Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 15.01.2026
Date of decision:27.01.2026
Uploaded on: 28.01.2026
+
RFA(OS)2/2026 & CM APPL.117/2026, CM APPL.118/2026, CM
APPL.119/2026
SAVITRI SHARMA & ANR.
.....Appellants
Through:
Mr. N. S. Dalal, Ms. Nidhi Dalal, Mr.
Alok Kumar, Ms. Rachna Dalal,
Advs.
versus
BHAGWANI DEVI NOW DECEASED THROUGH ALL LEGAL
HEIRS & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Ms. Chandrika Prasad Mishra, Mr.
Ankit Pandey, Ms. Prashasti Singh,
Ms. Harshita Bhardwaj, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
SHAIL JAIN, J.
1.
The present Appeal has been preferred under Section 96 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”),inter alia,
assailing the Order dated 12th November, 2025 (hereinafter referred to as
“Impugned Order”) and seeking the following reliefs:
“i) Set-aside the impugned order dated 12.11.2025 passed by the Ld.
Single Judge in C.S. (O.S.) No.411 of 2022 titled as "Savitri Sharma &
Another Vs. Bhagwani Devi (Since Deceased) & Others";
(ii) Decree the Suit being C.S. (O.S.) No.411 of 2022 titled as "Savitri
Sharma & Another Vs. Bhagwani Devi (Since Deceased) & Others"
and grant the relief as prayed for therein, in the interest of justice:
(iii) Award costs of the present Appeal in favour of the Appellants and
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:41:32
RFA(OS)2/2026
against the Respondents:
(iv) Pass any such other or further orders as this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit and proper on the facts and in the circumstances of the case
in favour of the Appellants and against the Respondents.”
2.
By way of the Impugned Order, the learned Single Judge has allowed
the two Applications being I.A. 16884/2022 and I.A. 3665/2023, seeking
amendment of the plaint, and while considering the Suit being CS (OS)
411/2022 along with Application being I.A.10980/2022, filed under Order
XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of the CPC, the learned Single Judge rejected the Suit
under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC on the ground that no cause of action
was disclosed.
3.
The case set up by the Plaintiffs/Appellants is that Respondent
No.1/Late Smt. Bhagwani Devi,was their mother; Respondent Nos. 2 to 5
are their brothers; Respondent No.6 is their sister-in-law; and Respondent
Nos. 7 and 8 are their nieces.
4.
The properties, which are the subject matter of the present appeal, are
stated to be ancestral in nature. The said properties originally belonged to
Late Sh. Aasa Ram, the grandfather of the Plaintiffs/Appellants, and upon
his demise in the year 1987, such properties devolved upon his five (5) sons,
including Late Sh. Dayanand Sharma, father of the Plaintiffs/Appellants.The
particulars of the properties-in-question are as follows:
I.
Property bearing Khata No. 188/2 Kharsa No. 41/10, 11/1,
12/3, 19, measuring 3252.48 Gaj Appx, situated in the Revenue
Estate of Village Mehrauli, Delhi, the property known as
Mehruali, Delhi.;
II.
One Residential Property bearing no. 626/27/28, Village & PO
Rajokri, New Delhi- 110038, Area measuring 500 Sqr Yards
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:41:32
RFA(OS)2/2026
Appx.’
III.
Property bearing Khatauni No. 40/36 Khasra No. 1108(4-3),
1109(4-16), 1111/1(2-0); Khatauni No. 42/39, Khasra No.
1102(4-5), 1110 (3-18) at Rajokri, Delhi;
IV.
Property bearing Khasra No. 152/140 Khasra No. 15555(4-16),
1556(4-16), 1560(4-4), 15621/1(3-1); Khatauni No. 41/37
Khasra no. 1559(4-16), 1561 (2-6); Khatauni No. 190/178
Khasra No. 1557(4-16), 1558(4-16), 1562/2(1-9) at Rajokri,
Delhi.
5.
According to the Appellants, the properties which came to the share
of their father were Joint Hindu Undivided Family (“HUF”) properties and
he became the Karta of the HUF in respect of the one-fifth (1/5th) share that
devolved upon him. Thereafter, Late Sh. Dayanand Sharma expired on 3rd
October, 2017.
6.
After the demise of their father, the Appellants sought partition of the
properties, however, the Respondents, in whose favour the mutation of the
properties had been sanctioned, did not accede to the said request.
Aggrieved thereby, the Appellants filed a Suit for Declaration, Partition &
Permanent Injunction before the learned Single Judge of this Court.
7.
From the pleadings of the Respondents before the learned Single
Judge, it came to the knowledge of the Plaintiffs/Appellants that Late Sh.
Dayanand Sharma had executed a Will dated 16th December, 1999, in
favour of Respondent Nos. 2, 3, 4, 5, 7 and 8; and a Sale Deed dated 11th
December, 1986, in respect of certain properties in favour of Respondent
No.1. Consequently, the plaint was amended and the Plaintiffs/Appellants
sought a declaration ofthe said Will dated 16th December, 1999 and Sale
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:41:32
RFA(OS)2/2026
Deed dated 11th December, 1986 as null and void.
8.
The learned Single Judge, vide Impugned Order rejected the suit filed
by the Plaintiffs/Appellants on the ground that no cause of action was
disclosed in the plaint. Aggrieved thereof, the Appellants preferred the
present Appeal.
9.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
10.
The principal reasoning adopted by the learned Single Judge was that
no HUF existed at the time of the death of the Late Sh. Dayanand Sharma,
and, therefore, the Plaintiffs/Appellants could neither be treated as
coparceners nor members of an HUF. Consequently, it was held that they
did not inherit any right in the properties-in-question.
11.
Relying upon the judgment inSunny (Minor)&Anr. v. Sh. Raj
Singh&Ors., 2015 SCC OnLine Del 13446, the learned Single Judge further
observed that after coming into force of Hindu Succession Act, 1956, any
property inherited by a Hindu male from his predecessor-in-interest would
be treated as his individual property and not as coparcenary property.
12.
The learned Single Judge also observed that after the institution of the
suit, the Plaintiffs/Appellants had amended the plaint on two occasions, and
that in the latest amendment it was merely pleaded that since the suit
properties were HUF properties, the father of the Plaintiffs/Appellants could
not have executed the Will dated 16th December, 1999. It was further noted
that even in the amended plaint, no specific challenge had been laid to the
validity or genuineness of the Will under the Indian Succession Act.
13.
Accordingly, the learned Single Judge held, first, that no HUF existed
in which the Plaintiffs/Appellants could claim any right, and secondly, that
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:41:32
RFA(OS)2/2026
the Plaintiffs/Appellants had not challenged the Will executed by Late Sh.
Dayanand Sharma in favour of Respondent Nos. 2 to 5, 7 and 8. On the
basis of the aforesaid, it was held that no cause of action was made out, and
the plaint was rejected.
14.
The Impugned Order has been challenged primarily on three grounds.
First, that there existed a Hindu Undivided Family comprising Late Sh.
Dayanand Sharma and his legal heirs and, therefore, the properties inherited
by him from his ancestors could not have been alienated by him in favour of
Respondent No.1. Secondly, it is contended that the Will dated 16th
December, 1999, allegedly executed by the Late Sh. Dayanand Sharma in
favour of Respondent Nos. 2 to 5, 7 and 8, is a sham and fictitious
document. Thirdly, it is submitted that post the 2005 amendment in the
Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the status of the daughters has been elevated to
that of a coparcener in every respect, at par with the sons, and the right of
the daughters cannot be curtailed on the mere ground of non-existence of a
Hindu Undivided Family, since they are Class-I legal heirs. Reliance is
placed on Nirmala &Ors. vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi &Ors., 2010 SCC
OnLine Del 2232.
15.
Undisputedly, in the present case, the question of existence of a cause
of action in favour of the Appellant is a mixed question of law and fact,
which cannot ordinarily be determined merely on a plain reading of the
plaint.
16.
The
observation
of
the
learned
Single
Judge
that
the
Plaintiffs/Appellants did not challenge the Will in the amended plaint, prima
facie, does not appear to be correct. Our attention was drawn to Paragraph
14 of the amended plaint, which contains categorical pleadings alleging that
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:41:32
RFA(OS)2/2026
the Will dated 16th December, 1999, is sham, fictitious, and fraudulently
brought into existence, and that Late Sh. Dayanand Sharma lacked the
competence to execute such Will in respect of the ancestral coparcenary
properties. The relevant paragraph of the Amended Plaint on record is
extracted hereunder“14. That as learnt from the written statement filed by the defendant
No. 1, 2, 5 to 8 that Sh. Dayanand had also executed alleged Will
dated 16.12.1999 in favour of defendant No. 2 to 5.7 und 8 which
infact is again a sham and fictitious document so fraudulently got
created by the beneficiaries and the other defendants and their
associates as legally late Sh. Dayanand was not competent and
capable to execute the alleged Will in respect of Joint Hindu
undivided coparcenary ancestral properties and thus the exceeding of
right by late Sh. Dayanand by executing the said Will is legally
untenable and depicts that deliberately in order to deprive the
plaintiffs, the fraud has been perpetuated by the defendants with
deceased Sh. Dayanand knowingly well that the subject properties as
mentioned in the alleged Will do not belongs to deceased Dayanand
as it was Joint Hindu undivided coparcenary ancestral properties
wherein the plaintiffs' right have accrued being coparceners on
account of their respective birth in the Joint Hindu undivided
coparcenary family and further the alleged impugned Will ought not
to have been executed as the same was not even for the benefit of the
management of the joint Hindu ancestral coparcenary properties and
when the alleged execution of Will is without legal necessity and not
for the benefit of the management of the joint Hindu ancestral
coparcenary properties then the alleged Will dated 16.12.1999
allegedly registered in the Office of Joint Sub-Registrar, Gurgaon,
vide document No. 579 in book No. 3. ZIld No. 142 on pages 96-97 on
16.12.1999 is sham and fictitious. The defendants till the filing of the
written statement have concealed and have kept secretly the alleged
Will and had not shown the light of the day nor it was ever brought to
the notice of the plaintiffs and even the plaintiffs are sure in their
person that where ever the alleged Will has been used in a clandestine
manner, the plaintiffs were not informed to those authorities being the
legal heirs of deceased Dayanand and hence, the alleged Will dated
16.12.1999 being based on a fraudulent act is liable to be declared
null and void being ineffective qua the rights of the plaintiffs and thus
the plaintiffs are entitled for the relief of declaration in this context,
the properties which have been made part and parcel of alleged sale
deed dated 11.12.1986 and the alleged Will dated 16.12.1999 are
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:41:32
RFA(OS)2/2026
infact legally having undivided coparcenary right of the plaintiffs with
their ownership rights coupled with possession in the said subject
properties being Joint Hindu undivided coparcenary ancestral
properties which are being used, occupied at the spot in which the
plaintiffs have their share by birth being co-owner/ coparcener/cosharer and have every right, title and interest therein which is being
threatened by the defendants is thus required to be separated by way
of decree of partition and further the said undivided right, title and
interest of the plaintiffs in the subject properties is required to be
protected by way of decree of permanent injunction during the
pendency of the suit.”
17.
A bare perusal of the amended plaint clearly reveals that the
Plaintiffs/Appellants have specifically challenged the Will dated 16 th
December, 1999, and have categorically pleaded that the said Will is a sham
and fictitious document and sought a declaration to that effect. We are of the
view that unless the parties are afforded an opportunity to lead evidence,
such question of the genuineness and validity of the Will-in-question cannot
be conclusively determined at the threshold.
18.
At this juncture, it is imperative to refer to the judgment of Nirmala
(supra), wherein it has been held by the Co-ordinate bench that the Section
4 has an overriding effect over Section 50 of the Delhi Land Reforms Act,
1954, and the daughter will have equal rights in succession of the
agricultural property. The relevant paragraph thereof is as under:
“28. It is in the light of these arguments, that the questions posed in
paragraph 10 above need to be answered. We may straightaway say
that the answers to the questions are that the rule of succession
contained in Section 50 of the DLR Act has been repealed by virtue of
the omission of Section 4(2) of HSA in 2005 and that, as a result, the
rule of succession would be the one prescribed under the HSA (as
amended). Consequently, the petitioners, being female, have the right
to succeed to the disputed agricultural land inasmuch as succession
opened out, in this case, on 15.12.2006 on the death of Late Inder
Singh.”
(emphasis added)
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:41:32
RFA(OS)2/2026
19.
In light of the aforesaid position of law, the Appellant/daughters,
being the Class-I legal heir, are also entitled to assert their rights in the
subject property, even being the agricultural land, however, determination of
such rights is also required to be adjudicated on the basis of the evidence
adduced by them.
20.
Thus, in the considered opinion of this Court, in the facts and
circumstances of the present case, the plaint cannot be rejected at the
threshold on the ground of absence of cause of action, The Appellants ought
to be afforded an opportunity to establish their case by leading evidence.
21.
Accordingly, the present Appeal is allowed and the Impugned Order
dated 12th November, 2025 is set aside.
22.
The matter is remanded back to the learned Single Judge for afresh
consideration on merits, after affording due opportunity to all parties to lead
evidence, in accordance with law.
23.
The parties, through their counsels, are directed to appear before the
learned Single Judge on 03.02.2026.
24.
In view of the above, the present appeal, along with pending
applications, stands disposed of.
SHAIL JAIN
(JUDGE)
VIVEK CHAUDHARY
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 27, 2026/Pallavi/MM/kp
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:41:32
RFA(OS)2/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review