
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
exercise of judicial review, does not ordinarily substitute its own view on the
quantum of punishment. The scope of interference is limited to cases where
the decision suffers from illegality, takes into account irrelevant
considerations or ignores relevant factors, or where the punishment imposed
is so disproportionate as to shock the conscience. In such a situation, the
normal course is to remit the matter to the disciplinary authority for
reconsideration, though in exceptional cases the Court may mould the relief.
29.
Tested on the above standard, the Petitioner’s challenge to the inquiry,
taken as a whole, does not warrant invalidation of the disciplinary
proceedings in their entirety. The inquiry report shows that although the
Petitioner did not appear at the initial stage, he was subsequently permitted
to participate in the proceedings. He was allowed to engage a defence
assistant, to cross-examine the prosecution witnesses, to make his statement
in defence, and to file a written brief. The report further records the Inquiry
Officer’s view that the listed documents had already been supplied with the
charge-sheet and that no further documents were sought. On the record, the
Court is unable to hold that the enquiry was vitiated for want of reasonable
opportunity.
30.
Nor can it be said that the finding of ‘unauthorised absence’ is
unsupported by evidence. The Respondents’ case does not rest on a solitary
accusation; rather, it is supported by a sequence of notices and memoranda
issued over time, beginning with the SCN dated 4th April, 2003, followed by
memoranda dated 17th February, 2004, 28th August, 2004, and 16th January,
2005, the newspaper publication dated 16th July, 2005, and the subsequent
memoranda dated 10th August, 2006 and 26th October, 2006. The inquiry
report also records the Petitioner’s own statement in general examination
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
that he informed FP&EMC only after about six months. This material was
sufficient to enable the department to conclude that the Petitioner had
remained absent without prior sanction/permission for leave.
31.
That, however, does not conclude the matter. Two salient features
emerging from the record cannot be overlooked. First, the Petitioner’s
defence, from the outset, was not a mere denial of absence; it was that he
had remained away on account of a serious spinal ailment, described in the
record as tuberculosis of the spine, and that he was under treatment at MMG
Hospital, Ghaziabad. Second, the Respondents’ own record does not support
a complete rejection of this medical case. On the contrary, it acknowledges
the submission of medical certificates for substantial periods, the furnishing
of medical documents on 26th October, 2006, and certificates indicating
fitness with effect from 6th December, 2005, 13th April, 2006, and again 26th
October, 2006. The Petitioner has consistently maintained this position in
his reply to the inquiry findings, in appeal, and in this petition.
32.
This aspect assumes significance because, as held by the Supreme
Court in Krushnakant B. Parmar v. Union of India & Anr.3, the question
whether absence from duty constitutes misconduct cannot be decided
without first determining whether such absence was wilful or occasioned by
compelling circumstances. The Court drew a clear distinction between
unauthorised absence and wilful absence, observing that mere absence
without prior permission may be unauthorised, but does not ipso facto
amount to misconduct. Where the absence is the result of circumstances
under which it was not possible for the employee to report for or perform
duty, such absence cannot be treated as wilful. It was emphasized held that,
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
in a departmental proceeding founded on absence from duty, the disciplinary
authority is required to establish that the absence was wilful; in the absence
of such a finding, the charge of misconduct cannot be sustained. The
enquiry, therefore, must address not merely the factum of absence, but
whether the absence was wilful in the sense contemplated by the applicable
Rules.
33.
In the present case, the authorities did not undertake that exercise with
the care in line with the established jurisprudence and the record. The
dismissal order states, in sweeping terms, that the Petitioner had failed to
explain his absence from 15th February, 2003 up to 23rd August, 2010, and
that his assertion of treatment at MMG Hospital was “not supported by any
documentary evidence”. This conclusion sits uneasily with the Respondents’
own record, which refers to medical certificates, fitness certificates,
treatment at MMG Hospital, and submission of medical documents on 26th
October, 2006. Even the Counter Affidavit acknowledges that the Petitioner
had, at different stages, produced medical documents. Once that position
emerges from the record itself, it was not open to the disciplinary authority
to treat the entire period as though no documentary support existed at all.
34.
The inquiry report suffers from a similar over-compression of the
record. While it correctly notes that the Petitioner did not inform the office
at the outset and that he failed to establish that he had actually resumed duty
at FP&EMC after the memorandum dated 26th October, 2006, it does not
stop there. The report does not separately examine the distinct periods for
which medical documents were admittedly produced, nor does it address
whether the absence, viewed phase-wise, remained wholly wilful despite the
(2012) 3 SCC 178.
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
medical material. It does not consider whether the real lapse lay in narrower
aspects, such as failure to regularise leave in accordance with the applicable
rules, failure to report at the proper place of posting after being found fit, or
continued non-compliance despite repeated directions.
35.
There is another feature which also merits notice. The Petitioner’s
case throughout has not been that he remained wholly untraceable or beyond
reach. His consistent stand has been that he repeatedly approached officers
of DAMB, went to the establishment of FP&EMC, tendered joining papers
along with medical documents, and was sent from one office to another
without any effective administrative resolution. That account may or may
not merit acceptance in full, but it required reasoned consideration; it could
not be brushed aside in general terms. The appellate order merely states that
the Petitioner’s submissions were “too feeble to prove his innocence”, while
the disciplinary order proceeds in similarly broad language. This does not
reflect the degree of reasoned scrutiny expected in a matter culminating in
dismissal from service after protracted proceedings.
36.
At the same time, the Petitioner cannot carry the argument to the point
of complete exoneration. This is not a case where the medical record wholly
answers the charge. The record still contains material of some weight
against him. He admittedly did not obtain prior sanction before absenting
himself. The inquiry report records his own statement that he informed
FP&EMC only after about six months. DAMB repeatedly called upon him
to report for duty. Even on the Respondents’ own showing, the medical
certificates relied upon by the Petitioner indicated fitness to resume duty on
more than one occasion. Yet, the record does not establish that he in fact
resumed duty at the office where he was posted. The memorandum dated
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
26th October, 2006 specifically required him to report at FP&EMC, and the
consistent stand is that he failed to do so. On this aspect, the Petitioner does
not furnish a satisfactory explanation.
37.
The Court is, therefore, unable to accept the submission that the
finding of misconduct must be set aside in its entirety. The position, in the
Court’s view, is more nuanced. The finding that the Petitioner remained
absent from duty without due authority cannot be characterised as perverse.
What can, however, be said with justification is that the authorities dealt
with the misconduct in an unduly broad and undifferentiated manner. They
did not sufficiently segregate medically supported periods from unexplained
periods; nor did they meaningfully examine whether the medical material,
even if insufficient to justify the entire absence, nonetheless explained a
substantial part of it. Equally, they did not adequately engage with the
Petitioner’s case that he had, at intervals, attempted to return to duty. These
shortcomings may not dislodge the core finding of unauthorised absence, but
they bear directly on the degree of culpability and the proportionality of the
penalty imposed.
38.
That brings the Court to the question of punishment. On this aspect,
the Petitioner’s case stands on firmer ground.
39.
In Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board & Ors.
v. T.T. Murali Babu4, the Supreme Court cautioned that, in exercise of
jurisdiction under Article 226, a writ court does not act as an appellate
authority over the findings or the punishment imposed in disciplinary
proceedings, and must refrain from extending misplaced sympathy in
matters of proved misconduct. The decision emphasises that unauthorised
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
absence over a considerable period reflects indiscipline and a lack of
responsibility, and that interference with the quantum of punishment is not
warranted unless the penalty imposed shocks the conscience of the Court. At
the same time, the Court also made it clear that the question of punishment
cannot be reduced to a rigid or straitjacket formula, but depends upon a
variety of factors, including the nature of service, the position held, the
length of absence, and the explanation offered. The principle, therefore, is
not that sympathy may override discipline, but that proportionality, though
of limited application, remains available where the punishment is found to
be grossly disproportionate to the misconduct established.
40.
The decision in Shri Bhagwan Lal Arya v. Commissioner of Police,
Delhi & Ors.5 is especially instructive in this context. There, the Supreme
Court therein expressly upheld the validity of the disciplinary enquiry and
declined to interfere with the findings of misconduct, noting that the enquiry
had been conducted in accordance with the rules and principles of natural
justice. The Court, however, proceeded to examine whether the penalty of
removal from service was commensurate with the nature of the proved
misconduct. Emphasising on the governing service rules therein, it held that
removal could be imposed only in cases of grave misconduct or continued
misconduct indicating incorrigibility and complete unfitness for service, and
that a single instance of absence on medical grounds, supported by
applications for leave and medical certificates, could not, by any stretch, be
characterised as such. The absence of any material to show habitual
absenteeism, coupled with the medical explanation on record, led the Court
(2014) 4 SCC 108.
(2004) 4 SCC 560.
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
to conclude that the punishment of removal was highly excessive and
disproportionate.
41.
That conclusion, however, turned on a factual matrix where the
medical evidence was duly supported, leave had in fact been sanctioned, and
the employee could not be described as a habitual absentee. The present case
stands on a less favourable footing for the Petitioner. Nevertheless, the
principle that emerges remains of relevance: where absence is consistently
attributed to illness, where some medical material is placed on record, where
there is no demonstrable history of continued misconduct indicating
incorrigibility, and where the disciplinary authority has not addressed
whether the misconduct rises to the level contemplated for the extreme
penalty under the governing rules, the question of punishment warrants close
scrutiny on the touchstone of proportionality.
42.
In the present case, several mitigating features emerge from the
record:
42.1. There is no material on record indicating any prior punishment or
earlier established misconduct. The Respondents describe the Petitioner as a
“habitual absentee” in their Counter Affidavit, but that expression appears
to be directed essentially at the episode in question itself. It is not supported
by any prior charge, penalty, or service record reflecting repeated
indiscipline before 2003. For assessing penalty, that distinction assumes
significance.
42.2. The Petitioner was not holding a post involving financial
responsibility, custody of records, confidential functions, or a position of
institutional trust in the conventional sense. He was serving as a
Gateman/Peon. This does not dilute the requirement of discipline; however,
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
it bears upon the choice between the severest civil consequence and a lesser
major penalty. This is not a case involving embezzlement, fraud, fabrication,
corruption, or moral turpitude. At its core, it concerns prolonged absence,
accompanied by a medical explanation that may be imperfect but cannot be
dismissed as wholly implausible.
42.3. This is not a case in which illness surfaced as an afterthought at the
writ stage. The medical narrative runs through the departmental record itself.
The Respondents’ own case acknowledges the Petitioner’s reliance on
treatment at MMG Hospital, Ghaziabad, and that medical documents were
furnished at different stages. The case against the Petitioner is not that he
fabricated illness altogether; rather, it is that he failed to regularise his
absence in accordance with the rules, failed to keep the Respondents duly
informed in a timely manner, failed to furnish complete supporting material
for the entire period, and failed to resume duty at the proper place of posting
despite being declared fit on certain occasions. That distinction is material
when the authority turns to the question of penalty.
42.4. The reasoning on penalty in both the disciplinary and appellate orders
is notably sparse. The disciplinary authority states that dismissal would
“suffice” because the Petitioner had voluntarily abstained from duty for
more than seven years. The appellate authority observes that such absence
reflects lack of interest in service and that retention of such an employee
would be detrimental to discipline. What is absent is any real balancing
exercise. There is no meaningful discussion of the periods supported by
medical material, no consideration of whether a lesser major penalty would
suffice, and no engagement with the Petitioner’s length of service, absence
of prior punishment, or the nature of the post held. The orders proceed as
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
though, once prolonged absence was established, dismissal followed almost
as a matter of course.
42.5. The relief now pressed is both limited and significant. The Petitioner
does not seek reinstatement. Mr. Yadav has fairly submitted that the
Petitioner would be satisfied if the matter is remitted for reconsideration of
punishment, including the possibility of a lesser terminal penalty. This
submission materially alters the complexion of the case. The Court is not
being asked to restore a stale employment relationship after many years;
what is sought is a lawful and proportionate reconsideration of penalty.
43.
Viewed in this light, the appropriate course becomes clear. This is not
a fit case for interference with the finding of misconduct, which cannot be
said to be unsupported by evidence or vitiated by procedural infirmity. At
the same time, and in keeping with the limits of judicial review as explained
in B.C. Chaturvedi and Om Kumar, this Court would not be justified in
itself prescribing a substituted penalty. The proper course, therefore, is to
leave undisturbed the finding that the Petitioner remained absent from duty
without due authority, while setting aside the impugned orders insofar as
they impose and affirm the penalty of dismissal, and to remit the matter to
the competent authority for reconsideration of the quantum of punishment.
44.
In directing such reconsideration, certain parameters must be
indicated to ensure that the exercise does not become a mere reiteration of
the earlier conclusion in different language. The competent authority shall
consider, expressly and separately, the periods for which medical material
exists on record; the fact that the Petitioner did not keep the department duly
informed from the outset; the fact that he does not appear to have resumed
duty at FP&EMC despite subsequent directions; the absence of prior proved
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
misconduct; the Petitioner’s length of service; the nature of the post held;
and the limited relief now pressed. The authority shall then determine
whether dismissal alone is warranted or whether some other major penalty
would adequately balance discipline with fairness.
45.
One further aspect merits notice. The Petitioner has relied upon the
governmental instruction dated 5th October, 1975 to contend that, during
disciplinary proceedings, an employee who reports for duty should
ordinarily be permitted to do so unless placed under suspension, without
prejudice to the proceedings already initiated. This Court does not treat that
instruction as determinative in the present case, since the factual controversy
regarding the Petitioner’s attempts to rejoin is neither simple nor wholly
one-sided. Nevertheless, the instruction reinforces a broader principle:
disciplinary control must not be exercised mechanically or without due
regard to context. Even where misconduct is established, the administrative
response must remain measured, fact-sensitive, and reasoned. On the present
record, the decision on penalty falls short of that standard.
46.
For the foregoing reasons, the present writ petition is allowed in part,
in the following terms:
46.1. The finding that the Petitioner remained absent from duty without due
authority is not interfered with.
46.2. The order dated 22nd January, 2013 passed by the disciplinary
authority and the order dated 2nd April, 2014 passed by the appellate
authority are set aside to the extent that they impose and affirm the penalty
of dismissal from service.
46.3. The matter is remitted to the competent disciplinary authority for
fresh consideration of the quantum of penalty. Such exercise shall be
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
completed within a period of twelve weeks from the date of this order, after
affording the Petitioner an opportunity of personal hearing.
46.4. While reconsidering the question of penalty, the authority shall keep
in view the observations made above and shall pass a reasoned and speaking
order.
47.
It is clarified that this Court has expressed no concluded view on the
nature of the substituted penalty. That determination shall rest with the
competent authority. It is further clarified that the reconsideration shall not
be treated as a formality, but as a fresh exercise confined to the question of
penalty.
48.
Since the Petitioner does not seek reinstatement at this stage, no
direction for rejoining, back wages, or continuity of active service is called
for. The Petitioner’s entitlement, if any, shall abide by the fresh order on
penalty.
49.
In the above terms, the petition is disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
APRIL 22, 2026/as
W.P.(C) 6531/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/04/2026 at 13:22:54
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review