Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~J* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 20.11.2025
Judgment delivered on: 07.01.2026
+
RC.REV. 300/2024, CM APPL. 63036/2024, CM APPL. 14953/2025
SATISH KUMAR GUPTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Dr. Amit George with Mr. Nitesh
Mehra, Ms. Hitaakshi Mehra, Ms.
Ibansara
Syiemlieh
and
Ms.
Pratishtha Verhwani, Advocates.
versus
SUSHIL KUMAR LOOMBA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Murari Tiwari, Mr. Tripurari
Tiwari, Mr. Rahul Kumar, Ms. Payal
Dhupar, Ms. Indira Murthy, Ms.
Shadwali and Ms. Nimisha Gupta
Advocates.
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI
J U D G M E N T
ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI J.
By way of the present revision petition filed under section
25B(8) of the Delhi Rent Control Act 1958 („DRC Act‟), the petitioner
challenges order dated 31.05.2024 passed by the learned Additional
Rent Controller, North-District, Rohini Courts, New Delhi („ARC‟) in
Eviction Petition bearing RC ARC No. 384/2016.
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.
Briefly, the present petition relates to Shop No. 2 situate on the Ground
Floor of property bearing No. C-32, Nehru Road, Adarsh Nagar, Delhi
(„subject premises‟), which premises has been in the use and
occupation of the petitioner for more than 30 years, with the last paid
rent of Rs. 702/- per month.
3.
On 14/15.10.2016 the respondent (landlord) filed an eviction petition
under section 14(1)(e) read with section 25B of the DRC Act seeking
eviction of the petitioner (tenant) from the subject premises, on the
ground that respondent bona-fidé requires the subject premises to start
his own business since the respondent‟s only source of income has
been his rental income.
4.
Pursuant thereto, on 16.11.2016, the petitioner filed his application
seeking to leave to defend the eviction petition under section 25B(4)
and (5) of the DRC Act, which application came to be dismissed; and
resultantly, the eviction petition was allowed vidé impugned order
dated 31.05.2024 passed by the learned ARC.
5.
The court has heard Dr. Amit George, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner; as well as Mr. Murari Tiwari, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent at length.
PETITIONER’S SUBMISSIONS
6.
On behalf of the petitioner, it is submitted that the present revision
petition has been preferred against order dated 31.05.2024 passed by
the learned ARC in the eviction petition, whereby the application
seeking leave to defend filed by the petitioner in respect of the subject
premises has been dismissed, thereby directing eviction of the
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
petitioner from the subject premises without trial. It is contended that
the impugned order is vitiated since it ignores material facts,
documentary evidence and settled principles governing the grant of
leave to defend under section 25B of the DRC Act.
7.
It is urged that the eviction petition was filed under section 14(1)(e) of
the DRC Act in 2016 with the sole intent of securing higher rental
income by evicting the petitioner, and not on account of any genuine or
bona-fidé requirement. The respondent is alleged to have deliberately
suppressed the availability of Shops Nos. 1 and 3 in the same building,
which, it is contended, remained vacant during the pendency of the
eviction proceedings, thereby creating a false appearance of scarcity to
found a false claim of personal necessity. The petitioner emphasises
that his tenancy in Shop No. 2 dates back to 1994 under a pagri
arrangement, pursuant to which an amount of Rs. 3,25,000/- was paid
to the respondent‟s father and rent of Rs. 360/- per month, then
commensurate with the market rate, has been regularly tendered
without default, though the respondent subsequently declined to accept
rent with the oblique motive to re‑let the premises for a higher
consideration.
8.
It is further submitted that the respondent‟s alleged closure and sale of
his industrial oxygen gas cylinder business under agreement dated
10.05.2016 for Rs. 1,00,000/- is denied by the petitioner, who asserts
that the respondent continues to carry-on the said business and that the
plea of closure of that business is a device to manufacture a false
ground of „need‟ which does not exist.
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
9.
The cornerstone of the petitioner‟s challenge is that the requirement
pleaded by the respondent is not bona-fidé in view of the availability of
suitable, alternate accommodation in the hands of the respondent, in the
form of Shops Nos. 1 and 3 in the same building. As to Shop No. 1, it
is contended that although the respondent initially claimed that the said
shop was let-out to one Mr. Vinod Kumar, the petitioner had placed
substantial documentary and photographic material on record before
the learned ARC to show that Shop No. 1 stood vacated as far back as
in 2016; and that, when confronted, the respondent produced a
purported Surrender Deed dated 20.08.2018 (appended as Annexure
A‑10 to the revision petition) to support his contention that the said
shop has been re-let, which surrender deed however did not even bear
the signatures of any witness, thereby casting serious doubt on its
genuineness. The petitioner also points-out, that later, the respondent
took a false plea that the respondent‟s wife had started a boutique under
the name and style of “M/s. Nice Boutique” from Shop No. 1 in
September 2018; but that plea did not find mention in the application
under section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, filed by the
respondent to place the said Surrender Deed on record, which,
according to the petitioner, betrays that the plea relating to the wife‟s
business was an afterthought on the respondent‟s part and was
inconsistent with the stand taken by the respondent earlier.
10. With regard to Shop No. 3, it is submitted that the said shop was
vacated by the Bank of India in 2022 and was available to the
respondent for his use; but that the respondent‟s intention is only to relet Shop No. 3 for earning higher rental income, while seeking to evict
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
the petitioner from Shop No. 2. The petitioner contends that the
respondent‟s true intention wholly undermines his plea of bona-fidé
requirement of Shop No. 2 for personal use, inasmuch as a similarly
situate commercial unit, viz., Shop No. 3 in the same building, is being
treated only as a source of higher rent and not as a premises required
for personal use.
11. The availability of Shops Nos. 1 and 3 throughout the substantial phase
of the eviction proceedings, is thus asserted to constitute clear
availability of alternative accommodation, and the photographs already
on record (appended as Annexure A‑21 to the revision petition) are
relied upon to show that both those shops remained vacant, which,
according to the petitioner, fatally erodes the credibility of the
respondent‟s projected „need‟.
12. The petitioner submits that, it is settled law that at the stage of
considering an application seeking leave to defend an eviction petition
under section 25B of the DRC Act, the court is only required to see
whether the tenant has raised any triable issues, which warrant a
full‑fledged trial; and that leave-to-defend cannot be refused where the
eviction petition appears to have been filed by way of a design to
wrongfully evict a protected tenant; and where the landlord‟s
requirement is neither bona-fidé in praesenti nor anything more than a
mere „desire‟ to evict the tenant and not any „need‟ as contemplated
under section 14(1)(e) of the DRC Act. It is further contended that the
learned ARC has adopted an erroneous and one‑sided approach to the
evidence on record, by uncritically accepting the respondent‟s
unsubstantiated assertions regarding the boutique business of his wife,
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
while completely disregarding the petitioner‟s documentary and
photographic material concerning the vacancy and availability of Shops
Nos. 1 and 3, without assigning any cogent reasons for discarding such
evidence.
13. On this basis, the petitioner prays that the impugned order be set-aside,
the existence of triable issues be recognized, and leave to defend the
eviction petition be granted to the petitioner, so that the matter may
proceed to trial on the question of the respondent‟s alleged bona-fidé
requirement and the availability of suitable, alternate accommodation
in the respondent‟s hands.
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
14. On behalf of the respondent, it is submitted that the present revision
petition assailing order dated 31.05.2024 passed by the learned ARC is
not maintainable and warrants outright dismissal, since the petitioner
has approached this court based on false and misleading assertions. In
particular, it is submitted that the petitioner has deliberately concealed
his residential address and falsely projected himself as a “caretaker” of
Shop No. 2, despite having been a tenant in the subject premises, who
has already been directed by the learned ARC to vacate the premises,
thereby attempting to obfuscate his true status and circumvent the
eviction order.
15. It is further submitted that the respondent is a senior citizen and the
admitted owner/landlord of the property comprising 03 shops, of which
the petitioner was inducted as tenant in Shop No. 2. It is pointed-out,
that in paragraph 16 of his leave-to-defend application filed before the
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
learned ARC, the petitioner has acknowledged the landlord‑tenant
relationship as between the respondent and the petitioner.
16. It is argued that the petitioner has falsely claimed that the eviction
petition was founded on false, frivolous and baseless allegations,
though the respondent‟s eviction petition was instituted on the ground
of his bona-fidé requirement of the subject premises for running his
own business to earn his livelihood, since the respondent had no other
reasonably suitable, commercial accommodation available to him.
17. The respondent supports the impugned order, by submitting that the
learned ARC has rightly rejected and dismissed the tenant‟s application
for leave to defend the petition, after recording a clear finding that the
respondent requires the tenanted shop for commercial use, and that no
suitable, alternate premises is available with the respondent. It is
argued that the learned ARC has also correctly held that the petitioner
failed to raise any substantial or reasonable defence which could give
rise to any triable issues, thereby justifying refusal of leave under the
special summary procedure under section 25B of the DRC Act.
18. With respect to specific objections, it is urged that the learned ARC
has also correctly discarded the tenant‟s plea that the respondent
continues to run an oxygen‑cylinder supply business, in view of the
undisputed transfer of that business to one Mr. Manish Kumar
Bhardwaj by an undertaking dated 10.05.2016, after which the
respondent has had no business of his own. Likewise, the contention
that Shop No. 1 constitutes alternative accommodation has also been
rightly rejected, since Shop No. 1 was let-out to Mr. Vinod Kumar
under rent agreement/deed dated 24.04.2015 and Shop No. 3 was let-
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
out to M/s Prizm Payment Services Pvt. Ltd. under a Lease Deed dated
13.04.2015; and the petitioner‟s assertion that Mr. Vinod Kumar had
surrendered Shop No. 1 in 2018 so as to satisfy the respondent‟s need
in August 2017, has been correctly found to be frivolous. It is
submitted that the learned ARC has also correctly disbelieved the
allegation that Shop No. 1 was lying vacant, since the evidence on
record shows that the respondent‟s wife has been running a
boutique/tailoring business for ladies‟ suits from that shop under the
name and style “M/s Nice Boutique” since 2018.
19. In support of the proposition that the landlord is the best judge of his
requirement, the respondent has placed reliance on the decision of the
Supreme Court in Anil Bajaj & Anr. vs. Vinod Ahuja1.
20. On this foundation, the respondent submits that the learned ARC‟s
findings on bona-fidé requirement and absence of alternative
accommodation are unassailable and that the petitioner‟s revision
discloses no ground for interference under section 25B(8) of the DRC
Act.
21. The respondent accordingly prays, that in light of the facts and the
judicial precedents cited, the revision petition be dismissed.
DISCUSSION & CONCLUSIONS
22. A perusal of the impugned order shows that the learned ARC has
proceeded to allow the respondent‟s eviction petition based on the
following inferences :
(2014) 15 SCC 610
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
22.1. Firstly, that there was no dispute qua the landlord-tenant
relationship between the respondent and the petitioner;
22.2. Secondly, that the bona-fidé requirement of the respondent for
using the subject premises for running a business was made-out,
since at the time of filing the eviction petition the respondent had
already sold his previous business of supplying oxygen
cylinders; and
22.3. Thirdly, that the respondent was able to establish that he did not
have any other suitable, alternative accommodation for his bonafidé need of running a business.
23.
On perusing the impugned order, it is seen that in arriving at the
above conclusions, the learned ARC has dealt with all the contentions
raised by the petitioner; and has observed that none of those
contentions were well-founded; and that the cases relied upon by the
petitioner also did not come in aid of his arguments.
24.
While dealing with the rival contentions of the parties, the learned
ARC has also inter-alia cited Ragavendra Kumar vs. Firm Prem
Machinery & Co.2 to re-iterate that:
“ …… the landlord is the best judge of his requirement for
residential or business purpose and he has got complete freedom in
the matter.”
25. On a conspectus of the above :
25.1. Firstly it is seen that there was no dispute as regards the
„landlord-tenant‟ relationship as between the respondent and the
petitioner.
(2000) 1 SCC 679, para 10
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
25.2. Secondly, the other bone of contention raised by the petitioner,
viz., that the respondent was already running the business of
supplying oxygen cylinders from elsewhere, was also a redherring for two reasons: one, that the respondent had placed on
record an undertaking dated 10.05.2016, which evidences that
the said business had been transferred by the respondent to a
third party; and two, even assuming that the respondent was
continuing with his business of supplying oxygen cylinders, that
would not, in and of itself, foreclose the respondent‟s right to
start a new business from the subject premises.
25.3. Thirdly, insofar as availability of alternate accommodation is
concerned, the learned ARC has duly dealt with that issue and
has accepted the explanation offered by the respondent in
relation to Shops Nos. 1 and 3, namely that both the said shops
are being used by the respondent's wife for running her boutique.
The learned ARC has also observed that the petitioner cannot
interfere with the discretion of the respondent's wife using a shop
which fell vacant during the pendency of the eviction petition in
relation to Shop No. 2 i.e., the subject premises. This court finds
no reason to form a different opinion on that issue.
26. Based on the preceding discussion, this court agrees that order dated
31.05.2024 issued by the ARC, which rejected the petitioner‟s leave-todefend application and issued an eviction order, is lawful. The court
finds that the learned ARC reached his conclusions based on the
documents on record and the admissions made by the petitioner, as
well as the admitted position between the parties.
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
27. As a result, this court is of the view that no triable issues arise in the
case, that would justify granting leave to defend.
28. It is also well settled that while exercising its revisional jurisdiction
under section 25B(8) of the DRC Act, this court must refrain from revisiting factual conclusions or replacing the Rent Controller's
assessment with its own. The limited remit of revisional proceedings
under section 25B(8) of the DRC Act is pithily enunciated by the
Supreme Court in Sarla Ahuja vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.3,
the most relevant paragraph of which judgment reads as under:
“6. The above proviso indicates that power of the High Court is
supervisory in nature and it is intended to ensure that the Rent Controller
conforms to law when he passes the order. The satisfaction of the High Court
when perusing the records of the case must be confined to the limited sphere
that the order of the Rent Controller is “according to the law”. In other
words, the High Court shall scrutinize the records to ascertain whether any
illegality has been committed by the Rent Controller in passing the order
under Section 25-B. It is not permissible for the High Court in that exercise to
come to a different fact finding unless the finding arrived at by the Rent
Controller on the facts is so unreasonable that no Rent Controller should have
reached such a finding on the materials available.”
(emphasis supplied)
29. Moreover, this court cannot turn the present revisional proceedings
under section 25B(8) into appellate proceedings, since the text of
section 25B(8) specifically bars any appeal or second appeal from a
possession order made by the Rent Controller.
30. Thus, this court of opinion that the eviction order passed by the learned
ARC vidé order dated 31.05.2024, when viewed from the prism of
section 25B(8) of the DRC Act, is “according to law” and does not
require interference by this court in its revisional jurisdiction.
(1998) 8 SCC 119, para 6
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
31. The present petition is accordingly dismissed, observing that the
respondent (landlord) is now free to enforce the eviction order
immediately, since the 06-month period stipulated in section 14(7) of
the DRC Act has expired, making the eviction order enforceable.
32. Pending applications, if any, are also dismissed.
ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI, J
JANUARY 07, 2026
Signed By:ANJALI
KAUSHIK
Signing
Date:07.01.2026 15:23
RC.REV. 300/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review