Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 325s 1
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N'V.SHRAVAN
KUMAR
WRIT PE TITION N O:35210 oF 2024
Between:
years'
S Shankaraiah Aoed about 63
. Sarikonda tshwaramma, Wo viir"g"
District
i"t Mandal'-Nalgonda
occ Agricultur" nlo.'Ui'iif,i"p'irv
years' Occ Agriculture
lndira, Wo Sanjay Kumar' Aged abo-ut 39.
2.
' Madhurai
ii[,.'cnrt"pilrv'virrrgJ ini Mandal' Nal-gonda District'
Aoed about 53 years'
3. Chaman Chandrakala' D/o Late Sriramultr -Nalgonda
District
occ. Agriculture R/o.Thin;p;rrv Viiage Jnd Mandal'
51 years' Occ Agriculture
Swaroopa, Wo B Narsing. [a-q' llSed,Sfout
4. Billakal
'Chri;prriiVirrage
District'
- Hi;
ano tvtaniat' Nalsonda
about 48 years
Aoed
-Nalsonda District
5. Mavilla Satyanarayana, S/o Late Sriramulu'
occ. Agriculture R/o Hi;ta;aiiiViir'g" inA Mandal'
occ' Agriculture
Wo.Rama Krishna, Ag.ed. about- 55. years,
M'Shobha,
6.
" [i;"chi;dpiirv Vil"g" and Mandal'-Nalgonda District'
Aged about -5O .years' Occ Agriculture
7' Shettv lndhu, Wo.Mallappa,
ini'rvtanoal' Nalgonda District
Hili'tsni'iiJpJirv viirlg"
Sriramulu' Aoed about 50 years'
8. Mavilla Krishnaiah, S/o Late
District
occ Agriculture nlo cnYiLparr-i Virr'i" ""0-uinda[ Nalgonda
...PETITIONERS
AND
z
J
Secretary Revenue Department
The State of Telangana, Rep by its Principal
Secretariat, HYderabad.
Nalgonda'
The District Collector, Nalgonda District At
Revenue Division Nalgonda
The Revenue Divisional Officer, Deverakonda
District.
District'
The Tahsildar, Chinthapalli Mandal Nalgonda
Station chinthapalli Mandal'
The station House officer, chinthapalli Police
Nalgonda District.
...RESPONDENTS
.,,
tf
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High. Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or directions more particularly a Writ in the nature of
mandamus declaring the action of the respondents, more particularly that of the
respondent Nos.3 and. 4 in seeking taking over the land and dispossessing the
petitioners from the subject land without following due process of Law or without
invoking either the Land Acquisition Act or Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, is
challenged in this writ petition as being arbitrary, illegal and violative of Articles '14,
19 (d), 21 and 300-4 of Constitution of lndia and consequently direct the
respondents not to take over the land or dispossess the petitioners from the land
in Sy Nos. 15415, 15412611 to 15412617 admeasuring Ac.0.625guntas each tota'ly
Ac.1 .10guntas, situated at Chinthapalli Village and Mandal, Nalgonda District
without following due process of Law and without the provisions of Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 201 3.
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section '15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondent No.3 to 5 not to interfere with the possession of the petitioners in
respect of the land in Sy.Nos. 15415, 15412611 to 15412617 admeasuring
Ac.0.625guntas each totally Ac.1 .1 0guntas, situated at Chinthapalli Village &
Mandal, Nalgonda District without following due process of Law
lA NO: 3 OF 2025
Between:
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary Revenue Department
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Nalgonda District At Nalgonda.
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Deverakonda Revenue Division Nalgonda
District.
4. The Tahsildar, Chinthapalli Mandal Nalgonda Diskict.
...PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS
t
t
AND
Sarikonda Eshwaramma, Wo.S.Shankaraiah, ASgd about 63 years'
oil'Agticrttuie nTo Cniniapatty Village and Mandal, Nalgonda District
Madhurai lndira, Wo.Sanjay Kumar, Aged abqut 39. years, Occ Agriculture
J
Chaman Chandrakala, Dlo. Late Sriramulu, A99d about 53 years'
R/o. Chintapally Village anb Mandal, Nalgonda District'
oC". ngii*ltriJ n7o. Chintipally Village and Mandal, Nalgonda District'
4 Billakal Swaroopa, Wo.B.Narsing Ra-q, Aged about 5'1 years, Occ Agriculture
R/o. Chintapally Vittage and Mandal, Nalgonda District'
48 years
5 l/tavilla Satvanaravana, S/o.Late. Sriramulu, Aged about
District
Nalgonda
Mandal,
and
Village
oJC ngrl"rlii,L nlol Cnihtapatly
6 M.Shobha, Wo.Rama Krishna, Aged about-55 years, Occ Agriculture
R/o. Chintapally Village and Mandal. Nalgonda District
7 Shettv lndhu, Wo.MallaPPa, Aged about 50 Years, Occ. Agriculture
R/o Chintapally Village and Mandai, N algonda District
B. Mavilla Krishnaiah, S/o. Late Sriramulu, Aged about^ 99. years'
occ.AgricultureR/o.ChintapallyVillageandMandal,NalgondaDlslrlct'
...RESPON DENTS/PETITION ERS
9. The Station House officer, chinthapalli Police station chinthapalli Mandal,
Nalgonda District.
...RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT
(Respondent No.g is not necessary party)
Petition under section 151 cPc praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the lnterim orders granted on 16.',12.2024 in wP No.35210 of 2024 and
also to dismiss this Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI BANDAMIDI SWAMY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos'1 to 4: AGP FOR LAND ACQUISITION
Counsel for the Respondent No.s: GP FOR HOME
The Court made the following: ORDER
.
i)
i-r<'
(1
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.V.SHRAVAN KUMAR
WRIT PETITION No.35 2L O of2024
ORDER:
This writ petition has been ftled to declare the action of the
respondents, more particularly that of the respondent Nos'3 and 4
in seeking taking over the land and dispossessing the petitioners
from the subject land without following due process of Law or
without invoking either the Land Acquisition Act or right to Fair
Compensation ald
Transparency in
Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2O 1 3.
2. Learned. counsel for the petitioner submits that all the
petitioners belongs to the same family and subject matter of the
writ petition is pertaining to lald in survey Nos. 154/5, 154 126ll
to 154126/7 admeasuring Ac-0.625 guntas each tota-lly Ac l1o
guntas, situated at Chintapalli Village & Mandal, Nalgonda District'
Petitioners submits that originally land was owned and possessed
by the grandfather of the petitioners by name Ramaiah' After the
demise of the said Ramaiah, the said land was transferred in the
name of his four daughters equally, the mother of the petitioners
was also got land Ac.1.1O guntas as her share. The mother of the
petitioners died in the yea-r 2OO4 and thereafter by an oral
partition, the subject land was shared by the petitioner in equal
proportion i.e., Ac.O.625 guntas each. The said oral partition has
been acted upon in as much as e-patta passbooks were a-lso issued
in the name of the petitioners and the names of petitioners have
been uploaded in the Dharani Portal. It is further submitted that
except the income from the subject land, the petitioners have no
other source of income. lt is further submitted that in a
neighboring village, the lands of the villagers which were taken over
under Rehabilitation scheme have been submerged for the
development of Cherlgudam Tank and under the Rehabilitation
Scheme.
3. It is submitted that on 08.12.2024, when petitioners went
to their respective land which is in a compact block, the
subordinates of the respondent Nos.3 and 5 prevented the
petitioners from entering into the subject land and informed that
the land is proposed to be acquired. Thereafter, the petitioners
approached the respondent No.3 on 7O.l?.2O24 arrd were informed
that the advance possession will be taken and thereafter notice will
be given. The petitioners main grievance is that the respondent
Nos.3 and 4 are seeking to take over the land by dispossessing the
petitioners from the subject land without following due process of
law or without invoking either the Land Acquisition Act or Right to
Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. Questioning the same
the present writ petition is hled.
i
,
/1
4. It is submitted that in the notification dated O7.1O.2O22
uide Form -VII issued under Section 19( 1) of Land Acquisition
Rehabilitation Act and Right To Reasonable Compensation Act,
2013 published in the Nalgonda District Gazettee, it was informed
that there is a proposal for acquiring land in survey No.154 to an
extent of Ac.28.22 guntas. However, the names of the petitioners
were not been reflected in the said notification and since their
lands are situated in survey No.154, they are effected parties.
Petitioners contended that by non inclusion of their names in the
notifrcation, the respondents cannot initiate any action bn the
subject lands without following due process of law.
5. Respondent No.3 hled a counter and would submit no
remarks to the extent of petitioners land in survey No.154 to an
extent of Ac. 1 . 10 guntas. It is submitted that on receipt of the
requisition proposals for acquisition of the lands from the Executive
Engineer, SRVR DLIP Division No.1 1, Marriguda, Nalgonda District,
uide Lr.No.EElIrrlDIV.11/MGM/DB/DEE(T)/AEE (T) 2O2O2l/165M, dated 05. 1O.2O2l in survey No.154 to an extent of
4c.28.22 guntas situated in the village limits of Chinthapally
Village and Mandal of Nalgonda District for providing R&R Center
for Narsireddygudem village of Marriguda Mandal of Nalgonda
District whose lands were submerged under Shivannagudem
Balancing Reservoir, the Land Acquisition process was initiated
e
-]
under Right to Fair CompensaLion and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2O 13 and got
surveyed the requisitioned land and arrived with reference to the
sub-division record for an extent of Ac.28.22 guntas in survey
No. 154 of Chinthapally Village
& Mandal of Nalgonda District.
Based on the preliminar5r notification under Section 11 of RFCT in
L.A. and R & R Act, 2013 has been submitted to respondent No.2
i.e., District Collector, Nalgonda District uide Lr.No.Fl98l2022,
dated 28.01 .2022 and the same was approved by the District
Collector, Nalgonda uide Proc. No. G I I SOla I 2021, dated O2.O2.2O22
and the sEune was has been published in Telangana Extraordinary
Gazette issued No. 14, dated O3.O2.2O22 and the notification has
been published in two daily newspapers vi'-, the Capital
Information English Daily News Paper on ll -O2-2O22 and Sakshi
Telugu News Paper dated 11.O2.2O22. But as per the Sub-Division
record and notification no narne of the petitioners are notified and
after publication of the notification also, the writ petitioners have
not hled any objection petitions or request petitions. Further, some
other interested persons have frled objection petitions and
thereafter a report was called from the respondent No'4 i'e',
Tahisldar, Chintapalli. Later report was submitted by the
respondent No.4 uide Lr.No.B/335/2021, dated O2.O5.2O22 on
objections regarding variations in extent ald alignment and
f
l
submitted revised enjoyment list. Thereafter, addendum to PN
proposals has been submitted by the respondent No.3 uide
Lr.No.F 198/2022 dated 12.05.2022 to the respondent No.2 and the
sarne was approved by the District Collector, Nalgonda uide
Proc.No.Gl/8Ol8l2O2L, dated 18.05.2022 and the same has been
putilished in two daily news papers on 30.05.2022 and on
29.05.2022. At that time also the writ petitioners have not raised
any objections before the respondents. Subsequently, the
Declaration proposals under Section 19(1) of the Act 2O of 20l3 in
Form-VII has been submitted by the R.D.O uide Lr.No.F/99/2022,
dated 27.09.2022 and the same was approved by the District
Collector, Nalgonda utde Proc.No.cl lSO|Bl2O2l dated OZ.tO.2022
arrd the gazett-e to this effect has also publishe d uide No.T4, dated
07.IO.2O22 and petitioners narnes were also not covered in
declaration for subject lands and also no objections were received
from the petitioners in stipulated time. Thereafter, respondent
No.3 had issued notices under Section 22(ll of Act, 3O of 2O13 for
the persons interested, fixing the hearing date for Award Enquiry
on 05.03.2023 at 11.30 A.M., in Grampanchayath Offrce,
Devarakonda and notices were served to the persons interested
through the Mandal Girdavar, Chintapally Mandal by hand on
06.07.2021. Further, it is submitted that market value per acre
Rs.3,20,889/- was approved by the District Collector, Nalgonda in
Lr.No.Gl/801812021, dated 19.01.2023 under Section 26 of RFCT
in L.A. and R & R Act, 2013 and award has been pronounced by
the respondent No.2 uid,e proceedings dated 12.04.2023 and
approved by
the District Collector, Nalgonda uide
Lr.No.Gl/8OlB/2021, dated 1a.O4.2023 for a-n amount of
Rs.2,99,67,519/ - (Rupees Two Crores Ninety-Nine Lakhs Sixty
Seven Thousand Five Hundred and Ninteen only) and total
compensation amount was disbursed to the awardees/affected
persons under proper acknowledgment. It is further submitted
that the petitioners are having assigned land in survey No. 154/5,
154/2611 to 15412617 to an extent of Ac.l.lo guntas (each an
extent of Ac.O.O625 guntas) in the limits of Chinthapally village arrd
Mandal to which they have got issued e-patta passbooks and the
subject lands were coming under alignment of acquisition for the
purpose of providing House sites under R&R package to the (289)
project displaced families of submerged village of Narsireddygudem
under Shivannagudem Balancing Reservoir of Dindi Lift Irrigation
Scheme. The said survey No.154 of Chinthapally village is having
total extent of Ac.96.14 out of which an extent of Ac.8.14 guntas of
assig:ned land was already acquired for R&R cener to (110) PDF's of
Lingannabavigudem and Puthalaram Thanda of Devarakonda
Mandal of Nalgonda District submerged under Gottimukkala
Balancing Reservoir under DLIS. An extent of Ac.26.OO guntas of
Ei
l
assigned land in the same survey No.154 of Chinthapally Viliage
and Mandat has also under acquisition for providing R&R center to
Laxmanapuram village of Nampally Mandal and trdulagandi Village
of Chinthapally Mandal which are submerged under Kistarainpally
Balancing Reservoir under DLIS. It is further submitted that the
subject lands have been notilied which is middle of the acquired
land in favour of other enjoyers and payment of compensatin has
a-lso been paid to them. Later on, it is noticed that the petitioners
land has under alignment of the acquired land and other assignees
covered in the award was claimed without valid title and they
received the compensation and the process of recovery of the excess
payment disbursed under Section 33(A) of the RFCT in L'A' and R
& R Act, 2013 has been initiated under Revenue Recovery Act,
1894 against the defaulters for which neces6ary action was
initiated for recovery of the amounts from the excess received
awardees.
6. It is further submitted that, it is necessary to acquire the
schedule lands of the petitioners for providing the R&R center of
Narsireddygudem village which
are submerged under
Shivannagudem Balancing Reservoir under DLIS and also stated
that it is necessary to vacate the PDF's of Narsireddygudem village
before the rainy season as the Shivannagudem Balancing Reservoir
Project works almost completed and storage of water in the
I
\ \l
--.1
reservoir will be submerge the Narsireddygudem village. Therefore,
it is necessary to take advalce possessin of the subject lands which
is the part of the acquired land to an extent of Ac.28.22 guntas in
survey No.154 of Chinthapally village & Mandal. It is further held
that respondents are ready to pay 8O%o advance compensation
amount to the petitioners to an extent of Ac.1.10 guntas in survey
No. 154 of Chintapalli village under Section 40 of RFCT in L.A. and
R&R Act, 2O13 in order to take advance possession of the subject
lands to contimre the layout works and necessary action will be
initiated for acquisition of the subject land and compensation will
be paid to the petitioners as per Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013.
7. Petitioners in their reply affidavit submits that the
answering respondent admitted that the land of the petitioners is
not covered by notifrcation and that the admitted compensation is
actually payable to the petitioners is knocked away by certain
individual by misguiding authorities and that no compensation is
paid to the petitioners and that when their land is not covered by
the notification, the respondent authorities cannot take possession
and in support of their submissions, photographs have been hled
which shows that the schedule land is under cultivation and now
there is jowar crop which is ripe for harvesting and if acquisition of
i
their land is inevitable then the respondent authorities must follow
due procedure of law contemplated under Section 11(1) of Right to
Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation arrd Resettlement Act, 20 13 and accordingly the
petitioners are not only entitled for monetary compensation has to
be paid but they are entitled to Rehabilitation Scheme i.e,
Assignment of House Site Patta and money of the purpose of
construction of the house,
8. Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Land Acquisition
9. Admittedly, the land in survey No. 154 of Chinthapally
village & Mandal to extent of Ac.28.22 guntas was notified on
07.1O.2022 under Section 19(1) of Land Acquisition Rehabilitation
Act and Right to Reasonable Compensation Act, 2O13 and that the
respondent No.3-Revenue Divisional Officer of Devarakonda
Revenue Division, Nalgonda District has admitted the claim of the
petitioners ald also stated that they
are
ready to pay the
compensatlon.
10. Therefore, in view of the above said findings, petitioners
are directed to place relevant documents in support of their title
before the Revenue Divisional Officer of Devarakonda Revenue
Division, Nalgonda District within a period of one (O1) week from
@
I
'1
l0
the date of receipt of a copy of this order and after verification of
the documents placed by the petitioners, respondent No.3 authority
is directed to pay the compensation to the petitioners within a
period of three weeks thereafter strictly in accordance to law. It is
made clear that the petitioners shall also be entitled for the
compensation under R&R package in terms of and Right to
Reasonable Compensation Act, 20 13 on par with the other land
losers who are affected by the said project, if they are otherwise
eligible.
1. With the above said direction, this writ petition is
disposed of.
Miscellaneous applications, if
any pending, shall stand
closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
SD/-A. SRINIVASA R DDY
ASSISTANT REGI RAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
'1. The Principal Secretary Revenue Department Secretariat, The State of
Telangana, Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Nalgonda District At Nalgonda.
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Deverakonda Revenue Division Nalgonda
District.
4. The Tahsildar, Chinthapalli Mandal Nalgonda District.
5. The Station House Officer, Chinthapalli Police Station Chinthapalli Mandal,
Nalgonda District.
6. One CC to Sri Bandamidi Swamy, Advocate [OPUC]
7. Two CCs to GP for Land Acquisition, High Court for the State of Telangana,
at Hyderabad [OUT]
8. Two CC to The GP for Home, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad[OUT]
9. Two CD Copies
TJ
BS
q-v
j
I
I
I
I
I
i
I
I
i
HIGH COURT
DATED:0310412025
o {{
1H
)
ORDER
\(\
i)
('
)
WP.No.35210 of 2024
2 7 lutl
*
-,r^,CH
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
3{
Z
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review