Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
+
: 04.11.2025
: 05.01.2026
: 05.01.2026
CRL.A. 1062/2016
SAURAV GUPTA
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Stuti Gujral, Advocate (Amicus
Curiae) with Mr. Miran Ahmad, and
Mr. Vipin Kumar, Advocates with
Appellant in person.
versus
STATE
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Shubhi Gupta, APP for State with
SI Ashwani Yadav, P.S. Kotla
Mubarakpur
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
The present appeal is directed against the judgment and order on
sentence dated 17.09.2016 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge02, South-East District, Saket Courts, in SC No. 1832/2016 arising out of
FIR No. 195/2014 registered at P.S. Kotla Mubarakpur, whereby the
appellant was convicted for the offence punishable under Section 394 IPC
and acquitted of the charge under Section 397 IPC.
Vide the impugned order on sentence, the appellant was directed to
undergo RI for 5 years along with paying a fine of Rs.15,000/-, in default
whereof he would undergo SI for 1 year. His sentence was suspended during
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
pendency of the appeal vide order dated 03.05.2017.
2.
The prosecution case, in brief, is that on 07.03.2014 at about 12:45
AM, the complainant/Saurabh @ Nikhil was allegedly taken by the
appellant to the roof of a house in Sewa Nagar, where, after consumption of
liquor, the appellant allegedly robbed him of his diamond ring, mobile
phone, and cash amounting to Rs.13,000-14,000/-, and inflicted an injury on
his face using an ustra. On the basis of the statement of the complainant
recorded by the police (Ex. PW-4/A), the subject FIR No. 195/2014 was
registered under Sections 394/341/323/506 IPC. While charges under
Sections 394/397/506 IPC were framed against the appellant, the two coaccused at the time, namely Mohit and Yash, were discharged vide order
dated 22.11.2014.
3.
During the course of trial, the prosecution examined 9 witnesses,
including police officials associated with the registration of the FIR,
investigation, arrest of the appellant, seizure of case property, and recovery
proceedings, as well as a medical witness who proved the MLC of the
injured. The prosecution case principally rested upon the testimony of the
injured complainant (PW-4), who supported the prosecution version with
respect to the occurrence, the identity of the appellant, and the alleged
recovery of robbed articles. In addition thereto, the prosecution relied upon
the recovery of the complainant’s mobile phone at the instance of the
appellant from the repair shop of PW-7/Puneet Gupta, which factum was
supported by the testimonies of PW-7 as well as his father, PW-3, who was
a witness to the recovery.
4.
The injured complainant (PW-4) deposed that on 07.03.2014 at about
12:45 AM, he was called by his cousin Yash, whereafter he met Mohit and
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
the appellant. He stated that they consumed liquor at the ground floor of
their house. Thereafter, Mohit took the accused aside and had a conversation
with him. Subsequently, the appellant came to the complainant and told him
that he would make him “enjoy” that day. The complainant then
accompanied the accused to Sewa Nagar, to the roof of a house, where they
consumed more liquor. He stated that the appellant forcibly took out his
diamond ring, Rs.13,000-14,000/-, and his mobile phone. When the witness
protested, the appellant took out an ustra and hit him on the face with the
same. He further stated that he sustained an injury on the left portion of his
cheek and was taken by PCR to AIIMS Trauma Centre. His statement
recorded by the police was exhibited as Ex. PW-4/A. He also identified his
mobile phone (Ex. P-4), two scissor blades (Ex. P-1 & Ex. P-2), and
currency notes of Rs.2,600/- (Ex. P-3).
In cross-examination, the complainant admitted that Mohit and Yash
were his cousins and certain property disputes existed between them. He
further stated that that the quarrel took place after consumption of liquor and
that he was injured by a “half ustra blade”, the same kind which is used by
barbers in saloons. The police did not seize his blood-stained clothes. The
incident took place around 2:00 AM and the quarrel lasted for 5-10 minutes.
5.
Rajender Singh, Record Clerk, AIIMS Trauma Centre (PW-8) proved
the complainant’s MLC No. 415490 dated 07.03.2014 (Ex. PW-8/A)
prepared by Dr. Hemraj, which records a laceration on the left angle of the
complainant’s mouth admeasuring 2 cm. The injury was opined to be simple
in nature.
6.
Pramod Kumar Gupta (PW-3) deposed that the appellant had given a
Samsung mobile phone for repair at his son’s shop at 666/667, Subhash
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
Market, which was later seized by the police vide Ex. PW-3/A.
7.
Puneet Gupta (PW-7), who ran the concerned mobile repair shop,
corroborated PW-3’s version and stated that the appellant gave him a mobile
phone for repairing. Two days thereafter, police officials came to his shop
along with Saurabh Gupta and the witness gave the said mobile phone to the
police officials.
8.
Both PW-3 and PW-7 were cross-examined, but they remained
consistent about the recovery of the mobile phone from the concerned repair
shop at the instance of the appellant.
9.
The I.O. of the case, SI Amrender Kumar (PW-6), deposed about
recording of the complainant’s statement, preparation of the rukka (Ex. PW6/A), the site plan (Ex. PW-4/B), the arrest of the appellant on 13.03.2014,
and the recovery of two scissor blades and Rs.2,600/- from the appellant’s
possession, which were seized vide seizure memo (Ex. PW-6/E).
10.
Ct. Sanjay Kumar (PW-9) deposed about the appellant’s arrest and the
recovery of articles from his possession. He admitted in cross-examination
that no public witness was joined at the time of the appellant’s arrest and the
subsequent recovery of articles.
11.
Ct. Raj Kumar (PW-5) deposed about the recovery of the mobile
phone from the concerned repair shop.
12.
In his statement dated 06.09.2016 recorded under Section 313
Cr.P.C., the appellant admitted that he had consumed liquor with the
complainant on the date of the incident. He also admitted that he took the
police party to the concerned mobile repair shop where he had given the
complainant’s mobile phone for repair, and that the complainant’s mobile
phone was taken into police possession. He denied having robbed the
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
complainant, having used an ustra upon him, and the recovery of any
scissors from his possession. He claimed false implication and declined to
lead defence evidence.
13.
Learned Amicus Curiae for the appellant, while assailing the findings
recorded in the impugned judgment, referred to the testimony of the
complainant to contend that once it has come on record that the incident
occurred under the influence of liquor, the appellant’s conviction under
Section 394 IPC is unsustainable. It was further contended that the material
on record demonstrates that the incident was the result of a sudden quarrel,
rather than a premeditated act of robbery. The prosecution’s reliance on the
medical evidence in the form of the complainant’s MLC was also questioned
on the ground that the MLC was exhibited through a Record Clerk (PW-8),
who had no personal knowledge of its contents. The recovery of the surgical
scissors in two pieces is doubted for it not being made in the presence of any
public witness. Neither was the alleged weapon of offence, i.e. the blade,
sent for forensic examination, nor were the blood-stained clothes of the
injured seized, which further weakens the prosecution version. Insofar as the
allegation of a diamond ring being robbed is concerned, the same was never
recovered and complainant did not bring on record any documentary proof
of its ownership. The Trial Court had partly disagreed with the prosecution
version as it had disbelieved the involvement of the two co-accused, Mohit
and Yash, both of whom were discharged. Learned Amicus has also stated
that in the backdrop of admitted family disputes, the possibility of false
implication of the appellant cannot be ruled out. In the alternative, learned
Amicus, on instructions from the appellant, has submitted that the appellant,
having already undergone half of his sentence, be considered for release on
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
the period of custody already undergone.
14.
Per contra, learned APP for the State submitted that the testimony of
the injured complainant (PW-4) is clear, consistent, and does not suffer from
any material contradictions. She submits that though the doctor who
medically examined the complainant and prepared the concerned MLC was
not examined, the said MLC was exhibited through the testimony of the
concerned Record Clerk (PW-8) and stands duly proved in terms of Section
47 Indian Evidence Act. Reliance in this regard has been placed upon the
decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Kamlesh Vs. State1; and the
decisions of Co-ordinate Benches of this Court in Rakesh & Anr. Vs. State2;
Gobind Mishra Vs. State3; and Rajesh Kumar @ Raju Vs. State4. The
appellant did not challenge the authenticity or genuineness of the said MLC
as the concerned Record Clerk was not even cross-examined. It is also
submitted that the concerned MLC records an injury on the face of the
complainant, which lends corroboration to the ocular version narrated by the
complainant. It was argued that the non-examination of the doctor is not
fatal when the injury itself is not disputed and the complainant has
consistently deposed about having sustained an injury. She also placed
reliance on the factum of recovery of the complainant’s mobile phone at the
instance of the appellant from the repair shop, proved through the testimony
of Saurabh Kumar Gupta (PW-3) and Puneet Gupta (PW-7). It was pointed
out that the appellant in his statement recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
has himself admitted that he took the police party to the concerned repair
Decision dated 05.01.2023 in CRL.A. 481/2019
Decision dated 18.11.2010 in CRL.A. 164/2001.
Decision dated 02.05.2011 in CRL.A. 323/2000.
2007 SCC OnLine Del 277.
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
shop and that the mobile phone of the complainant was recovered therefrom
and seized. Lastly, while handing over a status report, it is submitted that the
appellant is a habitual offender with multiple criminal antecedents and prior
convictions, who has also been declared a “Bad Character” by the competent
authority.
15.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties and carefully
examined the record.
16.
As per the case of the prosecution, the incident occurred in the
intervening night of 07/08.03.2014. The complainant has claimed that he
met the appellant, who was in acquaintance of his relatives, viz. Mohit and
Yash, after which they consumed liquor at the ground floor of the
complainant’s house. Thereafter, the complainant as well as the appellant
went to the latter’s house at Seva Nagar and at the terrace of the said house,
they consumed more liquor. The complainant has further claimed that after
some time, the appellant threatened him and demanded his diamond ring as
well as his wallet containing Rs.13,000-14,000/-. The appellant then forcibly
took out both the diamond ring and the wallet containing the said amount, as
well as the complainant’s mobile phone of the make Samsung Grand. The
complainant was also hit with an ustra on his face by the appellant.
17.
The first call about the incident was recorded through DD No. 12A.
The subject FIR was also registered on the very same day, based on the
aforesaid DD, which recorded that on the terrace of the concerned house,
two people had quarrelled. The inquiry of the incident was assigned to SI
Amrender Kumar, who has deposed that on receipt of the aforesaid DD, he
along with Ct. Rishi Kumar reached the spot, where they found the PCR Van
as well as the injured. The injured was removed to AIIMS Trauma Centre,
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
where SI Amrender Kumar recorded the statement of the injured. The
testimony of Ct. Rishi Kumar, examined as PW-2, is on similar lines as that
of SI Amrender Kumar.
18.
Neither any dispute nor any contentions were raised on the issue of
the identity of the appellant.
19.
Learned Amicus Curiae has contended that the incident occurred
under the influence of liquor. However, the factum of the appellant taking
away a diamond ring, a wallet containing Rs.13000-14000/-, and a Samsung
Grand phone, cannot be lost sight of. The allegation of robbery having been
committed by the appellant stands fortified by the recovery of surgical
blades from the possession of the appellant as well as the recovery of the
robbed mobile phone (Ex. P-4) from the mobile repair shop owned by
Puneet Kumar Gupta (PW-7) and his father Pramod Kumar Gupta (PW-3).
Both of the aforesaid witnesses have stated that the said mobile phone was
given for repair by the appellant at their shop. The police had done part
recovery of the robbed amount through recovery of Rs.2,600/-. PW7/Puneet Kumar Gupta deposed that it was the appellant who came to his
shop and gave the said mobile phone, i.e. Samsung Grand, for repair of its
speaker. He further claimed that after a few days, police officials came to his
shop along with the appellant and seized the said mobile. He identified the
appellant as well as the mobile phone.
20.
Though it has been contended by the learned Amicus that the
prosecution case was partly disbelieved as the co-accused persons were
discharged, it is pertinent to note in this regard that the Trial Court had
discharged the two co-accused as their names had not figured in the rukka,
but only in the supplementary statement of the complainant, despite them
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
statedly being related to him. As such, this contention has no merit.
21.
Section 394 IPC requires that the accused must have caused hurt
while committing the offence of robbery. In the present case, the
complainant has claimed that an ustra was used to inflict an injury on his
cheek. The MLC of the complainant notes a laceration on the left side of his
face. It is also worth mentioning that despite opportunity, there was no
cross-examination of the said Record Clerk.
22.
In light of the consistent testimony and the positive identification of
the appellant, the alleged defects in the investigation, namely the nonseizure of the blood-stained clothes and the weapon of offence not having
been sent to the FSL, are not of much relevance.
23.
In view of the above, this Court does not find any reason to interfere
with the findings arrived at by the Trial Court.
24.
Coming to the alternative plea seeking release of the appellant on the
sentence already undergone, it is observed that as per the nominal roll, the
appellant has undergone half of his sentence.
25.
The law regarding release of convicts who have undergone more than
half of their sentence was laid down by the Supreme Court in Sonadhar Vs.
State of Chhattisgarh5, and the relevant portion of the same is extracted
hereinunder:
“28. We thus issue the following directions:
a) A similar exercise be undertaken by the High Court Legal Services
Committee of different High Courts so that convicts represented by
legal aid Advocates do not suffer due to delay in hearing of the
appeals. NALSA will circulate this order to the concerned authority
and monitor the exercise to be carried on.
b) The Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee would take up the
cases of those convicts who have undergone more than half the
2021 SCC OnLine SC 3683
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
sentence in case of fixed term sentences and examine the feasibility of
filing bail applications before the High Court, while in case of „life
sentence‟ cases, such an exercise may be undertaken where eight
years of actual custody has been undergone.
c) We are of the view that in fixed term sentence cases, an endeavor be
made, at least as a pilot project, in these two High Courts to get in
touch with the convicts and find out whether they are willing to
accept their infractions and agree to disposal of the appeals on the
basis of sentence undergone.
d) A similar exercise can be undertaken even in respect of „life sentence‟
cases where the sentenced persons are entitled to remission of the
remaining sentence i.e., whether they would still like to contest the
appeals or the remission of sentence would be acceptable to such of
the convicts.”
26.
The appellant is aged about 35 years, is the sole breadwinner of his
family, and bears the responsibility of taking care of his aged and sick
mother. The offence in question pertains to the year 2014 and the present
appeal has been pending since 2016; the appellant has suffered the ordeal of
a protracted trial. He has already paid the fine of Rs.15,000/- imposed upon
him by the Trial Court and the receipt thereof is on record.
27.
Keeping in view the facts and circumstances noted hereinabove, the
fine being paid, as well as the decision in Sonadhar (supra), the substantive
sentence of the appellant is hereby modified to the period already undergone
by him.
28.
The personal bond furnished by the appellant stands cancelled and his
sureties are discharged.
29.
The present appeal is partly allowed and disposed of in the above
terms.
30.
A copy of this judgment be sent to the Trial Court and the concerned
Jail Superintendent.
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
31.
This Court records its appreciation for the valuable assistance
rendered by the learned Amicus Curiae, Ms. Stuti Gujral, Advocate.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 05, 2026
pmc
MOHAN CHOUDHARY
22:15:37
CRL.A. 1062/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review