Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~22, 23
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010554632024
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024
SH VEER SAIN
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. M.D. Jangra, Advocate.
versus
SH. SURENDER SINGH AND OTHERS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Deepak Thukral, AAG with
Ms. Noopur Singhal and Mr. Ajay
Pratap Singh, Advocates.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010211082019
W.P.(C) 4739/2019, CM APPL. 21082/2019
SH. VEER SAIN
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. M.D. Jangra, Advocate.
versus
M/S HARYANA ROADWAYS, DELHI AND ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Deepak Thukral, AAG with
Ms. Noopur Singhal and Mr. Ajay
Pratap Singh, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
%
W.P.(C) 4739/2019
ORDER
13.08.2026
The Controversy
1.
The Petitioner is a Conductor with Haryana Roadways. While serving
at the Delhi Depot, he was allotted Flat No. 506, Block-A, Haryana
Government Housing Complex, Shalimar Bagh, Delhi, by an Office Order
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
dated 13th April, 2015. He occupied the flat with his family, and
corresponding House Rent Allowance [“HRA”] was deducted from his
salary. The allotment and deduction of HRA are not in dispute.
2.
The controversy arose after the Petitioner was transferred from Delhi
to Gurugram. He continued to occupy the flat and was eventually called
upon to pay INR 11,00,800/- towards penal rent for the period from 1st
December, 2017 to 31st December, 2018. The Petitioner does not dispute his
continued occupation. What he contests is the Respondents’ decision to treat
such occupation as unauthorised overstay attracting penal rent of this
magnitude. The controversy, therefore, turns not merely on whether the
permissible period of retention had expired, but also on whether the penalrent regime under the governing Rules was applicable to the circumstances
of his case.
Factual Background
3.
In November 2017, the Petitioner was transferred from the Delhi
Depot to the Gurugram Depot. He joined there on 23rd November, 2017. The
joining order granted him joining time from 15th November, 2017 to 22nd
November, 2017 and directed him to report for duty at Gurugram. He
continued, however, to occupy the Shalimar Bagh flat with his family.
4.
The posting at Gurugram did not last long. The Petitioner was
transferred back to the Delhi Depot and joined there on 30 th November,
2018. The return transfer order records that “no TA/DA and joining time”
would be admissible, as the transfer was against a “vacant post”. Thus, from
his joining at Gurugram to his return to the Delhi Depot, the Petitioner
remained posted away from the Delhi Depot for approximately one year.
5.
The first formal action was taken by the House Allotment Committee
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
vide Memo No. 1117 dated 6th December, 2018. The Memo required the
Petitioner to vacate Flat No. A-506 and demanded INR 9,80,800/- towards
licence fee and penal rent up to November 2018. The Memo proceeded on
the basis that the Petitioner had been transferred from Delhi to the Faridabad
Depot and that he was entitled to retain the accommodation only for two
months from the date of transfer. It accordingly treated his continued
occupation thereafter as unauthorised and cancelled the allotment.
6.
The amount of INR 9,80,800/- was arrived at on the basis of the DFR-
5 calculation by applying the prescribed penal-rent multipliers to the normal
licence fee of INR 400/- per month. The calculation allowed the first two
months after transfer at the normal rate, followed by penal rent at 50 times
the licence fee for February 2018, 100 times for March 2018, 200 times for
April 2018 and 300 times for the period from May to November 2018. This
resulted in a demand of INR 9,80,800/- up to 30th November, 2018. The
calculation further provided for recovery at INR 1,20,000/- per month if the
Petitioner did not vacate the accommodation.
7.
Thereafter, Order No. 5966/EA/ECC dated 22nd January, 2019 was
issued by the General Manager, Haryana Roadways, Delhi. The order
required the Petitioner to vacate the accommodation and directed recovery
of INR 11,00,800/- towards penal rent for the period from 1st December,
2017 to 31st December, 2018, at the rate of 60% of his monthly salary. The
amount comprised the aforesaid demand of INR 9,80,800/- up to 30th
November, 2018 and a further penal-rent charge of INR 1,20,000/- for
December 2018.
8.
Order No. 4869/ECC dated 1st February, 2019 was thereafter issued in
response to the Petitioner’s application dated 22nd January, 2019 regarding
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
deduction of House Rent and licence fee. This communication referred to
Order No. 5966/EA/ECC dated 22nd January, 2019 and reiterated that the
penal amount of INR 11,00,800/- was to be recovered from the Petitioner’s
salary at the rate of 60% per month. It further called upon the Petitioner to
get the accommodation re-allotted in his name, stating that House Rent and
licence fee would thereafter be deducted from his salary.
9.
The Petitioner challenged the aforesaid communications in W.P.(C)
1781/2019 before this Court, seeking, inter alia, a declaration that the said
action was illegal, arbitrary and unjustified. By order dated 28th February,
2019, this Court disposed of W.P.(C) 1781/2019 by directing the
Respondents to treat the writ petition as the Petitioner’s representation and
to take a ‘lenient view’. Liberty was reserved to the Petitioner to challenge
the decision so taken before the appropriate forum.
10.
In compliance with the aforesaid order, the General Manager,
Haryana Roadways, Delhi issued Memo No. 7341 dated 28th March, 2019,
upon consideration of the Petitioner’s representation, and maintained the
view that the Petitioner’s allotment had stood cancelled upon his transfer
and that the penal-rent liability was justified. It, however, reduced the
monthly recovery from 60% of the Petitioner’s salary to INR 10,000/- and
directed that the HRA payments be adjusted against the penal rent. The
order did not interfere with the cancellation of the allotment or set aside the
underlying liability of INR 11,00,800/- towards penal rent.
11.
The present petition challenges all four aforesaid actions: (i) Memo
No. 1117 dated 6th December, 2018; (ii) Order No. 5966/EA/ECC dated 22nd
January, 2019; (iii) Order No. 4869/ECC dated 1st February, 2019; and (iv)
Memo No. 7341 dated 28th March, 2019.
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
Contentions
12.
Mr. M.D. Jangra, counsel for the Petitioner, places considerable
emphasis on the fact that Delhi and Gurugram are both within the National
Capital Region [“NCR”]. He argues that the movement was, in substance, a
local posting. Reliance is also placed on the continued deduction of HRA
and other charges, the absence of any timely direction to vacate, and the
subsequent policy dated 20th July, 2021 under which officers posted in
Haryana districts forming part of the NCR receive first preference in
allotment of houses at Shalimar Bagh. The Petitioner has also produced
instances of allotments to persons serving in NCR districts.
13.
Mr. Deepak Thukral, AAG for the Respondents, resists this
construction. Delhi and Gurugram, he points out, are separate stations in
different States, with separate Drawing and Disbursing Officers and
different HRA arrangements. The Petitioner’s salary after transfer was
drawn at Gurugram. The later policy relied upon by him deals with
preference in allotment and does not determine whether a transfer made in
2017 was a local transfer. Further, the documents produced by the Petitioner
concern officers or employees belonging to different cadres and cannot
found a claim of parity.
Analysis
14.
The Court is unable to accept the Petitioner’s contention that his
transfer from Delhi to Gurugram was a local transfer merely because both
places fall within the NCR.
15.
The governing provisions are contained in the Haryana Civil Services
(Allowances to Government Employees) Rules, 2016 [“2016 Rules”]. The
Rules came into force on 19th July, 2016 and ordinarily apply to Haryana
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
Government employees. The fact that the allotment itself preceded the Rules
is therefore immaterial. The event which gave rise to the present liability
was the transfer in 2017. The Finance Department continues to publish the
2016 Rules as part of the applicable Haryana Civil Services Rules.
16.
Rule 47 allows a Government employee transferred to another station
to retain Government accommodation for two months, with a further two
months available on the stipulated medical or educational grounds upon
approval. On expiry of the permissible period, Note 1 treats the allotment as
cancelled and attracts Rule 48. Rule 48 prescribes penal rent at fifty, one
hundred, two hundred and thereafter three hundred times the normal licence
fee, depending upon the duration of the overstay.
17.
Nothing placed before the Court supports the proposition that all
places falling within the NCR constitute one “station” for the purposes of
Rule 47. The geographical proximity of Gurugram to Delhi may matter
when the practical circumstances are considered, but it does not alter the
legal character of the transfer. The 2021 policy takes the Petitioner no
further. It was issued years after the transfer, deals with preference in future
allotment, and speaks specifically of officers posted in Haryana districts
falling within the NCR. It neither retrospectively preserves the Petitioner’s
2015 allotment nor supplies a definition of “station” for Rule 47. The
individual allotments produced with the Rejoinder suffer from the same
difficulty. No equality claim can be founded merely by placing side by side
allotments made under different circumstances to persons belonging to other
services or cadres.
18.
The TA/DA submission rests on a document that does not bear the
weight placed upon it. The return transfer order relied upon concerns the
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
Petitioner’s transfer back from Gurugram to Delhi. It records that no TA/DA
or joining time would be admissible because that transfer was made against
a vacant post. It says nothing about the character of the earlier transfer from
Delhi to Gurugram. The document, therefore, cannot support the contention
that the posting at Gurugram was merely a local transfer.
19.
In the opinion of the Court, upon expiry of the permissible period of
retention, the Petitioner’s continued occupation attracted Rules 47 and 48.
The allotment stood cancelled by operation of the Rules upon expiry of that
period. The subsequent quantification of liability did not render the
cancellation of the allotment retrospective.
20.
What remains is whether the Respondents were justified in treating
that liability as inexorable. The Rules themselves preserve a power of
relaxation where their operation causes undue hardship in a particular case.
That aspect was not considered.
21.
The same statutory scheme which prescribes the consequence of
overstay expressly reserves a power to mitigate its operation in an
appropriate case. Rule 5 vests the power of relaxation in the Finance
Department. Note 2 permits relaxation where application of a rule “causes
undue hardship in any particular case”, so that the matter may be dealt with
in a “just and equitable manner”. A statutory rule cannot be administered by
enforcing its prescribed consequence while ignoring a power of relaxation
which forms part of the same scheme.
22.
The circumstances, in the Court’s view, called for consideration under
Rule 5. The Petitioner is a Group ‘C’ Conductor. His posting at Gurugram
followed a departmental transfer and he joined there as directed.
Approximately a year later, he was transferred back to Delhi and had
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
rejoined the Delhi Depot on 30th November, 2018. The demand contained in
Memo No. 1117 dated 6th December, 2018 came after his return to Delhi.
The memo also proceeded on the erroneous factual premise that his transfer
had been to Faridabad, whereas it was admittedly to Gurugram. The
financial consequence was substantial. Against a normal licence fee of INR
400/- per month, application of the prescribed multipliers produced a
demand of INR 9,80,800/- up to 30th November, 2018. With INR 1,20,000/added for December 2018, the amount rose to INR 11,00,800/-.
23.
The record also discloses circumstances relevant to the question
whether the penal rates should operate without consideration of relaxation.
Throughout his posting at Gurugram, the Petitioner remained in the same
quarter and continued to bear the electricity and water charges. The HRA
and licence fee continued to be deducted from his salary. The speaking
authority did not reject that part of his case. On the contrary, it found that the
HRA payments for the relevant period had not been accounted for and
directed that they be adjusted against the penal rent. None of this authorised
the Petitioner to retain the quarter after the permissible period had expired,
nor could it prevent the Respondents from invoking Rules 47 and 48. These
circumstances are, however, relevant to the more limited question of undue
hardship under Rule 5.
24.
Rule 5 permits the Finance Department to relax the requirements of
the Rules where their operation causes undue hardship in a particular case,
to the extent necessary for dealing with that case in a just and equitable
manner. In the circumstances noticed above, the Court is of the view that the
Petitioner’s case warranted consideration under Rule 5. Whether those
circumstances ultimately justify relaxation, and if so, to what extent, is a
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
matter for the competent authority to determine.
25.
This approach finds support in the decision of the Division Bench of
this Court in R.D. Sagar v. UOI & Anr.1. There, the Court noted that,
though in terms of the applicable rules the allotment stood cancelled and the
petitioner was liable to pay penal rent and damages, the Government
nevertheless possessed the power to relax the rules. The Court took note of
the fact that the petitioner had been transferred to Calcutta in exigency of
service, had not been provided accommodation there, and had been retransferred to Delhi within fourteen months. In view of such circumstances
and the onerous liability arising from the penal rent and damages, the Court
directed the Government to consider exercising its power of relaxation. The
decision, however, did not treat hardship, by itself, as sufficient to warrant
relaxation of the applicable rules. In the present case too, the Court is not
itself granting any relaxation or waiving the Petitioner’s liability; the
direction is confined to requiring the competent authority to consider, in
accordance with Rule 5, whether the circumstances warrant such relaxation.
26.
The Petitioner’s reliance on State of Punjab & Ors. v. Rafiq Masih2
is misplaced. That decision was concerned with recovery of monetary
benefits which had been paid to employees in excess of their entitlement on
account of a mistake committed by the employer. The Court held that the
principles laid down therein apply where the excess payment was made by
the employer and the employee was not responsible for the mistake. The
present case stands on a different footing, as the demand towards penal rent
arises from unauthorised retention of Government accommodation under the
1998 (47) DRJ 783.
(2015) 4 SCC 334.
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
applicable Rules and is not a recovery of excess monetary benefits paid to
the Petitioner. The Petitioner’s Group ‘C’ status may be relevant to the
question of undue hardship under Rule 5, but does not, by itself, apply Rafiq
Masih.
27.
The petition is accordingly disposed of in the following terms:
(i)
The contention that the Petitioner’s transfer from Delhi to Gurugram
did not attract Rule 47 merely because both places fall within the NCR is
rejected. The finding that the Petitioner retained the government
accommodation beyond the permissible period is not disturbed.
(ii)
The impugned Memo No. 1117 dated 6th December, 2018, Order No.
5966/EA/ECC dated 22nd January, 2019, Order No. 4869/ECC dated 1st
February, 2019 and Memo No. 7341 dated 28th March, 2019 are set aside to
the limited extent that they determine or seek to enforce the Petitioner’s
liability towards penal rent without consideration of the power of relaxation
under Rule 5 of the 2016 Rules.
(iii)
Within two weeks from today, the concerned Department shall place
the Petitioner’s case, together with his representation(s) and a copy of this
order, before the Finance Department, Government of Haryana. The Finance
Department shall consider the case under Rule 5, Note 2 and pass a reasoned
order within eight weeks thereafter, after affording the Petitioner an
opportunity to place a brief written representation on the question of
relaxation.
(iv)
While doing so, the Finance Department shall consider separately the
period attributable to the Petitioner’s transfer to Gurugram and the period, if
any, for which he continued in occupation after his re-transfer to Delhi. It
shall have regard, among other relevant circumstances, to the duration of the
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
Gurugram posting, the Petitioner’s service status, the magnitude of the penal
multiplier in relation to the normal licence fee, his re-transfer to Delhi before
the principal recovery proceedings commenced, and the contemporaneous
treatment of the accommodation in his salary account.
(v)
No coercive recovery towards penal rent shall be made until the
Finance Department takes its decision. Any sum already recovered shall be
given full credit in the fresh determination. If the amount already recovered
exceeds the liability finally determined, the excess shall be refunded within
four weeks of that determination, without interest.
(vi)
Any subsequent demands founded upon the same continuing
calculation, including those issued during the pendency of this petition, shall
abide by the decision so taken. This direction does not confer upon the
Petitioner any right to retain government accommodation contrary to the
applicable allotment rules.
(vii) Considering that the Petitioner has been residing in the premises with
his family for several years and has continued to occupy the same
accommodation since his re-transfer to Delhi, any direction for immediate
vacation would cause disruption. If the Petitioner wishes to continue
occupying the premises, he shall, within four weeks from today, apply for
re-allotment of the accommodation presently occupied by him. Such
application shall be considered on its own merits, having regard, inter alia,
to the Petitioner’s seniority and the applicable order of preference under
policy. Until such application is considered and a decision thereon is
communicated to the Petitioner, no coercive steps shall be taken to evict him
from the premises. If the accommodation is not re-allotted to the Petitioner,
he shall vacate and hand over peaceful possession within four weeks of
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
communication of such decision.
28.
The writ petition is allowed to the limited extent indicated above.
Pending applications shall also stand disposed of.
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024
29.
The contempt petition arises from the order dated 8 th May, 2024
passed in CM APPL.27231/2024. While issuing notice in the application,
the Court directed the Respondents “not to precipitate the said letters till the
next date of hearing”. The application itself had sought, inter alia, stay of
the monthly recovery, restraint against issuance of further letters requiring
the Petitioner to vacate the accommodation and a direction concerning HRA.
The interim order, however, was confined to the direction extracted above.
30.
The grievance in the contempt petition is directed principally against
Memo No. 555-57 dated 1st August, 2024. The communication referred to
the Petitioner’s continued occupation of the accommodation and requested
the concerned authorities to initiate action for recovery. Its endorsement also
requested the General Manager, Haryana Roadways, Delhi to make recovery
from the Petitioner.
31.
The substantive dispute has, in any event, been decided by the order
rendered today in W.P.(C) 4739/2019. The contempt petition is,
accordingly, closed. This Court expresses no approval of the demand or of
the observations contained in the communication dated 1 st August, 2024.
The consequences thereof, as also any recovery founded upon it, shall be
governed by the directions issued in W.P.(C) 4739/2019.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
AUGUST 13, 2026/nk
CONT.CAS(C) 1366/2024 & W.P.(C) 4739/2019
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 20/08/2026 at 10:52:27
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review