Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 28th January 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 579/2013
SH DURVESH KUMAR
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. S.N. Parashar and Mr. Ritik Singh,
Advs.
versus
SH HARPAL & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Vandana Kahlon and Mr. Rudra
Kahlon, Advs. for R-3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J: (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed seeking enhancement of the compensation
awarded by the impugned award dated 15th February 2013 by the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal (‘MACT’) in MACT No.34/2011, whereby a total
compensation of Rs.11,81,930/- along with interest @ 7.5% per annum was
awarded.
2.
The accident occurred on 25th October 2010 due to the rash and
negligent driving of the offending truck driven by respondent no.1 (driver).
The appellant suffered grievous injuries resulting in amputation of the left leg
and suffered 85% permanent disability with respect to left lower limb.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
15:30:27
MAC.APP. 579/2013
1 of 8
3.
Mr. S.N. Parashar, counsel appearing for the appellant/claimant, places
his contentions seeking enhancement on the three counts.
4.
Firstly, it is contended that the functional disability ought to have been
assessed at 100% instead of 50%, as assessed by the impugned award,
considering that the appellant was working as a Manager at Kaleva Sweets
and could not continue in employment thereafter. He relies on the decision of
the Supreme Court in Anthony v. Managing Director, Karnataka State Road
Transport Corporation (2020) 7 SCC 161, wherein 75% physical disability
had been reduced to 25% by the High Court; however, the Supreme Court set
aside the said finding and held that the appellant was entitled to compensation
based on 75% permanent physical disability.
5.
To this, counsel for respondent/Insurance Company states that
appellant had already been granted Rs.2,58,150/- towards the provision of an
artificial limb, the quotation for which has been placed on record. Therefore,
the question of 85% disability with respect to complete loss of functionality
and earning capacity ought not to be entertained.
6.
Counsel for appellant contends that while deciding the issue of
functional disability, no reasoning or assessment has been given by the
MACT, as can be noticed from paragraph 35 of the impugned award.
7.
Reliance placed by counsel for the appellant on the decision of the
Supreme Court in Anthony (supra) may not be apposite, considering that
Anthony (supra) pertained to a painter engaged in manual labour.
8.
In the present case, as contended by the appellant, he was working as a
Manager at Kaleva Sweets. However, it is also noted that during the crossexamination of the injured/claimant as PW-1, he admitted that he did not
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
15:30:27
MAC.APP. 579/2013
2 of 8
possess any documentary proof to show that he was in employment or of his
income as on the date of the accident. Though, he did not deny that he was
not working for Kaleva Sweets on the date of the accident.
9.
In this scenario, even if it is assumed that the appellant was working as
a Manager at Kaleva Sweets, though not proved, the claim of 100% functional
disability cannot be sustained or permitted. There is no assertion on behalf of
appellant that he was involved in a manual or labour work.
10.
To the contrary, he was, at best, working in a managerial capacity,
which would require some movement but not extensive mobility.
11.
In Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (2011) 1 SCC 343, the Supreme Court
held that the Tribunal must assess not merely the extent of permanent
disability but its actual impact on the claimant’s earning capacity, which may
differ from the medical percentage of disability. This requires evaluating the
claimant’s pre-accident vocation, the functions affected, and whether
livelihood can still be earned despite the disability. The Court emphasized that
disability and loss of earning capacity are distinct concepts, except in cases
where evidence shows they coincide. Relevant paragraphs are extracted as
under:
“11. What requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is the
effect of the permanent disability on the earning capacity
of the injured; and after assessing the loss of earning
capacity in terms of a percentage of the income, it has to
be quantified in terms of money, to arrive at the future loss
of earnings (by applying the standard multiplier method
used to determine loss of dependency). We may however
note that in some cases, on appreciation of evidence and
assessment, the Tribunal may find that the percentage of
loss of earning capacity as a result of the permanent
disability, is approximately the same as the percentage of
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
15:30:27
MAC.APP. 579/2013
3 of 8
permanent disability in which case, of course, the
Tribunal will adopt the said percentage for determination
of compensation. (See for example, the decisions of this
Court in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New India Assurance
Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC 254 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1258 :
(2010) 10 Scale 298] and Yadava Kumar v. National
Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC 341 : (2010) 3 SCC
(Cri) 1285 : (2010) 8 Scale 567] )
12. Therefore, the Tribunal has to first decide whether
there is any permanent disability and, if so, the extent of
such permanent disability. This means that the Tribunal
should consider and decide with reference to the evidence:
(i) whether the disablement is permanent or temporary;
(ii) if the disablement is permanent, whether it is
permanent total disablement or permanent partial
disablement;
(iii) if the disablement percentage is expressed with
reference to any specific limb, then the effect of such
disablement of the limb on the functioning of the entire
body, that is, the permanent disability suffered by the
person.
If the Tribunal concludes that there is no permanent
disability then there is no question of proceeding further
and determining the loss of future earning capacity. But if
the Tribunal concludes that there is permanent disability
then it will proceed to ascertain its extent. After the
Tribunal ascertains the actual extent of permanent
disability of the claimant based on the medical evidence,
it has to determine whether such permanent disability has
affected or will affect his earning capacity.
13. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent disability
on the actual earning capacity involves three steps. The
Tribunal has to first ascertain what activities the claimant
could carry on in spite of the permanent disability and
what he could not do as a result of the permanent
disability (this is also relevant for awarding compensation
under the head of loss of amenities of life). The second step
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
15:30:27
MAC.APP. 579/2013
4 of 8
12.
is to ascertain his avocation, profession and nature of
work before the accident, as also his age. The third step is
to find out whether (i) the claimant is totally disabled from
earning any kind of livelihood, or (ii) whether in spite of
the permanent disability, the claimant could still
effectively carry on the activities and functions, which he
was earlier carrying on, or (iii) whether he was prevented
or restricted from discharging his previous activities and
functions, but could carry on some other or lesser scale of
activities and functions so that he continues to earn or can
continue to earn his livelihood.”
(emphasis added)
In Raj Kumar (supra), the Court summarized the principles, which are
extracted as under:
“19. We may now summarise the principles discussed
above:
(i) All injuries (or permanent disabilities arising from
injuries), do not result in loss of earning capacity.
(ii) The percentage of permanent disability with reference
to the whole body of a person, cannot be assumed to be
the percentage of loss of earning capacity. To put it
differently, the percentage of loss of earning capacity is
not the same as the percentage of permanent disability
(except in a few cases, where the Tribunal on the basis of
evidence, concludes that the percentage of loss of earning
capacity is the same as the percentage of permanent
disability).
(iii) The doctor who treated an injured claimant or who
examined him subsequently to assess the extent of his
permanent disability can give evidence only in regard to
the extent of permanent disability. The loss of earning
capacity is something that will have to be assessed by the
Tribunal with reference to the evidence in entirety.
(iv) The same permanent disability may result in different
percentages of loss of earning capacity in different
persons, depending upon the nature of profession,
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
15:30:27
MAC.APP. 579/2013
5 of 8
occupation or job, age, education and other factors.”
(emphasis added)
13.
Considering the observation made by the Supreme Court in Raj Kumar
(supra) and the facts of the present case, at best the assessment of functional
disability could be increased marginally to 60%, but not beyond that.
14.
This is also in the context that the appellant was awarded compensation
for an artificial limb, from which he may have derived benefit, and therefore,
in that scenario the reduction of the earning capacity would have been
somewhat mitigated.
15.
The second issue raised by Mr. Parashar, counsel for the appellant,
relates to attendant charges, which have not been granted, despite that PW-1
having stated in his affidavit of evidence that he had engaged an attendant at
Rs.3,000/- per month for ten months.
16.
Counsel for the respondent/Insurance Company contends that even in
the cross-examination no other evidence was produced by PW-1 regarding
the engagement of an attendant.
17.
However, this Court notes that in the cross-examination he denied the
specific suggestion given that he had not incurred any amount on the
attendant.
18.
It is admitted by counsels for parties that the injured/appellant was in
hospital for two months.
19.
Considering that he may have required the attendant for those two
months and may be a few months subsequently, the attendant charges can be
awarded to him for six months at Rs.3,000/- per month.
20.
Moreover, the Supreme Court in the case of Ningamma v. United India
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
15:30:27
MAC.APP. 579/2013
6 of 8
Insurance Co. Ltd. (2009) 13 SCC 710 has held that the Court is duty-bound
to award just compensation, even if the same has not been specifically pleaded
by the claimant. The relevant part of the judgment is extracted as under:
21.
“25.....Needless to say, the MVA is beneficial and welfare
legislation. In fact, the court is duty bound and entitled to
award “Just Compensation” irrespective of the fact
whether any plea in that behalf was raised by the claimant
or not......”
(emphasis added)
The third issue, which has been raised, pertains to application of the
multiplier of 14 instead of 15, even though the appellant was 40 years and 3
months of age at the time of the accident.
22.
In terms of the tabulation provided in Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6
SCC 121, the multiplier applicable would be 15 in the category of 35 years to
40 years.
23.
Accordingly, the same shall also stand corrected.
24.
The revised computation, therefore, is as under:
Sr. Heads of compensation
No.
Medical Expenses
Cost of nursing / attendant
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs. 73,226/-
50%
Awarded by this
Court
Rs. 73,226/Rs. 3,000 X 6 =
Rs. 18,000/60%
Rs. 42,120/Rs. 2,106
Rs. 1,09,512/14
Rs. 7,66,584/Rs.3,00,000/Rs. 11,81,930/-
Rs. 42,120/Rs. 2,106
Rs. 1,09,512/15
Rs. 9,85,608/Rs.3,00,000/Rs. 14,18,954/-
Percentage of loss of earning capacity
in relation to disability
Loss of income (Rs.7,020/- X 6)
Future Prospect @ 30% of Rs.7,020/Annual income (Rs.9,126/- X 12)
Multiplier
Loss of future income
Non-pecuniary loss
Total compensation
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
15:30:27
MAC.APP. 579/2013
7 of 8
25.
Interest awarded
Enhanced compensation
7.5% per annum
Rs. 2,37,024/-
7.5% per annum
The enhanced amount shall be deposited before the MACT within 4
weeks and be disbursed to the claimant within two weeks thereafter, in terms
of the directions of the MACT along with interest.
26.
Copy of the judgment be sent to the MACT for further directions in
terms of the re-computation.
27.
List before the MACT on 03rd March 2026.
28.
Appeal stands disposed of with above directions. Pending applications,
if any, are rendered infructuous.
29.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to appellant.
30.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL, J
JANUARY 28, 2026/mk/bp
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
15:30:27
MAC.APP. 579/2013
8 of 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review