Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
SH. RUBAL KHANNA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, Ms. Kritika
Matta, Mr. Pradeep Kumar, Ms.
Shreya Gupta, Ms. Tanya Rose and
Mr. Shubham Bahl, Advocates.
versus
PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK (HEAD OFFICE) AND ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhishek Vikas & Mr. Utkarsh
Bhushan, Advocates for R-1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
05.02.2026
%
1.
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution assails (i) the
order dated 7th April, 2017 passed by the Disciplinary Authority imposing
the major penalty of “dismissal which shall ordinarily be a disqualification
for future employment”, and (ii) the appellate order dated 28 th August, 2017
affirming the said penalty, communicated thereafter.
Facts in brief:
2.
The Petitioner joined Punjab National Bank on 5th February, 2013 as
Manager (Credit) at Central Staff College, Civil Lines, Delhi. He was
thereafter promoted as Senior Manager (Credit) and posted at Branch Office,
Civil Lines, Delhi. The disciplinary action traces its origin to an audio-visual
clipping aired on 20th December, 2016 on “Aaj Tak” and “India Today”, in
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
which the Petitioner was shown interacting with two individuals in the
backdrop of demonetisation, and purportedly offering to facilitate exchange
of specified bank notes for new currency.
3.
On 20th December, 2016, the Bank placed the Petitioner under
suspension. On the next day, the Petitioner furnished a written explanation.
The explanation does not deny the interaction. In the letter, he asserts that
two persons approached him under the pretext of a loan, and later started
speaking about exchange of notes. He “pretended” to agree, spoke
“vaguely”, and referred to commission only to “trap” them, with the asserted
intention of getting them caught “red handed”. He further asserts that he had
no role in cash operations, and that the branch itself did not have adequate
cash supply.
4.
The Bank served a charge sheet dated 2nd February, 2017. The solitary
article of charge premised on the televised sting operation is that the
Petitioner offered to exchange bank notes in violation of RBI and Bank
guidelines, thereby tarnishing the image of the Bank and causing
reputational loss, amounting to misconduct under Regulation 3(1) read with
Regulation 24 of the Punjab National Bank Officer Employees’ (Conduct)
Regulations, 1977.
5.
The Petitioner participated in the departmental enquiry and denied the
charge. The Presenting Officer relied upon three documents, marked as
MEx-1 to MEx-3. These were supplied to the Petitioner on 3rd March, 2017.
The parties filed written briefs and the enquiry culminated in a report dated
21st March, 2017 holding the charge proved. The Disciplinary Authority
accepted the findings and imposed dismissal by order dated 7 th April, 2017.
The departmental appeal was rejected by the Appellate Authority by order
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
dated 28th August, 2017.
Petitioner’s Submissions:
6.
The Petitioner challenges the disciplinary proceedings and urges that
the enquiry suffers from foundational procedural illegality, is unsupported
by legally sustainable material, and has resulted in a punishment that is, in
any event, wholly disproportionate. The contentions are summarised as
follows:
6.1.
The principal challenge is founded on Regulation 6(17) of the Punjab
National Bank Officer Employees’ (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations,
1977. It is submitted that the Regulation imposes a mandatory obligation
upon the Inquiring Authority to generally question the charged officer on the
circumstances appearing in evidence so as to enable an explanation. This is a
substantive safeguard and not a mere formality; its non-compliance vitiates
the fairness of the enquiry.
6.2.
It is urged that Regulation 6(17) is pari materia to Rule 14(18) of the
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. Reliance is placed on the DoPT Office
Memorandum dated 18th February 2015 emphasising strict compliance with
the corresponding rule. The Petitioner submits that denial of opportunity
contemplated under the Regulation renders the enquiry legally vulnerable.
6.3.
The omission to comply with Regulation 6(17) has caused real
prejudice. The Petitioner submits that he was deprived of an effective
opportunity to explain the circumstances arising from the audio-visual
clipping and the inferences sought to be drawn from it. The Petitioner would
have explained (i) the context in which the two individuals approached him,
(ii) the manner in which the conversation was steered, (iii) the Petitioner’s
true intention behind the interaction, and (iv) the incompleteness and editing
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
of the audio visual material. Reliance is placed on decisions including Moni
Shankar v. Union of India,1 Union of India v. D.S. Manchanda,2 Delhi
Tourism & Transportation Development Corporation Ltd. v. Azad Singh,3
Satya Prakash v. Union of India,4 and The Chief Secretary v. Jitender
Kumar Bhatia,5 to contend that breach of such a requirement vitiates the
enquiry.
6.4.
The second limb of the challenge is that the finding rests on “no
evidence”. The Presenting Officer led no oral evidence and examined no
witness to prove the relied upon documents. Where documents are disputed,
mere production does not constitute proof. The audio-visual clipping was
consistently disputed as to authenticity, completeness and inference. In the
absence of witness testimony establishing its reliability, the conclusion of
guilt is said to be unsustainable. Reliance is placed on A.K. Saxena v. Union
of India,6 Sita Ram v. State of U.P.,7 Narendra Kumar Pandey v. State
Bank of India,8 and State of U.P. v. Saroj Kumar Sinha.9
6.5.
The Petitioner assails reliance on sting material conducted by a
private news channel. Such material, particularly when unproved, cannot by
itself constitute reliable evidence of misconduct. Reliance is placed on
Government of NCT of Delhi v. Jai Bhagwan10 and Government of NCT
of Delhi v. Ex. ASI Surinder Kumar.11
(2008) 3 SCC 484.
011 SCC OnLine Del 1263.
2013 SCC OnLine Del 811.
2015 SCC OnLine Del 12161.
2016 SCC OnLine Del 5118.
2016:DHC:5711-DB.
MANU/UP/2069/2014.
MANU/UP/2212/2011.
MANU/SC/0082/2010.
2010:DHC:3851-DB.
2008:DHC:1440-DB.
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
6.6.
It is further urged that the relied upon documents were not supplied
with the charge sheet. Non-supply at the inception impaired his ability to
submit an effective reply and amounted to violation of natural justice,
particularly where the charge was rooted in specific audio-visual material.
6.7.
On merits, the Petitioner contends that the findings are perverse.
There is a clear distinction between admission of fact and admission of guilt.
He maintains that there was never any admission of misconduct. His
consistent stand has been that the clipping was edited and incomplete, and
that the explanation dated 21st December, 2016 was not an admission of
wrongdoing but a contextual clarification.
6.8.
The Petitioner emphasises that he was posted as Senior Manager
(Credit) and had no role in cash operations. He was not in a position to
facilitate currency exchange. He further relies on the prevailing shortage of
new currency and asserts that the branch lacked the cash availability
consistent with the alleged promise, supporting his case that the interaction
was not a genuine offer of exchange but an attempt to expose the individuals
who approached him.
6.9.
The Enquiry Officer and the disciplinary authorities failed to
appreciate that suspicion, however strong, cannot substitute proof. Reliance
is placed on Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank12 to submit that a
finding of guilt must rest on probative evidence and not conjecture.
6.10. The Enquiry Officer wrongly rejected his request to have the audiovisual clipping tested for authenticity and completeness. Given that the
clipping formed the principal basis of the charge, fairness required
independent verification once its integrity was disputed.
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
6.11. The independence of the Enquiry Officer is also questioned. The
Assistant General Manager of the Bank, being the Enquiry Officer, lacked
the detachment required, resulting in bias and violation of natural justice.
6.12. The allegation of “tarnishing the image” of the Bank is unproved. No
material was led to demonstrate any specific reputational loss attributable to
the Petitioner. It is urged that the charge is framed in broad and vague terms,
yet no evidence was led to establish the alleged reputational injury as a fact.
6.13. In any event, the penalty of dismissal is assailed as shockingly
disproportionate. The Petitioner relies on his age, length of service and
asserted clean record, and submits that mitigating circumstances were
ignored. Dismissal, which ordinarily disqualifies future employment, is an
excessive penalty violative of Articles 14, 16, 21 and 311 of the Constitution
and the governing Regulations.
Respondents’ submissions:
7.
The Respondent Bank submits that the disciplinary proceedings were
conducted in accordance with the Punjab National Bank Officer Employees’
(Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1977 and the Punjab National Bank
Officer Employees’ (Conduct) Regulations, 1977. The charge pertains to
serious misconduct during the demonetisation period, involving a bank
officer being recorded offering to facilitate exchange of specified bank notes
for new currency, in violation of RBI and Bank instructions. It is urged that
the misconduct directly undermined public confidence in the institution and
exposed the Bank to reputational harm. The Bank’s contentions are as
follows:
7.1.
The Petitioner was placed under suspension on 20th December, 2016
(2009) 2 SCC 570.
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
following the telecast of the audio-visual clipping. His written reply dated
21st December, 2016, does not deny the core interaction. The Bank submits
that the reply acknowledges statements conveying readiness to facilitate
exchange for commission, and the subsequent plea of “trapping” the
individuals is an afterthought.
7.2.
The Petitioner’s posting in the credit department is immaterial. The
misconduct lies in the assurance given by a bank officer that illegal
exchange could be facilitated. Even if no exchange ultimately occurred, the
representation itself is sufficient to constitute misconduct under Regulation
3(1) read with Regulation 24 of the Conduct Regulations and to damage the
Bank’s reputation.
7.3.
The allegation of tampering is contested. The Bank submits that it had
no role in the creation or broadcast of the clipping. In any event, the
Petitioner does not deny his presence in the video or the conversation; he
only seeks to reinterpret it. In these circumstances, the request for forensic
testing is characterised as irrelevant and dilatory.
7.4.
On Regulation 6(17), the Bank submits that there was no procedural
violation. The Petitioner participated in the enquiry and was afforded
opportunity to defend. No specific circumstance has been identified wherein
he was prevented from advancing his defence. The record, therefore, reflects
substantial compliance and fairness.
7.5.
On the absence of “oral evidence”, the Bank contends that there is no
legal requirement that each document must be supported by oral testimony
in every domestic enquiry. The test is fairness and opportunity.
Documentary material can validly be relied upon, particularly where it is in
the public domain, originates from the employee himself, or is not disputed
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
in substance.
7.6.
The complaint regarding non-supply of documents with the charge
sheet is without merit. The relied upon documents were supplied on 3 rd
March, 2017, well before the enquiry report dated 21 st March, 2017, and the
Petitioner filed his defence thereafter. Hence, no prejudice is shown.
7.7.
It is further submitted that the plea of prejudice is illusory in light of
the nature of the documents. The telecast CD was in the public domain, the
operational circular during demonetisation was widely circulated, and the
third document is the Petitioner’s own letter. The Petitioner cannot claim
disadvantage from non-supply of material already within his knowledge.
7.8.
On the argument that sting material by a private agency is “no
evidence”, the Bank submits that the Petitioner incorrectly imports criminal
trial standards into a departmental context. The applicable standard is
preponderance of probability. Strict criminal rules of admissibility do not
apply. Sting material can legitimately form part of the evidentiary basis,
particularly where the employee admits the interaction and disputes only its
interpretation.
7.9.
The allegation of bias is devoid of merit. Departmental enquiries are
routinely conducted by officers designated under service rules, and bias
cannot be presumed from designation alone. Further, no such objection was
raised during the enquiry or in appeal, which itself undermines the plea.
7.10. On the allegation of failure to prove reputational damage, the Bank
submits that the telecast on national television during demonetisation
inherently establishes harm to the Bank’s image. Separate proof is
unnecessary where reputational injury flows directly from the public airing
of the incident.
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
7.11. The misconduct is grave in the context of an integrity-sensitive
institution. Conduct suggesting that bank processes could be misused for
illegal exchange strikes at public trust. Dismissal, in these circumstances, is
neither excessive nor shocking, and is therefore, proportional. The
disciplinary and appellate authorities acted within jurisdiction and the
penalty does not warrant interference under Article 226.
Analysis and findings:
8.
Having considered the aforenoted facts and contentions, the
controversy essentially gives rise to the following issues:
(i)
Whether the enquiry stands vitiated for non-compliance with
Regulation 6(17);
(ii)
Whether the finding of guilt suffers from “no evidence” or perversity
warranting interference in writ jurisdiction;
(iii)
Whether the reliance on the audio visual clipping and allied material
is legally impermissible in a departmental enquiry;
(iv)
Whether the penalty of dismissal calls for interference on
proportionality.
Scope of judicial review
9.
Writ review over departmental proceedings is limited. Interference is
justified where the enquiry is vitiated by breach of natural justice, patent
procedural illegality causing prejudice, findings based on no evidence, or
perversity of the kind that no reasonable person could reach on the record.
The Court does not reweigh evidence or substitute its own view on factual
sufficiency merely because another view may be possible.13
Regulation 6(17)
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
10.
Regulation 6(17) provides that the Inquiring Authority “may” after
the officer employee closes his evidence, and “shall” if the officer employee
has not got himself examined, generally question him on the circumstances
appearing against him in evidence, to enable an explanation. The object is to
ensure that an employee is not condemned on circumstances that he had no
opportunity to explain.
11.
Even where a procedural requirement is couched in mandatory terms,
the enquiry does not automatically vitiate on a mere recital of infraction. The
question remains whether non-compliance has occasioned real prejudice.
This “prejudice” discipline well recognised in service jurisprudence. (see
State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma.)14
12.
The Petitioner’s own case demonstrates why the objection does not
carry the petition far. The “circumstances” which the Petitioner says he
would have explained are not only known to him, but were affirmatively
placed by him on record at the earliest. The contemporaneous letter dated
21st December, 2016 sets out the full narrative the Petitioner wishes to
advance: that he pretended to agree, spoke about commission only to trap
the persons, and that cash exchange was in any event not feasible through
the branch. The Petitioner thereafter participated in the enquiry, received the
relied upon material on 3rd March, 2017, and filed his defence. The
disciplinary record also reflects that the authorities considered and rejected
the “trap” explanation as implausible and unsupported by contemporaneous
conduct.
13.
Put differently, it is not a case where an incriminating circumstance
Deputy General Manager (Appellate Authority) v. Ajai Kumar Srivastava (2021) 2 SCC 612.
(1996) 3 SCC 364.
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
surfaced in evidence, unknown to the employee, and remained unexplained
because the Inquiring Authority never put it to him. The Petitioner’s
explanation stood disclosed and remained constant in theme. The grievance
is really about rejection of that explanation, not about absence of
opportunity to offer it. In these circumstances, even assuming that
Regulation 6(17) was not adhered to in the precise manner urged, the
Petitioner has not demonstrated what additional, tangible explanation he was
prevented from furnishing, or how the outcome would plausibly have
changed. The procedural ground, therefore, does not vitiate the enquiry.
“No oral evidence”, proof of documents, and the “no evidence” argument
14.
Domestic enquiries are not bound by the strict rules of the Evidence
Act. The enquiry must still be fair, and the material relied upon must have a
reasonable nexus to the charge, but proof is tested on preponderance of
probability, not proof beyond reasonable doubt.15 A departmental finding is
not assailable merely because no witness was examined, if the relevant facts
are demonstrable from admitted or reliable documentary material, and the
employee had an effective opportunity to respond.
15.
visual
Here, the enquiry record rests on three broad planks: (i) the audioclipping
aired
on
national
television;
(ii)
the
governing
circular/instructions issued in the wake of demonetisation; and (iii) the
Petitioner’s own contemporaneous letter dated 21st December, 2016. The
third plank alone materially answers the “no evidence” argument. The
Petitioner admits that he engaged the persons, discussed exchange, and
spoke about commission. The Petitioner’s attempt is to convert that
admission into innocence by attributing a benevolent intent. That is a
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
defence on merits. It does not erase the factual substratum that the Petitioner
held out facilitation of an act which, on any reasonable view, was contrary to
the regulatory regime during demonetisation.
16.
The submission that the audio-visual clipping was “tampered” also
remains at the level of bare assertion. The Petitioner does not take the case
to its logical end by denying presence, identity, voice, or the substance of
the interaction. The Petitioner accepts the meeting and seeks to explain the
tenor of conversation. Where the employee admits the core interaction and
advances a justificatory narrative, the enquiry does not become a case of “no
evidence” merely because the employee adds that the clip was incomplete.
17.
The Court also does not accept the proposition that absence of oral
evidence, by itself, renders documentary material unusable in a domestic
enquiry. The question is whether the employee had notice, access to the
material, and opportunity to contest it. Those conditions were satisfied.
Non-supply of documents with the charge sheet
18.
The Petitioner was supplied MEx-1 to MEx-3 on 3rd March, 2017. He
thereafter submitted his defence before the enquiry report dated 21 st March,
2017. The Petitioner’s own pleadings do not set out a convincing case of
prejudice of the kind recognised in service law, namely that the defence was
materially disabled or that the employee was ambushed by documents only
at the stage of findings. On the contrary, the Petitioner’s defence, including
the “trap” explanation, had already been articulated in writing on 21 st
December, 2016, even before the charge sheet was issued. In these
circumstances, the objection remains technical and does not warrant
interference.
Union of India and Ors. v. Dalbir Singh 2021 SCC OnLine 768.
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
Reliance on sting operation material
19.
The contention that sting material is “no evidence” proceeds on a
criminal trial paradigm. For reasons already noted above, that standard
cannot be imported disciplinary enquiries. The relevant question is whether
the material is reliable for administrative fact-finding and whether the
employee had a fair opportunity to respond. Where the employee admits the
interaction and seeks to justify it, the objection to the private origin of the
sting loses much of its force.
20.
The disciplinary charge is not that the Petitioner actually exchanged
currency through bank channels. The gravamen is that a responsible officer
of the Bank, during an extraordinary regulatory period, was seen and heard
offering facilitation of illegal exchange for commission, thereby eroding
public trust and exposing the Bank to reputational harm. In banking service,
integrity and public confidence are not ornamental values. They are the
foundation of the relationship between the institution and the public. The
Supreme Court has consistently recognised the special standard expected of
bank officers, and that conduct which undermines confidence can justify
severe action, including dismissal.16
Bias and refusal to send the clipping for testing
21.
The plea that the Enquiry Officer was biased merely because he was
an officer of the Bank is misconceived. Departmental enquiries in
institutional employment are routinely conducted by officers designated
under the service regulations. Bias must be pleaded and established on facts,
not presumed. There is also force in the Bank’s submission that this
Chairman and Managing Director, United Commercial Bank and Ors. v. P.C. Kakkar (2003) 4 SCC
364; Union Bank of India v. Vishwa Mohan (1998) 4 SCC 310.
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
objection was not contemporaneously pursued in the manner expected,
either during the enquiry or in departmental appeal.
22.
On the refusal to send the clipping for forensic testing, the enquiry
record, as placed, does not show a foundational case laid by the Petitioner
demonstrating why such testing was necessary to meet the charge. The
Petitioner did not deny the meeting or the conversation. The defence was
justification, not denial. In that situation, the enquiry cannot be faulted for
declining an open-ended fishing exercise, particularly when the Petitioner’s
own letter supplies a contemporaneous narrative that the disciplinary
authorities were entitled to evaluate.
Proportionality
23.
Interference with penalty lies within a narrow campus. Unless the
punishment shocks the conscience or is wholly disproportionate to the
misconduct proved, writ courts do not substitute their own view for that of
the disciplinary authority.17
24.
The misconduct here is not a minor lapse. It pertains to a bank officer
being shown offering unlawful exchange for commission during
demonetisation, a period when public confidence in banking operations was
under intense scrutiny. Even if the Petitioner claims he had no access to cash
operations, the act of holding out such facilitation as a bank officer, in public
glare, corrodes the trust reposed in the institution. In that setting, dismissal
cannot be characterised as shockingly disproportionate. The submission
founded on the Petitioner’s age and short service also does not assist him.
Where the proved misconduct goes to integrity and public confidence,
Jai Bhagwan v. Commissioner of Police (2013) 11 SCC 187; Dev Singh v. Punjab Tourism
Development Corpn. Ltd. (2003) 8 SCC 9.
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
length of service is immaterial.
Conclusion:
25.
The impugned orders do not disclose procedural illegality causing
prejudice, nor do they suffer from perversity or absence of evidence
warranting interference under Article 226. The disciplinary action is
founded on material which the Petitioner was aware of, had opportunity to
meet, and in substantial measure admitted, albeit with an attempted
justification. The justification was considered and rejected on reasons which
cannot be termed irrational or arbitrary. No ground is made out for judicial
review.
26.
The writ petition is dismissed, along with pending application(s), if
any.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
FEBRUARY 5, 2026/as
W.P.(C) 11582/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 12/02/2026 at 14:04:07
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review