Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 12th January, 2026
Pronounced on: 23rd April, 2026
+
RSA 131/2025, CM APPL. 53794-53797/2025
+
RSA 132/2025, CM APPL. 53800-53801/2025
SH. UTTAM PANDIT @ UTTIM LAL YADAV
(Now Deceased) through LRs:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Smt. Ram Kumari Devi: Wife
Satyanarayan Pandit: Son
Ganesh Pandit: Son
Gaurishankar Pandit: Son
Ms. Lakhi Kumari: Daughter
Ms. Santoshi Kumari: Daughter
All R/o Ghat No.24, Jamna Bazar, Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Rinku Garg and Mr. Piyush Joshi,
Advocates.
versus
SH. RAMESH CHAND (DECEASED) THR LR.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Smt. Sarla Devi W/o Sh. Ramesh Chand
Sh. Ajay S/o late Sh. Ramesh Chand
Sh. Sonu S/o late Sh. Ramesh Chand
Sh. Ravi S/o late Sh. Ramesh Chand
Sh. Shyam S/o late Sh. Ramesh Chand
Ms Pooja D/o late Sh. Ramesh Chand
All R/o Ghat No.24, Municipal No.2150,
Jamna Bazar, Delhi.
Through: None.
.....Respondent
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
1.
Both Regular Second Appeals under Section 100 read with Order XLI
Rules 1 and 2 of CPC have been filed on behalf of the Appellant, Uttam
Pandit against common Judgment and Decree dated 24.05.2025 passed by
Ld. District Judge, Delhi in RCA DJ No. 61896/2016 preferred by the
Respondent, Ramesh Chand and RCA DJ No. 148/2017 preferred by the
Appellant, Uttam Pandit respectively, whereby the Appeal of Ramesh
Chand was allowed and decree of possession in favour of Ramesh Chand
was
passed, while the Appeal of the Appellant, Uttam Pandit was
dismissed.
Suit No. 95328/2016: Filed by Ramesh Chand on 22.03.1995, for
Declaration, Recovery of Possession, Damages and Mesne Profit and
Permanent Injunction, against Uttam Pandit.
2.
The Respondent, Ramesh Chand filed a Suit No. 95328/2016
(initially bearing CRN No. DLCT03-000051-1995), before the Court of Ld.
Civil Judge -11 Delhi on 22.03.1995, against the Appellant Uttam Pandit for
Declaration, Recovery of Possession, Damages and Mesne Profit and
Permanent Injunction. Plaintiff Sh. Ramesh Chand stated that Sh. Om
Prakash was the original allottee of property bearing Ghat No.24, Municipal
No.2150, Jamuna Bazar, Delhi (herein after referred to as „Suit Property‟)
measuring about 13 Biswas (i.e. about 650 sq. yards) forming part of
Khasra No.235/101/36 situated in the revenue estate of Village Bela, Delhi,
which he had bequeathed to Smt. Munno Devi, vide Will dated 08.09.1964.
The case of the Ramesh Chand was that Smt. Munno Devi bequeathed the
Suit Property in favour of Respondent, Ramesh Chand through a Will dated
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
26.02.1992, by virtue of which, Ramesh Chand became the owner of
aforesaid property.
3.
Ramesh Chand in his Suit, further explained that Sh. Om Prakash had
one servant Sh. Suraj Prakash S/o Sh. Ram Ujagar and one room was given
to him in the Suit Property. After demise of Sh. Om Prakash, Sh. Suraj
Prakash started claiming himself to be the son of Late Sh. Om Prakash and
started creating nuisance. When this fact came to the knowledge of Smt.
Munno Devi, she terminated the services of Sh. Suraj Prakash and asked
him to vacate the room, which was in his occupation as a tenant in the Suit
Property, but he failed to vacate the room.
4.
Ramesh Chand further stated that Defendant Uttam Pandit was a
friend of Sh. Suraj Prakash and used to visit the Suit Premises, for offering
prayers and pooja. He in collusion with Sh. Suraj Prakash, filed a Suit for
Permanent Injunction on 20.10.1987 bearing No. 264/1987, which got
dismissed by the then Learned Sub-Judge, on 24.05.1988.
5.
Ramesh Chand further averred that one more Suit bearing
No.299/1988 was filed on 27.05.1988 by the Appellant Uttam Pandit, which
got dismissed by Learned Sub Judge First Class, Delhi, vide Order dated
12.01.1993.
6.
Ramesh Chand further stated that Smt. Munno Devi had filed an
Eviction Petition against Sh. Suraj Prakash, which was settled by way of a
compromise and Suraj Prakash vacated and handed over the possession of
the room. The Petition was, accordingly, disposed of as withdrawn.
7.
Sh. Ramesh Chand further stated that on 03.07.1994, Defendant Sh.
Uttam Pandit forcibly occupied the Suit Property, i.e. one room, which was
earlier in occupation of Sh. Suraj Prakash.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
8.
Ramesh Chand had also filed Suit No.315/1997 before the Court of
the Learned Civil Judge, Delhi for Declaration, Recovery of Possession,
Damages, Mesne Profit and Permanent Injunction, on 22.03.1995.
9.
The Local Commissioner appointed by Ld. Civil Judge, Delhi, visited
the property on 12.01.1999 and filed her Report before the Court. The
plaintiff relied upon the Report of the Local Commissioner. Thereafter, Ld.
Civil Judge, Delhi, passed the order on 21.01.1999 for maintaining statusquo regarding possession in the property.
10.
The Plaintiff, thus filed the Suit for Recovery of Possession of one
room in the Suit Property; Declaration that Sh. Uttam Pandit be declared as
a trespasser and be directed to pay damages and mesne profits; and
Permanent Injunction to restrain Sh. Uttam Pandit from occupying any
other portion of the Suit Property.
11.
The Suit was contested by Sh. Uttam Pandit, who in his Written
Statement claimed that the material facts have been suppressed. He
asserted that he was owner of the Suit Property, having purchased it from
Sh. Suraj Prakash, who was admittedly the son of Late Sh. Om Prakash. All
other contentions were denied by Sh. Uttam Pandit.
12.
Sh. Ramesh Chand in his Replication, reaffirmed his assertions
made in the Plaint and denied the contentions of Sh. Uttam Pandit.
13.
After completion of Pleadings, Issues were framed on 27.10.2004, as
under:
“1. Whether the present suit is hit by section 10 of CPC?
(OPD)
2. Whether this court has no jurisdiction to try the present
suit? (OPD)
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
3. Whether suit is bad for mis joinder and non-joinder of the
parties? (OPD)
4. Whether the Plaintiff is the owner of the suit property?
(OPP)
5. Whether Plaintiff is entitled for decree of possession as
prayed? (OPP)
6. Whether Plaintiff is entitled for decree of declaration as
prayed? (OPP)
7. Whether Plaintiff is entitled for damages and mesne profit
as prayed against the defendant? (OPP)
8. Whether plaintiff is entitled for decree for permanent
injunction as prayed? (OPP)
9. Relief.”
14.
Plaintiff Sh. Ramesh Chand, in support of his case, examined himself
as PW-1; PW-2 Sh. Anil Kumar, PW-3 Sh. Ansar Ali and PW-4 Sh. Prem
Chand Sharma.
15.
Defendant Sh. Uttam Pandit examined himself as DW -1 and deposed
on similar lines, as his Written Statement.
16.
Learned Civil Judge, vide judgement dated 28.07.2016, considered
the evidence of both the parties and observed that Ramesh Chand was
claiming ownership of the Suit Property on the basis of Will dated
26.02.1992, executed in his favour by Smt. Munno Devi, who, in turn, had
got the suit property vide Will dated 08.09.1964 from Sh. Om Prakash, who
was the original allottee of DDA. It was held that no document was filed to
prove that original allottee was Om Prakash.
17.
Furthermore, though Ramesh Chand was asserting that he had Will of
Smt. Munno Devi in his favour, but referred to the Judgment dated
23.10.2009, passed by Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Mrs.
Talat Parveen Naqvi vs. Delhi Development Authority & Anr. CS(OS)
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
1877/2009, which stated that mere Will per se does not confer any title, right
or interest in favour of the legatee. To establish the interest in the Property,
legatee must establish the title in his favour. Since no documents were
produced to substantiate the ownership of Sh. Om Prakash, through whom
Sh. Ramesh Chand was claiming title, he was not entitled to any relief.
18.
It was observed that though the names of Sh. Om Prakash and Smt.
Munno Devi and of Sh. Ramesh Chand, had been entered into Revenue
Records and the Suit Property had been mutated in their names, and they
were paying House Tax, but the Apex Court in the case of Balwant Singh &
Anr. Etc vs. Daulat Singh (Dead) By L.Rs., decided on 07.07.1997, observed
that Revenue Records are not the title documents to confer the right, title or
interest in the Property. A reference was also made to Union of India vs.
Vasavi Co-Op. Housing Society Ltd., Civil Appeal No.4702/2004 decided on
07.01.2014, to conclude that mutation of a particular property in the name of
an individual or paying of House Tax does not create any right, title or
interest in such person.
19.
The mutation or paying House Tax by Sh. Om Prakash, Smt. Munno
Devi or Sh. Ramesh Chand, was held to be not sufficient to establish their
right, title or interest in the Suit Property. It was thus, held that Sh.
Ramesh Chand was unable to prove his ownership in respect of the Suit
Property.
20.
Furthermore, Declaration that Sh. Uttam Pandit was trespasser in the
Suit Property was denied, in terms of Section 34 SRA. It was also observed
that Sh. Ramesh Chand had failed to seek any Declaration of ownership in
his own favour. Insofar as the possession by Sh. Uttam Pandit was
concerned, it was observed that there were contradictory pleas taken by the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
Plaintiff Sh. Ramesh Chand, about his status and possession. Considering
that Ramesh Chand was not found to be the owner, the Recovery of
Possession and other reliefs were declined and the Suit was dismissed.
Civil Suit No.28/1999: Filed by Sh. Uttam Pandit on 12.02.1999, against
Ramesh Chand seeking Possession of one room in the Suit Property:
21.
Sh. Uttam Pandit in his Suit claimed his ownership and occupation
in the Suit Property by virtue of GPA, Agreement to Sell and Receipt in the
sum of Rs.1,80,000/-, executed in his favour by Sh. Suraj Prakash. He
claimed to have purchased this Property in the year 1987. He got electricity
meter installed in his name and got his name entered in the electoral list. He
also got the property mutated in his name in Revenue Records and other
Government Departments.
22.
Sh. Uttam Pandit further claimed that Ramesh Chand was a
trespasser, who forcibly took possession of the room in 1988, in which
Ramesh Chand had been allegedly residing, though he is residing in another
colony. The possession has been taken forcibly from Uttam Pandit, who has
been dispossessed from another room.
23.
Hence, Uttam Pandit filed the Suit for Possession in respect of one
room forming part of the Suit Property.
24.
The defendant, Ramesh Chand (in this Suit), in his Written
Statement, asserted that the Appellant had no locus standi to file the Suit, as
GPA executed in his favour by Sh. Suraj Prakash, had been cancelled by
Suraj Prakash through Public Notice published in daily Punjab Kesari, Delhi
on 14.01.2000. Uttam Pandit was claimed to be a trespasser with no right,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
title or interest in the Suit Property. It is also claimed that Suit did not
disclose any cause of action.
25.
Ramesh Chand asserted that Uttam Pandit had also filed Suit
No.299/1988 against Respondent Ramesh Chand for Permanent
Injunction, before the Civil Court, Delhi, on 27.05.1988. While the Suit
was pending, he filed the Applications under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2
read with Section 151 and Under Order XXVI Rule 9 of CPC.
26.
The Local Commissioner inspected the Suit Premises and defined
the portions, in which the Plaintiff and Defendant were in possession in the
Suit Property.
27.
This Suit No.299/1988 got dismissed by Ld. Sub Judge, First Class,
Delhi, vide Order dated 10.01.1993, on the ground that Uttam Pandit had no
locus standi and was not in possession of any portion of the Suit Property.
28.
Sh. Ramesh Chand asserted that he was absolute owner of the Suit
Property through Registered Will dated 26.02.1992, executed by Smt.
Munno Devi, owner of the Suit Property, who died in the year 1994 and the
Property stood mutated in MCD Records in his name. He denied having ever
taken forcibly possession from Uttam Pandit, who was asserted to be a
trespasser.
29.
Issues were framed by learned Civil Judge on 04.05.2005, as under:
“1. Whether the suit is barred under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC?
(OPD)
2. Whether this suit is liable to be stayed under section 10 of
the CPC? (OPD)
3. Whether Plaintiff is the owner of the suit property? (OPP)
4. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for a decree of possession
as claimed? (OPP)
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
5. Relief.”
30.
The evidence led in Suit No.536/2012 (old No.160/2011), was read in
the present Suit, with the express consent of the Parties.
31.
Learned Civil Judge referred to the evidence, wherein Uttam Pandit
asserted that documents of ownership were prepared by Sh. Suraj Prakash in
his favour, on two occasions. First set of documents was prepared in 1986
and second set in 1988. He also relied upon mutation of his name in the
MCD Records. However, learned Civil Judge noted the discrepancies in
the testimony of Uttam Pandit and concluded that Uttam Pandit was unable
to establish ownership in the Suit Property. Moreover, GPA, Agreement to
Sell etc. did not constitute sale, in terms of the Judgment of the Supreme
Court in Suraj Lamp & Industries (P) Ltd. (2) vs. State of Haryana, (2012) 1
SCC 656.
32.
Furthermore, he was claiming title through Suraj Prakash, who was
alleged to be the adopted son of Sh. Om Prakash, when in fact, he was
domestic servant who was serving Om Prakash, and after his demise, since
he was facing financial hardships, he was given temporary shelter, and kept
in service of Smt. Munno Devi, the next owner of the Suit Property.
However, he slowly started claiming ownership and his service was
terminated, by Munno Devi. It was concluded that Uttam Pandit had no
ownership rights nor there was any Sale Deed or Transfer Documents
executed in his name and that Uttam Pandit was unable to prove his title in
the Suit Property and consequently, the Suit for Possession was dismissed.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
RCA DJ 61896/2016 filed by Ramesh Chand and RCA DJ 148/2017 filed
by Uttam Pandit:
33.
Ramesh Chand filed RCA DJ 61896/2016 and Uttam Pandit filed
RCA DJ 148/2017, both of which were decided vide common Judgement
dated 24.05.2025, by learned DJ-06 Delhi.
34.
Ld. DJ. observed that on the appreciation of evidence, it emerged
that both, Ramesh Chand and Uttam Pandit were deriving their title from the
same person, namely Om Prakash. It was held that Ramesh Chand had been
able to prove better possessory title in view of the earlier litigation
undertaken by Smt. Munno Devi against Sh. Suraj Prakash, who claimed to
be owner, but the matter got settled and Smt. Munno Devi got back the
possession of the Suit Property.
35.
Moreover, Uttam Pandit had filed a Suit for Permanent Injunction
against Ramesh Chand, but was dismissed vide Judgment dated 10.01.1993,
by observing that he was unable to show the sale of property in his favour by
Registered Sale Deed, as per Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act,
1882, and documents like GPA, Sale Agreement, Will through which he was
claiming his ownership, do not confer him any ownership rights.
36.
It was concluded that multiple litigations had been undertaken which
show that Uttam Pandit/Appellant had failed at different levels, to show a
better title qua Smt. Munno Devi and Sh. Ramesh Chand. It was thus, held
that Ramesh Chand had a better possessory title than Uttam Pandit;
therefore, it was held that Ramesh Chand was entitled to get possession in
respect of the Suit Property, while LRs of Uttam Pandit were held to be
illegally occupying the Suit Property.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
37.
Consequently, RCA DJ 61896/2016 preferred by Ramesh Chand
was allowed and his Suit for Declaration, Possession and Injunction was
decreed, whereas RCA DJ 148/2017 preferred by Uttam Pandit was
dismissed.
38.
Aggrieved by the said Judgment, Uttam Pandit has filed present two
Second Regular Appeals, one assailing the dismissal of his Suit and the
other assailing the decree passed in favour of Ramesh Chand.
39.
The grounds of challenge are that the learned Appellate Court erred
in observing that Respondent Ramesh Chand had a better title, despite there
being no registered Title/Sale/Conveyance Deed in his favour, thereby
erroneously the possessory claim of the Respondent, was accepted as
superior, even though he had no title.
40.
Learned Civil Judge had rightly held that there was no document on
record to show that the Suit Property was ever allotted to Sh. Om Prakash by
the DDA. In the absence of any such allotment or ownership proof, Sh. Om
Prakash had no right, title or interest to transfer the Suit Property to Smt.
Munno Devi. Once Sh. Om Prakash had no legal title, subsequent transfer
through Will dated 26.02.1992 executed by Smt. Munno Devi in favour of
Sh. Ramesh Chand, could not create any valid or enforceable rights, as she
herself had no transferable interest in the Suit Property.
41.
Learned Appellate Court failed to appreciate the well-reasoned
findings of the learned Civil Judge in this regard and erroneously accepted
the Will of Smt. Munno Devi, as proof of better title.
42.
Learned Appellate Court has contradicted the learned Civil Judge’s
correct finding that mutation or entry in Municipal/Revenue Records, cannot
confer any title. The chain of title documents relied by the Respondent that
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
flows from Sh. Om Prakash to Munno Devi to Ramesh Chand, was legally
not sustainable, since the original title of Om Prakash was never established.
The long, settled, peaceful and continuous possession of the Appellant/
Uttam Pandit since 1988, has not been appreciated correctly, in the light of
established jurisprudence that an independent possessory right enforceable
even against the true owner, existed in favour of the Appellant.
43.
Learned Appellate Court misdirected itself in law by not framing or
addressing the issue of adverse possession, which squarely arose from the
Appellant’s long-standing uninterrupted possession, spanning well over 12
years without any legal challenge. The evidentiary value of documents such
as Ration Card, Electricity Bills, Affidavits and Statements showing the
Appellant’s continued use, residence and occupation of the Suit Premises,
has not been considered, rendering the finding against the Appellant, as
perverse.
44.
The Supreme Court in Rame Gowda vs. M. Varadappa Naidu, (2004)
1 SCC 769, has held that if the possession is settled, it must be protected and
in the absence of better title, the person in possession is entitled to retain it.
45.
Learned District Judge wrongly assumed that Ramesh Chand had
better title merely based on alleged Revenue Records and Membership
Receipts of Association, which are not the documents of title under law. The
distinction between de facto possession and legal ownership, has not been
appreciated and the correct test has not been applied, for determining who
had better enforceable possessory right under the circumstances.
46.
The Appellant’s Appeal bearing RCA DJ 148/2017 has been wrongly
dismissed on the ground of limitation, without appreciating the bonafide
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
reasons for delay and without giving due weight to the fact that both parties,
had been engaged in ongoing parallel litigations.
47.
The Appellant/Uttam Pandit’s claim was summarily rejected, without
giving opportunity to prove that Suraj Prakash, from whom the Appellant
derived possession, was in settled occupation of the Suit Property for
decades and that his status as tenant or licensee, did not extinguish the
Appellant’s claim based on possession. The judgment of learned Court is
asserted to be based on conjectures and surmises. Moreover, the judgment of
Suraj Lamp (supra), is asserted to have been incorrectly applied.
48.
Learned Appellate Court ought to have adjudicated purely on the
basis of settled possession and conduct, rather than recognizing the
unregistered Will, as creating ownership in favour of the Respondent.
49.
Furthermore, in Suit No.299/1988, PW-7 Anand Rao had clearly
stated that he had paid rent to the Appellant/Uttam Pandit on the instruction
of Suraj Prakash, thereby, corroborating Appellant’s possession and control
over the Suit Property in a landlord-like capacity. Appellant/Uttam Pandit
has been proved to be collecting rent from tenants from Suit Premises,
which evidence possession, control and public perception of ownership,
none of which has been rebutted or challenged by the Respondents.
50.
The Receipts of Rent, as recorded in the testimony of PW-7 Anand
Rao, contradicts the allegations that Appellant was a mere trespasser; instead
supports his possessory title under equitable principles. The impugned
common Judgement dismissing the Appeal of Uttam Pandit and decreeing
the Suit of Ramesh Chand are, therefore, liable to be set aside.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
Submissions heard and record perused.
51.
It is not in dispute inter se the parties that both Uttam Pandit and
Ramesh Chand trace their respective claims in the Suit Property through Om
Prakash.
52.
The main contention of the Appellant was that he had a long and
settled possession through Om Prakash, and he could not be ousted by
Ramesh Chand, who had no title document, in his favour.
53.
The learned District Judge, while deciding both First Appeals, had
rightly observed that in the given circumstances, once both the parties were
tracing their respective right through Sh. Om Prakash, the Suit should have
been decided based on better possessory title over the Suit Property.
54.
Indeed, the dispute revolves around the “possessory rights” rather
than, on the basis of “ownership rights” inter se the parties.
55.
It is, therefore, significant to understand the two concepts, i.e.
“possessory rights” and the “ownership rights”. Salmond on Jurisprudence
(12 Edn. at paras 59-60) expounded the two concepts as under:
“These two concepts of ownership and possession,
therefore, may be used to distinguish between the de facto
possessor of an object and its de jure owner, between the
man who actually has it and the man who ought to have it.
They serve also to contract the position of one whose rights
are ultimate, permanent and residual with that of one whose
rights are only of a temporary nature.”
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
56.
While the law was still not certain whether the possession alone could
be entitled to protection, in Perry v Clissold (1907 AC 73), the Australian
Court categorically held that it cannot be disputed that a person in
possession of land, is in the assumed character of owner and exercising
peaceably the ordinary rights of ownership, has a perfectly good title against
all the world but the rightful owner. And if the rightful owner does not come
forward and assert his title by process of law within the period prescribed by
the provisions of the Statute of Limitations applicable to the case, his right is
forever extinguished, and the possessory owner acquires an absolute title.
57.
In English law, possession is a good title of right against anyone who
cannot show a better title. A wrongful possessor has the rights of an owner
with respect to all persons except earlier possessors and except the true
owner himself.
58.
Many other legal systems, however, go much further than this, and
treat possession as a provisional or temporary title even against the true
owner himself. Even a wrongdoer, who is deprived of his possession, can
recover it from any person whatever, simply on the ground of his
possession. Even the true owner, who takes his own, may be forced in this
way to restore it to the wrongdoer, and will not be permitted to set up his
own superior title to it. He must first give up possession, and then proceed in
due course of law for the recovery of the thing on the ground of his
ownership. The intention of the law is that every possessor shall be entitled
to retain and recover his possession, until deprived of it by a judgment
according to law.
59.
Legal remedies thus, intended for the protection of possession, even
as against ownership, are called possessory, while those available for the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
protection of ownership itself, may be distinguished as proprietary. The
distinction in modern and medieval civil law, is expressed by contrasted
terms; Petitorium (a Proprietary Suit) and Possessorium (a Possessory Suit).
60.
As far back as 1924, in Midnapore Zamindary Co. Ltd. v. Naresh
Narayan Roy 1924 SCC OnLine PC 18, the learned Judge observed that in
India, persons are not permitted to take forcible possession; they must obtain
such possession as they are entitled to through a court.
61.
This was followed by the case in Nair Service Society Ltd. v. K. C.
Alexander AIR 1968 SC 1165, wherein the Apex Court held that when the
facts disclose no title in either party, possession alone decides. It was further
held that if Section 9 of the Specific Relief Act, 1877 (corresponding to the
present Section 6) is employed, the plaintiff need not prove title and the title
of the defendant does not avail him. When, however, the period of six
months has passed, questions of title can be raised by the defendant, and if
he does so the plaintiff must establish a better title or fail. In other words,
such a right is only restricted to possession in a suit under Section 9 of the
Specific Relief Act (corresponding to the present Section 6) but does not bar
a suit on prior possession within 12 years from the date of dispossession,
and title need not be proved unless the defendant can provide one.
62.
It was also observed in Nair Service Society Ltd.(supra) that a person
in possession of land in assumed character of owner and exercising
peaceably the ordinary rights of ownership has a perfectly good title against
the entire world except the rightful owner. In such a case, the defendant
must show in himself or his predecessor a valid legal title and probably a
possession prior to the plaintiff's, and thus be able to raise a presumption
prior in time.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
63.
As held in the case of Nair Service Society Ltd. (supra), entitlement
either by way of Possessory Title or Proprietary Title is recognized under
Indian Law, which is evident from Articles 64 and 65 of Schedule to
Limitation Act,1963 which reads as under:
Description of suit
Period
of Time from which period
limitation
begins to run
64. For possession of immovable property Twelve
65.
64.
based on previous possession and not years.
on title, when the plaintiff while in
possession of the property has been
dispossessed.
For possession of immovable property Twelve
or any interest therein based on title. years.
Explanation…
The date of dispossession.
When the possession of
the defendant
becomes adverse to the
plaintiff.
Article 64 thus, recognizes the maintainability of a Suit for Possession
of immovable property based on previous possession and not on title,
thereby embodying the principle of possessory title.
65.
Likewise, Article 65 governs Suits for possession of immovable
property based on title, and thereby recognises proprietary title, where the
plaintiff must establish a better legal title as against the defendant.
66.
It is therefore, evident that Possessory Rights and Proprietary Rights
are distinct rights recognized under Indian Law, as has also been explained
in Nair Service Society Ltd. (supra).
67.
In Rame Gowda v. M. Varadappa Naidu (2004) 1 SCC 769, a three-
Judge Bench of the Apex Court, while discussing the Indian law on the
subject, observed as under:
“8. It is thus clear that so far as the Indian law is
concerned, the person in peaceful possession is entitled
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
to retain his possession and in order to protect such
possession he may even use reasonable force to keep
out a trespasser. A rightful owner who has been
wrongfully dispossessed of land may retake
possession if he can do so peacefully and without the
use of unreasonable force. If the trespasser is in
settled possession of the property belonging to the
rightful owner, the rightful owner shall have to take
recourse to law; he cannot take the law in his own
hands and evict the trespasser or interfere with his
possession. The law will come to the aid of a person in
peaceful and settled possession by injuncting even a
rightful owner from using force or taking the law in his
own hands, and also by restoring him in possession
even from the rightful owner (of course subject to the
law of limitation), if the latter has dispossessed the
prior possessor by use of force. In the absence of proof
of better title, possession or prior peaceful settled
possession is itself evidence of title. Law presumes the
possession to go with the title unless rebutted. The
owner of any property may prevent even by using
reasonable force a trespasser from an attempted
trespass, when it is in the process of being committed,
or is of a flimsy character, or recurring, intermittent,
stray or casual in nature, or has just been committed,
while the rightful owner did not have enough time to
have recourse to law. In the last of the cases, the
possession of the trespasser, just entered into would
not be called as one acquiesced to by the true owner.”
68.
In Rame Gowda, the Hon’ble Supreme Court thus, held that in the
absence of proof of better title, possession or prior peaceful settled
possession is itself evidence of title.
69.
Similar observations have been in Poona Ram vs. Moti Ram (2009) 11
SCC 309, the Apex Court endorsed the observations made in Rame Gowda
(supra) that legal remedies thus, appointed for the protection of possession
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
even against ownership, are called possessory, while those available for the
protection of ownership itself may be distinguished as proprietary. The
distinction is expressed in contrasted terms of petitorium (a proprietary suit)
and possessorium (a possessory suit). It was thus, held that the Plaintiff in
the absence of better Title, can claim prior peaceful settled possession which
itself is the evidence of title. It was held that the settled possession must be
(i) effective; (ii) undisturbed; and (iii) to the knowledge of the owner or
without any attempt and concealment by the trespasser.
Moreover, there
can be no straight jacket formula to determine settled possession and each
case must be decided on its own facts. The possession should contain an
element of animus possidendi. It was further observed that in order to claim
possessory title, the Plaintiff will have to prove his own case and also will
have to show that he has better title than any other person.
70.
In the case of Saleem & Ors. vs. Wahid Malik, RSA No.118/2022
decided by this Court, it was held that in a suit for possession simplicitor or
a suit for injunction against dispossession simplicitor, the Plaintiff is not
required to establish title or ownership, but is only required to establish a
better right to remain in possession of the Suit Property as compared to the
right of the Defendant.
71.
The aforesaid judgements thus, held that when the facts disclose no
title in either party, possession alone decides. It was thus, required to be
considered about who had a better possessory title over the property, as had
been rightly observed by Ld. District Judge, in the two Appeals.
72.
Essentially, the Appellant, Uttam Pandit had been claiming title by
asserting that he had purchased the Suit Property from Suraj Prakash, who
was stated by him to be the adopted son of Om Prakash, through GPA,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
Agreement to Sell, etc. dated 29.11.1988 Ex. PW-1/A to Ex. PW-1/C, Ex.
PW-1/E respectively, as well as the electricity bills of the Suit Property, for
15th September 2015 and 27th February 2007 as Ex. PW-1/H, which was
issued to him.
73.
It has been rightly held by the Courts below that these documents do
not create any right, title or interest in favour of the claimant so as to clothe
him with ownership in the Suit Property and therefore, the Appellant/Uttam
Pandit was rightly, held not to be the owner of the Suit Property.
74.
Pertinently, the record reflects that the predecessor-in-interest of the
Respondent, namely Smt. Munno Devi, had taken steps to recover
possession from Suraj Prakash, and the possession of the Suit Property was
restored pursuant to earlier proceedings. The subsequent occupation of the
Appellant is, therefore, not shown to be settled, continuous and acquiesced
to, but rather emerges as disputed and contested throughout.
75.
In these circumstances, insofar as the question whether Ramesh
Chand was entitled to recovery of possession from Uttam Pandit is
concerned, it has been rightly observed that Uttam Pandit and Ramesh
Chand, both were deriving their title from Om Prakash. The chain of
documents flowing through a Will from Om Prakash to Munno Devi to
Ramesh Chand have more credence, as compared to the Agreement to Sell
of the Appellant and consequently, Ramesh Chand was rightly, held to be
entitled to Decree of Possession.
76.
There is no perversity shown in the findings of the learned District
Judge. Essentially, the challenge in present Second Regular Appeal, is on
the facts and does not raise any substantial question of law.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
77.
There is no merit in both these Regular Second Appeals, which are
accordingly dismissed. Pending Applications, if any, stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
APRIL 23 , 2026/R
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
19:00:49
RSA 131/2025 & 132/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review