The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Therefore, in light of the observations made hereinabove, as the denial of appointment to the private respondent at the first instance was not justifiable in law and as this wrong was subsequently corrected by the authorities and that too on the strength of medical reports, this Court sees no reason to interfere with the orders, which have been assailed by way of this writ petition. The petition is, accordingly, dismissed. No order as to costs.
14. Taking into consideration the fact that the petitioner also belongs to the disabled category, it is impressed upon the Department that if there is any post lying vacant in District Bilaspur, where the petitioner can be adjusted, the same may done as an exceptional case, taking into consideration the peculiarities of the case in hand, wherein, the petitioner at the first instance was offered appointment and she also served for a period of 1 year and 9 months. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of. February 24, 2026 (Vinod) (Ajay Mohan Goel) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:3907
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT
SHIMLA
CWP No. 12795 of 2024
Decided on 24th February 2026
Seema Devi
…Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
For the petitioner:
M/s Anshul Attri and Ankit Chandel,
Advocates.
For the respondents: Mr. Rajpal Thakur, Additional Advocate
General.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge (Oral)
By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for the following reliefs:(i)
“That the impugned order dated 1st October, 2023
(Annexure P-5) passed by the learned 2nd Appellate
Authority in Appeal No.94/2024 titled as “Seema
Devi versus Rajneesh Thakur and others” may
kindly be quashed and set aside.
(ii)
That consequently the impugned termination order
dated 15th March, 2024 (Annexure P-3) passed by
the learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate (Civil) Sadar
District Bilaspur, H.P. may also be set aside.
2026:HHC:3907
(iii)
That resultantly the petitioner may kindly be ordered
to be reinstated as Part Time Multi Task Worker in
Government
Primary
School
Luharda,
District
Bilaspur, H.P. alongwith consequential benefits, in
the interest of justice.”
2.
Brief facts necessary for the adjudication of this
petition are that process was initiated by the Education
Department to fill up the post of Part Time Multi Task Worker in
Government Primary School, Luharda, Tehsil Sadar, District
Bilaspur, H.P., for the year 2021-22. The petitioner alongwith
the private respondent and some other candidates participated
in the said process. In terms of Annexure P-1, communication
dated 04.07.2022, the petitioner was declared successful
candidate and was offered appointment against the post of Part
Time Multi Task Worker. Her appointment was assailed by the
private respondent by way of an appeal before the First
Appellate Authority under Rule 19 of the Part Time Multi Task
Workers Policy, 2020. In terms of Annexure P-2, the appeal
filed by the private respondent was allowed. The services of the
petitioner were terminated.
Appeal filed by the present
petitioner against the order of termination was dismissed by the
2026:HHC:3907
Authorities. Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner has approached
this Court assailing the said orders, including the order of
termination passed by the Authority dated 15.03.2024.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the
petitioner and the private respondent are both physically
disabled. He submitted that, whereas, the petitioner is suffering
from deformity with regard to her eyes, the private respondent
is mentally retarded. He argued that the private respondent is
not mentally fit to be offered appointment and initially the
appointment was rightly offered to the petitioner. The act of the
Appellate Authority of allowing the appeal filed by the petitioner
was totally unsustainable in the eyes of law, as the Authority
erred in not appreciating that the private respondent was
suffering from mental illness, which rendered him incapacitated
to perform the duties of the post in issue. Learned counsel
further submitted that the subsequent act of the authorities, of
having the private respondent examined by the medical
authorities, offering him appointment and the rejection of the
appeals preferred by the present petitioner against the order of
her termination are also thus not sustainable in the eyes of law
2026:HHC:3907
for the reason that the offer of appointment to the petitioner at
the first instance was justifiable in the eyes of law, whereas,
termination of the service of the petitioner is bad in law and this
extremely important aspect of the matter has been ignored by
the Appellate Authorities while passing the impugned orders.
No other point was urged.
4.
On the other hand learned Additional Advocate
General referred to the orders passed by the Appellate
Authority dated 28.07.2023, 08.08.2024 and 10.09.2024 and
submitted that said orders are self-speaking and do not call for
any
interference.
Learned
Additional
Advocate
General
submitted that when initially appeal was preferred by the private
respondent against the appointment of the present petitioner, it
is not as if the Appellate Authority ordered his appointment
forthwith. He further submitted that what the Appellate Authority
did was that while accepting the appeal, it directed the Block
Elementary Education Officer-cum-Member Secretary Sadar,
District
Bilaspur
to
seek
clarifications
from
Education
Department whether the Department had identified certain
benchmark
disabilities
like
mental
illness/mental
2026:HHC:3907
retardation/autism as not suitable for the post of Part Time Multi
Task Worker. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submitted that in compliance to this order, needful was done by
the Department, which led to the passing of the termination
order of the present petitioner dated 15.03.2024. He submitted
that the termination order is demonstrative of the fact that
proper medical opinion was obtained with regard to the mental
fitness of the private respondent and the certificate which was
issued by the Chief Medical Officer concerned was to the effect
that there was nothing to suggest that the said respondent was
not fit for the job of a Part Time Multi Task Worker. Learned
Additional Advocate General also submitted that this aspect of
the matter cannot be ignored in the present case that the
private respondent herein was found to be more meritorious in
the selection process as compared to the present petitioner.
Accordingly, he argued that as there is no infirmity in the
impugned order, the present petition be dismissed.
5.
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
private
respondent has adopted the arguments of learned Additional
Advocate General. In addition, he argued that the contention of
2026:HHC:3907
the petitioner that the private respondent is medically unfit to
perform the duties of Part Time Multi Task Worker is without
any basis. He submitted that medical experts have opined that
the private respondent is not unfit to perform the duties of the
office and this view of the experts neither can be substituted by
the Court nor the petitioner. Learned counsel has also referred
to the provisions of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 in general
and Section 3(5) in particular and argued that it is not for the
petitioner to undertake the exercise of issuing certificates to the
effect as to whether a person is of unsound mind or not.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
have also carefully gone through the pleadings and documents
appended therewith.
7.
It is not in dispute that in the selection process
which was undertaken by the Committee to fill up the post of
Part Time Multi Task Worker, the private respondent was found
to be more meritorious than the present petitioner, on the basis
of the criteria for selection contained in the Multi Task Worker
Policy, 2020. After the authority issued appointment letter to the
present petitioner dated 05.07.2022, her appointment was
2026:HHC:3907
assailed by the private respondent, primarily on the ground that
despite him being more meritorious than the petitioner, his
candidature was rejected only on the ground that he was
mentally retarded. This as per him was done ignoring the fact
that the disability certificate which was produced by him
demonstrated that he was not suffering from such mental
illness, which caused an impediment to offer him the
appointment.
8.
In terms of the order passed by the Appellate
Authority dated 28.07.2023 (Annexure P-2), the authority
allowed the appeal by returning the following reasoning:“Based on the pleading of the Ld.
Counsel of both parties and perusal of record of
BEEO Sadar following points arise for
determination:
i.
Whether the candidate is a case of
disability more than 40%, if yes then category
of disability?
ii.
Whether mental illness comes in the
category of benchmark disability?
iii. Whether Govt. limits mental illness disability
candidates from recruitment?
iv. Whether department of education released
any
clarification/notification
regarding
unsuitability of any benchmark disability for this
multi task workers post?
2026:HHC:3907
v.
Whether soundness of mind of appellant
was examined by an expert in selection
committee?
vi. Whether the impugned order is liable to be
set aside on the basis of material on record?
vii. Relief.
For the reason to be recorded hereinafter
while discussing the points for determination,
my findings on the same are:
Point 1: Yes more than 40% disability in
the category of mental illness.
Point 2: Yes, as per letter No. PER(AP)C-F(4)-1/2020 dated 22.06.2020 of Department
of Personnel, Shimla HP, it comes under the
category of benchmark disability.
Point 3: No, mental illness disability
candidates are not barred.
Point 4: No.
Point 5: No, there was no medical expert
in selection committee.
Point 6: Yes.
Point 7: The appeal is partially allowed for
reasons recorded below:Reasons of finding:1. From the perusal of letter No.
PER(AP)-C-F(4)-1/2020 dated 22.06.2020 of
Department of Personnel, Shimla HP:
"2. Quantum of reservation:
2.1 In case of direct recruitment, four percent
of the total number of vacancies to be filled up
by direct recruitment, in cadre strength in each
group/class of posts ie Group class-1, II, III &
posts/services shall be reserved for persons
with benchmark disabilities.
2.2 Against the posts identified for each
disabilities, of which, one percent each shall be
reserved for persons with benchmark
disabilities under clauses (a), (b) and (c) and
2026:HHC:3907
one percent, under clauses (d) and (e), unless
otherwise excluded under the provisions of
para 3 herein under:
a) Blindness and low vision,
b) Deaf and hard hearing,
c) Locomotor disability including cerebral palsy,
leprosy cured, dwarfism, acid attack victims and
muscular dystrophy:
d) Autism, intellectual disability, specific
learning disability and mental illness,
e) Multiple disabilities from amongst persons
under clauses (a) to (d) including deaf
blindness.
3.
Exemption from Reservation:
Any establishment, in consultation with
the State Commissioner (Disabilities), may,
having regard to the type of work carried out in
any Govt. establishment, by notification and
subject to such conditions, if any, as may be
specified in such notifications exempt any Govt.
establishment from providing reservation to
person with benchmark disabilities. However,
the State Govt. has exempted the post of
drivers (Light & Heavy vehicles) in all
departments/Himachal
Road
Transport
Corporation, Police Constables and Firemen in
Civil Defence and Home Guards for the
purpose of reservation to the persons with
disabilities vide letter No. Karmik (NI-11) B(12)11/76 dated 20.02.1982.
4.
IDENTIFICATION OF JOBS/POSTS AND
ANNUAL REPORT:
4.1 Every Govt. establishment shall (i) identify
posts in the establishments which can be held
by respective category of persons with
benchmark disabilities in respect of the
vacancies reserved in accordance with para-2
above (ii) constitute an expert committee with
representation of persons with benchmark
2026:HHC:3907
disabilities for identification of such posts: and
(iii) undertake periodic review of the identified
posts at an interval not exceeding three years.
4.2 Every appointing authority/establishment
shall
sent
annual
report
regarding
representation of persons with disabilities,
showing position as on first of January every
year to the Social Justice and Empowerment
department who will compile the data being the
nodal department.
4.3 The structure of the expert committee for
the identification of posts which are to be
reserved for the persons with benchmark
disabilities has been notified by the Directorate
of Empowerment of SCs, OBCs, Minorities and
the specially abled, HP vide letter No. 4-1/2016(43)-SOM-WEL-(Identification)-19895-20015
dated 31.10.2018."
2.
Based on the record on file and the
appellant's and respondent averments, it is
clear that mental illness comes under the
category of benchmark disability and until &
unless specifically excluded in policy, it shall be
considered. There is no bar for selection of
person with mental illness.
3.
Moreover in this case, appellant appeared
in this court and while communication he was
found well oriented to time, place and person.
From the perusal of records it has also come to
the notice that appellant has cleared middle
examination in the year 2015. In totality,
impressions comes in the mind of undersigned
that appellant was not properly examined by
expert member during selection process. His
disability certificate was misinterpreted as of
that person with mental illness is equivalent to
person with unsound mind. This interpretation is
clearly not in consonance with mandate of
Government's policy as mentioned in letter No.
2026:HHC:3907
PER(AP)-C. F(4)-1/2020 dated 22.06.2020 of
Department of Personnel. Such posts must be
filled keeping in mind the interest of physically
disabled persons and person with benchmark
disabilities too.
4.
Therefore, in view of above findings, I
hereby partially accept the appeal and direct
respondent no.2 to seek clarification from
Education department that if the department
has identified benchmark disabilities like mental
illness/mental retardation/ autism not suitable
for this post (Part Time Multi Task Worker) if not
barred by Education Department, then this
mental illness category cannot be barred from
applying for these posts and appellant should
be given opportunity as per guidelines.
5.
After
receiving
clarification
from
Education department, BEEO must reconstitute
the committee under the chairmanship of Sub
Divisional Magistrate and Chairman must
ensure that soundness of mind of appellant is
examined by medical expert. Chairman must
pass speaking order with proper reasoning
regarding selection/rejection of appellant in this
matter and the entire process must be
completed within a month of receipt of the copy
of this order by the respondent no. 1 &
respondent No. 2.
The case file of this court be consigned to
the General Record Room after due
completion.”
9.
The reasoning given by the said authority which has
been quoted by me hereinabove is prudent reasoning and
during the course of the arguments addressed by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, it could not be demonstrated that the
2026:HHC:3907
reasons spelled out in this order were perverse. This is more so
for the reason that the Appellate Authority prudently did not
undertake the exercise of issuing any certificate in favour of the
appellant on its own as to whether he was mentally fit or not to
discharge the duties of the post, but, in terms of the findings
returned in the order, it partly allowed the appeal and directed
respondent No.2 therein to seek clarification from the Education
Department whether the actual disability from which the said
appellant was suffering stood declared as a disability barring a
candidate from applying for the post in issue or not. In this
backdrop, when one peruses the termination order of the
petitioner dated 15.03.2024, perusal thereof demonstrates that
after the appeal of the private respondent was decided, a
clarification was sought from the Director of Elementary
Education by the authority concerned and in terms of the
clarification, Clause-3 of the eligibility criteria of the relevant
policy stated that only such candidates will be eligible to apply
for the post in issue who are of sound mind.
10.
In fact, a Committee was reconstituted under the
Chairmanship of SDM to examine the soundness of mind of the
2026:HHC:3907
private respondent and he was examined by Department of
Psychiatry, AIIMS Bilaspur & District Disability Medical Board,
Bilaspur and the report of the Department of Psychiatry AIIMS,
Bilaspur, as is also mentioned in the termination order of the
petitioner, reads as under:“Patient reported in Psychiatry OPD, AIIMS
Bilaspur on 16.10.2023 for psychiatry evaluation
and patient was referred to PGI Chandigarh for IQ
assessment. He was again assessed on dated
08.01.2024 with IQ report. On the basis of history,
mental status examination & IQ assessment, we
are of the opinion that Mr. Rajneesh Thakur, S/o
Sh. Ram Singh is suffering from “Mild intellectual
disability disorder” which commensurate with 50%
disability. This condition originated during
developmental period and he has significantly
below average intellectual functioning & social
functioning. He also has physical deformities and
inadequate language development for which he
requires consultation with orthopedic surgeon and
ENT specialist respectively His condition may
interfere in independent living and he may require
appropriate support. The unsoundness of mind is
not used in medical parlance.”
11.
Not only this, a clarification was also received by
the said Committee from CMO, District Bilaspur as to whether
the private respondent was fit to perform the duties of the post
in issue and the relevant portion of the medical certificate which
finds mentioned in the termination order of the petitioner reads
as under:-
2026:HHC:3907
“According to clarification by the Chief
Medical Officer, District Bilaspur the detailed
assessment report/certificate in r/o Sh. Rajneesh
Thakur, S/o Sh. Ram Singh issued by Medical
specialist,
Psychiatry
Department,
AIIMS
Bilaspur, which is self explanatory. There is
nothing to suggest that Mr. Rajneesh Thaiur, S/o
Sh. Ram Singh not fit for the job of part time multi
task worker in view of bove stated report.
However, the health department issues the
medical fitness certificate for first entry in Govt.
service upon the issuance of appointment order
by the employer.”
12.
These are the reasons, which led to the issuance of
the termination order of the petitioner and it could not be
demonstrated during the course of hearing of this petition that
the findings of the experts which have been quoted in the
termination order, were not actually returned by the medical
experts. In this backdrop, if one peruses the orders passed by
the Appellate Authorities dated 08.08.2024 and 10.09.2024,
preferred by the present petitioner against her termination, one
cannot find any fault therein for the reason that these
authorities have also relied upon the reports of the medical
experts, who found the private respondent herein fit to perform
the duties of a Part Time Multi Task Worker.
2026:HHC:3907
13.
Therefore, in light of the observations made
hereinabove, as the denial of appointment to the private
respondent at the first instance was not justifiable in law and as
this wrong was subsequently corrected by the authorities and
that too on the strength of medical reports, this Court sees no
reason to interfere with the orders, which have been assailed
by way of this writ petition. The petition is, accordingly,
dismissed. No order as to costs.
14.
Taking into consideration the fact that the petitioner
also belongs to the disabled category, it is impressed upon the
Department that if there is any post lying vacant in District
Bilaspur, where the petitioner can be adjusted, the same may
done as an exceptional case, taking into consideration the
peculiarities of the case in hand, wherein, the petitioner at the
first instance was offered appointment and she also served for
a period of 1 year and 9 months. Pending miscellaneous
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
February 24, 2026
(Vinod)
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review