Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~53 to 56
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 30th March, 2026
%
+
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 & CM APPL. 73901/2025
HEENA ALEEM
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Varun Deswal and Mr. Danish
Khan, Advocates.
versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anand Prakash, SC for MCD
with Ms. Varsha Arya, Advocate.
+
W.P.(C) 17890/2025 & CM APPL. 74068/2025
SHAGUFTA FEROZ & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Varun Deswal and Mr. Danish
Khan, Advocates.
versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anand Prakash, SC for MCD
with Ms. Varsha Arya, Advocate.
+
W.P.(C) 17907/2025 & CM APPL. 74101/2025
SHAGUFTA FEROZ & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Varun Deswal and Mr. Danish
Khan, Advocates.
versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anand Prakash, SC for MCD
with Ms. Varsha Arya, Advocate.
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
+
W.P.(C) 17928/2025 & CM APPL. 74135/2025
SHAGUFTA FEROZ & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Varun Deswal and Mr. Danish
Khan, Advocates.
versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Anand Prakash, SC for MCD
with Ms. Varsha Arya, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL
AMIT BANSAL, J. (ORAL)
1.
Arguments have been heard in the present petitions on the previous
date of hearing i.e. 23rd March, 2026. There were clarifications to be sought
from the parties and hence, the petitions are listed today i.e. 30th March,
2026. Counsel for the parties have been heard with respect to the
clarifications.
2.
Since all the present writ petitions raise a common issue and are
pertaining to the same premises, all the said petitions are being decided by
way of this common judgment.
3.
The facts in W.P.(C) 17877/2025 have been considered for the
purposes of this judgment.
4.
All the writ petitions seek similar reliefs. For the sake of convenience,
the prayers sought in W.P.(C) 17877/2025 are set out below:
“A. issue a writ of mandamus of any other appropriate writ thereby
directing the respondents to permanently de-seal the middle portion, 2nd
floor, f-16, preet vihar, delhi -110092 (let out to m/s. alchemist enabling
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
through (cat, mba coaching);
B. issue a writ of mandamus of any other appropriate writ thereby setting
aside or directing the respondents to withdraw/revoke show cause notice
dated 16.5.2025, sealing order dated 29.5.2025, demand letter dated
22.7.25, breakdown of conversion/parking/interest charges dated
24.7.25;
C. issue a writ of mandamus of any other appropriate writ thereby
directing the respondents to permanently convert/regularize the said
portion under the head, 'other property' for mixed use in terms of clause
15.7. of mpd 2021;
D. issue a writ of mandamus of any other appropriate writ thereby
directing the respondents to carry out audit and settlement of accounts
qua the registration, yearly conversion, one time conversion and parking
charges etc deposited in respect of the above said property and refund
the excess funds, if any, deposited in respect of registration, yearly
conversion, one time conversion and parking charges qua the above said
property.”
5.
Mr. Varun Deswal, counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners
submits that the petitioners are lawful owners of the properties located at the
second floor in Preet Vihar (hereinafter the ‘subject properties’). The
petitioners had deposited the parking charges, one-time registration charges
and one-time conversion charges in relation to the aforesaid premises in
2018-19.
6.
On 16th May 2025, the respondent-Municipal Corporation of Delhi
(hereinafter ‘MCD’) issued a show cause notice to the petitioners alleging
that the petitioners did not have a Fire NOC in respect of the subject
properties.
7.
A sealing order was passed on 29th May 2025, on the ground that the
petitioners have failed to pay the misuse/penalty charges.
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
8.
Aggrieved by the same, the petitioners filed writ petitions before this
Court bearing no. W.P.(C) 9578/2025 and connected matters, which were
disposed of on 11th July, 2025. The relevant observations in the said order
are set out below:
“14. Considering the submissions made before this Court, it is directed
that the petitioners shall use the subject property as per the use, which is
permissible under the Master Plan for Delhi, 2021 and in accordance
with law. In case, any permission or license is required for carrying out
any activity from the premises in question, the same shall be obtained by
the petitioners from the concerned authorities.
15. Accordingly, the petitioners are directed to submit an undertaking
with the MCD that they shall use the subject property only in accordance
with law, and carry out permitted activities only.
16. Let the said undertaking be filed by the petitioners with the MCD,
within a period of two working days from today.
17. Upon the petitioners submitting such an undertaking, and complying
with other directions of the MCD in that regard, including, payment of
any requisite charges, the MCD is directed to de-seal the subject
property of the petitioner within two days of the petitioner carrying out
the necessary compliances.
18. Further, the petitioners are held to be bound by their undertaking
before this Court that they shall use the subject property only as per the
permissible activities, in accordance with law and after taking requisite
permissions/licences from the concerned authorities, wherever
required.”
9.
After the aforesaid writ petitions were disposed of, the petitioners
filed undertakings with the respondent-MCD on 12th July 2025 stating that
premises shall be used strictly in accordance with the applicable Municipal
Corporation of Delhi bye-laws.
10.
The respondent-MCD issued demand letters dated 22nd July 2025 and
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
24th July 2025 conveying the conversion charges/penalty for misuse to be
paid by the petitioners.
11.
Since the respondent-MCD did not de-seal the property of the
petitioners, the petitioners filed contempt petitions before this Court.
12.
The stand of the respondent-MCD before the contempt Court was that
MCD has raised certain charges, which the petitioners have failed to pay.
The contempt petitions were disposed of on 22nd September 2025 by giving
liberty to the petitioners to initiate appropriate legal proceedings in respect
of the aforesaid charges.
13.
Accordingly, the present writ petitions have been filed.
14.
On the first date of hearing on 26th November 2025, this Court
directed that the Deputy Commissioner of MCD shall grant a hearing to the
petitioners in relation to the amounts payable towards conversion charges,
registration charges and parking charges and pass a speaking order.
15.
Speaking order was passed on behalf of the respondent-MCD on 29th
January 2026, wherein it was noted that the petitioners were running
coaching centers from the subject property without requisite Fire NOC. For
ease of reference, the relevant extracts of speaking order dated 29th January
2026 is set out below:
“6. In view of aforementioned factual matrix, it is hereby ordered
that:
i. The activity of “Educational Consultancy” is considered as
“Other Activities” under clause ‘J’ of 15.7.1 of MPD-2021.
ii. The Building Department, Shahdara (South) Zone is
directed to convey the requisite charges payable by the
petitioner.
iii. The petitioner is directed to pay the requisite charges to the
MCD within the period stipulated in the demand letter which
will be issued in compliance of direction at 6 (ii) above.”
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
16.
Pursuant to this order, MCD calculated conversion charges/penalty
for misuse of various portions of the subject properties, which were
conveyed to the petitioners vide communication dated 3rd February 2026.
The petitioners were given adjustments towards the amounts already paid
towards parking charges and conversion charges.
17.
Counsel for the petitioner contends that the show cause notice issued
by the MCD on 16th May 2025 only dealt with the aspect of petitioners not
having the requisite NOC from the Fire Department and running coaching
centers. There was no averment in the said show cause notice with regard to
conversion charges not having been paid by the petitioners.
18.
He further submits that one time conversion charges were paid as far
back as 2019 and no objection was raised by MCD in this regard. So, MCD
could not have raised fresh demand for conversion charges, particularly
without issuing any show cause notice in that regard.
19.
It is submitted on behalf of the petitioners that whereas show cause
notice was issued on the ground of lack of Fire NOC, the impugned sealing
order proceeds on the basis that the petitioners have changed the user of
premises from residential to commercial and have failed to pay
misuse/penalty in terms of MPD 2021. The sealing order fails to take into
account that one time conversion charges had been paid by the petitioners.
20.
Mr. Anand Prakash, Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the
MCD submits that the petitioners did not have any sanctioned building
plan(s) or completion certificate(s) in respect of the subject properties. He
places reliance on the order of the Division Bench passed on 14th December,
2023 in W.P.(C) 12182/2016 titled as Sanjay Singhal v. State Govt. of NCT
of Delhi in terms of which Fire NOC is mandatory for running a coaching
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
institute, whether the same is run from the basement or any other part of the
property. He further submits that speaking order has been passed in terms of
the order passed by this Court on 26th November 2025 after giving hearing
to the petitioners.
21.
It is further submitted on behalf of the respondent/MCD that the
petitioners had paid one time conversion charges on a self-assessment basis.
After inspection it was found that the area was in excess and therefore, the
petitioners have been asked to pay conversion charges after adjusting the
amounts that had already been paid.
22.
I have heard counsel for the parties and examined the material placed
on record.
23.
In so far as the requirement of Fire NOC is concerned, it is no longer
res integra that coaching and tuition centers are required to comply with the
fire safety norms. In light of the order dated 14th December 2023 of the
Division Bench in Sanjay Singhal (supra), the petitioners would be required
to take a Fire NOC irrespective of the fact that the coaching centers are
being run in the basement or any other floor. The relevant paragraph of
Sanjay Singhal (supra) is set out below:
“23. Insofar as Clause 15.7.3(vii) of the MPD, 2021 is concerned, we
are inclined to accept the interpretation commended for our
consideration by the learned amicus. As we read that provision, we
find ourselves unable to construe the same as restricting fire safety
clearances being required only in case a coaching or tuition center
is proposed to be operated from a basement. In fact, a prima facie
examination of that clause would appear to indicate it that it has
been placed ex abundati cautela and cannot be read as intending to
extend the requirement of fire safety clearance only where a
coaching center is proposed to be established in a basement of a
building. In our prima facie opinion, the same would not detract
from coaching and tuition centers being required to comply with fire
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
safety norms that may be otherwise specified either under the MPD,
2021 or the 2010 Rules. We note in this regard that even the UBBL in
terms of Para 9.3 incorporates special measures for buildings covered
under Rule 27 of the 2010 Rules. Para 9.3 is extracted hereinbelow: “9.3 Fire Safety
The building plans for buildings covered under Rule 27 of
Delhi Fire Service Rules shall be marked fire and life safety
measures as per the National Building Code of India
concerning minimum standards for fire prevention and fire
protection as covered under Rule 33 of the Delhi Fire Service
Rules as amended from time to time; unless otherwise
specified in these bye –laws.” ”
[Emphasis supplied]
24.
During the course of the hearing, this Court was informed that the
petitioners have vacated the subject properties and are no longer running
coaching centers in the subject properties. Accordingly, in terms of the
undertaking filed by the petitioners, the petitioners would be required to take
Fire NOC for operating any coaching centers from the said premises.
25.
The next issue to be examined is that whether the levy of conversion
charges/penalty for misuse was in accordance with law or not.
26.
In terms of the judgment dated 11th July 2025 passed in the earlier
writ petitions being W.P.(C) 9578/2025 and the connected matters, the
properties were to be de-sealed after the payment of requisite charges. After
the said judgment was passed in the earlier writ petitions, the petitioners
were sent demand letters dated 22nd July 2025 and 24th July 2025 (AnnexureC and Annexure-D to W.P.(C) 17877/2025) that the petitioners were liable
to pay conversion/misuse charges after adjustment of the already paid
amounts.
27.
Pursuant to order passed by this Court on 26th November, 2025 in the
present batch of petitions, the Deputy Commissioner, MCD gave a personal
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
hearing to the petitioners and on the basis of the personal hearing, MCD has
calculated the conversion charges as well as parking charges. In respect of
the three of the petitioners in W.P.(C) 17877/2025, W.P.(C) 17890/2025 and
W.P.(C) 17907/2025, penalty has also been levied since the petitioners were
operating coaching centres without a necessary Fire NOC. The benefit of
“Other Activities” in terms of Clause ‘J’ of 15.7.1 of MPD-2021 was given
to petitioner in W.P.(C) 17928/2025, as he was running an ‘Educational
Consultancy’ and hence, no penalty was levied.
28.
The grievance of the petitioner is that the conversion charges, parking
charges and the penalty have wrongly been calculated/imposed by the
respondent-MCD.
29.
In my considered view, these are purely disputed questions of fact
which cannot be gone into in a writ petition. The communication dated 3rd
February 2026 was sent to the petitioners after the parties were heard at
length and the Deputy Commissioner, MCD passed a speaking order dated
29th January 2026. The respondent-MCD has also given credit to the
petitioners for the parking/conversion charges paid by the petitioners. The
relevant extracts of the communication dated 3rd February 2026 are set out
below:
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
30.
In view of the discussion above, I do not find any merit in the writ
petitions and the same are dismissed.
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
31.
Needless to state, upon the petitioners paying the requisite charges, as
directed by this Court on 11th July, 2025 and communicated to the
petitioners vide communication dated 3rd February, 2026, the MCD shall
forthwith de-seal the subject properties.
AMIT BANSAL, J
MARCH 30, 2026
ds
Digitally Signed
By:AARZOO
12:29:51
W.P.(C) 17877/2025 and connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review