Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 09.12.2025
Pronounced on:14.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 13649/2006
SATYENDRA DIXIT
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Anupam Dwivedi and Mr.
Ashutosh Kumar, Advs.
versus
UOI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Rishabh Sahu (SPC) with
Mr. Sameer Sharma, Adv.
Mr. Anshuman, Ms. Avshreya
Pratap Singh, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
This petition has been filed by the petitioner, challenging the
Orders dated 20.07.2005 and 20.01.2006 passed by the learned
Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘Tribunal’) in O.A. No. 1846/2004 and
R.A. No. 175/2005, respectively, whereby the O.A. filed by the
petitioner and the subsequent Review Application seeking recall of the
Order dated 20.07.2005 were dismissed.
FACTS OF THE CASE:
2.
The factual matrix of the case is that the petitioner was working
as a Storekeeper with the Central Ordnance Depot (COD), Agra,
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
under the respondents’ department. During the course of his service,
disciplinary proceedings were initiated against him, which culminated
in the penalty of dismissal from service. The said dismissal forms the
subject matter of the present Writ Petition.
3.
On 15.03.1999, the petitioner proceeded on medical leave after
submitting a duly completed application seeking sanction of leave.
The petitioner, from time to time, sought extension of leave and
intimations in this regard were duly sent to the respondents’
department along with the medical certificates issued by doctors of a
Government Hospital at Agra.
4.
During the period when the petitioner was on leave, a complaint
dated 03.07.1999 was lodged by a retired employee of the
respondents’ department, namely Subedar Major Shri V.P. Singh,
alleging that the petitioner, his younger brother, and another employee
had induced him to invest money in M/s. Alakhananda Growth Funds
Ltd. through M/s. Dixit Financial Consultancy. Similar allegations
were reiterated in a joint representation dated 05.07.1999 submitted by
certain employees of the respondents’ department.
5.
On the basis of the aforesaid complaints, the respondents’
authorities issued a Show Cause Notice dated 07.10.1999, bearing No.
22659/9-SD/Estt.-Coord., proposing disciplinary action against the
petitioner under the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, for allegedly canvassing
and promoting the investment schemes of M/s Alakhananda Growth
Fund Ltd.
6.
The
petitioner
submitted
his
reply
dated
12.10.1999,
categorically denying the allegations and stating that he had no role in
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
canvassing or promoting the business of the said financial company or
M/s Dixit Financial Consultancy.
7.
Thereafter, a charge-sheet dated 07.08.2000 was served upon
the petitioner vide Office Order dated 19.08.2000, alleging that he had
indulged in canvassing employees and retired personnel for
investment in the said company for profit and that he had remained
absent from duty on the pretext of illness.
8.
Upon receipt of the charge-sheet, the petitioner sought supply of
relevant documents and also requested a change of venue of the
Inquiry, by way of representations dated 06.09.2000 and 27.09.2000,
expressing apprehension of threat from the vested interests.
9.
Vide Office Order dated 23.11.2000, the Disciplinary Authority
agreed to supply some documents, denied access to others, and
rejected the request for change of the venue.
10.
In the absence of complete documents, the petitioner submitted
his statement of defence on 22.12.2000, denying the allegations.
Apprehending bias, he further sought appointment of an ad-hoc
Disciplinary Authority, however, the said request was declined.
11.
During the Inquiry, the petitioner raised objections regarding
the conduct of the Inquiry Officer and sought his replacement by way
of a representation dated 19.06.2001, however, the said request was
not accepted. The petitioner also disputed the authenticity of certain
documents and sought their authenticated copies, which, although
directed to be supplied by the Inquiry Officer, were not fully
furnished.
12.
Vide Orders dated 09.07.2001 and 26.07.2001, the Inquiry
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
Officer declared certain additional documents sought by the petitioner
to be relevant and directed their supply. It was further directed that
regular hearings be conducted only after due compliance with the said
directions. However, the Inquiry proceedings were conducted on
04.12.2001 despite non-compliance with the aforesaid directions.
13.
The respondents’ department filed its written brief on
09.08.2002, and the petitioner submitted his written brief on
16.08.2002.
14.
Thereafter, a copy of the Inquiry Report dated 30.12.2002 was
furnished to the petitioner on 02.01.2003, wherein all the charges were
held to be proved. The petitioner submitted his representation against
the Inquiry Report on 24.01.2003.
15.
The Disciplinary Authority issued an Office Memorandum
dated 15.05.2003 proposing the penalty of dismissal, to which the
petitioner submitted his response on 20.06.2003. Subsequently, vide
Office Memorandum dated 23.07.2003, the penalty of dismissal from
service was imposed upon the petitioner.
16.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner preferred a Statutory Appeal
on 23.08.2003, which, after due consideration, came to be rejected by
the Appellant Authority vide Order dated 05.03.2004, communicated
to the petitioner on 29.03.2004.
17.
Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner thereafter approached the
learned Tribunal by filing O.A. No. 1846/2004 on 16.08.2004,
challenging the Inquiry Report dated 30.12.2002, the Dismissal Order
dated 23.07.2003, and the Appellate Authority Order dated
29.03.2004.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
18.
The learned Tribunal, vide the Impugned Order dated
20.07.2005, dismissed the Original Application, being O.A.
1846/2004, on merits, holding as under:
“8. After hearing both the learned counsel for
the parties, we are convinced that the enquiry
and the disciplinary proceedings have been
conducted in accordance with law. The
applicant has been given all the opportunities
to defend himself. The plea taken by him that
he was not supplied with certain documents is
neither borne out by the facts nor could the
learned counsel for the applicant convince us
as to what those documents were and how they
were relevant for his defence. He also failed to
indicate as to how the non-supply of these
documents had caused any prejudice to him.
The applicant also almost conceded that his
father and his brother had played a fraud on
the employees. The plea taken by him that he
was not involved in this affair is not
convincing at all after considering the
documents furnished by the respondents with
their counter and the statements of the
witnesses. The misconduct of the applicant on
all the four charges has been proved beyond
doubt by the Enquiry Officer. The Appellate
Authority had also given him a personal
hearing, and the order of the Appellate
Authority is a well-reasoned order meeting the
points raised by him in his representation. We
do not find any legal infirmity in the conduct
of the enquiry and the disciplinary
proceedings.
9. It is a well-settled principle of law that the
jurisdiction of the Tribunal in the matter of
judicial review of the orders of the disciplinary
authority in departmental enquiries is quite
limited. In a series of decisions, including B.C.
Chaturvedi vs. Union of India and Others
(1995) 6 SCC 749, State of T.N. vs. T.V.
Venugopalan (1994) 6 SCC 302, Union of
India vs. Upendra Sinha (1994) 3 SCC 357,
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
State of T.N. & Another vs. Subramaniam
(1996) 7 SCC 509, Government of T.N. vs. A.
Rajapandian (1995) 1 SCC 216, and U.P.
State Road Transport Corporation vs. Basudeo
Chaudhar and Another (1997) 11 SCC 370,
the Apex Court has ruled that where the
Tribunal has not found any fault with the
proceedings conducted by the enquiring
authority, it has no jurisdiction to reappreciate
the evidence and to interfere with the order of
punishment. Judicial review is not an appeal
against a decision, but a review of the manner
in which the decision is made. The learned
counsel for the applicant has failed to
convince us about any lacunae or legal
infirmity in the conduct of the enquiry or
disciplinary proceedings. In such a situation,
the Tribunal cannot sit as a court of appeal
over the decision of the disciplinary authority.
In exceptional cases, the Tribunal can
interfere only if the findings of the disciplinary
authority are totally perverse, mala fide, or
legally unsustainable, which is not so in the
present case. Considering the gravity of the
misconduct of the applicant, the penalty
imposed on him is also not disproportionate to
the charges proved against him. We will not,
therefore, interfere in the matter.
10. In view of the foregoing, we do not find
any merit in the OA, and the same is
accordingly dismissed without any order as to
costs.”
19.
The Review Application, being R.A. No. 175/2005, was also
dismissed by Order dated 20.01.2006, holding as under:
“ This R.A. has been filed by the applicant against
the order dated 20.07.2005 on the ground that all
arguments have not been dealt with, e.g.:–
i) Some of the additional documents and listed
documents were not supplied, which vitiated the
entire proceedings.
ii) Orders passed by authority are cryptic.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
iii) Prosecution witnesses were all interested
and there was no evidence against the
applicant and the Inquiry Officer had taken
extraneous material into consideration;
therefore, findings are unsustainable in law.
2. Perusal of the judgment dated 20.07.2005 shows
all these points have been dealt with in detail in
paras 8 and 9; therefore, it is wrong to suggest
that points have not been dealt with. Applicant
may not be happy with the order, but that is no
ground to review the order.
3. We have already expressed our views and cannot
sit in appeal over our own orders. In Union of
India v. Taritranjan Das, reported in (ATJ 2004
(2) SC 190), it has been held by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court that the scope of review is very
limited and it is not permissible for the forum
hearing the review application to act as an
appellate authority in respect of the original order
by afresh and rehearing of the matter to facilitate
a change of opinion on merits.
4. We find no error in the judgment; therefore, R.A.
is rejected at the admission stage itself.”
20.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has filed the present Writ
Petition, challenging the Impugned Order passed by the learned
Tribunal, with the following prayers:
“A. Quash the impugned orders dated
20.07.2005 and 20.01.2005 passed by the
learned Central Administrative Tribunal,
Principal Bench at New Delhi, in O.A. No.
1846/04 and R.A. No. 175/05, vide Annexure
P/1 and P/2 to the present petition, by a writ of
certiorari or any other appropriate writ or
direction, and may further be pleased to quash
the order of dismissal dated 23.07.2003, the
order-in-appeal dated 05.03.2004, and the
findings of the Inquiry Officer contained in its
report dated 30.12.2002, by a writ of
mandamus or any other appropriate writ or
direction, declaring the same to be illegal and
perverse;
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
B. Further direct the respondents to reinstate
the applicant with all consequential and
attendant service benefits; and
C. Pass such other and further order(s) as may
be deemed just and expedient in the premises
of the present case.”
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER:
21.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the issuance
of a major charge-sheet without conducting any preliminary inquiry
into the allegations purportedly made by a group of employees of
COD, Agra, is ex facie arbitrary and contrary to the applicable Rules.
It is further submitted that the complaint itself was a joint
representation, made in contravention of G.I., Ministry of W.H. & S.,
A.V., Circular No. 305 dated 21.02.1967, thereby vitiating the very
foundation of the disciplinary proceedings.
22.
The learned counsel for the petitioner contends that although
the charge-sheet contained a detailed list of documents forming the
basis of each Article of Charge, the respondents deliberately failed to
supply copies of the listed documents. Such denial, particularly at the
stage when the first defence was required to be submitted, constitutes
a clear violation of the principles of natural justice and rendered the
petitioner incapable of mounting an effective defence.
23.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that while the
Officer-in-Charge (Records), by letter dated 23.11.2000, stating that
inspection of documents would be provided at a safer place due to
alleged security concerns, no such inspection was ever facilitated. The
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
assurance of inspection thus remained illusory, and the Petitioner was
continuously denied access to the material relied upon against him.
24.
He further contends that the petitioner repeatedly apprised the
Inquiry Officer that the listed documents had neither been supplied
nor shown for inspection, while the Presenting Officer proceeded on
the basis of unauthenticated material. Despite the petitioner
identifying specific documents necessary for his defence, including
additional documents relevant to Article-II, no remedial action was
taken.
25.
It is further submitted that the proceedings dated 09.07.2001
themselves record that inspection of the listed documents was
incomplete and that the Inquiry would not proceed further until such
inspection was completed. However, the subsequent proceedings
dated 26.07.2001 record that the documents were still unavailable, yet
the Inquiry was sought to be continued on the untenable premise that
the documents would be provided only at the stage of crossexamination.
26.
The learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the
Presenting Officer’s assertion that documents would be produced only
if required during cross-examination is wholly unsustainable in law. A
Charged Official cannot be compelled to defend himself without prior
access to the material relied upon, and any punishment based on
documents withheld on such pretexts is procedurally impermissible.
27.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
continuation of proceedings despite admitted deficiencies in the
supply of documents reflects a biased and predetermined approach,
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
thereby vitiating the Inquiry Process in its entirety.
28.
He further contends that arbitrariness is further evident from
Office Order dated 30.01.2001, which falsely records that a CBI
investigation was underway, despite there being no such Inquiry. This
incorrect recording betrays a prejudicial mindset and an intent to
portray the Petitioner as culpable without affording him a fair
opportunity of defence.
29.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Inquiry
Report itself acknowledges that the petitioner objected to the absence
of a Preliminary Inquiry and to the non-supply of documents. It
further records that several documents were either not shown, partially
shown, or not made available at all. Despite these admissions, the
Inquiry Officer proceeded to record findings of guilt without
addressing these foundational defects.
30.
The learned counsel for the petitioner contends that by
representation dated 24.01.2003, the petitioner specifically highlighted
multiple procedural violations and discrepancies in the Inquiry. These
objections were mechanically ignored, without any independent
application of mind by the Disciplinary Authority.
31.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
Tribunal failed to appreciate that the Inquiry Report and the
disciplinary proceedings, which formed the sole basis of the
punishment, were conducted in gross violation of the statutory rules
and the principles of natural justice. The finding that no prejudice was
caused is patently erroneous, as the Petitioner was punished without
being furnished the very documents relied upon against him.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
RESPONDENTS:
32.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
petitioner was appointed as Storekeeper at the Central Ordnance
Depot, Agra, on 26.09.1984 and continued on the said post until the
Order of dismissal dated 23.07.2003, which was served upon him on
31.07.2003. It is further submitted that the petitioner’s brother,
Sarvesh Dixit, who was appointed as an LDC at COD, Agra, on
13.08.1984, was also proceeded against in the same Departmental
Inquiry and was dismissed from service on 31.07.2003. It is pertinent
to note that the petitioner’s brother expired during the pendency of
O.A. No. 2118/2004.
33.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that during the
period 1996–97, the petitioner, along with his family members,
promoted and canvassed a private finance concern, namely M/s
Alakhnanda Growth Funds/M/s. Agra Tech Ltd., inducing investments
from depot employees by offering lucrative returns and issuing postdated cheques. It is contended that during his tenure at COD, Agra, the
petitioner engaged in unauthorized financial activities by promoting
and managing private deposit schemes through the said family-run
concern.
34.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
petitioner collected substantial amounts from employees and retired
personnel, misusing his official position and influence to gain the
confidence of subordinates, thereby indulging in conduct expressly
prohibited under Rule 15 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
35.
The learned counsel for the respondents contends that
impressed by the attractive scheme, civilian depot employees invested
approximately Rs. 10,45,940/-, including an amount of Rs. 2,40,000/invested by retired Sub Major V.P. Singh from his pensionary
benefits, all of which amounts were deposited through the petitioner.
36.
It is further submitted that in the year 1999 the said financial
company went bankrupt, following which the petitioner absented
himself from COD, Agra, with effect from 15.03.1999. It is further
submitted that the petitioner sought transfer from COD, Agra, to
COD, Kanpur, or COD, Delhi, and allegedly approached higher
authorities with external influence, including intervention by a former
Member of Parliament, in contravention of Rule 3 of the CCS
(Conduct) Rules, 1964.
37.
He submits that in or about 1999, a total of eighty-four
complaints were lodged by depot employees and a retired Subedar
Major, alleging that the petitioner was actively promoting private
deposit schemes run by a family-managed concern, issuing deposit
receipts and post-dated cheques which were dishonoured on maturity,
thereby causing financial loss to the complainants.
38.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that an FIR
under Section 406 of the IPC was registered on 21.01.1999, recording
that the petitioner, his brother, and other family members had invested
substantial amounts in M/s AGFL, thereby clearly establishing the
petitioner’s direct nexus with the financial operations of the said
concern. It is further submitted that the petitioner himself admitted
that his brother frequently visited the COD gate in connection with the
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
financial business.
39.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that visiting
cards bearing the name “Lord Mahadev,” containing residential
addresses and telephone numbers, were issued by the petitioner to
investors and were produced during the Inquiry as documentary
evidence, further corroborating his direct involvement in the financial
consultancy business of M/s AGFL.
40.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that from
August 1997 to March 1999, the petitioner collected money from
depot employees and retired soldiers during working hours within the
depot premises, thereby effectively conducting private business inside
government premises for the benefit of his family members.
41.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that
disciplinary proceedings under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules,
1965 were initiated, and the petitioner was charge-sheeted on
07.08.2000 for multiple acts of misconduct, including promoting a
family-run financial concern and soliciting investments from depot
employees, in violation of Rule 15 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
42.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that based on
the findings of the Preliminary Inquiry, which established the
petitioner’s active involvement in private financial dealings, the
competent authority found the misconduct to be grave and initiated
regular departmental proceedings by issuing a Memorandum of
Charge along with a Statement of Imputations.
43.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the AOC
(Records), Secunderabad, after agreeing with the Inquiry findings,
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
issued a Show-Cause Notice and appointed an independent Inquiry
Officer to conduct a full-fledged oral Inquiry in accordance with Rule
14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
44.
It is further submitted that the Inquiry was conducted strictly in
accordance with the prescribed procedure, during which documentary
exhibits were produced and witnesses were examined and crossexamined, and the petitioner was afforded a full opportunity to defend
himself.
45.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
evidence before the Inquiry Officer clearly established a pattern of
financial canvassing and misuse of official influence by the petitioner
within the workplace.
46.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the Inquiry
Officer, after appreciating the evidence, submitted a detailed and
reasoned report dated 30.12.2002, holding all charges proved against
the petitioner.
47.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
Disciplinary Authority, after considering the Inquiry Report and the
petitioner’s representation, imposed the penalty of dismissal from
service by Order dated 23.07.2003, for recorded reasons.
48.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
Statutory Appeal preferred by the petitioner was dismissed by a
reasoned Order dated 05.03.2004 after granting him a personal
hearing. The learned counsel for the respondents further submits that
the petitioner was provided with all reasonable opportunities
throughout the proceedings and that the principles of natural justice
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
were fully complied with.
49.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
petitioner’s prolonged unauthorized absence and attempts to invoke
external influence were relevant aggravating factors duly considered
by the authorities.
50.
The learned counsel for the respondents submits that the issue
of proportionality was duly examined, and the penalty of dismissal
was found to be appropriate considering the gravity of the misconduct.
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the learned
Tribunal found the evidence sufficient and the punishment
proportionate, and recorded concurrent findings of fact.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
51.
We have considered the submissions made by the learned
counsels for the respective parties.
52.
The issue that arises for consideration is whether the
disciplinary proceedings and the consequential order of dismissal are
vitiated due to violation of the principles of natural justice.
53.
It is a settled position of law that, in the exercise of jurisdiction
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, this Court
does not sit as an appellate authority over the findings of a disciplinary
authority. Interference is warranted only where the disciplinary
proceedings are shown to suffer from procedural irregularity, violation
of statutory rules, breach of the principles of natural justice,
perversity, mala fides, or manifest arbitrariness.
54.
In the present case, the principal grievance of the petitioner
throughout the disciplinary proceedings, before the Tribunal, and
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
before this Court has been the alleged non-supply and non-inspection
of certain documents, which, according to him, deprived him of a
reasonable opportunity to defend himself. It is well settled that a mere
allegation of non-supply of documents does not, by itself, vitiate
disciplinary proceedings. The delinquent employee must establish that
the documents allegedly withheld were relevant, were relied upon, and
that their non-supply resulted in real and demonstrable prejudice to the
defence. In the absence of such a showing, the plea of violation of the
principles of natural justice remains speculative. The test is not
whether some documents were not supplied, but whether such nonsupply had the effect of denying the delinquent a fair opportunity of
defence.
55.
The record, however, clearly demonstrates that the Inquiry
Officer contemporaneously recorded the objections raised by the
petitioner, including those relating to the non-supply or incomplete
inspection of documents, and also recorded the stand of the Presenting
Officer that certain documents would be produced, if required, at the
stage of cross-examination.
56.
At the same time, the record shows that, notwithstanding the
objections raised regarding the non-supply or incomplete inspection of
documents, the petitioner participated throughout the inquiry, availed
the assistance of a Defence Assistant, extensively cross-examined the
prosecution witnesses, examined himself in defence, and submitted
written submissions. The petitioner was served with a detailed chargesheet and was afforded adequate opportunity to lead defence evidence.
The Inquiry Officer thereafter assessed the material on record,
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
including oral evidence, documentary exhibits produced during the
proceedings, and circumstantial evidence, and returned detailed and
reasoned findings on each Article of Charge.
57.
In the present case, the petitioner has not been able to
demonstrate which specific documents were essential for his defence,
in what manner they were relied upon by the Inquiry Officer, or how
their non-supply disabled him from effectively cross-examining the
prosecution witnesses or leading defence evidence. On the contrary,
the record reflects that the petitioner actively participated in the
inquiry proceedings, cross-examined the witnesses at length,
examined himself in defence, and submitted detailed written
submissions. In such circumstances, the plea of prejudice stands
substantially diluted.
58.
Having considered the record and the submissions, this Court
finds that the learned Tribunal examined the challenge to the
disciplinary proceedings within the permissible limits of judicial
review. The learned Tribunal recorded a categorical finding that the
Inquiry was conducted in accordance with law, that the petitioner was
afforded adequate opportunity to defend himself, and that no prejudice
was caused to him on account of the alleged non-supply of documents.
59.
Considering the nature of the charges, which relate to the
misuse of official position, financial impropriety, and conduct
unbecoming of a government servant, the penalty of dismissal cannot
be said to be shockingly disproportionate so as to warrant judicial
interference.
CONCLUSION;
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
60.
In view of the above, this Court finds no ground to interfere
with the Impugned Orders passed by the learned Tribunal.
61.
The present petition is, therefore, dismissed, and the Impugned
Orders passed by the learned Tribunal is upheld.
62.
There shall be no order as to costs.
MADHU JAIN, J.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
JANUARY 14, 2026/RM
Signed By:RENUKA W.P.(C) 13649/2006
NEGI
19:59:07
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review