Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form J(2).
Item No. 109-110
Court No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
THE HON’BLE CHIEF JUSTICE SUJOY PAUL
AND
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE PARTHA SARATHI SEN
WPA(P) 361 of 2025
Ashim Kumar Baidya
Vs.
State of West Bengal & Anr.
With
WPA 25777 of 2025
Satya Sharan Mondal & Sons and Anr.
Vs.
State of West Bengal & Ors.
Appearance:For the Petitioners
In WPA(P) 361 of 2025
:
Mr. Shyamal Sarkar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Ram Anand Agarwal
Mr. Nibedita Pal
Mr. Ananda Gopal Mukherjee
Ms. Nasrin Khatoon
For the Respondent No.5
In WPA(P) 361 of 2025
&
For the Petitioner in
in WPA 25777 of 2025
:
Mr. Debabrata Saha Roy, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Pingal Bhattacharya
Mr. Neil Basu
Mr. Sankha Biswas
Ms. Oildrila Sarkar
Mr. A. Paul
For State
:
Mr. Swapan Kumar Dutta, Ld. GP
Mr. Nilotpal Chatterjee
Mr. Amritalal Chatterjee
Heard on
:
17.09.2025, 03.12.2025, 11.03.2026
17.03.2026
Delivered on
:
17.03.2026
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
PER, SUJOY PAUL, CJ.:1.
In PIL, being WPA(P) 361 of 2025 the petitioner has called in
question the legality, validity and propriety of the order dated
7th August, 2025. The order dated 7th August, 2025 is sought
to be implemented by a dealer in a Single Bench matter, i.e.
WPA 25777 of 2025. In other words, in the PIL the order dated
7th August, 2025 is the subject matter of challenge whereas in
WPA/25777/2025 it is prayed that the said order be directed to
be
implemented.
Accordingly,
both
the
matters
were
analogously heard with consent and decided by this common
order.
Factual Matrix :
2.
The facts are taken from PIL. On 7.9.2024, upon an inspection
conducted by the Food and Supply Department on the premises
of distributor/respondent no.5 it was found that 2513.80967
quintals of rice were found short and/or misappropriated.
Accordingly, on 9.9.2024, a show cause cum suspension notice
was issued to the respondent no.5. The respondent no.5 filed
his reply to the said show cause notice.
Stand of the Petitioner :
3.
The stand of the learned senior counsel for the petitioner in PIL
is that the public distribution system in State of West Bengal is
governed by the statutory provision, namely, West Bengal
Targetted Public Distribution System (Maintenance and
Control) Order 2024 (hereinafter referred to as the “Control
Order”).
This is not in dispute in the instant cases that the
validity of the impugned order needs to be decided on the anvil
of the said Control Order.
4.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner by taking this Court to
various provisions of the Control Order urged that the
competent authority has not acted in consonance with and in
terms of the said Control Order.
5.
In order to explain, it is submitted that Clause 48 of the Control
Order
deals
with
punishment
for
black
marketing,
misappropriation or siphoning off commodities under public
distribution system.
It is submitted that the authority in
consonance of Clause 48 can suspend the license of a
distributor immediately after giving him an opportunity of being
heard and if he is found guilty, may pass a reasoned order by
imposing a punishment of either fine or reduction of volume of
business according to the gravity of offence or terminate his
license. Reliance is also placed on Schedule C. Part II of the
Schedule C is relied upon which deals with penalty for
offence/contravention.
It is submitted that for committing
offence under Clause 48 the fine or cost can be imposed in the
manner described in the third column of Schedule C.
6.
By taking this Court to the impugned order, the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner submits that the District Controller (F
& S) (hereinafter referred to as District Controller) passed an
order, which is unknown to law. He permitted the respondent
no.5 to replenish the deficit quantity of 2513.80967 quintal of
rice and imposed a penalty of Rs.4,00,000/- only.
Upon
depositing the same, the license was directed to be restored.
7.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner also relied on Clause
50 of the Control Order to demonstrate that there exists a
statutory time limit of maximum 90 days within which the
disposal must take place. In the instant case, it is pointed out
that the proceeding commenced with issuance of show cause
notice on 9.9.2024 which ended with imposition of penalty of
Rs.4,00,000/- on 24.07.2025. Thus, the statutory time limit of
90 days was deliberately breached and the proceedings
continued upto 330 days.
8.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
Control Order/Statute does not contain any provision to
replenish the deficit quantity of food items. In absence of any
enabling provision, the statutory authority was not competent
to adopt this method, which is unknown to the Statute. It is
submitted that if a Statute prescribes a thing to be done in a
particular manner it has to be done in the same manner.
Reliance is placed on the judgement of Supreme Court in the
case of Nautam Prakash DGSVC, VADTAL vs. K.K. Thakkar &
Ors. reported in 2006(5) SCC 330.
9.
By placing reliance on a Single Bench judgement of this Court
in the case of Scotts (P) Ltd. & Ors. vs. Corporation of
Calcutta & Ors. reported in 79 CWN 883, it is urged that the
fundamental principle of law is that a natural person has the
capacity to do all lawful things unless his capacity has been
curtailed by some rule of law.
Conversely, the statutory
corporation/authority has no power to do anything unless such
power are specifically conferred on it by the relevant statute.
Thus, there is a sever criticism of method adopted by the
District Controller in the manner he permitted replenishment.
10.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that on the
one hand the petitioner is surprised about the kind of kindness
shown to the respondent no.5 and on the other hand for similar
offence
committed
by
another
distributor
order
dated
12.08.2025 (Annexure P7 of the Supplementary Affidavit) was
passed whereby his dealership was terminated and in addition,
he was directed to deposit Rs.2,47,14,100.00 as economic cost
on account of public distribution commodity misappropriation.
It is submitted that the same District Controller of same district
has acted in two different ways by applying two different
formulas in cases of similar nature of deficiency of rice. Thus,
pick and choose action and selective favour to respondent no.5
deserves to be deprecated.
Stand of State :
11.
Mr. Chatterjee, learned counsel for the State submits that the
facts are not in dispute. He at the outset fairly submits that the
statutory provision, namely, the Control Order, does not
contain any specific provisions which enables the District
Controller to allow replenishment of stock in case of deficiency
of stock. He submits that the District Controller in the given
factual matrix of present matter was kind enough in deciding
that replenishment may take care of the public needs, public
welfare
and,
therefore,
permitted
replenishment.
After
replenishment since there existed no deficiency of relevant food
item, he decided to impose only Rs.4,00,000/- as cost whereas
in the other case for which the order dated 12.08.2025
(Annexure P7 of the Supplementary Affidavit) was issued, the
quantity of misappropriated food item was much higher than
the quantity involved in the case of respondent no.5.
Stand of the Respondent no.5
12.
Mr. Saha Roy, learned senior counsel for the respondent no.5
opposed the petition by contending that not a single complaint
was preferred by anybody against the respondent no.5 in
relation to deficiency of food items or poor quality of item
distributed from his distributorship. Since no common man or
consumer has preferred any complaint regarding the deficiency
of services this petition cannot be treated to be a PIL filed on
behalf of the public at large. In the entire body of PIL there
exists no pleading to show as to what is the cause of action in
favour of the present petitioner.
He raised eyebrows on the
locus of the present petitioner.
13.
Secondly, the learned counsel for the respondent no.5 has
taken pains to take us through the show cause notice, reply
filed by the respondent no.5, hearing notice given to him and
the final impugned order passed in the instant matter.
He
strenuously contended that in the manner his agency was
placed under suspension and in the manner the procedure was
followed it clearly violates the Control Order.
The time limit
prescribed in the Control Order to complete the proceeding was
90 days.
Since it continued for much longer time, the
respondent no.5 under compelling circumstances replenished
rice item and the authority, accordingly, rightly imposed a cost
of Rs.4,00,000/- only.
During the course of hearing, the
learned senior counsel for the respondent no.5 also fairly
admitted that under the Control Order there exists no specific
provision which permits replenishment of misappropriated food
item by the District Controller.
14.
Lastly, by placing reliance on certain annexures filed with WPA
25777 of 2025 and in his counter filed in PIL he submits that
even after passing the impugned order dated 7th August, 2025
the dealership of the respondent no.5 was not restored. He was
compelled to approach the writ Court by filing WPA 25777 of
2025. The learned Single Judge observed that if the State is
not aggrieved by order dated 7th August, 2025 there is no
reason for not implementing the same.
15.
Lastly, he placed reliance on the order dated 7th December 2025
to canvass the position that till that date his distributorship
was not restored fully and the stock was not transferred from
the agency it was tagged at the time of suspension, namely
M/s. Annupurna Enterprise.
16.
The parties confined their argument to the extend indicated
above.
17.
We have bestowed our anxious consideration on the rival
contention and perused the record.
FINDINGS
18.
Before dealing with rival contentions it is apposite to mention
that the learned counsels for the parties agreed that the validity
of the impugned order has to be examined on the touch stone of
the Control Order. Relevant portion of the Control Order needs
reproduction. Clause 48 reads as follows:
“48. Punishment for Black marketing, misappropriation or
siphoning off etc. of public distribution commodities by
Distributor. – If a Distributor has committed an offence of –
(i) Black marketing, or
(ii) misappropriation, or
(iii) siphoning off,
of public distribution commodities, the licensing authority
may suspend his license immediately and after giving him
an opportunity of being heard, if found guilty of such
offence, may by passing a reasoned order in writing,
impose a punishment of either fine, or reduction of the
volume of business according to the gravity to the gravity
of the offence, or termination of his license, as per the
offences specified in Part I of Schedule C.
Explanation I.- Keeping public distribution commodities in
a godown other than the godown registered with the
licensing authority or shortage of stock may be regarded
as misappropriation of public distribution commodities and
the Distributor shall be liable for the penalty under this
clause.
Explanation II.- Selling the public distribution commodity
on the price higher than the price fixed by the Government
shall be regarded as black marketing and the Distributor
shall liable for the penalty as per this clause.
Explanation
III.-
Transferring
or
Selling
the
public
distribution commodity to any unauthorized person or
entity shall be regarded as siphoning and the Distributor
shall be liable for the penalty as per this clause.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
19.
This Clause needs to be read with relevant schedule i.e.
Schedule C (Part II). Relevant portion of this Schedule reads
thus.
Sl.
No.
Offences/cont Penalty for first
ravention
offence/
under
contravention
relevant cause
(1)
(2)
(3)
1.
Contravention
Penalty
for
second
time
offence/
contravention of
same provision
(4)
Penalty for third time or
subsequent
offence/contravention
of
same provisions
(5)
Fine of minimum Fine of minimum The licensing authority may
of any of the of Rs.25,000/- for of Rs.50,000/- for impose
provisions
of each
of
sub-clause (1) contravention
the each
of
contravention
a
penalty
of
the Rs.1,00,000/- for each of the
contravention committed by
to (5) of clause committed by the committed by the the distributor which may be
distributor which distributor which extended
to
may be extended may be extended Rs.2,00,000/-
maximum
of
for
each
to maximum of to maximum of contravention, with an overall
Rs.50,000/-
for Rs.1,00,000/- for limit of Rs.10,00,000/- and the
each
each
Licensing Authority may also
contravention
contravention,
render
his
license
under
with an overall with an overall suspension immediately for
limit
of limit
of minimum 3 three months and
Rs.2,00,000/-.
Rs.4,00,000/-.
maximum 6 months and after
giving him an opportunity of
being
heard
and
for
the
reasons recorded to be in
writing,
either
reduce
the
volume of business (upto 50%
quantity) according to the
gravity of the offence.
2.
3.
………………
…………………
………………….
…………………...
………
…..
Committing
Fine of minimum Fine of minimum Fine of minimum of 3 (three)
offence under of 2 (two) times of 2(two) times times the economic cost of the
clause 48
and maximum of and maximum of public
distribution
3 (three) times 3 (three) times the commodities
the
economic economic cost of minimum
also
fine
a
of
public Rs.10,00,000/- for an offence
cost of the public the
of
distribution
distribution
and
black
marketing
or
commodities and commodities and misappropriation or siphoning
also a minimum also a minimum off
distribution
of commodities meant for public
of fine
fine
public
Rs.3,00,000/- for Rs.10,00,000/- for distribution or terminate his
an
offence
of an
black marketing black
offence
of license.
marketing
or
or
misappropriatio
misappropriation
n or siphoning or siphoning
off
off
public public distribution
distribution
commodities
commodities
meant for public
meant for public distribution.
distribution.
4.
………………
………………….
………………….
………………………………
20.
On a combined reading of Clause 48 and entry 3 of Schedule C
makes it clear that there exists no enabling statutory provision
which permits the statutory authority to allow replenishment of
deficient/misappropriated stock.
In case of deficiency, the
statutory authority can take only such action which is
statutorily prescribed in Clause 48 read with Entry III of
Schedule C of first offence/contravention. Learned counsel for
parties during the course of hearing also fairly admitted that
there exists no statutory provisions which enables the District
Controller
to
permit
the
distributor
to
replenish
the
misappropriated deficit food items.
21.
This is trite that if a law prescribes a thing to be done in a
particular way it has to be done in the same manner and other
methods are forbidden. The basic judgement in this regard is
Tailor vs. Tailor reported in (1875) LR 1 Ch D426 which is
consistently followed by the Supreme Court in several cases
(See: 2014 (3) SCC 502 (Dipak Babaria & Anr. vs. State of
Gujarat)
22.
The judgement in the case of Nautam Prakash (Supra) on
which reliance was placed it was held that a statutory authority
must exercise its jurisdiction within the four corners of the
Statute. It cannot act beyond the same. Any order which is
passed by an authority which lacked inherent jurisdiction
would be ultra vires. In view of aforesaid legal position, there is
no cavil of doubt that the decision of the District Controller
permitting replenishment of misappropriated food item is ultra
vires the control order without authority and jurisdiction.
23.
For this reason alone, the impugned order cannot sustain
judicial scrutiny.
24.
It is also noteworthy that as per Clause 50 of control order the
statutory time frame for disposal of the proceeding is prescribed
which reads thus:
“50. Timeframe for disposal of the proceedings.-(1)
The inspecting authority or the team shall submit
their report to the licensing authority within twenty
one (21) days of the date of inspection or visit.
However, the report may be submitted within thirty
(30) days of the date of inspection or visit in special
circumstances and reasons for such delay shall be
recorded in the report.
(2)All the proceedings initiated under this chapter
shall be disposed of by the licensing authority within
sixty (60) days of the date of inspection or visit.
However, the case shall be disposed of within ninety
(90) days of the date of inspection or visit in special
circumstances and reasons for such delay shall be
recorded in writing.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
25.
In the instant case, there exists abnormal delay in concluding
the proceedings.
The District Controller (F&S) has permitted
the respondent no.5 to gain time to replenish the entire
misappropriated/deficient food staff.
This practice is totally
unknown to law and we deprecate the same. The very purpose
of providing public distribution system is to ensure that the
public at large gets the food items expeditiously and regularly.
If misappropriation is permitted to be replenished by extending
time in favour of defaulting distributor, it gives wrong signal
and cannot be said to be in public interest.
26.
The
Respondent
No.5’s
contention
about
locus
and
maintainability of petition is concerned, this court has already
dealt with this aspect when this objection was raised on 3rd
December, 2025 and overruled the said objection.
Even
otherwise, if there is huge misappropriation of rice by public
distributor working under public distribution system, it cannot
be said that grievance in this regard has no public element in it.
In our considered opinion, petition of this nature falls within
the ambit of public interest litigation.
27.
Even assuming that petitioner did not have any locus to raise
this issue or was personally interested the petition involving
grave public interest cannot be thrown to winds. The Apex
Court has drawn curtains on this issue in Akhil Bhartiya
Upbhokta Congress vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors.
reported in (2011) 5 SCC 29. It is apt to quote the relevant
Paragraph:
“80. The challenge to the locus standi of the appellant merits
rejection because it has not been disputed that the appellant is
a public-spirited organization and has challenged other similar
allotment made in favour of Punjabi Samaj, Bhopal, That apart,
as held in Shivajirao Nilangekar Patil vs. Mahesh Madhav
Gosavi even if a person files a writ petition for vindication of
his private interest but raises question of public importance
involving exercise of power by men in authority then it is the
duty of the court to enquire into the matter.
(Emphasis Supplied)
In view of the principle laid down in this Judgment of Apex
Court, by no stage of imagination it can be said that instant
matter is not a public interest litigation or it must be rejected
on the technical grounds.
28.
So far argument of ld. Counsel for Respondent No.5 about
procedural flaws allegedly committed by the Food and Supply
Department while weighting the food stock etc. and other
alleged procedural flaws are concerned, suffice it to say that
Respondent No.5 did not challenge those alleged procedural
flaws before any appropriate forum. He on his own decided to
replenish
the
misappropriated/deficient
food
item.
The
impugned order in the PIL was not called in question by him.
Instead, he filed the connected writ application seeking
execution/enforcement of the said order. Thus, it does not lie in
his mouth to say that the procedure adopted by Food
Department while assessing the shortage of rise suffered from
any irregularity or illegality.
29.
So far the question of discretion of District Controller is
concerned, the comparative reading of impugned order in the
present case dated 07.08.2025 and order date 12.08.2025
passed in case of other distributor shows that the District
Controller (F&S) who passed the order in both the cases is same
and belongs to the same district. Whether or not he belongs to
same district and same person, the authority is guided by same
statute namely control order. Thus, his jurisdiction is confined
to pass an order within the framework of the control order. He
cannot be permitted to act as per his whims and fancies. For
one distributor act beyond the control order and act in a totally
different way for another distributor.
such unfettered discretion.
He does not have any
The discretion is flowing from
Clause 48 and schedule which permits him to impose fine or
issue direction for reduction of volume of business or terminate
his licence as the case may be, considering the gravity of
offence and so far cost is concerned, he can take guidance from
Entry 3 of Schedule C Part II of the control order. In that case
also, the discretion is limited to impose fine either two times or
three times considering the gravity of the matter. Beyond that,
there is no other discretion available with the District
Controller.
30.
In this view of the matter, in our opinion, the impugned order
dated 07.08.2025 in the PIL cannot sustain judicial scrutiny.
Resultantly, the order dated 07.08.2025 is set aside.
The
matter is remitted back to the District Controller (F&S) to pass
a fresh order in accordance with control order by taking into
account the observations made by us hereinabove.
31.
As notice above, in the connected WPA 25777 of 2025, the
petitioner is seeking enforcement of the order dated 07.08.2025
which has been set aside in the previous paragraph, hence no
relief is due in this petition.
32.
In the peculiar facts of this case, we deem it proper to direct
that if in the meantime, District Controller (F&S) of the South
24 Parganas, who had passed the impugned order is changed,
new District Controller ( F&S) may on remand pass the fresh
order in accordance with law.
In case the said District
Controller (F&S), who passed the impugned order, is still
continuing in the same district, it shall be the duty of State
Government to direct the District Controller (F&S) of North 24
Parganas to pass a fresh order on remand in accordance with
law.
33.
The entire exercise be completed by the concerned District
Controller (F&S) within 30 days from the date of production of
the copy of this order. Accordingly, the PIL being WPA(P) 361 of
2025 is allowed and the writ petition being WPA 25777 of 2025
is dismissed.
34.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
delivered to the learned advocates for the parties, upon
compliance of all formalities.
(SUJOY PAUL, CJ.)
I agree.
(PARTHA SARATHI SEN, J.)
RP(AR.CT.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review