Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~22 & 23
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 07th September 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010480162025
+
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & CM APPL. 43923/2025
UTTAR PRADESH STATE ROAD TRANSPORT
CORPORATION
.....Appellant
Through:
Ms. Sthavi Asthana, Advocate.
versus
SAURABH KUMAR & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Varun Sarin, Ms. Parul Dutta,
Mr. Shantanu Sharma, Advocates for
Respondent no.1.
(23)
#
CNR No. DLHC010787142025
+
MAC.APP. 665/2025
SAURABH KUMAR
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Varun Sarin, Ms. Parul Dutta,
Mr. Shantanu Sharma, Advocates
versus
RAJ KUMAR & ANR.
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Sthavi Asthana, Advocate for
Respondent no.2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & MAC.APP. 665/2025
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:59:44
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
These cross-appeals have been filed assailing the Award dated 29th
1.
April 2025 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, South East,
Saket Courts, New Delhi (‘Tribunal/MACT’) in MACT No. 868/2021.
While the appellant/Uttar Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation
[hereinafter referred to as ‘Corporation’] has filed MAC.APP. 461/2025
challenging the territorial jurisdiction, the finding on negligence and the
quantum of compensation, whereas claimant has filed MAC.APP. 665/2025
seeking enhancement of compensation.
2.
Ms. Sthavi Asthana, counsel for appellant/Corporation, challenged
the award on the following grounds:
i.
Firstly, the tribunal did not have the territorial jurisdiction as the
accident took place in Aligarh, Uttar Pradesh and the claimant was
also a resident of Uttar Pradesh, as verified by the verification report
of his Aadhar;
ii.
Secondly, that there was no independent witness who had deposed
to the accident. His cousin, who was also riding on the motorcycle
with him, was also not made an eyewitness;
iii.
Thirdly, notional income was awarded on minimum wages
applicable in NCT of Delhi, whereas the claimant was a resident of
Uttar Pradesh; and
iv.
Fourthly, compensation awarded under other heads was excessive.
3.
Mr. Varun Sarin, counsel for the claimant, however, contends that the
claimant has been rendered 100% visually disabled and has been certified
as suffering from complete blindness as a result of the accident. He,
therefore, submits that the functional disability ought to be assessed at
100% and not at 80%.
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & MAC.APP. 665/2025
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:59:44
4.
Further, he states that the notional income ought to be taken at
minimum wages of a graduate as the claimant was pursuing B.Sc. degree
and preparing for various government job examinations.
5.
As regards territorial jurisdiction, he shows that the Aadhaar card
placed before the MACT reflected the claimant's address as Sriniwaspuri,
New Delhi, which was accordingly taken into account by the MACT.
6.
Ms. Asthana, on the other hand, contends that the verification of the
Aadhaar card showed it to be of the State of Uttar Pradesh. According to
her, there was no other material on record, presented by claimant, except a
rent agreement produced by the claimant, which was dated 17 th February
2021, i.e., after the date of the accident, i.e. 05th January 2020.
7.
In this regard, Mr. Sarin has pointed out the testimony of
injured/claimant, who, in his cross-examination, when confronted by the
Corporation, stated that he had been staying in Delhi since 2017. He
deposed that he was initially residing at Mukherjee Nagar, Delhi, and in
2019 shifted to Laxmi Nagar, Delhi, after completing his coaching, where
he remained till October 2019. Thereafter, he resided at Sriniwaspuri, New
Delhi, during the years 2019-20. After the accident on 05th January 2020,
he had been staying in Jagat Puri, Delhi, along with his uncle since his
treatment was going on.
8.
PW1/ claimant further stated that his first Aadhaar card had been
issued in Uttar Pradesh in 2009 and that he had subsequently changed his
address in 2017.
9.
Mr. Sarin further points out to the coaching ID card, which shows
that the claimant was a student of Paramount Coaching at Mukherjee
Nagar, Delhi, showing the date of admission as 18th May 2017. Taking this
into account and the testimony of PW1, which synchronizes with the dates
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & MAC.APP. 665/2025
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:59:44
on the coaching ID card as well as the Aadhaar card itself, the Court is not
inclined to accept the plea of territorial jurisdiction.
10.
As regards the plea that rash and negligent driving has not been
proved by the claimant, the testimony of PW1, who is himself the injured
witness, assumes significance. PW1 specifically identified the offending
vehicle as a U.P. Roadways bus bearing registration No. UP-81BT-0436.
The said registration number also finds mention in the FIR, which was
lodged on the very next day at the instance of his brother. The FIR
culminated in the filing of a charge sheet, which has not been challenged.
Accordingly, applying the decision of the Supreme Court in Ranjeet v.
Abdul Kayam Neb 2025 SCC OnLine SC 497, the contention advanced on
behalf of the Corporation cannot be accepted. Moreover, the assessment in
motor accident claim cases is to be made on the touchstone of the
preponderance of probabilities, and there is no evidence on record to
suggest that the aforesaid vehicle was not involved in the accident.
11.
As regards the assessment of notional income, although PW1
claimed that he was pursuing the final year of a B.Sc. course through
correspondence from Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar University, Agra, Uttar
Pradesh, no documentary evidence in support thereof has been produced.
The only document relied upon is a handwritten certificate on the letterhead
of Satyawati Devi Mahavidyalaya. No explanation has been offered as to
how the said institution was affiliated with Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar
University, Agra, Uttar Pradesh.
12.
Accordingly, the plea that the claimant's notional income should be
assessed on the basis of the minimum wages payable to a graduate cannot
be accepted. The income of matriculate taken by the MACT will continue
to subsist.
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & MAC.APP. 665/2025
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:59:44
13.
Future prospect at 40% and multiplier of ‘18’ has rightly been taken
by the MACT.
14.
As regards functional disability, Mr. Sarin submits that the same
ought to be assessed at 100%, considering the nature of the injuries
suffered by the claimant and the fact that he has been certified as suffering
from 100% visual disability.
15.
In this regard, the MACT’s observations are taken into account. The
Tribunal has also noted that the claimant suffered from 100% visual
disability and had additionally sustained a fracture of the left leg, thereby
further impairing his mobility. However, the MACT assessed the functional
disability at 80% on the ground that facilities are available to enable
visually impaired persons to read, write and pursue further studies.
16.
Having considered the assessment made by the MACT, this Court is
inclined to enhance functional disability to 90%, taking into account the
fact that, notwithstanding the disability suffered by the claimant, he may
still have some opportunities to earn his livelihood, even though there
would be some loss as opposed to what he was proposing to do in the
future.
17.
As regards non-pecuniary losses, the following is noted:
i.
For pain and suffering, Rs.10,00,000/- has already been
awarded;
ii.
For loss of marriage prospects, Rs.5,00,000/- has been
awarded;
iii.
18.
For loss of amenities of life, Rs.2,00,000/- has been awarded.
As regards attendant charges, Mr. Sarin states that only Rs.50,000/-
has been awarded. Accordingly, he states that the attendant charges should
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & MAC.APP. 665/2025
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:59:44
be calculated by applying the principles laid down in Kajal vs. Jagdish
Chand and Ors. (2020) 4 SCC 413, as the claimant would require the
services of an attendant throughout his life on account of the disability
sustained by him in the accident.
19.
In the opinion of this Court, considering that the claimant has visual
disability but no impediment to his mobility, to award compensation for an
attendant on the basis of the multiplier may not be correct, appropriate or
reasonable. Accordingly, an amount of Rs. 10,00,000/- is awarded as a
lump sum.
20.
Accordingly, the revised computation is as under:
Sr.
No.
Heads
1.
Expenditure on Medical Bills
and medical treatment (A)
Expenditure on conveyance
(B)
Expenditure on special diet
(C)
Attendant charges (D)
Income of injured per
month(E)
Loss of income (L)
Add: Future prospects (F)
2.
4.
5.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Awarded by the
Tribunal
PECUNIARY LOSS
Awarded by
this Court
Rs. 95,000/-
Rs. 95,000/-
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 50,000/-
Rs.50,000/-
Rs.50,000/-
Rs.50,000/Rs. 17,991/-
Rs. 10,00,000/Rs. 17,991/-
Rs.1,07,946/40% of Rs. 17,991/-=
Rs. 7,196.4/18
80%
Rs. 43,52,386/-
Rs.1,07,946/40% of Rs. 17,991/-=
Rs. 7,196.4/18
90%
Rs. 48,96,430.56/-
Multiplier (G)
Functional disability (H)
Loss of future income/future
earnings [(E+F) x 12 x G x
H] = (I)
NON-PECUNIARY LOSS
Pain and suffering (J)
Rs. 10,00,000/Loss of amenities of life (K)
Rs. 2,00,000/Compensation for mental and
Rs. 5,00,000/-
Rs. 10,00,000/Rs. 2,00,000/Rs. 5,00,000/-
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & MAC.APP. 665/2025
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:59:44
15.
16.
physical shock (M)
Total compensation (A + B +
C + D + H + I+ J+ K+L+M)
= (N)
Interest awarded
Enhanced compensation
21.
Accordingly, the compensation is enhanced by Rs. 14,94,048/-.
22.
Accordingly, it is directed that the enhanced amount along with
14.
Rs.64,05,332/-
Rs. 78,99,376.56/(rounded to Rs.
78,99,380/-)
9% per annum
9% per annum
Rs. 14,94,048/-
accrued interest be deposited by the Insurance company with the Registrar
General of this Court within a period of 6 weeks.
23.
Further, it is directed that a lump sum amount of Rs. 2,00,000/- shall
be released to the claimant from the amount so deposited within a period of
two weeks thereafter. Remaining amount, along with accrued interest, shall
be kept in Fixed Deposit Receipts (FDRs) of Rs. 25,000/- each for periods
of 1 month, 2 months, 3 months and so on, in succession as maybe
calculated. Interest accruing on said FDRs shall be credited to the
designated Savings Bank Account of claimant. The amount of FDRs on
maturity would be released to the Savings Bank Account of claimant upon
due verification.
24.
By order dated 8th August 2025, this Court directed the Insurance
Company to deposit the entire awarded compensation and granted a stay.
Vide order dated 9th October 2015, this Court directed release of 60% of the
deposited compensation along with accrued interest. Accordingly, the
balance amount shall be released in accordance with the directions of the
MACT in the impugned award.
25.
Appeals are disposed of in the above terms.
26.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & MAC.APP. 665/2025
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:59:44
27.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned MACT/ bank for
information and necessary compliance.
28.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 7, 2026/ak/bp
MAC.APP. 461/2025 & MAC.APP. 665/2025
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
16:59:44
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review