Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 30th January 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 567/2013
SH BALVINDER SINGH & ORS
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Manish Maini, Ms. Astha
Chauhan, Advocates.
versus
SH NASURULA & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Ravi Sabharwal, Mr. Vivan Garg,
Advocates for Respondent no.3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J: (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed seeking enhancement of compensation
awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (‘MACT’) by award passed
on 16 th February 2013 in Claim Petition No.14/2010. The compensation was
granted at Rs.10,39,944/- along with interest @ 7.5% per annum to the
husband of deceased (Sh. Balvinder Singh) and appellant nos.2 & 3/children
of the deceased.
2.
The accident occurred on 15 th October 2009 at about 11:15 P.M.,
when the deceased was travelling on a motorcycle along with her
husband/appellant no.1; when they reached Patparganj Road, Geeta Colony,
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:46:03
MAC.APP. 567/2013
1 of 7
Delhi, a truck bearing registration No. DL-1LG-2139 driven by respondent
no.1/Sh. Nasurula, in rash and negligent manner, hit the motorcycle. The
deceased fell on the road and was run over by the wheel of the truck.
Subsequently, she succumbed to injuries on 18 th October 2009.
3.
In the assessment of claim filed by the husband and the legal heirs, the
MACT in determination of Issue no.2 arrived at a finding that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of respondent no.1 (driver).
4.
As regards the compensation, there are three issues which are asserted
by Mr. Manish Maini, counsel for appellant. The first issue is that despite
Income Tax Return (‘ITR’) of assessment year 2009-10 being brought on
record which showed that the income of the deceased as Rs.1,99,658/- per
annum, the same was disregarded by MACT for lack of supporting
documents to ITR filed. The MACT, instead, used minimum wages of nonmatriculate as the benchmark income.
5.
Counsel for respondent has, however, drawn attention to the
testimony of Sh. Balvinder Singh (PW-1/husband of deceased), where in his
cross-examination, he stated that deceased/wife had an embroidery factory
located at 407 Jheel Khuranja, Delhi and he himself was working in a
factory doing embroidery work located at 407-A Jheel Khuranja, Delhi. He
stated that it is not the same factory which is run by his wife. He was unable
to give the names of either of the factories, or provide any bills, or any
document in that regard. He asserted that the factory was for embroidery
work and no licence had been taken in this regard. He denied the suggestion
that both are the same factory.
6.
Further, during cross-examination of PW-1 recorded on 29 th February
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:46:03
MAC.APP. 567/2013
2 of 7
2012, he placed some cash memos issued by Anjaneyay Textiles to his wife
for cloth purchased for her firm, though there were no bills or invoices
against the cash memo.
7.
Counsel for respondent no.3/Insurance Company states that this
testimony was recorded in November 2012 after more than one and a half
years of the initial testimony and the cash memos produced were without
any supporting evidence and therefore, could not have been considered. The
MACT was right in considering the benchmark income as that of minimum
wages of a non-matriculate.
8.
The second issue relates to the reimbursement of medical expenses
incurred. Bills to the tune of Rs.3,60,605/- were raised by the hospital, which
as per the claimant were paid in cash, since the medical insurance repudiated
on account of original bills not being provided to Vipul Medicore Pvt. Ltd
(TPA). In this regard, Mr. Maini points out to the statement made by Mr.
Yogesh (Assistant) who had appeared on behalf of Medi-claim on 3 rd
November 2011 before the MACT, where he stated that the claim submitted
was rejected on 30 th September 2010 on the ground that the original Mediclaim policy was not furnished.
Analysis
9.
Having considered the submissions of parties, it is noted that there is
complete absence of any documentation provided by PW-1 regarding the
name of the factory run by his wife, or any other transactional document like
cash memos, invoices, bills, purchase documents, etc. The fact is that the
two factories, as asserted by PW-1, were adjacent to each other located at
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:46:03
MAC.APP. 567/2013
3 of 7
407 and 407 A, Jheel Khuranja, Delhi. Since both were doing embroidery
work, it does seem that the business income was split between the husband
and wife, though the embroidery work would have been carried out in
adjacent units.
10.
Thus, the Court would have to consider whether the income as
declared by wife as Rs.1,99,658/- per annum for the Assessment Year 200910 should be taken in full to her benefit or not. It is noted that the passbook
of deceased wife which was furnished by PW-1 also noted that her
occupation was “housewife”.
11.
However, taking a broader view in the matter and assessing the
evidence on record, the Court is of the view that some reasonable income
ought to be considered, taking into account the contribution of wife to the
embroidery work that seemingly both husband and wife were involved in. It
could very well be that the income of the collective unit was being split into
two business entities for better tax management.
12.
Therefore, the Court is of the view that a reasonable income allocated
to the wife would be Rs.12,000/- per month, which would amount to about
Rs.1,44,000/- per annum grossly. In this regard, the Court takes support of
judgment of Supreme Court in K. Ramya & Ors. V National Insurance Co.
Ltd. & Anr., 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1338 where the Supreme Court held that
even if the deceased was not working but had a potential to earn money
basis their managerial skills, some reasonable income ought to be allocated
to that person.
13.
In this regard, one must also take into account the Profit & Loss
statement appended along with the ITR, which shows that there were entries
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:46:03
MAC.APP. 567/2013
4 of 7
of Opening Stock, Purchases, Labour Charges, Salary and other expense,
whereas the entries towards income was through Sales and Job-work. There
is clearly some evidence of business being run in which the wife participated
despite no other evidence.
14.
The third issue relates to reimbursement of medical expenses. Having
considered the statement recorded on behalf of the Medi-claim Officer that
insurance claim had been rejected on 30 th September 2010, the testimony of
PW-1 and PW-2 must be considered.
15.
The MACT records in paragraph 31 of the impugned award that PW-
2, Sh. Naveen Kumar (Medical Record In-charge, Max Balaji Hospital),
who had produced the entire medical record including discharge summary
and medical bills, stated that the hospital raised the bills to the tune of
Rs.3,60,605/- against the treatment provided and “entire bill was paid in
cash”. Therefore, the MACT was amiss basis this evidence on record to
have rejected the claim for reimbursement of the hospital bills.
Conclusion
16.
Accordingly, the claimants are entitled to enhancement of
compensation by taking the benchmark income of the deceased as
Rs.12,000/- per month instead of minimum wages. The claimants are also
entitled to reimbursement of the medical expenses incurred to the tune of
Rs.3,60,605/-. Further, the other heads of compensation are required to be
aligned with the principles laid down in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680.
17.
Since the deceased was 32-33 years old at the time of death and was
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:46:03
MAC.APP. 567/2013
5 of 7
self-employed, he is entitled to 40% towards future prospects and a
deduction of one-third towards personal expenses considering a family of
three. Conventional heads such as loss of consortium, loss of estate, and
funeral expenses are also to be aligned in terms of Pranay Sethi (supra).
Compensation awarded under the head of loss of love and affection shall be
nil, in view of the law laid down in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Satinder Kaur, (2021) 11 SCC 780.
18.
The re-computation is as under:
S.no. Heads of Compensation
Awarded by
the Tribunal
Awarded by
this Court
1.
2.
3.
Rs. 4,146/Rs. 1,036/Nil
Rs. 12,000/Rs. 4,800/Rs. 5,600/-
Rs. 5,182/-
Rs. 11,200/-
5.
Loss of income per month (A)
Future Prospects @40% (B)
Less Personal expenses of the deceased
(C) 1/3rd
Monthly Loss of Dependency (A+BC=D)
Annual loss of dependency (D x 12=E)
Rs. 62,184/-
Rs. 1,34,400/-
6.
Multiplier (F)
7.
Total loss of dependency (E x F = G)
Rs.9,94,944/-
Rs.21,50,400/-
8.
Medical expenses (H)
Nil
Rs. 3,60,605/-
9.
Compensation for loss of consortium
(I)
Rs.10,000/-
Rs. 1,20,000/-
10.
Compensation for loss of love and
affection (J)
Rs. 25,000/-
Nil
11.
Compensation for loss of estate (K)
Nil
Rs. 15,000/-
12.
Compensation towards funeral
expenses (L)
Rs.10,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
4.
(Rs.40,000x3)
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:46:03
MAC.APP. 567/2013
6 of 7
13.
Total compensation
Rs.10,39,944/- Rs.26,61,005/-
(G+H+I+J+K+L = M)
14.
Rate of Interest Awarded
7.5%
7.5%
Directions
19.
Accordingly, enhanced amount will be deposited by the Insurance
Company within a period of 6 weeks from today, before the MACT. The
same shall be released by the MACT as per its directions.
20.
List before the MACT, East District, Karkardooma Courts on 12th
March 2026. Copy of the order be sent to the concerned MACT.
21.
Recovery rights granted to the Insurance Company by the impugned
award to recover the compensation from respondent nos.1 & 2 have not been
challenged. Therefore, they stand sustained.
22.
Appeal stands disposed of with above directions.
23.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
24.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to the appellant.
25.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL, J
JANUARY 30, 2026/ak/zb
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:46:03
MAC.APP. 567/2013
7 of 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review