Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010445922025
2026:CGHC:26527-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 2140 of 2025
Semal Deepak S/o Late Semal Ramesh Aged About 32 Years R/o Ward No.
08, Ambedkar Para, Konta, District Sukma, Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
versus
Union Of India Through N.I.A. Branch Raipur, C.G.
... Respondent
For Appellant
:
Mr. Somkant Verma and Mr. Manoj
Chouhan, Advocates
For Respondent/UOI
:
Mr. B. Gopa Kumar, Advocate along with
Ms. Navya Gopan and Mr. Ayush Bhatt,
Advocates
CGHC010149302026
2026:CGHC:26527-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.07.09
14:53:41 +0530
CRA No. 1010 of 2026
1 - Nara Bhaskar S/o Nara Raghu Aged About 24 Years R/o Bhejjipara Ward
No. 10, Konta, Distt. Sukma, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Telam Mutta S/o Telam Raja Aged About 32 Years R/o Village Banda,
Mausampara, P.S. Konta, Distt. Sukma, Chhattisgarh.
... Appellants
versus
Union Of India Through The N.I.A. Branch Raipur, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellants
:
Mr. Amit Singh Chauhan, Advocate
(through Legal Aid)
For Respondent/UOI
:
Mr. B. Gopa Kumar, Advocate along with
Ms. Navya Gopan and Mr. Ayush Bhatt,
Advocates
Hon’ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
30/06/2026
1.
Both these appeals are arising out of the same crime number and
same Special (NIA) Case No. 9 of 2024, therefore they are being
heard and decided together.
2.
Both these criminal appeals have been filed by the appellants against
the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence dated 22.04.2025,
passed by the learned Special Judge (NIA/Scheduled Offences)
Bastar, Place Jagdalpur, in Special (NIA) Case No. 9 of 2024, whereby
the appellants have been convicted and sentenced in the following
manner:-
For the appellant- Semal Deepak (in CRA No. 2140 of 2025)
CONVICTION
SENTENCE
U/s. 04(b) of the Explosive
Substances Act 1908
Rigorous Imprisonment for 07 years
U/s. 05 of the Explosive
Substances Act 1908
Rigorous Imprisonment for 05 years
U/s. 38(2) of Unlawful Activities Rigorous Imprisonment for 05 years
(Prevention) Act 1967
& fine amount of Rupees 500/- in
default of fine R.I. for 01 month
U/s. 39 (2) of Unlawful Rigorous Imprisonment for 05 years
Activities (Prevention) Act 1967
All the sentences are directed to run concurrently.
For the appellants- Nara Bhaskar and Telam Mutta ( in CRA No. 1010
of 2026)
CONVICTION
U/s 4(b) of Explosive
Substances Act, 1908
SENTENCE
R.I. for 7 years (to both the
appellants)
U/s 5 of Explosive Substances R.I. for 5 years (to both the
Act, 1908
appellants)
U/s 23(1) of Unlawful Activities R.I. for 5 years and fine of Rs. 500/-,
(Prevention) Act, 1967
in default of payment of fine, 1 month
R.I. (to both the appellants)
U/s 38(2) of Unlawful Activities R.I. for 5 years (to both the
(Prevention) Act, 1967
appellants)
U/s 39(2) of Unlawful Activities R.I. for 5 years (to both the
(Prevention) Act, 1967
appellants)
All the sentences are directed to run concurrently.
3.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that the police inspector
Shivanand Singh (PW-16) received a secret information on 08.03.2023
that the appellant Semal Deepak along with his two friends is going to
Belpochcha jungle to supply the explosive substances to Vetti Bhima,
who was engaged in naxalite activities. Inspector Shivanand Singh
informed the secret information to his senior officer Rohit Shukla (PW7) and reduced in writing in rojnamcha (exhibit P-36). The secret
information panchnama (exhibit P-37) was also prepared by the police.
The SDOP Rohit Shukla (PW-7) constituted a search party and the
search party along with arm ammunition, investigation kit, documents,
laptop, printer proceeded towards village Banda, Belpochcha and their
departure was recorded in rojnamcha (exhibit P-25). On the way the
witnesses M. Mallika Arjun (PW-1) and Madvi Nitin (PW-20) met and
they were asked to be the independent witnesses. When the search
party reached near Belpochcha jungle, they saw three persons in a
motorcycle, who tried to ran after seeing the police persons. They were
intercepted by the police and they disclosed their names as Semal
Deepak, Nara Bhaskar and Telam Mutta and disclosed that on the
instance of Vetti Bhima, who was the commander of banned moist
organization. They are going to village Gompad to supply the explosive
substance to one Rama, who was also engaged in naxalite activities.
From the bag of accused Semal Deepak, 20 nos. batteries, 45 nos.
electronic detonators, one mobile phone and one naxalite banner,
were recorded. From the plastic carry bag of accused Nara Bhaskar,
33 gelatin rod, one bundle of electric wire and one mobile phone have
been seized and from the plastic carry bag of accused Telam Mutta,
cordex wire 49 feet and 10 gelatin rod were seized. On being asked,
they disclosed that, they have no document or bill of the seized
substance. The search party took the accused persons and seized
explosive substance to CRPF Camp, Murliguda and recovery
panchnama (exhibit P-4) with respect to seizure from Semal Deepak,
exhibit P-3 with respect to seizure from accused Nara Bhaskar and
exhibit P-5 with respect to seizure from Telam Mutta have been
prepared and seizure panchnama (exhibit P-6) was prepared. The
accused persons were arrested and their arrest have been informed to
their family members.
4.
Spot map (exhibit P-26) was prepared and they were taken to Konta
police station and their arrival was recorded in rojnamcha (exhibit P27). FIR (exhibit P-28) was registered against the accused persons for
the offence under Section 34 of the IPC, Section 4-B of the Explosive
Substances Act, 1908 and Sections 23(1), 38 and 39 of the Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967.
5.
During the patrolling at Murliguda road, the Assistant Sub-Inspector
Harishchandra Uike (PW-13) has taken into custody the accused Papi
Putti Reddy on suspicion, who disclosed that he was the resident of
Laxminagaram and he was feeling nervousness. After informing the
SDOP, they took him to Konta police station and his memorandum
statement (exhibit P-1) was recorded, in which he disclosed about his
involvement in various incidents and disclosed that he concealed the
detonator, cordex wire and gelatin rod in the shrubs at Murliguda road.
On his instance, the said articles have been seized and seizure memo
(exhibit P-2) was prepared and he too was arrested. The seized
explosive substance were sent for its examination to BDS team and
sent to Reserved Police Station, Sukma. On 15.05.2023, they sent a
request letter (exhibit P-22) to the Special Court (NIA) South Bastar,
Dantewada for disposal of the explosive substances and after
obtaining due permission from the Court as well as from the
Superintendent of Police, Sukma, the explosive substances were
disposed of at firing range of Reserved Police Centre, Sukma by the
BDS team. After its disposal, the plain and gunpowder mixed soil have
been collected from there and sent it for its chemical examination to
FSL. The disposal panchnama (exhibit P-21) was prepared. The FSL
report (exhibit P-24) was received from Regional FSL, Jagdalpur,
District Bastar.
6.
Statement of the witnesses under Section 161 of CRPC have been
recorded. The sanction for prosecution was obtained from the District
Magistrate as well as Home Department, State of Chhattisgarh, Raipur
(exhibit P-35) and after completion of usual investigation charge sheet
was filed before the learned trial Court.
7.
The learned trial Court framed charge against the accused persons
and after framing of charge, 7 witnesses were examined. Thereafter, in
pursuance of the order passed by the Ministry of Home, Government
of India, the case was transferred to NIA Court and by the order dated
15.04.2024 passed by this Court in TP (CR) No. 14 of 2024, the case
was transferred to the NIA Court on 29.04.2024 for its trial.
8.
The learned Special Court (NIA) framed charge against the accused
persons under Section 4(b) and 5 of Explosive Substances Act, 1908
and Section 23(1), 38(2) and 39(2) of the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act, 1967. The accused persons denied the charge and
claimed trial.
9.
In order to prove the charge against the accused persons, the
prosecution has examined as many as 21 witnesses. Statements of
the accused persons under Section 313 of CRPC have been recorded,
in which they denied the circumstances, pleaded innocence and
submitted that they have been falsely implicated in the offence. One
defence witness Purnachand Naidu (DW-1) has been examined by the
defence.
10.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence led by the
parties, the learned trial Court acquitted the accused Papi Putti Reddy
from the alleged offences, however convicted the accused persons
Semal Deepak, Nara Bhaskar and Telam Mutta as has been disclosed
in the earlier part of this judgment. Hence these appeals.
11.
Mr. Somkant Verma, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
Semal Deepak would submit that, the prosecution has failed to prove
its case beyond reasonable doubt. There are material omissions and
contradictions in the evidence of prosecution witnesses, which cannot
be made basis to convict the appellant for the alleged offence. The
appellant has been convicted only on suspicion and the alleged
recovery from the appellant has not been proved in accordance with
law. The appellant was not found in possession of explosive
substances and the same has been seized from an open place
accessible to all. The mandatory provisions of the Explosive
Substances Act, 1908 and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act,
1967 have not been complied with. There are material inconsistencies
in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses including the evidence of
Rohit Shukla (PW-7) and Shivanand Singh (PW-16). The independent
witnesses have not supported the prosecution case and there is no
cogent and clinching evidence against the appellant, therefore, his
appeal may be allowed and he may be acquitted from the alleged
offence.
12.
Mr. Amit Singh Chouhan, learned counsel appearing for the appellants
Nara Bhaskar and Telam Mutta adopting the submissions made by
learned counsel for the appellant Semal Deepak, would submit that,
only the paper formalities have been prepared by the police and no
explosive substances have been seized from these appellants. The
prosecution has failed to produce any reliable evidence against the
appellants to connect them in the offence in question. He would also
submit that the independent witnesses have not supported the
prosecution case and there is no evidence that they involved in
naxalite activities. The judgment passed by the learned trial Court is
perverse and contrary to the evidence available on record and has not
been considered in its proper perspective, therefore, these appellants
are also entitled for their acquittal.
13.
Mr. B. Gopa Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the Union of India
opposes the submissions made by learned counsel for the respective
appellants and would submit that the prosecution has proved its case
beyond reasonable doubt. But for minor omissions or contradictions
the evidence of the prosecution witnesses are fully reliable, which are
sufficient to hold the appellant guilty for the alleged offence. When the
police proceeded for search on the secret information, the appellants
were apprehended and electronic detonator, cordex wire and gelatin
rod have been seized from them, which was being used in explosive
substance. The place, from where the seizure was made from the
accused persons is a dense forest area and naxalite affected and
various naxalite activities occurred there. The appellants could not
explained about the possession of such a huge quantity of explosive
substances. The seizure of explosive substances and the suspicious
activities of the accused persons have been proved by the witnesses,
and there is no infirmity or perversity in the impugned judgment passed
by the learned trial Court. The appeals being sans merit, liable to be
dismissed.
14.
We have heard learned counsel for the respective parties and gone
through the record of the trial Court.
15.
PW-16 Shivanand Singh, Inspector of Police, received the secret
information about the offence. He stated in his evidence that on
08.03.2023, he received secret information that the accused Semal
Deepak along with his two friends is going to supply explosive
substances to Vetty Bhima. He informed it to his senior officer and
reduced in rojnamcha, which is exhibit P-36. Secret information
panchnama (exhibit P-37) was prepared in presence of the witnesses
and copy of which was forwarded to SDOP, Konta through the
constable Preet Ram Kunjam and the relevant rojnamcha is exhibit P38 and P-39. He was being instructed by the SDOP and then a police
team was constituted and proceed towards Banda Belpochcha village.
When they reached near village Belpochcha jungle, they saw three
persons in a motorcycle and they started fleeing after seeing them.
They were intercepted and then they disclosed their names as Semal
Deepak, Nara Bhaskar and Telam Mutta. They also disclosed that they
are waiting for naxalite Madkam Rama. They also disclosed that they
had explosive substance in their bags. On being searched, from Semal
Deepak, 20 nos. batteries, 45 electronic detonators, one mobile phone
and one naxalite banner was seized. From accused Nara Bhaskar, 33
nos. gelatin rods and wire and from Telam Mutta, 49 feet cordex wire
and 10 gelatin rods were seized. Considering that the place are highly
sensitive area, they were taken to Murliguda, CRPF Camp. The
accused persons could not produce any document of possession of
the seized explosive substances and then they were taken to Konta
police station and FIR was registered. The further investigation was
done by SDOP Konta.
******* In cross-examination, though the defence tried to bring
discrepancies with respect to the timing of the search and seizure
proceedings, but he duly answered the timing of the proceedings,
which he conducted. He also described the location of the area, where
they seized the explosive substances from the accused persons. He
firmly denied that no article has been seized from the accused persons
and duly proved the seizure made from the accused persons. He
shown his ignorance about profession of the accused persons. From
the evidence of this witness, the defence could not be able to extract
any material, which makes his evidence doubtful and he remained firm
in the proceedings, which he conducted during search and the seizure
of the explosive substances from the accused persons.
16.
PW-1, M. Mallika Arjun is the independent witness, who has turned
hostile, but has admitted his signature over the documents (exhibit P-1
to P-10).
17.
PW-2, Riyajuddin has also turned hostile and not supported the
prosecution case, but has admitted his signature over the documents
(exhibit P-1, P-2 and P-10).
18.
PW-3, Budla Shiva Reddy and PW-4 Jiri Venkat Ramanna also turned
hostile and not supported the prosecution case. PW-5 Sodi Joga is the
Patwari,
who
prepared
the
spot
map
(exhibit
P-15).
PW-6,
Girijashankar Sao is the SDOP posted at Naxal Operation, Konta. He
stated in his evidence that, he prepared the spot map (exhibit P-16) in
presence of the accused Papi Putti Reddy. He recorded his
memorandum statement (exhibit P-1) and based on his memorandum
statement, the detonator, cordex wire and gelatin rod have been
seized from shrubs at Murliguda road vide seizure memo (exhibit P-2).
He also proved the seizure memo (exhibit P-17) from constable
Luhdhar Markam. He arrested the accused Papi Putti Reddy and
informed his family members. The seized articles were sent for its
examination from BDS team along with the memo (exhibit P-19). He
also sent a request letter (exhibit P-20) to the learned Special Court,
South Bastar, Dantewada for permission for disposal of seized articles
and after obtaining due permission, the seized articles were disposed
on 25.05.2023 and a panchnama (exhibit P-21) was prepared. The
memo sent to the Superintendent of Police for disposal of the seized
article is exhibit P-22. Along with the memo (exhibit P-23), the plain
and gunpowder mixed soil were sent to Regional FSL Jagdalpur for its
chemical examination, from where FSL report (exhibit P-24) was
received. He recorded the statement of the witnesses. In crossexamination, he too remained firm and denied that he prepared the
documents in the police station. He duly proved his part of the
investigation which he conducted.
19.
PW-7, Rohit Shukla is the SDOP Konta, who stated in his evidence
that, on 08.03.2023, he received an information from Inspector
Shivanand Singh about secret information and then he instructed for
constitution of police party, in which he himself was also a member
along with other police personnel. They proceeded towards the
informed place along with arms and ammunition, investigation kit,
documents, laptop and printer. Since, the suspected place was highly
sensitive area, they proceeded under the due protection. On the way,
they met with the independent witnesses M. Mallika Arjun and Madvi
Nitin. Near village Belpochcha, they saw three persons in a
motorcycle, who after seeing them tried to flee. They were intercepted
and then, they disclosed their names. He identified those three
accused persons, who were found present. All the three persons
disclosed that on the instance of commander of banned moist
organization Vetty Bhima, they are going to deliver the explosive
substance to Rama resident of village Gompad. On being searched,
from Semal Deepak, 20 nos. batteries, 45 electronic detonators, one
mobile phone and one naxalite banner was seized. From accused
Nara Bhaskar, 33 nos. gelatin rods and wire and from Telam Mutta, 49
feet cordex wire and 10 gelatin rods were seized. The seizure memos
(exhibit P-3, P-4 and P-5) were prepared. On the same day, the
seizure memo (exhibit P-6) was also prepared. The accused persons
were arrested and their arrest have been informed to their family
members. Spot map (exhibit P-26) was prepared and they came back
to police station, where rojnamcha sanha entry was made vide (exhibit
P-27) and then, FIR (exhibit P-28) was registered. In his crossexamination, he too has remained firm in search and seizure
proceedings, which was conducted by him. Though he admitted that
the recovery and seizure panchnama have not been prepared on the
spot, but he stated that it has been prepared in presence of the
witnesses. But for minor omission or contradiction, he supported the
substantial part of the allegation about recoveries of the explosive
substances from the accused persons.
20.
PW-10 Dirdo Hunga is the Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police, and he
too was a part of search and seizure party and also supported the
prosecution case that, when they reached near Belpochcha, they saw
three persons tried to flee after seeing them and they intercepted
them. They disclosed their names and then, the detonator, naxalite
poster, batteries, gelatin rod and cordex wire have been seized. The
accused persons were taken to CRPF Camp, Murliguda, because the
place where the accused persons were arrested was a dense naxalite
affected and sensitive area. In his cross-examination, also the defence
could not be able to elicit any material to disbelieve his testimony. He
being the part of search and seizure party, supported the prosecution
case.
21.
PW-12 Maheshwara Nand Netam, Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police
was the member of search party, who proceeded towards Murliguda
camp. During the MCP duty, another Assistant Sub-Inspector,
Harishchandra Uike informed the SDOP that they took a suspected
person at Konta police station, whose name is Papi Putti Reddy. When
the said accused was interrogated at Konta police station, he disclosed
that he is going to village Gompad on the instance of Rama for delivery
of goods. He also disclosed that he was having detonators, gelatin
rods, cordex wires and batteries, which he concealed in the truck at
jungle. Two independent witnesses Riyajudin and Mallika Arjun were
called and then on the instance of the accused, the said explosive
substances were seized. In his cross-examination also, he remained
firm in saying that, on the instance of the accused, they seized the
explosive substances. This witness is relates to the proceeding of
search and seizure from accused Papi Putti Reddy, who is the
acquitted accused in the case.
22.
PW-13, Harishchandra Uike is the Assistant Sub-Inspector has stated
in his evidence that, on 19.03.2023, they conducted MCP near
Murliguda and at that time, they arrested the suspected accused Papi
Putti Reddy an on his interrogation, electronic detonator (105 nos.),
pencil batteries (10-15 nos.), one bundle wire, 35 nos. gelatin rod have
been seized from shrubs. This witness is also related with the seizure
of the explosive substance from the acquitted accused Papi Putti
Reddy.
23.
PW-14, Sunita Sodhi is the steno/typist posted at the office of District
Magistrate Sukma and her evidence is with respect to grant of sanction
for prosecution against the accused persons. She proved the
documents (exhibit P-33 and P-34) which were the recommendation
for sanction of prosecution dated 06.07.2023. She typed the said
recommendation and forwarded it to the Superintendent of Police and
the State Government.
24.
PW-15, Smt. Hemin Baghe, who is the Deputy Secretary, State of
Chhattisgarh has granted sanction for prosecution of the accused
persons, which is exhibit P-35. Nothing substantial could be extracted
from her cross-examination.
25.
PW-17 is a protected witness, who stated in his evidence that at the
time when he was aged about 14 years, he was being kept at child
organization by Podium Raje and Podium Rage. He stayed there for
about 4 years, thereafter, Madvi Suresh took him from there. In the
year 2014, he was made Deputy Commander in LGS and having
INSAS Rifle with him. He was a member of Burkapal Ambus in the
year 2017 and subsequently, he was made a member of Konta Area
Committee in the year 2018. He was made LOS Commander at
Polampalli in the year 2019 and was having SLR weapon. In the year
2020, he had gone to Errabon Student Organization and met with
Semal Deepak. In the year 2021, he called 6 bundles electronic wire
from Semal Deepak and in the year 2022, 8 bundles of tiger bomb and
crackers. Semal Deepak supplied the electronic wire, tiger bomb,
crackers to Madakamrama of village Gompad and in turn, he given it to
Vetti Magadu, who was the in-charge of Konta area. In the year 2023,
in the month of February-March, he again called electronic wire,
gelatin detonator, walkie-talkie battery and cordex from Semal Deepak,
but it was seized by the police on the way. He knew Nara Bhaskar and
Telam Mutta, who was the associate of Semal Deepak.
******* In cross-examination, he stated that he surrendered for the
police on 22.04.2024. He is not presently employed in the police
service. He admitted that Semal Deepak was a contractor for
construction of the road and culvert. Nara Bhaskar and Telam Mutta
were also working as contractor along with Semal Deepak. He came to
know about supply of the articles from Madakamrama. He admitted
that Semal Deepak has directly not supplied the weapons to him. He
further admitted that the gelatin codex wire, detonator are not available
in open market.
26.
PW-18 is another protected witness, who stated in his evidence that,
on 10.03.2024 he surrendered at Superintendent of Police office,
Sukma. In the year 2007, he got admitted in Naxalite organization
through Sodhi Linge. He spent there for one year, and thereafter he
had gone to Kistaram area. In the year 2012, he was made ACM and
in the year 2020, he was made DVCM. He knew the accused Papi
Putti Reddy since 2018 and he met with him at Buraklanka Jungle
through Rajesh Kartam. Rajesh Kartam informed him that they will call
supply of articles through Papi Putti Reddy. In the year 2018, he called
a Epson printer machine and Jio mobile, which was delivered by him to
South Division DVC Secretary, Vikas Reddy alias Raghu Reddy. In the
year 2020, he purchased two tablets electronic gadget of Samsung
company through Papi Putti Reddy, which was delivered by him by
Naxali Courier Sona Putti Papi Reddy.
******* In cross examination, he admitted that in his presence no article
has been seized from Papi Putti Reddy on 19.03.2023. He is presently
working at district Sukma. His statement was recorded by NIA officers
at Sukma. He denied that the NIA officers have tutored him for giving
evidence. This witness is also deposed against the acquitted accused
Papi Putti Reddy.
27.
PW-19 is another protected witness, who stated in his evidence that he
surrendered on 22.04.2024. He entered into Naxalite organization in
the year 2006 and up to 2010, he worked as a teacher under the
Jantana government. From 2011 to 2013, he worked as LOS
Commander at Kistaram area and from 2014 to 2023, he was
president of Jantana Government at Kistaram committee. Prior to that,
he was Secretary and DVC member of Kistaram Area committee. He
knew the accused Papi Putti Reddy and met him in the year 2017-18
through Kamloo Prakash. In the year 2018-19, he called army cap,
magazine pouch, battery and gelatin rod through Papi Putti Reddy,
which was supplied by him to Naxalite organization, Hidma. In the year
2021, he purchased one Epson printer, medicines, codex wire, gelatin
and detonator from Papi Putti Reddy, which was also delivered to
Hidma. In the month of February 2023, he again called gelatin, codex
wire and detonator, which were again supplied to Hidma. Papi Putti
Reddy was an active member of Naxalite organization and after supply
of the articles, he further supplied it to Hidma.
******* In cross examination, he disclosed about recording of his
statement by the police and from his evidence, it also transpires that
he stated against the accused Papi Putti Reddyi.
28.
PW-20 Madvi Nitin is an independent witness, who stated in his
evidence that on 08.03.2023 on the way, he met with the police
persons who disclosed him about secret information and the accused
persons and asked him to accompany. When they reached on the spot
at Belpochcha village, the accused persons started running and they
were intercepted by the police. On being searched of their bags, one
mobile phone, 20 nos. of wireless set batteries, 45 detonators and
naxalite banner were seized from the accused Semal Deepak, 33 nos.
of gelatin rods, one bundle electric copper wire and one mobile phone
was seized from Nara Bhaskar, 10 gelatin rods and codex wire 49 feet
were seized from accused Telam Mutta. On being inquiry, all the three
accused persons could not produce any document of its possession
and then the police has seized the said articles and they have been
arrested.
******* In cross-examination, he remained firm in saying that, when
they reached on the spot along with the police persons, they arrested
the accused persons and seized the incriminating explosive substance
from them. Nothing substantive could be elicited from his evidence to
disbelieve him and his evidence is reliable with respect to seizure of
the explosive substances from the appellants.
29.
PW-21 Krishna Kumar Agrawal alias Kishan Agrawal has stated in his
evidence that he is resident of Lal Bazar, Hyderabad. His father was
having a shop of military store and after his death, he is running the
said shop. Papi Putti Reddy was purchasing articles from his shop and
make payment on his bank account. He also disclosed the mobile
number of himself, his father and bank account details of them, in
which the amount has been transferred by Papi Putti Reddy.
******* In cross-examination, he stated that he is having no license of
the shop and his shop is also not registered. In further crossexamination, he sold the articles to military persons, but not to the
civilians. In further cross-examination, he stated that his father has
died on 18th April, 2022 and he brought the bank account statement
from 01.01.2021 to 08.01.2025, which is exhibit P-40. He denied that
he engaged in illegal selling of Naxalite articles and he also denied that
he falsely implicated the accused Papi Putti Reddy. His evidence is
also related to the accused Papi Putti Reddy, who has already been
acquitted in the offence and he supplied the articles to Papi Putti
Reddy, who made payment of the same.
30.
DW-1 Purnachand Naidu deposed that he knew accused Semal
Deepak, Nara Bhaskar and Telam Mutta as they were associated in
road construction work, stating that on 08.03.2023, while they were
engaged in earthwork on the Maraiguda–Godgubal Para road under a
partnership arrangement, two constables from Konta Police Station
arrived at about 5:30 p.m. and asked the three accused to accompany
them to the police station on the directions of the Station House
Officer, Shivanand Singh. According to him, he and Pawan Kumar also
went to the police station, where the SHO permitted them to leave after
assuring that the accused would be released shortly, but on the
following day they learnt that the accused had been arrested on
allegations of supplying explosives to Naxalites. He further stated that
about a week prior to the incident, the SHO had questioned them on
suspicion of having links with Naxalites because they were working in
an interior area, and about a week after the arrest he was threatened
by the SHO not to disclose these facts.
******* During cross-examination, he admitted that there was no
documentary proof of the alleged partnership, that he himself was not
a registered contractor, and that criminal cases had previously been
registered against him, with two ending in acquittal and one remaining
pending. However, he consistently maintained that the accused were
present with him at the work site throughout the day, that they were
taken to the police station by the police from the work site, and that no
search, seizure or recording of statements was conducted either at
Maraiguda or in his presence at the police station on 08.03.2023.
31.
Upon a comprehensive re-appreciation of the entire evidence available
on record, this Court finds that the prosecution has succeeded in
establishing beyond reasonable doubt that on the basis of prior secret
information, a duly constituted police party apprehended the appellants
near Belpochcha jungle while they were proceeding towards the
interior naxal-affected area carrying explosive substances. The
evidence of PW-16 Shivanand Singh, PW-7 Rohit Shukla, PW-10
Dirdo Hunga and PW-20 Madvi Nitin is consistent on all material
particulars regarding the receipt of secret information, constitution of
the search party, interception of the appellants, recovery of explosive
articles from their respective possession and preparation of seizure
proceedings. Though certain minor discrepancies have been pointed
out by the defence regarding the timing of the proceedings or the place
where the seizure documents were prepared, such omissions are
natural and do not affect the substratum of the prosecution case.
Rather, the evidence consistently establishes that, considering the
area to be a highly naxal-infested and sensitive forest region, the
police party shifted the appellants and the seized articles to the nearby
CRPF Camp for safety before completing the documentation. Such
procedural course, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case,
does not create any doubt regarding the genuineness of the seizure.
32.
The contention of the appellants that the prosecution case deserves
rejection because some of the independent witnesses have turned
hostile also deserves to be rejected. It is well settled that merely
because an independent witness has not supported the prosecution,
the otherwise reliable testimony of official witnesses does not become
unacceptable. The learned trial Court has rightly appreciated that the
hostility of an independent witness does not eclipse the otherwise
cogent and convincing evidence of official witnesses. In Nathusingh v.
State of M.P., (1974) 3 SCC 584, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
categorically held that "the mere fact that they are police officers was
not enough to discard their evidence. No reason was shown for their
hostility to the appellant." The same principle has consistently been
reiterated by the Supreme Court that the evidence of police officials is
to be tested on the same parameters as that of any other witness and
cannot be rejected merely because of their official status.
33.
The aforesaid principle has been further elaborated by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Anil v. State of Maharashtra, (1996) 2 SCC 589,
wherein it was held in paragraph 5 as under:
“5. ….... There is, however, no rule of law that the
evidence of police officials has to be discarded or
that it suffers from some inherent infirmity.
Prudence, however, requires that the evidence of
the police officials, who are interested in the
outcome of the result of the case, needs to be
carefully
scrutinised
and
independently
appreciated. The police officials do not suffer from
any disability to give evidence and the mere fact
that they are police officials does not by itself give
rise to any doubt about their creditworthiness.”
34.
Similar principles have been reiterated in State (Govt. of NCT of
Delhi) v. Sunil, (2001) 1 SCC 652, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme
Court authoritatively held that there is no legal presumption that police
officers are untrustworthy witnesses and the Court cannot begin with
an initial distrust of official acts. Their Lordships observed that it would
be an archaic notion to approach police evidence with suspicion
merely
because
no
independent
witness
has
supported
the
prosecution. Unless there are compelling reasons to doubt the fairness
of the investigation or the credibility of official witnesses, their
testimony cannot be discarded solely on the ground that they are
police personnel. Likewise, in Ajmer Singh v. State of Haryana,
(2010) 3 SCC 746, while considering similar objections regarding
absence of independent witnesses in recovery proceedings, the
Supreme Court held:
“19. …..it is normally expected that there should be
independent evidence to support the case of the
prosecution. However, it is not an inviolable rule.
Therefore, in the peculiar circumstances of this
case, we are satisfied that it would be travesty of
justice, if the appellant is acquitted merely because
no independent witness has been produced.
20. We cannot forget that it may not be possible to
find independent witness at all places, at all times.
The obligation to take public witnesses is not
absolute. If after making efforts which the court
considered in the circumstances of the case
reasonable, the police officer is not able to get
public witnesses to associate with the raid or arrest
of the culprit, the arrest and the recovery made
would not be necessarily vitiated. The court will
have to appreciate the relevant evidence and will
have to determine whether the evidence of the
police officer was believable after taking due care
and caution in evaluating their evidence.”
35.
Applying the aforesaid settled principles to the facts of the present
case, we find that although PW-1, PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 did not fully
support the prosecution, PW-1 admitted his signatures on the seizure
documents
and
PW-20,
who
was
an
independent
witness
accompanying the police party, has fully corroborated the prosecution
version regarding interception of the appellants and recovery of
explosive substances from their possession. More importantly, the
evidence of PW-7, PW-10, PW-16 and other official witnesses is
consistent, natural and inspires confidence. Nothing substantial has
been elicited in their lengthy cross-examinations to indicate any motive
for falsely implicating the appellants or to create any serious dent in
the prosecution case. Their evidence also stands corroborated by the
documentary evidence, seizure memos, rojnamcha entries, FSL report
and the sanction orders placed on record. We also find that the
protected witness (PW-17), who was formerly associated with the
banned organisation, has specifically deposed regarding the role of
appellant Semal Deepak in supplying explosive materials to the
banned organisation and has further identified Nara Bhaskar and
Telam Mutta as his associates. His testimony lends additional
corroboration to the prosecution case regarding the nexus of the
appellants with the banned organisation.
36.
The defence evidence led through DW-1 Purnachand Naidu is also not
of such quality as would probabilise the defence version. His testimony
suffers from inherent infirmities. Admittedly, no documentary evidence
regarding the alleged road construction work, partnership arrangement
or presence of the appellants at the work site has been produced. He
also admitted that he was not a registered contractor and that criminal
cases had previously been registered against him. His version is not
only unsupported by any independent documentary evidence but is
also contrary to the consistent and reliable testimony of the
prosecution witnesses. The learned trial Court has, therefore, rightly
declined to place reliance upon his evidence.
37.
The recovery effected from each of the appellants is distinct and
specific. From appellant Semal Deepak, 45 electronic detonators, 20
batteries, one mobile phone and a naxalite banner were recovered;
from appellant Nara Bhaskar, 33 gelatin rods, electric wire and one
mobile phone were seized; whereas from appellant Telam Mutta, 49
feet cordex wire and 10 gelatin rods were recovered. None of the
appellants could furnish any lawful explanation or documentary
authority for possessing such explosive materials. The quantity and
nature of the articles recovered, coupled with the place of interception,
the prior secret information and the evidence regarding their intended
delivery to active naxalite cadres, clearly establish conscious
possession and active participation in facilitating the activities of the
banned organisation. The ingredients of Sections 4(b) and 5 of the
Explosive Substances Act, 1908 and Sections 23(1), 38(2) and 39(2)
of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, as applicable to the
respective appellants, thus stand fully established.
38.
We also find no merit in the submission regarding alleged noncompliance with the mandatory procedural requirements. The
prosecution has satisfactorily proved the receipt and recording of
secret
information,
constitution
of
the
search
party,
seizure
proceedings, registration of FIR, preparation of spot map, forwarding of
seized
articles
for
expert
examination,
disposal
of
explosive
substances after obtaining permission from the competent Court,
collection of remnants, FSL examination and grant of valid sanction for
prosecution. The procedural safeguards contemplated under law have
been substantially complied with and no prejudice whatsoever has
been demonstrated to have been caused to the appellants.
39.
In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered opinion
that the learned Special Judge has meticulously appreciated the oral
and documentary evidence in its proper perspective and has recorded
findings which are fully supported by the evidence available on record.
The findings of conviction do not suffer from any perversity, illegality or
misappreciation of evidence warranting interference by this Court in
appellate jurisdiction.
40.
Accordingly, both the criminal appeals, being devoid of merit, deserve
to be and are hereby dismissed. The conviction and sentence
imposed upon appellant Semal Deepak in Criminal Appeal No.2140 of
2025 and upon appellants Nara Bhaskar and Telam Mutta in Criminal
Appeal No.1010 of 2026 by the judgment dated 22.04.2025 passed by
the learned Special Judge (NIA/Scheduled Offences), Bastar at
Jagdalpur in Special (NIA) Case No.9 of 2024 are hereby affirmed.
41.
The appellants shall undergo the remaining part of their sentences.
42.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail where the appellants are undergoing their jail
sentence to communicate the same to the appellants informing them
that they are at liberty to assail the present judgment passed by this
Court by preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with
the assistance of High Court Legal Services Committee or the
Supreme Court Legal Services Committee.
43.
Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be transmitted to
the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information and
compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
HEAD NOTE
******* In cases arising from Naxalite-affected areas,
where the presence of independent witnesses may not
always be feasible, the testimony of police officials
cannot be rejected merely on the ground that they are
official witnesses, and if their evidence is found to be
cogent, trustworthy, reliable, and credible, it is sufficient
to sustain a conviction.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review