The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. In view of the above, this Court is of view that the finding recorded by the learned Trial Court does not suffer from any infirmity or illegality. The parties are well aware of their rival claims and can lead evidence in support of their claims under the issues and additional issues already framed by the Trial Court.
15. Accordingly, the revision lacks merit and the same is hereby dismissed. (Subhash Upadhyay, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Civil Revision No.85 of 2026
Saurabh Balyan
…Revisionist
Versus
1. Smt. Meera Goel
…Respondent
2. Praveen Goyal
3. Deepshikha
…Proforma respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. Vikas Bahuguna, learned counsel for the revisionist
Mr. Arvind Vashishtha, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. Disha Vashishtha
and Ms. Devanshi Joshi, learned counsel the respondent no.1
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Judgment: 21.08.2026
Hon’ble Shri Justice Subhash Upadhyay, J.
1.
By means of present civil revision, filed under
section 115 of CPC, the revisionist has assailed the order
dated 14.07.2026 passed by learned 3rd Additional Civil
Judge (S.D.), Dehradun in O.S. no.447/2022, whereby the
application no.305C2 filed by the revisionist/defendant no.2
under Order XIV Rule 5 CPC, seeking framing of additional
issues, has been rejected.
2.
Brief
facts
of
the
case
are
that
an
Original Suit No.447/2022 was filed by the respondent
no.1/plaintiff
against
the
revisionist
and
proforma
respondent nos.2 and 3 herein. The proforma respondent
nos.2 and 3 herein were arrayed as defendant nos.1 and 3
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
and the revisionist was arrayed as defendant no.2 in the
said suit.
The aforesaid suit was filed for permanent
injunction thereby restraining the revisionist/defendant
no.2 and proforma respondent nos.2 and 3 herein from
interfering in the title, peaceful possession, use and
enjoyment of the scheduled property specified in the plaint.
The respondent no.1/plaintiff contended that the mother of
the plaintiff (Smt. Jadishwari Gupta) purchased the land
bearing khasra no.39/1 (new no.26Ga) having an area of
455.24
sq.mts.
situated
in
Village
Brahmmawala
(Sahastradhara Road), Dehradun (hereinafter referred to
the
‘suit
property’)
from
Smt.
Pushpa
Tandon
vide
registered sale deed dated 22.03.2004 and her name was
duly mutated in the revenue records. It is the further case
of respondent no.1/plaintiff that, her mother being the
absolute and exclusive recorded owner / bhumidhar of the
suit property, vide registered Will dated 22.03.2004,
bequeathed the said property in favour of respondent
no.1/plaintiff. After the death of Smt. Jagdishwari Gupta on
02.10.2016, the respondent no.1/plaintiff became the
absolute and exclusive owner of the said suit property. It
is the further case of respondent no.1/plaintiff that one
Shri Ashish Bhargav having no concern or connection with
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
the
suit
property
through
his
alleged
authorised
representative namely Praveen Goyal-proforma respondent
no.2/defendant no.1 filed a false and frivolous suit being
suit no.139 of 2020 Ashish Bhargav vs. Anand Prakash and
without impleading the respondent no.1/plaintiff in the suit
obtained an ex-parte injunction.
The said suit was in
respect of khasra no.39/3 (new no.26Ka and 40ka). Under
the garb of the ex-parte injunction, the possession of the
respondent no.1/plaintiff over the suit property was sought
to be disturbed.
3.
In the suit, though the respondent no.1/plaintiff
was not made a party but her brother was impleaded as
defendant
no.2
by
his
childhood
name
“Raju”.
The
respondent no.1/plaintiff filed an impleadment application
in the said suit and a preliminary objection was also filed
by her brother and after hearing the parties, learned Civil
Judge (S.D.), vide order dated 09.06.2020, modified the
injunction order and directed the parties to maintain status
quo. During the pendency of the said suit, Ashish Bhargav
through his attorney executed three sale deeds. Two sale
deeds were executed in favour of proforma respondent
no.2/defendant no.1 and one sale deed in favour of
revisionist/defendant
no.2.
In
the
pending
suit
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
no.139/2020, brother of the respondent no.1/plaintiff
initiated proceedings under Order 39 Rule 2A of CPC
against Shri Ashish Bhargav and the attesting witness
Virender Verma for execution of aforesaid sale deeds, in
defiance to the interim injunction order of status quo. The
said proceedings were said to be pending at the time of
institution of the suit.
4.
The Respondent no.1 / plaintiff apprehended that
after the sale deeds being executed in favour of proforma
respondent
no.2/defendant
no.1
and
the
revisionist/defendant no.2, suit no.139/2020 would not be
contested by Shri Ashish Bhargav. As the dismissal of the
said suit would affect her right, as such the respondent
no.1/plaintiff
filed
the
suit
no.447/2022
against
the
revisionist and the proforma respondent nos.2 and 3 herein
for
permanent
injunction.
In
the
aforesaid
suit
no.447/2022 the revisionist/defendant no.2 filed his written
statement and contended that Smt. Pushpa Tandon, who
sold
the
property
to
the
mother
of
respondent
no.1/plaintiff, did not possess any lawful title or authority in
her
favour.
The
proforma
respondent
nos.2
and
3/defendant nos.1 and 3 also filed their separate written
statements. The learned Trial Court, vide order dated
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
03.07.2026, framed the issues in the case. Thereafter, on
an application filed by proforma respondent no.2/defendant
no.1 under order XIV Rule 5 CPC, the Trial Court, vide its
order dated 09.07.2026, framed an additional issue.
Subsequently, the revisionist/defendant no.2 also filed an
application bearing paper no.305-C2 under Order XIV Rule
5 CPC praying for framing of additional issues, however, the
said application was rejected by the Trial Court by the
impugned order dated 14.07.2026, against which the
present revision has been filed.
5.
Learned counsel for the revisionist submits that
the entire claim of ownership of respondent no.1/plaintiff is
founded upon a void and fraudulent chain of title i.e. the
alleged sale deed dated 22.03.2004, the subsequent
mutation and the alleged Will. Thus, the said issue goes to
the root of the plaintiff’s title and the learned Trial Court
erred in dismissing the application no.305-C2 filed by the
revisionist for framing the additional issue.
6.
He
further
submits
that while
allowing
the
application of proforma respondent no.2/defendant no.1
under order XIV Rule 5 CPC the learned trial court took into
consideration the pleadings made in his written statement
and framed the additional issues, whereas in considering
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
the application filed by the revisionist, the said provisions
were not followed and the jurisdiction sought to be
exercised was not done. He further submits that the Trial
Court failed to appreciate that framing of proper issues is
crucial in deciding the real questions involved in the
controversy between the parties and ensure a fair and
effective trial. The failure to frame said issue has seriously
prejudiced the claim and defence of the revisionist.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent no.1/plaintiff made preliminary objection and
contended that as per the proviso to Section 115(1) CPC
(as substituted by the CPC Amendment Act, 2002), the
Hon’ble Court shall not vary or reverse any order made in
the course of a suit except where the order, if it had been
made in favour of the party applying for revision, would
have finally disposed of the suit. He further submits that
there is no jurisdictional error or material irregularity in the
impugned order and the application filed by the revisionist
has been decided on merits by recording cogent reasons.
He further submits that Section 115 CPC is not an avenue
for correcting an order merely because it is alleged to be
erroneous on facts or in law. Moreover, the proceedings of
the suit has been expedited by order dated 06.04.2026
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
passed by the High Court in WPMS No.813/2026 “Meera
Goyal vs. Praveen Goyal & Others”, wherein this Court had
directed the learned Trial Court to decide the O.S.
no.447/2022 within four months. He further submits that
the additional issues sought to be framed and to be
incorporated as additional issues by the revisionist are
already covered by the issues and the additional issues
framed by the Court and the learned trial court has
considered the said fact and has thus held that the issues
already framed take care of the additional issues sought to
be incorporated by the revisionist.
8.
Heard
learned
counsel
for
the
parties
and
perused the record. The facts which are not in dispute in
the present case are that the learned Trial Court on
03.07.2026 had framed the following issues:“i) Whether the plaintiff is the owner / bhumidhar in
possession of the suit property on the basis of the Will
dated 23.03.2004
ii) Whether the defendants have attempted to interfere
with the peaceful possession of the plaintiff?
iii) Whether the plaintiff’s suit is barred by Sections 34
and 41 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963?
iv) Whether the plaintiff has undervalued the suit?
v) Whether the plaintiff has paid insufficient court fee”
vi) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief claimed?
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
9.
Thereafter, on an application filed by proforma
respondent no.2/defendant no.1 in the suit, who sought
two additional issues to be framed, one additional issue
was framed on 09.07.2026, which is as follows:“vi) Whether the plaintiff’s mother, Smt. Jagdishwari
Gupta, had a lawful right to transfer the disputed
property by Will, and if so, its effect?”
10.
The revisionist/respondent no.2 thereafter moved
an application no.305C2 on 12.07.2026 for framing of four
additional issues. The issues sought to be framed by the
revisionist are as follows:-
“1- D;k çfroknhx.k }kjk oknxzLr Hkwfe ds lEcUèk esa okfnuh ds dfFkr
LokfeRo vfèkdkj dks fookfnr fd;s tkus rFkk okfnuh ds LokfeRo ij
es?kkPNkfnr mRiUu gksus ds dkj.k okfnuh }kjk ?kks"k.kk dk vuqrks"k ekaxs
fcuk LFkk;h fu"ksèkkKk dk okn fofèk esa iks"k.kh; gS\
2- D;k Jherh iq"ik VaMu dks okfnuh dh ekrk Jherh txnhÜojh xqIrk
ds i{k esa oknxzLr Hkwfe dk foØ; foys[k fnuk¡d 22@03@2004
fu"ikfnr djus dk dksbZ oSèkkfud vfèkdkj ,oa oknxzLr Hkwfe dk LokfeRo
çkIr Fkk \
3- D;k okfnuh dks viuh ekrk Jherh txnhÜojh xqIrk dh dfFkr
olh;r ds vkèkkj ij oknxzLr Hkwfe ij dksbZ oSèk LokfeRo ,oa vfèkdkj
çkIr gqvk gS\
4- D;k okfnuh dh ekrk Jherh txnhÜojh xqIrk ds i{k esa oknxzLr Hkwfe
ds foØ; foys[k fnu‚d 22@03@2004 esa dwVjpuk dj jktLo
vfHkys[kksa esa okfnuh dh ekrk Jherh txnhÜojh xqIrk dk ukekUrj.k
¼Mutation½ gqvk gS\ ;fn gk¡ rks mldk çHkko\”
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
11.
Learned counsel for the revisionist, during the
course of arguments, submitted that issue no.2 sought to
be framed as an additional issue goes to the root of the
matter besides other three issues which are also relevant
for deciding the controversy.
12.
Learned Trial Court, considering the application
filed by the revisionist and by the impugned order, came to
a conclusion that the issues sought to be incorporated are
already covered under the issues and the additional issues
framed by the Court. The finding recorded by the Trial
Court in para 6 of the order dated 14.07.2026 reads as
under:-
“6- tgka rd çfroknh la[;k&2 dh vksj ls ;ksftr çkFkZuk&i= esa ;kfpr
vfrfjä okn fcUnq fojfpr fd;s tkus dh ;kpuk dk ç'u gS rks bl
lEcU/k esa mYys[kuh; gS fd U;k;ky; }kjk iwoZ esa fnukad 03-07-2026 dks
06 okn fcUnqvksa ,oa fnukad 09-07-2026 dks vfrfjä okn fcUnq la[;k&7
dk fojpu fd;k tk pqdk gS] mä fojfpr okn fcUnqvksa ds voyksdu ls
fofnr gS fd çfroknh la[;k&2 }kjk ftu rF;ksa ds fuLrkj.k gsrq
vfrfjä okn fcUnqvksa ds fojpu fd;s tkus dh ;kpuk dh xbZ gS] mä
rF;ksa dk fu/kkZj.k U;k;ky; }kjk iwoZ esa fojfpr okn fcUnqvksa ds fuLrkj.k
esa lekfgr gksuk ifjyf{kr gSA ,slh fLFkfr esa çfroknh la[;k&2 dh vksj
ls ;kfpr vfrfjä okn fcUnqvksa dks bl Lrj ij fojfpr fd;s tkus dk
dksbZ vkSfpR; ugha jg tkrk gSA vr% çfroknh la[;k&2 dh vksj ls
çLrqr çkFkZuk i= Lohdkj fd;k tkuk U;k;ksfpr çrhr ugha gksrk gSA
vkns'k rn~uqlkj&”
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
13.
The object of framing the issues is to deliberate
upon the questions on which the parties have to lead
evidence and the purpose is to indicate the party on whom
the burden of proof lies. Moreover, non-framing of an issue
in a particular manner, as sought by the party, is
insignificant when the parties are well aware of their rival
case. The power to amend or strike out any issue under
Order XIV Rule 5 CPC rests upon the Court and the
additional issues can be framed, as may be necessary, for
determining the matter in controversy.
In the present
case, the learned Trial Court had exercised the said power
and
has
come
to
a
conclusion
that
the
matter
in
controversy can be considered and decided under the
issues
already
framed.
This
Court
has
taken
into
consideration the issues and the additional issues framed
by the learned Trial Court and has also seen the additional
issues sought to be framed by the revisionist and is in
agreement with the finding recorded by the Trial Court that
the issues sought to be framed by the revisionist are
already
covered
under
the
issues
already
framed.
Moreover, the Coordinate bench of this Court in WPMS
no.813/2026 had directed the Trial Court to expedite the
matter and to decide the same, preferably within four
UKHC010133282026
2026:UHC:7587
months. Thus, the learned Trial Court is justified in making
the efforts to decide the suit expeditiously.
14.
In view of the above, this Court is of view that
the finding recorded by the learned Trial Court does not
suffer from any infirmity or illegality. The parties are well
aware of their rival claims and can lead evidence in support
of their claims under the issues and additional issues
already framed by the Trial Court.
15.
Accordingly, the revision lacks merit and the
same is hereby dismissed.
(Subhash Upadhyay, J.)
21.08.2026
Rajni
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review