Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
W.P.(C) 8522/2007 & CM APPL. 415/2015
Date of Decision: 06.04.2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
SATYADEV
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Chirayu Jain with Ms. Raksha A
wasya, Advocates.
versus
DELHI FIANCIAL CORPORATION & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mrs Avnish Ahlawat, Standing
Counsel GNCTD with Mr Nitesh
Kumar Singh, Ms Aliza Alam&Mr
Mohnish Sehrawat, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
JUDGEMENT
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J. (ORAL)
1.
The instant petition has been filed seeking the following reliefs:
“i.) To quash and set aside the punishment order of removal from service dated
9.11.06.
ii.) To quash and set aside the appellate authority order dated 12.6.07.
iii.) To issue writ of mandamus for reinstating the petitioner in service with all
consequential benefits.
iv.) To allow the writ petition with exemplary costs”
2.
It is the case of the petitioner that by way of the impugned order dated
09.11.2006, he was removed from service by respondent no. 1, on the basis
of a report submitted by the Departmental Committee (“the Committee”)
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 8522/2007
13:45:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
constituted by respondent no. 1 to examine a sexual harassment complaint
filed against him.
3.
The petitioner submits that the inquiry proceedings conducted by the
Committee were in violation of the principles of natural justice. Learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner contends that a copy of the
complaint was never furnished to him. It is further submitted that the
complainant was not examined during the proceedings. Accordingly, it is
argued that the impugned order deserves to be set aside. Reliance is placed
on the following decisions: Union of India v. Dilip Paul,1 Sur Enamel and
Stamping Works v. Workmen,2 Abraham Mathai v. State of Kerala,3 PS
Thapar v. DDA and Ors.,4 Institute of Hotel Management, Catering
Technology & Applied Nutrition v. Suddhasil Dey,5 and Jawaharlal Nehru
University v. Flora Gupta. 6
4.
The respondents are represented by Ms. Aliza Alam, learned counsel.
In response to the aforesaid contentions, she submits that throughout the
course of the inquiry proceedings, the petitioner never sought a copy of the
complaint. She further submits that the allegations against him are
substantiated by the statements of two witnesses, and therefore, the
impugned order is good in law and warrants no interference. Reliance is
placed on the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Apparel Export
Promotion Council v. A.K. Chopra.7
5.
I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1423
1963 SCC OnLine SC 97
2024 SCC OnLine Ker 7081
(2005) 79 DRJ 57
2020 SCC OnLine Cal 3320
2012 SCC OnLine Del 5722
(1999) 1 SCC 759
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 8522/2007
13:45:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
appearing for the parties and have perused the record.
6.
The following charges were framed against the petitioner:
“Statement of Article of Charge framed against Shri Satvadev. Staff
Car Driver. Delhi Financial Corporation.
Annexure I
Shri Satyadev while working in the Corporation as Staff Car Driver
committed following act of misconduct/misbehaviour and indiscipline.
Article I
That on 17.12.03, Shri Satyadev posted as Staff Car Driver in Branch
Office (Rohini) visited the Head Office without any apparent purpose.
Around 4.30 p.m. he entered Chief General Manager's Staff Room and
addressed Ms. Swaran Kaur Grewal, P.A. to CGM, who was alone in
the room, with comments which amounted to indecency and implied
unwelcome conduct subjecting Ms. Grewal to harassment. Ms.
Grewal also suspected Shri Satyadev being drunk.
Thus the above act of Shri Satyadev amounts to misconduct,
indiscipline and misbehaviour and unbecoming of an employee of the
Corporation under Staff Regulations 41(1) of the DFC Staff
Regulations.”
7.
It appears that the charges against the petitioner were sought to be
substantiated by a list of witnesses, which was also annexed to the Office
Memorandum dated 09.01.2004. The said list contained the names of the
following two witnesses:
8.
(i)
Mr. Dalbir Singh, Peon
(ii)
Mr. Raj Kumar, Peon
However, a perusal of the inquiry report reveals that the only material
witness in support of the allegation was one Mr. R.P. Singh. Despite this, he
was not named as a witness in the said list. Moreover, even the statement
given by Mr. R.P. Singh does not reveal any material facts establishing the
petitioner’s guilt. It appears that he did not state anything other than that he
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 8522/2007
13:45:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
noticed the complainant looking very disturbed and upset.
9.
The conclusion drawn by the Committee in its report is extracted as
under:
“Since there is no eyewitness to the alleged incident but from the
material on record, deposition of witnesses the probability that the
charged official had interacted with the complainant appears heavy in
favour of the complainant and against the charged official. In view of
the above facts and the totality of circumstances, which have emerged,
we have no hesitation to hold the complaint of the complainant have
substance in it and accordingly hold the charged official guilty of
misbehaviour but it cannot be conclusively stated that the charged
official was drunk at that point of time.”
10.
A perusal of the entire record indicates that there is no evidence to
substantiate the allegations levelled against the petitioner. The Committee
seems to have acted in a manner unknown to law, inasmuch as the burden of
proof was effectively shifted on the petitioner to explain as to why the
complainant herein would furnish a false complaint. Thus, the Committee’s
finding that the charges against the petitioner stand proved is based on no
evidence at all.
11.
In Kuldeep Singh v. Commissioner of Police & Ors.,8 the Supreme
Court has held that even in departmental inquiries, the findings must be
based on some cogent evidence pointing towards the guilt of the delinquent,
and such evidence must be of a nature that does not leave the matter in a
state of mere suspicion. Paragraph 7 of the said decision is extracted as
under:
“7. In Nand Kishore Prasad v. State of Bihar² it was held that the
disciplinary proceedings before a domestic tribunal are of quasijudicial character and, therefore, it is necessary that the Tribunal
(1999) 2 SCC 10
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 8522/2007
13:45:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
should arrive at its conclusions on the basis of some evidence, that is
to say, such evidence which and that too, with some degree of
definiteness, points to the guilt of the delinquent and does not leave
the matter in a suspicious state as mere suspicion cannot take the
place of proof even in domestic enquiries. If, therefore, there is no
evidence to sustain the charges framed against the delinquent, he
cannot be held to be guilty as in that event, the findings recorded by
the enquiry officer would be perverse.”
12.
It is also a well-known principle that suspicion, however high may be,
can, under no circumstances, be held to be a substitute for legal proof. This
principle has been reiterated by the Supreme Court time and again in various
decisions, including, Ravishankar Tandon v. State of Chhattisgarh,9
Varkey Joseph v. State of Kerala,10 and Digamber Vaishnav v. State of
Chhattisgarh.11
13.
Furthermore, the record indicates that the petitioner was not supplied
with a copy of the complaint. The contention of the learned counsel for the
respondents that the petitioner did not seek a copy of the complaint cannot
be accepted, as the same is a basic requirement for adherence to the
principles of natural justice.
It also appears from the record that the
complainant was not examined during the inquiry proceedings.
14.
For all the aforesaid reasons, this Court is of the view that the inquiry
proceedings, culminating in the termination of the petitioner’s services,
cannot be sustained in law. The entire inquiry and the conclusions drawn
therein are vitiated for non-adherence to the principles of natural justice, and
are hereby set aside. Accordingly, the impugned order of termination also
stands set aside.
2024 SCC OnLine SC 526
1993 Suppl (3) SCC 745
(2019) 4 SCC 522
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 8522/2007
13:45:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
15.
The Supreme Court, in Manorama Verma v. State of Bihar,12 has
held that the normal rule is that, in case termination of service is set aside as
illegal, the consequential order of grant of back-wages ought to follow. The
relevant portion of the same is extracted below, for reference:
“4. We do not see any justification for the High Court not allowing the
appellant back wages after it came to the conclusion that the termination
was illegal. Ordinarily, the consequential order of grant of back wages
must follow, unless there are reasons on record which would justify a
departure from the normal order. We do not see any reasons on record to
come to the conclusion that the appellant was not entitled to back wages.
There is also nothing on record to show that during the period she was
out of service, she was gainfully employed elsewhere. In the
circumstances we allow this appeal and set aside that part of the High
Court's order by which the appellant was denied back wages and award
her back wages from the date of termination of service till she was
reinstated in service under the impugned order of the High Court. The
appellant will be paid her back wages within three months from today.
There will be no order as to costs.”
16.
However, the Supreme Court, in Salim Ali Centre for Ornithology &
Natural History v. Mathew K. Sebastian,13 has held that the initial burden to
establish that he was not gainfully employed during the period of
termination lies on the petitioner, and only thereafter, the burden to prove
otherwise would shift to the respondents. The relevant portion of the said
decision is extracted below, for reference:
“8.2. That as per the settled position of law, it is the employee who has to
prove by leading evidence that he was not gainfully employed during the
period he remained out of employment. Reliance is placed upon the
decisions of this Court inState of U.P. v. Atal Behari Shastri,14; Kendriya
Vidyalaya Sangathan v. S.C. Sharma,15; J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. K.P.
1994 Supp (3) SCC 671
(2022) 20 SCC 692
1993 SCC (L&S) 423
(2005) 2 SCC 363
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 8522/2007
13:45:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Agrawal,16; P. Karupaiah v. Thruuvalluvar Transport Corpn. Ltd.17”
17.
It is seen that in the present case, the petitioner has, nowhere in the
petition, taken a stand that he was not gainfully employed during the period
of termination. In fact, he was hale and hearty at the time of termination and
as such, cannot be expected to have remained idle. He has also not placed
on record any affidavit to establish that he was not gainfully employed in the
meantime.
18.
In view of the forgoing discussion, since the termination of the
petitioner is wholly illegal and based on no justification, the Court deems it
appropriate to direct reinstatement of the petitioner with all consequential
benefits, limiting the back wages to the extent of twenty five percent of the
last drawn salary.
19.
In view of the aforesaid, the writ petition stands disposed of. Pending
applications also stand disposed of.
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J
APRIL 6, 2026
tr
(2007) 2 SCC 433
(2018) 12 SCC 663
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
W.P.(C) 8522/2007
13:45:47
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review