Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~48 & 49
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 25th April 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 981/2013
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Neerja Sachdeva, Advocate.
versus
SH RAJ SINGH & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Manish Maini, Ms. Aastha
Chauhan, Mr. R.K. Jain, Advocates
for Respondent no.1.
(49)
+
MAC.APP. 335/2014
SH RAJ SINGH & ORS
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Manish Maini, Ms. Aastha
Chauhan, Mr. R.K. Jain, Advocates.
versus
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD
.....Respondent
Through: Ms. Neerja Sachdeva, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
These cross-appeals have been filed challenging the Award dated 11 th
September 2013 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Dwarka
Courts, New Delhi (‘MACT’) in MACT No.32/2013. MAC.APP. 981/2013
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
has been filed by the Insurance Company seeking reduction of the
compensation, whereas MAC.APP. 335/2014 has been filed by claimant
seeking enhancement of compensation.
The accident occurred on 21st June 2012 at around 11: 25 PM, when the
2.
claimant driving his motorcycle bearing registration no.DL-1S-S-1223 near
Dwarka, New Delhi suffered a collision with the Maruti Swift car bearing
registration no.HR-26-AW-9912 (offending vehicle), driven by Mr. Devinder
Kumar. Claim petition was filed, which resulted in award of compensation of
Rs.24,02,832/- along with interest @7.5% from the date of filing of claim
petition till its realization.
3.
Ms. Sachdeva, on behalf of the insurance company, has raised the
following issues:
i.
While the Disability Certificate assessed disability at 60%, functional
disability was taken by the MACT at 70%.
ii.
Amount of Rs.80,000/- each was awarded towards cost of 2 prosthetic
and Rs.50,000/- for maintenance, whereas there is no evidence led in
that respect.
iii.
Rs. 50,000/- awarded towards agriculture income; however, there is no
evidence to support it. In fact, impugned order mentions that the
claimant was Head Constable in the Delhi Police and could not have
continued the agriculture work on his own.
iv.
Future prospects ought not to have been granted, since in paragraph
59 of the impugned award it had been noted that the Head Constable is
earning the same income as he was earning at the time of the accident.
4.
Mr. Manish Maini, counsel for the claimant, to counter these
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
submissions and canvass his plea for enhancement, places the following
submissions:
i.
Functional disability may be taken at 60%, considering that the
Disability Certificate itself certifies permanent disability at 60% with
respect to the whole body. Though there was an amputation of the right
limb below the knee.
ii.
As regards the prosthetic, he states that, as per the Supreme Court’s
judgment of Mohd. Sabeer v. U.P. SRTC (2023) 20 SCC 774, the
amount of Rs.80,000/- was awarded based on the evidence of PW8,
Shri Kapil Kaushik from M/s Endolite India Ltd., who stated that
Rs. 80,000/- are spent on the prosthetic, and the life of prosthetic is
about 7 to 8 years. He, therefore, stated that since the age of the injured
was 47 years of age at the time of accident, and keeping an average of
70 years of age as per Mohd. Sabeer (supra), he would be required a
prosthetic for about 23 years, and, therefore, with the life expectancy of
an artificial limb, 7 to 8 years, he would require 4 prosthetics in his
lifetime.
iii.
He seeks enhancement of the prosthetic repair amount from
Rs.50,000/- to Rs.1,00,000/- for four prosthetics.
iv.
He points out paragraph 63 of the impugned award, where the income
has been first deducted by 50% and then the disability of 70% has been
multiplied, which amounts to duplication in the reduction. He states
that the impugned order is erroneous in the matter of this calculation.
v.
The income of claimant should have been taken as Rs.31,629/-,
including the allowances on account of transport and ration money,
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
however, deducting the amounts on account of washing and
convenience allowance, which will not form part of his income.
Accordingly, he should be taken to have benchmark income of
Rs.31,479/-.
vi.
A multiplier of 9 has been suggested by Mr. Maini on the basis that
since he was in his job till retirement, but there would be loss of future
income since he could have been engaged as a security agency, a
multiplier of 9 ought to be taken on the benchmark income along with
future prospects of 30% to be calculated as per principles of National
Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680,
considering the age at the date of the accident of 47 years.
vii.
The enhancement of the non-pecuniary damages is pleaded on account
of pain and suffering, loss of amenities and disability. This has been
objected to by Ms. Sachdeva on the basis that the amounts awarded
were sufficient, considering the date of the accident was 2012.
However, Mr. Maini points out that, as per the decision in Mohd.
Sabeer (supra), where Rs. 2 lakhs were awarded on these accounts, the
accident had taken place in 2009, and, therefore, Ms. Sachdeva's
submissions may not be tenable.
5.
The Court has perused the record and has made an assessment on each
of these contentions raised by respective counsel as under:
5.1.
As regards the functional disability, which was taken at 70% despite
Disability Certificate certifying the permanent physical disability at 60%, the
MACT’s discussion in paragraph 60,61 and 63 is taken note of. Considering
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
it was a case of amputation of 1/3rd of the right lower limb, the injured was a
Head Constable in Police Department and no doubt physical fitness and
mobility was critical for proper service in the Police Department and for
further promotions as well. Therefore, the functional disability could have
been taken at 60% and not increased to 70% in terms of the Disability
Certificate and applying the principles of Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (2011) 1
SCC 343.
5.2.
As regards the amounts awarded for prosthetic including the
maintenance, Ms. Sachdeva challenges the testimony of PW8/Senior
Executive
(Material
Department),
M/s
Endolite
India
Ltd.
In
cross-examination, PW8 had stated that he had no knowledge about the
component of artificial limbs and had not taken any special training in any
institute. In response, Mr. Maini submits that the witness is from a reputed
company and has produced receipts of Rs. 80,000/-, based on which the
MACT computed compensation for the prosthetic limb, exhibited as Ex.
PW-8/1 and Ex. PW-8/2. The Court has perused the testimony of PW-8 and
finds no reason to disbelieve the stated expenditure, which is supported by the
receipts. In any event, in several decisions concerning prosthetics, higher
amounts have been awarded. Further, taking into consideration the decision
of the Supreme Court in Mohd. Sabeer (supra) and the age of the injured as
47 years, prosthetic replacement would be required for approximately 23
years. Considering a prosthetic lifespan of 7-8 years, the injured would
require at least four prosthetics. The MACT has awarded compensation for
only two prosthetics; accordingly, this is enhanced to Rs. 80,000/- each for
four prosthetics. The maintenance amount is also enhanced from Rs. 50,000/-
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
(for two prosthetics) to Rs. 1,00,000/- (for four prosthetics).
5.3.
As regards the addition of Rs. 50,000/- as a lump sum towards
agricultural income, the Court agrees with Ms. Sachdeva’s contention that
there is no evidence in this regard, as is evident from paragraph 57 of the
impugned award. The MACT appears to have added this amount on mere
speculation. Accordingly, the same is liable to be deleted from the
computation of compensation.
5.4.
On the issue of assessment of income, Mr. Maini contends that only
Washing Allowance and Conveyance Allowance ought to be deducted,
whereas Transport Allowance and Ration Money should not be deducted. The
Court is inclined to accept this submission in view of the decisions of the
Supreme Court in Manorma Sinha & Anr. v. The Divisional Manager,
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd & Anr. 2025 INSC 1237, Kavita Devi &
Ors. v. Sunil Kumar & Anr. 2025 INSC 938 and Meenakshi v. Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd., 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1872. The Supreme Court has
clearly held that income will include the various allowances which are part
and parcel of amounts which are for the benefit of the family and on which tax
has been paid. Accordingly, the benchmark income would be taken at
Rs.31,479/-.
5.5.
On the issue raised by Ms. Sachdeva that no future prospects ought to
be granted since the injured continued as a Head Constable, the law is well
settled that, for an injured person in public sector job, who would retire on
superannuation, post-retirement loss of income must be computed by
applying a multiplier of ‘9’, considering retirement at 60 years of age. In this
regard reliance may be made decisions of this Court in Desh Raj Singh
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
Gautam v. Sunil Kumar & Ors. 2016:DHC:4159, Rajbir Singh v. National
Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
2024:DHC:9034 and Govind Singh
Mauni v. Tej Bhan & Ors. 2026:DHC:1020. In fact, this Court in its
assessment in Govind Singh Mauni (supra), considered the issue of loss of
potentiality to earn post-retirement for which compensation must be taken
into account. Accordingly, future prospects at 30% should be granted since
the injured was 47 years of age at the time of accident for calculation of loss of
future income.
6.
Ms. Sachdeva further contends that the pension receivable
post-retirement ought to be deducted. However, this issue has been settled by
the Supreme Court in Hanumantharaju B (Dead) by LRs v. M. Akram
Pasha & Anr., 2025 INSC 682, wherein it has been categorically held in
paragraph 19 as under:
19. It is also now well settled that the amount of compensation
is to be calculated on the basis of last drawn salary of the
injured/deceased in respect of salaried persons and pension
and such retirement benefits enjoyed cannot be deducted for
computing the income, these being statutory rights receivable
by the employee or his legal heirs irrespective of any
unforeseen incident of accidents, fatal injuries etc. and such
pensionary benefit is not directly relatable to the motor
accident. Hence, pensionary benefit could not have been
treated as “pecuniary advantage” liable to be deducted for the
purpose of computation of compensation within the scope of
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. For this proposition of law, we may
refer to the decision in Vimal Kanwar & Ors. v. Kishore Dan &
Ors. (2013) 7 SCC 476, wherein this Court, by referring to the
earlier decision in Helen C. Rebello v. Maharashtra SRTC
(1999) 1 SCC 90, held as follows:“19. The aforesaid issue fell for consideration before this
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
Court in Helen C. Rebello v. Maharashtra SRTC [(1999)
1 SCC 90: 1999 SCC (Cri) 197]. In the said case, this
Court held that provident fund, pension, insurance and
similarly any cash, bank balance, shares, fixed deposits,
etc. are all a “pecuniary advantage” receivable by the
heirs on account of one's death but all these have no
correlation with the amount receivable under a statute
occasioned only on account of accidental death. Such an
amount will not come within the periphery of the Motor
Vehicles Act to be termed as “pecuniary advantage”
liable for deduction. The following was the observation
and finding of this Court: (SCC pp. 111-12, para 35)
“35. Broadly, we may examine the receipt of the
provident fund which is a deferred payment out of
the contribution made by an employee during the
tenure of his service. Such employee or his heirs are
entitled to receive this amount irrespective of the
accidental death. This amount is secured, is certain
to be received, while the amount under the Motor
Vehicles Act is uncertain and is receivable only on
the happening of the event viz. accident, which may
not take place at all. Similarly, family pension is
also earned by an employee for the benefit of his
family in the form of his contribution in the service
in terms of the service conditions receivable by the
heirs after his death. The heirs receive family
pension even otherwise than the accidental death.
No co-relation between the two. Similarly, life
insurance policy is received either by the insured or
the heirs of the insured on account of the contract
with the insurer, for which the insured contributes in
the form of premium. It is receivable even by the
insured if he lives till maturity after paying all the
premiums. In the case of death, the insurer
indemnifies to pay the sum to the heirs, again in
terms of the contract for the premium paid. Again,
this amount is receivable by the claimant not on
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
account of any accidental death but otherwise on
the insured's death. Death is only a step or
contingency in terms of the contract, to receive the
amount. Similarly, any cash, bank balance, shares,
fixed deposits, etc. though are all a pecuniary
advantage receivable by the heirs on account of
one's death but all these have no corelation with the
amount receivable under a statute occasioned only
on account of accidental death. How could such an
amount come within the periphery of the Motor
Vehicles Act to be termed as ‘pecuniary advantage’
liable for deduction. When we seek the principle of
loss and gain, it has to be on a similar and same
plane having nexus, inter se, between them and not
to which there is no semblance of any co-relation.
The insured (the deceased) contributes his own
money for which he receives the amount which has
no co-relation to the compensation computed as
against the tortfeasor for his negligence on account
of the accident. As aforesaid, the amount receivable
as compensation under the Act is on account of the
injury or death without making any contribution
towards it, then how can the fruits of an amount
received through contributions of the insured be
deducted out of the amount receivable under the
Motor Vehicles Act. The amount under this Act he
receives without any contribution. As we have said,
the compensation payable under the Motor Vehicles
Act is statutory while the amount receivable under
the life insurance policy is contractual.”
Thus, this Court has categorically held that any amount
receivable on account of PF, pension or insurance cannot be
deducted from the salary of the victim for the purpose of
determining the income or loss of earning for calculating
compensation. This principle was reiterated in Reliance
General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shashi Sharma & Ors. (2016) 9
SCC 627 and National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Birender &
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
Ors. (2020) 11 SCC 356.
(emphasis supplied)
7.
As regards pain & suffering, loss of amenities of life and loss due to
disfigurement, the MACT has already awarded Rs.1,00,000/- for each
component. These amounts are not being disturbed.
8.
Accordingly, the compensation is recomputed as under:
S. no
Heads of Compensation
Awarded by the
Court
Pecuniary Loss
1.
Expenditure on treatment (A)
Rs.1,05,772/-
2.
Expenditure on special diet (B)
Rs. 7,500/-
3.
Expenditure of conveyance and special Rs. 7,500/diet (C)
4.
Attendant Charges (D)
Rs. 21,060/-
5.
Income of injured per month (E)
Rs.31,479/-.
6.
Future prospects @ 30% (F)
Rs. 9,443.7/-
7.
Loss of income (G) 246 days
Rs. 2,58,128/(Rs. 1049.3 x 246)
8.
Functional disability (H)
60%
9.
Multiplier (I)
10.
Loss of future income
Rs. 26,51,791/-
[(E+F) x 12 x H x I]= J
11.
Agricultural Income
Nil
Non-Pecuniary Loss
12.
Pain and suffering (K)
Rs. 1,00,000/-
13.
Loss of Amenities of Life (L)
Rs. 1,00,000/-
14.
Disfigurement (M)
Rs. 1,00,000/-
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
15.
Total (A+B+C+D+G+J+K+L+M= N
Rs. 33,51,751/-
16.
Interest
7.5%
17.
Prosthetic Limb
Rs. 3,20,000/-
18.
Annual Maintenance
Rs.1,00,000/-
Directions
9.
The compensation granted by the Tribunal is Rs. 24,08,832/-. For the
aforesaid reasons, compensation has been enhanced by Rs. 9,42,919/-.
10.
By order dated 30th October 2013, this Court had passed directions for
deposit of entire compensation amount along with accrued interest before the
Registrar General of this Court and release of 50% of deposited amount in
favour of claimant, in terms of directions of MACT in the impugned award.
Balance amount along with accrued interest deposited with the Registrar
General of this Court shall be released to the claimant as per the directions of
MACT.
11.
Enhanced amount along with 7.5% interest per annum from the date of
filing the petition shall be deposited before MACT within a period of four
weeks. It is directed that a lump sum amount of Rs.3,00,000/- shall be
released to the claimant from the deposit of enhanced amount within a period
of two weeks thereafter. Remaining enhanced amount, along with accrued
interest, shall be kept in Fixed Deposit Receipts (FDRs) of Rs. 25,000/- each
for periods of 1 month, 2 months, 3 months and so on, in succession as maybe
calculated. Interest accruing on said FDRs shall be credited to the designated
Savings Bank Account of claimant. The amount of FDRs on maturity would
be released to the Savings Bank Account of claimant upon due verification.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
12.
The said amount for the prosthetic limb and annual maintenance will be
deposited by the Insurance Company within a period of four weeks before the
MACT which will be kept in an interest-bearing fixed deposit, the same will
be disbursed to the claimant only on production of original invoice/purchase
document issued by authorized seller of prosthetic limb. Further, cost towards
annual maintenance shall also be disbursed on production of invoice. If any
amounts remain unutilized, the Insurance Company will be entitled to
withdraw the same along with accrued interest.
13.
Appeals stand disposed of in above terms. Pending applications, if any,
are rendered infructuous.
14.
Copy of this judgement shall also be sent to concerned bank.
15.
Statutory deposit be refunded to the Insurance Company.
16.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
APRIL 25, 2026/ak/zb
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
18:40:11
MAC.APP. 981/2013 & MAC.APP. 335/2014
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review