Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 15th May, 2026
Pronounced on: 04th August, 2026
%
#
CNR No : DLHC01073320202
+
RSA 185/2024, CM APPL. 62837/2024 & 27158/2026
1.
SH. BRIJ RAJ
S/o Sh. Chand Babu
2.
SMT. RENU RAJ
W/o Sh. Brij Raj
Both R/o H.No.201,
Ground Floor,
MIG Flats (Metro Apartments)
Jahangir Puri, Delhi-110033.
.....Appellants
Through:
Mr. Aftab Husain and Ms. Anita
Advocates.
versus
SH. CHAND BABU
S/o Late Sh. Ram Chander
R/o H.No.201, Ground Floor,
MIG Flats (Metro Apartments),
Jahangir Puri, Delhi-110033.
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Puneet Kumar, Mr. Vipul Kumar,
Mr. Rakesh Kumar and Ms. Taniya,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
JUDGMENT
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 185/2024
1.
Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 CPC has been filed against
the Judgment dated 01.08.2024, whereby the learned District Judge has
upheld the Judgment dated 27.05.2023, whereby the learned Civil Judge
has decreed the Suit of the Plaintiff/Respondent (Sh. Brij Raj and Smt. Renu
Raj) for Mandatory Injunction directing the Defendants/Appellants to
hand over the Possession of the property to the Plaintiff but denied the
claim for User/Occupation Charges against the Appellants.
2.
The Suit No.36255/2016 was filed by the Plaintiff/Respondent for
Permanent and Mandatory Injunction.
3.
This is a case where the Plaintiff’s father, Sh. Chand Babu who is the
owner of the property bearing House No.201, Ground Floor, MIG Flats
(Metro Apartments), Jahangir Puri, Delhi- 110033 (hereinafter referred to as
‘Suit Property’) has permitted Defendant No.1 Sh. Brij Raj, his son and Smt.
Renu Raj, daughter in law, to reside in one room of the suit property out of
love and affection after their marriage which took place on 28.01.2012.
4.
However, the Plaintiff has averred that from December 2014 onwards,
the Defendants' conduct towards him became increasingly hostile and
disrespectful, and that they failed to provide him with the care and support
required in his old age. In the month of June,2015 the Defendants threatened
to dispossess him from the suit property.
5.
Consequently, he terminated their right to stay in the property vide
Legal Notice dated 13.07.2015 and thereafter, filed a Suit for Mandatory
Injunction directing the Defendants to hand over the Possession of the suit
property and also for future damages @ Rs.5,000/- per month w.e.f
01.08.2015 till the delivery of Possession.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 185/2024
6.
The Defendants in their Written Statements claimed that the Plaintiff
was not the absolute owner as an amount of Rs.2 lakhs was given by
Defendant No.2 to the Plaintiff, who had assured that he would get the Sale
Deed executed in his favour. The Defendants further claimed that a huge
portion of money was given by Defendant No.1 for the maintenance and
other expenses for the house, thereby making Defendant No.1 a co-sharer in
the property.
7.
The claim of atrocities which have been committed by Defendant
No.2 after marriage on the Plaintiff, were denied. It was claimed that
Defendant No.2 had made a Complaint in CAW Cell, which was eventually
settled. It was asserted that the Suit was liable to be dismissed.
8.
The Plaintiff in the Replication re-affirmed the assertions made in the
Plaint and denied the averments made in the Written Statement.
9.
The Issues were framed on 01.06.2017 as under:
(i)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the decree of
mandatory injunction, as prayed for? OPP
(ii)
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the decree of
damages, as prayed for? OPP
(iii)
10.
Relief.
The Plaintiff examined himself as PW1 and proved the documents
Ex.PW1/1 to Ex.PW1/10 which is the Allotment Letter (dated 09.09.1996)
of the suit property, Water Bills etc. in support of his case.
11.
The Defendants despite multiple opportunities, failed to produce any
evidence, which was closed vide Order dated 27.03.2023.
12.
The learned Civil Judge on appreciation of the evidence, observed
that admittedly, the property had been purchased by the Plaintiff’s father
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 185/2024
(Sh. Chand Babu) which was evident from the Allotment Letter and the
Receipt of deposit of Rs.40218.43/- to establish his ownership.
13.
Defendant No.1 claimed to be a co-owner, but failed to adduce any
evidence. The right of daughter-in-law/Defendant No.2 Smt. Renu Raj of
residence in shared household was considered in extenso and it was
concluded that the relationship between the parties was established to be
hostile.
From the pleadings of the parties, and the evidence of the
respondent, it was established that there was no indefeasible right of
daughter-in-law to live in the suit premises.
14.
Accordingly, Suit for Mandatory Injunction was allowed and the
Defendants were directed to handover the peaceful vacant Possession of the
property within one month.
However, on consideration of the entire
evidence and the relationship between the parties, it was held that the
Plaintiff was not entitled to any Damages.
15.
Aggrieved by this Judgment and Decree, the Defendants had preferred
the First Regular Appeal, under Section 96 read with Section 41 CPC.
16.
The learned District Judge on re-appreciation observed that according
to the Appellant, the Complaint in CAW Cell against both the father-in-law
and mother-in-law was compromised, although this Compromise was never
brought on record. Even otherwise, no evidence was led by the Defendants
in support of their case. Though the defendant No.1, the son had claimed
that he had contributed Rs.2 lakhs for purchase of the property, but no
evidence was led in this regard.
17.
The learned Appellate Court concurred with the findings of the
learned Trial Court including that in respect the right of the daughter-in-law
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 185/2024
to reside in the house of the father-in-law. Finding no merit in the Appeal, it
was dismissed vide Order dated 01.08.2024.
18.
Aggrieved by the dismissal of the Appeal, the present Second
Regular Appeal has been preferred.
19.
The grounds of challenge are that the Learned Trial Court failed to
appreciate the existence of a domestic relationship between the Appellants
and the Respondents, as recognized by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Prabha Tyagi v. Kamlesh Devi, wherein it was held that when parties are
residing together, then they are held to be in domestic relationship.
20.
Furthermore, it has not been appreciated that the suit property was
the shared household, where the Appellant No.2/Defendant No.2 had come
to reside after the marriage and she has a right of residence, irrespective of
the ownership of property in favour of the Respondent/father-in-law.
21.
It was claimed that the learned Civil Judge has failed to appreciate the
defence of the Appellants that they had contributed Rs.2 lakhs in the
purchase of the suit property and that the Respondent/Plaintiff had assured
of getting the Sale Deed executed in his favour.
22.
It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned Judgment and Decree be
set aside.
Submissions heard and record perused.
23.
There is no challenge to the basic facts involved in the case that the
father who is admittedly the owner of the suit property, had permitted the
Appellants who are the son and daughter-in-law in one room of his flat, but
on account of their cruel conduct, was compelled to terminate the
permissible user and occupation, vide Legal Notice dated 13.07.2015.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 185/2024
24.
Admittedly, the Appellants had no legal right to continue in the
property, once the permission was withdrawn by the father. Frivolous
ground was taken by the Appellants that the Appellant No.1 had paid Rs.2
lakhs towards the purchase of the suit property, but it is bereft of any
evidence; in-fact no evidence whatsoever, was led by the Appellants. It has
been rightly concluded by the learned Civil Judge and upheld by learned
District Judge that there was no proof any contribution by the Appellants
and that the Respondent the father was the absolute owner of the suit
property.
25.
The second aspect was in regard to the right of the daughter-in-law to
reside in the property. Reference is made to the Judgment of Prabha Tyagi
(supra), wherein the right of the daughter-in-law to reside in the property of
father-in-law, was considered in detail. The Apex Court has recognized the
right of daughter-in-law to stay in the shared household, even if she has no
right, title or interest in the property.
However, in the case of Satish
Chander Ahuja vs. Sneha Ahuja (2021) 1 SCC 414 it has been explained
that the right of daughter-in-law is not indefeasible and the only caveat is
that she can be dispossessed, only in accordance with law. The distinction
was also made in respect of the daughter-in-law whose husband has died and
that whose husband was still alive.
26.
It has been rightly held that the Appellants can claim no right to
continue in the property of the father, once he had withdrawn his permission
from them to continue to reside in the premises. The aforesaid discussion
reflects that the challenge is only to the facts which beyond the scope of
Second Regular Appeal. No Substantial Question of Law has emerged in
this Second Regular Appeal, which is hereby dismissed.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 185/2024
27.
The pending Applications are disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
AUGUST 04, 2026
va
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 185/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review