The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. 09.2026 JUDGEMENT & ORDER (CAV) [1] Heard Mr. Osbert Khaling, learned counsel for the petitioner/accused and Mr. Y. Ashang, learned PP assisted by Mrs. R.K. Emily, learned Dy. GA on behalf of the State respondent. [2] The present bail application has been filed by the petitioner/accused under Section 439 of Code of Criminal Procedure read with Section 37 of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, 1985 praying for releasing the petitioner/accused on bail in connection with FIR Case No. 49(12) 2022 TPL-PS under Sections 21(c)/29 & 60 (3) ND & PS Act, 1985 and the prayer of the petitioner is reproduced below: Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025 2026:MNHC:201 (i) To issue notice to the respondent, (ii) To grant regular bail u/s 439 of the Cr.P.C. to the petitioner/ accused namely Mr. Seiminthang Mate in connection with FIR No. 49(12) 2022 TPL-PS U/s 21(c)/29 & 60 (3) ND & PS Act, 1985 and (iii) Pass any order/direction which the Hon’ble Court deems fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case as to meet the end of justice. Brief facts of the present case are as follows: [3] On 16.12.2022, the 20th Assam Rifles, Tengnoupal while in normal course of checking found illegal contrabands drugs (49 packets of Brown Sugar weighing about 2.163 kg including packing materials) hidden inside the seat of a Mahindra Bolero bearing registration no. MN 01AG 9896 (white colour) be…
22. 950 kgs of ganja) for more than one year was released on bail due to nonexamination of any witness after framing of charge. It is urged that the petitioner is in custody for more than three and half years and there is hardly any progress in the trial. It is prayed that the petitioner may be released on bail during the pendency of the trial, as he is first time offender that too without any incrimination materials; and the petitioner would be bound by any conditions as imposed by this Court. [6] Per contra, Mr. Y. Ashang, learned PP submits that in a seizure of commercial quantity, the bail application has to pass the strict rigors of twin test as mandated by Section 37 of NDPS Act, i.e., (i) the accused is not likely to be guilty of the offence, and (ii) he will not commit such offence while on bail. Since the seizure was made from the vehicles in which the accused were travelling, the statutory presumption of conscious possession under Section 35 of the Act will operate against the petitioner. The question of whether the petitioner was a passenger simpliciter or an accused is to be decided in trial and not in a bail application hearing. It is pointed out that FSL report gave a positive finding for heroin. Long incarceration is not the sole consideration for releasing bail in commercial quantity case. It is urged that in a chance recovery of narcotic substances by Assam Rifles …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MNHC:201
NON- REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Bail Appln. No. 5 of 2024
Seiminthang Mate aged about 35 years, S/o Thongkhopao Mate of Sibong
Khudengthabi, Tengnoupal District, Manipur-795131
… Petitioner/Accused
- Versus The Officer-in-Charge of Tengnoupal Police Station, Manipur-795131
… Respondent
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Osbert Khaling, Adv.
For the respondent
:
Mr. Y. Ashang, P.P. & Mrs. R.K. Emily, Dy. GA
Date of reserved
:
15.05.2026
Date of Judgement
:
10.09.2026
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard
Mr.
Osbert
Khaling,
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner/accused and Mr. Y. Ashang, learned PP assisted by Mrs. R.K. Emily,
learned Dy. GA on behalf of the State respondent.
[2]
The
present
bail
application
has
been
filed
by
the
petitioner/accused under Section 439 of Code of Criminal Procedure read with
Section 37 of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, 1985
praying for releasing the petitioner/accused on bail in connection with FIR Case
No. 49(12) 2022 TPL-PS under Sections 21(c)/29 & 60 (3) ND & PS Act, 1985
and the prayer of the petitioner is reproduced below:
Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025
2026:MNHC:201
(i) To issue notice to the respondent,
(ii) To grant regular bail u/s 439 of the Cr.P.C. to the petitioner/
accused namely Mr. Seiminthang Mate in connection with FIR
No. 49(12) 2022 TPL-PS U/s 21(c)/29 & 60 (3) ND & PS Act,
1985 and
(iii) Pass any order/direction which the Hon’ble Court deems fit and
proper in the facts and circumstances of the case as to meet
the end of justice.
Brief facts of the present case are as follows:
[3]
On 16.12.2022, the 20th Assam Rifles, Tengnoupal while in normal
course of checking found illegal contrabands drugs (49 packets of Brown Sugar
weighing about 2.163 kg including packing materials) hidden inside the seat of
a Mahindra Bolero bearing registration no. MN 01AG 9896 (white colour) being
driven by Mr. Mamang along with two passengers namely Mr. Seiminthang Mate
(petitioner herein) and Mr. Pandian of Ward No. 4, Premnagar, Moreh, Manipur.
While checking, the driver/owner of the said vehicle went to the toilet and fled
into the nearby dense jungle. Thereafter, seizure memo and arrest memo were
made for the two passengers and later handed over to the Officer-in-Charge of
Tengnoupal PS. On the same day, the Tengnoupal PS registered an FIR No.
49(12) 2022 TPL-PS U/s 21(c)/29 & 60 (3) ND & PS Act. On 17.12.2026, the
petitioner and other accused namely Pandian were sent to Police Custody for
6(six) days till 22.12.2022 by the Court of Ld. Chief Judicial Magistrate, Chandel.
On expiry of Police remand the accused persons were produced before learned
Judge Special Court (ND & PS), Manipur at Lamphel for remanding them into
Judicial custody for a period of 15(fifteen) days w.e.f. 22.12.2022 to 05.01.2023.
However, Ld. Judge Special Court (ND & PS), Manipur had remanded them into
judicial custody for a period of 8(eight) days till 29.12.2022 and also order them
to submit the progress report of the investigation on 29.12.2026 and the same
is submitted by the I.O of the case. Thereafter, chargesheet has been submitted
against the accused persons before the Ld. Special Judge (ND&PS), Manipur and
a Special Trial has been registered by the Ld. Special Judge as Special Trial No.
Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025
2026:MNHC:201
34 of 2023 and the stage of the case is at charge hearing. Moreover, the
petitioner filed a bail application u/s 439 Cr.P.C. before the Ld. Special Judge
(ND&PS), Manipur which was registered as Cril. Misc. (B) Case No. 277 of 2023
and the same was rejected on 28.12.2023 mainly on the ground that with the
recovery of narcotic substances of commercial quantity from the vehicle in which
the two arrested persons was travelling, there are sufficient materials for
proceeding against the accused persons. Hence, the petitioner filed the present
bail application before this Court.
[4]
Mr. Osbert, learned counsel for the petitioner/accused No.1
submits that the petitioner is only a passenger in the bolero vehicle driven and
owned by one Mamang and he was travelling to Imphal on that fateful day by
taking lift from Mamang. Since the driver escaped from the spot, the petitioner
and other passenger were arrested by the personnel of Assam Rifles in order to
make up their negligence in failure to arrest main accused Mamang. It is pointed
out that there is no material to presume conscious possession of narcotic
substance of commercial quantity against the petitioner and as such statutory
presumption of culpable mental state under Section 35 of NDPS Act, will not
operate against the petitioner. Learned counsel draws the attention of this Court
to the fact that there is no material to link the petitioner as owner of the seized
vehicle nor was he the owner of the contraband; and in absence of any credible
materials, the statutory presumption is not automatic. Violation of mandatory
provisions of Sections 50 and 57 of the Act is also alleged by the petitioner.
Rigors of Section 37 of the Act will not be applicable, as there is no material to
link the seizure of contrabands from the petitioner.
[5]
Mr. Osbert, learned counsel further continues that the petitioner
was first arrested on 16.12.2022 and he has been in custody for more than three
and half years and there is slow progress in the trial and it is not likely to
complete the trial in near future. It is highlighted, learned Spl Judge (NDPS),
Chandel is also in charge of Family Court, Manipur at Lamphelpat, Imphal (which
is more than 60 km apart). It is pointed out that the petitioner has no past
involvement in any criminal case except the present case and hence, the twin
Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025
2026:MNHC:201
test is in his favour. Reliance is placed on a decision of this Court in the case of
Ngangom Somorendro Singh v. Officer-in-Charge, Moreh Police
Station, [order dated 19.12.2022 in Bail Application No. 17 of 2022], where in
absence of any material of previous involvement of narcotic case, an accused
who was in custody for four months was leased on bail. Learned counsel also
refers another decision of this Court in the case of Harshala Desai v. Narcotics
Control Bureau, Imphal [Order dated 12.08.2025 in Bail Application No. 14 of
2025], in which the accused in custody for more than two years was released on
bail on ground of slow trial and long incarceration; as co-accused in the same
FIR was released on bail by Hon’ble Supreme Court. He has further cited a recent
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Rajadurai v. State of Tamil
Nadu: MANU/SCOR/29613/2026, where an accused in custody (recovery of
22.950 kgs of ganja) for more than one year was released on bail due to nonexamination of any witness after framing of charge. It is urged that the petitioner
is in custody for more than three and half years and there is hardly any progress
in the trial. It is prayed that the petitioner may be released on bail during the
pendency of the trial, as he is first time offender that too without any
incrimination materials; and the petitioner would be bound by any conditions as
imposed by this Court.
[6]
Per contra, Mr. Y. Ashang, learned PP submits that in a seizure of
commercial quantity, the bail application has to pass the strict rigors of twin test
as mandated by Section 37 of NDPS Act, i.e., (i) the accused is not likely to be
guilty of the offence, and (ii) he will not commit such offence while on bail. Since
the seizure was made from the vehicles in which the accused were travelling,
the statutory presumption of conscious possession under Section 35 of the Act
will operate against the petitioner. The question of whether the petitioner was a
passenger simpliciter or an accused is to be decided in trial and not in a bail
application hearing. It is pointed out that FSL report gave a positive finding for
heroin. Long incarceration is not the sole consideration for releasing bail in
commercial quantity case. It is urged that in a chance recovery of narcotic
substances by Assam Rifles without any prior information and that too from a
vehicle, the provisions of Section 50 of the Act will not be applicable. Learned PP
Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025
2026:MNHC:201
refers to the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India
vs. Vigin K. Varghese reported in 2025 INSC 1316 at para 18, where it was
held that any offences involving commercial quantity of narcotics drugs stand on
a distinct statutory footing. Section 37 enacts a specific embargo on the grant of
bail and obligates the Court to record satisfaction on the twin requirements
noticed above, in addition to the ordinary tests under the Code of Criminal
Procedure. In that case, High Court without appreciating the fact that the
petitioner, arrested in connection with commercial quantity of narcotics
substance on earlier occasion, does not satisfy the twin tests of statutory
satisfaction as laid down by Section 37(1)(b) of ND&PS Act. It is prayed that the
bail application be rejected.
[7]
This Court has considered the materials on record and the
decisions cited at bar. The admitted facts are: (i) since his arrest on 16.12.2022,
the petitioner is in custody for more than three and half years; (ii) the trial is at
a slow pace; (iii) the petitioner is a first time offender and has no previous
involvement in similar cases; (iv) apart from the fact that he was travelling in the
vehicles from which commercial quantity narcotic substance was seized, any
other material is not annexed with the charge sheet; and (v) no material is on
record to link or suspect the petitioner as owner of the seized vehicles.
[8]
With regards to the submission of Mr. Osbert, learned counsel for
the petitioner to the point that long incarceration is a ground for releasing on
bail involving commercial quantity as per decisions cited supra, it may be clarified
that there are instances of few decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court which
emphasize on personal liberty as enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India. However, the issue is settled (at least for the time being, awaiting
adjudication by a larger bench) in the latest decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of State of Punjab vs. Balraj Singh @ Billa reported in 2026
SCC Online SC 1058 and it was held in ‘para 17’ that when it comes to the
case involving commercial quantity of narcotics, the mandatory requirement of
Section 37 of ND&PS Act ought to be considered and reference to the twin
conditions enumerated under Section 37 of the Act is mandatory.
Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025
2026:MNHC:201
[9]
In a very recent judgment passed by this Court in the case of
Shri Lunkhogin Kipgen v. Officer-in-Charge, NAB PS, Imphal: 2026:
MNHC: 195 [judgment dated 08.09.2026 in Bail Application No. 33 of 2023], it
has been observed and held as below relying on a catena of decisions:
[14]
It is settled proposition of law that in a bail under ND&PS
Act involving commercial quantity, the Court has first to satisfy the twin
tests laid down by Section 37(1)(b). In fact, before the twin test is
applied; the prosecution has to be given an opportunity of being heard
for objecting the bail application involving commercial quantity. After
that the twin test will apply; firstly, the Court should have a reasonable
ground of believing that the accused is not guilty of such offence; and
secondly, he is not likely to commit offence while on bail. The latest
judgment of Balraj Singh @ Billa (supra), it has been specifically held
in ‘para 17’ that the rigor of Section 37 of ND&PS Act has to be satisfied
while considering the application in bail for an offence involving
commercial quantity. Long incarceration alone is not a ground to be
released on bail and rule of long incarceration as laid down in the
judgments cited above, i.e., Dheeraj Kumar Shukla (supra) & Rabi
Prakash (supra) has to be considered in tune with the principle laid
down in Balraj Singh @ Billa (supra) case. To put it differently, it
means that while considering bail application on ground of long
incarceration in custody without initiating the trial or in a trial with no
substantive progress, still the rigor of Section 37 of ND&PS Act has to be
satisfied, in view of the principle laid down in Balraj Singh @ Billa
(supra). Since the question of interplay of rigor of bail in special statute
and long incarceration along with the principle of speedy trial laid down
in Article 21 of the Constitution, is pending before larger bench of Hon’ble
Supreme Court, and in view of the decision of Sundeep Kumar Bafna
(supra); the principle of law, stands as on date, has to be followed by
High Court and Trial Court. Mere pendency of the question before the
larger bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court will not empower the High Court
or Trial Court to have a different view apart from the settled position of
law propounded in Balraj Singh @ Billa (supra), as the law stands
as on date. The same is in view of the principle of Article 141 of the
Constitution that all other Courts in India are bound by law declared by
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
[15]
In other words, while examining the bail application in a
special statute such as ND&PS, the twin tests laid down in Section 37 of
the ND&PS Act has to be followed while considering bail application on
the ground of long incarceration without any trial or in a trial with no
substantive progress. In the present case, this principle has to be
applied.
Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025
2026:MNHC:201
[10]
From the above cited decision, it is clear that at least for the State
of Manipur, the law is clear (as per Balraj Singh @ Billa), the twin test under
Section 37 of NDPS Act has to be satisfied in a bail application involving
commercial quantity of narcotic substances, irrespective of the fact of long
incarceration. Present case has to be examined in this legal prism.
[11]
In the case in hand, the petitioner is in custody since his arrest
on 16.12.2022 for more than three and half years. The trial is at a slow pace. As
per charge sheet, the petitioner does not have previous involvement in similar
offence. Apart from the fact that he was a passenger in the vehicle from which
commercial quantity contraband was seized, there is no credible materials in the
chargesheet against him. The ownership of the seized vehicle is not attributed
to him by the prosecution. The whole case is proceeding solely on the basis of
statutory presumption under Section 35 of NDPS Act, which a rebuttable
presumption.
[12]
Considering the settled proposition of law and admitted facts on
record, this Court is of the view that the present case satisfies the twin test under
Section 37 of NDPS Act; it is undisputed that the petitioner is in custody for more
than three and half years without much progress in trial; and the same can be
treated as long incarceration in custody. In the circumstances, the petitioner is
released on bail on submission of personal bond of Rs.1,00,000/- [Rupees one
lakh] with a surety [gazetted officer] of like amount to the satisfaction of learned
Special Judge (NDPS), Chandel on the following conditions:
(i) He shall appear before the Court on every date fixed by the
Court or as directed by the Court from time to time.
(ii) He shall not try to influence any persons acquainted with the
facts of the present case.
(iii) He shall not temper with any materials/evidence of the case.
(iv) He shall not leave the State of Manipur without the leave of
the Special Judge, (ND&PS), Chandel, Manipur.
(v) The passport, if any, of the petitioner shall be surrendered
before the Special Judge, (ND&PS), Chandel, Manipur.
Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025
2026:MNHC:201
(vi) On violation of any of the aforesaid conditions, the State
respondent is free to approach this Court for cancellation of
the bail.
[13]
With these observations, Bail Appln. No. 5 of 2024 is allowed and
disposed of.
[14]
Before concluding, it may be clarified that this Court does not
express any opinion on the merit of the case including the complexity of the
petitioner in connection with the present FIR and nothing stated and observed
herein, shall prejudice the Trial Court in the ongoing trial. Any observations and
findings made herein is confined for disposal of the bail application and the same
shall not construe as expression of the opinion by this Court on the merit of the
case. Trial Court is free to form its own opinion as per law in the factual
circumstances.
[15]
Registry is directed to send a copy of this order to the learned
Special Judge, (ND&PS), Chandel, Manipur for information.
Oinam
Oinam Thoiba Meitei
2026.09.10
Thoiba Meitei Date:
16:50:10 +05'30'
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Thoiba
Bail Appln. No. 6 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review