Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~57 & 58
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 29.09.2026
(57)
#
CNR No. DLHC010470132026
+
LPA 798/2026, CM Nos.67694/2026 & 67695/2026
SMT NIRMALA DEVI GARG & ORS.
.....Appellants
Through: Dr. Anurag Kumar Agarwal, Mr.
Umesh Mishra and Ms. Surbhi Mittal,
Advs.
Versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Tushar Parashar, Panel Counsel,
Mr. Bhanu Pratap Singh Phore,
Advocate, with Mr. Raja Ram Meena,
AE, MCD
(58)
#
CNR No. DLHC010470162026
+
LPA 799/2026, CM Nos.67697/2026 & 67698/2026
SH NARAYAN PRASAD & ORS.
.....Appellants
Through: Dr. Anurag Kumar Agarwal, Mr.
Umesh Mishra and Ms. Surbhi Mittal,
Advs.
Versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Tushar Parashar, Panel Counsel,
Mr. Bhanu Pratap Singh Phore,
Advocate, with Mr. Raja Ram Meena,
AE, MCD
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:19:56
LPA 798/2026 & LPA 799/2026
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, J. (Oral)
CM No. 67695/2026 (Exemption) in LPA 798/2026
CM No. 67698/2026 (Exemption) in LPA 799/2026
1.
Exemptions are allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The Applications stand disposed of.
LPA 798/2026, CM No.67694/2026;
LPA 799/2026, CM No. 67697/2026
3.
Heard the learned counsel for the Parties.
4.
Since the facts and issues in these two Letter Patent Appeals are
intertwined, with the consent of the learned Counsels for the Parties, we
proceed to decide both the Appeals by the common Judgment, which
follows:5.
The subject matter of these appeals are two buildings situated
opposite each other, namely WP-489 and WP-531, Shiva Market, Wazirpur
Village, Ashok Vihar, Delhi – 110052.
6.
On the basis of visual inspection said to have been conducted by the
authorities of the MCD, two separate Orders, both dated 15.09.2026 were
passed by the Executive Engineer concerned on behalf of the Municipal
Commissioner directing the occupants of the buildings to vacate and
thereafter, demolish the same.
7.
The said Orders have purportedly been passed by the authority
concerned in exercise of its powers vested under Section 348 / 349 of the
Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 (“Act”). It has been stated by
learned Counsel for the Appellants that though Section 348 & 349 of the Act
vests power with the Commissioner or any other authority authorised by him
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:19:56
LPA 798/2026 & LPA 799/2026
in that behalf to pass an order vacating and also demolishing the dangerous
buildings, however, such order should be based on some relevant and
relatable material.
8.
His further submission is that so far as the instant cases are concerned,
the only material relied upon by the authorities of the MCD for passing the
order of demolition or vacation is some kind of a visual inspection of the
buildings, based on which it is allegedly reported that the buildings are in a
dilapidated and ruinous condition.
9.
Learned Counsel representing the MCD has, however, submitted that
the photographs appended with these appeals itself are testimony enough to
form an opinion that the building are in dilapidated and ruinous condition
and therefore, are liable to be removed. The submission thus is that the
authority concerned while passing the order of demolition has exercised its
powers available to it statutorily under Section 348 / 349 of the Act and
therefore, no fault can be found in the same.
10.
We have considered the respective submission made by the Counsels
for the Parties.
11.
Section 348 of the Act vests power in the Commissioner of the
Municipal Corporation to require the owner or occupier of any building to
demolish or secure or repair, in case he forms an opinion that the building is
in ruinous condition or is likely to fall or in anyway dangerous to any person
occupying, resorting to or passing by such building.
12.
The provisions of Sub-Section 2 of Section 348 of the Act clearly
provides that the concerned authority of the Municipal Corporation can
direct the occupier or owner of the said building to secure or repair the
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:19:56
LPA 798/2026 & LPA 799/2026
building or to set up a proper and sufficient hoard or fence for the protection
of passers-by and other persons, with a convenient platform and handrail
wherever practicable.
13.
Certain other powers have also been vested in the authorities of
Municipal Corporation under Section 348 for removal of the dangerous
buildings. Section 348 of the Act reads as under:“348. Removal of dangerous buildings
(1) If it appears to the Commissioner at any time that any
building is in a ruinous condition, or likely to fall, or in any
way dangerous to any person occupying, resorting to or
passing by such building or any other building or place in the
neighbourhood of such building, the Commissioner may, by
order in writing, require the owner or occupier of such building
to demolish, secure or repair such building or do one or more
of such things within such period as may be specified in the
order, so as to prevent all cause of danger therefrom.
(2) The Commissioner may also, it he thinks fit, require such
owner or occupier by the said order either forthwith or before
proceeding to demolish, secure or repair the building, to set up
a proper and sufficient hoard or fence for the protection of
passers-by and other persons, with a convenient platform and
handrail wherever practicable to serve as a foot-way for
passengers outside of such board or fence.
(3) If it appears to the Commissioner that danger from a
building which is in a ruinous condition or likely to fall is
imminent, he may, before making the order aforesaid, fence off,
demolish, secure or repair the said building or take such steps
as may be necessary to prevent the danger.
(4) If the owner or occupier of the building does not comply
with the order within the period specified therein, the
Commissioner shall take such steps in relation to the building
as to prevent all cause of danger therefrom.
(5) All expenses incurred by the Commissioner in relation to
any building under this section shall be recoverable from the
owner or occupier thereof as an arrear of tax under this Act.”
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:19:56
LPA 798/2026 & LPA 799/2026
14.
Similarly, Section 349 of the Act vests power in the Commissioner or
any other Officer authorised on his behalf to vacate the building in certain
circumstances. The order of vacation can be passed in a situation where the
building, in the opinion of the authority concerned, is in a dangerous
condition or is not provided with sufficient egress in case of fire or is
occupied in contravention of the provisions of Section 346. The Proviso
appended to Section 349 of the Act makes it mandatory for the
Commissioner to record a brief statement of reasons for vacation.
15.
When we peruse the Order of demolition/vacation, which was
challenged before the learned Single Judge in proceedings of the respective
Writ petitions, what we find is that the only reason indicated in the said
orders is that on visual inspection, the buildings in question were found to be
in dilapidated and dangerous condition.
16.
Recording of reasons in support of any direction, which needs to be
issued by the authorities under Section 348 / 349 of the Act does not mean
that such reasons should be based on no material at all or on unrelatable and
irrelevant material. Any opinion formed by the authorities for passing an
order of demolition or vacation under Section 348 / 349 of the Act based on
a visual or virtual inspection without getting some kind of structural audit or
structural inspection conducted by the persons having technical knowledge,
in our opinion, cannot be said to be either relatable or relevant.
17.
Accordingly, it is difficult for us to find ourselves in agreement with
the reasons given by the authorities concerned for passing the order of
demolition/vacation of buildings in question.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:19:56
LPA 798/2026 & LPA 799/2026
18.
However, having observed as above, we cannot ignore the condition
of the buildings, which is apparent from a bare perusal of the photographs of
the said buildings enclosed with these appeals.
19.
Learned counsel for the Appellants himself has stated that so far as
the structure in the same building on the first and second floor are
concerned, they are in not in a safe condition and prima facie appear to be
dangerous.
20.
In view of the aforesaid facts, we are of the opinion that proceeding
under Section 348 and 349 of the Act needs to be drawn afresh by the Delhi
Municipal Corporation, however, for the said purpose, they need to collect
relevant material, if they have to pass any order of removal or vacation of
the building.
21.
In view of what has been observed by us above, we dispose of the
instant appeals with the following directions:(a)
The Municipal Corporation of Delhi shall get the structural
data/inspection of the buildings in question conducted within two
days by some experts, to be engaged by them.
(b)
The experts should, accordingly furnish their report within three
days, which shall be furnished to all the Appellants within a day
thereafter, whereupon it will be open to the Appellants either
personally or through their own technical representative to file
objection to report of the structural audit of the inspection.
(c)
The Appellants shall have two days’ time to respond to such
report, thereafter, within two further days, the final decision in the
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:19:56
LPA 798/2026 & LPA 799/2026
matter would be taken by the Commissioner or any other Officer
authorised on his behalf under Section 348 / 349 of the Act.
(d)
We further direct that the report of the technical audit / inspection
shall be served upon Dr. Anurag Kumar Agarwal, Advocate,
representing the Appellants by the MCD. The service of the report
of the technical audit on the learned Counsel will be deemed to be
service on the Appellants, who shall participate in the proceedings
further as directed above.
(e)
The shops existing in these two buildings on the ground floor will
not be operated by the Appellants from today till the final decision
is taken by the competent authority of the MCD under this Order.
Any violation of this condition would be viewed seriously by the
Court and may amount to contempt of this Court.
(f)
On conclusion of the process as aforesaid, if any order of
demolition / removal is passed against the Appellants and they
feel aggrieved, it will be open to them to take recourse any legal
remedy as available to them under law.
(g)
We further direct that while considering the report of technical
audit / inspection and the submissions in respect thereof on behalf
of the Appellants, the appropriate decision will be taken by the
Authorities of the MCD, which may be, if facts and circumstances
so require, an order for repair and taking steps for strengthening
the building as well.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:19:56
LPA 798/2026 & LPA 799/2026
22.
The impugned order dated 24.09.2026 passed by the learned Single
Judge in WP(C) Nos. 14108/2026 and 14111/2026 stands modified in the
aforesaid terms.
23.
In view of the aforesaid and on the request of learned Counsel for the
Parties WP(C) Nos. 14108/2026 and 14111/2026 are also finally disposed
of. Let a copy of this order be placed on the aforesaid Writ Petitions by the
office. The date already fixed in the Writ Petitions i.e. 01.10.2026 stands
cancelled.
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
TEJAS KARIA, J
SEPTEMBER 29, 2026/ss
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
18:19:56
LPA 798/2026 & LPA 799/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review