Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28362
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.B.SURESH KUMAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE JOBIN SEBASTIAN
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.A NO. 885 OF 2018
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 15.03.2018 IN SC NO.819 OF
2014 ON THE FILES OF THE ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-V,
KOLLAM
APPELLANTS/COUNTER PETITIONERS:
SELVARAJ @ RAJU
AGED 38 YEARS, S/O. MANUVEL, KARIKATHIL VEEDU,
THEKKETHERI MURI, DARFA, PATTAZHI VILLAGE,
KOLLAM DISTRICT.
SUSEELA KUNJUMOLE,
AGED 35 YEARS, D/O. KUTTY, PALLATHUVEEDU,
KIZHAKKE THERUVU, ERINGOOR MURI, MELILA
VILLAGE.
BY ADVS.
SRI.B.RENJITHKUMAR
SUNEESH KUMAR R
SRI.K.T.SEBASTIAN
K.P.ABHIRAMI S. LAL
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
STATE OF KERALA
REP. BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF
KERALA, ERNAKULAM, KOCHI-31
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 2 :2025:KER:28362
SRI.ALEX.M.THOMBRA SR.PP
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
17.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
03.04.2025
DELIVERED
THE
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 3 :2025:KER:28362
P.B.SURESH KUMAR & JOBIN SEBASTIAN, JJ.
----------------------------------------------Crl. Appeal No.885 of 2018
----------------------------------------------Dated this the 3rd day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
P.B.Suresh Kumar, J.
The appellants in this appeal are the accused in
S.C.No.819 of 2014 on the files of the Additional Sessions Judge-V,
Kollam. They stand convicted and sentenced for the murder of
Suresh, the husband of the second accused.
2.
The second accused has an elder sister named
Mani. The first accused is the younger brother of the husband of
Mani. There was a function in the house of Mani on 17.03.2013.
Suresh, the second accused and their daughter, Soorya took part in
that function. After the function, the second accused and Soorya
stayed in the house of Mani on the said day. Suresh, however, left
the house of Mani to witness a temple festival. On the following day,
when the second accused and Soorya returned home, Suresh was
not found in the house. When Suresh was contacted on his mobile, it
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 4 :2025:KER:28362
was switched off. The search for Suresh by his friends and relatives
thereafter did not yield any results. Consequently, a complaint was
lodged
by
the
second
accused
before
Kunnicode
Police
on
19.03.2013 and a case was registered on that complaint for “man
missing” under Section 57(A) of the Kerala Police Act.
3.
While the investigation in the case was going on,
the police found the body of Suresh in a rubber estate on
20.03.2013. The investigation conducted thereafter revealed that
accused 1 and 2 were in an illicit relationship; that they hatched a
criminal conspiracy to murder Suresh who was a hindrance to their
relationship; that in pursuance of this criminal conspiracy, the first
accused lured Suresh into his autorickshaw on 17.03.2013 on his
way back from the house of Mani by offering to take him to the
venue of the temple festival and that thereafter, the first accused
pulled him out of the autorickshaw, knocked him down with a kick
on his abdomen and strangulated him with an electric wire. When
Suresh became unconscious, the first accused ensured his death by
strangulating him again with the dhothi worn by the first accused
and thereafter buried the body in the property of one Kunjamma.
Later, on 19.03.2013, the first accused exhumed the body, carried
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 5 :2025:KER:28362
the same in his Maruti Car after packing the body in gunny bags and
abandoned it in the rubber estate of one Vinod. The final report was
accordingly filed in the case against accused 1 and 2 alleging
commission of the offences punishable under Sections 120B, 302,
201, 202 and 203 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
(IPC).
4.
On the accused being committed to trial, the Court
of Session framed charges against them in terms of the final report
and they pleaded not guilty to the charges. The evidence in the case
consists of the oral evidence of PWs 1 to 48 and Exts.P1 to P61. MO1
to MO31 are the material objects identified by the witnesses. The
accused were thereupon questioned under Section 313 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure (the Code) as regards the incriminating
evidence brought out by the prosecution and they denied the same.
As the Court of Session did not find the case to be one fit for
acquittal under Section 232 of the Code, the accused were called
upon to enter on their defence. The accused examined three
witnesses at that stage as DW1 to DW3. Exts. D1 and D2 are the
documentary evidence on the side of the accused, of which Ext.D1
is a portion of the statement of PW15 recorded under section 161 of
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 6 :2025:KER:28362
the Code and Ext.D2 is a document proved by the accused through
DW2. Thereafter, on an appreciation of the materials on record, the
Court of Session found that the accused 1 and 2 are guilty of the
offences punishable under Sections 120B, 302, 201 and 203 read
with Section 34 IPC. The Court of Session found the second accused
guilty
of
the
offence
punishable
under
Section
also.
Consequently, the accused were convicted for the said offences and
sentenced, among others, to imprisonment for life. The accused are
deeply aggrieved by their conviction and sentence in the case and
hence this appeal.
5.
Heard Adv.B.Renjithkumar for the first accused and
Adv.Suneesh Kumar R. for the second accused. Sri.Alex M.Thombra,
the learned Public Prosecutor addressed arguments on behalf of the
State.
6.
The point that arises for consideration in the
appeal is whether the conviction of the accused and the sentence
passed against them, are sustainable in law.
7.
As there is no direct evidence to prove the case,
the prosecution attempted to prove its case through circumstantial
evidence. One of the arguments seriously pressed into service by
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 7 :2025:KER:28362
the learned counsel for the appellants was that the circumstances
proved in the case do not establish the guilt of the accused beyond
reasonable doubt. In the light of the said contention, it is necessary
to delve deep into the evidence let in by the prosecution.
8.
PW1 is Soorya, the daughter of Suresh and the
second accused. PW1 deposed among others that the second
accused contacted the first accused on his mobile more than once
on 16.03.2013 and that it was the first accused who picked PW1 and
the second accused from Kottarakara and dropped them near the
house of Mani at Pattazhi wherein a family function was being held
on the following day. It was deposed by PW1 that the house of Mani
is situated at a higher plane and one has to walk uphill beyond the
reach of the autorickshaw to reach there. It was deposed by PW1
that after stopping the autorickshaw, the first accused proceeded to
the house of Mani first after making them wait for sometime stating
that there would be trouble if they all go to the house of Mani at
once. It was deposed by PW1 that her father reached the house of
Mani on 17.03.2013 and that after the function, he left therefrom at
about 9 p.m. to witness the temple festival at Bharanikkavu. It was
deposed by PW1 that when she enquired with the second accused
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 8 :2025:KER:28362
about her father, the second accused told PW1 that she was
informed by the first accused that her father was lying in the
autorickshaw of the first accused which was parked outside the
house then. It was deposed by PW1 that on 18.03.2013, when the
second accused and Soorya returned home, Suresh was not found in
the house and that when her father was contacted on his mobile, it
was switched off. It was deposed by PW1 that the police summoned
the second accused to the station on 19.03.2013 and when the
second accused went to the station, PW1 also accompanied her;
that after questioning the second accused for sometime, the police
took them to Kottayam where the first accused was working then;
took him into custody and while returning, the first accused took out
a blade from the cover carried by him and cut his neck. It was
deposed by PW1 that the woman police constable who accompanied
them,
attempted to prevent the first accused from doing so and
took him to the Government Hospital, Kottarakkara and after
admitting the first accused in the said hospital for treatment, PW1
and the second accused were taken to Kunnikkode Police Station,
Kollam. In cross-examination, when it was put to PW1 that it is as
required by the police that she deposed that there was an illicit
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 9 :2025:KER:28362
relationship between the accused, PW1 admitted the suggestion. It
was also clarified by PW1 in cross-examination that there was no
occasion for the first accused to come to their house at any time.
9.
PW2 is the nephew of the first accused. PW2
deposed that the first accused called his father for help to procure
petrol for the vehicle of the first accused in the early hours of the
morning of 20.03.2013 and that PW2 went to Kura along with his
father as required by the first accused. It was deposed by PW2 that
when they reached Kura, the first accused was found waiting near
his blue Maruthi 800 car with two empty mineral water bottles; that
after dropping his father there, PW2 took the first accused to a
petrol outlet, procured petrol and returned to the same place where
the said car was parked and the first accused then left therefrom
after re-fueling his car. It was deposed by PW2 that the body of
Suresh was found on the same day at the same place where the first
accused was waiting for him and his father earlier that day. PW5 is
Mani, the elder sister of the second accused. PW5 deposed that the
first accused left her house at about 8 p.m. after attending the
function on 17.03.2013 and that Suresh left thereafter at about 9
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 10 :2025:KER:28362
p.m. PW6 is the wife of the first accused. She turned hostile to the
prosecution.
10.
PW7 is a gunny merchant. PW7 deposed that the
first accused purchased two gunny bags from his shop on
19.03.2013. PW8 is a person who was running a workshop at
Kottarakkara during the relevant time. PW8 deposed that the first
accused came to his workshop on 19.03.2013 to repair the Maruti
Car of the first accused and that PW8 sent a technician named
Manoj along with the first accused to repair the car and that after
sometime, both the first accused and the technician returned to the
workshop with the car after its repair and the first accused left the
workshop at about 6 p.m. It was deposed by PW8 that on the
morning of the following day, the first accused brought back the car
to the workshop for additional work and at that time, a foul smell
was emanating from the car and its interiors were found to be wet.
PW10 is a vegetable merchant. PW10 deposed that the first accused
came to her shop on 19.03.2013 in a blue coloured Maruti Car and
purchased five strands of rope.
11.
PW9 was a member of the Thalavoor Grama
Panchayat during the relevant time. It was she who informed the
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 11 :2025:KER:28362
police that a foul smell was emanating from a gunny bag lying in the
rubber estate of Vinod. It was deposed by PW9 that when the police
arrived at that place, PW9 also accompanied them and on
inspection, it was found that a dead body was packed in the said
gunny bag. It was explained by PW9 that the body was in fact
packed using two gunny bags, one covering the head portion and
the other covering the lower portion of the body and that the gunny
bags were tied using ropes. It was also deposed by PW9 that they
found a letter also near the body. PW15 was the pastor of a church.
He was blind. PW15 deposed that the first accused was the
secretary of the church until he was employed elsewhere and that
PW15 entrusted to the police a notebook which was maintained by
the first accused to keep a record of the accounts of the church.
PW18 is the wife of PW15. PW18 deposed that it was she who
handed over the account book of the church to the police. PW18
identified Ext.P7 as the account book. She also identified the
handwriting in Ext.P7 as that of the first accused. PW25 was the
Assistant Executive Engineer attached to the Pallam Division of the
Kerala State Electricity Board during 2013. It was PW25 who allotted
a dormitory to the first accused on his request. PW25 identified
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 12 :2025:KER:28362
Ext.P13 as the application submitted by the first accused for the
said purpose.
12.
One
Dr.P.Rema
conducted
the
post-mortem
examination on the body of the deceased and issued Ext.P23 postmortem certificate. The ante-mortem injury noted at the time of
post-mortem was described in Ext.P23 as thus:
“Abrasion 36cm long, horizontal on the neck: being just below right
ear (3.5cm broad) 8cm below occiput (3cm broad) just below left ear
(3.5cm broad) and 5cm below chin. (3.5cmbroad) Soft tissues
underneath was found contused on the front of neck. Contusions were
noted in upper end of left sternomastoid muscle (2.5x1x1cm) and left
cricothyroid muscle (2x1x1cm) Extensive infiltration of blood was
noted in prevertebral muscles of neck, around epiglottis and inner
surface of thyroid cartilage. Hyoid bone, other cartilages and bones of
neck were normal and intact.”
It was opined by Dr.P.Rema in Ext.P23 that the death was due to
constriction force around neck. PW37 was a doctor who was working
with Dr.Rema during the relevant time. PW37 affirmed that the
signature in Ext.P23 post-mortem certificate is that of Dr.Rema.
13.
accused
on
PW38 was the doctor who examined the first
21.03.2013
at
the
Taluk
Headquarters
Hospital,
Kottarakkara and issued Ext.P24 wound certificate. It was deposed
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 13 :2025:KER:28362
by PW38 that the history was reported to her by the police as “ബ ഡ
ക
ണ ഴതൽ മറബ ലചത ന ൽ". The injuries noted by PW38 on the body of
the first accused as deposed by her were the following:“Multiple cut wound on cillus side of neck. 7X2x1 cm deep left
side of neck 7x3x1 cm deep on the right side of neck
extending from side of midline respectively. Multiple tendative
like cuts over arteries aspect of neck. Lacerated wound of
2x0.5 cm over left wrist.”
It was opined by PW38 that the injuries sustained could be caused
as alleged. It was also clarified by PW38 that these type of injuries
could be caused only with sharp edged objects like blade. It was also
deposed by PW38 that on the same day she examined PW36 and
issued Ext.P25 certificate. It was deposed by PW38 that the cause of
the injury of PW36 was reported to her as “കശല ന എനയ കള custody
യല എടതക
ണ രന
നത ന ടയല blade ക
ഴ ബയ
ണ
ഴതറത ആതഹത$ക ശമ കനത ന ടയല അയ കള പ ടചമ റ
യല ബപ ന യത ല ച'.” The injuries noted by PW38
on the body of PW36 as deposed by her are as follows :
“1. Cut wound 1x0.1 cm size over dorsum of left index finger.
2. Linear abrasion 1 cm in between 2 nd and 3rd knuckles of
fingers.”
It was also deposed by PW38 that the aforesaid injuries could be
caused as alleged.
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 14 :2025:KER:28362
14. PW43 was the Scientific Assistant who examined the
Maruti 800 car involved in the crime on 02.04.2013 and collected
samples of hairs and fibres as also a white paper with some
indentation from the same. PW43 deposed that the items collected
by her from the car were handed over by her to the investigating
officer for onward transmission to the Forensic Science Laboratory,
after packing the same with a label under her seal. PW44 was the
Nodal Officer of the Telecom Service Provider – Airtel. It was PW44
who made available to
the investigating officer the subscriber
details as also the call details of the mobile phone bearing number
9995966853 held by the first accused. PW44 deposed the said fact
in his evidence. Ext.P28 is the call details and Ext.P29 is the
subscriber details.
15. PW36 was the woman Police Constable who
took
the second accused along with her to Kottayam, where the first
accused was residing. PW36 deposed that while returning with the
first accused, the first accused made an attempt to commit suicide
with a blade and when PW36 attempted to prevent him from doing
so, she also sustained injuries. PW47 was the police officer who
conducted the initial investigation in the case. It was deposed by
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 15 :2025:KER:28362
PW47 that it was he who sent PW36 to Kottayam to secure the
presence of the first accused. In addition, it was deposed by PW47
that the letter discovered at the place where the body was found,
was collected and stored by him in safe custody at the police station
and that the same was later made available to the investigating
officer. PW48 was the police officer who conducted the rest of the
investigation. PW48 gave evidence as to the various steps taken by
him as part of the investigation. PW48 identified MO27 as the letter
found along with the body of the deceased, and seized the same in
terms of the inquest report, and MO29 as a white paper with
indentation collected and entrusted to him by PW43, the Scientific
Assistant, from the Maruti Car involved in the crime. It was deposed
by PW48 that in the course of the investigation, he collected the
sample writings of the first accused for scientific examination.
16.
Ext.P57 is the report of the Molecular Biology
Division of the Forensic Science Laboratory, Thiruvananthapuram
and Ext.P59 is the report of the Document Division of the Forensic
Science Laboratory. The forwarding notes submitted by PW48, on
the basis of which various objects forwarded for scientific as also
forensic examination, were not seen marked in the proceedings. But,
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 16 :2025:KER:28362
the same are available in the records. Items 1(a) and 1(b) in Ext.P57
report are the scalp hairs and body hairs respectively of the
deceased collected at the time of post-mortem examination. Item
26 in Ext.P57 report are the hairs and fibres collected by PW43 from
the dicky of the Maruti Car involved in the crime. It is reported in
Ext.P57 that two out of the sample hairs collected from the Maruti
Car are similar to the scalp hairs of the deceased collected at the
time of post-mortem examination and six out of the sample hairs
collected from the Maruti Car are similar to the body hairs of the
deceased collected at the time of post-mortem examination.
17.
S1 to S4 referred to in Ext.P59 are the specimen
handwritings of the first accused, A1 and A2 referred to in Ext.P59
are
Exts.P7
and
P13
documents
containing
the
admitted
handwritings of the first accused, Q1 referred to in Ext.P59 is the
handwriting in MO27 letter found with the body of the deceased and
Q2 referred to in Ext.P59 is the white paper with indentation
collected from the dicky of the Maruti Car. It is reported in Ext.P59
that the person who wrote the standard writings in A1, A2, S1, S2,
S3 and S4 is the person who wrote the questioned writing in Q1.
Similarly, it is reported in Ext.P59 that the indentations deciphered
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 17 :2025:KER:28362
from the questioned document were found tallying with the writings
in Q1.
18.
It is based on the evidence discussed in the
preceding paragraphs that the Court of Session came to the
conclusion that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the accused
beyond reasonable doubt. Before proceeding further, it is necessary
to note that the specific case of the prosecution is that the first
accused committed the murder of the deceased in pursuance of the
criminal conspiracy between him and the second accused as they
were in an illicit relationship and the deceased was a hindrance to
that relationship. The Court of Session did not accept the case of the
prosecution that the accused were in an illicit relationship, for want
of evidence. Nevertheless, it accepted the case of the prosecution
that the accused hatched a criminal conspiracy to commit the
murder of the deceased. It is seen that the sole basis of the finding
rendered by the Court of Session in this regard is that there were
frequent
telephone
calls
between
the
accused,
after
the
disappearance of the deceased. The said finding was rendered
based on the call records of the mobile phones used by the accused.
No
doubt,
through
the
evidence
of
PW44,
the
prosecution
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 18 :2025:KER:28362
established that the first accused was using the SIM bearing number
9995966853. Ext.P28 call details would show that there were
frequent calls from the said SIM to the SIM bearing number
9961800486. According to the prosecution, the latter number was
one used by the second accused at the relevant time. But, there is
no legally acceptable evidence before this court to prove that SIM
bearing number 9961800486 was one allotted to the second
accused by the concerned telecom service provider. The evidence in
this regard was tendered only by PW48, the investigating officer. It
was PW48 who tendered in evidence, Ext.P53 call details obtained
by him from the telecom service provider, namely Idea Cellular
Limited. PW48 was incompetent to let in evidence as regards the
call records of SIM bearing number 9961800486 and its certification,
in terms of Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act. If so, the finding
rendered by the Court of Session based on the call records that
there
were
frequent
calls
between
the
accused
after
the
disappearance of the deceased, is unsustainable in law.
19. The essence of the criminal conspiracy lies in
forming a scheme or agreement between parties. No doubt, it is not
necessary to prove an express agreement. On the other hand, the
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 19 :2025:KER:28362
evidence as to transmission of thoughts sharing the unlawful design
is sufficient. In other words, when the circumstances in a given case
are taken together, it must be possible for the court to infer the
meeting of minds between the conspirators for the intended object
of committing the offence. Inasmuch as it has been found by this
court that the prosecution has failed in establishing even its case
that there were frequent calls between the accused after the
disappearance of the deceased, what remains is only the evidence
of PW1 that there used to be telephone calls between the accused
as also her evidence that the second accused used to travel in the
autorickshaw of the first accused. Inasmuch as the accused are
close relatives, the facts that there used to be telephone calls
between them and that the second accused used to travel in the
autorickshaw of the first accused, are hardly sufficient to hold that
they conspired to commit the murder of the deceased. The offence
of criminal conspiracy is a serious offence which carries the same
punishment as that of the intended offence. There has to be
satisfactory evidence to infer that there was consensus ad idem
between the accused to commit the crime. The prosecution has no
case that there is any evidence, other than the alleged telephone
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 20 :2025:KER:28362
calls between the accused to connect the second accused with the
crime. Needless to say, the finding rendered by the Court of Session
that the circumstances proved in the case establish a criminal
conspiracy between the accused to commit the murder of the
deceased, is unsustainable. Inasmuch as the second accused was
charged for the remaining offences viz, offences punishable under
Sections 201 and 202 IPC on the basis of the alleged criminal
conspiracy, she is liable to be acquitted of all the charges framed
against her.
20.
As noted, the first accused was convicted not only
for hatching a criminal conspiracy to commit the murder of the
deceased under Section 120B, but also for committing the murder in
pursuance of the criminal conspiracy under Section 302 IPC. He was
also convicted for causing disappearance of the evidence of murder
under Section 201 IPC and for giving false information in respect of
the offence under Section 203 IPC. The case of the prosecution, on
the basis of which the first accused was found guilty under Section
203 IPC is that he wrote MO27 letter and placed the same near the
body of the deceased in which the names of some persons related
to the deceased were mentioned to divert the investigation.
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 21 :2025:KER:28362
According to the prosecution, the said conduct of the first accused
would amount to the offence punishable under Section 203 IPC. It is
established in the case that it was the first accused who wrote
MO27 letter and kept the same along with the body of the deceased.
The recitals in MO27 letter read thus :
"പ ശ ഇത ന നകള സമ ന4. ഇതബപ ക6 ഒറയ ഞങളകട ക യൽ ട4.
അടത ഊഴ4 കനജ - പ കന നAയ4 ഞങകള ഉപദ ച കE ഞങൾ ഒEകല4 ടല
ഇ കന ഞങൾ മണനടയൽ ആകയത ണ. നA ഒതങ ൻ ബ ണ മ ത4 ഞങൾ
ടതരന അകലങ ൽ ഒര 6ത4 സബEഷ കന ന ങൾക ടല ബ ബട ട പEമന റ
ഒര പ ശ$4 കട ണങ. ഇ ൻ ഞങകട ശEAEത ക
ചതക ണ ണ ഇ കന
ഈ ഗത നത - പബണ ഇ ൻ ഞങകട ബന ടപള യ ണ. സക കന ഞങൾ
നലതബപ ക6 ക
E$4 കZയബത ള 4. ഒതങയ ൽ ന നകകഒകക നലത
അകലങ ൽ ഇതബപ ക6 ഓബE നകന ഞങൾ പറഞ ട4. ഓർബത .”
No doubt, the conduct of the first accused in writing a letter in the
nature of MO27, after the commission of the crime, with the
intention of misleading the investigation, is relevant in terms of
Section 8 of the Indian Evidence Act as subsequent conduct, but, the
said conduct of the first accused would not attract the offence
punishable under Section 203 IPC for, the same would not amount to
giving information regarding the offence committed. Needless to
say, the prosecution has failed to establish the charge against the
first accused under Section 203 of the IPC.
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 22 :2025:KER:28362
21.
circumstances
Let us now consider the question whether the
proved
in
the
case
would
establish
beyond
reasonable doubt, the guilt of the first accused of the remaining
charges namely, the charges under Sections 302 and 201 IPC. It is
now trite that the circumstances to be proved to establish the guilt
of the accused in a given case, shall be of a conclusive nature and
tendency and the same shall be fully established, which means that
the circumstances shall unequivocally establish the truth of the
facts, leaving no reasonable doubt, or alternative explanation and
the same should have a definite tendency of implicating the accused
in the crime. If one examines the evidence let in by the prosecution
in the case keeping in mind the principles aforesaid, the following
are the circumstances that could be taken as proved :
(i)
that accused 1 and 2 were relatives; that they
were close to each other and that there used to be frequent
telephone calls between them;
(ii)
that the second accused and her daughter went
to the house of PW5 on 16.03.2013 in the autorickshaw of
the first accused;
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 23 :2025:KER:28362
(iii)
that
the
deceased
was
missing
from
the
morning hours of 17.03.2013;
(iv)
that the first accused purchased two gunny
bags from the shop of PW7 on 19.03.2013;
(v)
that the first accused purchased five strands of
coir from the shop of PW10 on 19.03.2013;
(vi)
that the first accused contacted PW8 for
assistance to repair his car which was involved in the crime
on 19.03.2013 and availed the services of PW8 for the
same;
(vii)
that PW2 saw the first accused by the side of
his car which was involved in the crime in the morning
hours of 20.03.2013 close to the rubber estate of Vinod
where the body of the deceased was found abandoned;
(viii) that when the first accused took his car to the
workshop of PW8 for further repair on 20.03.2013, the
interiors of the car was found wet and a foul smell was
emanating from the car;
(ix)
that when the body of the deceased was found
in the rubber estate of Vinod on 20.03.2013, the same was
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 24 :2025:KER:28362
seen packed in two gunny bags tied using ropes in such a
manner that one bag covered the upper body and the other
bag covered the lower body;
(x)
that when the police party took the first
accused in custody for questioning him in connection with
the death of the victim, the first accused made an attempt
to commit suicide on the way to the police station;
(xi)
that the cause of death of the victim was due to
constriction force around the neck;
(xii)
that two out of the sample hairs collected from
the car of the first accused which was involved in the crime
were found to be similar to the scalp hairs of the deceased
collected at the time of post-mortem examination;
(xiii) that six out of the sample hairs collected from
the car of the first accused which was involved in the crime
were found to be similar to the body hairs of the deceased
collected at the time of post-mortem examination;
(xiv) that the writing in MO27 letter recovered from
the place where the body of the deceased was seen
abandoned, was found to be that of the first accused;
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 25 :2025:KER:28362
(xv) that the indentations deciphered from MO29
white paper recovered from the car of the first accused
which was involved in the crime were found to be tallying
with the writing in MO27.
(xvi) that the first accused made an attempt to
mislead the investigation in the case by placing MO27
letter written by him along with the body of the deceased.
22. One of the arguments advanced by the learned
counsel for the first accused is that inasmuch as Dr.Rema who
conducted the post-mortem examination was not examined in the
case, there is no evidence to prove the cause of death of the victim.
The learned counsel conceded that statements written or verbal of
relevant facts made by a person who is dead, or who cannot be
found or who has become incapable of giving evidence or whose
attendance cannot be procured without an amount of delay or
expense which under the circumstances of the case appears to the
court unreasonable, are themselves relevant in terms of Section 32
of the Indian Evidence Act, when the statement relates to an opinion
given by that person. But, according to him, for accepting the
statement of such persons, it has to be shown that he is either dead
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 26 :2025:KER:28362
or cannot be found or has become incapable of giving evidence or
whose presence cannot be procured without any delay or expense
which under the circumstances of the case appears to the court
unreasonable.
23.
evidence
of
The cause of death is ordinarily proved through the
the
doctor
who
conducted
the
post-mortem
examination, which constitutes substantive evidence. In that case,
the post-mortem certificate being a document containing the
previous statement of the doctor, can be used only to corroborate or
contradict the doctor. Section 32(2) of the Indian Evidence Act is an
exception to this. If the doctor who conducted the post-mortem is
dead or not available for examination under the circumstances
mentioned in Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act, the certificate
issued by the doctor, is itself relevant and admissible. At the same
time, the court can come to its independent conclusion as to the
cause of death, if there is independent evidence on record in
support of it. Inasmuch as the post-mortem certificate contains what
was observed by the doctor while conducting the post-mortem
examination and the conclusion arrived at by him, a statement
coming under Section 32 can be proved as prescribed in Section 47
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 27 :2025:KER:28362
of the Indian Evidence Act. The fact that Ext.P23 post-mortem
certificate is one issued by Dr.Rema has been duly proved by PW37
in terms of Section 47 of the Indian Evidence Act. In other words,
Ext.P23 establishes the prosecution case.
24.
The question that remains to be considered is
whether the circumstances mentioned above, are sufficient to hold
that it was the first accused who committed the murder of the
deceased and caused disappearance of the evidence. Before
examining the question above mentioned, it is necessary to keep in
mind the principles to be followed in this regard. The principles are:
(1)
that the circumstances from which the conclusion of
guilt is drawn are fully established,
(2)
that the facts so established are consistent only with
the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to
say, they should not be explainable on any other
hypothesis except that the accused is guilty,
(3)
that the circumstances are of a conclusive nature and
tendency,
(4)
that they should exclude every possible hypothesis
except that the accused is guilty, and
(5)
that there must be a chain of evidence so complete as
not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and must
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 28 :2025:KER:28362
show that in all human probability, the act must have
been done by the accused.
On an evaluation of the circumstances established in the case, we
are of the view that the same would form a chain of evidence so
complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and would show that in
all human probability, it was the first accused who committed the
acts alleged against him and that the same would exclude every
possible hypothesis except that he is guilty. We are not oblivious to
the fact that there is no satisfactory evidence in the case to
establish the motive of the first accused to commit the crime and
the motive, in cases involving circumstantial evidence, plays a
significant role. But, having regard to the totality of the facts and
circumstances of the case, according to us, the same shall not deter
us from arriving at the conclusion aforesaid.
In the result, the appeal is allowed in part. The
conviction of the second accused for the offences charged against
her is set aside and she is acquitted. She shall be set at liberty
forthwith and released from custody, if her continued detention is
not required in connection with any other case. Registry is directed
Crl.A. No.885 of 2018
-: 29 :2025:KER:28362
to communicate the above order forthwith to the concerned prison,
where
the second accused is
undergoing incarceration.
The
conviction of the first accused under Sections 120B and 203 IPC are
set aside and his conviction and sentence for the offences
punishable under Sections 302 and 201 IPC are confirmed. The
sentences shall run concurrently.
Sd/P.B.SURESH KUMAR, JUDGE.
Sd/JOBIN SEBASTIAN, JUDGE.
YKB
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review