Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:14244
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
LPA No. 72 of 2026
Reserved on: 22.04.2026
Date of decision: 30.04.2026.
Uploaded on: 30.04.2026
Sapna Devi
...Appellant.
Versus
State of H.P. & others
...Respondents.
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the appellant
:
For the respondents
Mr. Anshul Jairath, Advocate.
:
Mr. Varun Chandel,
Advocate General.
Additional
Bipin Chander Negi, Judge
The present appeal is preferred against the
impugned
judgment
dated
18.11.2025,
whereby
the
learned Single Judge has dismissed CWPOA No. 5173 of
2019, filed by the present appellant and has further upheld
the order dated 25.08.2010, discharging the appellant from
the post of Lady Constable, during her training period.
Besides the aforesaid, order dated 22.04.2015, passed on
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:14244
-2-
the representation made by the appellant against the order
of discharge dated 25.08.2010, has also been upheld.
2.
The appellant had been appointed as a Lady
Constable on 01.01.2010 (appointment letter is at page 77
of the paper book). Thereafter, she was sent to Training
Center,
Sakoh.
While
under
training,
the
appellant
proceeded on medical leave, on 14.02.2010. The appellant
was permitted to do so by the Commandant 2nd Indian
Reserve Battalion. However, the appellant did not resume
training and as a result whereof, the appellant was marked
absent from training w.e.f. 19.02.2010.
3.
The appellant was directed to resume training
vide wireless message dated 22.02.2010.
However, on
22.02.2010 itself a telegram was received in the office of
the Commandant 2nd Indian Reserve Battalion from the
appellant for extension of leave on medical ground.
The
appellant resumed training on 07.04.2010, after absenting
for about 47 days from training.
4.
With respect to her absence from training, the
appellant produced three medical certificates, first w.e.f.
18.02.2010 to 02.03.2010, issued by the MO PHC,
2026:HHC:14244
-3-
Bhadsali, District Una, second medical certificate advising
rest w.e.f. 03.03.2010 to 09.03.2010, was issued by the
MO, Kumar Nursing Home, Una. Other than the aforesaid,
a third medical certificate advising rest w.e.f. 10.03.2010 to
06.04.2010 was issued by MO, New Saini Hospital,
Hoshiarpur. The same are placed on record from pages 79
till 91. In the enquiry report, medical certificates issued by
the Private Hospitals have been ignored on account of the
fact that the same are not approved by the government.
Besides in all three certificates it has been held in the
enquiry report that the present appellant is affected by
different medical problems and in the response filed to the
summary of allegations a different version of a medical
problem was forthcoming.
5.
On account of her aforesaid willful absence, the
appellant was repatriated from the Training Center Sakoh
to her parent unit i.e. 5th India Reserve Battalion vide order
dated 07.04.2010. In pursuance thereto, the appellant
reported for training on 08.04.2010.
Thereafter, on
16.04.2010, the appellant proceeded on sanctioned four
days casual leave and one day station leave.
2026:HHC:14244
-4-
6.
In the aforesaid attending circumstances, the
appellant was to report back at Battalion Headquarter on
22.04.2010. However, the appellant did not turn up on the
conclusion of the sanctioned period.
Vide wireless
messages dated 24.04.2010 and 06.05.2010, the appellant
was directed to resume duty. The appellant failed to join.
On account of her willful absence a departmental enquiry
was ordered against her by the Commandant 5th Indian
Reserve Battalion, vide order dated 28.05.2010 and the
appellant was placed under suspension.
7.
The enquiry was conducted in accordance with
the provisions of Rule 16.24 of the Punjab Police Rules, as
applicable to the State of Himachal Pradesh. In the
enquiry, the appellant had submitted a response to the
summary of allegations. The same were duly considered
by the Inquiry Officer.
However, to the formal charge-
sheet, no reply was filed by the appellant. The appellant
had requested that her reply to summary allegations be
considered as reply to the charge-sheet.
At the enquiry,
the defense of the appellant was that the appellant was
2026:HHC:14244
-5-
under acute medical depression, for which, she was being
treated by a “Tantrik”.
8.
In the enquiry, the appellant did not produce
any defense witness despite opportunity being afforded.
Based on the enquiry, an enquiry report was prepared and
as per which, the appellant was guilty of willful absence
from the training center & Battalion Headquarters.
same
was
sent
to
the
appellant
for
The
making
a
representation. However, no representation was made by
the appellant. Subsequent thereto, a show cause notice
was issued to the appellant, to which again, the appellant
failed to file any reply.
It is on consideration of the
aforesaid material that the order of discharge dated
25.08.2010 was passed against the appellant. The same
was passed under Rule 12.21 of the Punjab Police Rules.
9.
While
on
suspension,
the
appellants
headquarter was fixed at Battalion Headquarter, Police
Line, Bilaspur. Therein on 01.07.2010, the appellant was
found absent from the Battalion headquarter.
The
appellant reported back after absenting herself for seven
days. On 09.07.2010 suspension was revoked. Thereafter,
2026:HHC:14244
-6-
she left for Una without seeking appropriate necessary
permission. Despite reminders to join duty on 15.07.2010
and 27.07.2010, the appellant did not join back on duty.
10.
No
statutory
appeal/revision
before
the
Competent Authority was filed against the discharge order
dated 25.08.2010. A representation dated 29.11.2014 was
filed by the appellant, after a lapse of almost four years.
Before the representation could be decided, the appellant
assailed the discharge order dated 25.08.2010 by filing
CWP No. 320 of 2015. The same was disposed of by the
Coordinate
Bench
07.01.2015,
of
directing
this
Court
the
vide
order
dated
respondents/competent
authority to decide the representation by affording due
opportunity of hearing to the petitioner.
In pursuance
thereto, the appellant was heard and a detailed impugned
speaking
order
on
22.04.2015
was
passed
by
the
authorities.
11.
Heard counsel for the appellant and perused the
record and the impugned judgment.
12.
The only contention raised is based on a
judgment of the Apex Court in Bhagwan Lal Arya vs.
2026:HHC:14244
-7-
Commissioner of Police, Delhi & others, (2004) 4 SCC
560.
The contention raised on the basis of the aforesaid
judgment is that the penalty imposed on the appellant, in
the case at hand, is highly disproportionate and therefore,
the same is required to be set aside.
The aforesaid
judgment is clearly distinguishable, as in the said case,
there was only one instance of absence and that too
because of bad health. Therefore, therein the Apex Court
was of the view that there was valid and justifiable ground
for
the
absence
from
duty.
Hence,
awarding
of
punishment of removal from service was held to be
excessive and disproportionate. The relevant extract of the
judgment relied upon is being reproduced herein below:“It is not the case of the respondents that the appellant is
a habitual absentee. He had to proceed on leave under
compulsion because of his grave condition of health and,
therefore, the punishment of removal from service is
excessive and disproportionate. We are of the view that
the punishment of dismissal/removal from service can be
awarded only for the acts of grave nature or as
cumulative
effect
of
continued
misconduct
proving
incorrigibility of complete unfitness for police service.
Merely one incident of absence and that too because of
bad health and valid and justified grounds/reasons
cannot become basis for awarding such a punishment”.
2026:HHC:14244
-8-
13.
The initial order of discharge dated 25.08.2010
was passed under Rule 12.21 of the Punjab Police Rules.
Rules 12.21 reads as under:“12.21.
A constable who is found unlikely to prove an
efficient
police
officer
may
Superintendent at any time
be
discharged
by
the
within three years of
enrolment. There shall be no appeal against an order of
discharge under this Rule.”
14.
The said proviso came up for consideration
before the Apex Court before a three Judge Bench in State
of Punjab & others vs. Sukhwinder Singh, (2005) 5
SCC 569, wherein it was held that when an employee is on
probation, an opportunity is afforded to the employee to
watch
the
work,
ability,
efficiency,
sincerity
and
competence of the employee and if the employee is not
found suitable for the post, the employer has a right to
dispense his service without anything more during the
period of probation. The relevant extract wherein reads as
under:“In the present case neither any formal departmental
inquiry nor any preliminary fact finding inquiry had been
held and a simple order of discharge had been passed.
The High Court has built an edifice on the basis of a
2026:HHC:14244
-9-
statement made in the written statement that the
respondent was habitual absentee during his short period
of service and has concluded therefrom that it was his
absence from duty that weighed in the mind of Senior
Superintendent of Police as absence from duty is a
misconduct. The High Court has further gone on to hold
that there is direct nexus between the order of discharge
of the respondent from service and his absence from duty
and, therefore, the order discharging him from service will
be viewed as punitive in nature calling for a regular
inquiry under Rule 16.24 of the Rules. We are of the
opinion that the High Court has gone completely wrong in
drawing the inference that the order of discharge dated
16.3.1990 was, in fact, based upon the misconduct and
was, therefore, punitive in nature, which should have
been preceded by a regular departmental inquiry. There
cannot be any doubt that the respondent was on
probation having been appointed about eight months
back. As observed in Ajit Singh and others etc. vs. State of
Punjab and another (supra) the period of probation gives
time and opportunity to the employer to watch the work
ability, efficiency, sincerity and competence of the servant
and if he is found not suitable for the post, the master
reserves a right to dispense with his service without
anything more during or at the end of the prescribed
period, which is styled as period of probation. The mere
holding of preliminary inquiry where explanation is called
from an
employee
would
not
make
an
otherwise
innocuous order of discharge or termination of service
punitive in nature. Therefore, the High Court was clearly
in error in holding that the respondent's absence from
duty was the foundation of the order, which necessitated
2026:HHC:14244
-10-
an inquiry as envisaged under Rule 16.24(ix) of the
Rules”.
15.
In State of Punjab & others vs. Constable Avtar
Singh, (2008) 7 SCC 405, the said view was followed when
there was absence of period of one month and thus the
discharge order was upheld by allowing the appeal of the
State. The relevant portion reads as under:“11.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties. We
are in total agreement with the submission of the learned
counsel for the State of Punjab that the controversy
involved in this case is no longer res integra. Learned
counsel appearing for the respondent had drawn our
attention to a two-Judge bench decision of this court in
Prithipal Singh v. State of Punjab & Others (2002) 10 SCC
133 [LQ/SC/2000/835] . The court held that once there is
stigma, the principle is well settled, an opportunity has to
be given before passing any order. Even where an order
of discharge looks innocuous, but on a close scrutiny, by
looking behind the curtain if any material exists of
misconduct and which is the foundation of passing of the
order of discharge, or such could be reasonably inferred,
then it leaves no room for doubt that any consequential
order, even of discharge, would be construed as stigmatic.
The decision in Sukhwinder Singh, (2005) 5 SCC 569
(supra) was given by a three-Judge bench and in view of
that decision in 2005, there is no scope for this court to
take a different view. We are squarely bound by the said
decision.”
2026:HHC:14244
-11-
16.
From the perusal of the aforesaid judgments, it is
evident that in terms of Rule 12.21, holding of a formal
departmental inquiry/preliminary fact finding inquiry is
also not required while considering the case of an employee
thereunder.
In the case at hand, the appellant had been
discharged from service after holding a full-fledged inquiry
under Rule 16.24 of the Punjab Police Rules.
17.
The issue of a member of a disciplined force
remaining absent from duty without seeking leave came up
for consideration in State of Punjab & others vs.
Mohinder Singh, (2005) 12 SCC 182.
The Apex Court
was of the view that remaining absent without leave in
disciplined
force
would
amount
to
a
grave
act
of
misconduct and employee, who remains on leave without
seeking permission in a disciplined force cannot be
retained in service. The relevant extracts of the same read
as under:“5. The conduct of the respondent who is a member of a
disciplined force in remaining absent from duty for fiveand-a-half months without sanctioned leave or prior
intimation is reprehensible.
6. Rule 16.2 of the Punjab Police Rules reads as follows:
2026:HHC:14244
-12-
“16.2 Dismissal.—Dismissal shall be provided only
for the gravest acts of misconduct or as the
cumulative effect of continued misconduct proving
incorrigibility and complete unfitness for police
service. In making such an award regard shall be
had to the length of service of the offender and his
claim to pension.
(2)***”
7. Rule 16.2 provides that an order of dismissal can be
passed only for the commission of gravest acts of
misconduct or as the cumulative effect of continued
misconduct proving incorrigibility and complete unfitness
for police service.
8. We do not agree with the High Court that a single act of
remaining absent without leave would not amount to
gravest act of misconduct. This would depend upon the
fact situation of each case. In the present case we find
that the respondent remained absent without leave for
quite a long period. The explanation rendered by him did
not find favour either with the enquiry officer or the
punishing authority. The finding of facts were not
disturbed in the departmental appeal/revision. This
finding was also not disturbed in the suit. The only
ground for setting aside the orders impugned in the suit is
that a single act of remaining absent from duty without
sanctioned leave did not merit an order of dismissal from
service. We find from the record that the respondent had
remained absent from duty without sanctioned leave on
15 different occasions. Although no major punishment
was awarded to him but he was ordered to be censured
once. In our view, the respondent being member of a
disciplined force could not be permitted to remain absent
2026:HHC:14244
-13-
without taking leave and that too for such a long period.
He cannot be retained in service. The order impugned
before us is set aside and the suit is ordered to be
dismissed.
9. Counsel appearing for the respondent submitted that
the order of dismissal may be converted into an order of
compulsory retirement from service as the respondent has
already put in more than 23 years of service. Counsel
appearing for the appellants after taking instructions
states that the case of the respondent would be
considered sympathetically by the authorities if he moves
an application for converting his order of dismissal into an
order of compulsory retirement. Impugned orders are set
aside. The authorities however shall be at liberty to pass
an appropriate order on the representation, if any, filed by
the respondent for converting the order of dismissal into
an order of compulsory retirement”.
18.
No
other
contention
has
been
raised.
Specifically no contention regarding the findings pertaining
to willful absence from duty, has been raised. Other than
the aforesaid, no infirmity in the regular departmental
enquiry under Rule 16.24 of the Punjab Police Rules has
been pointed out to this Court. From a perusal of the
record, it is evident that the enquiry was conducted in
accordance with the principles of natural justice.
The
findings of the enquiry officer and the disciplinary
2026:HHC:14244
-14-
authority are sustainable with reference to the evidence
which was adduced during the enquiry.
19.
In view of the aforesaid, we see no reason to
differ with the view taken by the learned Single Judge.
Hence, the present appeal is dismissed being devoid of any
merit. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(G. S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
30th April, 2026
(kck)
(Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review