Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 18th December, 2025
Pronounced on: 13th March, 2026
%
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
+
SHAH KRUTIBEN HEMAL KUMAR
C/O Iqbal Rupani, TPS IV,
4™ ROAD, Bandra (W), Mumbai.
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Aniruddha Deshmukh, Advocate
versus
THE COMPETENT AUTHORITY
Ministry of Finance,
Department of Revenue,
Govt. of India,
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985,
1st Floor, CU Shah Building,
Ashram Road, Navarangpura,
Ahmedabad, Gujarat.
Also at
C/O Siddharth Majmudar,
Inspecting Officer,
C-Wing, Mittal Court,
3rd Floor, Nariman Point, Mumbai.
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Saumya Tandon, CGSC with
Mr. Gaurav Singh Sengar, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
1.
Petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(hereinafter referred to as „Cr.P.C.‟) has been filed by the Petitioner, Smt.
Shah Krutiben Hemal Kumar to challenge the Order dated 19.05.2017 of
the Appellate Tribunal, PMLA as the Appellate Tribunal for Forfeited
Property under Section 68(O) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act (hereinafter referred to as „NDPS Act‟), in Case No.FPAND-29/BOM/2014, dismissing the Appeal against the Order of forfeiture of
property dated 17.10.2014, by the Respondent/Office of Competent
Authority, NDPS Act.
2.
Briefly stated, Mr. Iqbal Musa Master Patel was apprehended on
07.07.2001, by Narcotics Control Bureau, Ahmedabad, who was found in
possession of 03 kg. of Heroin. His trial in Sessions Case No.183/2001,
resulted in his conviction for the offence under Section 8(c) read with
Section 21 and 29 of the NDPS Act and sentenced to undergo RI for 12 years
and with fine of Rs.2,00,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to undergo
SI for two years, vide Order dated 03.11.2006. He was released from Jail on
06.07.2013, after completion of his sentence.
3.
Subsequent to his arrest on 07.07.2001, Competent Authority
commenced proceedings under Section 68E of the NDPS Act and “identified
illegally acquired properties”, in the name of his wife and brother, as under:
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
4. Having reasons to believe that there is a direct nexus
between the said assets, vehicles land bungalow, property,
bank a/c vis-à-vis illegally earned money, from illicit
trafficking in narcotics drugs on part of the said accused,
his relative and associate, a preliminary Freezing Order
dated 05.12.2001 under Section 68F (1) NDPS Act was
passed in respect of movable and immovable properties,
till further orders. Further, Shri Iqbal Musa Patel was
restrained not to deal, transfer, alienate or dispose of
these properties in any manner.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
5.
Thereafter, the Competent Authority vide Confirming Order dated
31.12.2001, observed that personal hearing was duly given to Mr. Iqbal
Musa Master Patel, who failed to join the proceedings or give any
explanation. Preliminary Freezing Order dated 05.12.2001, was
confirmed.
6.
The Petitioner, (subsequent purchaser) stated that she had contacted
Smt. Hamida Iqubal Musa Patel, the sole and exclusive owners of the
premises in question, and was informed that they had even obtained NA
permission for the sale. The title documents/Revenue Record which had
entries right till 10.07.2001, were duly examined by her before purchase, but
there was no endorsement of Order of Freezing. Petitioner claimed that had
there been any actual confirmation of the Freezing Order upon the property
by the Competent Authority, there would have been such an endorsement in
the Revenue Record.
7.
Petitioner further claimed that finding no defect in the title of the
subject property, she purchased it from Smt. Hamida Iqubal Musa Patel and
Mr. Yunus Musa Master, for a total consideration of Rs.14,00,000/-, vide
registered Sale Deed dated 11.09.2012. Consequently, the record of rights
was updated and it was recorded that there were no encumbrances upon the
said land and the Petitioner was recorded as the owner. Thereafter, Mutation
Entry was made in her name and she has been paying taxes for the said
property.
8.
For the first time, a Show Cause Notice dated 09.10.2013 under
Section 68H of the NDPS Act, was issued by the Competent Authority to
the affected persons, but it was never served upon the Petitioner; instead, it
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
was served upon the Land Revenue Officer, Bharuch. Thereafter, vide Order
dated 06.11.2013 subject property (hereinafter referred to as „Forfeiture
Order‟) was forfeited by the Competent Authority, without giving any
Notice or hearing to the Petitioner. She came to know about the said Order
dated 06.11.2013 on 18.11.2013, when the endorsement was made in the
Revenue Record and the same was communicated to her by the Revenue
Department.
9.
She then, filed two representations with the Respondent, requesting
them to vacate the Forfeiture Order qua her property, as she was a bona fide
purchaser for valuable consideration.
10.
The Competent Authority passed Order dated 17.10.2014 under
Section 68V of the Act, whereby the Petitioner‟s Representation was
rejected only on the ground that the sale was null and void, in terms of
Section 68M NDPS Act, while completely overlooking that the Petitioner
was an excepted holder and the property was outside the purview of the
provisions of the Act, since she had purchased it bona fide, for valuable
consideration.
11.
Aggrieved by the Order of the Competent Authority dated
17.10.2014, the Petitioner preferred Appeal No.FPA-ND-29/BOM/2014
before the Tribunal for Forfeited Property, specifically pleading that the she
was not served with any Notice, prior to passing its decision by the
Competent Authority.
12.
Competent Authority filed its Reply, and also placed on record
additional documents.
13.
Thereafter, vide Order dated 26.05.2017, the learned Tribunal
dismissed the Appeal observing that the Petitioner had no locus standi to
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
challenge the Orders and that the transfer in favour of the Petitioner, after
passing of the Order dated 05.12.2001 under Section 68F(1) NDPS Act, was
null and void; once the property was frozen, the Petitioner cannot acquire
any right, title or interest in the property.
14.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid Order dated 26.05.2017 of the learned
Tribunal, Petitioner has filed the present Petition. The grounds of challenge
are that Section 68A(1) of NDPS has not been considered, which
specifically states that the provisions of Chapter VA (Forfeiture of Illegally
Acquired Property) would only apply to persons specified therein and not to
any other class of persons. Thus, Chapter VA could not be attracted against
the Petitioner.
15.
Furthermore, the commencement of the forfeiture proceedings itself
was invalid and without jurisdiction. Even Section 68A(2)(f) of NDPS Act
has been overlooked, which provides that only the holder of the property can
be proceeded against. The impugned Order fails to note Section
68B(g)(iii)(A) NDPS Act, which defines as to what would constitute illegally
acquired property. The sub-clause (A) specifically states that illegally
acquired property would not include a property purchased by a transferee in
good faith, and for valuable consideration. The Petitioner had demonstrated
that she was a transferee in good faith and for adequate consideration, and
the provisions of Chapter VA, could not
be invoked against her. The
impugned Order is erroneous in coming to a finding that the property was
illegally acquired property, even though Petitioner was a bona fide
purchaser.
16.
Moreover, impugned Order fails to note Section 68H of NDPS Act,
which requires the Competent Authority to demonstrate that there existed a
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
reason to believe that the property being proceeded against was illegally
acquired property. The term „reason to believe‟ predicates that the
Competent Authority to have existence of reasons, to conclude that the
property was legally acquired and not to act merely on suspicion. Order of
Competent Authority fails to demonstrate that either the transfer to the
Petitioner was in any manner fraudulent or that the Petitioner was an
associated person, as defined under the Act, which is fatal to the
proceedings.
17.
The impugned Order materially misinterprets the provisions of the
Explanation to Section 68M of NDPS Act, in so far as the explanation only
seeks to save a Notice of forfeiture, if the same is defective to the extent
indicated in the Explanation and does not save substantive proceedings
wherein it would be mandatory for the Competent Authority, to demonstrate
the compliance with the provisions of Section 68H(1) of NDPS Act. There
existed no reasonable basis for the Competent Authority to pass impugned
Order, which ex-facie demonstrates the gross perversity of the Order.
18.
Further, Competent Authority, despite possessing the power under
Section 68S of NDPS Act, to determine the owner of the property, failed to
do so and did not serve a notice upon the Petitioner, which demonstrates the
mechanical manner in which the entire proceedings have been conducted.
There is nothing on record to show that the Competent Authority complied
with provisions under Sections 68A and 68B of NDPS Act, in order to
invoke proceedings in the first place.
19.
Therefore, a prayer is made for the quashing and setting aside of the
Impugned Judgment dated 19.05.2017 of the Appellate Tribunal, PMLA.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
20.
Counter Affidavit has been filed on behalf of the Respondent,
wherein preliminary objection was taken that Forfeiture Order dated
17.10.2014 of the Competent Authority, was made in respect of the property
belonging to Smt. Hamida Iqubal Musa Patel and Mr. Yunus Musa Master,
the wife and brother of Mr. Iqubal Musa Master Patel, a convict who
underwent his sentence of 12 RI years along with fine, under Section 8(c)
read with Section 21 and 29 of the NDPS Act.
21.
After conviction of the Accused, the Proceedings for freezing the
property in question, had been initiated vide Order dated 05.12.2001 under
Section 68(F)(1) NDPS Act, by the Intelligence Officer, Narcotics Control
Bureau, Ahmedabad. This preliminary Order of freezing, was confirmed by
the Competent Authority, vide Order dated 31.12.2001 under Section 68F(2)
NDPS Act. The communication was made to all Land Revenue Authorities
including Sub-Registrar, Talati (Patwari) etc. and the Acknowledgment
Slips were also provided to the Petitioner.
22.
The impugned property was apparently purchased by the Petitioner on
11.09.2012, from the wife and brother of convict, who were persons covered
under Section 68(A)(2)(d) of NDPS Act. If the contention of Petitioner is
accepted, then every person, in order to avoid forfeiture of property in the
future, would sell the property to third party and frustrate the proceedings
under the Act. Moreover, Section 68(M) of the Act specifically provides that
all transfers, done after the Order is passed under Section 68F(1) of NDPS
Act, are null and void. Therefore, the learned Appellate Tribunal has rightly
upheld the Order of the Competent Authority, forfeiting the Suit property.
23.
Reliance is placed on Winston Tan and Anr. vs. Union of India,
(2012) 12 SCC 222, wherein provision in SAFEMA, which is analogous to
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
section 68M of NDPS Act, was considered by Hon‟ble Apex Court and it
was held that such plea is not available to a transferee, who has purchased
the property during forfeiture proceedings.
24.
It is claimed that the Petitioner is not an affected person and therefore,
has no locus standi to make contention that Show-Cause Notice under
Section 68H of NDPS Act, should have been communicated to her.
Moreover, she has already been heard by the learned Appellate Tribunal and
all the contentions on merits have been dealt with in the impugned Order.
There is no merit in the present Petition, which is liable to be dismissed.
25.
Petitioner has filed Written Submissions, wherein similar grounds, as
agitated in the Petition, have been reiterated.
26.
Respondent in its Written Submissions, after reiterating dates and
facts as already narrated, re-affirmed the contentions raised in its CounterAffidavit.
27.
Reliance is placed on Tejas R. Doshi vs. Competent Authority & Anr.,
R/Special Civil Application No.2797/2012, decided on 14.10.2024, wherein
identical issue was raised and it was held that the transfer must be treated as
void, ineffective and inoperative in law.
28.
Further reliance is placed on Judgment dated 30.08.2024 passed by
Hon‟ble Gujarat High Court in R/Special Civil Application No. 10076/2011,
titled as Mer Nagabhai Chhaganbhai Dedara & Ors. vs. Competent
Authority SAFEMA/NDPS, Mumbai & Ors.
Submissions heard and records perused.
29.
The Petitioner, Smt. Shah Krutiben Hemal Kumar has challenged the
Order dated 19.05.2017 whereby the Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi has
upheld the Order dated 17.10.2014 of the Office of Competent Authority,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
Ministry of Finance, Deptt. of Revenue, NDPS Act, whereby the subject
property was declared as illegally acquired property, within the meaning of
Chapter 5A NDPS Act and forfeited it to the Central Government, free from
all encumbrances.
30.
It is not is dispute that Narcotic Control Bureau, Ahmedabad Zonal
Unit, Ahmedabad on 07.07.2001, arrested Mr. Iqbal Musa Master Patil, who
was found in possession of 3.056 Kgs heroin. Subsequent to the seizure, he
faced the trial in Sessions Case No.183/2001 and was eventually convicted
and sentenced on 03.11.2006.
31.
During the investigations, the Investigating Agency traced the
movable and immovable properties of the Accused (Convict), including the
suit property, which was reflected in the Revenue Records, etc. to be
purchased in the name of the wife and son of the Convict Iqbal Musa Master
Patel, on 18.10.2000, vide a registered Sale Deed. It was subsequently,
purchased by the Petitioner, who has challenged the forfeiture, on the
ground of being a bona fide purchaser.
32.
Chapter 5A of NDPS deals with Forfeiture of illegally acquired
property.
33.
The term “illegally acquired property” is defined under Section
68B(g), as under:
“(g) “illegally acquired property”, in relation to any
person to whom this Chapter applies, means, —
(i) any property acquired by such person, whether before
or after the commencement of this Chapter, wholly or
partly out of or by means of any income, earnings or
assets derived or obtained from or attributable to 2[the
contravention of any provisions 3[of this Act or the
equivalent value of such property; or
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
(ii) any property acquired by such person, whether before
or after the commencement of this Chapter, for a
consideration, or by any means wholly or partly
traceable to any property referred to in sub-clause (i) or
the income or earning from 1[such property or the
equivalent value of such property; or]
[(iii) any property acquired by such person, whether
before or after the commencement of the Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic Substances (Amendment) Act, 2014,
wholly or partly out of or by means of any income,
earnings or assets the source of which cannot be proved,
or the equivalent value of such property,]
and includes—
(A) any property held by such person which would have
been, in relation to any previous holder thereof, illegally
acquired property under this clause if such previous
holder had not ceased to hold it, unless such person or
any other person who held the property at any time after
such previous holder or, where there are two or more
such previous holders, the last of such previous holders is
or was a transferee in good faith for adequate
consideration;
(B) any property acquired by such person, whether before
or after the commencement of this Chapter, for a
consideration, or by any means, wholly or partly
traceable to any property falling under item (A), or the
income or earnings therefrom;”
34.
Section 68(C) prohibits holding of illegally acquired property either
by the Accused himself or through any other person on his behalf, and states
that any person who holds any illegally acquired property in contravention
of provisions of Sub-Section (1), such property shall be liable to be forfeited
to the Central Government, in accordance with the provisions of this
Chapter.
Proviso to Sub-Section 2 provides that no property shall be
forfeited under this Chapter, if such property was acquired by a person to
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
whom this Act applies, before a period of six years from the date when he
was arrested.
35.
The first step in the Forfeiture proceeding is the identification of the
illegally acquired property, which may include an inquiry, investigation or
survey in respect of place, person, property etc, in terms of Section 68E.
36.
The Revenue Record filed on record, show that the Suit land had been
purchased vide Registered Sale Deed dated 22.10.2000 for a sale
consideration of 75,000/- by Hamida Iqbal Musa Patil, wife of Accused and
Yunus Musa Mohd. Hassan Hussaina, GPA Holder Musa Umarji Mohd,
from the erstwhile recorded owners. The property, therefore, had been
acquired within a period of six years before the arrest of the Accused on
07.07.2001; therefore, the forfeiture proceedings under NDPS Act, was
validly initiated against him and his family members.
37.
The second step is whether the wife/ brother of the Accused, in whose
name the property was purchased, would be amenable to forfeiture
proceedings. Section 68A provides that the provision of this Chapter shall
be applicable to the persons specified therein. Sub-Section 2(d) provides
that it is applicable to every person who is a relative of a person, referred to
in Clause (a) or Clause (b) or Clause (c) or Clause (cc). Further, Section
68(i) defines the relative to be the spouse of a person as well as brother or
sister of the person.
38.
The Sale Deed being in the name of the wife and son who are the
relatives of the Accused is, therefore, amenable to the forfeiture proceedings
under Chapter VA.
39.
The third aspect is the procedure to be followed for the
Forfeiture. Section 68F provides for seizure or freezing of illegally acquired
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
property. It states that if the Officer conducting inquiry, has reason to
believe that the property is illegally acquired property and is likely to be
concealed, transferred or dealt with in any manner which may result in
frustration of any proceeding undertaken for forfeiture of such property.
40.
During the inquiry, it was found that Account No.894 and 895 were
opened on 23.02.1994 by Accused Person, in the name of (AP)-4 Fiaz Iqbal
Musa Patel and AP-5 Minhas Iqbal Musa Patel, both sons of Accused, who
were minors at the time of opening of the Account and were pursuing their
studies.
41.
Account No.1784 was opened on 24.08.2000 by Accused No. 2 in the
name of Hamida Iqbal Musa Patel, the wife, wherein she had stated herself
to be a „Housewife‟.
42.
It was found that none of these three persons were having any
independent source of income. The perusal of the Bank Statements of the
aforesaid Accounts revealed that there were negligible transactions from the
date of opening till 1999. However, credit entries for the period 2000 to
2001 till the date of arrest of Musa Iqbal, were frequent and of higher
amounts.
43.
The Income Tax Office, Bharuch vide their Letters dated 13.06.2013
and 25.06.2013 informed that none of these affected persons held a PAN
and were not filing Returns of income, to claim their legal income.
44.
The records reflected that the Accused Iqbal Musa was engaged in
drug trafficking since long time and he did not have any legal source of
income. He had credited funds in the aforesaid Savings Accounts of his
wife and sons, thereby routing and adjusting the illegal income earned by
him. It was established that neither the wife nor the sons, had any legal
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
source of income, to acquire the aforesaid property and therefore, there was
a reason to believe that the properties had been illegally acquired.
45.
Therefore, there was sufficient evidence to establish that the subject
property was acquired from the illegal funds generated by Iqbal Musa from
the illegal activity of drug trafficking. There is no ground shown to question
this finding.
46.
The next step in the Freezing proceedings was issue of Show Cause
Notice, to the affected person. The record reflects that the Competent
Authority issued a Notice to the Accused Sh. Iqbal Musa Patil for personal
hearing, through Superintendent of Ahmedabad Central Prison, Sabarmati,
Ahmedabad, and thereafter, confirmed on 31.12.2001, the Freezing Order
dated 05.12.2001 confirmed on 31.12.2001. Due procedure was thus,
followed while making the Freezing Order.
47.
The main contention of the Appellant is that she was a bona fide
purchaser of the subject property vide registered Sale Deed dated
11.09.2012 and, therefore, the forfeiture was liable to be set aside.
48.
The Competent Authority undertook the Forfeiture Proceedings, in
respect of suit property, in respect of which Freezing Order had been made
in December 2001 and confirmed on 31.12.2001. The Show Cause Notice
dated 09.10.2013 was issued to Iqbal Musa, the wife, brother and the two
sons, asking them to explain within 30 days from the receipt of Notice, the
source of their income, earnings or assets out of which they had acquired the
subject properties, and also to submit the evidence on which they relied and
other relevant information and particulars, to show cause why the said
property
be not declared as „Illegally Acquired Property‟, in terms of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
Clause (g) of Section 68B and thereafter, forfeit the same to the Central
Government.
49.
Subsequent to the issue of Show Cause Notice under Section 68H
NDPS Act on 09.10.2013 to the Affected Persons/Noticee, a Representation
dated 06.05.2014 was received from the Petitioner, Shah Krutiben Hemal
Kumar through Sh. Ghani Ayub Musabhai, the duly constituted Attorney
who claimed to have purchased the subject property vide a Sale Deed dated
11.09.2012, for a consideration of Rs.14 lakhs and requested the Respondent
to withdraw the Show Cause Notice, in respect of the subject property. The
Petitioner thus, claimed that she being the purchaser of the subject property,
the same was not amenable to forfeiture.
50.
The first ground of challenge of the Petitioner was that no Notice in
respect of the forfeiture proceedings, had been given to her. She had made
all necessary inquiries in respect to the subject land in the Revenue Record
and in the Record of Rights, wherein the ownership was shown in the name
of Hamida Iqbal Musa Patel i.e. the wife of the Convict, who was reflected
as having a legal and valid title over the disputed land, before purchasing the
disputed land. Her name has already been entered in the Revenue Record, on
21.10.2012.
51.
This contention of the Petitioner has been rightly rejected by the
Appellate Authority in the impugned Order, by making a reference to the
Proviso to Section 68 (H) NDPS Act, which reads as under:
“68H. Notice of forfeiture of property.—(1) If, having
regard to the value of the properties held by any person
to whom this Chapter applies, either by himself or
through any other person on his behalf, his known
sources of income, earnings or assets, and any other
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
information or material available to it as a result of a
report from any officer making an investigation under
section 68E or otherwise, the competent authority has
reason to believe (the reasons for such belief to be
recorded in writing) that all or any of such properties are
illegally acquired properties, it may serve a notice upon
such person (hereinafter referred to as the person
affected) calling upon him within a period of thirty days
specified in the notice to indicate the sources of his
income, earnings or assets, out of which or by means of
which he has acquired such property, the evidence on
which he relies and other relevant information and
particulars, and to show cause why all or any of such
properties, as the case may be, should not be declared to
be illegally acquired properties and forfeited to the
Central Government under this Chapter.
(2) Where a notice under sub-section (1) to any person
specifies any property as being held on behalf of such
person by any other person, a copy of the notice shall
also be served upon such other person.
Provided that no notice for forfeiture shall be served
upon any person referred to in clause (cc) of sub-section
(2) of section 68A or relative of a person referred to in
that clause or associate of a person referred to in that
clause or holder of any property which was at any time
previously held by a person referred to in that clause.
Explanation.—For the removal of doubts, it is hereby
declared that in a case where the provisions of section
68J are applicable, no notice under this section shall be
invalid merely on the ground that it fails to mention the
evidence relied upon or it fails to establish a direct nexus
between the property sought to be forfeited and any
activity in contravention of the provisions of this Act.”
52.
The similar facts as in hand, were considered in the judgment of
Winston Tan & Anr. vs. Union of India & Anr. 2012 (12) SCC 222 in respect
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
of Section 7 Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators (Forfeiture &
Property) Act, 1976, which is para materia to Chapter VA of NDPS Act. In
the said case as well, the petitioner had claimed to be the bona fide
purchaser of the Suit property, in respect of which the Forfeiture Order had
been passed.
53.
In the case of Winston Tan & Anr., (supra) it was held that there is a
distinction made between the relatives and associates and from the holders
who though may have purchased the subject property from a Convict/
Detenu, which is not liable to be forfeited. However, such distinction has no
application to a transferee who has purchased illegally acquired property
from a Convict or his relative or associate, after issuance of Notice of
Forfeiture. Once a Notice of Forfeiture has been issued in respect of any
property, any subsequent transfer of such property, is prohibited and shall
be ignored for the purpose of the forfeiture proceedings. If such property is
subsequently forfeited, then such transfer shall be deemed to be null and
void.
54.
Similarly, in the case of Aamenabai Tayebaly & Ors. vs. Competent
Authority under SAFEMA and Ors., (1998) 1 SCC 703, Supreme Court held
that the transaction of transfer affected after the issuance of Notice of
Forfeiture, is of no legal consequence and such transfer does not confer any
title on the transferee.
55.
In order to show that the Appellant was a bona fide purchaser, she has
referred to mutation of her name in the Revenue Records. However, there
may not have been any entries in the Revenue Records about the property
being frozen, but the question of good faith and adequate consideration,
does not arise for the simple reason that the sellers i.e. Hamida Iqbal Musa
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
Patel through Iqbal Musa, had sufficient Notice of the freezing of the
property in December, 2001. They were having no title to transfer the
subject property, to any third person. Therefore, any transfer made by them
in favour of the Petitioner, was nothing but null and void.
56.
This aspect was explained in Winston Tan & Anr. (supra), of which
paragraph 28, reads as under:
“It is true that the appellants had obtained encumbrances
certificates from the Sub-Registrar prior to purchase
which show that there were no encumbrances to the
subject flat. It is also true that the appellants had
obtained loan from Vijaya Bank, Brigade Road Branch,
Bangalore for purchase of the said flat. It is a fact that
sale consideration to the tune of Rs. 26 lakhs was paid
directly by the Bank to the vendors after the Bank was
satisfied about the title of the vendors. The appellants had
also mortgaged the flat with the Vijaya Bank as a security
towards loan. But unfortunately these facts are of no
help to the appellants as the sale in their favour was
effected after notices under Section 6(1) were issued to
the vendors. Such sale has no legal sanction. The sale is
null and void on the face of Section 11; it is not protected
so as to enable the purchaser to prove that he is
transferee in good faith for adequate consideration. As a
matter of law, no title came to be vested in the appellants
by virtue of sale deed dated 10.02.2005 as the vendors
could not have transferred the property after service of
the notice under Section 6(1) and during pendency of
forfeiture proceedings under SAFEMA. The title in the
subject flat is deemed to have vested in the Central
Government on or about 08.12.2003 when the first
notice under Section 6(1) was issued and served on one
of the vendors. The vendors ceased to have any title in
the subject flat on the date of transfer i.e. 10.02.2005.
They had no transferable right. The appellants cannot
claim any right in the flat. In the circumstances, question
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
of according any opportunity to the appellants to prove
that they are transferees in good faith with adequate
consideration does not arise.”
57.
It is also significant to note that the Order of freezing of NCB dated
05.12.2001 passed under Section 68F of the NDPS Act and was
subsequently confirmed by the Competent Authority, Mumbai in exercise of
power vested under Section 68F(2) vide Order dated 31.12.2001. These
Orders were duly communicated to the respective Land Revenue Authorities
viz Collector, Mamlatdar (Tehsildar), Sub-Registrar, Talati (Patwari), etc.
The Appellate Tribunal in the impugned Order noted that the related AD
slips had been placed on record by the Respondent and the copies were duly
supplied to the Appellants. Once, the subject property was frozen by the I.O,
NCB and confirmed by the Competent Authority in terms of Section 68M of
the Act, any further transaction in relation to the property, was null and void.
58.
The impugned Order of the Appellate Tribunal has been made in
accordance with Chapter VA of the NDPS Act. There is no infirmity in the
impugned Order dated 19.05.2017.
59.
The Petition is, therefore, dismissed and stands disposed of along
with pending Applications, if any.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MARCH 13, 2026
R/VA
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:13:05
CRL.M.C. 4975/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review